Monday, August 12, 2013

Democratic Voice of Burma

Democratic Voice of Burma


UN envoy arrives in Sittwe following clashes between Rohingya, police

Posted: 12 Aug 2013 05:29 AM PDT

UN special rapporteur on human rights Tomas Quintana arrived in Arakan state on Monday days after clashes between local police and Rohingya Muslims left at least seven people injured.

With tensions rising between authorities and the state's Muslim communities, Quintana was met by Arakanese Buddhist protesters Monday who made it clear they were wary of foreign interference in the restive state, where relations between Buddhists and Rohingya remain inflamed after two bouts of religious violence last year left hundreds dead and more than 140,000 people displaced.

"The rally took place at the airport as [Quintana] was arriving. There was no shouting of [slogans] – the participants were peacefully protesting and carrying signs, and there wasn't that many [participants]," said Arakan state's government spokesperson Win Myaing.

During the demonstration, protestors held banners calling Mr. Quintana “one-sided” and accused the envoy of backing Arakan state's Muslim population.

“Whatever he decides to put in his report, I want him to do it correctly and justly,” said Nya Ae from the Rakhine Women's Network during an interview with Reuters.

Despite the demonstration against the envoy's visit, Quintana said he was glad to see people exercising their right to protest.

“It’s great that people have the right to demonstrate here in Myanmar (Burma). That shows they have the possibility to express themselves. That’s important. We need to hear all voices,” said Quintana.

The commencement of Quintana's 10-day trip comes after reports surfaced over the weekend that at least seven people were injured when a group of Rohingya Muslims clashed with the police last Friday.

The unrest reportedly erupted after the body of a Muslim fisherman washed ashore. While authorities claimed the victim drowned after a boat capsized, members from the Rohingya community said the victim was beaten to death.

According to Win Myaing, a mob surrounded a local police outpost in Sittwe and demanded that authorities hand over the body to the crowd. When the police refused to give into the mob's demand, Win Myaing claims the crowd set fire to a police guard post and about three or four buildings nearby that were previously housed by customs officials.

"I assume the incident was orchestrated because Mr. Quintana is coming for a visit," said the Arakan state spokesperson.

"It's not very nice of the [Rohingya] to come up like this when we are trying to work things out for both societies."

In March, the UN envoy released a statement claiming he had received reports of "state involvement" in the violence between Buddhists and Muslims.

In his statement, Quintana pointed to "instances where the military, police and other civilian law enforcement forces have been standing by while atrocities have been committed before their very eyes, including by well organised ultra-nationalist Buddhist mobs.

"This may indicate direct involvement by some sections of the State or implicit collusion and support for such actions."

Quintana is set to visit Arakan, Kachin, Shan and Chin states. The UN representative is scheduled to visit IDP camps in northern Arakan state's Butheedaung on Monday afternoon.

-Ko Htwe and Shwe Aung provided additional reporting

Ministry to meet with civil society groups to discuss controversial association bill

Posted: 12 Aug 2013 03:22 AM PDT

Representatives from civil society groups are scheduled to meet with officials from the Ministry of Home Affairs later this week to discuss the controversial associations draft bill that was presented to the parliament by the government body late last month.

According to the draft, parties hoping to form associations must seek permission to register with a Home Affairs body led by the minister, who has the mandate to decide whether or not to approve the group's request.

On 27 July, dozens of civil society groups slammed the draft claiming the bill violates provisions in the 2008 constitution that provide citizens with the right to freely join associations and organisations.

"The freedom of association is already specified by the constitution so we don't really like this idea about having to seek permission to start an organisation," said LGBT advocate Aung Myo Min from Equality Myanmar during an interview with DVB.

"This is basically an attempt to restrict a constitutional right by enacting another law."

Founders of organisations who fail to register their groups can also be sentenced to up to three years in prison, according to the bill.

"Generally, NGOs and civil society organisations are to provide mostly social assistance and it is unreasonable to jail people for three years just because they don't register their organisations," said Ko Ni, a Rangoon-based attorney.

"The jail punishment for not registering an organisation violates the freedom of association provided by the article 354(c) of the constitution."

Earlier this month, a delegation from various civil society organisations met with parliamentary representatives in Naypyidaw where officials pledged to schedule a future meeting with the Ministry of Home Affairs so the groups could air their grievances concerning the current draft directly.

Dr Kyaw Thu, a well known civil liberties advocate, urged government officials to allow civil society groups to play a more participatory role in drafting the bill.

"Every human being has a right to form an association or be a part of one, and the associations have freedom to voice their opinion, form independent networks with each other and seek funding and the government should legally protect these rights," said Dr Kyaw Thu.

"We stressed with the parliament that the bill should see to protect the rights of civil societies to allow them to legally and effectively operate."

Kyaw Thu emphasised the instrumental role civil society organisations played in democracies and said such groups were pivotal in addressing and publicising local grievances with the Latpadaung Copper Mine in central Burma's Sagain division and the Tavoy Deep-sea Port in southern Burma's Tenasserim.

-Shwe Aung provided additional reporting

Schools set to offer courses in ethnic languages

Posted: 12 Aug 2013 02:21 AM PDT

For the first time in more than 40 years, students in Burma will soon be able to learn their ethnic languages in government-run schools.

The country's quasi-civilian government has launched a new education plan to bring teaching more in line with international standards and starting in June next year, the teaching of ethnic languages will be allowed in state schools.

“We don’t understand Burmese”, said Ji Pan, an eight-year-old student whose mother tongue is Kachin.

“Then the teacher beats us, so many people stopped going to school.”

As many as 60 percent of children in Burma fail to graduate because of language barriers, according to the exile-based rights group Canadian Friends of Burma

Nai Maung Toe from the Mon Language Literature and Cultural Organisation tells a similar story.

