Monday, June 12, 2017

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Kachin Community Told Not to Open IDP Camps in Tanai

Posted: 12 Jun 2017 07:35 AM PDT

Around 950 people who fled fighting in the villages of Tanai Township, Kachin State, continue to take temporary shelter at the churches and monasteries in Tanai town, as the authorities have reportedly barred the opening of camps for internally displaced persons (IDPs).

Due to nearly a week of clashes between the Myanmar Army and the Kachin Independence Army (KIA) near the Kawng Ra, N'Ga Ga and the Nambyu areas, locals and those working in amber and gold mines have been leaving since last Tuesday. Internal migrants have largely returned to their homes elsewhere, but local villagers have said they have no other place to go.

Some of those fleeing were not allowed to travel to Tanai town last week using standard routes and waterways; others used longer, more unorthodox paths to reach safety in the city.

On Monday morning, the relief committee formed by Christian religious leaders providing support to displaced villagers had a meeting with township authorities, including Tanai's administrative director, police and the military personnel. According to the community representatives, these authorities said that they do not want the relief workers to open formal IDP camps.

Until Saturday, June 10, the Tanai authorities had been instructing displaced people to move to Kawng Ra village, where the current fighting continues, said Mung Dan, from the Tanai-based Kachin Baptist Convention (KBC). The IDPs refused, fearing for their security.

"On Monday, they did not say anything about moving [the IDPs to Kawng Ra], but they did say that no IDP camps could be opened in Tanai, in order to preserve the dignity of town. We can help the people in our churches," he said.

More people have been slowly arriving, trickling in to the town, rather than showing up in large groups.

Relief workers told The Irrawaddy that more than 500 people are taking shelter at KBC churches, while 200 people are under the care of the Catholic Church, and an estimated 133 people are being cared for by the Anglican Church. Around 120 are also staying in monasteries in Tanai.

They have been asked to compile a list of the displaced in the churches and monasteries, which will be checked by authorities later, Mung Dan said.

When fighting erupted last week, the Tatmadaw reportedly distributed a written message from helicopters warning workers to leave amber and gold mines in Tanai no later than June 15.

State Counselor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi was asked on June 10 by members of the Burmese community in Canada—where she was on an official visit—what the government would do to follow up on this order to flee. She replied that she had "not heard anything" about the military's letter, but would investigate it.

"We have to know who ordered it, and if it is true, it is the job of the social welfare ministry to take care of it," she said.

According to U Win Myat Aye, the Union minister for social welfare, relief and resettlement, the ministry helps those IDPs "who can make it to Moegaung Township only," which is south of and not bordering Tanai. He added that they have assisted about two dozen people who are seeking shelter with relatives there.

Nang Lwin Hnin Pwint contributed to this report.

The post Kachin Community Told Not to Open IDP Camps in Tanai appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

FBR Medic: ‘It Was a Great Privilege to Be Able to Help’

Posted: 12 Jun 2017 06:16 AM PDT

Free Burma Rangers (FBR), a Christian humanitarian group, sent a team to Iraq to assist civilians who were affected by conflict waged by the group calling itself the Islamic State (IS). Formed in 1997 by former US Army officer David Eubank, FBR has provided emergency relief in ethnic minority areas in Myanmar plagued by more than 60 years of civil war. Since January 2016, FBR has repeatedly traveled to Iraq for relief and reporting trips.

The Irrawaddy's senior reporter Saw Yan Naing interviewed FBR member Silverhorn Lermu, an ethnic Karen medic who recently returned from a relief mission to Mosul, Iraq.

Please tell us about your experience in Iraq.

I had the chance to go and help people in a country I had never been to. My duty on this trip was to treat injured civilians and assist refugees who had fled IS fighters. People had been injured by gunshots, building collapses and fire. We were not a large team but it was a great privilege to be able to help, even in a small way.

When did you go to Iraq and for how long? How does the conflict there compare to Myanmar?

I went from April 17 to May 17. Conflict in Iraq and Karen State, Myanmar is very different. They are geographically different as well, hence the use of different military equipment. I saw many refugees in Iraq who were fleeing the conflict.

IS is notorious for its extreme violence. Weren't you afraid? How did you prepare for the trip?

IS fighters kill women, old men, children and the disabled. I was worried for my safety before I left. But when I got there and saw the suffering, my fear disappeared. I believed God would protect me and I trusted the Iraqi military. I mainly followed them and treated the injured.

Did you confront IS troops?

