Tuesday, May 20, 2014

Democratic Voice of Burma

Democratic Voice of Burma


KNU constructs housing in preparation for peace

Posted: 20 May 2014 03:26 AM PDT

The Karen National Union (KNU) has begun building houses to accommodate troops set to return to Burma after the signing of a nationwide ceasefire, which is expected to be achieved late this year.

Around 100 low cost-houses are being prepared by the KNU, as one of Burma's largest ethnic armed groups prepares for peace.

Maj Saw Mozatt of the KNU's 7th Brigade said that construction began in April on new homes in the KNU-held territories of Maw Pho Ke and Mae Tharee villages, and is now 70 percent complete.

"We are building 100 homes – 50 each in Maw Pho Ke and Mae Tharee villages – for our returning members if the ceasefire is reached – these are not intended for the refugees but we would also like to provide homes for them if possible," said Saw Mozatt.

"We are planning to build more homes in the next dry season."

According to the KNU, funding for the projects has come from the Ministry of Border Affairs, which has provided five million kyat (USD$5,000) for the construction of each home. The KNU has pledged that living spaces will be provided for free to returning families and job opportunities will be also created.

"We received funding for the project via the Ministry of Border Affairs – five million kyat for each house, Saw Mozatt said, we have been told that a Japanese organisation has provided some of the funds."

It is unclear whether Saw Mozatt was directly referring to the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), who in October 2013 released a report outlining resettlement projects for Karen refugees returning to Burma from camps across the Thai border. The controversial plan was slammed by local advocates for a plan that would recruit returning refugees as cheap labour for the construction and operation of several proposed Special Economic Zones.

JICA proposed that the Burmese government take advantage of a recent minimum wage increase in Thailand to attract labour-intensive jobs across the border. JICA estimates that 200,000 jobs could be created in the Burmese towns of Myawaddy and Hpa-an, to be filled by resettling refugees returning home across the border from refugee camps and the area surrounding the Thai town of Mae Sot.

In spite of the optimism shown by the KNU in planning for the retirement of their soldiers, the European Burma Network (EBN) released a statement on Tuesday raising concerns as to robustness of the peace accords.

"Reforms in Burma, including the peace process, have not progressed to a degree where it is safe for refugees to return, the EBN statement reads. "Even where ceasefires have been signed, full codes of conduct for the ceasefires have not been agreed. The Burmese Army is increasing, rather than decreasing, its presence in ethnic states.

"Human rights violations by the Burmese Army and associated forces, although reduced in some areas, are still taking place. Political dialogue which could lead to a lasting peace has still not begun, and there is little prospect of genuine dialogue starting in the foreseeable future," read the statement.

A national treasure

Posted: 20 May 2014 03:12 AM PDT

Archaeologists in central Burma's Pegu region have discovered what they believe to be the ruins of an ancient religious site.

Ten stupas and a square structure that is thought to be an ancient ordination hall were uncovered between Paegon and Ingyincin villages in Shwetaung Township on 8 May.

The religious ruins are presumed to be 1,000 years old, which would date the site back to the Pyu era of Burma, from 2nd century BC to mid 11th century AD.

During the Pyu era, Tibeto-Burman speaking Pyu, migrated south from present-day Yunnan, and built walled city-states throughout Upper Burma. Twelve such sites have been excavated to date. The Pyu are considered to be the earliest recorded inhabitants of Burma.

Thirty statues of arhats, a Buddhist term for someone who has attained nirvana, were found inside the ordination hall.

"We assume there were 20 arhats on the each side of the wall, making 80 in total on all sides," said the farmer who uncovered the site, as he pointed out the ruins that made up gates and entrances.

There is speculation from local archaeologists that the site found in Shwetaung Township could be contextually liked to two other ancient ordination halls found in the region.

One was discovered near the neighbouring town of Prome and the other is believed to be located outside Myola town.

According to local legend, each site each represents the sunset and sunrise, with the current discovery alluding to the midday sun.

"Surprisingly, the 80 arhats from the site in Prome are almost identical to the ones recently found here, but that's just my perspective," said regional parliamentary representative, Tun Tun Oo.

But archaeologists in Prome say it is too early to draw conclusions about the age and identity of the structure.

Once the Department of Archaeology conducts full study of the site, they will be able to determine just how old the religious structures are.

