Saturday, May 23, 2015

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Returned Fisherman’s 10 Years of Indonesian Misery

Posted: 22 May 2015 09:48 PM PDT

Myan Myo Myint, 26, returned to Burma last week. (Photo: Nobel Zaw / The Irrawaddy)

Myan Myo Myint, 26, returned to Burma last week. (Photo: Nobel Zaw / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — After failing his matriculation exam and a fight with his parents, Myan Myo Myint ran away from home. At the time, he had no idea he wouldn't see his family again for 10 years.

One of possibly thousands of people trafficked by Thai fishing boats in the last 20 years, Myan Myo Myint was among the 530 Burmese nationals who arrived in Rangoon last week after the slave trade was exposed by an Associated Press report in March.

A middle-class native of Kawthaung town, Tenasserim, the then 16-year-old crossed the border into Thailand after he left home, and was approached by a broker while sitting on a train platform in Ranong province. Afraid of being caught by Thai police after illegally crossing the border, he agreed to work on a fishing boat after meeting its owner.

Presented with a Thai language contract, he was told he would be paid 9000 baht (US$270) per month with a two-year commitment. Along with several others, he was sent in a car to Samut Sakhon province near Bangkok.

Life in the boat was miserable. Unable to quickly master the basics of fishing, he was assaulted and threatened by the Burmese supervisor of the vessel. The long shifts kept the crew in a perpetual state of fatigue, and those who couldn't be woken to work had firecrackers thrown into their beds.

Despite his promised salary, he was told he would be earning only 1000 baht (US$30) per month. When he asked the shipmaster for his pay, he was told that his employer was saving it for the end of his contract. After a month, he asked to quit the job without his salary, and was refused again.

Taken to the Maluku Islands in Indonesia, he worked for over two years before he made the decision to run away with a friend when the vessel made landfall one day.

"I couldn't eat for four days while I ran to escape from them," he told The Irrawaddy.

Eventually, an elderly Indonesian woman took the pair in, despite the lack of a common language. He remained there for the next eight years, helping with home repair work and other odd jobs around the village in return for food.

"If I didn't get work on one day, I would be worried about whether I could eat the next," he said.

His friend left the village soon after they arrived. To this day, Myan Myo Myint doesn't know whether he is still alive.

From time to time, he reached out to the local police station. Authorities told him they didn't have the budget to return him home. He told The Irrawaddy that the Burmese Embassy in Jakarta were aware both of his presence and that of other trafficking victims. Similarly unable to repatriate the Burmese nationals, the embassy would occasionally send bags of rice to former fishermen who had married Indonesian women and begun to raise families.

Myan Myo Myint said there were many more Burmese nationals stranded on the islands over the last two decades after they ran away from life on the boats, and the 530 to return were largely those who had been trafficked to the island in the last few years.

"We could build a town from the Burmese stranded in Indonesia," he said. "It's more than five hundred, it's more than a thousand. There are still many people living in these villages."

After arriving in Rangoon, Myan Myo Myint was able to call Kawthaung and eventually locate his parents. He returned home this week after nearly a decade away.

"My mother thought I was dead," he said. "I have so many regrets from what I did. I promised her I would try to become a good man."

The post Returned Fisherman's 10 Years of Indonesian Misery appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

The Irrawaddy Business Roundup (May 23, 2015)

Posted: 22 May 2015 05:00 PM PDT

Japanese industry giants Mitsubishi Corporation and Hitachi Ltd have won a $20 million contract to upgrade signaling on the railway line between Rangoon and Naypyidaw. (Photo: Teza Hlaing / The Irrawaddy)

Japanese industry giants Mitsubishi Corporation and Hitachi Ltd have won a $20 million contract to upgrade signaling on the railway line between Rangoon and Naypyidaw. (Photo: Teza Hlaing / The Irrawaddy)

Telecoms Firm Ooredoo Changes Up Management

With recent figures showing that the Qatari telecommunications company is losing the race to capture the larger chunk of Burma's fast-growing mobile phone subscriber market, Ooredoo has announced a reshuffle of its most senior post in the country.

Ross Cormack, the Ooredoo Myanmar chief executive officer who oversaw the firm's launch as the first private telco to operate in Burma, "has taken the decision to leave his position later this year," according to a statement from the company.

Cormack has "significantly contributed to the growth of the company’s businesses," the statement said, crediting him with leading the company "from a green field operation to a fully-fledged telecoms provider" in Burma.

But it hasn't escaped the notice of observers that the announcement came less than a week after Ooredoo's rival private telecoms license holder, Telenor of Norway, announced it had picked up 6.4 million subscribers since launching in October.

