Tuesday, March 20, 2018

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Analysis:What Lied Behind the NLD’s Protest Law Amendments?

Posted: 20 Mar 2018 07:21 AM PDT

YANGON — A recently proposed list of amendments to the Peaceful Assembly and Procession Law, better known as the protest law, has become the most controversial piece of legislation of the past two years.

Hundreds of people have marched against it, and more than 200 civil society groups issued a joint statement opposing the proposed changes. Critics have even launched an anti-amendment sticker campaign. Sixty of the military’s parliamentary appointees have signed up to debate the bill.

Opponents say the proposed changes would place further restrictions on the right to free assembly and expression and are so broadly defined that they could be exploited to stifle political dissent. The original protest law — enacted in 2011 under the previous military-backed government and amended in 2014 — has already been used to arrest and imprison activists.

The law was replaced in October 2016, after the National League for Democracy (NLD) came to power, so that protesters had only to notify authorities and no longer needed to secure their permission.

Some senior NLD officials, however, said easing the rules has provided an opportunity for those who want to incite unrest and destabilize the country.

Since the law was replaced, the country has seen a series of mass nationalist protests in some of its biggest cities, most of them religiously tinged and accusing the government of neglecting Buddhism in favor of Islam or criticizing the appointment of a special advisory commission for crisis-torn Rakhine State.

The protests have been a headache for a government already under intense international pressure over the crisis.

Thousands of demonstrators march in Yangon in support of Myanmar’s military and civil servants on Oct. 29. / Myo Min Soe / The Irrawaddy

The most notable of the protests were the pro-army rallies that drew thousands of supporters of the military, or Tatmadaw, which the UN and US have accused of an ethnic cleansing campaign against Rohingya Muslims in northern Rakhine.

Some of the protests’ most active participants have turned out to be nationalist Buddhist monks, members of the military-backed Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP), and followers of Ma Ba Tha — the most prominent group in the country spreading anti-Muslim sentiment, it was banned by the government last year.

Those who have organized and joined recent nationalist protests have said the events were paid for by fellow nationalists and sympathetic donors.

In May, Religious Affairs Minister U Aung Ko said a group or organization wanting to reverse the country’s transition to democracy — he did not specify who — was supporting the nationalists.

Monywa Aung Shin, secretary of the NLD's central information committee, told The Irrawaddy that the growing number of nationalist protests since the protest law was replaced was one reason for the recently proposed amendments.

"Because we eased the restrictions, it became worse," Monywa Aung Shin said.

He said the nationalists’ protests threaten the rule of law and need to be prevented.

Hoping to deter those with hidden motives from orchestrating protests from the shadows, the NLD proposed a set of amendments to the law on Feb. 19.

A Year of Nationalist Protests

May 20, 2017: About 300 nationalists and Buddhist monks, along with some 2,700 more supporters from across the country, marched to Naypyitaw to accuse U Aung Ko of neglecting Buddhism and favoring Islam.

They demanded that the minister apologize and that a number of nationalists convicted or accused of crimes see the charges against them dropped or that they be released from prison.

After the protest, U Aung Ko released a statement claiming participants were paid between 7,000 kyats to 30, 000 kyats ($5 to $22) and that 800 million kyats ($584,000) was spent on organizing the demonstration. He also claimed that an organization or group of people wanting to reverse the country’s transition to democracy was supporting the nationalists.

June 25, 2017: More than 200 Buddhist monks and laymen gathered in Mandalay and called for U Aung Ko’s resignation.

Nationalist monks and laymen stage an anti-government protest in Yangon on Aug. 2. / Myo Min Soe / The Irrawaddy

Aug. 2, 2017: Several dozen nationalist monks and laymen staged sit-ins at religious sites in Yangon, Mandalay and Taunggyi in Shan State calling for the government to step down because it had failed to protect Buddhism.

After the government broke up the protesters’ camp in Mandalay on Aug. 5, those in Yangon and Taunggyi shut down their own camps.

Ultranationalist monk U Wirathu joins a demonstration near Yangon on Aug. 30. / Myo Min Soe / The Irrawaddy

Aug. 30, 2017: Hundreds of nationalists held a demonstration near Yangon City Hall against the final recommendations of the government-appointed Rakhine State Advisory Commission and the recent attacks by the militant Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) in Rakhine on Aug. 25.

Ultranationalist monk U Wirathu joined the demonstrators, who called on the government to declare martial law in Rakhine and to convene a meeting of the military-dominated National Defense and Security Council (NDSC).

Sept. 18, 2017: Hundreds of nationalists protested again near Yangon City Hall against the commission’s recommendations, opposing its call for a review of the country's Citizenship Act and an end to restrictions on Rohingya.

Rally: Former Defense Minister Lt. Gen. Wai Lwin gives an address to USDP members and the public at a rally on Rakhine State in Naypyitaw on Sept. 21. / Myo Min Soe / The Irrawaddy

Sept. 21, 2017: The former ruling USDP staged a rally in Naypyitaw at which they warned that the conflict in Rakhine State could lead to "territorial loss" for Myanmar.

The USDP also rejected the government's formation of the advisory commission and the recommendations the commission came up with. It also complained about the NLD government's failure to call a meeting of the NDSC.

Sept. 26, 2017: About 3,000 nationalists in Mandalay and from surrounding areas joined a rally to condemn the ARSA attacks and protest against foreign interference in the internal affairs of the country, referring to the crisis in Rakhine State.

The protesters also rejected the advisory commission’s recommendations and any suggestion of amending the Citizenship Act.

Nov. 19, 2017: Thousands of people including Buddhist monks joined two mass rallies in Mandalay Region and Karen State held simultaneously by the "Tatmadaw Admirer Group" to show support for the army's actions in Rakhine Sate. Similar pro-army rallies were held in September and October in Mon State and Yangon, respectively, that attracted thousands of people including USDP members, nationalist monks and their followers.

Feb. 2, 2018: Nationalists appeared at a Yangon court hearing for the accused murderer of Muslim lawyer U Ko Ni wearing T-shirts reading "Eat Well” to show their support for the co-conspirators on trial. The phrase in Burmese is considered a threat to show one's anger and to warn of impending revenge, advising the target to have a final, hearty meal before death.

Prevention or Restriction?

The recently proposed amendments would require would-be demonstrators to identify their funding sources and stipulate jail time for using protests to instigate unrest.

Rights groups say the changes prioritize control over the right to protest.

NLD lawmaker Naw Susana Hla Hla Soe said terms in the proposed amendments are too broadly and give authorities lots of leeway to define them, citing the proposed Article 18 as an example.

The article would stipulate prison sentences of up to two years for provoking or exhorting others to organize or participate in demonstrations by bribing or paying them money or doing anything else with the intention of harming the stability, rule of law, peace and tranquility of the community and public morality.

But senior NLD officials and other supporters of the bill say the changes would impose no new restrictions on peaceful protesters.

"Some people are saying they will be charged under the amendments if they give just a water bottle to a protester or if they clap and cheer. It is not so. It depends on the intention [of the supporter] and the amount [of the support]," NLD lawmaker U Myat Nyana Soe, who supports the bill, told The Irrawaddy.

Despite strong opposition, the bill was passed by the Upper House earlier this month — the majority of votes came from the NLD — and forwarded to the Lower House, though the maximum prison time for violating Article 18 was dropped from three years to two.

"We proposed the amendments to target the dark elements behind [the protests]” U Myat Nyana Soe said.

Human rights activist U Aung Myo Min said it was clear that the NLD wants to amend the law in order to take action against those who mastermind demonstrations that might cause instability or create a crisis for the government.

Still, he said, the law should not be changed with the intention of preventing groups from taking to the streets, adding that free expression and peaceful assembly were fundamental human rights.

But opposition to the bill is not only coming from democratic forces.

The USDP, which used the protest law to arrest activists while in power, and the military, which has a long history of human rights abuses and of cracking down on peaceful protesters, are opposed to the changes too.

During a discussion of the amendments in the Upper House Bill Committee, Brigadier General Tint Lwin argued against them.

"Whichever organization funds the protest, the citizens' right to peaceful assembly is more essential," Major Aung Ko Min, a military appointee to the Upper House, said the day the chamber voted on the bill. He said the proposed amendments would hinder those who want to pay for a protest honestly.

Lieutenant Colonel Tin Lin Oo spoke out against Article 18 as well.

"The military [appointees] are now repeating the words that the NLD and pro-democracy activists once used," said U Pe Than, a Lower House lawmaker for the Arakan National Party. "I think they want to show the public that they guard the Constitution and stand together with the people."

Rights activist U Aung Myo Min said the military’s words may sound similar but had different motives.

"We stand for human rights. Even if they speak the same words, the intention is different because we don't have any political motives," he said.

The post Analysis:What Lied Behind the NLD’s Protest Law Amendments? appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Ministry To Consult Private Sector on Tax Rate for Unexplained Income

Posted: 20 Mar 2018 06:53 AM PDT

NAYPYITAW—The Ministry of Finance and Revenue will hold extensive discussions with the business sector on whether to reduce the tax rate on income from unidentified sources.

"We will hold extensive discussions with concerned departments, UMFCCI [Union of Myanmar Federation of Chambers of Commerce and Industry] and big taxpayers, and try to draft a separate law that will be more comprehensive. We'll start as soon as we can," U Maung Maung Win, deputy minister for planning and finance, told reporters in Naypyitaw.

On Tuesday, the Union Parliament approved a recommendation from the Joint Bill Committee to exclude from the 2018 Union Taxation Law a provision on the taxing of income and possessions whose source taxpayers cannot explain.

Under Chapter 8 of the draft Union Taxation Law 2018, the tax rate on such income was to be reduced. This led to a public outcry amid complaints that the provision would facilitate money laundering.

In 2016, the National League for Democracy (NLD)-led government imposed a 30-percent tax rate on the purchase of property paid for with funds whose source the buyer cannot identify.

The move aimed to rein in property prices, as the government was concerned that large sums of money were being laundered through the property market.

However, many developers were adversely affected by this move, and the property market saw its worst year in 2017 as a result.

"If the tax rate is to be reduced, we need a separate law. The provision in the [draft] Union Taxation Law is not sufficient," the secretary of the Joint Bill Committee, Dr Myat Nyana Soe, told Parliament.

Developers are not happy with Parliament's decision to reconsider the tax reduction, as they were anticipating a tax cut effective April 1. Their hope was that the reduced tax rate would spur the sluggish property market and attract investors.

"The government needs to explain to lawmakers in advance why those taxes need to be reduced. Lawmakers said they didn't know about it," said Dr Soe Tun, a businessman based in Yangon.

Developers will be hit hard by the postponement, he said. "Some developers have taken loans from banks. So if developers are hit hard, banks may also suffer the consequences," he said.

Some lawmakers claimed in Parliament that a reduction in the tax rate on unexplained income would not be fair to average taxpayers.