Our mission was not to fight. We were there to help in an emergency situation. I did not go there to fight IS nor help the Iraqi Army. I was there to assist civilian communities.

Your team leader David Eubank was injured. How did that happen and what is his current condition?

I heard that he was injured the day after I returned to Karen State. He and an Iraqi Army officer were confronted by four IS fighters. His hand was injured but his condition now is good.

How did you and assist and how did Iraqi civilians respond to you?

We delivered water, food and clothes and provided healthcare. We also provided reports based on our experience there for the international community. Civilians and Iraqi Army officers were appreciative.

This interview was edited for clarity and brevity.

The post FBR Medic: 'It Was a Great Privilege to Be Able to Help' appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Karen State Ma Ba Tha Chapter Keeps Name Despite State Sangha Ban

Posted: 12 Jun 2017 04:07 AM PDT

YANGON — The Karen State chapter of the Buddhist nationalist Association for Protection of Race and Religion—known as Ma Ba Tha—will continue to use the name, despite a ban by the State Buddhist Sangha authority.

The state Buddhist Sangha authority—known as Ma Ha Na—on May 23 banned the nationalist organization from operating under its current name and also ordered that all signs bearing the name be taken down across the country by July.

Members of the Karen State Ma Ba Tha chapter, however, decided to continue using the name at a meeting on Sunday.

"This is not in opposition to Ma Ha Na. We've looked into its legality and decided to continue using the name as it is not against the law," said a Ma Ba Tha monk from Karen State.

The Karen State chapter released a statement on Sunday stating that the name does not go against Sangha organizational laws or procedures and that it conforms to the 2008 Constitution and the 2014 Association Registration Law.

Senior monks from the Buddha Dhamma Charity Foundation (Central)—formerly Ma Ba Tha (Central)—attended the meeting and said they respected the decision.

Dr. Sopaka, a leader of the Buddha Dhamma Charity Foundation (Central), said: "Though Ma Ba Tha (Central) has decided to go by Buddha Dhamma Charity Foundation, it does not instruct all chapters to change their names. We have no comment on this decision."

In the statement released on Sunday, Karen State's Ma Ba Tha chapter said it would follow the guidelines of the Buddha Dhamma Charity Foundation and also cooperate with Dhamma Wunthanu Rakhita, other charity groups, and all nationalist forces.

Ma Ha Na has said any monk who breaches its ban would be punished under Sangha law and any layperson would be referred to the Home Affairs Ministry for prosecution.

Ma Ba Tha on May 20 rebranded itself as the Buddha Dhamma Charity Foundation following Ma Ha Na's ban.

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post Karen State Ma Ba Tha Chapter Keeps Name Despite State Sangha Ban appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

U Wirathu Claims Facebook Blocked His Accounts

Posted: 12 Jun 2017 02:17 AM PDT

Myanmar's ultranationalist Buddhist monk U Wirathu claimed Facebook temporarily shut down his account in a video shared on another Facebook account last Friday.

"On May 31 [Facebook] said they would shut down the account for a month, after sending a report," he said, adding that he had not posted anything that violated Facebook policy.

A screenshot of Friday's video displayed a report sent by Facebook saying the account was temporarily blocked for 30 days as the account holder had repeatedly made posts, which were not allowed on Facebook.

The account had almost 400,000 followers.

"I did not write the names of people on my Facebook," said the firebrand monk in the video. "I did not post any personal attacks, I only wrote simple things, but they shut it down," he said.

U Wirathu, a prominent member of ultranationalist organization Ma Ba Tha known for his anti-Muslim hate speech, spuriously accused Facebook of falling under the control of Muslims.

Another of his accounts under the name Ma Soe Yein Wira Thu in Myanmar language with 70,000 followers was allegedly also shut down.

"I got a report saying they would close it for a week. But, I found later that they destroyed it completely," he said in the video.

The National League for Democracy-led government has sought to curb hate speech by U Wirathu and other Ma Ba Tha members. In March, the Buddhist authority State Sangha Maha Nayaka Committee, known as Ma Ha Na, banned U Wirathu from delivering sermons across the country for one year.

Last month, Ma Ha Na imposed restrictions on Ma Ba Tha, banning the organization from operating under its current name and ordering that their signboards be taken down across the country by July.

It was the second blow by the Buddhist cleric authority after its announcement last year that Ma Ba Tha was not a "lawful monks' association" as "it was not formed in accordance with the country's monastic rules."

