Thursday, December 10, 2015

Shan Herald Agency for News

Shan Herald Agency for News

What can Burma learn from Colombia’s peace process?

Posted: 10 Dec 2015 01:18 AM PST

On December 2, a 14-person delegation from Burma flew halfway across the world to Colombia to see what the Latin American nation can teach the peacemakers in our own war-torn country.
This is especially true when a deadline has been set for the signing of a Colombian peace deal on March 23, 2016, after which the country's biggest rebel organization, the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) will be abandoning its weapons within six months. In early November, The Economist described it as "a peace process that could become an example to the world.
The delegation from Burma consisted of five representatives from the Burma Army, two from the Myanmar Peace Center (MPC) and the rest from the Karen armed movements that have signed Burma's Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement (NCA).
The delegation in Colombia. 
There are many things about Colombia which are similar to Burma. It has:
  • 68 ethnic languages and dialects
  • A population of 48 million
  • Endured more than 51 years of war
  • Deep involvement in the war by an international superpower (in this case the United States)
  • A deep-rooted illicit drug problem
  • Undergone peace negotiations that began in 2012
There are also many other things which are different:
  • The belligerents will not have a comprehensive peace and ceasefire deal until March 2016. FARC has declared a unilateral ceasefire, but the government led by Juan Manuel Santos has only maintained a "de-escalation" policy which nevertheless has brought down conflict-related violence, according to a think-tank in Bogota (the Colombian capital)
  • Formal negotiations, unlike in Burma, are conducted in a third country (Cuba)
  • FARC, due to countless reports alleging that it has committed murder, rape, kidnapping, bombings and forced recruitment of children, is very unpopular. Millions took part in demonstrations against it in 2008.
  • The agenda for negotiations has only six dialogue items, (compared to six main topics and 32 sub-topic items in Burma) out of which four are already completed.
These main topics are:
  • Rural development and land issues (Already agreed)
  • Safeguards for participation in politics (Already agreed)
  • Cooperation against illicit drugs and for crop substitution programmes (Already agreed)
  • Rights of victims, also known as Transitional Justice (Already agreed)
  • Ending the conflict, including a bilateral ceasefire and disarmament, demobilization and reintegration (DDR) (Yet to reach agreement)
  • Implementation (Yet to reach agreement)
Among Colombia's dialogue topics, one appears to be conspicuously absent from Burma's: Transitional Justice.
According to The Economist, those who confess to their crimes and collaborate with a truth commission in Colombia will benefit from light sentences: five to eight years of community work with "effective restrictions on liberty" but no jail time. Those who do not confess will face up to 20 years in jail if convicted. These measures will apply to both FARC and the government officers.
One thing seems to be certain. The Burmese delegation will definitely learn from the Colombian experience and vice versa.
By SAI KHUENSAI / Director, Pyidaungsu Institute and Founder, Shan Herald Agency for News (SHAN)
All views expressed are the author's own.

Displaced Ta’ang relocate after Burma Army burns their village—twice

Posted: 10 Dec 2015 12:52 AM PST

Over 170 civilians resettled to a nearby community on Tuesday after their own village in northern Shan State was burned by the Burma Army twice in less than 30 days.  


Bang Gan village, in Nam Tu Township, was once home to 35 ethnic Ta'ang households. The displaced have built makeshift shelters on nearby paddy fields and resettled in a monastery in another village, Wan San, preferring to stay near their ancestral land rather than relocate to a city.

Remnants of Bang Gan, the village burned by Burma Army troops (top left and right), and the makeshift shelters constructed by the area's IDPs (bottom left and right) (Photo: Shan Youth Network)
Villagers told SHAN that in mid-November, about 300 government troops from Battalion 88 accused Bang Gan's residents of supporting the Ta'ang National Liberation Army (TNLA), with whom SHAN reported that the Burma Army has been fighting in renewed clashes in the area.


One 37-year-old local man, Ai La, was detained by the Burma Army and forced to work as a porter. The villagers allege that on November 13 he was killed in a clash with the TNLA.


"The battle happened at a distance from the village," said one villager, Ai Yi. "After that, the Burma Army burned our village on November 14 and 29."


When government forces set fire to Bang Gan village for the first time, locals said that not all households were destroyed. However, after the second attack, the entire community was made inhabitable. Between and after the incidents, residents said they hid in the nearby forest.


Due to ongoing active conflict, it was not until December 8 that SHAN was able to obtain photos of the burned land and houses in Bang Gan.  


"We ran away and took nothing," said the village head, who did not want to provide his name.
Among the displaced are Ai La's wife and young children—a three-year-old son and one-year-old daughter.


According to The Border Consortium and Burma Link, in the last 20 years, more than 3,700 villages in Burma have been destroyed and its residents forced to relocate. The United Nations Refugee Agency (UNHCR) estimates that Burma's population of internally displaced people is well over 500,000.


By SIMMA FRANCIS and ZAAI ZAAI LAO MURNG / Shan Herald Agency for News (S.H.A.N)
Posted by at

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)