Chinese ‘hostages’ released in Latpadaung

Posted: 20 May 2014 01:59 AM PDT

Two Chinese employees of Myanmar Wanbao Mining Copper Ltd who were apprehended and detained by local villagers in Seté on Sunday have been released, the Chinese firm has announced.

"We are very happy to declare that our two Chinese colleagues kidnapped by the activists have been released, and they came back to the camp at 7:15pm local time [on Monday night]. They are in good shape. We would like to take this opportunity thank all the media for your attention to this incident and also all the villagers and village elders who contacted us and offered their help to release our colleagues," the company said in a statement.

"We also thank local government officials for their efforts in the release of the two young people in a peaceful manner."

Seté villager and anti-mine activist Win Win Htay said the two Wanbao staffers were released around 6pm on Monday. He said the Chinese employees, thought to be surveyors, were "'held for just a short time – not abducted", adding that the two men were returned unharmed.

"We have handed over the two Chinese following a meeting at the Wanbao office with Mining Minister Hla Tun, District Administrator Zaw Myo Nyunt, and a police colonel named Nay Tun from Monywa," said Win Win Htay.

"We had administrator Zaw Myo Nyunt and the police colonel stand witness to the fact that we did not cause any bodily harm to the two Chinese – in contrast to the company's claim that we beat them up – and we asked the two men to clarify to the media that we did not beat them up and that we treated them well," he said.

He concluded by noting that the officials at Monday's meeting did not make any guarantee or promise not to seek legal action upon those concerned with the incident.

Originally, three staff members of Myanmar Wanbao – two Chinese nationals and their Burmese driver – were seized when they appeared to be taking measurements of land plots around Seté. This reportedly infuriated locals whose lands had been confiscated by the company and its Burmese partners, the military-backed Union of Myanmar Economic Holdings.

The Burmese driver was later released but the two Chinese surveyors were detained while negotiations continued.

Myanmar Wanbao on Monday issued a statement saying the men had been beaten and that death threats had been made. The activists, or villagers, originally demanded the complete shutdown of the Latpadaung copper mine in exchange for their release, the firm said.

Karenni villagers asked to pay the price to connect to the grid

Posted: 19 May 2014 07:45 PM PDT

Residents of nearly 50 villages in Karenni State, which are outside the reach of the national grid, have the option of linking themselves to the country's electrical network – but with a preliminary price-tag set at 10 million kyat (more than US$10,000) per village.

The regional government of eastern Burma's Karenni State has announced that it will arrange the construction of transmission lines to the 47 villages in question, but said that the residents must collectively fund the expense of building the power lines and linking their outlying towns to the main grid via transformers.

Karenni State Minister of Electric Power Saw Huhu said, "We plan to bring electricity to 47 villages under this self-sponsorship scheme. Each village will have to contribute an initial payment of 10 million kyat, but that amount will not cover the full cost."

He said that the villages in question will be responsible for the total bill which could exceed the 10 million kyat they have already contributed.

"One or two villages are yet to pay the bill and the deadline is past," he said. "But we are putting them on the list and will start work [to install electricity] for their village once the payments are made."

Htay Myint Oo, chief engineer at the Electricity Department in the Karenni town of Demoso – which is less than 40km from one of the longest rivers in Asia, the Salween – said the construction of the national grid is 90 percent complete.

Several residents in the outlying villages in Karenni, officially known as Kayah, have spoken out against the scheme.

"Each village has to pay 10 million kyat regardless of its size and the number of households," said a Demoso villager named Shamya. "There are already power poles erected in our village but no electricity."

According to recent data from the Mekong Energy and Ecology Network, 75 percent of the total area in Burma is not connected to the national power grid.

National News

National News


Daw Suu challenges military powerbrokers to take off uniforms

Posted: 19 May 2014 02:02 PM PDT

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi has challenged military officials to quit the army if they want to take part in politics, as she kicked off a series of public rallies in Yangon on May 17.


Meth production soars to meet demand

Posted: 19 May 2014 12:25 PM PDT

Strong and growing demand for drugs in Asia is driving up global production of methamphetamine, with seizures in the region tripling in five years to record levels, says UNODC.

Letpadaung workers released

Posted: 19 May 2014 12:12 PM PDT

Two Chinese workers kidnapped and threatened at a China-backed copper mine in Myanmar have been released, after they were held by activists demanding a halt to the controversial project.