Late last month, Facebook seemed to impose a ban on the word "kala," which originally was used to describe those of South Asian descent but has increasingly been used as a derogatory term for Muslims.

The post U Wirathu Claims Facebook Blocked His Accounts appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Dengue Fever Outbreak Claims 8 Lives in Yangon

Posted: 12 Jun 2017 12:00 AM PDT

YANGON — Yangon Division is experiencing the most fatal dengue fever outbreak since 2010, according to the division's public health department.

So far this year, 1,477 dengue cases have been recorded in the division—of which eight were fatal.

"There are more urban areas [than rural areas] in Yangon Division. And fatality is higher in urban areas," said Dr. Khin Nan Lone of the public health department at its press conference on dengue on Saturday.

"There is no cure for the disease, so it is important that the patient is sent to the hospital in time. The disease can be fatal in one in every 100 infected, even if they are sent to the hospital in time," she added.

In 2010, 906 cases were recorded in Yangon Division; six were fatal. In 2011, 102 cases were recorded; 117 cases in 2012; 1,014 cases, including five fatal cases, in 2013; 456 cases, including three fatal cases, in 2014; 968 cases, including six fatal cases, in 2015; and 280 cases in 2016, of which four were fatal.

"Mosquitoes have bred a lot this year. Now, there is no place in the country where dengue fever does not break out," said Dr. Khin Nan Lone, referring to Chin State, which only reported two cases last year.

The government usually conducts spraying campaigns in residential wards during the rainy season in urban areas, but community-level efforts are critical to preventing the disease as mosquitoes breed in clear water, she said.

"Mosquito spray only lasts for an hour, and mosquitoes are now resistant to spray. Some countries no longer use spray as at it can cause breathing problems," she added.

Yellow fever mosquitoes—aedes aegypti­—are mainly responsible for dengue fever, which tends to be found in places where there is a large population, standing water, and poor sanitation.

The disease includes common symptoms such as a few days of fever, headache, muscle pain and joint pain, and sometimes a rash. Children are more vulnerable to the disease.

Dr. Win Lwin, head of the division's public health department, urged ward authorities to encourage residents to clear the bushes and ponds that collect rainwater in their wards.

"The best prevention is to get rid of them at the larval stage," he stressed.

According to figures from the public health department, the outbreak has been highest in the heavily populated Hlinetharyar Township, with more than 200 cases this year, followed by South Dagon, Dala, East Dagon, and Twante, with about 100 cases each.

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post Dengue Fever Outbreak Claims 8 Lives in Yangon appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

The Forgotten Frontier

Posted: 11 Jun 2017 11:30 PM PDT

SS Khaplang, the Naga rebel leader of the National Socialist Council of Nagaland-Khaplang (NSCN-K), passed away at age 77 last Friday, according to the Council of Naga Affairs (CNA) based in Zingkaling, Hkamti in Sagaing region, northwest Myanmar.

The Irrawaddy revisits this article from Nov. 2014 about rebel groups in Myanmar's remote frontiers.

There is no shortage of coverage in local as well as regional media of the ongoing armed conflict in Myanmar's Kachin State in the north, the activities of the heavily armed United Wa State Army (UWSA) in the northeast or the still volatile situation in areas of Kayin State along the border with Thailand. However, hardly a word is written about the host of armed rebel groups that are active in some of the country's wildest and most remote mountain ranges which form the more than 1,600 kilometer-long border with India. Yet, this is where the rivalry between Myanmar's two mighty neighbors, India and China, has often played out and where there is potential for even more trouble in the future.

In the mid-1950s, a rebellion broke out among ethnic Naga tribesmen in India's northeast. Being a predominantly Christian tribe of Mongol stock, they did not feel that they belonged to India and demanded independence. Not surprisingly, they received support from India's arch-enemy Pakistan and training facilities were provided in what was then East Pakistan, now Bangladesh. But more significantly, much more aid came from China.

In 1959, the Dalai Lama fled to India after a failed uprising against the Chinese who had invaded his homeland, Tibet. Asia's two giants were on a collision course and, three years later, China attacked India and a short but fierce war was fought along a disputed border in India's northeast.

From 1967-76, nearly 1,000 Naga rebels trekked from northeast India through northern Myanmar to China, where they received military training. They were sent back to India equipped with assault rifles, light machine-guns, rocket launchers and other modern Chinese weapons. The Naga were escorted by rebels from the Kachin Independence Army (KIA), which, in return for their services, kept some of the Chinese weapons.