Meanwhile, the Union Parliament approved the Union Taxation Bill's provision to reduce tax from 20 percent to 10 percent on purchases of small cars of 1,500 to 2,000cc, which are within the reach of middle-income families.

According to a report by the Joint Bill Committee, the tax rate for unexplained sources of income is 15 percent on income from 1 kyat to 30 million kyats, 20 percent from 30 million kyats to 100 million kyats, and 30 percent for income above 100 million kyats.

Despite public calls for an income tax cut, the Union Parliament maintained the clause requiring anyone with a minimum annual income of 4.8 million kyats to pay income tax.

The post Ministry To Consult Private Sector on Tax Rate for Unexplained Income appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Singer, Ex-lawyer Face Prosecution for Criticizing Court

Posted: 20 Mar 2018 06:04 AM PDT

MANDALAY — Judges from Mandalay Region have filed separate lawsuits against a singer and a former lawyer for insulting and defaming the court.

Singer Ma Khing @ Ta Tha Tha was sued under the Telecommunications Law, Article 66 (d), for posting a video clip on Facebook that insulted the court in Singu Township, Mandalay divisional judicial authorities said at a press conference on Tuesday.

In the video clip, Ta Tha Tha talks in front of the court in Singu after losing a lawsuit, saying she would rather sit with prostitutes than judges.

"What she posted on Facebook was so harsh; she is not only insulting and defaming the court but also creating a misunderstanding over the judicial system by posting the video, which was widely shared among Facebook users," said Daw Khin Hla Kyi, a Mandalay district judge.

The judicial officials explained that the singer filed a lawsuit at Singu Court in June 2015 against her ex-son-in-law and 15 others accusing them of stealing property worth more than 43 billion kyats. On Friday, the court rejected the lawsuit on the grounds that the singer had failed to present proper witnesses or concrete evidence.

"The court could not continue the hearing without concrete evidence, so it had to reject the case. The singer can appeal to a higher court in accordance with the law if she wants to proceed with the lawsuit. But she insulted the judge and the court through her Facebook [post], so Judge U Win Zaw Oo filed the lawsuit against her under the Telecommunications Law," Daw Khin Hla Kyi said.

In a separate incident, a judge from Pyigyitagon Township filed a lawsuit against former lawyer U Zaw Win for throwing a slipper at a sign outside the court and insulting the judge and the court.

U Zaw Win, a former political prisoner and lawyer, was at the court in Pyigyitagon Township to show his support for political activist Ma Zar Zar Tun, who was herself facing a lawsuit under the Defamation Act for insulting the court and a judge.

When the court sentenced Ma Zar Zar Tun to four months' imprisonment after detaining her without access to her lawyer for a day, an angry and disappointed U Zaw Win threw a slipper at the signboard of Pyigyitagon Court.

"Actually, Ma Zar Zar Tun refused to talk to the court and produced no witnesses, so the judge sentenced her in accordance with the law," explained Daw Khin Khin Cho, a judicial officer at the Mandalay Region Judiciary Office.

According to the authorities, Ma Zar Zar Tun was sued on March 14 after she shouted and threatened the judge in front of the court to show her disagreement with the court regarding a lawsuit involving her brother-in-law.

"U Zaw Win also insulted the court and the judge, so Daw Su Thet Nguon, the judge from Pyigyitagon Township, filed the lawsuit against him for gravely insulting and defaming the judicial system," the officer added.

Mandalay Region judicial authorities said they are trying to eliminate misunderstandings over the judicial system and the fight against corruption, so every act that defames or creates misunderstanding shall be prosecuted.

The post Singer, Ex-lawyer Face Prosecution for Criticizing Court appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Weaving a Little Lotus Magic at Inle Lake

Posted: 20 Mar 2018 05:24 AM PDT

Inle Lake is a uniquely Myanmar attraction that is very popular with tourists. It is famous for its floating gardens, fishermen who row their canoes with one leg (Intha), and wooden houses on stilts.

Surrounded by the Shan Hills, the large freshwater lake is situated in southern Shan State, about 650 km from Yangon.

Most of the people who live around Inle Lake make their living as farmers, hotels, restaurateurs, and tour guide operators. Another trade that has benefited from the tourist industry is lotus weaving.

The Padonmar Kyar variety of lotus grows on Inle Lake./ Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy

More than 100 years ago, local women began weaving textiles using fabric made from the lotus flowers that grow on the lake.

There are many villages around the lake but the lotus weaving industry is centered on Kyaing Khan and In Paw Khone villages.

A boat tour lead me to the Khit Sunn Yin Lotus, Silk and Cotton Hand-Weaving Centre at In Paw Khon village. It was the first time I had gotten a close-up look at how the lotus pieces are hand-woven.

The center displays each stage of the lotus-weaving process. An employee will guide you through the process from beginning to end, and it is amazing.

A woman extracts fibers from the lotus stems./ Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy

At the entrance, you will see an old woman seated at a small wooden table cutting lotus stems into small pieces and extracting their fibers by hand using a knife.

Then, the fibers are moistened and rolled together to form threads. The process is repeated again and again to produce the long, fine threads used in lotus weaving.

That stage is the first and most important part of the lotus silk-making process, and workers need to be patient. So, most of the staff are older because young people are too restless, an employee at the center said.

A woman weaves a product on an old hand loom./ Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy

In the second stage, another older woman is spinning and weaving the raw, pure lotus silk into spools by using a hand-turned wheel.

The lotus threads are a creamy color; the weavers dye them using jackfruit, bark, seeds, lotus leaves and other natural materials to get colored fabric.

Then, the lotus threads are turned into products using the old hand looms; this is the final stage of the lotus silk weaving process.

Visitors tour the shop at the Khit Sunn Yin center./ Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy

The whole process is very labor intensive; no wonder the finest lotus products are among the most expensive textile products in the world.

Using lotus stems produces incredibly high quality clothing, and I have so much respect for the skilled artisans who can weave this kind of magic.

One small neck scarf requires about 4,000 lotus stems, takes a day to make (if the worker is quick) and sells for hundreds of dollars. A full set of monk's robes requires about 220,000 lotus stems, and takes about 60 weavers more than 10 days to complete.

The staff said that wearing lotus products keeps one cool in summer and warm in winter. The fabric is soft, lightweight and yet so delicate; you can see every detail and the composition exquisite.

Finished products made from lotus flowers, silk and cotton. / Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy

The center not only demonstrates the lotus silk weaving process, but also shows how clothes are woven from other fabrics including silk and cotton.

The final stop on the tour is the shop. Here you can find all kinds of finished products at a range of prices. The products made from pure lotus are the most expensive.

There are various species of lotus, but only the Padonma Kyar can be used to make these woven products. The lotuses must be grown in muddy waters and can only be harvested during the wet season.

The lotus weaving process never fails to amaze me and I strongly recommend a trip to a workshop like Khit Sunn Yin whenever you are visiting Inle Lake.

The post Weaving a Little Lotus Magic at Inle Lake appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Analysis: Is Suu Kyi’s Health Cause for Concern?

Posted: 20 Mar 2018 04:53 AM PDT

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi's abrupt cancellation of an event at the Lowy Institute disappointed some in Australia. "This afternoon, the Lowy Institute was informed by the Myanmar Embassy that the State Counsellor will no longer be able to participate in this event as she is not feeling well. The event is now cancelled," the Lowy Institute said in a statement.

Before she flew to Australia for a summit between Australia and the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), Suu Kyi, 73, had a routine medical check-up.

Rumors of her ill health and her hesitance to take long-haul flights have been discussed by some Asian diplomats in Myanmar.

"She is downcast …. Now under enormous pressure…," an Asian diplomat with extensive knowledge of Myanmar remarked a few months ago.

But she traveled to Australia, where she received a 19-gun salute, discussed the situation in Rakhine State with heads of state behind closed doors, and held talks with Myanmar citizens who came out to support her.

"We discussed the situation in Rakhine State at considerable length today," Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull told reporters at the end of the summit.

"Daw Aung San Suu Kyi addressed the matter comprehensively at some considerable length herself… She seeks support from ASEAN and other nations to provide help from a humanitarian and capacity-building point of view."

Her health is of great concern, but some skeptics will say the event cancellation was an avoidance of an uneasy question and answer session over sensitive topics. Since her administration assumed power, she has avoided local media and spoken to few foreign media organizations including the BBC.

In 2016, months after her government came to power, Suu Kyi traveled to the US, where she met with President Obama and held several meetings in Washington, D.C. It was a two-week trip that also included a stop in London.

During the visit, for the first time, the state counselor addressed the United Nations in New York where she spoke about peace and sustainable solutions in strife-torn Myanmar.

Subsequently, she also spoke at the Asia Foundation. But she was forced to cancel a meeting with the Partnership Group on Burma in New York, taking a doctor's advice to rest.

It was reported that she joked, during a visit to Roosevelt High School, that it would be good for her health to be placed under house arrest again on the weekends. Landing in Yangon, Suu Kyi arrived fatigued, reportedly briefly using a wheelchair.

Back in Myanmar, her office responded stating that her health was "not a cause for concern," as rumors swirled on social media about the state counselor being seen in a wheelchair at the airport after arriving from the US.

Aung San Suu Kyi's health is stable, but she is suffering from weakness and exhaustion and needs to rest following more than two weeks of official travel to the United States and Britain, a government official said.

Some diplomats didn't believe that she was ill but avoiding the issue of the Rohingya.

Last year, facing a storm of global criticism over issues in northern Rakhine State in which she and the military were accused of ethnic cleansing and genocide, the Nobel laureate canceled her planned visit to the United Nations General Assembly. She addressed diplomats and media in the capital and sent her vice president instead to New York.

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi's health has long been under scrutiny, despite her being known as health-conscious, having undergone regular medical check-ups even while under house arrest.

In September, she underwent a medical checkup at the Grand Hantha Hospital in Yangon. She also reportedly undergoes regular medical checkups in Naypyitaw. She had an eye operation a few years ago.

Last year, there was a rumor that she had been paralyzed, which was untrue. But political observers and party members were left agreeing that the public should know about the health of the highest official in the government.

Myint Soe, her former chef, published memoirs a few years back and mentioned that the state counselor was health conscious.

"She doesn't eat red meat. She shuns MSG and oily food. She wants less salt in her food. Fish, prawns and vegetables are her meals of choice. Plus, chicken and duck," Soe told The Irrawaddy. "She is very health-conscious. She told me to use sugar as a substitute for MSG. She doesn't want to be fat, either."

The post Analysis: Is Suu Kyi's Health Cause for Concern? appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Officials Trying to Push Muslim Families out of Hpasawng

Posted: 20 Mar 2018 04:11 AM PDT

Authorities in Hpasawng, Karenni State, are pressuring dozens of minority Muslims to leave the town, claiming they are staying there illegally, according to local sources.

Six Muslim families reside legally in the town, but another 21 families are there illegally, an immigration official said. He said that under the law, they needed to be on the housing list if they wanted to stay in Hpasawng.