World Bank ‘sorry’ over river dispute

Posted: 19 May 2014 12:05 PM PDT

A World Bank official has apologised to civil society groups for describing the Ayeyarwady River as an "international river" because its tributaries originate in China and India.

Shan Herald Agency for News

Shan Herald Agency for News


More on Unity

Posted: 20 May 2014 05:49 AM PDT

Unity is difficult to define, and all these years our people have been shouting "ais are not united" "We need unity" - I don't think they really know where, when and why we need to be united.

Sao Noan Oo
As I mentioned before, each human being is so different from the other, even amongst brothers and sisters each has his or her own personality and opinion. We should respect that individuality and freedom, but at the same time people who have the same interest, desire and values can work together to get what they want. The more people work together, the greater the success.

Therefore to me, Unity is when people who want the same things, think and feel the same way and have the same value or principles work together for a common good. The decision to do so should come from the decision and heart of the individual, talking and listening to each other's point of views.

The dictatorial armed forces are united, but their "unity" is uniformity of the mind and body. They are indoctrinated or conditioned to think the same, act the same and feel the same. They have no freedom of choice or respect for the individual.

In the case of  the Shan State, all the groups be it Pa-O, Palaung, Wa or Tai/Shan, they want peace and the rights to be free, free from fear, free from the control of the Burmese Armed forces. As citizens of the Shan State they want to have a say in how the resources are used for development and welfare of the people- They believe in equality, truth, justice and fairness. The groups have many things in common, but they have been denied them by the common foe. In order to achieve the things they want they have to unite to fight against the foe, preferably by non-violence means. This is their purpose or cause or goal.

Without achieving this the peoples of the Shan States cannot move forward. Fighting for the common cause should therefore be their priority.

Each group in the Shan State also has its own language, culture and religion, and each want their own autonomous region. As the population of the Shan State is diverse there will be issues in some areas, which can be resolved only by debate and discussion or votes. If they are to live together in peace, there will have to be understanding, tolerance and consideration for each other. But, this second process cannot take place while the Shan State is still under the control of the dictatorial regime, therefore it is important  that everybody knows that these are minor compared to the to fighting for their cause.

Now we come to the question of how can we achieve our goal? I think we must recognise that we are freedom fighters, fighting for liberty and freedom from oppression by a very strong institution of terrorists, who use terror tactics, killing indiscriminately to gain maximum impact.

Many people have fought for freedom from slavery and these freedom fighters have struck blow after blow against the institution, rallying for Black unity, freedom, rights and power. Nelson Mandela fought hard and long in his struggle against apartheid. There are many infamous freedom fighters who fought hard for their cause, but somewhere along the way were branded terrorists, like the regime does to the ethnic resistant fighters.

Freedom fighters can be politicians, religious leaders or ordinary men and women. At one time it was the top people who lead people to rebel, but now it is the voice and will of ordinary people that count. But as you know our people's knowledge of politics is so far below the rest of the world.  After being threatened for half a century to stay away from politics, they are still being psychologically infected with FEAR.

The dictators are bullies, they use political violence to intimidate, physical violence to inject fear and emotional violence to undermine. The more you show the bullies that you are frightened of them, the more they will bully you. This is seen in the behaviour of a bully even in the school play ground.

First and foremost we should encourage people to confront their fear, while at the same time make them understand that  we are freedom fighters trying to change the fabric of  society, and in order to succeed we must work together. Creating inner power within each of us will create confidence to tackle and confront the difficulties ahead of us.

The Marn (Burmese) generals are also cowards, they dare not compete with other ethnic nationalities on the same level, so they make sure they have a handicap by building a huge army. They are afraid that the ethnic nationalities will secede from Burma, leaving them stranded in the centre of nowhere. They go about the wrong way, by using force instead of trying to establish friendship.

The teaching of Buddhism and their duty and responsibility towards their Motherland can entice different groups to want to work together, although talking about Buddhism too much might alienate Christians.

It would be a good idea to have a network of people to explain and spread your political ideas and principles around the population. Although many youth organisations have sprung up, the Shan State also needs the voice and will of the ordinary to bring the dictators down. (By a necessary war? because such situation cannot go on forever) I have written what comes into my mind- I hope it makes sense.

The contributor is the daughter of the ruling prince of Lawksawk and the author of "My Vanishing World".

