Thursday, August 4, 2016

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Govt ‘Blacklist’ Practices Highlight Lack of Transparency, Activists Say

Posted: 04 Aug 2016 08:06 AM PDT

The expanded Rangoon International Airport, photographed on March 12, 2016. (Photo: Pyay Kyaw/ The Irrawaddy)

The expanded Rangoon International Airport, photographed on March 12, 2016. (Photo: Pyay Kyaw/ The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — The Ministry of Labor, Immigration and Population officially announced on Wednesday the removal of over 600 people from Burma's notorious blacklist.

A total of 619 names—of both foreign and Burmese nationals—were taken off of a previously existing blacklist of more than 4,380 people, minister Thein Swe told the reporters at a press conference in Naypyidaw.

The names which have been removed include individuals put on the blacklist by the former Thein Sein government for political reasons, according to Minister Thein Swe. He said there was no plan to disclose the blacklisted names, in order to protect the privacy of the people in question.

"Fifteen ministries are working together to scrutinize the list of blacklisted people and to continue relaxing regulations," he added.

Despite the removals, activists are still skeptical about the announcement, which comes on the heels of an incident involving Maung Maung Wann, an educator, 88-generation political dissident and former Burmese political prisoner who was deported back to the US on Tuesday by Burmese immigration officers at the Rangoon International Airport. They claimed he was on the country's blacklist.

Maung Maung Wann was in fact granted entry to Burma with the permission of State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi, but he was forced to return to the United States before being notified of this development.

So why was Maung Maung Wann, a US citizen, issued a visa by the Burmese embassy in the United States if his name was featured on a blacklist?

Myint Kyaing, a permanent secretary with the Immigration and Population Department, told The Irrawaddy that the name "Maung Maung Wann" was on the blacklist until August 2, but was removed.

However, spokesperson Aye Aye Soe of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs claimed on Wednesday that the Burmese embassy in the US had issued him a visa because his name was not on the blacklist that the ministry had used as a reference.

Aung Myo Min, executive director of Equality Myanmar and a once-exiled activist, questioned the government mechanisms at play, describing them as "not transparent" and exhibiting a "lack of coordination."

"The case proves there is a lack of coordination between respective ministries," he said. "Such a blacklist—and the removals—should be announced publicly so that similar cases to Maung Maung Wann do not happen again."

"Without knowing who is still on the blacklist and who has been removed, we can't pressure the government about who else should be removed," he explained.

Bo Kyi, of the Assistance Association for Political Prisoners (AAPP) agreed that the current government faces challenges in reforming the much-criticized bureaucracy of its predecessors.

He also highlighted the lack of clear guidelines and government policy reflected in the removals. Some exiled activists have been forced to sign pledges that they will not engage in political activity in Burma, lest they face a rejection of their visa if they try to return.

Ko Ni, a legal advisor to the ruling National League for Democracy party, said that the current government should remove all names of those who were put on the blacklist by the former military junta due to their political stances or dissident beliefs. He also feels these changes should be publicly announced once they are finalized.

Former President Thein Sein's administration removed more than 2,000 names from a blacklist of more than 6,000 in 2012—one year into his quasi-civilian rule. The names included many exiled pro-democracy activists, foreign journalists and political critics.

The post Govt 'Blacklist' Practices Highlight Lack of Transparency, Activists Say appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Govt to Take Action Against Those Behind ‘Illegal’ Hpakant Mosque

Posted: 04 Aug 2016 07:39 AM PDT

A Buddhist nationalist mob gathers near the site of the mosque in Lone Khin Village Tract, Hpakant Township, Kachin State. (Photo: Zaw Min Htun / Facebook)

A Buddhist nationalist mob gathers near the site of the mosque in Lone Khin Village Tract, Hpakant Township, Kachin State. (Photo: Zaw Min Htun / Facebook)

RANGOON — The Ministry of Culture and Religious Affairs has announced that the mosque burned down by a mob in rural Hpakant Township in Kachin State had been built "illegally" on state-owned land, and action would be taken against those who constructed it.

The mosque, in Lebyin Village of Lone Khin Village Tract, was burned down by a Buddhist nationalist mob on July 1, after which five locals were arrested. The Irrawaddy phoned the Lon Khin Village Tract administrator and local police officials but they could not be reached.

The ministry's statement on Thursday via state-owned media outlined the background of the Muslim place of worship, according to government investigations:

Ye Maung, a local Muslim, was permitted to construct a "temporary" home in 1985 on vacant land in the village held by Khin Maung, the chairman of the local People's Council. After the latter's death, the land defaulted back to the state.

In September 2014, Sonny Thein, another local Muslim, was being employed as a supervisor on the construction of the Uru Creek Bridge in the village. Sonny Thein erected a wall around a yard adjacent to the construction site to prevent it being used as a footpath. The walled-in area contained the small structure built earlier by Ye Maung, which Sonny Thein then expanded and adapted into a mosque.

When the bridge was opened on March 28 this year, local Buddhist residents and monks discovered that local Muslims were using the structure and its extensions as a place of worship. The structure was not legally authorized for religious purposes, according to the statement.

The Buddhist residents urged local authorities to take action. Hpakant Township authorities met with two trustees of the mosque on June 26-28 and said they would be charged according to the Vacant, Fallow and Virgin Lands Management Law (2012), if they did not demolish all the "illegal" buildings.

The ministry's statement said the Mosque trustees then oversaw the demolition of three extensions to the structure, but refused to have one part demolished because it had been funded by private donations. This prompted the authorities to charge the trustees—although legal proceedings could not get underway before the mob burned the structure down.

Tin Soe, the National League for Democracy representative for Hpakant Township in the Lower House of Parliament, told The Irrawaddy that he had attempted to mediate between the mosque trustees and the township authorities.

He and local authorities had had around seven meetings with the mosque trustees, who ultimately promised to demolish all the buildings—in contradiction to the ministry's statement—before the "extreme nationalist" mob came.

"A very upsetting incident happened because of some extremists. Our efforts were ruined within a moment," he said.

Tin Soe claimed that Ma Ba Tha members were among the mob, and that the Ma Ba Tha township chapter was "behind" the incident.

He told The Irrawaddy that four men and one woman—of Burman, Shan and Arakanese ethnicity—were being tried in court for the Lone Khin mosque burning, and were now acquiring a defense lawyer.

The lawmaker also recalled an earlier incident, which had received little publicity, in Tanai Township of Kachin State, where a mosque had also been destroyed by a local mob.

The Irrawaddy phoned the director of the Ministry of Culture of Religious Affairs, Aung San Win, on Thursday. He confirmed that the government would be taking action against both the people behind the construction of the "illegal" mosque in Lone Khin and the people involved in burning it down.

The director said the relevant government department in Kachin State is still investigating the case.

The ministry's statement on Thursday explained that the government had also been taking action against the illegal construction of Buddhist religious structures.

It stated that, in early 2014, the government had demolished 24 "illegal" Buddhist monasteries in the Naypyidaw area. Additionally, legal proceedings against 173 monasteries in Rangoon Division and 86 in other states and divisions had been launched at the recommendation of the State Sangha Maha Nayaka Committee, the government-appointed council that oversees monastic discipline in Burma.

Ministry director Aung San Win confirmed these actions, stating that many of these "monasteries" had been not been authorized for religious observance. He declined to say how many monks had been imprisoned, although some individuals behind these monasteries had been given prison terms.

"When we found them guilty, we disrobed and jailed some of them," he said. "Some are on the run."

Although the ministry statement cited a total of 283 monasteries that had been previously been charged as "illegal," it did not mention any figures for places of worship related to other religions, such as Christianity or Islam.

Aung San Win said a list of "illegal" religious buildings had been compiled across the country, although he would not disclose the number.

The post Govt to Take Action Against Those Behind 'Illegal' Hpakant Mosque appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

For Sumlut Roi Ja’s Husband, Trauma Continues Five Years After Her Disappearance

Posted: 04 Aug 2016 07:16 AM PDT

 Dau Lum, husband of Roi Ja, pictured on July 28, 2016. (Photo: Hein Htet / The Irrawaddy)

Dau Lum, husband of Roi Ja, pictured on July 28, 2016. (Photo: Hein Htet / The Irrawaddy)

Since his wife disappeared in Oct. 2011, Dau Lum has struggled with chronic illness and depression. Sumlut Roi Ja, a then-28-year-old mother of one, was abducted while harvesting corn, allegedly by Burma Army soldiers from the Light Infantry Battalion (LIB) 321 in eastern Kachin State. It is believed that she was raped and murdered, but her body was never found.

