Tuesday, September 15, 2015

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Limited Rice Trade Resumes as Govt Weighs New Export Policy

Posted: 15 Sep 2015 06:04 AM PDT

A man carries a sack of rice from a boat on the banks of the Rangoon River, Rangoon, November, 2013. (Photo: Soe Zeya Tun / Reuters)

A man carries a sack of rice from a boat on the banks of the Rangoon River, Rangoon, November, 2013. (Photo: Soe Zeya Tun / Reuters)

RANGOON — While limited rice exports resumed on Tuesday after a 45-day halt, the government announced overland rice exports would remain suspended as it considered a new trade policy on the back of recent severe flooding.

Flooding across the country over the last two months inundated more than 1.3 million acres of paddy fields and, in early August, the Myanmar Rice Federation (MRF) called on its members to halt rice exports until mid-September.

But while rice exports via sea routes resumed on Tuesday, Myint Cho, Director of Trade Promotion in the Ministry of Commerce, said the government would not yet resume overland exports as it mulled a new export policy.

"Even during these past 45 days, some exporters, on a case-by-case basis, were granted special permission to trade by sea," Myint Cho said.

He added that the government was focused on ensuring local consumption needs were met and ongoing concerns had convinced officials to consider adjusting Burma's rice export policy.

"As of now, an exporter may have to save at least 2 percent of his rice volume as surplus," he said.

Following a meeting between MRF members and officials from the Ministry of Commerce on Tuesday, the federation said the government would soon issue new export licenses, but no date was specified.

Ye Min Aung, general secretary of the MRF, told The Irrawaddy the federation was waiting to see details of the new export policy. He said the ministry would have to weigh local consumption, prices and export volumes in determining a new approach.

"If the government has plans for a surplus of rice, we will have to check how to store it, who will handle it and what the volume will be," he said.

Chan Tha Oo, a rice exporter based in Muse, Shan State, said that the new export policy would be of national importance and that exporters would just have to wait and see how it played out.

"Rice policy must look out for all farmers, traders, and consumers. We therefore shouldn't rush to implement a new policy," he said. "Rice exports across border check points have been stopped now, only local consumption is allowed here."

Of the approximately 15 million tons of rice produced in Burma in the 2014-15 fiscal year, about 1.5 million tons, or 10 percent, were exported, according to the MRF.

The post Limited Rice Trade Resumes as Govt Weighs New Export Policy appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Stupa Construction in Hpa-an Township Draws Community Concerns

Posted: 15 Sep 2015 04:42 AM PDT

The stupa, constructed within a Baptist church compound in Hpa-an Township, Karen State. (Photo: Saw Black Karen / Facebook)

The stupa, constructed within a Baptist church compound in Hpa-an Township, Karen State. (Photo: Saw Black Karen / Facebook)

Christian religious leaders are concerned that the construction of a stupa in a Baptist church compound in Mi Zine Village in Karen State's Hpa-an Township may cause religious tensions.

Leaders from the Myanmar Baptist Convention (MBC) asked Myaing Kyee Ngu Sayadaw, who led construction of the stupa, to halt the project, according to Mann San Thein Tun of the MBC.

"The Sayadaw said there were pagodas and stupas [in the area] since the time of King Asoka. He even asked us to understand that he had to [build the stupa] because of happenings in his previous existence," Mann San Thein Tun told The Irrawaddy.

The Christian church has stood since 1919, the MBC representative said, and construction of the stupa began on August 21.

Christian leaders of the MBC conveyed their concerns to Burma's Religious Affairs Minister Soe Win who pledged to resolve the issue, Mann San Thein Tun said.

"We made the request to the Religious Affairs Minister U Soe Win in person on Sept 7. He gave us two promises: that he would talk to Myaing Kyee Ngu Sayadaw and settle the issue to the satisfaction of Christians at an opportune time," he said.

The Irrawaddy contacted both the Ministry of Religious Affairs in Naypyidaw and the Karen State government, but officials declined to comment.

The church's vicar, Michael, who has served at the church since 1980, said some Christian worshippers had been disturbed enough that they had stayed away from the church compound.

"Christians could not pray at the church since the stupa was built. They pray at my house because it is not convenient for them to pray [at the church] as [Buddhist monks] recite religious verses with loud speakers close to the church. We asked them to reduce the volume just for an hour while we are praying, but they said they could not," he told The Irrawaddy.

Some locals in Mi Zine, a small village of around 150 households that includes a Buddhist community, are concerned that construction of the stupa could lead to heightened religious tensions.

"There are other vacant spaces in the village where they can promote their religion. Why don't they choose one of those places? They did not inform the church in advance of the stupa's construction. It is quite strange. Some locals here are suspicious that they are creating religious problems," said a local, who did not want to be named.

The Karen National Union (KNU) also expressed concern over the issue, pointing to past examples of communal tensions.

"There were riots… resulting from religious issues [in the past], which in fact should not have happened. Therefore, we are concerned that [tensions] might arise again," said Padoh Ar Toe, responsible for internal and religious affairs with the KNU.

Myaing Kyee Ngu Sayadaw is an influential monk in Karen State with reputed ties to local ethnic armed groups including the Democratic Karen Benevolent Army (DKBA).

The Irrawaddy could not reach Myaing Kyee Ngu Sayadaw for comment on Tuesday.

The post Stupa Construction in Hpa-an Township Draws Community Concerns appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Election 2015: Generals Take It Easy as Parliamentary Hopefuls Battle It Out

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 11:12 PM PDT

Child Workers in Thai Seafood Industry Face Hazards, Injuries: Report

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 10:45 PM PDT

Migrant workers from Burma unload fish at a seafood market near Bangkok in 2010. (Photo: Reuters)

Migrant workers from Burma unload fish at a seafood market near Bangkok in 2010. (Photo: Reuters)

BANGKOK — Children employed in Thailand's seafood processing industry are more exposed to workplace hazards such as fire or gas, and are twice as likely to be injured than minors working in other industries, experts said on Monday.