"There are people staying there legally, but there are also people there illegally. We did not say anything to the persons who were legal. We even helped to add their children to the housing list. Those who are there illegally have to go back to their home towns after one month," said U Tin Tun.

"We told them they need to show Form 10 [residence permission documents] if they want to stay in Hpasawng," he added. There are 21 families totaling 50 people staying in the town illegally, he said.

The 50 Muslims have been in the area for two years, but the order to pressure them to leave Hpasawng came from the top, according to immigration officials.

Security forces involved in pressuring the 50 Muslims to leave the town include police, immigration and township authorities, according to Aung Zaw Oo, a rights activist based in Loikaw.

He sent a letter to the chief minister of Karenni State yesterday asking for help to solve the problem involving minority Muslims.

"This is a case of rights abuse. They should stop it," Aung Zaw Oo said.

The Muslim families sell clothes and vegetables, or work as mechanics fixing cars and motorbikes in Hpasawng town.

The authorities met the Muslims on March 13 and told them to return to the townships in which they were born. Many were from Loikaw, but some were born in Taunggyi or Mandalay, local sources said.

Muslim sources claim the authorities did not issue Form 10 permission letters enabling the families to stay because of their religion. Therefore, they may have to leave Hpasawng soon as the pressure from authorities is mounting.

"They gave us three days to leave the town, but it is impossible to do so quickly," one of the affected Muslims, who did not want to give his name, told The Irrawaddy.

Immigration officials had issued pink cards to the Muslims to indicate they were Myanmar citizens, but other immigration authorities had warned them they did not have full citizenship yet, he said.

The situation began when some people from Hpasawng who disliked Muslim people coming to set up small businesses in the town told authorities to move them out.

Minority Muslims living in Myanmar have experienced various forms of discrimination, including being targeted by ultranationalist monks. Widespread anti-Muslim violence emerged under the previous government, but restrictions on Muslims continue under the democratically elected NLD-led government, as old laws remain in place.

The post Officials Trying to Push Muslim Families out of Hpasawng appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

NLD Stalwart Returns to Ongoing Speculation Over Party Role

Posted: 20 Mar 2018 02:46 AM PDT

YANGON — National League for Democracy stalwart supporter and aide to Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, U Win Htein, will return to Myanmar later this week after meeting with the State Counselor in Australia, according to sources close to his family.

He left suddenly for Australia in January after his son's wedding, which Suu Kyi had criticized for its grandeur. At the time, rumors circulated on social media that the party had suspended him from his duties, and even that he had resigned.

U Win Htein is one of the party's Secretariat members who has been overseeing the ruling party since Daw Aung San Suu Kyi was appointed to Union ministerial positions and State Counselor in 2016 after the NLD government came to power. But he was known for his influence both in the party and government due to his proximity to Suu Kyi as well as his reckless remarks, including that the country's military may be involved in spreading rumors to destabilize the NLD government.

During her visit to Australia, Suu Kyi had meetings with U Win Htein on Sunday and Monday. Local media reported – quoting people with knowledge of the meetings – that the state counselor had urged him to return to Myanmar before the end of March. On Monday, after the meeting, people close to him posted on social media that U Win Htein would head to Myanmar on Saturday.

According to some of the party's central executive committee (CEC) members, he had not reported his trip to the party. But he sent a letter to the party in late February, asking the CEC to decide if he was still permitted to continue his duties serving the party.

Party CEC member Dr. Myo Nyunt told local media that he did not want to comment on the situation at the moment.

"We take his departure as a leave. If he decides to come back, he will have to assume his duties as usual," he said.

During his absence, the NLD held CEC meetings in Naypyitaw. After the January meeting, U Nyan Win, the chairman of the NLD information team, told the media that the meeting had not discussed anything related to U Win Htein and that he remained a central executive committee member of the party.

The post NLD Stalwart Returns to Ongoing Speculation Over Party Role appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Bangladesh Heightens Scrutiny of NGOs in Cox’s Bazar

Posted: 20 Mar 2018 01:58 AM PDT

DHAKA, Bangladesh — Bangladeshi authorities are placing local and foreign aid workers in the refugee camps of Cox's Bazar under added scrutiny to root out groups working without proper visas or promoting religion.

Bangladesh’s elite Rapid Action Battalion (RAB) and Cox's Bazar district police have detained more than 60 foreign nationals to review their work permits and visas. They were all released after providing written statements explaining why they were not carrying the required documents.

It follows a meeting on the work of non-governmental organizations (NGOs) in Cox’s Bazar on Feb. 4 chaired by the district’s then-deputy commissioner, Ali Hossain.

The meeting ended with 13 new rules for NGOs to follow, including that they stop working in the camps each day by 5 p.m. They must also now secure permission from authorities before working in medical camps and “child-friendly zones.”

“We are monitoring their activities because of various [media] reports, including of religious motivational activities,” district Deputy Commissioner Muhammad Mahidur Rahman told The Irrawaddy.

At the meeting, a committee was also formed to supervise the NGOs’ work.

“We received a number of allegations and they are under investigation. We will have a meeting at the end of March with both local and international organizations and will make public what they are actually doing,” said district Assistant Commissioner Akramul Siddiq, the committee’s top representative in Ukhia, home to the largest of the refugee camps.

Nearly 700,000 people, the vast majority of them Rohingya, have fled Myanmar for Bangladesh since late August, when militant attacks on security posts in northern Rakhine State sparked a massive clearance operation by Myanmar’s security forces.

A number of daily newspapers in Bangladesh have reported that local and international NGOs have been overpricing relief materials meant for the refugees.

Detained and Questioned

Law enforcement officials said they were worried by reports that some charities were promoting their religious beliefs among the refugees, most of who are Muslim but include Buddhists and Hindus.

“More than 350 Rohingya Muslims have converted to Christianity without changing their Muslim names for safety. We have interrogated a top worker of a Dhaka-based Catholic charity working in Cox's Bazar about its activities. But the worker was released because voluntary religious conversion is not considered a crime in our country,” a district police official said, speaking on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the issue.

Security and intelligence agencies have interrogated a number of aid workers, most of them from faith-based groups. Police said some Islamic charities have had their activities reviewed as well to determine whether they have been encouraging extremist views.

Visa Troubles

The detention of more than 60 foreign aid workers over recent months has raised tensions with Bangladesh’s development partners as well.

On Feb. 23, police detained for eight hours 11 foreigners working for Doctors Without Borders and the Turkish International Cooperation and Development Agency who were on their way to a camp in Ukhia.

“We detained them and handed them over to the local police station because they failed to show proper documents and original passports,” said Major Ruhul Amin, the RAB company commander in Cox's Bazar.

In a statement released the day its staff was detained, Doctors Without Borders country chief Pavlo Kolovos said his NGO — which has worked in Bangladesh for the past 25 years — was fully registered in Bangladesh and remained committed to complying with all applicable regulations.

Of the 11, two were British and two were Italian. The others were from Norway, Brazil, the Netherlands, South Korea, Kenya, Belgium and Turkey.

In a separate incident in mid-January, two aid workers from Myanmar were transferred to Dhaka without explanation.

Most recently, on March 11, at least 39 foreign aid workers were detained for lacking proper travel documents.

The same day, The Dhaka Tribune quoted Andrea Manenti of the British Red Cross as saying: “We have been hearing for the last two, three weeks that Bangladeshi authorities are stopping the foreign aid workers on their way to the camps. But today was the first time I faced this. I was supposed to provide sanitation, but I am stuck here with my entire team.”

Officials from the police force’s Special Branch said the aid workers needed work permits and work visas to carry out their relief activities in the camps.

According to the Special Branch, more than 1,700 foreigners are currently staying in the city of Cox's Bazar. It says two-thirds of them are working for local and international NGOs and the rest on various power projects currently under construction.

A Special Branch official, who asked to remain anonymous because he was not authorized to speak with the media, said the problem was with the types of visas many aid workers were applying for.

“Work permits are a must if you are employed here. But the process is too long, so many aid workers get visas on arrival, causing the trouble,' the official said.

“We just want to encourage the aid agencies. How can we allow any foreigner to work without a work permit?” said Afruzul Haque Tutul, a deputy district police chief, adding that authorities would continue to conduct random checks.

On March 12, United Nations Resident Coordinator Mia Seppo held an urgent meeting with Home Ministry officials to discuss how the visa process could be eased for aid workers.

“The government is working on ways to simplify the visa process…. We hope the problem will be solved shortly,” said a Bangladeshi official who works closely with the refugees and donor agencies and asked not to be named because of the sensitivity of the talks.

The head of the Department of Immigration and Passports, Major General Masud Rezwan, could not be reached for comment because he was out of the country.

Leading Bangladeshi rights activist Nur Khan Liton, who has been following the Rohingya crisis over the years, said the government should immediately stop hindering the NGOs in their work.

“If you have a specific allegation, prosecute them. Otherwise, such detentions will give the wrong message to foreign friends,” he said. “If possible, please issue a visa within 24 hours.”

Muktadir Rashid is a Dhaka-based journalist contributing to The Irrawaddy.

The post Bangladesh Heightens Scrutiny of NGOs in Cox’s Bazar appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Mon Party Still Struggling to Hold Public Meetings Even After Ceasefire Deal

Posted: 20 Mar 2018 12:23 AM PDT

YANGON — The New Mon State Party (NMSP) says it is still finding it hard to hold public consultations with ethnic Mon people as part of its national-level political dialogue more than a month after it signed the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement (NCA) with the government.

The national-level political dialogue is a mandatory step of the NCA, in which regional stakeholders gather at large, public consultations to give suggestions and recommendations that are then shared at the Union Peace Conference, also called the 21st Century Panglong.

The NMSP said it had to cancel five preliminary public meetings across Mon State on March 10 after the Myanmar Army, or Tatmadaw, refused to allow more than 30 people join each event.

"The military didn't want more than 30 people at each of those places. If it is a public meeting, there must be public participation. Without the participation of the public, it is meaningless," said Nai Win Hla, a member of the NMSP’s central executive committee.

On March 12, MNTV reported that Peace Commission Secretary U Khin Zaw Oo said the commission and Tatmadaw had reached an agreement to let the NMSP hold its public meetings.

Nai Win Hla, however, told The Irrawaddy that the party had yet to receive a reply from either the National Reconciliation and Peace Center or the Peace Commission.

The Irrawaddy was unable to reach U Khin Zaw Oo for comment.

In recent months the Tatmadaw also blocked efforts by the Restoration Council of Shan State to hold similar meetings for ethnic Shan.

The NMSP says it still plans to hold its national-level dialogue on April 6-9 in Mon State's Ye Township and is asking the union government for permission to hold the smaller preliminary meetings with as many guests as it wants.

The 21st Century Panglong is scheduled for May in the administrative capital of Naypyitaw.

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post Mon Party Still Struggling to Hold Public Meetings Even After Ceasefire Deal appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

AirAsia in Talks to Set Up Myanmar Airline

Posted: 19 Mar 2018 10:32 PM PDT

HONG KONG — Tony Fernandes' AirAsia Bhd is in talks with a potential partner to open an airline serving Myanmar, in a move that would help the low-cost carrier cover up to 95 percent of the Southeast Asian travel market.