Ooredoo, which in August began a slow roll out beginning in central parts of the country, had only put on 3.3 million subscribers as of the end of March.

State-owned telco MPT, which has entered a joint venture with Japan's KDDI and Sumitomo, has 8.4 million subscribers, according to Reuters.

Replacing Cormack at the head of Ooredoo Myanmar will be Rene Meza, the current managing director of Vodacom Tanzania, according to the Ooredoo statement, which also cited the executive's experience in Kenya, Pakistan and countries in Latin America.

"Rene Meza has considerable experience in leading the growth of telecoms businesses in emerging markets and we believe he has all the qualities to take Ooredoo Myanmar to the next level as we continue to roll-out Myanmar’s first 3G-only mobile network," Dr. Nasser Marafih, Ooredoo Group CEO, was quoted saying.

Burmese Mobile App Firm Looks to Raise Finance in London

Burmese tech start-up MySQUAR will attempt to raise more than $3 million on the London Stock Exchange, according to the Financial Times.

The London-based newspaper reported that the company, which makes Burmese-language messaging app MyChat, has been valued by brokerage firm Beaufort Securities at about US$36 million.

The company will try to raise about $3.14 million when it floats on the Alternative Investment Market (AIM), a sub-market of London's main bourse, at the beginning of June, according to the FT.

"But MySQUAR's services are free for now while it builds its customer base and it will not start to charge users for add-on services or advertisers for space for a while," the report said. "MySQUAR will not generate cash for months, if not years. The profits may come after that. Then again, they may not."

MySQUAR launched in 2013 and was touted as "Myanmar's first social media network" in numerous glowing newspaper features. According to the FT, the company now has some 700,000 users in Burma and is hoping for growth as the number of mobile phone users continues to climb.

However, it faces some stiff competition, and the social media habits among Burma's nascent smartphone addicts have proven hard to predict.

While Facebook is used by many in Burma as the default internet browser, a survey last year by On Device Research found that messaging app Viber—which has said it has more than 5 million users in Burma—was the most ubiquitous way to chat. Some 79 percent of survey respondents said they use Viber, compared with 27 percent for Facebook messenger.

"Twitter, Instagram, and other popular Western services remain below the 5% threshold," On Device Research said in a discussion of its findings. "Surprisingly, local mobile social network MySquar wasn't popular either."

Telenor Orders More Towers for Mobile Network

Telecoms infrastructure firm Apollo Towers said this week that it has agreed to provide 700 more mobile phone masts to Telenor, as the Norwegian company expands its network around Burma.

The company was selected by Telenor in 2013, shortly after the first private telecoms licenses were awarded to Telenor and Qatar's Oordeoo. In a statement on May 20, Apollo Towers said that it had received a new purchase order for 700 new towers from Telenor.

The Wall Street Journal recently reported that both Ooredoo and state-run provider MPT have about 2,000 towers around the country each, while Telenor has only 1,500.

"The ongoing partnership between Telenor Myanmar and Apollo Towers Myanmar provides the platform for multi-tenancy on towers in order to accelerate the development of efficient and cost-effective shared mobile telecommunications infrastructure in Myanmar," the Apollo Towers statement said.

"As part of Telenor Myanmar's commitment to contribute to the local economy, Apollo Towers Myanmar is working with a number of Myanmar-based companies in the infrastructure build-out across the country, providing opportunities for local businesses and promoting a more vibrant business environment in Myanmar."

Apollo Towers was founded by former Orange CEO Sanjiv Ahuja, who also serves as a non-executive director at Telenor. Major shareholders in Apollo Towers include US-based entities Tillman Global Holdings LLC and Texas Pacific Group.

Japanese Firms Win Railway Signals Work

Japanese industry giants Mitsubishi Corporation and Hitachi Ltd have signed a contract worth about $20 million to upgrade the ailing signals system on the railway line connecting Burma's biggest city and the capital.

According to a joint announcement, the companies signed a deal with the state-owned Myanma Railways on May 15 with funding for the work coming from Japan's state aid organization, JICA.

The agreement will see the firms supply and install a train monitoring system to oversee traffic and control signals on a 140-kilometer stretch of line between Rangoon's Central Station and Pyuntasa, part of the way to Naypyidaw on the line that continues north to Mandalay.

"Given the aging of existing railway infrastructure in Myanmar, improvement of the quality and safety of railway services has become an urgent issue," the statement said.

"Furthermore, since most long-haul transportation in Myanmar depends on automobiles and airlines, developing rail transportation infrastructure is needed in order to accommodate increasing demand for passenger and cargo transportation."