Under Thai law, the minimum age of employment is 15 years, but many younger children—including migrant children from neighboring Burma—are working illegally and not attending school, they said.

Almost 20 percent of children in the seafood industries reported workplace injuries, compared to 8.4 percent in other workplaces, the International Labor Organization and the Asia Foundation experts said in a new report.

"In the 21st century, no child should be brutalized by exploitation," said Maurizio Bussi, head of the International Labor Organization's office in Thailand, Cambodia and Laos.

Migrant children are disproportionately exploited because Thailand's seafood industry, with exports valued at US$3 billion a year, relies heavily on cheap labor, mostly from Burma.

Children in the seafood industry work almost 50 hours per week—about 6 hours more than Thai children—and few are aware of child labor laws. Just 30 percent of minors who are above the minimum employment age enjoy the legal protection of a contract, the report said.

Thailand, the world's third-largest seafood exporter, is under pressure internationally after rights groups and media investigations accused the seafood industry of using slave labor.

Vitit Muntarbhorn, an international human rights lawyer and professor at Chulalongkorn University in Bangkok, said the country has the laws in place to tackle labor abuses.

"What we need is better enforcement," Vitit, a member of the ILO Committee of Experts, told the Thomson Reuters Foundation at the launch of the report. "The question is how do you get children out of this situation?"

The report recommended improving migrant children's access to early childhood education centers, from the age of three, so they become proficient enough in Thai to enter formal schools in first grade.

It also said part-time schooling for migrant children, in particular 15- to 17-year-olds, would improve their chances of staying in education.

The report found big differences in labor standards between the canned tuna and the shrimp industry.

The shrimp industry, with more than 10,000 farms, traders and processors, is much harder to monitor and regulate than the canned tuna industry, which is dominated by three big players who improved labor standards after pressure from overseas buyers.

Governments, buyers, producers, NGOs and international organizations should work together to improve labor conditions, the report said.

In addition, procedures for migrant workers to register with the Thai government should be simplified, while buyers abroad should be held accountable to work with suppliers to maintain international standards.

The post Child Workers in Thai Seafood Industry Face Hazards, Injuries: Report appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Thailand’s Military Govt Detains Newspaper Reporter

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 10:36 PM PDT

 Thai journalist Pravit Rojanaphruk in a photograph from June. (Photo: Pravit Rojanaphruk / Facebook)

Thai journalist Pravit Rojanaphruk in a photograph from June. (Photo: Pravit Rojanaphruk / Facebook)

BANGKOK — Thailand’s military government has detained a reporter for an English-language newspaper, in what appears to be part of a fresh crackdown on critics of the ruling junta.

A spokesman for the junta, Col. Winthai Suvaree, said in a text message to local reporters Monday that Pravit Rojanaphruk, a senior journalist for The Nation newspaper, had received an “invitation” for a talk with the authorities because of statements that could “cause confusion to the public.” Pravit has been a high-profile critic of the military regime that took over after a coup in May 2014 toppled an elected civilian government.

After turning himself in Sunday, Pravit was taken to an unidentified location and is being held incommunicado, according to The Nation. Detainees of the junta usually are held at an army camp.

Winthai said the length of Pravit’s detention depends on how cooperative he is. The detention process has been used since the coup, with the junta calling it “attitude adjustment.” To expedite their release, detainees are reportedly pressured to sign a statement promising to refrain from further public criticism.

The Nation’s editor-in-chief, Thepchai Yong, called for Pravit’s immediate release and said he would submit a letter to Prime Minister Prayuth Chan-ocha to demand that he order Pravit to be freed.

“We see this as a direct threat to press freedom,” Thepchai said in a statement on The Nation’s website.

Pravit has written critical commentaries in The Nation and frequently posts his opinions on Twitter.

It is the second time he has been detained by the junta, which called in large numbers of politicians and potential dissidents in the months after the coup but appears to have begun a new round of detentions.

Last week, the military detained two politicians who had been critical of the junta, including a former energy minister. Both men were members of the Pheu Thai party, which led the government that was ousted by the army in the coup.

The post Thailand’s Military Govt Detains Newspaper Reporter appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Behind Singapore Ruling Party’s Victory, a Rising Star

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 10:28 PM PDT

  IMFC Chairman Tharman Shanmugaratnam speaks at a news conference during the Spring Meeting of the IMF and World Bank in Washington, April 20, 2013. (Photo: Yuri Gripas / Reuters)

IMFC Chairman Tharman Shanmugaratnam speaks at a news conference during the Spring Meeting of the IMF and World Bank in Washington, April 20, 2013. (Photo: Yuri Gripas / Reuters)

SINGAPORE — Singapore's ruling party is celebrating a resounding re-election victory, thanks partly to its economic Tsar, an ethnic Tamil politician whose voter appeal poses an awkward question for its leaders: can a non-Chinese ever become prime minister?

As the People's Action Party (PAP) settles down to another five years in power, the guessing game of who will succeed Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong has begun – and the name of Tharman Shanmugaratnam keeps coming up.

The odds of Shanmugaratnam, who is deputy prime minister and finance minister, making it to the top job should be long.

All three of Singapore's prime ministers to date have been of Chinese origin and, in a country where three-quarters of the residents are ethnic Chinese, it would be hard to break that tradition. Just one in 10 Singaporeans can, like Shanmugaratnam, trace their roots back to South Asia.

PAP officials declined to comment on the question of who will come after Lee, 63, who has hinted that he may step down by 2020, because it is a sensitive subject in a party that is in any case instinctively secretive.