“They’re forced to learn the language. Sometimes they get depressed or afraid of the language. And one of the reasons that many children drop out of primary school is language,” he said.

Under the country's former military dictatorships that ruled Burma for more than four decades, only the teaching of Burmese was allowed in state schools.

Chan Kakao, a student from the Mon ethnic group, said he had only been allowed to study his own language during the holidays.

“If we only learn our ethnic language during the summer, it will only be for a month. At school, we learn for nine months a year. It is more effective”, he said.

Even with the new changes, most classes will still be taught in the Burmese language, but after 3pm select classes will be offered in ethnic languages.

However, Nai Maung Toe said he believed ethnic languages be integrated into school’s standard curriculum.

“Children are studying from nine in the morning until three in the afternoon,” said Nai Maung Toe. “If we teach the local languages after 3pm, it is too much for them. It is like torturing them.”

He added there would be significant benefits to integrating ethnic languages into the mainstream teaching.

“Learning your own language can maintain your culture and literature,” he said. “Otherwise our ethnic group will disappear from the world.”

Indonesian officials arrest alleged fundraiser behind Burmese embassy plot

Posted: 12 Aug 2013 12:50 AM PDT

Indonesian police have arrested the alleged fundraiser of a failed plot to bomb the Burmese embassy in the capital Jakarta in May, an official said Monday.

Authorities were also investigating whether Muhammad Syaiful Sabani, detained in the central Javanese city of Yogyakarta on Friday, is linked to a recent bomb attack on a Buddhist temple in the capital, police said.

Both the embassy plot and temple bombing highlighted growing anger in Muslim-majority Indonesia at the plight of the persecuted Rohingya Muslim minority in Burma, where a majority of the population is Buddhist.

The police’s elite anti-terror squad arrested Sabani in a car park near a hotel in Yogyakarta, national police spokesman Ronny Sompie, told AFP.

“He has been named a suspect for helping to raise funds to finance the bombing of the Myanmar (Burmese) embassy,” he said.

Sompie said a second man was arrested along with Sabani and police were investigating whether he was linked to the embassy plot.

Police foiled the plot on May 2 when they detained two men with a backpack holding five pipe bombs, who had allegedly been planning to launch an attack the following day.

Later the same month, they detained the alleged mastermind of the plot and a second man suspected of being the bombmaker.

Sompie said Sabani was linked to the alleged mastermind and bombmaker, and “was assigned to source funds”.

“We believe he could be behind several robberies at gold shops,” he said.

On 4 August, a low-intensity bomb exploded at one of Jakarta’s biggest Buddhist temples as hundreds of worshippers prayed, lightly injuring one person.

At the time police said the bomb package bore the words “we are responding to the screams of the Rohingya”.

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Burma Awards Contracts to Build, Expand International Airports

Posted: 12 Aug 2013 05:06 AM PDT

A view of the main building at Yangon International Airport. (PHOTO: Reuters)

RANGOON — Burma has awarded contracts to expand two existing airports and build a new international airport, amid the growing demands of tourism in a country which expects to see annual foreign arrivals rise from about 2 million to 7 million by 2020.

A contract to expand Burma's main international airport, Yangon International Airport, has been awarded to a consortium led by Pioneer Aerodrome Services Co., an affiliate of the major Burmese conglomerate Asia World, which is run by Steven Law, who is still on the US sanctions list.

Steven Law, also known as Tun Myint Naing, is the son of the recently deceased Burmese drug kingpin Lo Hsing Han. US companies are forbidden from doing business with him due to his connection to Burma's former military regime and involvement in the illicit drug trade.

Malaysian and Singaporean companies are also part of the consortium to expand the airport near Burma's biggest city and commercial capital, Rangoon.

Apart from Yangon International Airport—which currently has a capacity to handle 2.7 million passengers annually—a new international hub will be built by South Korea's state-run Incheon International Airport Corp (IIAC).

The new hub, Hanthawaddy International Airport, will be built in Pegu, about 50 miles northeast of Rangoon. The airport is expected to handle 12 million passengers a year, according to South Korea's transport ministry.

On Sunday, the ministry said in a statement that the final contract for the Hanthawaddy project—worth over US $1 billion—would be signed at the end of the year. The facility will be finished by 2018 and will be the country's second-biggest international airport, according to Burma’s Department of Civil Aviation.

Meanwhile, a consortium of Mitsubishi Corp., Japan Airlines Corp. and SPA Project Management Ltd. won a contract on Saturday to repair and operate an international airport serving Mandalay, Burma's second-biggest city.

Established in 2000, the existing Mandalay airport is currently a domestic aviation hub capable of handling 600,000 passengers a year. Located in central Burma, the airport flies to 12 cities across the country and saw a 20 percent growth in annual passengers last year, with 500,000 domestic passengers and some 80,000 international passengers.

Since President Thein Sein came to power in 2011, Burma has embarked on a series of political and economic reforms, prompting warming relations with the international community and a growing number of visitors. In addition to a surge in foreign tourists, the country has attracted world leaders, international investors and foreign businesspeople.

Last year hotel rooms were in short supply due to the extra arrivals, and Burma's government warned the number of foreign visitors was set to exceed the annual capacity of 2.7 million that Yangon International Airport could handle.

Two Rohingya Killed by Police in Arakan: State Govt

Posted: 12 Aug 2013 04:06 AM PDT

An armed policeman observes a scene at unofficial camp for displaced Rohingya in Sittwe Township. (Photo: Jpaing / The Irrawaddy)

At least two Rohingya Muslims were killed by police and seven others were injured in Sittwe, according to the regional government, which said the violence came during two incidents involving unruly mobs in the capital of Arakan State.