At the time of the interview with The Irrawaddy in late July, Dau Lum is still visibly distressed.

"I often get sick, and since she was taken, my mind has become traumatized and sad," Dau Lum said. He and his lawyer took the case against the commander of LIB 321 all the way to Burma's Supreme Court, but it was dismissed in 2012 due to a lack of evidence. Although he traveled to Naypyidaw, Dau Lum was not allowed a chance to testify.

Since then, civil society organizations have attempted to put pressure on public officials to re-examine the case, particularly the Kachin Women's Association Thailand (KWAT), which sent an open letter to ex-president Thein Sein asking him to re-open the Roi Ja's case. He did not.

Dau Lum and his parents have since abandoned their village of Hkaibang and relocated to a camp for internally displaced people, about a three-hour drive from Mai Ja Yang on the Chinese border.

The Irrawaddy visited Dau Lum and Roi Ja's house, built just after their marriage in 2007, but now abandoned. Uninhabited, it is now broken and empty of belongings.

Dau Lum and Roi Ja's daughter entered first grade this year. The girl, Dau Lum said, often asks him where her mother is.

"I say to her, 'your mother went to look for money,'" he said, using a local expression for leaving home in search of employment. "Then, she replies, 'why does it take her so long to find money?'"

Dau Lum still remembers the last day he saw his wife. They were with his father, harvesting corn just outside their village. He said Burma Army soldiers appeared and detained them—Dau Lum and his father managed to escape, but as soldiers shot after them, Roi Ja could not keep up.

"They tightened the rope around our hands, but the three of us ran away. Then, they shot at us, and my wife was afraid, and she could not run anymore," he said.

Some locals reported seeing her in the Burma Army barracks on the mountain ridge outside the village. Troops from the Kachin Independence Army—a local ethnic armed group—who monitored the base said, on at least one occasion, they saw a woman they identified as Roi Ja.

The Irrawaddy asked Dau Lum whether he believed Roi Ja was still alive.

"She is not alive," he said quietly. "She has been killed already."

The post For Sumlut Roi Ja's Husband, Trauma Continues Five Years After Her Disappearance appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Govt Seeks Work Permits for Undocumented Domestic Workers Abroad

Posted: 04 Aug 2016 05:55 AM PDT

A seminar to mark International Domestic Workers' Day in Thailand on June 16, 2016. (Photo: Nyein Nyein / The Irrawaddy)

A seminar to mark International Domestic Workers' Day in Thailand on June 16, 2016. (Photo: Nyein Nyein / The Irrawaddy)

NAYPYIDAW—Burma's government will seek the cooperation of concerned labor ministries to issue official work permits for undocumented Burmese domestic workers in foreign countries, said Thein Swe, minister of labor, immigration and population.

"We will cooperate with concerned embassies and labor ministries to make a list of illegal Burmese domestic workers in foreign countries so we can provide legal protection and guarantee their fundamental rights," said Thein Swe.

The decision follows labor rights defenders' request to State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi to take care of Burmese domestic workers in Thailand, during her visit to the country in July.

The government began compiling a list of undocumented domestic workers in cooperation with Burmese embassies and labor organizations after Suu Kyi returned from her trip to Thailand. The government estimates that the numbers could be as high as 28,000 in Thailand and 40,000 in Singapore.

Most of the domestic workers in Thailand are women who do not have any legal protection since they are working without official permission.

"They don't get fair wages and it is difficult to protect them in the case of violence," said Thein Swe.

The government estimates that there could be at least 28,000 Burmese migrants in Thailand working odd jobs—as garden cleaners, office gophers, vendors, drivers and so on, said Thein Swe.

The Singaporean government already recognizes Burmese domestic workers as legal workers even though they do not hold proper documentation to work there.

"Although the Burmese government doesn't officially send domestic workers to Singapore, they go there on tourist visas and then stay on. We've learned that the number is somewhere between 30,000 and 40,000," said the minister.

"Even though the Singaporean government recognizes Burmese domestic helpers, the Burmese Embassy in Singapore receives complaints almost daily regarding abuses inflicted by home owners or requests for help changing jobs," Thein Swe added.

Burma sent 174 people to Hong Kong and 130 people to Singapore in 2014 to work as domestic workers under a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with the respective governments.

Employees, labor rights advocates, and the MAP Foundation—a Thai non-governmental organization working with Burmese migrant workers in Thailand—met in June in northern Thailand to mark International Domestic Workers' Day. Participants at the commemorative seminar agreed that relations between Burma and Thailand have improved, but with little positive impact on Burmese domestic workers in Thailand.

The post Govt Seeks Work Permits for Undocumented Domestic Workers Abroad appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Lawmakers Blame Burma’s Drug Problem on Warlord-Govt Nexus

Posted: 04 Aug 2016 05:36 AM PDT

Burma's Upper House of Parliament in session. (Photo: The Irrawaddy)

Burma's Upper House of Parliament in session. (Photo: The Irrawaddy)

Upper House lawmakers have blamed Burma's endemic drug problem on a nexus of corrupt government officials and warlords commanding ethnic militias, and demanded that the government take a tough line against both.

In a session of the Upper House of Parliament on Tuesday, lawmakers said the connivance of such highly placed actors, in an environment of general impunity, made it particularly difficult to tackle the drug scourge, which was particularly harming Burma's youth.

Khun Than Pe, representing Shan State Constituency-9, said that "drug lords" could begin to produce drugs on a grander commercial scale by posing as ethnic armed resistance leaders at a time when the military junta was forging a series of bilateral ceasefires in the 1990s.

"It was in the 1990s that [the drug problem] spread across both urban and rural areas. It is fair to say that [the problem] was born with 'peace,'" said Khun Thein Pe.

He said that "uniformed people," besides drug kingpins and militiamen, are selling drugs in the Pa-O Self Administered Zone of southern Shan State. He also said that, "In eastern Shan State, [drugs] as served like snacks in public gaming centers. You can see people openly abusing drugs in groups, as if they don't care."

Though the government has formed dedicated drug squads in the police force at the division and state level, they are too understaffed and under-equipped to arrest drug lords even if they want to, said Myo Win, a lawmaker from Mon State Constituency-8.

On the other hand, he said, the complicity of government authorities in the drug trade has frustrated efforts to arrest drug kingpins and major dealers because government officers leak information to them.

He cited a raid on July 15 on 13 known drug-dealing hotspots in the city of Mandalay involving 350 policemen, which resulted in the arrest of only drug users and small-time street dealers.

In the parliamentary session, military representative Lt-Col Tin Lin Oo countered that large-scale drug seizures were now frequent. However, he did not comment on the causes of the drug problem in Burma or on whether the Burma Army had a special plan to combat the activities of drug lords in cooperation with police drug squads.

Lawmakers suggested that higher-level government authorities should take the responsibility of taking on drug lords and rooting out government officials working in cahoots with them.

They also urged the government to conduct public awareness campaigns on a wide scale and provide poppy growers with alternative livelihoods.

Various lawmakers commented on increases in drug abuse within their constituencies, particularly among the young, many of whom become prone to committing crimes when short of money to buy drugs.

"Drugs are available even at betel nut shops in the streets in Arakan State, although poppy is not grown there," said Myint Naing, a lawmaker representing Arakan State Constituency-5.

Poppy, the primary ingredient for opium and heroin, is grown in Shan, Kachin, Karenni and Chin states of Burma. According to the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, Burma is second largest producer of opium in the world, after Afghanistan. Large quantities of methamphetamine drugs are also produced and trafficked in Burma.

The post Lawmakers Blame Burma's Drug Problem on Warlord-Govt Nexus appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Commission Approves 13 Foreign Investment Proposals During New Govt Term

Posted: 04 Aug 2016 05:32 AM PDT

A worker is seen at a construction site for Shangri-La Residences in Rangoon on September 20, 2013. (Photo: Soe Zeya Tun / Reuters)

A worker is seen at a construction site for Shangri-La Residences in Rangoon on September 20, 2013. (Photo: Soe Zeya Tun / Reuters)

RANGOON — The newly re-formed Myanmar Investment Commission (MIC) approved 13 foreign investment proposals and nine local investments over the last two months, a figure significantly lower than the same period in 2015, Aung Naing Oo, secretary of the MIC, told The Irrawaddy.