Lee has said that the chances of a non-Chinese becoming prime minister are better for the new generation of leaders but a lack of Mandarin, widely spoken here, could be a problem.

For some Singaporeans, though, the idea is as outlandish as a non-Malay prime minister in Malaysia or an Indonesian from outside the political heartland of Java becoming president.

In a book published two years before his death this year, Lee Kuan Yew, Lee's father and the deeply respected first prime minister of this tropical city-state, listed four ethnic Chinese men as the new generation of up-and-coming leaders.

Still, Shanmugaratnam's hustings performance in the run-up to last week's election was so impressive that even an opposition candidate, Paul Tambyah of the Singapore Democratic Party, openly longed for him to lead a grand coalition of parties.

"People would like to see Tharman around to set the tone for a new PAP leadership," said Catherine Lim, a long-time political commentator and critic of Lee Kuan Yew.

"It's time now for a completely different one, and the only person whom I can think of to set that tone convincingly and who can appeal to Singaporeans across ethnic groups would be Mr Tharman," she said.

Shanmugaratnam, 58, said in July he was not keen on the prime minister's job, though he expected Singapore to have a leader from one of its minority ethnic groups at some point.

He was not available to comment for this article.

A Transitional Prime Minister?

The PAP won almost 70 percent of the popular vote in the election, a stunning recovery from its record low of 60.1 percent in 2011. In his own district, Shanmugaratnam led a handful of lawmakers to a win with about 80 percent of the vote.

Analysts say that rebound was helped by a wave of patriotism after the death of Lee Kuan Yew and independent Singapore's 50th birthday celebrations, but also by a slight shift from unbridled capitalism to Western welfarism that was led by Shanmugaratnam.

In his campaign speeches, Shanmugaratnam pressed the right buttons for an electorate that has in recent years begun to question the hard-nosed growth-at-all-costs policies of the PAP that left many marginalised and struggling to make ends meet.

In a calm baritone and with his trademark avuncular style, he crunched numbers to show how social welfare is working.

He also explained changes the PAP has embraced after 50 years of unbroken rule, but conceded still more were needed.

"It used to be a top-down government, often quite heavy-handed," he told one rally. "It's no longer that way … Strong leadership is listening, engaging, moving with people."

Shanmugaratnam spoke some Mandarin on the campaign, and when he quoted from an ancient Chinese poem at one rally the crowd exploded with cheers.

He was educated at the London School of Economics, Cambridge and Harvard, and spent most of his career at the Monetary Authority of Singapore, the island state's central bank and financial regulator.

He got into a legal tangle in the 1990s when he was fined for failing to protect the secrecy of official information after economic data was published in a newspaper ahead of its release. Shanmugaratnam had pleaded not guilty.

He is also well known on international circuits: a darling of international investors, he was appointed chairman of the International Monetary Fund's policy steering committee in 2011.

Eugene Tan, a law professor at Singapore Management University and a political commentator, said one obstacle for Shanmugaratnam is that he is seen as part of the prime minister's generation, when perhaps ideally a new generation would be coming forward.

"However, if it is assessed that a transitional prime minister is needed while the fourth generation is ready to take over, then … Tharman is well-positioned to step up," Tan said.

The post Behind Singapore Ruling Party's Victory, a Rising Star appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

National News

National News


Northern Rakhine facing major political shake-up

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 09:07 PM PDT

In 2010, Rafi, 25, voted for the military-backed Union Solidarity and Development Party. At the time he was a white-card holder. Two years later he fled northern Rakhine State.

Former minister warns of Syria syndrome

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 08:40 PM PDT

Former defence minister U Wai Lwin, who has shed his general's uniform to run for parliament, has warned that reforms should move ahead "smoothly and gently" and that Myanmar must avoid the risk of ending up like Syria.

Independents hit back at NLD leader for ‘worthless’ remark

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 08:36 PM PDT

Independent candidates are taking offence at Daw Aung San Suu Kyi calling a vote for them "worthless".

Opposition manifesto sparse on details

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 08:33 PM PDT

The National League for Democracy has given voters a glimpse of what an opposition government might ideally look like in their election manifesto.

Hyper-nationalists celebrate four ‘race and religion’ laws

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 08:25 PM PDT

Hyper-nationalist Buddhist groups yesterday kicked off a two week celebration of four controversial race and religion bills recently signed into law.

Parties quiz government over how exclusive ceasefire can be ‘nationwide’

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 08:23 PM PDT

Ethnic parties have questioned the government over the "nationwide" element of its proposed ceasefire agreement, which is intended to exclude several armed ethnic groups.

Mandalay lawyers join campaign

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 08:18 PM PDT

Mandalay lawyers have joined the yellow ribbon movement demanding an end to militarisation of the judicial system.

NLD extends media ban for candidates

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 08:17 PM PDT

In its latest gag order for party members contesting the November elections, the National League for Democracy has warned would-be parliamentarians to stay away from anyone who could fall under the Unlawful Associations Act.

Heavy rain expected this week

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 08:11 PM PDT

Lower Myanmar can expect a drenching over the coming week due to low pressure areas in the Bay of Bengal, the Department of Meteorology and Hydrology says.

Waste pipeline leaves villagers ill

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 08:03 PM PDT

Villagers are suffering vomiting and dizziness after a pipeline carrying industrial effluent through their village sprang a leak.

Monday, September 14, 2015

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Govt Canvasses Post-Ceasefire Political Dialogue Plans

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 06:43 AM PDT

 The government's chief peace negotiator Aung Min addresses a multi-stakeholder meeting on post-ceasefire political dialogue held in Rangoon on Monday. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

The government's chief peace negotiator Aung Min addresses a multi-stakeholder meeting on post-ceasefire political dialogue held in Rangoon on Monday. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

President's Office Minister and chief peace negotiator Aung Min called on all stakeholders to collaborate to establish a common framework for political dialogue during a meeting with ethnic armed groups and political parties in Rangoon on Monday.