In an interview with Reuters on Monday, the airline's group chief executive said he also expected AirAsia's Vietnam joint venture to be flying by October.

AirAsia now has businesses in Malaysia — its home — along with India, Indonesia, the Philippines, Japan and Thailand, as well as plans to launch an airline in China.

"Once you've covered Vietnam and Myanmar, you've got all the big [Southeast Asian] populations," Fernandes said. "Vietnam, we're talking about October. We've had great support from the Vietnam government and we have a great partner. My team is very bullish."

A number of companies have also been looking at Myanmar for its policy of slowly opening to foreign investment and its rapid economic growth, although Japan's ANA Holdings Inc. last year dropped a plan to form an airline with local partner Golden Sky World after authorities rejected their application.

"It's not going to be a big airline there, because the airport infrastructure is not there. But it is 50 million people and it will develop over time," said Fernandes, who was in Sydney over the weekend for the meeting of the 10-member Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN).

He added: "We had a good meeting with someone in Sydney. He's got a good airline that we've known for a long time and he is a well-respected guy. We're going through that process."

He did not name the potential partner.

The comments come as AirAsia is emerging from a period of turbulence after it was beset by fears it had over-extended itself, triggering an extended fall in its shares. The airline also had to deal with the fatal crash of an Indonesian flight in 2014 that killed 162 people.

More recently, AirAsia has pursued an "asset light" model, forming a joint venture for its Singapore and Malaysian ground-handling operations and this month selling its leasing business in a staged process that will ultimately see 182 planes pass to established leasing portfolio manager BBAM Ltd.

Fernandes was in Hong Kong for the launch of what he has termed a "We're more than an airline" pitch, which he was due to present to analysts and investors at Credit Suisse's Asia Investment Conference.

AirAsia has been moving rapidly to launch additional services for its 80 million-plus customers, from financial offerings, including foreign exchange, to e-commerce and content.

"The biggest asset is our data," Fernandes said. "While Southeast Asian companies like Grab have to go out and spend a fortune to build that brand and data, we have 89 million customers travelling with us every year and we have data going back 18 years.

"We're more than an airline. That's the message for 2018, [like] Amazon is more than a bookseller."

The post AirAsia in Talks to Set Up Myanmar Airline appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Ten Things to Do in Yangon This Week

Posted: 19 Mar 2018 10:06 PM PDT

'90s Rock Legends | March 24

Zaw Win Htut, J Maung Maung, and Chit Kaung, all celebrated singers from the 1990s, will perform.

March 24, 7 p.m. Thuwunna Bhumi Event Park, Thuwunna Tsp. Tickets 9,000 to 50,000 kyats, Mann Thiri Recording.

 

Academy Award Presentation | March 23

Myanmar Academy Awards presentation ceremony will be broadcast live on MRTV 4, Channel 7 and Sky Net channels.

March 23, 3 p.m. Myanmar Event Park, Mayangone Tsp.

 

International Marionette Festival | March 25

Event features puppet shows from India, Japan, Australia, Israel, Thailand, France, US and Indonesia.

March 25, 7 p.m. National Museum, Myoma Kyaung Street. Free Admission.

 

Idiots x Youk $hi | March 24

The music band Idiots will perform.

March 24, 7 p.m. to 10 p.m. Hard Rock Café, 4thfloor, Myanmar Plaza, Tickets start from 15,000 kyats, Tel: 09-977009157

 

One1ness Fashion Show | March 25

Charity fashion show aims to raise funds for displaced persons in Kachin and Shan states.

March 25, 6 p.m. Taw Win Garden Hotel, Tickets start from 10,000 kyats.

 

Seikku Cho Cho Book Sale | March 17-25

The publishing house offers 10 to 40 percent discounts on all of its books.

March 17-25, Seikku Cho Cho book shops in Yangon and Mandalay.

 

Flower, Pet Show and Contest | March 23-27

There will be 16 pavilions and more than 30 shops selling flowers, pets and related goods.

March 23-27, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Kandawgyi.

 

The Less, The More | March 24-28

Artist Maung Theid Dhi will showcase his latest creations.

March 24-28, Ahla Thit Art Gallery, No. 17, University Road, Bahan Tsp.

 

Five Friends Together | March 24-27

Exhibition will showcase the work of five young artists.

March 24-27, 43 Art Gallery, 43rd Street, Botahtaung Tsp.

Group Art Exhibition | March 24-28

Seven artists will display paintings depicting the landscapes and culture of Karen State.

March 24-28. Hninzi Myaing Art Gallery, Hninzigon Home for the Aged.

The post Ten Things to Do in Yangon This Week appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Australia PM Meets Daw Aung San Suu Kyi to Raise Human Rights Concerns

Posted: 19 Mar 2018 09:45 PM PDT

SYDNEY — State Counselor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi arrived in Canberra on Monday to be met by a military honor guard and Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull, who has said he will raise human rights issues during her visit.

Aung San Suu Kyi has been in Australia since Friday, attending a special summit of Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) leaders in Sydney, where her presence drew street protests and a lawsuit accusing her of crimes against humanity.

Australia’s Attorney General has said he would not allow the lawsuit, lodged by activist lawyers in Melbourne on behalf of Australia’s Rohingya community, to proceed because Aung San Suu Kyi had diplomatic immunity.

Since coming to power in 2016, Aung San Suu Kyi, who won the 1991 Nobel Peace Prize for her struggle for democracy in Myanmar, has faced growing criticism for failing to condemn or stop military attacks on her country’s minority Rohingya Muslims.

UN officials say nearly 700,000 Muslim Rohingya have fled Buddhist-majority Myanmar to Bangladesh after militant attacks on Aug. 25 last year sparked a crackdown, led by security forces, in Rakhine State that the United Nations and United States have said constitutes ethnic cleansing.

The UN independent investigator on human rights in Myanmar, Yanghee Lee, said in Geneva this month she saw growing evidence to suspect genocide had been committed.

Myanmar denies the charges and has asked for “clear evidence” of abuses by security forces.

Neither Aung San Suu Kyi nor Malcolm Turnbull made public remarks before their meeting, but the Australian leader said on Sunday that Aung San Suu Kyi spoke “at considerable length” during the ASEAN meeting about Rakhine State, appealing to her Southeast Asian neighbors for humanitarian help.

Aung San Suu Kyi had been scheduled to give a speech and answer questions at a foreign policy think-tank event in Sydney on Tuesday but cancelled because she was not feeling well, event organizers said, without giving more details.

Aung San Suu Kyi’s spokesman, Zaw Htay, declined comment and referred questions to the Myanmar Embassy in Canberra. A Reuters call to the embassy went unanswered.

The post Australia PM Meets Daw Aung San Suu Kyi to Raise Human Rights Concerns appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Myanmar is Worst-performing Country for Aid Access, as Rohingya Refugees Face Monsoon Threats

Posted: 19 Mar 2018 09:40 PM PDT

Myanmar tops a list of countries where the ability of aid groups to reach people in need has worsened in the past six months, the Geneva-based research group ACAPS has said.

In examining 37 countries, ACAPS analysts considered nine indicators, including violence against humanitarian workers and restrictions preventing people from reaching aid.

“Myanmar is the country where humanitarian access has deteriorated the most, as access for the Rohingya population has become increasingly difficult,” the group said in a statement.

The ACAPS report preceded another released Tuesday by a British parliamentary committee, which warned floods and disease could kill thousands of Rohingya refugees in camps in neighboring Bangladesh.

The chair of the International Development Committee, Stephen Twigg, said in a statement that time was running out, adding that donors "must work with the Bangladesh government."

“Substantial numbers of refugees are about to face another crisis. With the weather about to turn, the fragile safety and sanctuary that the Rohingya have found in temporary camps provided by Bangladesh is in jeopardy,” Twigg said.

United Nations’ officials say nearly 700,000 Muslim Rohingya have fled Buddhist-majority Myanmar to Bangladesh.

That came after militant attacks in August sparked a crackdown, led by security forces, in Rakhine State that the UN and United States have said constitutes ethnic cleansing.

Myanmar has repeatedly denied reports implicating soldiers in widespread abuses of Rohingya civilians, particularly in Maungdaw, a border district in western Rakhine State.

Although the Myanmar government had allowed some groups to access the district, it was "in a short-term and unpredictable manner," said Pierre Peron, a spokesman for the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) in Myanmar.

“Most humanitarian organizations that had been working in Maungdaw District for years have still not been able to resume life-saving programs for some of the most vulnerable people in the world,” he told the Thomson Reuters Foundation via email.

A Myanmar government spokesman was unavailable for comment.

The British parliamentary committee said the situation for Rohingya would likely worsen, with heavy rains expected to begin within days, followed by the cyclone season.

“Severe weather conditions and heavy rainfall could result in the deaths of thousands of Rohingya,” the IDC said.

The committee warned that the camps in Bangladesh are ill-equipped to withstand the 2.5 meters of heaviest rains predicted to fall from June through August. The camps were built quickly, with shelters in places prone to landslides and flooding.

Poor sanitation, as well as a low vaccination rate among Rohingya who had limited access to healthcare in Myanmar, meant flooding would likely bring disease, the IDC said.

ACAPS said humanitarian access had also deteriorated in Cameroon, Ethiopia, Libya, Mali, Pakistan and Turkey.

The post Myanmar is Worst-performing Country for Aid Access, as Rohingya Refugees Face Monsoon Threats appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

India Most Vulnerable Country to Climate Change: HSBC Report

Posted: 19 Mar 2018 09:33 PM PDT

LONDON — India is the most vulnerable country to climate change, followed by Pakistan, the Philippines and Bangladesh, a ranking by HSBC showed on Monday.

The bank assessed 67 developed, emerging and frontier markets on vulnerability to the physical impacts of climate change, sensitivity to extreme weather events, exposure to energy transition risks and ability to respond to climate change.

The 67 nations represent almost a third of the world's nation states, 80 percent of the global population and 94 percent of global gross domestic product.

HSBC averaged the scores in each area for the countries in order to reach the overall ranking. Some countries were highly vulnerable in some areas but less so in others.

Of the four nations assessed by HSBC to be most vulnerable, India has said climate change could cut agricultural incomes, particularly unirrigated areas that would be hit hardest by rising temperatures and declines in rainfall.

Pakistan, Bangladesh and the Philippines are susceptible to extreme weather events, such as storms and flooding.

Pakistan was ranked by HSBC among nations least well-equipped to respond to climate risks.

South and Southeast Asian countries accounted for half of the 10 most vulnerable countries. Oman, Sri Lanka, Colombia, Mexico, Kenya and South Africa are also in this group.

The five countries least vulnerable to climate change risk are Finland, Sweden, Norway, Estonia and New Zealand.

In its last ranking in 2016, HSBC only assessed G20 countries for vulnerability to climate risk.