Since the MIC was re-staffed in early June under the chairmanship of Kyaw Win, Union Minister of National Planning and Finance, the commission has been met with more than 100 proposals left over from the previous government's term; most are still waiting to be approved.

"The new MIC has approved 13 foreign investment proposals. We're checking more proposals, as most of them are for the construction of office towers," said Aung Naing Oo.

"It's only the beginning stage of the new government. That's why we are taking more time to approve the proposals," he said.

The foreign investment proposals approved by the MIC over the last two months have an estimated net worth of more than US$124 million. These include proposals for seven projects in the manufacturing sector, three in transport and telecommunications, and three proposals whose sectors were not known at the time of publication.

Approved local proposals, which total nine projects, include one in transportation, construction, manufacturing, agriculture, respectively. Two projects have been approved in the hotel and tourism industry, and three are not yet known. The total investment is valued at nearly US$35 million.

"Some local proposals include investment in hotel projects in Mandalay and Kengtong [Kengtung]," Aung Naing Oo said.

The amounts of these investments—both local and foreign—are estimates provided at the time of proposal.

Yet these foreign investment projects are expected to create 9,651 job opportunities in Burma; the local investment proposals aim to establish more than 1,750 jobs.

The MIC, which is responsible for assessing and approving large-scale investments and is headed by Union-level government officials, initially consisted of at least nine members who dealt largely with processing foreign investment. Each set of MIC members serve a term of three years.

In the first quarter of the 2015-16 fiscal year, 71 projects were approved at a valuation of $2.65 billion. The first quarter of the 2014-2015 fiscal year saw 39 projects approved which were valued collectively at $810 million.

However, when compared to last year, the first quarter of the 2016-2017 fiscal year has seen lower numbers of approval, which some attribute to the country undergoing a transition period with the new government.

Dr. Maung Maung Lay, vice chairman of the Union of Myanmar Federation of Chambers of Commerce and Industry (UMFCCI), told The Irrawaddy that though the National League for Democracy-led government has announced its 12 economic policies, they appear to be very general, which will impact foreign direct investment (FDI) entries.

"General economic policies will not work well. More rules and regulations need to be put into place—that's why decisions concerning FDI are also 'wait and see' this year," he said.

Maung Maung Lay added that other countries in the region are welcoming FDI with more attractive methods, which could delay Burma's own development, as investors often have to build infrastructure themselves in order to complete projects.

"It is important to welcome FDI here," he said.

The post Commission Approves 13 Foreign Investment Proposals During New Govt Term appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Commentary: Still Too Early For Burmese Refugee Return

Posted: 04 Aug 2016 03:48 AM PDT

Bamboo huts with leaf roofs, built by refugees, dot the hills of Mae La Oon camp southwest of Mae Sariang in northern Thailand. (Photo: The Border Consortium)

Bamboo huts with leaf roofs, built by refugees, dot the hills of Mae La Oon camp southwest of Mae Sariang in northern Thailand. (Photo: The Border Consortium)

Service centers for Burmese refugees who wish to return home will soon be opened in the camps along the Thai-Burma border—a sudden development that has alarmed refugees and camp leaders.

Set up with the involvement of agencies including the International Organization of Migration, the Voluntary Repatriation Centers will provide counseling, advice and provisions to enable voluntary returns. The UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) will conduct official processing in coordination with the Thai authorities.

However, refugee community leaders and local organizations have told The Irrawaddy that a majority of the 120,000 registered refugees in the nine camps along the border do not wish to return to Burma.

The conflict-wracked areas of rural Karen State in eastern Burma that many of the refugees fled from are still considered unsafe, due to continued militarization.

There is a perception among sections of the international community that, after 30 years on Thai soil—and after the installment of a democratically elected government and the signing of a Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement that included the Karen National Union (KNU)—it is time for many of the refugees to return home.

In the last few years there has been a decline in assistance from international donors to the border refugee communities, which has coincided with an increase in donor funds dispersed inside Burma, including through government channels.

The decline in assistance has also been attributed to unprecedented global pressures on refugee funds and resources caused by the current refugee crisis in the Middle East.

The UNHCR has given assurances that all returns would be voluntary and that refugees retain the right to decide. However, many refugees consider the choice as one of "do or die," being unsure of their chances of survival in Thailand under dwindling donor assistance. Some have interpreted cuts in this assistance as a form of pressure.

Since Thailand does not legally permit refugees to work, those in search of extra income—outside of running small-scale businesses within the camps—would have to join the ranks of "illegal" Burmese migrant workers in Thailand, whom labor rights organizations have estimated to number as high as 2 million (against 1.7 million Burmese migrants working legally). Those with family members or friends working in third countries may be able to live on remittances.

Saw Honest, chairman of Mae La camp, the largest Burmese border camp hosting around 40,000 refugees, said that, when the Mae Fah Luang Foundation—a Thai nongovernmental organization—conducted a survey in 2014, "only 2 or 3 percent" of the [refugee] population showed an interest in going home.

"Most of them wanted to resettle in third countries. The second largest proportion wanted to remain in Thailand," said Saw Honest.

"We know that we are coming under pressure, anyhow," said Saw Honest.

More official and up-to-date statistics on refugees' willingness to return home are not currently available, but refugee community leaders claim that the majority of refugees consider it "still too early" to return home.

Refugees have gone individually to check on their abandoned villages and farmlands, they said, but the continued presence of Burma Army units there have precluded the desire of most to return permanently.

"We know that the KNU has made a ceasefire with the Burmese government and they have developed a greater understanding of one another. But there are still threats to civilian safety because the Burma Army and [non-state] armed groups are deployed close to villages, and landmines have not yet been removed. Also, land ownership issues should be addressed," said Saw Honest, referencing a legacy of military land grabs.

A large proportion of the refugees who fled conflict have lost whatever land registration documents they might have had, after their villages were burned down or ransacked and they went on the run, moving from place to place before reaching Thailand.

After visiting some of the villages that these refugees had fled from in Karen and Mon states in April this year, this Irrawaddy reporter found that several of the "model villages" built for returnees were incomplete and seemingly abandoned.

Some that have made return visits to their villages in Thaton and Bilin townships of Mon State—from which 3,000 refugees fled armed conflict to the border camps in Thailand—found that their old farmland had been confiscated.

Across Papun and Hpa-an districts of Karen State, which saw large outflows of refugees due to conflict, militarization remains significant, with not only the Burma Army present across rural areas but also ethnic Karen armed groups including a Border Guard Force, the Democratic Karen Benevolent Army and brigades of the KNU.

These groups have also seized farmland and exploited land rich in gold and tin for business opportunities—including land once held by the current refugees.

Despite apparent progress in the peace process, with the "21st Century Panglong" Union Peace Conference scheduled for later this month, there have been scant moves by the Burma Army to withdraw their troops from rural civilian areas. Furthermore, the KNU's armed wing, the Karen National Liberation Army, is continuing to recruit and train new soldiers, and is remaining on the alert.

Naw Blooming Night Zar, a spokesperson for Karen Refugee Committee, told The Irrawaddy that she had raised with the UNHCR her concern that the sudden introduction of Voluntary Repatriation Centers might frighten refugees.

"We do not see so many refugees interested in returning. Some individuals have gone home only to observe the situation. There are no group returns. We have told [the UNHCR] that it is not yet time," said Blooming Night Zar.

The UNHCR, meanwhile, said that it would distribute pamphlets to inform refugees about the voluntarily return process, and would explain to community leaders about the current preparations.

Iain Hall, a UNHCR senior field coordinator, insisted that they were not "promoting or encouraging refugees' return," but were making the necessary preparations to "support any refugees that have made a voluntary decision to return, as is their right."

Such preparations, being undertaken in earnest, appear to reflect the new priorities of donors and governments. But instead of expediting their altered policies, the UNHCR should be exercising its mandate to speak of behalf of refugees and their concerns.

Without fully understanding or addressing the challenges on the ground—such as continued militarization in the areas of Burma where these refugees may return to—any decisions made by the Thai and Burmese government, donors, international agencies and non-state armed groups to accelerate repatriation would be premature.