Representatives of seven ethnic armed groups and a handful of political parties including the Union Solidarity and Development Party and the National League for Democracy attended the morning meeting to discuss the structure of political dialogue that would follow the signing of a nationwide ceasefire agreement (NCA).

Government, ethnic and parliamentary representatives have been meeting informally to discuss the issue since last year, with the general view that some headway should be made before a prospective peace pact is concluded.

"We have started these meetings to be able to quickly step up to the political dialogue following the NCA signing, as the framework drafting could take at least four months to a year," Aung Min said in his opening remarks on Monday.

In the NCA text, it is stipulated that political dialogue must take place within 60-90 days of signing the accord.

Aung Min told interlocutors at the meeting that a nationwide ceasefire signing ceremony would be held in the first week of October, with political dialogue expected to take place in January next year.

In the afternoon, he briefed some 150 representatives from 78 political parties on the process to follow the NCA signing.

The minister said that a meeting of the Joint Implementation Coordination (JIC) team would be held 14 days after the NCA signing, with a so-called Union Peace Dialogue Joint Committee to be formed within 15 days.

The Myanmar Peace Center (MPC) gave a similar briefing to Burmese media in Rangoon on Friday.

"The discussions [on political dialogue] have been ongoing for a year. After the NCA is signed, the process will be quicker," said Hla Maung Shwe of the MPC.

A high-level meeting between Burma's president and leaders of major ethnic armed groups in Naypyidaw last Wednesday ended with a somewhat tentative pledge to sign a nationwide ceasefire pact in early October. However, no date has yet been agreed.

Aung Min and ruling party MP Thein Zaw met with representatives of the United Wa State Army and the National Democratic Alliance Army in Kengtung, Shan State, on Saturday, to discuss the ongoing peace process, according to Hla Maung Shwe.

Both groups have bilateral ceasefire agreements with the government and are observers to the ceasefire process but not members of the ethnics' negotiating bloc.

Government negotiators urged them to take part in the NCA signing, according to Hla Maung Shwe, with the Wa and Mongla groups only confirming they would hold internal discussions on the matter.

Kyi Maung, a central committee member of the National Democratic Alliance Army in eastern Shan State, told The Irrawaddy on Monday that the armed group shares the same view as the majority of groups regarding an all-inclusive ceasefire.

He also said the NDAA stands together with the UWSA, Burma's largest ethnic armed group, which has previously stated it would not sign the NCA but would join the subsequent political dialogue.

Despite rumors Aung Min would also meet with Kokang leaders of the Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army, no such meeting occurred over the weekend, Hla Maung Shwe said.

The post Govt Canvasses Post-Ceasefire Political Dialogue Plans appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

‘Angels and Demons’

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 06:35 AM PDT

think

 

The post ‘Angels and Demons’ appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Rare Praise for Human Rights Body After Call for Letpadan Justice

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 05:34 AM PDT

 Police violently disperse peaceful student protestors at Letpadan in Pegu Division on March 10, 2015. (Photo: Steve Tickner / The Irrawaddy)

Police violently disperse peaceful student protestors at Letpadan in Pegu Division on March 10, 2015. (Photo: Steve Tickner / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — The Myanmar National Human Rights Commission (MNHRC) has received rare praise after it called on the Burmese government late last week to take action against police officers who brutally cracked down on a group of peaceful student protestors earlier this year.

Lawyer Thein Than Oo, a member of the Myanmar Lawyers' Network, told The Irrawaddy on Monday that the commission—long criticized as spineless—had helped rehabilitate its image in the eyes of the public with its statement on Friday.

"They did not stand on the side of the government, they stood instead on the side of the people. For us, we welcome and support their stand," said the lawyer, who is providing legal counsel to some of the students who were jailed following the crackdown. "We found that they conducted a good investigation. We can say that their report is fair. This will do good things for their image."

Thein Than Oo did not, however, hold out hope that the commission's call for justice would be heeded by the government, though he added that it might go some way toward exonerating the dozens of students on trial and facing charges linked to the March 10 crackdown.

The MNHRC was formed by President Thein Sein, and has frequently had its independence called into question.

Its statement on Friday accused police of failing to following procedure when they violently dismantled the student protest in Letpadan, a town located some 80 miles northwest of Rangoon in Pegu Division.

The statement also said disproportionately harsh charges had been brought against the students, who at most, according to the commission, should face charges under Burma's Peaceful Assembly Law.

About 50 students remain behind bars at a prison in neighboring Tharrawaddy Township, awaiting a verdict in their cases, while some 20 others have been released on bail.

The MNHRC's investigation included documents and footage of the crackdown, as well interviews with 38 people involved in the incident, including both student protestors and police officers. Pegu Division authorities did not cooperate with the probe, according to the commission's statement.

The investigation found nothing to indicate that student protestors had verbally instigated the police to prompt the officers to violence. The trigger for the crackdown, according to the investigation, was a water bottle thrown at police as they blocked students' attempt to march from Letpadan to Rangoon. The March 10 crackdown was preceded by a nine-day standoff between police and the students, who had marched more than 300 miles from Mandalay to protest a National Education Law that they were pushing to have amended.

The MNHRC statement on Friday was the most explicit condemnation of a police action ever issued by the commission, which was formed in 2011 and has shied away from strident criticism of the government or its appendages in a number of instances over the years.

Dr. Nyan Zaw, who is a member of the MNHRC, told The Irrawaddy on Monday that "we hope they will take action against those who violated the law."

In the immediate aftermath of the crackdown, presidential spokesman Ye Htut defended the police action as lawful, an assertion disputed by Nyan Zaw.