Win Myaing, a spokesperson for the Arakan State government, confirmed to The Irrawaddy on Monday that one person died on Sunday at a hospital in Sittwe, where he was receiving treatment for gunshot wounds. Another person's death was reported by Rohingya community leaders from Ohn Htaw Gyi, a camp for internally displaced persons (IDPs).

"One person died yesterday and another one we found out about from their people at the camp, but they did not show the dead body to us," Win Myaing said.

He said his government had provided compensation to the victims' families, giving them 200,000 kyat (US$205) each for those wounded and 400,000 kyat to families of the deceased.

Gunfire rang out in two separate incidents on Friday, the first after an angry mob gathered outside a police outpost in the morning demanding that the body of a fellow Rohingya who had drowned the day prior be handed over. Police reportedly refused to provide the body, provoking a skirmish between the two sides.

Local sources said later that evening, another clash took place at the Buduwa IDP camp, nearby to Ohn Htaw Gyi. Police there reportedly fired into a crowd that had gathered in relation to the drowning victim.

Citing a "Rohingya spokesman," the Rangoon-based Myanmar Times reported that at least five people were killed during the clashes on Friday.

The state-run Burmese-language newspaper Myanma Alin did not report any fatalities. It said eight people were detained after a group of some 500 Rohingya gathered at the police outpost to collect the drowned Rohingya body. The newspaper said police used rubber bullets to disperse the crowd, which grew increasingly aggressive. One police officer, Htay Win, was beaten by the mob, Myanma Alin reported.

The Rohingya are a Muslim minority found mainly in Arakan State. They are denied citizenship by the Burmese government, which considers them illegal "Bengali" immigrants from neighboring Bangladesh, despite the fact that many of them have been living in Burma for generations.

International human rights groups and the UN human rights envoy have criticized the government's handling of the crisis in western Burma, where Arakanese Buddhists clashed with Rohingya in June and October 2012. The unrest led to nearly 200 deaths and displaced about 140,000 people, mostly Rohingya Muslims.

Student Army Marks 8888 Anniversary by Signing Truce With Govt

Posted: 12 Aug 2013 03:34 AM PDT

ABSDF fighters eat a meal near the frontline in Kachin State, in December 2012. (Photo: Simon Roughneen / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON – The Burma government and the All Burma Students' Democratic Front (ABSDF) announced a truce on Saturday that will see the long-time antagonists start a political dialogue, in a possible end to a quarter century of on-off armed rebellion by the former students against what was one of the world's most brutal military regimes.

The deal, which could see the ABSDF open four liaison offices inside Burma, comes two days after the now-40-something leaders of the 1988 student uprising against the military regime marked their Silver Jubilee with three days of ceremony and speeches in Rangoon.

Both government ministers and opposition presidential candidate Aung San Suu Kyi, whose own political career was launched on the back of the uprising, attended the festivities.

The Burmese junta's brutal crackdown on the demonstrations prompted some student demonstrators to form a militia aimed at overthrowing it: the ABSDF.

Minister Aung Min, the government's main peace negotiator, told The Irrawaddy that the deal illustrated the changes sweeping Burma. "The essence of the gathering was that people who once fought against each other can share the same room—and this is a testament to the moves we are making toward democracy," he said.

Since ushering through a series of reforms in March 2011, the Burma government has freed political prisoners, including the key 1988 student leaders, and relaxed bans on trade unions and public protests.

But in the past few days, leaders of a march through Rangoon commemorating the 1988 events have been charged with holding a public protest without a permit. Protestors against land-grabs have also been jailed in recent months.

And although there are 17 ceasefires signed or in negotiation, according to the Myanmar Peace Monitor, a project set up to track the various peace processes, fighting between the Burma Army and ethnic rebels continues in northern Shan and Kachin states.

In a prelude to Saturday's agreement, the ABSDF signed a regional deal with the Karen State government on August 5.

Than Khe, chairman of the ABSDF, described Saturday's deal as a "first step," adding that progress "depends on the attitude of the government."

But it seems that the ABSDF will focus on negotiations, rather than armed struggle, in the future. "Our uprising was for democracy and human rights," Than Khe told The Irrawaddy, before adding that "now we have to go ahead with this new path, this political new phase."

International observers were present as the deal was signed on Saturday. Emma Leslie, executive director of the Phnom Penh-based Center for Peace and Conflict Studies, told The Irrawaddy that the agreement was significant because it was "the first union-level deal between the government and the ABSDF."

Also in attendance was Thein Zaw, vice-chairman of the Union Peacemaking Work Committee and chairman of the Parliament Committee on National Race Affairs and Internal Peacemaking.

In July, House speaker and presidential hopeful Shwe Mann sought greater Parliament input into the various peace talks between the government and rebel militias, a move widely seen as an attempt to bolster his own standing ahead of Burma's 2015 national elections.

88 Generation leaders Min Ko Naing and Ko Ko Gyi—fresh from their gala commemorations—served as observers to the peace talks, as did Mya Aye, another student demonstrator in 1988, who told The Irrawaddy that "it was a smooth negotiation and it went well."

Informal negotiations between the government and the ABSDF have been taking place for almost two years, said Aung Naing Oo, a former ABSDF member who now works for government-linked think-tank the Myanmar Peace Center.

"Things took time at first," he told The Irrawaddy. "But in the last few days the talks went very well and very smoothly."

The army’s 1988 crackdown killed an estimated 3,000 civilians, prompting some protestors to take to Burma's jungle borderlands. The 25 years of sporadic fighting since then have cost the lives of 600 ABSDF fighters.

Since then, the "student army" has struck alliances with a number of Burma's ethnic militias and lost 600 fighters in anti-government fighting. Dozens of members were executed amid internal purges during the 1990s, and for a time the ABSDF was listed as a terrorist organization by the United States.