If the wrong choices were made, it is not they, but the refugees, who would suffer the consequences.

The post Commentary: Still Too Early For Burmese Refugee Return appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Advocacy Group Calls for Release of Arrested Arakan Activist

Posted: 04 Aug 2016 02:39 AM PDT

Khine Myo Htun faces charges for accusing the Burma Army of committing war crimes in the Arakan State. (Photo: ERI)

Khine Myo Htun faces charges for accusing the Burma Army of committing war crimes in the Arakan State. (Photo: ERI)

EarthRights International (ERI) called on Thursday for the immediate release of prominent environmental activist Khine Myo Htun, who will appear for a court hearing on Friday.

Khine Myo Htun, deputy-spokesperson for the Arakan Liberation Party (ALP) was arrested last week in Arakan State's capital Sittwe, after being accused of sedition and incitement under Burma's severe penal code. He faces charges for accusing the Burma Army of committing war crimes in the state.

In its statement on Thursday, United States based advocacy organization ERI said that Khine Myo Htun’s arrest was politically motivated.

Ka Hsaw Wa, co-founder and executive director of ERI said in the statement that the Burma Army had once again demonstrated its ruthlessness and unwillingness to change by going after activists who dared to expose its abuses, despite the introduction of a new democratic government.

"It is disgraceful that human rights activists continue to be persecuted for exercising their democratic rights in a country led by a former prisoner of conscience," he added.

The Arakan Liberation Army, the military wing of Khine Myo Htun's ALP party, was one of eight non-state ethnic armed groups that signed the nationwide ceasefire agreement (NCA) in October with the former government.

The outspoken activist was charged under sections 505(b) and 505(c) of Burma's Penal Code – for sedition and incitement respectively. The charges were filed by Lt Col Tin Naing Tun from the Sittwe-based Regional Operations Command of the Burma Army on May 5.

Khine Myo Htun is a former student at ERI's school for human rights and environmental activists in Chiang Mai, Thailand. He also worked with Arakan Oil Watch, an environmental and human rights group. He is the co-founder of Natural Resources for the People and a board member of the Arakan Natural Resources and Environmental Network.

In April, the ALP incited controversy when it accused the Burma Army of violating the Geneva Conventions by targeting civilians for forced portering and torture.

ERI, however, said that it had reviewed the audio and video evidence backing torture and forced portering allegations against the army and deemed that it was credible. The rights advocacy group said it would support Khine Myo Htun's legal case.

The post Advocacy Group Calls for Release of Arrested Arakan Activist appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

KBZ Bank Opens Office in Bangkok

Posted: 04 Aug 2016 12:33 AM PDT

Nang Lang Kham, the executive director of KBZ Bank, talks at the opening ceremony of the bank's representative office in Bangkok on Aug 3. (Photo: KBZ Bank)

Nang Lang Kham, the executive director of KBZ Bank, talks at the opening ceremony of the bank’s representative office in Bangkok on Aug 3. (Photo: KBZ Bank)

Kanbawza Bank (KBZ Bank) has opened a representative office in Bangkok, the first Burmese bank to establish an international presence.

Earlier this year, KBZ Bank officially received a licence from the Bank of Thailand to open the office in the capital. The bank also recently obtained a representative licence to open an office in Singapore, continuing its planned expansion within the Asean region.

Than Cho, senior managing director of KBZ Bank, said the office would start offering financial and advisory services as soon as possible to Burmese people and to businesses in Thailand.

The KBZ representative office at Sathorn Square Office Tower in Bangkok (Photo: KBZ Bank)

The KBZ representative office at Sathorn Square Office Tower in Bangkok (Photo: KBZ Bank)

"Naturally, Thai businesses are interested in entering Burma. We hope they take advantage of our extensive knowledge of Burma's financial markets and join the growing bilateral trade between our two countries," he said.

Zeyar Sein Htut, KBZ Bank’s new chief in Thailand, said the bank will focus on activities such as market research, liaising with the private sector and serving as a source of information, including regulatory requirements for doing business both in Thailand and Burma.

KBZ Bank wants to explore opportunities to build relations with, and eventually cater to, the large Burmese population in the kingdom—estimated at 3 million people—when they return to their home country.

Thailand’s Deputy Prime Minister Prawit Wongsuwan met Burma’s President Htin Kyaw in Naypyidaw last month. The two countries announced they intended to double bilateral trade to US$20 billion in 2017.

The post KBZ Bank Opens Office in Bangkok appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

A Legacy of Military Land Grabs in the Delta: a Test for the New Govt

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 10:47 PM PDT

Than Shin poses with copies of her land documents in Irrawaddy Division's Maubin Township in April 5, 2016. (Photo: Reuters)

Than Shin poses with copies of her land documents in Irrawaddy Division's Maubin Township in April 5, 2016. (Photo: Reuters)

By the standards of her village in Burma's swampy Irrawaddy Delta, Than Shin was a prosperous woman. She had 20 acres of farmland on which her family grew rice.

But her fortunes changed in 2000 when the military government informed her it was taking possession of her land. Over the next year, Than Shin watched as the fields that for decades had provided her family with a living were cleared to make way for fish farms.

Today, Than Shin and her family live in a thatched shack along the main road leading to Burma's commercial capital Yangon. Her 67-year-old husband goes door to door on his bicycle selling soybeans. "We depended on that land our whole lives. When they grabbed it, we had nothing, no income. We had to eat curry made from leaves," she told Reuters.

Than Shin’s story is just one example of what the ruling party of Aung San Suu Kyi says was the systematic confiscation of land from farmers by the army and the placing of that land in the hands of crony companies close to the military junta that ruled Burma for half a century. The fish farms that were built on her land were owned by a company linked to then regional military commander Shwe Mann, who is now one of Burma's most powerful political figures, according to a Reuters review of corporate filings.

When Suu Kyi's National League for Democracy (NLD) stormed to power in elections last November, its victory was fueled in part by rural anger over land seizures and the party's pledge to provide redress. Just days after the NLD formed the first government since 1962 that is not backed by the military, the new deputy agriculture minister told local media that returning land to its rightful owners was the duty of the government.

Now the NLD is moving to make good on that promise. The parliament member overseeing the effort, Sein Win, told Reuters the party aims to solve all land-grab cases within one year.

That's an ambitious timeframe. In untangling land disputes, the new government will have to contend with powerful business interests, many linked to the military. That could put Suu Kyi on a collision course with the generals and threaten Burma's fragile transition to democracy.

‘VIRGIN’ LAND

The NLD's Sein Win estimates that the number of land-grab cases is in the hundreds of thousands. Based on surveys conducted by the party's branches around the country, he says that between three to five million acres of land was forcibly taken by the military.

Shwe Mann, the former army commander, held the powerful post of speaker in the previous military-dominated parliament. Today, he is a close confidante of Suu Kyi.

In a rare interview, he defended the junta's actions, saying that vast swathes of land were allocated to him in his capacity as the regional commander and to local authorities by the government as part of a national project by Burma's military rulers in the 1990s to bolster food security and agricultural production. All the land in the area he oversaw, he said, was "vacant, fallow or virgin" and so the junta's actions were not illegal.

Still, Shwe Mann said there could be a discrepancy between "what's on the map in the land record office and the situation on the ground.” In the past, he said, farmers did not want to register land as agricultural to avoid participation in a socialist economy.

The military did not respond to questions from Reuters.

The previous military-dominated parliament set up two bodies to investigate and mediate land-grab cases, but was criticized for dragging its feet. In total, the government reviewed 17,000 cases, but only resolved around 1,000, according to local media reports.

With Suu Kyi's party now taking the lead, the new government has formed a taskforce to deal with land-grab cases. In June alone, 6,434 acres of land that was seized in the Irrawaddy Delta was returned to 324 villagers, according to the state-owned Myanma Alinn Daily and local media.

The vast majority of land was taken in the 1990s and early 2000s, amid a military-led transition from socialism to a market-driven economy. The state owned all land, but farmers were granted rights to cultivate it.

"The land grabs were done by the (junta) government, with most of it going to the military, companies, government departments and ministries," the NLD's Sein Win said.

MILITARY CONNECTIONS

Hta Ni village, a collection of hamlets about two hours from Yangon, encapsulates the challenge facing Suu Kyi.