"Police have their handbook about what to do when they disperse a crowd. They have a procedure for it. If they did not act based on their procedure, this means they violated the law. Therefore, we are asking that action be taken," he said, adding that he hoped the commission's work would lead the Tharrawaddy court to be more lenient in its sentencing of the students.

"For us, we cannot do anything about the charges against the students. But the case of their punishment could be reduced, we hope, after the issuance of our report," Nyan Zaw said.

The post Rare Praise for Human Rights Body After Call for Letpadan Justice appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Dr Pornthip: ‘Victims or Suspects Have the Right to Ask For a Second Opinion’

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 04:43 AM PDT

Head of Thailand's Central Institute of Forensic Science, Dr Pornthip Rojanasunand. (Photo: Reuters)

Head of Thailand's Central Institute of Forensic Science, Dr Pornthip Rojanasunand. (Photo: Reuters)

Thailand's most prominent forensics expert, Dr Pornthip Rojanasunand, who is head of the country's Central Institute of Forensic Science, was recently called on by the defense team representing two Burmese men accused of murder to reexamine crucial DNA evidence. Zaw Lin and Wai Phyo were arrested last year for the killing of British backpackers David Miller and Hannah Witheridge on a Thai resort island on the night of September 15, 2014. However, the handling of the case by Thai police has been the subject of significant controversy and the two Burmese men have alleged they were tortured into a confession. The trial is continuing on Koh Samui. The Irrawaddy's Saw Yan Naing spoke with Dr Pornthip about her team's findings and ongoing involvement in the case.

How did you become involved in this case?

First of all, the defendants' lawyers came into the institute [the Central Institute of Forensic Science] and asked us for our interpretation of the scientific evidence. They asked us to support this case. Secondly, there was a request for a second DNA [testing] of the evidence in the case. There was also a request from the National Human Rights Commission [of Thailand] for an investigation into [allegations] the suspects were tortured. So there were three issues.

Please explain what your institute's findings were regarding the DNA test.

Our team found that the DNA profile on the weapon [a garden hoe police believe was used to kill the British tourists] didn't belong to the suspects [Zaw Lin and Wai Phyo]. It belongs to an unknown man. We need to have the DNA of other people [involved]. We only found the DNA from an unidentified man which was not compatible with the suspects' [DNA].

Who else should be subject to DNA testing?

That is not my duty. I can't say who else needs to be tested. It is the task of the police.

What other requirements should be carried out in the course of fact finding for this case?

In this case, I can't say anything because I didn't have a chance to look at the DNA profile [related to] all the evidence. I just looked at the DNA from the weapon that the police sent to our institute. There are some [aspects] of the DNA profile that I can't discuss. We have to wait.

There were previous reports that DNA found on the butt of a cigarette shared by the two suspects matched that found on the female victim's body. Were you able to consider that evidence?

No. Because the police said that all that evidence was destroyed already. The police said there was no evidence left to send to our institute.

From now on, how will you and your team be involved in the process?

In the next [week or two], there will be scientific testimony given in [Koh Samui Provincial] court. Two scientists and one doctor [from the Central Institute of Forensic Science] will testify at the court. The two scientists will testify about the DNA findings. And a doctor will testify on the physical examination of the two suspects because they [the suspects] told judges and the National Human Rights Commission that they were tortured by the police [during interrogation]. The doctor did the physical determination when the suspects were in prison. So that will be our institute's testimony.

You are very well respected for your expertise in DNA analysis. The Burmese public would be very interested in your comments. What is your message to them?

In Thailand, we have the chance to ask for help on issues of human rights. This means that victims or suspects have the right to ask for a second opinion on forensic investigations. And it's our duty, at the Central Institute of Forensic Science under the Ministry of Justice, to do that job. We can help suspects or victims. If they want a second opinion, they can ask for it. And we will try our best.

The post Dr Pornthip: 'Victims or Suspects Have the Right to Ask For a Second Opinion' appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Analysis: Singaporeans Fall Back on Tried and Tested Party

Posted: 14 Sep 2015 12:03 AM PDT

Singapore's Prime Minister and Secretary-General of the People's Action Party Lee Hsien Loong, center, and his team thank supporters on Saturday after the general election in Singapore. (Photo: Edgar Su / Reuters)

Singapore’s Prime Minister and Secretary-General of the People’s Action Party Lee Hsien Loong, center, and his team thank supporters on Saturday after the general election in Singapore. (Photo: Edgar Su / Reuters)

SINGAPORE — Every four or five years, Singaporeans vote in general elections without ever asking the question: Which party can best run the government? That’s a no-brainer. It’s the same party that’s been ruling the wealthy Southeast Asian city-state for a half-century. The questions most ask instead is how much voice should they give the opposition.

That explains the overwhelming majority that the People’s Action Party has won in every election since independence in 1965, including the last one on Friday, which returned it with an even greater share of the votes than before. It was a result that any political party in the world would salivate over—83 of 89 seats in Parliament and 70 percent of all votes cast.

In some ways, it was the direct outcome of the PAP’s relatively poor showing in the 2011 elections, when even though it won 81 of the 87 seats at stake, it garnered only 60 percent of the votes.

There was clear anger among the voters against the rising cost of living. Singapore is among the most expensive cities in the world while being the ninth-richest nation on an annual per capita income basis, one spot ahead of the United States. An open immigration policy promoted by the government to keep the economy robust had led to overcrowding and resentment against foreign workers seen to be stealing local jobs.

Restrictions on the media and freedom of speech—although less than in the early years after independence—remain in place. Income disparities are stark. On the one hand, executives are earning six-figure salaries, driving expensive cars, living in magnificent homes, and on the other, old retirees are eking out a living on meager pensions of about $1,000 a month while doing odd jobs.

All this gave the opposition fodder to launch an invigorated attack. Its campaign rallies attracted tens of thousands of people compared to a few hundred or 3,000 at the most for the PAP. Social media—the only alternative voice in a country where the mainstream newspapers, radio and TV stations are controlled by the government—were abuzz with talk of the opposition flexing its newfound muscles.