Various other insurgent groups in India's northeast also sought Chinese assistance. In the early 1970s, about 200 Mizo rebels—a tribe then fighting for self-determination in what is now the state of Mizoram—were trained in China; in 1976, a group of insurgents from the Indian state of Manipur made it to Tibet, where they received political training and some military instruction; and in the late 1980s, rebels from the state of Assam attempted to reach China through northern Myanmar, but ended up staying in areas controlled by the KIA—which trained some of them in guerrilla warfare.

It was clear the rebellions in India's northeast were not solely an internal affair and that Myanmar, the land in the middle of the two regional powers, would inevitably be drawn in. This became even more evident in the 1970s when the Indian army managed to drive the Naga rebels out of their bases on the Indian side of the border. They regrouped in the rugged Naga Hills of the northern Sagaing Region. There, beyond the reach of the Indian army, they could launch cross-border raids into India.

Myanmar's military, preoccupied with ethnic insurgencies elsewhere in the country, paid little attention to the Indian Naga who linked up with a group of Naga in Myanmar led by S.S. Khaplang. Manipuri as well as Assamese rebels also sought sanctuary on the Myanmar side of the border.

The only fall-out came in 1988 when the Naga from Myanmar, simply tired of being treated as serfs by their Indian cousins, drove them out of the area. The National Socialist Council of Nagaland (NSCN) then split into two factions: the National Socialist Council of Nagaland-Khaplang (NSCN-K), led by Khaplang, and the National Socialist Council of NagalimIsak-Muivah (NSCN-IM), the Indian faction led by Isak Chishi Swu and Thuingaleng Muivah which adopted the name Nagalim, a new term for a "greater Nagaland" encompassing the state of Nagaland as well as most of Manipur, a chunk of Assam, and the Naga Hills of Myanmar. In July 1997, the NSCN-IM entered into a ceasefire agreement with the Indian government and in 2001, the NSCN-K did the same. In April 2012, NSCN-K also struck a ceasefire deal with the Myanmar government, making it the only insurgent group to have ceasefire agreements with the governments of two sovereign states.

But none of this means that the conflicts are over. Hundreds of rebels from various outfits in Manipur as well as the once powerful United Liberation Front of Asom [Assam] (ULFA) are based at Khaplang's headquarters at Taka near the Chindwin River, north of Singkaling Hkamti in Sagaing Region. As late as December 2011, the Indian journalist Rajeev Bhattacharyya, who had trekked to Taka, observed ULFA forces taking delivery of a major consignment of weapons that most probably had been smuggled to the base from China. According to other sources, there is a booming trade in weapons acquired along the Sino-Myanmar frontier that are smuggled via Mandalay and Monywa to the Indian border. Old stocks from the UWSA's vast arsenal of weapons and other military equipment have also been found in areas along the Indo-Myanmar border.

In late 2012, it emerged that the Myanmar army had obtained Swedish-made 84mm Carl Gustaf rocket launchers most probably supplied by India and intended for use against the ULFA and other Indian insurgents. They were instead employed against the KIA and a major scandal ensued during which questions were raised in Sweden's parliament and the Indian ambassador in Stockholm was summoned by the Swedish foreign ministry for an explanation. Ultimately, India submitted a report stating that the weapons, which according to their serial numbers had been delivered by Sweden to India, had not been transferred to Myanmar through conventional channels, and New Delhi promised the Swedes that it would not happen again. For years, India has urged Myanmar to close down the camps that insurgents have established inside Myanmar's Sagaing Region, but to no avail. It is clear that fighting India's rebels is not a priority for Myanmar's military.

And China? When ULFA commander Paresh Barua is not inspecting his troops at the Taka camp, he is in China. Obtaining weapons there does not seem to be a problem. Beijing appears to reason that if India can shelter one of its main enemies, the Dalai Lama, then Barua is welcome to stay in China. The situation promises to become even more entangled as the NSCN-IM continues to express frustration over the direction that 17-year-long negotiations with Indian authorities are headed. Barred from entering Khaplang's area, NSCN-IM cadres in October this year were reported to have been scouting the hills east of Manipur for potential new sanctuaries in anticipation of a breakdown in talks.

New Delhi, of course, wants to see peace established along its entire border with Myanmar so it can implement its so-called "Look East Policy"—aimed at linking India with the booming economies of Southeast Asia. Myanmar's Wild West may be almost forgotten in today's discussions about the country's ethnic issues, but the number of armed groups in the area with conflicting agendas makes it the country's messiest frontier.