The post India Most Vulnerable Country to Climate Change: HSBC Report appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

KNU Vice Chair Hopes Talks Can End Latest Standoff with Tatmadaw

Posted: 19 Mar 2018 06:30 PM PDT

Military tensions have been running high in Karen State's Hpapun District since March 5, after Myanmar army, or Tatmadaw, troops allegedly tried to repair a road in Lu Thaw Township — an area controlled by Karen National Liberation Army (KNLA) Brigade 5 — and sparked a fresh round of fighting.

More than 2,000 local residents have since fled their homes.

On March 8, Brigade 5 sent a letter to the union-level Joint Monitoring Committee (JMC) to complain about the Tatmadaw Southern Command's deployment of troops in KNLA-controlled territory to resume construction of the road.

On March 16, the ethnic armed group’s political wing, the Karen National Union (KNU), said in a statement that it viewed the Tatmadaw's work on the road a violation of the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement (NCA) and called on the Tatmadaw to withdraw its troops.

Padoh Saw Kwel Htoo Win, the KNU’s vice chairman, spoke to The Irrawaddy's Kyaw Kha about the military tensions between the KNU and Tatmadaw in the area and about clashes between the KNU and New Mon State Party (NMSP).

What is the latest development in the clashes between the KNU and Tatmadaw?

In March, Tatmadaw troops entered our controlled areas. According to our intelligence, they were around 600 troops. Prior to that, the Tatmadaw asked KNU Brigade 5 to let them rebuild that road. They said they would use the road to deliver food supplies.

We agree with the delivery of food supplies because it is stated in the NCA. But because of the limited level of trust and the concerns of local people, Brigade 5 asked them to use only horses and manpower. However, the Tatmadaw deployed more troops and we had to fire shots as a warning or sign of complaint. It was not a real clash.

The Tatmadaw also opened fire when they saw our villagers, who came back to their villages for foods after fleeing the shooting. Though it was not a serious clash, there were two or three exchanges of fire a day until around March 10.

But the Tatmadaw continued rebuilding the road, which we don't accept. We've asked them to withdraw until we have reached an agreement.

So how is the negotiation going?

We have not yet spoken in person, but we are trying to arrange it. We have told them over the phone not to conduct military operations. We won't do military operations, either, but we have to prepare to protect ourselves.

In its statement, the KNU said the Tatmadaw's deployment of troops violates the NCA and that it can't accept it. What do you mean by “violation” and “unacceptable?”

They built the road alignment even before we signed a bilateral agreement and the NCA [with the government]. At that time, we were still clashing with the Tatmadaw and parts of the road alignment were destroyed in the fighting. [The Tatmadaw] aborted construction of the road around 2008. It was no longer used.

After we signed the NCA with the government, local residents started returning to their villages and resumed farming. But they still don't have trust [in the Tatmadaw], and although the military didn't say its deployment of troops was for military operations, both we and locals have concerns.

According to the NCA, the Tatmadaw and the NCA signatories need prior approval to go into each other's territories. But they entered our controlled area while we were still negotiating about it. This is a violation of the NCA.

Will this have a negative impact on the NCA process?

As we said in the statement, we'll negotiate based on the NCA. It is the fault of the group that doesn't follow the NCA. We will, however, make sure they follow the NCA. We don't want the NCA to break.

Are there different views within the KNU about the clashes with the Tatmadaw?

We acted according to the opinion of the highest-ranking officials of the brigade. They agreed to solve conflicts through negotiation, and we will act according to that policy. We will check if the army deployed its troops because of instructions from upper levels or if the troops at the lower level acted on their own because of logistical requirements. For our part, we are defending ourselves.

We heard that over 2,000 locals have fled the recent fighting between the Tatmadaw and KNU. What will the KNU do for them?

People here are honest and live a simple life. They returned to those areas not long ago. They just came back after we signed the NCA, and now they had to flee again. The weather was cold there, and it has negatively affected their health, especially the elderly and children.

As I've said, they have left behind foods in their villages. As military troops came in suddenly, they only took as much as they could and hid in the forest. They are concerned that they will be shot if they come back to take their food. There are health problems, and school children could not sit their exams as now is exam time. For the time being, district and township authorities are helping them. Humanitarian bodies of the KNU will also help them.

Has the KNU asked President U Htin Kyaw, State Counselor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and Senior General Min Aung Hlaing to help solve the problem?

We'll try for negotiation, as we said in our statement. For the time being, we are planning to negotiate with the local battalion of the military. It will depend on to what extent we can build understanding. The level of trust is already low, and the fact that [the military] has done this [deployed troops to rebuild the road] has further undermined the trust we and the people have in them.

The statement said that there was a misunderstanding of even the basic idea of national-level political dialogue in the NCA process. Can you explain?

It is a problem that public consultations are not allowed to be held freely in the areas of some [NCA] signatories. This shows that we have different views about national-level political dialogue and therefore need negotiation.

What does the statement mean in stating that there is a need to coordinate deployment and the JMC?

What the JMC needs to monitor is whether the two sides follow or breach the bilateral agreements. But there is still no bilateral agreement, and we therefore said that JMC monitoring is unrealistic.

Will the conflict between the Tatmadaw and KNU hamper the signing of the NCA by NCA non-signatories?

Though they have not ceased fire, they maintain contact with the military. For NCA signatories, there is hardly any shooting now compared to the past. Skirmishes will still happen.

We need to build trust for the guns to fall silent. If one side violates, there may be shooting. But not every shot results in a clash, and not every clash leads to war.

We heard that there have been at least three clashes between the KNU and NMSP. What is the latest development?

The Brigade 6 district chairman and those responsible with the NMSP met and decided to hold frequent talks. They agreed to solve the problems through dialogue rather than armed fighting.

There are concerns that conflict between the KNU and NMSP may escalate. What will the leaders of the two sides do to avoid that?

We've formed joint committees in adjacent areas. But we have to make sure those committees are active. Different views exist anywhere. There are different views even in a family. Our territories are adjacent to the NMSP's and there are differing views in some cases. Leaders will make sure not to resort to violent methods whenever problems arise.

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post KNU Vice Chair Hopes Talks Can End Latest Standoff with Tatmadaw appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Monday, March 19, 2018

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Hpakant Landslides Continue to Kill

Posted: 19 Mar 2018 04:28 AM PDT

CHIANG MAI, Thailand — At least four jade prospectors have been killed and dozens are reportedly missing after a waste pile collapsed in jade-rich Hpakant on Friday night.

The collapse happened around 10:45 p.m., while prospectors searched the mining waste for gems.

It is the same location where deadly landslides happened in November 2015, claiming more than 100 lives.

Seik Mu village tract local U Shwe Thein told The Irrawaddy on Monday that four bodies were found on Saturday and that two injured men were being treated at the Hpakant Hospital.

The death toll estimated by locals at the Kan Kham jade mines in La Maung village of Seik Mu village tract, Lone Khin, is more than 40, U Shwe Thein said, but the search for bodies is likely to halt due to bad weather and the risk of further collapse in the area. Two bulldozers from a company called Kyauk Sein Taung were also buried in the collapse but later removed.

"There is a risk of further collapse. There were strong winds and rain on Sunday and authorities and elders at an emergency meeting advised that the search should be halted to avoid further loss [thought it resumed on Monday]," he said.

The Lone Khin police officer on duty told The Irrawaddy that four people were currently thought to be missing with the search ongoing.

Ko Khun Aung, a Hpakant resident, said a search was carried out over the weekend with at least five bulldozers combing the area for bodies but to no avail.

Hpakant jade mines – controlled by Myanmar Army troops and companies backed by both the Myanmar Army and the Kachin Independence Army – are vulnerable to landslides at mining waste sites sometimes piled hundreds of feet high.

The landslides continue and searches often stop after a few days. Many bodies are believed to be left uncounted under the waste.

"It is because we don't have rule of law in the area, and the lives of prospectors who come from different parts of the country are not treated as valuable," said U Shwe Thein.

The post Hpakant Landslides Continue to Kill appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

UWSA Denies Reports It Plans To Sign NCA

Posted: 19 Mar 2018 04:04 AM PDT

The United Wa State Army (UWSA) has denied claims by a member of the government's Peace Commission that it planned to sign the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement (NCA) and accused him of trying to mislead the public.

The UWSA issued a statement on March 15 saying that contrary to comments by U Aung Soe, it had never accepted the nationwide ceasefire, and was not ready to sign the NCA. This followed comments by U Aung Soe reported in some Burmese-language media that the UWSA had agreed to sign the ceasefire agreement.

"His statement was specious and we suspect it was made to deliberately confuse the public. This was very irresponsible and confuses fact and fiction. It has caused unnecessary disruption to the peace process in Myanmar, which already has problems," the UWSA said.

Democratic Voice of Burma and the Yangon-based News Watch both reported that the UWSA had agreed to sign the NCA, based on an interview with U Aung Soe on March 14. However, when other news media followed up on the story, it emerged that his claim was untrue. The actual story was that the government Peace Commission and the UWSA were meeting as part of the regular peace process.

The UWSA, NLD-led government and Myanmar military (Tatmadaw) have differing views on how to proceed over the NCA. The UWSA was not involved in discussing the draft of the agreement. Nonetheless, both the former and current governments have pressured the group to sign.

The UWSA wants to sign alongside other ethnic armed groups who are fellow members of the Northern Alliance: the Ta'ang National Liberation Army (TNLA), Kachin Independence Army, Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army (MNDAA), Arakan Army (AA) and Shan State Progress Party.

"A dialogue is needed to overcome this major difference of views. The three parties must be involved, and the channels of communication between the three must also be unimpeded, but this dialogue does not mean that the UWSA has accepted the NCA," the statement reads.

The UWSA has said it would sign the NCA only if the government and military allowed amendments to parts of the agreement relating specifically to its region. The current draft NCA is not suitable, according to the UWSA, which seeks an autonomous region that would be different in nature from those run by other ethnic armed groups.

The UWSA remains firmly opposed to some of the terms of the NCA.

"Making efforts to promote peace in Myanmar is the consistent position of Wa State. Force and war are not the priority options for Wa State," the ethnic armed group said.

The UWSA signed a ceasefire agreement with the Burmese government in 1989, and has not engaged in fighting with the Tatmadaw since then. The region has experienced some development thanks to border trade with China. The UWSA has at least 40,000 troops, making it the largest ethnic armed group in Myanmar.

The UWSA has tried to lead the Federal Political Negotiation and Consultation Committee (FNPCC) into peace talks with the government and Tatmadaw, but the latter refuses to include the TNLA, AA, and MNDAA in the peace process. Fighting between the Tatmadaw and Northern Alliance members has erupted in areas near UWSA-controlled parts of northern Shan State. This has caused concern within the UWSA that the Tatmadaw will attack it as well.

Commenting on the UWSA's response to U Aung Soe, some Burmese peace process observers said it could be intended to placate the other ethnic armed groups in the alliance. The Northern Alliance members have agreed that they will only sign the NCA as a block.