Some even began to talk about the possibility that the nine opposition parties combined would unseat the government, because for the first time in history they were together contesting all seats.

That, for many Singaporeans, was unacceptable. They wanted to give the opposition some voice—but not enough to take charge.

In a country that does not allow opinion polls, it is hard for voters to judge the strength of the opposition, and how much votes it should get without upsetting the apple cart. Unwilling to fall into the trap of over-voting for the opposition, the traditionally risk-averse Singaporeans always end up going for the safe option. This time, the risk seemed larger. The fear that they could lose a government that they trusted and relied on tipped the undecided on the PAP’s side.

“There was a certain palpable concern that the PAP may come out of the election severely weakened. That resulted in the middle ground, the group of undecided voters, to rally behind the PAP, going back to a tried and tested party,” Eugene Tan, an associate professor of law at Singapore Management University, told The Associated Press.

Even the opposition acknowledged that.

“One of the things which I think probably did loom in people’s minds … is the fact that for the first time, all 89 seats are contested, and perhaps some people did feel that there was some risk (of the PAP faring poorly),” Workers’ Party chairman Sylvia Lim said at a victory parade in Aljunied. The party retained five seats by a slim margin.

“There is a perception that the opposition movement is growing strong. There could be a pushback on that, because I think people still feel comfortable with the PAP as a government,” she added.

So why do Singaporeans trust the PAP so much?

For one, it is the party’s track record. After a period of British colonial rule, Singapore became part of the Malay Federation in 1963, whose other giant member was neighboring Malaysia. However, Singapore was kicked out of the union in 1965, with Lee Kuan Yew as the prime minister of the newly formed nation.

A fiery orator, master strategist and a no-holds-barred street fighter, Lee led the PAP to decisive victory in the 1968 general elections, and every one since, until his death in March.

Lee and other founding leaders in the PAP created a unique system of development for Singapore. Lee promoted meritocracy, attracted foreign investment through tax incentives, introduced English-language education, raised productivity and brooked no corruption. He also brooked no dissent and treated the opposition with contempt. Most opponents could not match his fighting skills—some were thrown in jail and others taken to court for defamation, leading to bankruptcy. Soon the opposition was emasculated.

Meanwhile, Singapore’s spectacular development continued amid restrictions on free speech. In many ways, Singapore became a nanny state, with the government masterminding social policies, including the racial mix among Chinese, Malays and Indians in public housing where a majority of its 5.6 million people live, how much they should save, what they could read and what they could watch on TV. Singaporeans seemed willing to pay that price for the economic gains.

After disenchantment became deeply evident in the 2011 elections, the government made amends. It cut back on immigration. The annual growth of foreign professionals, managers and executives fell from 45,000 a year to 13,000 last year. It made reforms to the pension scheme and the medical insurance. The government also reached out to the youth on hot-button issues—and the results paid off.

Ultimately, it was the people’s choice—even if forced by a set of circumstances unique to Singapore—that strengthened the ruling party at the expense of producing a more representative Parliament.

“I guess Singaporeans get the government they deserve, so I don’t want to hear any more complaints,” said opposition leader Kenneth Jeyaretnam.

The post Analysis: Singaporeans Fall Back on Tried and Tested Party appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Malaysia Arrests Three Suspects in Connection with Bangkok Blast

Posted: 13 Sep 2015 10:18 PM PDT

  Experts investigate the Erawan shrine at the site of a deadly blast in central Bangkok, Thailand, August 18, 2015. (Photo: Athit Perawongmetha / Reuters)

Experts investigate the Erawan shrine at the site of a deadly blast in central Bangkok, Thailand, August 18, 2015. (Photo: Athit Perawongmetha / Reuters)

KUALA LUMPUR — Malaysia has arrested three suspects in connection with the investigation into a bomb blast in central Bangkok last month that killed 20 people, police chief Khalid Abu Bakar said on Monday.

Two Malaysians and a Pakistani national were arrested and were assisting with the investigation, Khalid told reporters.

"We believe the suspects can help in the investigation… our arrest was made to assist the Thai police in the Thai bombing investigation," he said. "Malaysian and Thai police are working closely in cooperation."

No group has claimed responsibility for the Aug. 17 attack at the Erawan Shrine shrine in Bangkok, which killed 20 people, including 14 foreign tourists, among them seven from Hong Kong and mainland China.

Thai police have been heavily criticized over the investigation and over statements from top officials about possible perpetrators, motives and information extracted from suspects which have been contradictory, speculative and often cryptic.

Khalid said the Pakistani suspect is male while one of the local suspects is female and the other is male. He said there were no plans to move the suspects to Thailand yet.

Khalid also said Malaysian police were unsure if the main suspect was in Malaysia. The Thai investigation unearthed a lead earlier this month that suspected bomber may have crossed Thailand's southern border into Malaysia.

The post Malaysia Arrests Three Suspects in Connection with Bangkok Blast appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Okinawa to Revoke Approval for US Base Work in Headache for Abe

Posted: 13 Sep 2015 10:09 PM PDT

 Protesters raise placards during a rally to oppose the transfer of a key US military base within the prefecture, at a baseball stadium in the prefectural capital Naha on Japan's southern island of Okinawa, in this photo taken by Kyodo, May 17, 2015. (Photo: Kyodo / Reuters)

Protesters raise placards during a rally to oppose the transfer of a key US military base within the prefecture, at a baseball stadium in the prefectural capital Naha on Japan's southern island of Okinawa, in this photo taken by Kyodo, May 17, 2015. (Photo: Kyodo / Reuters)

TOKYO — The governor of Japan's Okinawa prefecture said on Monday he will move to halt work on a contentious US air base, a headache for Prime Minister Shinzo Abe at a crucial time in his push to get widely opposed security bills passed.