In the late 1990s and early 2000s, local authorities under then-Southwestern Regional Military Commander Shwe Mann seized roughly 1,000 acres from about 200 homes, according to local paralegals who base their estimate on statements and documents from villagers.

It was during this period that 474 acres of land in Hta Ni was handed to Asia Might Co. Ltd., the company with ties to Shwe Mann, for an aquaculture project. The former commander confirmed that Asia Might was linked to him and that it took part in the project at his request.

He also confirmed that the company was run at the time by Min Naing, whom he described as a "close friend." A brother of Shwe Mann served as a company director and was a minority shareholder, according to corporate filings.

"When it comes to my role, I take full responsibility," said Shwe Mann. "I acted according to the existing law." Min Naing did not respond to questions from Reuters that were sent via a son of Shwe Mann.

"There are a lot of villages, particularly across the delta, which have lost almost all of their agricultural land to land grabs," said Tim Millar, the Burma program director of Namati, a legal aid group involved in helping farmers in Burma retrieve their land.

With the start of Burma’s transition away from military rule in 2011, villagers began actively demanding the return of land. After its November election victory, the NLD instructed its branches across the country to gather information on land dispute cases. Now that the review has begun, the NLD's Sein Win is hoping his party's massive parliamentary majority will forestall any resistance from the military.

It won't be easy. The country's constitution still reserves key ministerial posts for the military, including defense, border affairs and internal affairs. And Suu Kyi’s relationship with the army is strained: The constitution drafted by the military in 2008, for instance, bars her from the presidency.

"Whether or not these cases will be solved depends on whether the NLD has a good relationship with the military commander-in-chief,” said Myint Naing, the director of Human Rights Watch Defence, a local NGO in the Irrawaddy Delta that is helping the villagers in Hta Ni.

If they're not resolved, "we’ll be forced to take to the streets," he said.

‘LIKE SELLING STOLEN GOODS’

Frustration has already boiled over. A police officer was killed and 40 people injured in a 2013 land protest in the village of Ma Let Toe, not far from where Than Shin lost her land 16 years ago. Villagers are still occupying a tract of land they say was stolen by the army and forms part of a fish and rice farm owned by Orchard Co. Ltd.

Orchard’s owner, Myint Sein, says his entire concession was either "virgin land" given to him for free by the military or land that he legally purchased from farmers. He showed Reuters a 2003 aerial map of some of the concession area, which shows a section of the land as empty swamp. But the map did not include the area currently occupied by protesting farmers.

Adding to the challenge of addressing land disputes is the sheer complexity of the cases and often the absence of a clear paper trail. In many areas of the country, documents such as land tax receipts, government loan books, land use permits and witness statements from village elders have been destroyed by the damp climate. Cyclone Nargis, which killed as many as 140,000 people in the Irrawaddy Delta in 2008, also destroyed many of the documents kept by locals in their homes.

Land-grab victims often don't know who now owns the land they once farmed. In many cases, the land has been divided and sold on several times, further complicating efforts to settle disputes.

None of the Hta Ni villagers or NGO workers interviewed by Reuters were aware that Asia Might was linked to Shwe Mann. What's more, Asia Might no longer owns the land. In the mid-2000s, the company transferred ownership, according to the chief land office official in the area.

Even if companies that were originally given the land have sold it on, the transfer should be viewed "like selling stolen goods,” Namati’s Millar said. "It’s not theirs to sell in the first place."

The post A Legacy of Military Land Grabs in the Delta: a Test for the New Govt appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

National News

National News


Thousands remain on the ‘no entry’ blacklist

Posted: 04 Aug 2016 12:04 AM PDT

Over 4300 people, mostly foreigners, were enumerated on the blacklist maintained by the previous government, the Minister for Labour, Immigration and Population revealed yesterday.

No relaxation of citizenship law for Kokang: minister

Posted: 04 Aug 2016 12:02 AM PDT

Could the issue of citizenship documents to Kokang residents in Shan State open the back door to infiltration from China? That appeared to be the implication floated by Myanmar's immigration minister yesterday when he spoke to MPs of the progress of regularising citizenship in the self-administered zone.

MPs voice need to prioritise drop in crime

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 11:59 PM PDT

Noting that crime has not declined in recent years, members of the Pyithu Hluttaw urged the Union government to take more proactive measures to cut the crime rate yesterday.

Better allocation of natural resources can promote national reconciliation: analyst

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 11:41 PM PDT

The government's economic policy, released last week, could dovetail with its peace policy to help ensure resources are shared for the country as a whole, an economic analyst has said. A statement released on July 29 said greater fairness in the allocation of resources among regions and states could help the country pursue national reconciliation.

Rakhine minister presses armed group to withdraw contested claims of war crimes

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 11:22 PM PDT

The Rakhine State Ministry for Border Affairs and Security is continuing to pressure an ethnic armed group to retract a statement it made alleging forced portering by the Tatmadaw. The ministry, which is headed by a military appointee, refuses to release a detained communications officer of the group until its demand is met, according to members of the armed organisation.

Shan State coal mine cited in fight against resource extraction

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 11:19 PM PDT

Shan activists and politicians are calling for a halt to resource extraction in parts of Myanmar plagued by conflict, with one human rights group using a controversial coal mine to highlight the damage these projects are inflicting on local communities.

Record rainfall wrecks roads, bridges in Magwe

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 11:16 PM PDT

Record rainfalls knocked out roads and bridges in Magwe Region's Ngape and Sidoktaya townships near the end of the Ayeyarwady River.

State counsellor named a target on ‘IS threat’ list in Malaysia

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 11:10 PM PDT

Myanmar's government will monitor an investigation by its Malaysian counterpart into a hit list purportedly penned by a member or sympathiser of the Islamic State terrorist group that includes the name of State Counsellor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and several Malaysian leaders.

Amyotha Hluttaw urges drought and flood analyses

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 11:09 PM PDT

The Upper House has asked the Union government to establish a systematic, nationwide review of floods and droughts annually in order to compile effective measures to prevent damage.

Labour union threatens boycott of Arbitration Council

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 11:07 PM PDT

One of Myanmar's largest officially recognised labour unions has vowed to boycott the Arbitration Council and to stage strikes if they encounter problems with employers. The announcement is yet another protest of the newly appointed representatives to the dispute resolution body.

Wednesday, August 3, 2016

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Women Continue to Suffer Due to Land Grabs and Militarization

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 06:30 AM PDT

The Karen Human Rights Group present their new report, "Hidden Strengths, Hidden Struggles," in Rangoon on Wednesday. (Photo: Nyein Nyein / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — Land confiscation and rights abuses linked to the continued militarization of ethnic minority regions in southeastern of Burma has had particularly adverse impacts on women, ethnic Karen human rights advocates said at a press conference in Rangoon.

While the launching of the peace process in 2011 and a series of bilateral ceasefires with ethnic armed groups has lessened certain abuses, including forced labor and extrajudicial killings, new business opportunities have led to an increase in land seizures, they said.

The Karen Human Rights Group (KHRG) has documented the experiences of women in rural areas of Karen and Mon states and Tenasserim and eastern Pegu divisions, and has compiled four years' worth of findings on the effects of landmines, land confiscation, forced labor, torture and violence against women in a report released on Wednesday.

The report, "Hidden Strengths, Hidden Struggles: Women's Testimonies from Southeast Myanmar," was based on the analysis of 1,048 documents, including 98 interviews with separate women, said KHRG advocacy officer Jasmin, who pointed out a change in the type of abuses suffered by local women since 2012.

2012 was the year the previous government reached a bilateral ceasefire with the Karen Nation Union, the largest ethnic Karen armed group whose operations span the area of study, and which also signed the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement in October last year.

Jasmin said, "In our report ten years ago ["Dignity in The Shadow of Oppression," published in Nov 2006], cases of rape and forced porterage [for the Burma Army] were extensively documented. In our report this year, accounts of such abuses have lessened, with a change in the form of rights abuses."

"Because of the peace process, we now have more business operations, and land confiscation has become the main problem," Jasmin added. "They are losing their livelihoods and still being displaced due to that."

Despite the signing of both bilateral and "nationwide" ceasefire agreements, the presence of Burma Army troops across rural areas continues to threaten the safety of local people, especially women, said the rights advocates.