The post The Forgotten Frontier appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

More Bodies Recovered from Crashed Military Plane

Posted: 11 Jun 2017 11:24 PM PDT

YANGON — Myanmar rescuers have recovered the bodies of about half of the 122 people who were on board a military plane that went missing after it crashed into the Andaman Sea last week, the army said on Monday.

The Chinese-made Y-8-200F transport plane crashed into the sea last Wednesday when it was carrying 122 soldiers, family members and crew on a weekly flight from several coastal towns to Myanmar's largest city, Yangon.

The number of bodies retrieved so far rose to 62 on Monday as the hunt for the plane stretched into a sixth day, the military said on its official Facebook page. Nine children were among those found.

While the cause of the incident has yet to be confirmed, Myanmar's Commander-in-Chief Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing said on Sunday there was "a very big cloud" near the plane crash site, according to his official Facebook page.

He did not elaborate.

"The crashed plane was expected to be found soon as it crashed in the country's territory and some evidences were collected," he said.

Myanmar authorities had rejected offers of help from several countries including China, the state-run newspaper Global New Light of Myanmar said on Sunday.

Some bodies pulled from the waters off Myanmar's southern coast were cremated last week as relatives and friends mourned the identified victims in the coastal town of Dawei.

Aircraft accidents, involving both civilian and military planes, are not uncommon in the Southeast Asian country.

A military helicopter crashed last June, killing three military personnel. Five were killed in February last year when an air force aircraft crashed in the capital, Naypyitaw, media reports said

The post More Bodies Recovered from Crashed Military Plane appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Four Arrested as Police, Hired Heavies Clear Squatters in Yangon

Posted: 11 Jun 2017 10:59 PM PDT

YANGON—Police arrested four men and one woman on Monday morning for resisting the eviction of five villages on Ministry of Construction-owned land near a tollgate on the Yangon-Naypyitaw Highway in Hlegu Township.

In the first forced eviction by the National League for Democracy (NLD)-led government, nearly 200 police troops and 700 hired civilian reinforcements armed with clubs, swords and axes were deployed Monday morning to clear nearly 20,000 houses.

Police Brig-Gen Mya Win, who was on the ground, told The Irrawaddy that anyone hostile to authorities would be arrested. A number of police vans were parked beside the highway.

According to the director general of the Housing Department, U Yu Khaing, the area is owned by the government and slated for development by the Housing Department and the Ministry of Construction.

"We can't say exactly when the development will be started, but it will begin soon after eviction and demolition," he said.

The area was first bulldozed in 2015 to evict squatters.

Related Video(1)

Related Video(2)

Related Video(3)

The post Four Arrested as Police, Hired Heavies Clear Squatters in Yangon appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

National News

National News


New import laws for LNG in the pipeline

Posted: 11 Jun 2017 01:22 PM PDT

The Ministry of Electricity and Energy (MOEE) is going to draft new laws on liquefied natural gas (LNG) in cooperation with the Myanmar Oil and Gas Services Society (MOGSS) and Hluttaw but details of the draft are not known, MOGSS vice-chair Daw Hnin Phyu Phyu Aung told The Myanmar Times.

‘Death Railway’ to get a new lease on life

Posted: 11 Jun 2017 01:20 PM PDT

The historic Yangon-Mandalay railroad, better known as the Death Railway, is in dire need of a facelift.

Myanmar, Singapore ink MoU to establish skill standards for workers

Posted: 11 Jun 2017 01:14 PM PDT

The Ministry of Labour, Immigration and Population signed an MoU with Singapore's Temasek Foundation-Singapore Polytechnic in Nay Pyi Taw on Thursday to cooperate on establishing a technical institution quality assurance framework for Myanmar workers.

Substations, transmission lines to be extended in new towns

Posted: 11 Jun 2017 01:12 PM PDT

Construction of substations and transmission lines by the Ministry of Electricity and Energy to provide electricity to new towns and regions is part of the 5-year plan beginning in fiscal 2017-2018, Deputy Minister Dr Tun Naing said at last week's Pyithu Hluttaw session.

Causes of plane crash narrowed

Posted: 11 Jun 2017 01:07 PM PDT

The Commander-in-Chief of the Defence Services Senior General Min Aung Hlaing has said that the possible causes for the June 7 crash of a Y-8F 200 Tatmadaw transport plane are mechanical failure, an explosive material on board or pilot error.

More bodies from plane crash recovered

Posted: 11 Jun 2017 01:03 PM PDT

Search crews in Myanmar have now recovered the bodies of nearly half of those who died in last week's military plane crash, the army said Sunday.