The ABSDF has set up a Truth and Justice Commission to look into the killings. Criminal proceedings have been started by family members of some of the deceased.

Meeting Between Govt, Journalists Yields No Breakthrough on Media Bills

Posted: 12 Aug 2013 02:16 AM PDT

Information Minister Aung Kyi gestures during a press conference in Rangoon on Monday. (Photo: Steve Tickner / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — A stand-off between the Burma government and local journalists over proposed media laws looks set to continue, with Burma's Upper House continuing to mull a controversial publishing bill that would give the Ministry of Information broad powers to issue and revoke publishing licenses.

Information Minister Aung Kyi met with members of Burma's interim Press Council, a journalists' organization, in Rangoon on Monday morning, but according to Myint Kyaw, a journalist and council member, there was no discussion of the terms of the Printers and Publishers Registration Bill, or of the council's own draft press law.

"We just agreed to continuing discussions but otherwise there were no details discussed," he told The Irrawaddy.

The meeting, which finished early, ended with a proposal by the ministry that the Press Council discuss the ministry's proposed "social responsibility" code for the country's media—terminology redolent of restrictive press regimes elsewhere in Southeast Asia in recent decades.

"We explained this [social responsibility] to the interim Press Council and we will await their views," Deputy Information Minister Ye Htut told The Irrawaddy. Myint Kyaw told The Irrawaddy that the council would meet soon to discuss the social responsibility concept.

Asked whether Burma's government had examined media laws in other countries, such as Malaysia, where publications have been subject to similar licensing provisions as those proposed for Burma, Aung Kyi told The Irrawaddy that "we have looked at examples such as France and India." The most important criteria in drafting the law, the Minister added, were not external examples, but "our own customs and needs."

Press Council members, on Monday clad in white T-shirts emblazoned with the slogan "Give freedom to Media Law for the People to get truth," have said they will resign if the Printers and Publishers Registration Bill is passed into law as it stands. The council wants publishing licenses to be regulated under commercial rather than media laws.

"We welcome that there is difference of opinion over these laws," Ye Htut told The Irrawaddy. "It is normal in a democratic society."

The bill is currently being discussed by the Upper House of Burma's Parliament. It was passed by the Lower House on July 4. "We gave our feedback to the Upper House on July 24," said Myint Kyaw. "We hope they will make some changes to the bill before passing it."

The draft legislation contains vague language banning criticism of Burma's 2008 Constitution, as well as the prospect of publishing licenses being withheld or revoked by the Ministry of Information.

Ye Htut said the Printers and Publishers Registration Bill could be sent back to the Lower House for further consideration. "We cannot say what will happen," he told The Irrawaddy. "It came from the Lower House so perhaps the Upper House will make changes and send it back."

The Press Council is preparing to send its own press law to Parliament for consideration, Myint Kyaw said. The Ministry of Information had previously sought amendments to the council's draft, but the council has rebuffed those suggestions.

"We decided to put to Parliament through an MP, not from USDP [the ruling Union Solidarity and Development Party], not from NLD [opposition National League for Democracy]," Myint Kyaw told The Irrawaddy. "But through the New National Democratic Party and MP Thein Nyunt," he said.

The Press Council will meet with opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi on Tuesday to discuss the various media codes. The council's own draft is intended as a professional code for journalists, while the government contends that the Printers and Publishers Registration Bill is an enterprise-related law. Media watchdogs have criticized the latter bill, however, for alleged mission creep, saying that it strays into content regulation.

Veteran Burmese Journalist Maung Wuntha Dies

Posted: 12 Aug 2013 01:58 AM PDT

Journalist Maung Wuntha passed away on Sunday at the age of 68. (Photo: Facebook / Maung Wuntha)

Maung Wuntha, a veteran Burmese journalist who also served as deputy chairman of the country's interim Press Council, succumbed to cancer on Sunday. He was 68 years old.

His son Naung Naung Soe confirmed Maung Wuntha's death to The Irrawaddy, saying his father passed away after a battle with lung cancer at Rangoon's Victoria Hospital, where he had undergone treatment for more than a month.

"We still haven't confirmed the date for the funeral as we are waiting for one of our family members who is far from home," Naung Naung Soe added.

Born Soe Thein, the man widely known by the pen name Maung Wuntha entered journalism in the 1960s, working for government newspapers. He was forced to resign as editor of the Botahtaung daily newspaper for his active participation in Burma's 1988 pro-democracy uprising. He was formerly a member of the National League for Democracy (NLD), and was imprisoned for several years after winning a seat in Burma's 1990 parliamentary elections, the results of which were ignored by the ruling military regime of the time. Maung Wuntha was detained on three separate occasions over the years.

Since his last release in 2001, Maung Wuntha had stepped back from active participation in politics, instead resuming his career as a journalist. He thrived in the relative openness that Burma's media have enjoyed since a quasi-civilian government took power in March 2011, writing regularly about political developments in the country and acting as an editorial adviser to the People's Age journal. He offered praise and criticism of the new government in equal measure, urging President Thein Sein to release political prisoners and end Burma's long-running ethnic conflicts.

Maung Wuntha was also quick to embrace the Internet age and social media, using Facebook to communicate with Burmese exile communities around the world. He also took to Facebook to announce his cancer diagnosis in October of last year.

When the country's interim Press Council was founded in 2012, Maung Wuntha took a leading role in fighting for press freedom in Burma, according to Pe Myint, an editor of the People's Age as well as a fellow council member. Maung Wuntha was also president of the Myanmar Journalists Association (MJA).

Pe Myint on Sunday praised Maung Wuntha as a prolific writer who had closely followed Burma's political progress over the years.