They added that a lessening in hostilities has had the side effect of diminishing the authority of women at the village level. Over 60 years of civil conflict, with the enrollment of men in rebel armies, women have had to step forward and become village leaders. With the return of men over the last few years to their traditional positions of authority in the community, women have lost these roles.

Jasmin said the report aimed to heighten the public's awareness "of the experiences of women and their changing roles in the southern part of the country."

However, the KHRG advocates noted that locals in the area of study still fear to talk openly about instances of abuse, making it hard to verify and adequately document them.

The KHRG also urged the government, legislators and the Karen National Union to "improve justice mechanisms" and create secure avenues for women facing gender-based violence and abuses linked to land confiscation to file cases with local authorities, and "bring perpetrators before independent and impartial civilian courts."

The KHRG framed these demands with reference to Burma's obligations under the United Nations' Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women, which Burma signed in 1997.

Win Mra, chairman of Burma's National Human Rights Commission, attended the press conference and commended the KHRG's report, which he said "fairly documents human rights violations, the situation since the ceasefires and the [2015] election, and abuses against women."

He stressed the importance of implementing the recommendations contained in the report, rather than merely continuing to document cases and hold seminars and workshops.

"Our [national human rights commission] is doing the same activities as the KHRG and as the Gender Equality Network. We will not stop with workshops. We will continue working to achieve results," Win Mra said, with reference to the commission's partnership with UN Women on empowering rural women.

The post Women Continue to Suffer Due to Land Grabs and Militarization appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Burmese Bank Signs Trade Financing Agreement With ADB

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 05:49 AM PDT

Chief Executive Officer of United Amara Bank, Thein Lwin, signs off on a trade finance agreement on Wednesday, August 3, at Rangoon's Sedona Hotel with the Asian Development Bank, represented by Burma country director Winfried Wicklein. (Photo: United Amara Bank / Facebook)

Chief Executive Officer of United Amara Bank, Thein Lwin, signs off on a trade finance agreement on Wednesday, August 3, at Rangoon's Sedona Hotel with the Asian Development Bank, represented by Burma country director Winfried Wicklein. (Photo: United Amara Bank / Facebook)

RANGOON – The United Amara Bank (UAB) signed off on a trade finance agreement with the Asian Development Bank (ADB) on Wednesday at Rangoon's Sedona Hotel that allows UAB a letter of credit (LC) insuring them for US$4 million for each international transaction the bank makes.

The LC is a bank guarantee service for those involved in import-export business ventures. When a cash payment must be made, a third party (the ADB) makes a guarantee on behalf of the service provider (the UAB). An LC process can adopt varying time frames, with some banks specifying that one transaction is allowed every two to three months, according to Kyawt Kay Khaing, UAB's Chief Business Officer.

"ADB will allow [UAB to make transactions of] US$4 million each time. If the specified rate is up, the traders need to wait until next time," she said.

The project aims to boost Burma's trade volume. Currently, the LC approach is not practically popular among small and medium businesses in Burma, who continue to perform transactions using the more traditional Telegraphic Transfer (TT) method. This involves customers transferring the money after receiving goods from a foreign company. In addition to being risky, Burmese businesspeople widely criticize the TT system as delaying trade flow.

ADB's country director for Burma, Winfried Wicklein, stressed that he believes the impact of the trade finance program will bring benefits not only for domestic businesses in Burma as they connect with international commercial communities, but also new opportunities for local banks to extend their business with international banks.

UAB owner Nay Aung is the son of Aung Thaung, who is now deceased but was once a notorious hardliner in Burma's former military regime. Many famous conglomerates and figures with ties to military generals have been faced with US economic sanctions, including former general Aung Thaung. Yet Nay Aung's UAB has never been featured on US sanction lists.

A board member of UAB, Than Win Swe, confirmed that UAB is not on the US sanction list.

"If UAB was on the sanction list, how could ADB collaborate with UAB?" he said.

The UAB's Chief Executive Officer, Thein Lwin, stated that their customers could now potentially connect with 200 ADB partner banks in the US, Europe and other Asian countries; ADB, he said, will issue a Foreign Letter of Credit on behalf of UAB if the foreign banks require an additional guarantee or confirmation.

Both UAB and ADB's senior officials pointed out that under this deal, Burmese businesspeople will be backed by a AAA rating, ADB's highest credibility score.

The UAB will officially launch applications on August 15 for those clients who want to access the bank's credit scheme. Interested applicants need to provide trading licenses issued by the Ministry of Commerce. Customers are not required to pay any service charges for utilizing the LC, however, they must guarantee fees required by the bank for financial transactions, according to Kyawt Kay Khaing.

Kyawt Kay Khaing declined to provide specific information about guaranteed fee rates because they are designated by ADB, and the fees depend on both the foreign country and the banks involved. For example, the rates for transactions in Asia and in Europe are different.

The agreement is a part of ADB's Trade Finance Program (TFP), which offers both guarantees and loans to banks to facilitate international trade. At Wednesday's signing ceremony, Rangoon divisional chief minister Phyo Min Thein and the Central Bank's deputy governor Set Aung presented honors to both the ADB and the UAB.

The post Burmese Bank Signs Trade Financing Agreement With ADB appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Burma’s Peace Process and the Swiss Bank Account

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 04:34 AM PDT

 Burma's former chief peace negotiator Aung Min at a meeting with ethnic leaders in Chiang Mai, Thailand, in February. (Photo: Nyein Nyein / The Irrawaddy)

Burma's former chief peace negotiator Aung Min at a meeting with ethnic leaders in Chiang Mai, Thailand, in February. (Photo: Nyein Nyein / The Irrawaddy)

Burma's peace negotiators must be able to open a Swiss bank account if they want to achieve their goals in the peace process.

Such first-rate advice was the legacy of Aung Min, the former government's chief negotiator at the Myanmar Peace Center, which has been rebranded as the National Reconciliation and Peace Center (NRPC) under the leadership of State Counselor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi.

You may ask: How is Burma's peace process related to Swiss banking?

In a recent publication, "Peace Process and the Analyses of Those Involved," Aung Min wrote a 12-page reflection on how he had led peace talks with the ethnic armed organizations through shuttle diplomacy, a tactic used throughout his leadership. In the article, he explained the term shuttle democracy by telling the "Swiss Bank Account" story.

The story goes: Once upon a time, there was a rich man who had a very beautiful daughter. There was also a broker who wanted to arrange a marriage between the daughter and a poor boy in town. He asked the rich man to allow his daughter to marry the poor boy, but the rich man refused because of the boy's poverty. The broker said the boy had a Swiss bank account. Thinking that a person with a Swiss account must be wealthy, the rich man agreed to the nuptial.

Then, the broker went to the daughter and urged her to marry the boy, but she refused. The broker explained that her father had approved the match. She was then afraid of losing the rights to her father's wealth and agreed to marry the boy. The broker again went to the boy and urged him to marry the daughter of the rich man. The boy said she would not marry him because he was poor. When the broker said that she already agreed to marry him, the boy agreed as well.

Finally, the broker went to a Swiss bank and asked them to open an account for the boy. The bank refused. The broker told the bank that the boy was going to be the son-in-law of a billionaire. Knowing that, the Swiss bank agreed to open an account for the boy.

U Aung Min wanted readers to understand that he had played the role of the broker in the story and was able to open a Swiss bank account to achieve his goal. Transposed to the peace process, he was able to achieve the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement (NCA) between the government and several ethnic armed organizations by using his brand of shuttle diplomacy.

The story could also be understood through the well known Machiavellian principal, "the ends justify the means," implying that any means necessary are acceptable in achieving one's goals.

But, if Aung Min actually led the peace talks with the ethnic armed organizations over the past four years with the Swiss bank account story as a template, it was nothing but deception, no matter how noble the results were.

What is worse is that he wrongly interpreted shuttle diplomacy. The term was first coined when Henry Kissinger shuttled between countries while acting as the US government's negotiator in a peace process between Israel, Egypt and Syria following the Yom Kippur War in 1973.

The term shuttle diplomacy is used when a peace negotiator has to deal with multiple parties; shuttle between the parties numerous times to seek a consensus; understand that all goals will not be met initially and that flexibility must be encouraged; and be able to shift from negotiator to counselor in order to persuade concerned parties in instances of deadlock.

Most importantly, from what we know about Kissinger's Israel-Arab negotiations, he did not employ the underhanded tactics described in Aung Min's Swiss bank account story to persuade concerned parties into agreement.