Communication law ‘likely to be reviewed’

Posted: 11 Jun 2017 01:00 PM PDT

An amendment to section 66(d) of the Communication Law has been discussed by the Assessment Commission of Legal Affairs and Special Issues and is likely to be reviewed, commission member and ruling NLD spokesperson U Win Htein said.

PC, UNFC to discuss int’l community’s role in ceasefire in next meeting

Posted: 11 Jun 2017 12:56 PM PDT

The role of the international community in preserving the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement signed between the armed ethnic groups and the government will likely dominate the upcoming negotiations in early July between the government's Peace Commission (PC) and United Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC).

Machines may stem farm labour shortage in Magwe

Posted: 11 Jun 2017 12:52 PM PDT

The agriculture sector should switch from labour-intensive farming to mechanisation to overcome a worker shortage, according to U Nay Myo Kyaw, minister of Labour, Immigration and Population in Magwe Region.

7 Myanmar workers rescued from sugar-cane farm in Thailand

Posted: 11 Jun 2017 12:48 PM PDT

Thai and Myanmar officials have rescued seven Myanmar nationals who were tricked into working for nothing on a sugar-cane farm in a forest in Kanchanaburi Province, Thailand.

Shan Herald Agency for News

Shan Herald Agency for News


To Hopeland and Back: The 30th trip (15-18 May 2017)

Posted: 12 Jun 2017 01:46 AM PDT

Everyman is my superior in some way
In that I learn from him.
(Ralph Waldo Emerson (1803-1882)

The trip came about due to the Pyidaungsu Institute (PI) Yangon Office's plan to launch its latest work," English-Myanmar Glossary of Federalism Terms," on 16 May.

It came in the wake of the 5 sets of proposals produced by the Union Peace Dialogue Joint Committee (UPDJC) for the 5 dialogue topics (Politics, Security, Social, Economic, and Land and Natural resources Management) to be discussed at the Union Peace Conference (UPC)#3, otherwise Union Peace Conference 21stCentury Panglong (UPC 21 CP) #2, scheduled for 24-28 May.

Naturally, I had taken the opportunity to visit the country in order to seek advice from my friends, both Shan and non-Shan.

The following journal details what I had found out from them. Obviously, I will be doing my best to follow the Chatham House rule.

Day One. Monday, 15 May 2017

In international experience since 1989, the likelihood of a military solution to conflict drops to 25% after one year, or 10% after three tears.

Can Myanmar's peace process learn from international experience? Frontier, 24 May 2017

The Bangkok Airways lands at Mingladon at 12:10. Twenty minutes later, I arrive at the office of the Shan Nationalities League for Democracy (SNLD), better known as the "Tiger Head" party. I'm there to ask for its stance on the 12 May propositions by the UPDJC, which were reported to the Peace Process Steering Team (PPST), the highest organ of the 8 signatory EAOs on the following day:

§  The propositions on politics are based on the EAOs' 8 point guideline that was adopted in 2005, and acceded by the July 2016 Mai Jayang conference:

1.     Sovereign power (and its exercise)
2.     Equality
3.     Right of Self-Determination
4.     Structure and division of power
5.     Minority rights
6.     Democratic right, human rights, and gender equality
7.     Secular state
8.     Multiparty democratic system

§  At first, it was agreed that the UPC#3 will discuss only 6 points: sovereign power, exercise of sovereign power, equality, right of self-determination, structure and division of power, secular state, and multiparty democratic system, leaving the rest for UPC#4

§  However due to a press interview on 9 or 10 May by an ethnic politician that had reportedly offended the Tatmadaw, it returned with a new parcel of proposals on the next day, revoking everything it had agreed earlier. One of them was the Tatmadaw's original stand on secularism which is enshrined in the 2008 constitution, where Buddhism, according to an EAO member, "is more equal than other religions." In the ensuing negotiations, each side refused to budge, so the point was removed from the political sector for the upcoming session.