Finnwatch Researcher Andy Hall to Face Police Investigators to Defend Latest Natural Fruit Company Ltd. Criminal Charges in Thailand on 19th May

Posted: 20 May 2014 05:48 AM PDT

PRESS RELEASE

16th MAY 2014

Finnwatch Researcher Andy Hall to Face Police Investigators to Defend Latest Natural Fruit Company Ltd. Criminal Charges in Thailand on 19th May
For more information on this media advisory, please contact:
  1. Sonja Vartiala, Executive Director, Finnwatch: +358 445687465 and This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it </
  2. Andy Hall, Migration Researcher: +66 846119209 and This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it </ (@atomicalandy)
  3. Nakhon Chomphuchart, Legal Advisor to Andy Hall: +66 818473086 and This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it </
For more detailed information on Natural Fruit's prosecutions of Andy Hall and the campaign to have the charges dropped, see www.andyjhall.wordpress.com
British migrant rights activist Andy Hall, who campaigns to improve conditions for migrant workers in Thailand, has appointed investigators at Bangna Police Station in Bangkok on Mon. 19th May 10am  to give evidence against the latest criminal charges filed against him by Natural Fruit Company Ltd., a pineapple exporter based in Prachuap Kiri Khan, Thailand.

Human and labour rights abuses against Natural Fruit's workers have now been the subject of two Finnwatch research reports, the first to which Hall contributed.

The latest criminal charges filed against Hall by Natural Fruit Company Ltd. at Bangna Police Station, the 3rd set of charges filed against him so far, reportedly relate to defamatory remarks made by Hall in an interview to Aljazeera in Myanmar. The Aljazeera story featured Hall's reflections on migrant conditions in Thailand and also charges of criminal defamation and breaches of the Computers Crimes Act and a 300 million baht (US$10m) civil defamation case filed against him by Natural Fruit.

If a court finds Hall guilty of the criminal charges laid against him, he could face a maximum of 7 years imprisonment per count. This has raised strong concerns from 6 UN human rights Rapporteurs. All the charges reportedly relate to his role in conducting interviews with migrants from Myanmar to assist Finnwatch to compile a report, Cheap Has a High Price. This report, released in Jan 2013 (available here) outlined poor labour conditions in various seafood and pineapple export companies in Thailand. A follow up report, released in Jan 2014 (available here), outlined how all previously researched companies still failed to remedy abuses reported in the original report. According to interviewed Natural Fruit workers, the company still confiscated work permits, prevented workers from changing employer and made deductions from unlawful salaries. The problems highlighted in Thai officials own investigation of conditions at the Natural Fruit factory still persisted. Natural Fruit has responded to Finnwatch's findings denying all illegalities.

Hall previously reported to Bangna Police Station on 28 Sep. 2013 after the British Embassy in Bangkok notified him of fresh criminal charges filed against him but refused to provide details. During this visit, an officer attempted to get Hall to sign a Thai language confession accepting guilt. Hall refused to sign the document, requested a copy and left the station.

Hall later filed complaints against police misconduct to the Commander of the Thai Police Force, Thailand's Minister of Foreign Affairs, Thailand's National Human Rights Commission and the Foreign and Commonwealth Office in London. In a Nov. 2013 letter, Bangna Police stated officials had already informed Hall of the charges against him in compliance with law and no unfair conduct was present. The letter did not mention the confession statement Hall was asked to sign.

Hall continues to insist the latest criminal charges against him at Bangna Police Station have no legal basis as they relate to an interview given to Aljazeera outside of Thailand. In any case, prior to pressing defamation charges, Natural Fruit Company Ltd. only listened to part of the interview he gave to Aljazeera that was disseminiated. In order to assess admissibility of such a case, police officers should first obtain all related evidence, including a copy of the full interview, prior to deciding whether to proceed with the case. Hall understands officers didnt adequately investigate charges against him prior to his previous station visit.

According to internal documents obtained by Hall under the UK's Freedom of Information Act, by the end of Sep 2013 the British Embassy in Bangkok was informed by Bangna Police Station that an arrest warrant against Hall was pending in relation to the latest charges and likely to be issued in Oct 2013. Following this, Hall would be apprehended by Immigration officials should he arrive to Thailand from overseas. The same documents described how the Embassy planned not to inform Hall of these developments as they were 'unable to interfere in the judicial process.'