Significant work is required to modernize Burma's rail network and rolling stock, much of which has seen little attention since the colonial era. Mitsubishi Corporation and Hitachi Ltd. said they would "continue to pursue opportunities for involvement in future railway infrastructure projects" in Burma.

Firm Plans Tourist Hotel in Chin State Capital

The mountainous reaches of Chin State may not be typical tourist territory, but the rugged terrain has begun to attract more adventurous travellers. Not surprising, then, that investors may be starting to get into the local hotel market.

According to a report on Burma News International this week, a company named Mahemiah Co-operation Company (MCC), wants to construct a tourist hotel in the state capital, Hakha.

The report cited company official Pu Thawng Za Lian saying that the firm, which is reportedly registered in the United States as well as in Burma, will open an office in Hakha next month.

The BNI report said the company would be involved in agricultural investment and construction projects in Chin State, but also want to cash in on tourism growth to the region.

"We often hear about the insufficient number of hotels for tourists and travellers in Chin State. So we approached the concerned authorities to construct a hotel. Local elders supported us," Pu Thawng Za Lian was quoted saying.

Marcus Allender, founder of travel website Go-Myanmar.com, told The Irrawaddy there was potential for tourism to flourish in Chin State.

"With remote villages strewn across mountains that are home to distinctive local tribes and colourful fauna and flora, Chin State certainly offers plenty of potential for tourism," Allender said.

"The issue is access—the only area that currently has any tourism development is Nat Ma Taung National Park, and that is an 8 hour drive on rough roads from the nearest airport at Bagan. Although access for foreigners is now unrestricted and roads are gradually being improved, it largely remains a destination only for the most adventurous and determined."

The post The Irrawaddy Business Roundup (May 23, 2015) appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Shan Herald Agency for News

Shan Herald Agency for News


Min Aung Hliang’s disarmament request and Chinese response

Posted: 23 May 2015 12:38 AM PDT

Recently, two pieces of news that are quite crucial to better understand the nature of ethnic conflict were published, which need emphasizing.
Sai Wansai
One is the interview of Khun Okker, Nationwide Ceasefire Coordination Team (NCCT) member, with DVB on 21 May, and the other Commander-in-Chief Min Aung Hliang's request to Deputy Foreign Affairs of CCP, Central Committee, on 19 May, reported by Mizzima.

Khun Okker said that NCCT preparation of Ethnic Armed Organizations (EAOs) leaders' summit meeting will be held in Chiangmai, Thailand from 25 to 27; and the ensuing summit meeting will take place at Lawkhila, Karen National Union (KNU) controlled area, from 2 to 6 June.

When asked why Myanmar Peace Center (MPC) and Union Peace-making Work Committee (UPWC) have to be present at the forthcoming Lawkhila meeting, Khun Okker said that they probably taking advantage of all ethnic leaders' gathering to adjust glitches and discuss with the EAOs' leaders that they usually do and not to attend the meeting.

No doubt, many might see it in another aspect, given that the KNU is close to the government and also lately held a meeting in Inya Lake hotel, Rangoon, with Restoration Council of Shan State (RCSS), also a group keen to sign the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement (NCA) as soon as possible, plus various registered political parties, on 9 May.

Various other questions Khun Okker answered are as follows:

  • No altering of NCA, due to the awaited, lengthy procedure of even changing a word of preposition, for it will have to go from MPC to UPWC, then to the military for approval and they cannot decide on their own. Given such circumstance, he doesn't think they will touch or alter the already accepted 5th NCA draft of 31 March. Otherwise, the process could be very long.
  • United Wa State Army (UWSA) is not against NCA, but agrees that it should proceed with those that are already involved and those not in it should go with their own process and formula.
  • Regarding Kokang conflict, it is the key issue that will determine if NCA could be signed. The regime would need to stop the military offensives or tone down the attacks on Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army (MNDAA), if favorable condition to sign NCA is to be achieved. For without it, it will be impossible for the EAOs to go ahead with ratification. It depends on how much give-and-take could be handled between the two parties.
  • On 16 EAOs count of UPWC and NCCT differ. While government count might include UWSA, National Democratic Alliance Army (NDAA), also known as Mongla, RCSS and groups that have signed ceasefire, either state-level or union-level, NCCT is for all-inclusiveness, which means all those within the NCCT and non-NCCT, EAOs should be involved in the signing of NCA. Besides, he pointed out the fact that Kachin Independence Army (KIA) and Ta'ang National Liberation Army (TNLA) haven't sign ceasefire agreement, but are accepted by the government as negotiation partners.
  • Although all-inclusiveness doesn't mean that all EAOs have to sign the NCA together at the same time, the remaining, excluding or left out groups must be taken in at a later date into the peace process; that is the signing of NCA. Furthermore, excluding groups must not mean permanent left out or subject to military offensives of the military; for this won't be accepted by the EAOs. The excluding groups would need to have political guarantee to participate in the future.
  • If one of the EAOs is attacked in one corner of the country and still NCA is signed, all will become a laughing stock.