§  The military also insisted the clause "No part of the territory constituted in the Union shall ever secede from the Union" which comes directly from the 2008 constitution, be the cardinal point in the proposal

Members of the Peace Process Steering Team (PPST) 
meet, 13-14 May, in Chiang Mai, Thailand, 
over the weekend to discuss the UPDJC proposals to be 
submitted to the Union Peace Conference, 24-28 
May. (Photo: The Irrawaddy)
The EAOs' arguments against this includes, among others;

1.     We have already agreed to the Tatmadaw's 3 main national causes: Non disintegration of the Union, Non disintegration of National solidarity, and Perpetuation of national sovereignty. There is therefore no need to insert this clause
2.     We should choose words that are positive, that promote a sense of unity, definitely not this one

The Burmese military bloc wouldn't yield an inch on this issue, saying:

§  To fulfil your sense of spiritual security, we will agree to your call for equality, right of self-determination, and state constitutions
§  In return, we want you to fulfil ours too, by agreeing not to secede from the Union

In brief, the military was offering a tradeoff between "equality, right of self-determination, and state constitutions" and "non-secession".

The State Counselor reportedly decided to jump into the fray by announcing she supported the military's proposition.

The result: the EAO UPDJC agreed to accept the unwanted clause as a Hobson's choice for the UPC#3 to make. As the PPST, being the signatory EAOs decision making body, key EAO UPDJC representatives had flown to Thailand on 12 May evening to report back to it on the following.

As to be expected, the PPST didn't have a Yes or No answer for the question. Giving either one without consulting its own people, as one Karen participant said on 14 May, would amount to a "political suicide."

If it is a difficult issue for the Karen National Union, that had conducted both ethnic and local level national political dialogue (NDs), it is the more difficult for EAOs like ALP and RCSS that have yet to do NDs. Moreover, this question, they believe, must be answered not just by the NCA signatories but also the non-signatories.

Gen Yawd Serk, President of the RCSS, put it this way:

"I'm not agreeing or disagreeing to it. I think I understand the military's concern very well. But the military should also try to understand our difficulties."

Note: On 21 May, the RCSS issued a statement saying it would "attend the UPC 21CP Second Session only as one of the NCA signatories, but will not present any propositions. In addition, if there is going to be a preliminary agreement as part of the planned Union Accord, it will not be a participant or a signatory."

My question during the briefing was why the proposals weren't publicized ahead of the UPC. No answer came forth.

The SNLD, known as a party for "principles," is forthright:

·        This demand (of the military) contradicts the Panglong Agreement of 1947. We will not accept it.
·        If anyone or any party is thinking of accepting it, please remember one is not giving up what belongs to one, but what belongs to all of us.

In the evening, I'm at the home of Sai Ai Pao, leader of the Shan Nationalities Democratic Party (SNDP), popularly known as "White Tiger" party to meet its leaders.

True to its "in the interests of the nation" principle, its response is different from the SNLD's "stick to your principles" principle. "There should be lots of better words than 'not to secede,' which is very negative. We are ready to accept the deal, provided the wording is changed."

I'm back at the hotel by 21:00.

Day Two. Tuesday, 16 May 2017

The failure to honor the Panglong Agreement had led to strife and war. It is clear that to bring peace, there is no way other than to honor Panglong.

Swiss ambassador Mr Paul Seger
(Photo: Embassy of Switzerland in Myanmar Facebook)
Khaing Soe Naing Aung, Vice Chairman, Arakan Liberation Party (ALP), speaking at PPST ad hoc meeting, 13 May 2017

Today, we hold a launch for the PI booklet, which is blessed by the Swiss ambassador Mr Paul Seger by his charming presence and opening remarks.

The following are extracts from my brief statement:

How many types of federalism are out there? The booklet here says not less than 12. We have here:

·        Administrative federalism
·        Ethno federalism
·        Executive federalism
·        Fiscal federalism
·        Three layer federalism

And when we run in to "asymmetric federalism," we will want to know what 'symmetric federalism" is. The same goes for "non-territorial federalism." We will be asking how it is different from "territorial federalism." Fortunately for us, all 4 types will be found in the booklet.

Apart from those already mentioned, there are also intriguing types like "coercive federalism," "competitive federalism," "cooperative federalism", "double federalism," and, to further confuse us, even "dual federalism,"

And coming to this, the question arises: What type of federalism will fit our country? Is it going to be "coercive federalism" or "cooperative federalism"? Some are saying one thing, and others the other. We will soon find out at the upcoming Union Peace Conference, also dubbed as 21stCentury Panglong.

The rest of the day is spent in meeting friends to find out what they think about the proposals from the UPDJC.

Here are what two of them have to say.

Friend #1

·        The UPDJC should not be the ultimate arbiter.
Note: For some time, we've been hearing from both sides of the fence that the UPC 21 CP is only a "rubber stamp" to what the UPDJC decides. *
·        The proposed non-secession clause is technically not a problem. But politically it can hendanger the whole process.
·        The people must be consulted. But if one part of them okays to the clause, while the others say No, what do we do?