"He was always on alert when it came to politics in the country," Pe Myint said. "So there are many people who enjoyed reading his commentary column in our journal. His death is a loss for us."

Apart from his journalistic endeavors, Maung Wuntha is well known for his translations of biographies on US Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, Israeli military leader Moshe Dayan and Egyptian President Anwar Sadat.

Maung Wuntha is survived by his wife Myint Myint, four children and two grandchildren.

J-League Looks to Extend Influence in SE Asia

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 11:32 PM PDT

Ganso, center, of Copa Sudamericana champion Sao Paulo fights for the ball against Yuya Osako, left, and Mitsuo Ogasawara of J League Yamazaki Nabisco Cup champion Kashima Antlers during the Suruga Bank football championship match in Kashima, east of Tokyo on August 7, 2013. (Photo: Reuters)

SEOUL, South Korea — The English Premier League has long dominated the popularity of international football in Southeast Asia. It's newest rival for regional audiences comes not from the major leagues of Spain or Italy, but from Japan.

The J-League, established in 1993 and generally regarded as Asia's best domestic competition, does not have the history or the prestige of the big European leagues. But while English clubs like Manchester United and Liverpool often play a friendly in Bangkok or Kuala Lumpur every couple of years, the J-League insists it is committed to developing football in Southeast Asia for the long-term and at a number of levels.

Over the past two years, the J-League has signed separate partnership agreements with leagues in Thailand, Vietnam, Cambodia, Singapore and Burma which involve the exchange of expertise on and off the field.

Japanese clubs have established relationships with teams in the region, and from 2012 Thailand, Vietnam and Burma started broadcasting J-League games with more countries expected to follow suit.

"We fully understand how popular the English Premier League is in Southeast Asia," Daisuke Nakanishi, J-League director of competitions and sales management, told The Associated Press. "That's why we think that there is no way of winning if we apply the same approach in the market, and we believe that we should do something different."

Nakanishi says Japan's league has two advantages over the European leagues.

"We are in Asia, so we are close to the region geographically and mentally, and Japan is the only country which used to be very weak but has grown rapidly in very short period," he said. "So we can be a role model. We are more than happy to share our know how with Southeast Asia in order to develop together."

The size and global reach of the top English clubs mean that any partnerships they form in Southeast Asia are unequal. In the past, local clubs have sometimes been reduced to becoming little more than merchandise sellers for the big teams.

On the pitch it can be a similar story. In 2007, three of Thailand's top players famously joined Manchester City, then owned by the country's former Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra, yet none made it close to a Premier League appearance and soon departed. The J-League is good but not to the extent that it is a closed door for Southeast Asian talent.

"In the near future, we hope that there will be many star Southeast Asian players playing in the J-League, which makes the J-League more visible and popular in the region," Nakanishi said. "This is a unique approach which the English Premier League does not have."

Worawi Makudi, president of the Thailand Football Association, agrees that Japan has much to offer as a role model to follow for developing nations in Asia as it has come a long way in a short time.

"At the moment in the [Southeast Asian] region the English Premier League is popular and is tough to beat, but maybe the Japanese league in terms of broadcasting rights can grow," Worawi said. "If Japanese clubs have Thai players then people in Thailand would like to watch them."

There are plans to make it easier for the best Thai stars to head east. Much could depend on the success of Le Cong Vinh, who has been one of the biggest stars in Vietnam and the region for a number of years.

The striker had a short but unsuccessful spell with Portuguese club Leixoes in 2009 and last month joined Consadole Sapporo, which was last season relegated to Japan's second tier. Ngo Le Bang, general secretary of the Vietnamese Football Federation has high hopes for the player.

"Le Cong Vinh is one of our best players," Bang said. "Firstly his appearance in Japan, even in the second division, could promote the image of Vietnamese football, and then after him there could be other opportunities."

Bang says the experience the country's players could receive in Japan will benefit the Vietnamese national team and professional league.

"The reputation of the J-League is improving partly due to the increasing number of players from Japan heading to the top leagues of Europe. Their football players have made huge progress in domestic and international competitions. … Japan shows how a team can compete equally against physically stronger teams."

The Vietnamese striker does not see himself as a figurehead for the new relationship between Southeast Asia and Japan. He just wants to play.

"I think the J-League is the best league in Asia and I believe that I can learn a lot of things here," Le said said. "That's why I decided to come here. … I am ready to show my strengths to the fans."

It won't be just fans in Vietnam who will be watching with interest to see if Le is able to do so.

Man Arrested After Allegedly Selling Burmese Migrants into Slavery

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 10:29 PM PDT

Burmese human trafficking victims are seen last year in Thailand's Chonburi Province after Thai authorities rescued them from a fishing boat they were forced to work on. Over the weekend, Thai police said they had arrested and charged a suspected human trafficker who allegedly sold hundreds of migrants from Burma into slavery to work in Thailand's fishing industry. (Photo: Kyaw Thaung)

BANGKOK — Thai authorities have arrested and charged a suspected human trafficker who allegedly sold hundreds of migrants from Burma into slavery to work in Thailand's fishing industry, police said Saturday.

Ko Myo, a 42-year-old Burma national, was captured in a raid by police and justice officials on Aug. 1 in Thailand's southern province of Surat Thani and faces human trafficking charges, said Police Maj. Gen. Chavalit Sawangpuech.

"This is a very significant case as Ko Myo is the leader of one of most notorious human trafficking rings in Thailand," Chavalit said. "He is an agent with a large client base, who has abused his own countrymen on Thai soil for 10 years."

Ko Myo is being held in custody at a hospital after sustaining gunshot wounds during the raid.