The post UWSA Denies Reports It Plans To Sign NCA appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Police Hand Over Fatal Crash Case Involving Army Driver to the Military

Posted: 19 Mar 2018 03:18 AM PDT

NAYPYITAW — Police have handed over to the army an investigation into a fatal crash in which a journalist was hit by a car driven by a military officer.

U Tin Lin, a senior reporter at The Voice Journal, was killed instantly as he rode his motorcycle near the Naypyitaw Central Railway Station in Pobbathiri Township in the administrative capital after being hit from behind by a car driven by an army major at around 10:30 p.m. on Saturday.

"We have investigated the case, and handed it over to the concerned battalion as [the offender] is an army official," said police lieutenant Thaung Htike Oo of the Pobbathiri Township police station.

U Tin Lin lived alone in Pobbathiri Township, away from his family in Yangon. He had worked as a reporter for more than 15 years.

In the 2010 general election, he had unsuccessfully contested a Lower House seat for the National Democratic Force (NDF) representing his hometown in Yangon's Kungyangon Township.

"We will bring the body to back to Kungyangon Township and organize his funeral. And the rest [lawsuit against the army officer] is up to his family," Ko Aung Soe, executive editor of The Voice, told The Irrawaddy.

The driver, who was identified as Major Kaung Htoo Lwin from the Health and Disease Control Unit in Zayarthiri Township, was sent to the 1,000-bed No. 2 Military Hospital to undergo a blood alcohol test to check if he was drunk while driving, but the result is still unknown, lieutenant Thaung Htike Oo said.

Kyi Taung Kan police station in Pobbathiri Township has opened a case against Maj Kaung Htoo Lwin for reckless driving and causing death.

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post Police Hand Over Fatal Crash Case Involving Army Driver to the Military appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

New Air Force Chief Has Risen Rapidly Through the Ranks

Posted: 19 Mar 2018 03:12 AM PDT

The leadership of Myanmar's military, the Tatmadaw, has seen frequent reshuffles in recent years, with more new blood and new faces being injected into the top ranks.

One of them is General Maung Maung Kyaw, who became the new commander-in-chief of the air force in January. Gen Maung Maung Kyaw replaced General Khin Aung Myint, who retired from the post.

In January, soon after his appointment, Gen Maung Maung Kyaw accompanied Senior-General Min Aung Hlaing, commander-in-chief of the Tatmadaw, in paying a courtesy call on President U Htin Kyaw. He worked closely with Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing on last month's military drills on Hsinbyushin Island in the Irrawaddy Delta, the largest since 1997.

Gen Maung Maung Kyaw is widely tipped by defense analysts in Myanmar to be a likely candidate to move into an even more senior role eventually.

He is seen as close to Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing and is known to be a capable and experienced air force officer.

Gen Maung Maung Kyaw's background also seems solid. He is the youngest son of General Kyaw Htin, who served as commander-in-chief of the armed forces in the 1980s.

Kyaw Htin was close to former dictator Gen Ne Win. He joined the army in the 1940s and fought against the Japanese in World War II. Raised in Pyay, Kyaw Htin in his early days served in the famous 4th Burma Rifles, which was regarded as Ne Win's most trusted and favored regiment. Many officers from the 4th Burma Rifles rose rapidly through the ranks of both Ne Win's socialist government and the armed forces after Ne Win staged a coup in 1962.

Kyaw Htin resigned from the top army post in 1985 but continued to serve in the Burma Socialist Program Party until 1988 as deputy prime minister. He resigned along with Ne Win and died in 1996 at the age of 70.

His eldest son U Thant Kyaw served as deputy foreign minister in former President U Thein Sein's administration.

Maung Maung Kyaw has been steadily promoted through the ranks to become Air Force chief. Previously, he served as commander of the Meikhtila Air Force headquarters. As Myanmar's Air Force is planning to expand and upgrade its capabilities and capacity in coordination with the army and navy, Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing saw Gen Maung Maung Kyaw's potential.

Maung Maung Kyaw also accompanied the senior-general on overseas trips in 2017. They visited Israel together in 2015.

In 2017, observers noted that Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing, who is known to have political ambitions, appointed several new commanders to the top ranks.

Major-General Myo Zaw Thein, who served as chief of the Yangon Command, was promoted to lieutenant-general and became head of the military's Bureau of Special Operations 5 (BSO-5). He is the youngest among the heads of the BSO.

Lt-Gen Moe Myint Tun, former commander of BSO-5, became army chief of staff and Maj-Gen Myint Maw became head of the Naypyitaw Command. He previously served as principal of the Defense Services Academy in Pyin Oo Lwin.

The post New Air Force Chief Has Risen Rapidly Through the Ranks appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Heart of an Artist Showcased at National Museum

Posted: 19 Mar 2018 03:06 AM PDT

YANGON — Min Kyi left this world some 10 years ago. When the inevitable happened, the artist left behind his hearts, which now hang at the National Museum in Yangon. Those hearts are not made of blood or vessels, but with paint and brushwork.

Whenever he had to sell his paintings for money, Min Kyi told his family: "I had to pull my heart out to feed you."

Those hearts now fill the hall of the National Museum for the exhibition 'Min Kyi's Retrospective.' Min Kyi was known for his brilliant depiction of rural Myanmar culture and landscapes.

He quit working as a civil servant, losing his steady income and choosing to eke out a living as a full-time artist. Though his paintings were popular, he hated selling them and tried to hold on to as many as he could. Unfortunately, he lost some 300 paintings when his house caught fire.

Johnny Wuke Kah Pok, a Singaporean art collector, was able to collect more than 600 of Min Kyi's paintings, which he is showcasing at the exhibition.

"I fell in love when I saw his paintings at the Traders Hotel. So, I asked for his address and went to his home and purchased all of his paintings," said Pok.

The art exhibition at the National Museum commemorates the 10th anniversary of Min Kyi's death. Paintings will not be sold, but visitors will be presented with books featuring photos of more than 150 of his works. The exhibition will be held through this month.

"I will showcase his paintings in France in 2019. He struggled, and dedicated his life to his art. He deserves a place in the art history of Asia," said Pok.

The post Heart of an Artist Showcased at National Museum appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Naypyitaw Council Member Dismissed Over Corruption Scandal

Posted: 19 Mar 2018 01:34 AM PDT

NAYPYITAW — The Myanmar government has removed a member of the Naypyitaw Council, an executive body under the direct control of the president that administers the Naypyitaw Union Territory, over a corruption scandal.

"He was sacked because of a scandal. He was mainly responsible for tenders and projects, as well as reporting to Parliament [about the projects]," a member of the Naypyitaw municipality told The Irrawaddy on condition of anonymity.

The President's Office released a notice on March 15 stating that Naypyitaw Council member U Tin Htut was dismissed according to the 2008 Constitution, Union Government Law, and Naypyitaw Council Law. But the notice did not explain the reason for the dismissal.

U Tin Htut is the highest-ranking official to be dismissed in Naypyitaw under the National League for Democracy (NLD) government. In January 2018, U Myo Tint, a former military officer, also resigned from the Naypyitaw municipality.

"U Myo Tint was asked whether he wanted to resign or be dismissed. There was a lot of evidence of corruption against him. He could not deny it. U Tin Htut denied the corruption allegations. So, he was sacked," said the municipal official who asked for anonymity.

U Tin Htut did not know of his dismissal in advance, said U Myo Thant, a personal staff officer of U Tin Htut.

U Tin Htut is not an NLD member. He resigned as an assistant secretary of the Ministry of Energy in 2015 and was assigned to the Naypyitaw Council in 2016, the staff officer said.

Some lawmakers in the Naypyitaw Council area said that U Tin Htut was too close to businessmen and that his close relationships had led to a bribery scandal.

Lower House lawmaker U Kyaw Tint from Tatkon Township in the Naypyitaw Union Territory said he had worked with U Tint Htut, who was responsible for his constituency, and witnessed both his strong and weak points.

"I checked and balanced him as his actions could have undermined the image of the government. As a colleague, I gave him brotherly advice in some cases. I would say he was sacked because of some weakness in his actions," U Kyaw Tint told The Irrawaddy.

"He was dismissed because he could not perform his duties well," said an Upper House lawmaker on condition of anonymity who declined to elaborate.

U Tin Htut had switched off his mobile phone at the time of reporting this story. The NLD-government also fired two municipal officers who were sued under the 2013 Anti-Corruption Law for taking bribes from butchers in October 2017. The two are still facing trial at the Mandalay Region high court.

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post Naypyitaw Council Member Dismissed Over Corruption Scandal appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

11 Arrested After Mob Attacks Police to Demand Rape Suspect’s Handover

Posted: 19 Mar 2018 12:39 AM PDT

MANDALAY — Police in Mandalay Region’s Aungmyaythazan Township said they arrested 11 people on Sunday accused of joining a mob that attacked a police station holding a suspected child rapist arrested earlier in the day.

"When the crowd got bigger, the police blocked the road to the police station. Some angry men destroyed the bamboo barriers and started shouting to the police to hand over the rapist," said U Paw Lu, a township administrator.

"Later they threw stones and bricks at the police who tried to dispersed the crowd by opening fire into the air to scare them away," he added.

Police say they arrested 11 of the rioters and have filed related charges against them.

Earlier in the day, police arrested Kyaw Soe, 38, for the rape of a 7-year-old girl in Aungmyaythazan Township’s Amarahtarni quarter on Thursday. According to a neighbor, Daw Khin Khin, the girl complained of pain and bleeding to her mother on Sunday and was rushed to a doctor who discovered that she had been raped.

"The girl told her mother only on Sunday afternoon and police arrested him. We are waiting here to find out how the police will charge him. We want the death sentence for rapists like him," she said in front of the police station.

Police said they filed a rape charge against Kyaw Soe and were keeping him in custody.

Coincidentally, a campaign group advocating for tougher penalties for rapists had visited Amarahtarni on Sunday. The national campaign has picked up steam following a number of child rape and rape-murder cases in recent months.

In February, a 2-year-old girl was raped and murdered in Mandalay’s Madaya Township by a 23-year-old man. Locals staged a protest to urge authorities to sentence the man to death.

The post 11 Arrested After Mob Attacks Police to Demand Rape Suspect’s Handover appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Aung San Suu Kyi Spoke at Length About Myanmar Troubles: Turnbull

Posted: 18 Mar 2018 09:38 PM PDT

SYDNEY — Myanmar leader Aung San Suu Kyi spoke at length about her country’s troubled western state of Rakhine at a Sydney conference on Sunday and appealed to Southeast Asian neighbors for help, Australia’s prime minister said.

“We discussed the situation in Rakhine state at considerable length today,” Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull told reporters at the end of a summit of Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) and Australia, much of it held behind closed doors.

“Daw Aung San Suu Kyi addressed the matter comprehensively at some considerable length herself… She seeks support from ASEAN and other nations to provide help from a humanitarian and capacity-building point of view,” he said, using a Burmese honorific.