It is telling that eight ethnic armed organizations did not sign the NCA even though they participated fully in negotiations and had agreed in principle to the pact. It could be that there were additional reasons behind their abstention, other than the exclusion of the Arakan Army, the Ta'ang National Liberation Army and the Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army.

With the publication arriving at a critical period, while the government is preparing for the 21st Century Panglong Conference, it was assumed that it would contain profound ideas and invaluable tips for the new NRPC leadership, in their efforts to resume peace talks.

However, Aung Min's advice differs sharply from the political philosophy of Aung San Suu Kyi, who now chairs the NRPC. Since 1988, she has always believed that "the means justify the ends," indicating that if the means were morally acceptable, the end would preserve the political integrity she values so highly.

The post Burma's Peace Process and the Swiss Bank Account appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Social Welfare Minister: Deforestation and Exploitation of Resources Contributed to Flooding

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 03:53 AM PDT

 Burma's Social Welfare, Relief and Resettlement Minister Win Myat Aye talks to the media at the Parliament in March 2016. (Photo: Myo Min Soe / The Irrawaddy)

Burma's Social Welfare, Relief and Resettlement Minister Win Myat Aye talks to the media at the Parliament in March 2016. (Photo: Myo Min Soe / The Irrawaddy)

As Burma once again experiences serious flooding, the Ministry of Social Welfare, Relief and Resettlement has invited civil society organizations (CSOs) to join the ministry's relief and rescue efforts. The ministry is set to meet CSOs in Mandalay on August 6 and has invited organizations from Kachin, Chin and Shan states, as well as Sagaing, Magwe and Mandalay divisions. Floods have affected more than 50,000 people so far, most of them in Arakan State and Mandalay and Magwe divisions. Win Myat Aye, minister for Social Welfare, Relief and Resettlement, spoke to The Irrawaddy's Htet Naing Zaw about his ministry's plans to address the rising water levels.

What have you been doing to respond to the flooding?

I have been inspecting the situation on the ground. I just got back from Magwe, Minbu, and Pwintphyu [in Magwe Division]. We have seen floods in towns along the Irrawaddy River. The flooding was severe in Minbu, and some villages, along with [locals'] cattle, had to be relocated. We are providing relief supplies in these places. I met those affected and comforted them.

It seems that the floods may not subisde over the next two days, so we have talk with the Magwe regional chief minister and the border affairs and security ministers to move people to safer places.

It is not that all the townships are facing flooding—only townships along the Irrawaddy River. There has been no flooding in inland towns. We have not yet declared a state of emergency, because the effect of the floods is not nationwide. When the waters subside, it will go downstream into Lower Burma, so we are doing preventative work, such as evacuating people and cattle in advance.

Does your ministry have a sufficient budget for the relief and rescue work?

We do have a sufficient budget. We also have disaster preparedness funds, and we are also cooperating with civil society organizations, but their participation is still low. Maybe it is just because the floods have not caused a serious impact.

Which places were hit the hardest?

You can check the flood mapping which we have posted on our ministry's Facebook page and our website. We have an emergency response center and that center has published a flooding map in cooperation with international partners. It will be clearer if you have a look at the map. For the time being, Magwe and Minbu have been hit worst by floods.

What are the short-term and long-term plans of your ministry to address the flooding, since we also saw devastating floods last year?

Speaking of a long-term plan, we need to take a look back at the causes of this. Deforestation and exploitation of resources contributed to this. Waterways and tributaries have silted up, which caused floods. These things need to be solved in the long run. Our ministry is also making plans to solve it. We have dredged watercourses in Pegu and the floods there are not as severe as last year's. The long-term solution is afforestation and dredging of watercourses. And we'll do it, but for the time being, we have to [focus on] rescue.

The disaster preparedness central committee is led by the second vice-president and I am the vice chair. The central committee is set to meet on August 5 and the meeting will be attended by all the chief ministers in the division and state governments and concerned ministries. In the meeting, we will discuss solutions.

What is your message to flood victims?

Some Facebook users have posted the photos of last year's floods, and in some cases, this has led people into thinking that the situation needs to be treated as a state of emergency. So, I want people to verify the news. I would like to urge them to continuously watch the announcements of Myanmar Radio and Television (MRTV), and Department of Meteorology and Hydrology, and our ministry.

Some users have shared incorrect news and last year's weather predictions by experienced meteorologists, which misled the people. I want to stress that people need to verify these reports.

We have a hotline, and people can contact directly us for any inquiries round the clock: 067-404666 or 067-404777. You can enquire, send information and seek advice at those numbers. What's more is that we have developed an Android application. We will upload it soon on our website for download. Through this app, users will be able to contact us for help.

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post Social Welfare Minister: Deforestation and Exploitation of Resources Contributed to Flooding appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Security Increased After ISIS Hit List Targets Aung San Suu Kyi

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 03:47 AM PDT

State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi is pictured holding a meeting with peace negotiation teams in Naypyidaw in July. (Photo: Htet Naing Zaw / The Irrawaddy)

State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi is pictured holding a meeting with peace negotiation teams in Naypyidaw in July. (Photo: Htet Naing Zaw / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — President Office's Spokesperson Zaw Htay said that State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi's security would be increased, in response to reports that she was on an ISIS target list in Malaysia.

"We don't need to worry too much but we also can't underestimate it. We will take this matter seriously and will increase security during her local and international tours," Zaw Htay told The Irrawaddy on Wednesday.

The Straits Times reported on Tuesday that Aung San Suu Kyi was on an ISIS hit list sent to Maylasia's Negri Sembilan police station on Monday, along with the Malaysian prime minister, his deputy, the attorney-general, the inspector-general of police, and three ministers.

The report stated that the two-page letter entitled "IS threat" included photographs of the targeted leaders and claimed there were about 700 ISIS militants in Negri Sembilan. Malaysian police have dismissed the claim.

It said police would investigate the authenticity of the letter and try to establish the identity of the sender.

"Given the nature of IS activities, the group generally works by connecting with in-country networks. Although we haven't faced terrorist attacks, we will watch suspicious networks closely. We will also cooperate with the international community, including Asean and the Malaysian police," Zaw Htay said.

ISIS is an acronym for the jihadist group known as The Islamic State in Iraq and al-Sham (or the Levant). The armed organization controls areas of conflict-torn Iraq and Syria.

The post Security Increased After ISIS Hit List Targets Aung San Suu Kyi appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Analysis: China’s More Proactive Policy Could Hold the Key to Peace in Burma

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 02:45 AM PDT

 Ethnic armed group leaders, including UNFC vice chairman Nai Hong Sar, enter Mai Ja Yang in Kachin State, having passed through Chinese Immigration. (Photo: Hein Htet / The Irrawaddy)

Ethnic armed group leaders, including UNFC vice chairman Nai Hong Sar, enter Mai Ja Yang in Kachin State, having passed through Chinese Immigration. (Photo: Hein Htet / The Irrawaddy)

So that they could attend the summit in the border town of Mai Ja Yang in Kachin State, the Chinese authorities allowed ethnic armed group leaders to travel freely through Chinese territory from the Muse border in northern Shan State—a marked departure from previous practice.

In 2011, senior Karen National Union leader Mann Nyein Maung was detained by Chinese immigration officers while also transiting through China—to reach the border town, and Kachin Independence Army headquarters, of Laiza in Kachin State—and was handed over to the Burmese authorities. Sentenced to life imprisonment, he was released in a 2012 amnesty.

China had also been steadfast in its support for Burma's military regime prior to the 2011 handover to a nominally civilian government, lending the country an economic lifeline while it remained isolated by stringent sanctions from Western countries.

As the ethnic armed group leaders crossed the border into China at Muse, they were reportedly treated courteously by Chinese immigration officials and allowed to proceed freely on the one hour drive to the border connecting Mai Ja Yang in Kachin State.

Tar Bong Kyaw, secretary of the Ta'ang National Liberation Army (a group conspicuously absent from the Mai Ja Yang summit), told The Irrawaddy in Ruili—the Chinese border town opposite Muse—how Chinese authorities "ignore our traveling now."

He recalled how Chinese intelligence officers would "chase" him in the past—but they now let him travel through China "without restriction." He commented that he would not have been able to meet the Irrawaddy reporter "in a public place" in previous times.