Chavalit said police were also investigating his alleged involvement in the rape and killing of a Burmese woman in March in Thailand's Trang province, on the Andaman coast.

Three of Ko Myo's close aides were arrested in separate raids. All three face human trafficking charges, while two were also charged with rape and murder of the same Burmese woman.

Chavalit said Thai police would reach out to their counterparts in Burma to try to arrest more human trafficking suspects.

The London-based Environmental Justice Foundation said in a statement Friday that it welcomed the capture of the suspects and called for parties "to work together to prevent human trafficking in Thai seafood production and bring an end to this devastating practice."

Typhoon Batters Philippines; 23 Fishermen Missing

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 10:19 PM PDT

An aerial view of devastated coastal Banganga town more than one month after Typhoon Bopha hit Davao Oriental in southern Philippines, seen from a military helicopter on January 16, 2013. Another typhoon, known as Typhoon Utor, struck the northern Philippines on Monday. (Photo: Reuters)

MANILA, Philippines — A powerful typhoon struck the northern Philippines on Monday, toppling power lines and dumping heavy rains across mountains, cities and food-growing plains and leaving at least 23 fishermen missing.

Typhoon Utor, described as the strongest typhoon globally so far this year, slammed ashore in mountainous eastern Aurora province with sustained winds of 175 kilometers (109 miles) per hour and gusts of up to 210 kph (130 mph).

About 1,000 residents in the central Bicol region spent the night in shelters while Aurora province was without power, the national disaster agency said. Radio stations reported roofs were blown off and a covered basketball court washed away in Dinalungan town.

There was no immediate word on casualties, but 23 fishermen who were out at sea failed to return home in four towns in Catanduanes province, according to their families. Authorities were hoping they just took shelter in coves and nearby islands, said Office of Civil Defense regional director Bernardo Alejandro IV.

"I hope they're just waiting for the typhoon to pass and will show up as soon as the weather clears," he said. A higher number of missing had been reported over the weekend, but some fishermen since returned home.

More than 8,000 travelers were stranded as passenger and cargo ferries were grounded.

Classes in towns and cities on the typhoon's path were suspended, including in the capital Manila, and several domestic flights canceled.

Utor was forecast to cut across the main northern island of Luzon on Monday and move into the South China Sea on Tuesday in the direction of Guangdong in China, expected to make landfall there Wednesday.

Utor is the 12th of about 20 storms and typhoons expected to lash the Philippines this year.

Curfew in Sri Lankan Capital After Mosque Attack

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 10:11 PM PDT

Sri Lanka's riot police patrol outside a vandalized mosque in Colombo on Sunday. (Photo: Reuters)

COLOMBO, Sri Lanka — Sri Lankan police on Saturday declared a curfew in the capital, Colombo, to prevent possible religious clashes after a Buddhist mob threw rocks and vandalized a mosque, injuring at least seven worshippers.

A trustee for the mosque in Colombo, A. Hameed, said that four of the seven worshippers hurt in the attack on Masjid Deenul Islam have been hospitalized.

Police spokesman Buddika Siriwardena said two police officers were injured while trying to prevent clashes between the Buddhist mob and Muslim youth who gathered to defend the mosque.

The attack comes amid a growing anti-Muslim campaign by Buddhist nationalist groups who consider Muslims, who make up 9 percent of the island nation's 20 million population, to be a threat to the political and economic well-being of the 70 percent ethnic Sinhalese-Buddhists.

"There is a limit to our patience, there is no point regretting if this breaks out into a major clash. But some fools do not understand this," said Mohamed Miflal, a Muslim community worker. "I ask the authorities give us enough protection."

Buddhist nationalist groups complain that Muslims are dominating businesses and are conspiring to take over the country demographically by increasing their birthrate and secretly sterilizing Sinhalese.

Since September 2011 more than 30 attacks on Muslim-owned businesses have been reported.

6 Killed by Indonesia Volcano Had Refused to Leave

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 09:56 PM PDT

An aerial view of Anak Krakatau volcano in Indonesia spewing ash and smoke in the Sunda strait in February. Indonesia is home to 129 active volcanoes. Another, Mount Rokatenda, erupted early on Saturday in East Nusa Tenggara province, and thousands were evacuated. (Photo: Reuters)

MAUMERE, Indonesia — The six people swept up and killed by hot lava from an erupting volcano in eastern Indonesia had refused to leave the area for safer ground when the mountain began rumbling last year, an official said Sunday, one day after the eruption.

Officials continued searching Sunday for the bodies of two children buried by the hot lava as rumbling could still be heard from Mount Rokatenda on the small island of Palue in East Nusa Tenggara province.

Nearly 3,000 people have been evacuated from the area since the volcano erupted early Saturday morning, according to the National Disaster Mitigation Agency. The volcano had been active since last October.

Tini Thadeus, head of the local disaster agency, said the six victims, who died while sleeping in a beachside village, were among those who had refused to leave last year when evacuations were carried out to establish a safety zone around the volcano.

"On their belief, if all the old villagers abandoned the red [danger] zone, then lava will destroy the residential area," Thadeus said from Kupang, the provincial capital. Among the dead was a 58-year-old woman, the grandmother of the two children who also died.

"But unfortunately, not like in the past, lava from Saturday's eruption flowed northward and hit them," Thadeus said, adding that during earlier eruptions since the 1930s, volcanic material had always flowed southward.

On nearby Flores island, Mutiara Mauboi, an official at the command post helping evacuees, said 138 had arrived Sunday in the town of Maumere. Eleven people, including two pregnant women and two disabled people, were taken to a hospital due to injuries sustained during the eruption.

The people who died included three adults and the two children. The age of the sixth person is not clear.

Thadeus said he was not optimistic about recovering the children's bodies since they were buried under hot volcanic material.