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi’s spokesman, Zaw Htay, was not immediately available for comment on Turnbull’s comments.

Turnbull did not tell reporters whether Suu Kyi gave details of what support she was seeking or whether she spoke specifically about violence against the Rohingya, however ASEAN’s Coordinating Centre for Humanitarian Assistance has been providing some aid since October.

UN officials say nearly 700,000 Muslim Rohingya have fled Buddhist-majority Myanmar to Bangladesh after militant attacks on Aug. 25 last year sparked a crackdown, led by security forces, in Rakhine that the United Nations and United States have said constitutes ethnic cleansing.

The UN independent investigator on human rights in Myanmar, Yanghee Lee, said in Geneva this month she saw growing evidence to suspect genocide had been committed.

Myanmar denies the charges and has asked for “clear evidence” of abuses by security forces.

Since coming to power in 2016, Daw Aung San Suu Kyi – who won the 1991 Nobel Peace Prize for her struggle for democracy – has failed to condemn the violence against the Rohingya.

Australia’s attorney general on Saturday rejected a private bid by activist lawyers to have Suu Kyi face charges for crimes against humanity, saying she has diplomatic immunity.

In response to questions posed by Reuters about the lawyers’ move, Suu Kyi spokesman Zaw Htay said earlier in the day such “pressure” was unhelpful in solving the conflict in Rakhine, which he called “the Bengali problem” – using a term to describe the Rohingya that suggests they are interlopers from Bangladesh.

Militants from the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) had instigated the violence with attacks on government forces in October 2016 and August 2017, said Zaw Htay, director general at the State Counselor’s Office in Myanmar’s capital, Naypyitaw.

“All of this happened because of ARSA. The government did nothing,” he said in response to a question about the legal move.

“Those who are putting pressure like this need to be careful that doesn’t become encouraging terrorists.”

Singaporean Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong said it was a “complex inter-communal situation” which ASEAN leaders would continue to discuss "frankly."

“It’s an issue which is also in the public attention and it’s one of those where intense public attention sometimes makes it more difficult to solve,” he added.

Suu Kyi’s attendance at the ASEAN summit, hosted by Australia despite it not being a member of the 10-nation bloc, drew street protests in Sydney on Saturday.

The post Aung San Suu Kyi Spoke at Length About Myanmar Troubles: Turnbull appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Australia AG Rejects Lawyers’ Bid to Prosecute Daw Aung San Suu Kyi

Posted: 18 Mar 2018 09:32 PM PDT

SYDNEY — Australia’s attorney general said that Myanmar leader Daw Aung San Suu Kyi has diplomatic immunity, rejecting a bid by activist lawyers to have her face charges for crimes against humanity over the country’s treatment of minority Rohingya Muslims.

Lawyer Alison Battisson said she filed the private prosecution on behalf of Australia’s Rohingya community on Friday in Melbourne Magistrates Court and had not had a formal response from Attorney General Christian Porter.

“As it is an ongoing matter that’s about all I can say,” she told Reuters by phone.

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi’s spokesman, Zaw Htay, said on Sunday such “pressure” was unhelpful in solving the conflict in the troubled western state of Rakhine, which he called "the Bengali problem."

Many in Myanmar refer to the Rohingya as Bengalis and insist they are immigrants from Bangladesh.

Militants from the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) had instigated the violence with attacks on government forces in October 2016 and August 2017, said Zaw Htay.

“All of this happened because of ARSA. The government did nothing,” he said in response to a question about the legal move.

“Those who are putting pressure like this need to be careful that doesn’t become encouraging terrorists.”

According to UN officials, nearly 700,000 Rohingya fled Buddhist-majority Myanmar to Bangladesh after militant attacks on Aug. 25 last year sparked a crackdown led by security forces in Rakhine that the United Nations and United States have said constitute ethnic cleansing.

Myanmar denies the charge and has asked for “clear evidence” of abuses by security forces.

Porter said he would not allow the prosecution of Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, who arrived in Sydney on Saturday for regional talks, citing diplomatic immunity provisions, which protect foreign heads of state from being arrested, detained or served with court proceedings.

“Aung San Suu Kyi has complete immunity, including from being served with court documents, because under customary international law, heads of state, heads of government and ministers of foreign affairs are immune from foreign criminal proceedings and are inviolable,” Porter told Reuters by email.

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi is foreign affairs minister as well as state counselor.

The lawyers’ case argues that Suu Kyi “failed to use her position of authority and power” to prevent the “deportation” of Rohingya people from Myanmar, according to a statement emailed by Battisson.

Under the principle of universal jurisdiction, which is recognized in Australia, courts can try individuals suspected of crimes against humanity or war crimes regardless of where they were alleged to have been committed, although it requires the permission of the attorney general.

The legal action coincided with the start of Association of Southeast Asian Nations meetings in Sydney.

Australia hosted the meetings, despite not being a member of the 10-nation bloc, as it seeks to tighten political and trade ties in the region amid China’s rising influence.

Nobel Peace Prize laureate Suu Kyi’s invitation sparked protests, which included about 100 activists gathering on Saturday in Sydney’s Hyde Park where they chanted "Aung San Suu Kyi, shame on you."

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi spoke at length about Rakhine at a conference on Sunday and appealed to Southeast Asian neighbors for help, Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull said.

The post Australia AG Rejects Lawyers' Bid to Prosecute Daw Aung San Suu Kyi appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

China’s ‘Silver Fox’ Foreign Minister Promoted

Posted: 18 Mar 2018 09:24 PM PDT

BEIJING — Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi retained his job and was also promoted to a state councilor on Monday, meaning he now has the country’s two top diplomat roles, in a vote of confidence for his strong defense of China’s interests.

Sources had previously told Reuters that Wang would probably become a state councilor with responsibility for foreign affairs, and that he may also keep his job as foreign minister.

He has been likened to a “silver fox” in China’s state media, and online, for his looks and his staunch defense of Chinese positions, which has won him a loyal following. Foreign diplomats say he can be suave and charming, as well as tough.

Unusually friendly to the foreign media for a senior Chinese official, Wang has won plaudits in China for his tough line on issues like the disputed South China Sea and quick-witted – sometimes bad-tempered quips – to counter criticism of China.

Wang, 64, has been China’s foreign minister since 2013. A career diplomat and fluent Japanese speaker, Wang has also served as China’s ambassador in Tokyo and head of China’s policy-making Taiwan Affairs Office.

The country’s largely rubber stamp parliament approved Wang’s job in a mostly ceremonial vote in the Great Hall of the People with reporters present.

State councilors, who report to the Cabinet, are more senior than the ministers responsible for the same portfolio. While unusual, it is possible to be both a minister and state councilor at the same time.

It was not immediately clear what position former state councilor Yang Jiechi would get. Diplomatic sources said previously he may have become a vice premier, but his name was not included in the list for that position.

Yang still sits on the Communist Party’s Politburo, the second-largest of the party’s elite ruling bodies, meaning he will retain an influential voice in China’s foreign policy.

Previously China’s foreign minister himself, Yang speaks perfect English but has a low-key public profile and rarely talks to foreign reporters.

Yang has served as one of China’s main go-betweens with the Trump administration, with his deep knowledge of the United States coming from previous stints in the Chinese embassy in Washington, including as ambassador from 2000-2004.

Newly appointed Vice President Wang Qishan, a key ally of President Xi Jinping, is likely to have handling the Trump administration and festering trade tensions between the two countries as part of his job.

China also gets a new defense minister, Wei Fenghe, who already sits on the Central Military Commission, which runs China’s armed forces. Wei has been appointed to a state councilor as well.

The defense minister is more of a figurehead position, as real power rests with Xi and the Central Military Commission. Wei is the fourth-ranked member of that seven-man body.

The post China's 'Silver Fox' Foreign Minister Promoted appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Saturday, March 17, 2018

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


30 Years Since Myanmar’s Pro-democracy Uprising

Posted: 16 Mar 2018 08:33 PM PDT

Kyaw Zwa Moe: Welcome to Dateline Irrawaddy! For Myanmar, it is fair to say that March is the Month of Revolution. Taking a look back at history, Myanmar fought back fascist Japan on March 27, 1945. This revolution finally led to independence in 1948. Looking back to 1988, Ko Phone Maw, a student at RIT [Rangoon Institute of Technology], was shot and killed by riot police on March 13. On March 16 and 17, students staged protests on the campus of Rangoon University, which led to the 8888 [pro-democracy] popular uprising. That event will have its 30th anniversary this year. Ko Sanny and Ko Ye Naing Aung, also known as Ko Wa, who joined the student movement in March 1988, join me to discuss how far the student movements we initiated have come and the challenges we have encountered along the way. I'm Irrawaddy English editor Kyaw Zwa Moe.

30 Years Since Myanmar's Pro-democracy Uprising

DATELINE IRRAWADDY30 Years Since Myanmar's Pro-democracy UprisingThe Irrawaddy discusses achievements and challenges in that time with two veterans of the student and pro-democracy movements.

Posted by The Irrawaddy – English Edition on Friday, March 16, 2018

It has been 30 years. The Tiananmen Square incident, to make a comparison with neighboring countries, happened in 1989. In terms of the political freedoms in our country at present, I find that we are ahead of China in that regard. Ko Phone Maw died in March, and Ko Sanny, you joined the student protests on March 16 and 17. What did you do, and why?

Ko Sanny: We were students at that time, and I participated as a student in the protests. We got acquainted with RIT students during the banknote crisis [the government's demonetizing of banknotes without warning] in September 1987. We went to RIT after we learned about [the police shooting of Ko Phone Maw] on March 13. We lived in Insein [Township], and RIT was not far from us. RIT students had formed a committee and posted a notice [on the wall] listing their demands. One of the demands was [for the government] to reveal the truth since [the government] claimed that [Ko Phone Maw] died while fighting other students. They asked us to distribute the papers at other schools such as Rangoon University, Hlaing University, Kyimyindaing University and RC [regional college] 1. We Rangoon University students could not stand [the killing], and we felt that we should also join them. On March 14, we posted demand notices at universities.

KZM: So, you joined the protest because you could not put up with it. What were your other aims?

Sanny: We came to realize that the congress [of the Burma Socialist Program Party] was a rubber-stamp body; that the education system was not a good one; and that it was the outcome of the political system. We still didn't know the exact causes and effects, but understood that it was the result of a lack of political liberty. We wanted to change the political system. We felt sad about their suppression of students and their hiding the truth, so we decided to fight back.

KZM: So, it could be said that protests broke out because of people's dislike of single-party dictatorship, the poor education system, and economic hardship. Ko Wa, you were an RIT student then. How did you come to join the student protests in March?