Conventionally muted on the topic of Burma's politics and its long-running civil conflicts, China has recently become more vocal and demonstrative in its support of Burma's peace process.

During the Mai Ja Yang ethnic armed group summit, which ran July 26-30, China's Special Envoy on Asian Affairs Sun Guoxiang gave an address on the opening day, stating that China backed "all the forces that support internal peace in Burma."

Sun Guoxiang announced that China had donated US$3 million to the Joint Monitoring Committee, a body overseeing the commitments of the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement reached between the previous government and eight ethnic armed groups in October last year.

This more proactive stance may reflect a growing realization of the importance of peace in Burma for China, given their substantial economic interests in Burma, and their long—and perennially unstable—shared border.

Every day at the Muse border, fleets of trucks can be seeing ferrying large quantities of goods between the two countries. Most of the towns on the border with China that are controlled by ethnic armed groups—such as Mai Ja Yang, Laukkai, Pangshang and Mongla—now resemble Chinese towns, their growth having been driven by investment from Chinese businessmen.

Burma's most powerful ethnic armed groups, the United Wa State Army and the Kachin Independence Army—alongside others such as the Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army (Kokang), the National Democratic Alliance Army (Mongla), and the Ta'ang National Liberation Army—have benefitted from border trade agreements with Chinese authorities, alongside private Chinese investment.

China's leverage over a wide portion of Burma's ethnic armed groups is therefore considerable. China's role may be key to resolving Burma's peace process.

In his address at the Mai Ja Yang summit, the Chinese envoy said he expected all ethnic armed groups to attend the "21st Century Panglong" Union Peace Conference scheduled for later this month, where a peace deal including a blueprint for federalism is hoped to be reached.

However, he cautioned that resolution might not come all at once. Using the example of a train undertaking a journey, the envoy said that not all passengers would get off at the same station, but at separate stations along the line.

The post Analysis: China's More Proactive Policy Could Hold the Key to Peace in Burma appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

National News

National News


Youth ethnic alliance emerges after summit

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 12:12 AM PDT

A major new national ethnic youth alliance has been formed this week with its first vow being to ensure the inclusion of young people in the forthcoming 21st-century Panglong Conference – despite government chiefs' attempts to dismiss them.

Advocates demand inclusive education for disabled students

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 12:02 AM PDT

A consortium of organisations advocating for people with disabilities has urged the Ministry of Education to form an Inclusive Education Department.

Parliamentarians told to pay up on guesthouse tax

Posted: 02 Aug 2016 11:59 PM PDT

Lawmakers dorming in state-owned accommodation in the capital will now be subject to a 5 percent commercial tax, according to the Nay Pyi Taw City Development Committee.

Pyin Oo Lwin residents permitted to transfer land ownership

Posted: 02 Aug 2016 11:54 PM PDT

Villagers in Pyin Oo Lwin township, Mandalay Region, are benefiting from cuts in red tape that allow them to transfer ownership of land, or to change the use to which the land is put. The new system came into force on July 28, said regional hluttaw MP U Aung Min (NLD).

U Bein Bridge closed to pedestrians amid flooding

Posted: 02 Aug 2016 11:47 PM PDT

A sudden, rapid influx of water into Mandalay's Taungthaman Lake has forced authorities to block access to the city's famed U Bein Bridge. Barriers were erected on both sides of the bridge to block pedestrian access on August 1 after the waters of the lake rose almost to the level of the bridge walkway.

A tale of two teens, as Panglong awakens at last

Posted: 02 Aug 2016 11:43 PM PDT

"I regret it now!"
The Panglong Conference was a pivotal moment in Myanmar history and its significance resonates throughout the country even 70 years later, but at the time 19-year-old U Tun Shwe just wasn't that interested.

Rains trigger more landslides in northern Chin State

Posted: 02 Aug 2016 11:27 PM PDT

After five days of heavy rain, landslides struck northern Chin State yesterday, breaking down transportation in the area.

Thousands displaced as floods hit five regions, one state

Posted: 02 Aug 2016 11:22 PM PDT

Nearly 100,000 people across five regions and one state have been relocated due to flooding, according to data from the Department of Relief and Resettlement covering the period from the last week of July to yesterday.

Ministry of Home Affairs seeks bigger budget for drug crackdown

Posted: 02 Aug 2016 11:19 PM PDT

The Ministry of Home Affairs will request a separate budget allocation to crack down on use and distribution of illicit narcotics, Deputy Home Affairs Minister Major General Aung Soe said at yesterday's Amyotha Hluttaw session, one week after an MP from Shan State urged the government to get tough on drugs.

Hunted elephant found dead in Bago Region

Posted: 02 Aug 2016 11:17 PM PDT

A dead elephant was discovered in a Bago Region dam's reservoir with a poison arrow in its neck on July 29.

Shan Herald Agency for News

Shan Herald Agency for News


Mining operation exacerbates civilian abuse in Nam Ma, says SHRF

Posted: 03 Aug 2016 02:51 AM PDT

The Burmese army and its allies arbitrarily arrest, torture and kill civilians as they bid to secure coal-mining concessions in the Nam Ma area of Hsipaw in northern Shan State, according to a leading Shan rights group.

PHOTO BY SHRF: Coal mining site in Nam Ma area.
In a statement released on Tuesday, the Shan Human Rights Foundation (SHRF) alleged that Burmese government troops had killed two residents in Nam Ma, forced several to work as porters for the army, and had looted and destroyed properties in the area, while simultaneously launching offensives against the Shan State Progress Party/Shan State Army (SSPP/SSA) in May.

"Over 500 Burmese troops from four battalions -- Lashio-based IB 41, Tangyan-based LIB 523, Mongyai-based IB 67, and Nam Pawng-based LIB 291 -- as well as hundreds of pro-government militia troops (from the Man Pang militia and local Lahu militia), and helicopter gunships [were involved]," reads the report.

"There were about 100 soldiers camped in our village," a resident of Pieng Hsai village told SHRF. "Twenty-two soldiers slept in my house for three nights. They took our rice, salt and oil to cook for themselves. Fortunately there were no young women in the village. They had all fled when the fighting started."

SHRF reported that about 50 houses in the villages of Na Taw and Teung Hai were looted and destroyed.

The Burmese military has overseen coal-mining operations in this area since 1990s. However, since 2004, the Mandalay-based Ngwe Yi Pale Company, in a joint venture with Myanmar's No. 3 Mining Enterprise, has taken over full control.

Businessman U Thein Myint, also known as Chaung Hpin, retains a 43.55 percent share of the enterprise, while U Myint Shein owns 29.2 percent, according to a recent report by Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI), an international industry watchdog.

"Villagers estimate that over a hundred large trucks transport lignite each day from the mines to Ngwe Yi Pale's 'Crown' cement and sugar-producing factories in Nawng Khio and Mandalay," the statement said.

Sai Hor Hseng, the SHRF spokesperson, said that the Burmese army has displaced villagers from their homes, but at the same time allowed mining operations to continue while it fights the SSPP/SSA.

"They [the Burmese armed forces] ordered the villagers not to enter the area, but allowed the mining company to continue operations," he said. "People have been suffering from these activities. Their houses were destroyed and their properties were looted.

"They never pay any compensation," added Sai Hor Hseng. "These kind of cases are never brought to justice. They just disappear."

On July 13, Shan Herald reported that Nang San San Aye, an MP from the Shan Nationalities League for Democracy (SNLD) who represents Hsipaw Township, had requested the Shan State government take action against the Ngwe Yi Pale Mining Co Ltd. But her calls fell on deaf ears.

Due to the impact of mining – including damage to farmlands, water contamination and air pollution – villagers from Peng Zai, Parng Ngar and Nar Goon staged a protest in May, calling on the company to permanently halt operations.

"SHRF strongly condemns this offensive and the abuses committed against civilians," Tuesday's report reads. "We reiterate our calls for the Burma Army to immediately end their offensives, troop expansion, and abuses in the ethnic areas, and for an end to Burma Army impunity."

It concluded: "We also reiterate our calls to the Burmese government for an immediate suspension of all resource extraction projects in ethnic conflict areas. Projects should only be reconsidered when a federal peace settlement has been reached, granting local communities the right to decide over natural resources in their areas."

BY: Sai Aw/Shan Herald Agency for News (SHAN)