The central government wants to move the US Marines' Futenma base to another location on the southern island, but many Okinawa residents who resent US military installations want to get rid of it altogether.

Okinawa governor Takeshi Onaga, who won election last year on his anti-base stand and has accused Abe of looking down on the island, said his government will revoke a permit for key landfill work that is needed to relocate the base.

"This is a first step towards keeping this from being built," Onaga told a news conference, days after the government resumed reclamation work after a month's suspension for talks that left the two sides still far apart.

It will take about a month to revoke the permit, which was issued by Onaga's predecessor, and this action could prompt a legal response from the government, NHK national television said.

The base issue has sparked widespread sympathy around Japan and could further weaken support for Abe, who aims to pass security bills that would let Japan's military fight overseas for the first time since World War Two before the current session of parliament ends on Sept. 27.

The government forced the bills through the lower house of parliament in July despite massive protests.

More than half of people polled on the issue oppose the bills, which would allow Japan's armed forces to defend an ally under attack, a drastic shift in Japan's post-war security policy.

Abe told a parliamentary committee that there is no change in the government's stance on the base.

"We want to move Futenma and ease the worries of residents there as soon as possible," he said.

The post Okinawa to Revoke Approval for US Base Work in Headache for Abe appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

National News

National News


More than 100 scrubbed from final candidate list

Posted: 13 Sep 2015 08:11 PM PDT

Over 100 election hopefuls – mostly minority candidates – were knocked out of the running in the Union Election Commission's final list, with citizenship status by far the most common stumbling block.

Tangled interests and lack of voter awareness confront Daw Suu Kyi

Posted: 13 Sep 2015 08:01 PM PDT

As Daw Aung San Suu Kyi stepped off the plane at Loikaw airport to a cheering crowd, her election campaign in politically divided Kayah State appeared to be off to a good start.

USDP campaigns in strongholds, promises development

Posted: 13 Sep 2015 07:57 PM PDT

Prominent candidates of the ruling USDP campaigned in hoped-for strongholds over the weekend, with parliamentary speaker Thura U Shwe Mann declaring he was politically alive and well despite his purge as party leader during an internal coup last month.

Rights commission urges action against police

Posted: 13 Sep 2015 07:55 PM PDT

The Myanmar National Human Rights Commission has urged the government to take legal action against police and students for a brutal crackdown on students and activists at an education reform rally in Letpadan.

Information war plagues flood victims

Posted: 13 Sep 2015 07:50 PM PDT

When she read in the paper how the regional government had taken action to help the residents of her village in Sidoktaya township, Magwe Region, Daw Hla Hla Win could not believe her eyes. Then she started to cry.

Floods wreak havoc with Rakhine

Posted: 13 Sep 2015 07:49 PM PDT

In the aftermath of the deadly flooding that devastated Rakhine State, one third of paddy acreage in the northern part of the state is littered with fallen trees and branches, dead animals and the detritus of wrecked houses.

Nationwide ceasefire in doubt as KIO holds out

Posted: 13 Sep 2015 07:47 PM PDT

Fresh doubts have been cast on President U Thein Sein's hopes of finalising a genuinely nationwide ceasefire agreement within weeks after the Kachin Independence Organisation, one of the main armed ethnic groups, insisted that it would only sign the pact if all factions were included.

Travel agent blacklisted, barred from trips abroad

Posted: 13 Sep 2015 07:42 PM PDT

When he went to the airport on September 5 ahead of a tourism conference in India, travel company director U Aye Kyaw found himself in a strange bind for a travel aficionado – he was unable to leave the country.

Koh Tao DNA evidence doesn’t match Myanmar defendants

Posted: 13 Sep 2015 07:41 PM PDT

The DNA from the murder weapon used to kill British backpackers on a Thai tourist island last year does not match the two men on trial for the grisly crime.

Saturday, September 12, 2015

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


The Irrawaddy Business Roundup (Sept. 12, 2015)

Posted: 11 Sep 2015 08:05 PM PDT

 A woman walks out a branch of Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, in Beijing. (Photo: Jason Lee / Reuters)

A woman walks out a branch of Industrial and Commercial Bank of China, in Beijing. (Photo: Jason Lee / Reuters)

Government Announces Low-Cost Housing Plan as Minimum Wage Bites

Garment manufacturers loudly opposed the level of the country's first minimum wage, which came into force on Sept. 1 at 3,600 kyat per day. Some workers have reportedly already been laid off by employers, who claim that the level makes it hard for them to compete internationally for orders from clothing brands.

But, according to state media, the Ministry of Labor, Employment and Social Security is hoping that a new low-cost housing project will help to offset higher labor costs.

In a story headlined "Sharing The Burden" on Tuesday, the Global New Light of Myanmar newspaper hailed the ministry's plan to spend some $20.3 million on housing especially for workers.

"The ministry will invite tenders this month for the project in Hlaing Tharyar and Shwepyithar industrial zones," the report said.

"The housing structures will consist of several five-storey buildings on a total of 45 acres, and housing will be affordable, Deputy Minister U Htin Aung told factory bosses following a meeting in Hlaing Tharyar Industrial Zone.

The ministry is also in talks with factories to make sure that workers' benefits, like factories paying for transportation costs, are not curt as a result of the new minimum wage, the report added.

Officials estimate that about 500 workers have already lost their jobs as a result of the minimum wage. But the industry employs more than 250,000 people, and advocates say that the minimum will improve the image of Burma and therefore encourage oversees investment.

Factory owners have argued that they are squeezed between the government's new regulation and the pressures of the international apparel market, which demands cheap clothes to sell to consumers in Europe, the United States and elsewhere in Asia.