He said small explosions could still be heard coming from the peak, which was still spewing smoke up to 600 meters (656 yards) into the sky.

"But all of the villagers have been evacuated out of the danger zone" near the crater, he said.

Mount Rokatenda is one of 129 active volcanoes in Indonesia, an archipelago of more than 17,000 islands that's home to 240 million people. The country is prone to earthquakes and volcanic activity because it sits along the Pacific "Ring of Fire," a horseshoe-shaped series of fault lines.

The Ministry of Information prepares for some ‘preemptive pruning’

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 09:47 PM PDT

National News

National News


South Korean state-run operator gets airport contract

Posted: 12 Aug 2013 03:28 AM PDT

Myanmar has picked South Korea's state-run airport operator to build a new international hub near it's main city.

Sunday, August 11, 2013

National News

National News


NGO reps to meet MPs over draft law

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 09:56 AM PDT

Representatives from local NGOs in upper and lower Myanmar will meet this week to prepare for discussions with MPs over the draft Association Law, which will govern how non-government groups register and operate.

Monks demonstrate over media, U Wirathu bombing

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 09:41 AM PDT

Hundreds of monks in Mandalay staged an illegal demonstration last week, calling for "fairer" treatment in the international media and an end to terrorist acts.


Government, MPs set for another showdown

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 09:24 AM PDT

MPs have slammed the president for refusing to sign the Region/State Hluttaw Bill 2013 on the grounds that it is unconstitutional.

ABSDF, govt hold more talks following ceasefire

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 09:20 AM PDT

The All Burma Student's Democratic Front was scheduled to hold "union-level" peace talks over the weekend after signing a ceasefire agreement with government negotiators in Yangon earlier in the week.


Groups praise govt cooperation with Rakhine aid effort

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 09:15 AM PDT

Humanitarian groups say relief and recovery efforts in Rakhine State have proceeded faster than expected, thanks in part to the cooperation shown by state and national government officials.

Forgive, but do not forget

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 09:08 AM PDT

The photo exhibitions and videos brought the bloody crackdowns of 1988 back to life for many visitors – but 88 Generation leaders stressed the need for cooperation, not confrontation.


Don’t bear grudges: Daw Suu

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 08:58 AM PDT

It was the revolution that propelled Daw Aung San Suu Kyi to international stardom – but she said last week that she did not consider herself a part of the uprising.

Debate over justice for 1988

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 08:57 AM PDT

As activists and members of the public came together last week to mark the 25th anniversary of the 1988 uprising, a number of human rights groups and individuals also raised the prospect of justice for the estimated 3000 people killed.

Robust debate needed on constitution

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 08:50 AM PDT

Strengthening the separation of powers will make Myanmar more stable and attractive to investors.

Government working to harmonise investment rules

Posted: 11 Aug 2013 08:46 AM PDT

The government plans to amend bylaws, orders and instructions that do not match provisions in the Foreign Investment Law, a government official told parliament last week.

Saturday, August 10, 2013

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Mandalay’s New Day

Posted: 09 Aug 2013 09:32 PM PDT

Exploring art by his students, Suu Myint Thein encourages questions and discussion. (Photo: VIRGINIA HENDERSON / MANDALAY)

Voluptuous and provocative, she sure is. Suu Myint Thein's huge sculpture of a strong nude woman, perching precariously on the roof of the kooky art center on 69th Street is becoming a Mandalay icon—a celebrated symbol of freedom of expression and equality.

For 10 years she lay on the floor of a workshop at the Mandalay School of Art, covered with cloth and hidden from government advisors visiting to check on Suu Myint Thein's unconventional teaching at the institution. When the passionate art instructor eventually left the state system, he set out to forge an alternative path and follow his dream of reaching outside the city walls and teaching children to express their ideas and feelings through art.

The Mandalay Contemporary Art Centre (MCAC), which opened in March of last year, is a humming vibrant space with an extraordinary capacity to inspire and reach children. A successful partnership between AlinDagar Art School, Suu Myint Thein's own art school where he has taught summer intensive classes for 21 years, and the Dreamland Art Studio, created by artist Kyan Lee and her husband Arr Lone, MCAC brings together dedicated art trainers and supporters with many years' experience. The new artspace works on the underlying conditions for artistic freedom of expression, including addressing the lack of arts education in communities and schools. An active meeting place for young and old curious about art, MCAC explores the key theme of "art and politics" through innovative workshops and exhibitions with young people.

Bold art education outreach programs take the MCAC team to villages near and far from Mandalay, enabling thousands of young rural people to experience the wonders of art through stimulating and engaging activities. Many of the children had never done any art in their lives. The Colorful Light International Children's Art workshop and exhibition continues to grow, following road trips to Kyauk Mae, Lashio, Hsipaw and Nam Kham in Shan State, Myittha in Mandalay Region and Zi Gon in Bago Region. Large crowds of Shan, Kayin, Palaung, Danu, Myanmar and Chinese children and their parents participated in the drawing, painting and performance art activities, producing their own artworks which were exhibited, documented and shared at other venues. These days MCAC is being urged by the locals themselves to visit more towns, to come back soon, and to share their extraordinary teaching skills and approaches.

Suu Myint Thein explains: "For a long time, it's been my dream to go to many towns where the children have never been exposed to art. It was the first time they had done any drawing. The children thought that the artworks by kids overseas were great but then they did the workshop and saw their own work and realized their potential. They said to themselves, "I can do it!" The seed is planted for the future—for us to become an art college for kids."

MCAC's public performance art events have also attracted hundreds of participants. Supporting the revival and reinterpretation of traditional arts, during the Thingyan New Year's festival in April, MCAC performed with the country's first female Thangyat (traditional poetry and song) group, the Tamaryeit Women's Group, on stages around Mandalay.