Ko Wa: On March 14, 1988, the RIT incident spread to the campus of Hlaing University, which was then called Regional College (2). We saw crowds of students gathering at the university canteen. While we were sitting at a teashop of the canteen, someone fixed a paper to the bamboo pole near us. From the words on the paper, we guessed that the student movement had become an anti-government movement. So, we realized that this had become the very first place, in the more than 260,000 square miles of Myanmar's territory, to enjoy the democratic right of freedom of expression. Political repression was quite harsh at that time; we were not even allowed to form community-based religious groups to offer alms to monks or make criticisms during the rule of the Burma Socialist Program Party. To us, it was the moment that marked the transition from student movement to political movement. Students launched the movement not because they had strong political awareness, but because they felt that the injustices created by the political system would destroy the future of the country. At first, students living nearby or studying in the same class would gather; for example, in my case, I and with my friends wrote statements and fixed them on buses and distributed them to passers-by. Later, students in each community gathered across the country; it had become a popular revolution.

KZM: It has been 30 years now. Ko Sanny and Ko Wa, you were both imprisoned for years. Ko Wa was arrested two, three times. Ko Sanny spent eight, nine years in prison. Thirty years later, the one-party dictatorship has ended. And we now have an elected government and a certain degree of democracy. Are you satisfied with the situation today, given the sacrifices of the students?

Sanny: Frankly speaking, I am not satisfied. Compared with other [democratic] countries, ours is not yet a democratic country—I don't mean development and prosperity, but in terms of political liberty. Our expectation was to abolish the one-party system influenced by military dictatorship.

KZM: There is no longer such a system.

Sanny: Though there is no such system, they [the military] have officially taken seats in the Parliament. Furthermore, there is a considerable amount of unseen control [by the military]. So, I feel that our expectations have not yet been fulfilled, as there is still no open political system.

KZM: Ko Wa, do you think Ko Sanny's expectations are too unrealistic? Are you satisfied with what your sacrifices have achieved?

Ko Wa: Generally speaking, the country has not yet reached the goal I anticipated, but I am somewhat satisfied. Because, as I've said, there was only a bamboo's space of liberty in the past. At that time, the press censorship board imposed draconian censorship on the media, and it was therefore even dubbed as a press "kempeitai" [referring to the military police of the Japanese Army during World War II, known for its brutal torture of detainees]. Now, we can publish newspapers and journals freely.

KZM: Perhaps to a certain extent [there is press freedom].

Ko Wa: Yes, to a certain extent. There is no censorship board now and we are free to form, support and run civil society organizations. Compared to the situation then, we are enjoying things that we didn't dream of at that time. But comparing the current situation against the yardstick of genuine democratic norms and the fundamental rights of society, we are lagging far behind. For example, the 2008 Constitution must be amended. We don't like it. But the Constitution at least confirms the rights and entitlements of citizens. So, I'd say there has been some progress, but it is not yet satisfactory, and we have not reached our goal. But I believe we have a good foundation from which to move forward.

KZM: Since the death of Ko Phone Maw in 1988, we have demanded democracy as our political cause. The democracy we have achieved has never been a complete one. I mean we now enjoy a certain degree of democracy. The fact that we have an elected government is a sign of democracy. But this democracy is subject to restrictions, like the 2008 Constitution and other political controls. So, the democracy we have now is limited. There are problems such as establishing a ceasefire, achieving internal peace and the Constitution. Our country could be compared to a patient with a chronic illness. My question is, how much has our country recovered after 30 years, and what has yet to be healed?

Sanny: There has been a certain amount of progress as Ko Wa has mentioned. But problems remain. There was no 2008 Constitution in the past. It imposes a barrier for us. In the past, there was greater potential for political reforms because there was no 2008 Constitution. But while the 2008 Constitution provides fundamental rights for citizens, it has also become a new hurdle to us. We have Parliament now, but it is not yet strong, which is understandable. However, there are more complex issues now. For example, the issues we face today didn't exist before. Twenty years ago, there were no ultra-nationalists. There are radical forces now. What's more, we political forces were united in the past. There was a degree of unity among student activists and political parties, but that unity has gradually disappeared now. These are great obstacles for us.

KZM: We have entered a democratic transition period since Myanmar opened the door in 2011 under President U Thein Sein's government. In other words, Myanmar has been trying to recover, but has not yet fully recovered. In terms of the political system, there are obstacles like the Constitution. At the same time, there are disagreements. We have not yet even reached a ceasefire agreement to achieve internal peace. And there is still no equality and self-determination. So, there are many problems. At times like this, political and religious tolerance is important. Ko Wa, what steps can the current government take to promote such tolerance?

Ko Wa: Personally, I think the 2008 Constitution needs to be amended. I'm not satisfied with it, but it does provide fundamental rights. To answer your question, suffice it to say that our country is faced with countless problems in the economic, social, health and education sectors. Individuals, political parties and groups may have different views about how to handle those issues. But I think the government or a political party should take the lead role to design a national strategy to address all those issues together. I mean if we try to solve problems separately, we will never solve them. If we solve this problem, that problem arises. So, we need a comprehensive strategy to address those issues together. If we can make that happen through dialogue and negotiation, there are good opportunities for us to move forward, I'd say.

KZM: There are provisions that restrict liberty and don't meet democratic norms in the 2008 Constitution. So, this hampers democratic transition. The Tatmadaw [Myanmar's military] has traditionally played a role in politics because of the part it played in the country's history as well as the position it secured by creating the 2008 Constitution. If we don't consider these — the Tatmadaw did play a role in the country's history because it was formed before independence — but if we remove it from a political role, what will happen? Because some argue that Myanmar is not yet ready to enjoy complete democracy and complete liberty.

Sanny: Yes, the Tatmadaw played a role in the country's history. Tatmadaw leaders seized power in 1962, and they ruled the country for many years. So, they might feel that they are well versed in managing the country. At the same time, they might look down on civilians and politicians. And their low opinion of them didn't change even after the 2015 election. It has not changed much. After the NLD won the 1990 election, there was a call for dialogue. Dialogue means an open discussion between two sides—democratic forces and the military. There are third-party stakeholders, like ethnic groups. But, at first, there must be bilateral discussions. I think there is still no genuine dialogue between the two sides so far. The meetings and agreements so far are the result of personal ties between the two sides rather than the result of an open dialogue. This won't work, I believe. Our country didn't undergo a normative democratic transition. Both the Tatmadaw and the political forces, especially their leaders, are responsible for this. It is important that the democratic transition is transparent and meets norms. It is highly important that [agreements] are transparent and accurately documented in a transition. We still can't make that happen. And people are not informed by the authorities about their agreements. So, agreements which come as the outcome of personal ties are not good for the country as a whole. As Ko Wa has said, we need dialogue based on documented and true agreements between all political forces. We need to persuade the military and mobilize political forces to make that happen.

KZM: Given the current situation, can we say it is unlikely?

Ko Wa: It is unlikely that the Tatmadaw will easily give up the political power they have held. It is said that civil society organizations and political parties are weak in political transition. But that is the result of the restrictions on political rights from 1962 to 2010. That is the reason behind our problems today. Our country lags behind on the economy, education, technology and so on, and only when civil society and political parties are strong will we be able to catch up. If the Tatmadaw really wants to establish modern armed forces that are on a par with those of other countries, it needs to change its attitude and let civil society and political parties grow. They Tatmadaw needs to seriously consider this. Even if the Tatmadaw alone is capable, it can't promote the interests of itself and the country given the current economic and technological inferiority and lack of unity among people in the country. More importantly, there will be tough competition in the region when the One Belt One Road Initiative and the ASEAN Economic Community (AEC) are implemented. If there is no unity among the forces including the Tatmadaw, we won't be able to overcome those challenges.

The Tatmadaw should start taking steps now. It has accepted federal Union in principle, and though it has not officially said when it will give up political power, the Constitution implies that it must give up some time in the future. So, the Tatmadaw should be thinking about how to build capable armed forces, how to strengthen civil society and political parties that support building strong armed forces, and how to facilitate the national economy.

Without doing this, it won't be able to build a modern, capable and professional army that can be on a par with those of other countries. Tatmadaw leaders need to make changes now for the future of the country in cooperation with political parties, civil society and organizations that represent the people. On behalf of people who want democracy, I would like to say that we don't view the Tatmadaw as the enemy. Our country needs the Tatmadaw. I personally want to see a highly modern and capable Tatmadaw. For that to happen, I would like to urge the Tatmadaw to boldly join hands with the people in trust.

KZM: Ko Sanny, Ko Wa thanks a lot!

The post 30 Years Since Myanmar's Pro-democracy Uprising appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

This Week in Parliament (March 12-16)

Posted: 16 Mar 2018 08:23 PM PDT

Monday (March 12)

U T Khun Myat, deputy speaker of the Lower House, submitted a report on the Myanmar parliamentary delegation to the 137th Inter-Parliamentary Union (IPU) Assembly in October 2017. The IPU Assembly "urges the global parliamentary community to take concrete steps to put an end to the ethnic cleansing of the Rohingya from Rakhine state, and to end further human rights violations." U T Khun Myat said that the Myanmar delegation raised objection to the resolution and responded to accusations of 'ethnic cleansing.'

Tuesday (March 13)

In the Lower House, the defense ministry refused to hand over to farmers more than 100 acres of land it confiscated in Shan State's Kyethi Township in the 1990s, citing security reasons and farmers' lack of ownership documents.

In the Upper House, six lawmakers discussed the bill amending the Anti-Corruption Law. Khun Win Thaung of Kachin State Constituency (11) called for rewriting the law, saying that corruption is still rampant in the country despite the fact that the law came into effect in 2013. More lawmakers are set to debate the bill on March 20.

Wednesday (March 14)

In the Lower House, Dr. Maung Thin of Meiktila Township urged the government to explain in detail the repatriation of Muslim refugees from Bangladesh. Deputy Minister for Social Welfare, Relief and Resettlement U Soe Aung replied that Myanmar and Bangladesh signed the 'Arrangement on Return of Displaced Persons from Rakhine State' on Nov. 23, 2017, and that the repatriation process would be carried out according to the 1982 Myanmar Citizenship Law and 1993 agreement between the two countries.

In the Upper House, lawmaker U Kyaw Htwe of Yangon Constituency (8) asked about private banks and Vice Governor of the Central Bank of Myanmar U Soe Thane replied that there are currently 24 private banks in the country. The Central Bank of Myanmar is considering the applications of five new private banks and has suspended accepting new applications.

Thursday (March 15)

In Union Parliament, lawmakers discussed the report on the Myanmar parliamentary delegation to the 137th Inter-Parliamentary Union (IPU) Assembly in October 2017. Dr. Than Win of Mandalay Constituency (1) said that an IPU resolution to urge governments to put diplomatic pressure on Myanmar exaggerates the issue and does not solve the problem.

The Ministry of Transport and Communications sought approval from Parliament for a 56.622 billion yen ($536 million) loan from Japan to upgrade the country's rail system.

Friday (March 16)

Four lawmakers discussed the report of the Government’s Guarantees, Pledges and Undertakings Vetting Committee in the Lower House, which agreed that there is a need for greater checks and balances to make sure government-funded projects meet standards and deliver value to the public

The post This Week in Parliament (March 12-16) appeared first on The Irrawaddy.