However, following Hall's Sep 2013 attendance at Bangna Police Station and the reported confession documents, in Oct 2013 the British Ambassador to Thailand, Mr. Mark Kent, wrote a letter to Thailand's Ministry of Foreign Affairs, stating that 'Any accusation of attempted coercion to sign a confession is of course a serious claim and we hope that the Thai authorities will look into this as a matter of urgency.'

The initial 2 criminal and civil cases filed by Natural Fruit Company against Hall have yet to proceed due to the failure to serve case summons on him. However, Hall considers it important that in the latest case filed at Bangna Police Station he should again attend the police station to deny the charges and defend himself. In addition, on 19th May, Hall will again press officers to drop the latest case as there is no legal jurisdiction to prosecute and the full interview he gave to Aljazeera has yet to be obtained. Hall also accepts the Thai criminal justice process and respects the need to face police officers to defend charges laid against him.

Finnwatch continues to demand that Natural Fruit Company drop all criminal and civil charges filed against Andy Hall and address poor labour conditions in it's factory. Finnwatch, alongside the Finnish League of Human Rights, also continues to express it's dissatisfaction at the validity of Thai officials inspections of Natural Fruit's factory and urges the Thai authorities to properly investigate labour conditions at Natural Fruit's factory again more thoroughly and without further delay.

Peacemakers need to work fast and furious

Posted: 20 May 2014 05:46 AM PDT

Following the 6th meeting between Naypyitaw's Union Peacemaking Work Committee (UPWC) and the ethnic armies' Nationwide Ceasefire Coordination Team (NCCT), Lt-Gen Myint Soe, head of the Burma Army's Bureau of Special Operations (BSO) #2, reportedly told the media the long-awaited Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement (NCA) could be signed by 1 August.

Perhaps not to be outdone, the NCCT's Dr Lian Hmung Sakhong responded by saying it could be done earlier, probably by May.

Since then the two sides had met again from 5-8 April when they successfully worked out a single text document for the NCA. Dr Lian later said both found each other 50% in consensus.

However when the NCCT met again on 28-19 April in Chiangmai, they found too many wordings both were in disagreement (such as whether to designate the non-Burman armed opposition "Ethnic Armed Movements" or "Armed Ethnic Movements") plus a few but serious differences in principles (such as disagreements between the two sides will be arbitrated by the government's most powerful organ, National Defense and Security Council (NDSC)), popularly known as "Ka-Long".

Simple people like the writer and the rest may scoff and say, "What's in a name?" But for the NCCT, made up by members some of whom are well-versed in legal matters, words and names do matter. "We concluded that we would need to focus more on the concepts rather than the wordings themselves," Dr Lian told SHAN. "If we find out that both sides share the same concepts, then a rose by any other names would smell just as sweet."

The NCCT is reportedly holding a last minute meeting in the Kachin resistance capital of Laiza to finalize its proposals to the planned 8th UPWC-NCCT meeting on 19-20 May, which has been postponed to 21-22 May.  It is not known whether the UPWC is having its own meeting in the meantime.

But judging from the situation, it is unlikely the NCA could be signed anytime soon unless and until, as Naypyitaw's chief negotiator U Aung Min said, both sides are ready to meet halfway with each other.

Part of that halfway should preferably be to push most of the political issues (such as adherence to federalism and the 2008 constitution) to where they should be i.e. the next stages: negotiations for framework for political dialogue and most particularly the political dialogue itself. That would save a lot of space and time for the NCA.

Another important point is that the two sides, instead of meeting once or twice a month, should meet every day to work out the NCA together. That will at least help ease well-founded fears that either each is or both sides are deliberately trying to forestall the much-anticipated political dialogue.

Now we all wait for the upcoming meeting in Rangoon on Wednesday, 21 May, in suspense.

En people don’t believe their man is guilty

Posted: 20 May 2014 05:44 AM PDT

On 5 May, Sai Ai Keng, chairman of village level Shan Nationalities League for Democracy (SNLD) from Pengtao tract, Kengtung, township was detained by government authorities and has been accused of having a gun given by the Restoration Council of Shan State / Shan State Army (RCSS/SSA).

The En are known in Shan State as "the gentlest" of all the races there. "No more honest people can be found anywhere," according to both Shan and Lahu sources.