Commander-in Chief request to China
On 19 May, the Vice Minister, of the International Department of the Communist Party of China, H.E. Mr. Chen Fengxiang and Commander-in-Chief Min Aung Hliang met, where the latter stressed that along the 2000 kilometers border between China and Burma, problems of ethnic armed conflicts couldn't be resolved until now, and that since it is the violation of Burma's sovereignty employing armed insurrection, it could not be accepted. Furthermore, as strategic partners, in view of keeping good bilateral relationship, China is requested to help solicit the ethnic armed organizations to give up arms, according to Mizzima report of 20 May.

However, it is not reported on how Mr.Chen has responded to the request.

The Commander-in-Chief's request was interpreted by some MPs and political parties' leaders as below.

  • U Khin Maung Swe, Chairman of National democratic Front (NDF) said political settlement is essential before asking the EAOs to give up arms and government must show sincerity and give political security first.

  • U Hla Swe, the MP from Magwe, said that Min Aung Hliang seems to be telling that China should not help MNDAA militarily, while Daw Dwe Bu, an MP from Kachin State, stressed that speedily implementing federalism will do the job, without having to solicit help from outsiders.

  • Sai Nyunt Lwin a top leader of Shan Nationalities league for Democracy (SNLD) is of the opinion that Burma Army wants China's help to win the war and it is likely asking China not to help MNDAA militarily. He said political solution is the best.

According to DVB report of 22 May, responding to Burmese military chief Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing's call for ethnic groups to abandon armed struggle, the general secretary of NCCT, Saw Kwe Htoo Win, has said that disarmament was never an issue on the table at ceasefire talks between the ethnic bloc and the government. Besides, surrendering arms was never an option nor was the matter included in the 5th NCA draft, signed on 31 March.

"During the era of the military junta, they used such terminologies as 'abandoning the armed movement' and 'entering the legal fold', but those issues or phrases were not used during the ceasefire talks," he said.

Points to ponder
Given the prevailing situation, there are quite a few points to speculate or ponder. They are on how China would respond to Min Aung Hliang's request, particularly the disarming of EAOs along the Burma-China border; both countries taking responsibility of the border areas; and the blaming of MNDAA for the latest bombardment that landed on Chinese soil, on 14-15 May.

With the Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Hong Lei stressing in a daily news briefing that China required the Burma to make a "serious, overall and responsible" investigation into the incident and give a responsible explanation to China, on 20 May, it was made clear on what the Chinese thought of Min Aung Hliang's accusation that the 14-15 May bombing was the handiwork of the MNDAA. Otherwise, it would have come down hard on MNDAA.

According to 20 May Xinhua news, Hong said China also asked the Myanmar side to take effective measures to prevent similar incidents.

"We urge the relevant parties to cool down the situation and restore peace and stability to the China-Myanmar border area at an early date," Hong said.

Again, taking responsibility of the border areas interpretation could also be different. While Min Aung Hliang point of view is to disarm and conducting joint-military operation to weed out the elements like MNDAA, UWSA, NDAA and the likes, which are more or less dependent on China and some even outrightly see them as China's proxies, China's position is to promote negotiations and resolve the armed conflict peacefully. Besides, it has always made known that it could be involved in a peace-keeping force headed by the United Nations to help return the border areas to normalcy.

Before summing up two paragraphs from The Diplomat issue of 20 May, written by Dr. Xue Li, Director of the Department of International Strategy at the Institute of World Economics and Politics, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, might be just what China is having in mind, regarding the ongoing problems along Burma-China border.

"Finally, China should use the advantages of the Kokang area, and make it a model for implementation of the Silk Road and the Maritime Silk Road Strategy. A prosperous Kokang can benefit both China and Myanmar. Establishing a Kokang Special Administrative Area (a step forward from the current autonomous area), where the Myanmar government is only responsible for defense and diplomacy, might be a viable solution. This will need Myanmar's government to genuinely implement the Panglong Agreement, and to go beyond the 2008 constitution, which is not recognized by local ethnic minorities".

"An autonomous Kokang can provide economic benefits. It can also set an example for Wa and Kachin States. For the Chinese government, a stable Kokang is beneficial to the Bangladesh-China-India-Myanmar Economic corridor, oil and gas pipelines, and other transportation infrastructure, and allows for the protection of ethnic Chinese in the area".


The contributor is ex-General Secretary of the dormant Shan Democratic Union (SDU) — Editor