Peter McAllister, director of the UK-based Ethical Trading Initiative—an alliance of companies, trade unions and NGOs that works on labor issues—said that international brands themselves needed to absorb some of the additional costs of production created by Burma's new minimum wage.

"International supply chains must now accommodate this wage increase so that the benefits are passed on to workers," McAllister said in emailed comments.

"Global brands and retailers need to make sure the pricing of existing and future contracts takes the new wage into account, and that suppliers' margins are not squeezed."

Concerns Raised Over Safeguards in China's New Infrastructure Bank

A global group of civil society organizations has called on the Chinese-led Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB) to hold an "open and inclusive" consultation on how it will mitigate the environmental and social impacts of its projects.

The formation of the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB) was first touted by China in 2013 and is seen as counter to existing multilateral banks that are dominated by the United States and its allies.

Burma was the first country to formally commit to becoming a founding member of the AIIB, and is among 57 countries that are currently expected to join the bank. The country is in much need of investment in infrastructure projects, especially in the fields of energy and transportation, and would likely be a frontrunner to receive some of the $50 billion expected start-up capital of the AIIB.

A statement distributed this week by the NGO Forum on ADB, which traditionally monitors the activities of the Asian Development Bank, said that 60 groups from different countries both in Asia and elsewhere had signed a letter to the president-designate of the AIIB, Jin Liqun, raising concerns over a recently released draft of the AIIB's Environmental and Social Framework (ESF).

The framework would set out the checks and balances for loans offered by the AIIB, seen as a vital way to prevent damaging projects from going ahead.

"The groups expressed alarm over the 'lack of inherent transparency' and 'gross inadequacy' of the ESF consultation plan, which would fail to include the voices of Asia's local communities and civil society," the statement said.

"They cited the absence of public announcement on the consultation process, the fast track one-month consultation period with the stakeholders, use of videoconferencing technology and English language as primary means for consultation, and limited information on the AIIB website."

"Civil society groups around the world are worried that the AIIB is fast tracking a very opaque and unrealistic consultation process in order to set its ESF into stone for early operations in 2016," NGO Forum on ADB executive director Rayyan Hassan said in the statement.

"We appeal to the Bank to ensure an inclusive and transparent consultation for the drafting of its safeguards policy, standards and process."

First Chinese Bank Moves Into Burma

The Chinese state-run Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC) announced its entry to the Burmese market this week, officially opening a branch in Rangoon and inking a trade-facilitation agreement with a major local bank.

ICBC is the only Chinese bank out of nine overseas financial institutions granted licenses to operate in the country last year.

Chinese state newswire Xinhua reported that ICBC President Yi Huiman attended an opening for the new Yangon branch on Tuesday. The opening "represents an important achievement of economic cooperation between China and Myanmar, as well as an important milestone of ICBC in expanding its global layout," he reportedly said.

Alongside banks including Australia's ANZ Bank, Japan's Bank of Tokyo Mitsubishi UFJ and Bangkok Bank of Thailand, ICBC will at first only be allowed to offer limited services. The new government licenses—the first after decades in which overseas banks were barred from having operations in Burma beyond setting up a representative office—do not allow the banks to offer retail banking.

Xinhua said that ICBC, which is considered the world's largest bank in terms of assets, had also signed a deal with one of Burma's biggest local banks, Serge Pun's Yoma Bank.

The deal was "on facilitation of the direct flow of trade-related funds between Myanmar and China, according to a press release of the Myanmar bank," Xinhua said.

"In addition, the ICBC also signed agreements with some Chinese companies on related business links," the report said.

Japanese Machinery Firm Wants to Supply Jade Miners

Japanese machinery producer Komatsu has officially opened its new plant in the central Burma city of Mandalay, with an official statement saying the company hopes to cash in on the county's controversial jade mining sector.

According to company statement, Komatsu has been selling and servicing its products—which include diggers and trucks used for mining—in Burma since 1995, but is now expanding into production. Through subsidiary Komatsu Manufacturing Myanmar Ltd, the firm has set up the new Mandalay plant primarily to remanufacture equipment for the mining and construction sectors. It will also manufacture generators, the statement said.

"In addition to its rapid economic development for the last few years, we are expecting growth in demand for construction and mining equipment in the long term there, as Myanmar is a leading producer of jades in the world," the statement added.

While jade exports remain sanctioned by the United States over concerns that the trade fuels conflict and human rights abuses, international companies not impacted by the embargo are already likely profiting from it. Terex Trucks, a subsidiary of Sweden's Volvo Group, has declared it is supplying diggers to a jade-mining firm.

Swiss Logistics Firm Hopes to Capitalize on Growing Energy Sector

Switzerland-based company Panalpina is hoping to that its new freight business in Burma will tap into the growing energy industry in the country.

The company, which says it provides "supply chain solutions," said in a statement this week that it had established a new office in Rangoon in August.

"Panalpina's team on site is able to handle end-to-end ocean and air freight shipments, both imports and exports, for local and international customers," it said.

The company said its biggest opportunities in the country are in telecommunications, manufacturing and, especially, oil and gas. The energy sector is set to boom as international and local companies explore a raft of new offshore and onshore blocks for hydrocarbons following competitive tenders in the last few years.

"Apart from transport infrastructure, power plants, refineries and gas terminals need to be built," it said. "Myanmar has vast offshore natural gas reserves and is rich with oil deposits and other natural resources such as gemstones and minerals."

Thorsten Harenberg, country manager for Panalpina Myanmar, said in the statement that: "We expect our Energy Solutions team to be heavily involved, as the country develops in the coming years."

"In the short term, both air and ocean imports will be driving the business," he added. "Exports will be limited until the country develops a viable manufacturing industry. Further down the road we also intend to offer value-added logistics services."

 

The post The Irrawaddy Business Roundup (Sept. 12, 2015) appeared first on The Irrawaddy.