All of the sources inquired by SHAN believe Ai Keng must have been framed by the authorities.

The following is an article from 'Undercurrents', an annual newsletter published by the Lahu National Development Organization (LNDO) on the En.

Shan congratulates to newest degree holders-Shan monks in abroad

Posted: 20 May 2014 05:43 AM PDT

CHIANG MAI-MAY 20. Over 600 Shan people congratulated to the newest degree holders—Shan monks convocation at the public Buddhist university-Mahachulalongkornrajavidyalaya University, Ayuthaya, Thailand on May 18, 2014.

There were over 10 Shan monks attained university degrees, both undergraduate and postgraduate.

shan-monk-univer
The Shan monks taking a group-photo on the convocation at the Mahachulalongkornrajvidhayalaya university, on May 18, 2014. (Photo: Shan Music)

Sai Hseng Harn said "We are proud to be Shan and really proud with the Shan monks who newly got the degrees. We really satisfied with the event, all Shan wore unique Shan traditional dresses/outfits. We performed Shan circle dance, Kinnari dance and folksong."

According to Sai Hseng Harn, the Shan people gathered and congratulated to the monks every year, but this was the biggest ever if compared to few years back. About 30 Shan people from Shan State also came to celebrate at the convocation.
shan-monk-univer2
The graduated monks taking a group-photo with the devotees on the convocation at the Mahachulalongkornrajvidhayalaya university, on May 18, 2014. (Photo: Shan Music)

In addition, there were hundreds of Shan people gathered at the event because the Saokhu Tayjanyana, he is a well-known monk and have many devotees.

Sai Kyaw Oo said "Congratulations, but please do not forget to bring your knowledge and skills to go back and develop your home country."

There are hundreds of Burmese monks study at Mahachulalongkornrajavidyalaya, including Burman, Shan, Karen, and Pa-O monks study at the public Buddhist university, Mahachulalongkornrajavidyalaya University.

There are about 20-30 Shan monks come to study in Thailand every year, at the Buddhist Universities.

If Wa granted self determination, others must be too, says paper

Posted: 20 May 2014 05:41 AM PDT

Of all the non-Burman ethnic nationalities, only the Wa are enjoying their right to self determination at the expense of others seeking similar ends, according to Legal Aid Network (LAN) paper which was released Thursday, 16 May.
Legal Aid Network (LAN)'s logo

"(T) hey govern their respective territory, form their own army and conduct their self-rule, without any embarrassment from successive ruling military regimes," say the paper prepared by legal experts which include well-known human rights lawyer Aung Htoo, Josef Silverstein, Suzannah Linten, David Fisher, Simon Young and Venkat Iyer. "However, it may not be fair and just when the Wa alone enjoy it at the expense of other ethnic nationalities who are seeking for similar ends. "

The State Law and Order Restoration Council (SLORC), that came to power during the 1988 democratic uprisings, it says, had entered a ceasefire with the United Wa State Party/United Wa State Army (UWSP/UWSA), formed by the Wa mutineers following their overthrow of the Communist Party of Burma (CPB), and provided a formal recognition of the existence of its territory, organization and army, "by violating laws in force."

Scrutinizing the situation from the aspect of the Rule of Law, one of whose principles, is that equal situations must be treated equally, it argues the action of the Burmese government is discriminatory and against the Rule of Law. "Undisputed facts indicate that other non-Myanmar ethnic states such as Kachin, Chin, Shan, Arakan, Mon, Karen, Karenni etc …. (had) existed independently in history.".. They should therefore "also have the right to enjoy equal status, at minimum, similar to Wa. Unfortunately, this is not taking place.

The right to self determination of other non-Myanmar ethnic nationalities have been consistently denied by successive military regimes although such right has been granted to Wa nationals in practice since May 19899."

In view of this, it reasons that "the 2008 constitution and other organic laws need to be amended."

The paper however not only dwells an legal as pects but also on actual situation on the ground. It points out to the fact that the UWSP/UWSA is being let off while Naypyitaw is still dealing with other ethnic armed organizations (EAOs) until they "have been annihilated — or, at minimum, neutralized — by the regime after the nationwide ceasefire. Hence, it means that the UWSA survives now at the expense of the other EAOs (but like them), it may also face a similar fate in the end."

It sums up its argument this way: The government does not operate under the law but merely through it.