Friend #2 (who is a trained lawyer)

·        The military, apart from "secession" is worried about calling the federal units "states" instead of "regions and states". Because if all become states," then some will be rekindling an "8 state" arrangement.
·        I disagree with both the 1947 constitution which allows states to secede "without any reason," and the 2008 which forbids states to secede "for whatever reasons." Both are extremes, and being extremes are hotbeds for rebellions
·        My suggestion is rewording: How about "The Union, established on the principles of equality, right of self-determination and federalism, is one and indivisible"?
(I ask him what it means, and here is his reply: As long as equality, right of self-determination and federalism are practiced, there should be no secession, and vice versa, It is a mutually binding clause, providing each party what is wants.)**
·        As for the 9 point Panglong Agreement, he says Clause 5 (Full autonomy) and clause 7 (rights and privileges which are fundamental in democratic countries) are still valid.

By 21:00, I'm back in my hotel room. It has been a very instructive day, so I say to myself.

Day Three. Wednesday, 17 May 2017

Splinter factions emerge when security arrangements don't satisfy the political goals of all members.

Can Myanmar's peace process learn from international experience? Frontier, 24 May 2017

Today's another day for duck hunting. But I only find one.

He's a veteran peacemaker, but out of touch with the day-to-day affairs of the process. When I tell him what's been reported to the PPST on 13-14 May, he says:
"Is that what really happened?" he asks. "And I have saying 'Sadhu' (Amen) every time I hear the government announcing that significant achievements like constitutions for the states have been reached."

"I know how the military feels about this secession issue," he says. "It's an obsession
Drug Elimination Museum.
(Photo: www.vice.com)
with the generals, past and present. But during my days, I had always tried to encourage words that carried the same meanings but put together differently so both sides could agree. Please try to do the same. Always use inoffensive words. And also value everything you manage to reach agreement."

The rest of the day is spent visiting the Drug Elimination Museum on the corner of Kyundaw Road and Hanthawady Road in Kamayut Township.

I find that, unlike its counterpart in Chiang Saen at the Golden Triangle, it has been suffering from neglect.

To be expected, there are no photos of General Khin Nyunt who fell from grace in 2004. And as to be expected, those of the late Gen Soe Win, who replaced him, were there.

Almost all the campaigns waged against the armed resistance naturally came under the heading of anti-narcotics, including those against the Kuomintang forces in the 50's. For example:

From 8-16 April 1983, the Mo Hein Campaign #7 was launched against the Shan United Revolutionary Army (SURA), of which I was a member.

A panel there informs us: 19.6 kg of raw opium and 74.5 kg of grey (cooked) opium were seized. A friend who was among the attacking Burmese force later told me that several villagers were recruited to carry the drugs and cooking utensils from all the way to Sanklang, opposite Mae Hong Son's Pai district.

I wouldn't say the Shan resistance was an innocent bystander when it came to drugs. Only that a few days under attack gave ample time for the drug entrepreneurs to make their getaway. What's remarkable was the fact that the Burma Army was ready and prepared for that eventuality.

I have another meeting in the evening. But nothing to report without rocking boats.
At 21:00, I'm back in my room again.

Day Four. Thursday, 18 May 2017

Between 1989-2012, 80% of security focused agreements globally have broken down, if non-security issues were not also addressed. In contrast, more than 80% of comprehensive peace agreements between 1989-2012 — that is, agreements that include a wide range of social, economic, political and security issues— have successfully guarded against a return to violence when they are fully implemented.

Can Myanmar's peace process learn from international experience? Frontier, 24 May 2017

At 08:00 in the morning, I'm with friends from the other side of the fence.
Their advice:

Negotiation is basically not about who's right and who's wrong. But how we are going to overcome the deadlock together.

Which seems to go in line with what the great Indian teacher, the Buddha, said:
Speak only when it's true and beneficial, whether it's pleasant or not.

He seemed to be telling us that being "principled" is not enough. And neither is being "in the interests of the nation." But the two must come together.

At 13:00 the Bangkok Airways takes off to Chiangmai, a little over one hour flight away.

Note

*After 29 May 2017, when the 37 points of agreement were signed, some have accused that the UPC 21CP isn't even a "rubber stamp" but just a spectator.

**His suggestion here was taken up for consideration during the UPC 21 CP, but was later turned down. "You might think its your Trump card," one later commented. "But in the end it turns out to be a Hillary card."