In August of last year, former political prisoner Htein Lin, who now resides in the UK, worked with MCAC in a performance art workshop on freedom of expression, culminating in 12 public performances and outreach activities at a local monastery and monastic school.

Although he is known chiefly as a sculptor, Suu Myint Thein is also a highly respected painter and performance artist. In his Blue Man for Peace performance last September, he took to the streets completely wrapped in blue tape, walking slowly, saying nothing, but in doing so generating enormous public interest.

Curious crowds followed the artist until he was stopped by the police and taken to the station for creating a disturbance. Police told Suu Myint Thein they took him away for his own health, to protect him from exhaustion and the crowd. MCAC's artistic director reported overhearing people saying things like, "That's strange," "He's mad," and "It's some kind of art".

The outcome? Another successful challenge to the people, encouraging them to question and explore new ways of being and expressing ideas and feelings. Mission accomplished, for MCAC. And so it goes, seeking to push the boundaries of conventional thinking to create alternatives.

People who took part in Suu Myint Thein's Creative Art Workshop at MCAC every Wednesday from February to April 2013 said they had been given the chance, for the first time in their lives, to question teachers, discuss free expression and open their minds. They valued the new conversations and encouragement to explore alternative modes of expression. At the end-of-workshop group exhibition, "A Flight of Free Thoughts and Colors," in early June, the new artists were able to speak about the social and political messages in their bold and expressive artworks.

Student Ko George explained:

"These three months have been so strange. I can feel again. I got the smell; I got the feeling. Before that, I had lost my social life, like many my age in this country. We are alive again. My life is so positive, now we can write again. We can see the future more clearly. I see good things."

This story first appeared in the August 2013 print issue of The Irrawaddy magazine.

Onyx Restaurant: A Focus on Meat

Posted: 09 Aug 2013 09:09 PM PDT

Tenderloin steak with Korean seasoning with a side of sautéed kale and mashed potatoes at the Onyx restaurant (Photo: SEAN HAVEY / THE IRRAWADDY)

Tucked away down a side street in Bahan Township, the Onyx Restaurant is a favorite of meat-crazed locals and expats alike. Opened nine years ago by Martin Shin, a native Korean, Onyx offers juicy steaks and a decent selection of wines that are sure to satisfy.

"Our restaurant is not very sophisticated, but people come here to eat and fill their stomachs. It makes them happy, and that makes me happy," says Mr Shin.

With steak entrees that cost 6,000 kyat and a glass of the house red going for 3,000 kyat, a meal at the Onyx is well within the budgets of most travelers or the NGO crowd that has made up roughly half its patronage in recent years.

There is also an extensive list of vegetarian and fish dishes that can be perused for a while, but the focus is definitely on the meat at Onyx.

If you can't find anything you like, Mr. Shin is happy to make a few off-menu suggestions, including steak smothered in blue cheese or a full tenderloin big enough to feed three or four people for just 15,000 kyat.

Of the variety of meals on offer, the steak tenderloin with Korean spices is the best bet. Cooked to perfection and topped with grilled onions with a side of lightly sautéed kale and rather stiff but tasty mashed potatoes, the substantial portion is sure to leave even the hungriest patron's appetite satiated.

Ask for a wine list and a waiter will direct patrons to a crate of 10 to 15 international varieties of wine that they can dig through. Bottles range in price from 12,000 kyat to over 20,000 kyat.

Located at 135 Dhamazadi Road, the Onyx can be reached by taxi from downtown for no more than 3,000 kyat. It's very close to the Savoy Hotel, so dinner at the Onyx would dovetail nicely with a drink or two at the nearby Vista Bar to soak up the night view of Shwedagon Pagoda.

This story first appeared in the August 2013 print issue of The Irrawaddy magazine.

Burma Business Roundup (Aug. 10)

Posted: 09 Aug 2013 09:00 PM PDT

US Import Ban on Rubies, Jade Stays Due to 'Problematic Burmese'

The United States is maintaining an import ban on Burmese precious stones such as rubies as well as jade.

The ban will stay because some of the people involved in their mining and trade still "contribute to human rights abuses or undermine Burma's democratic reform process," the US deputy national security adviser Ben Rhodes said in a statement.

It was renewed as part of an otherwise general relaxation of trading between the two countries as many US sanctions expired at the end of July.

"President Obama fully supported the expiration of the broader ban on imports from Burma and is taking this step to advance our policy of promoting responsible economic engagement and encouraging reform that directly benefits the Burmese people," Rhodes said in the White House statement on Wednesday.

"The removal of the broad ban on imports of articles other than jadeite and rubies, and articles of jewellery containing them, represents the next step in the Administration's continued efforts to promote responsible trade and investment in support of Burma's reform process," he said.

Reuters news agency quoted an unnamed US official as saying, "We want to encourage responsible trade and investment in Burma, and at the same time we want to continue to target … those sectors and entities and individuals that we consider to be problematic."

The continuing ban on jade and rubies is "largely an act of political symbolism," said the former British ambassador to Thailand and Vietnam, Derek Tonkin, who is now chairman of the non-profit Network Myanmar.

"China is far and away the greatest importer of jadeite, while the [US] ban on imports of rubies affects Thai and Singaporean jewellery exporters as much if not more than [Burma] itself," he wrote in a statement on the Network Myanmar website.

Thailand Named Burma's Biggest Investor in January-June Period

Thailand was the biggest investor in Burma in the first half of this year, according to figures from the Ministry of National Planning and Economic Development.

Thai companies spent US$410 million in investments in the January-June period.

Thailand was also the second-biggest two-way trader with Burma in the half year, behind China, said local media and the Chinese news agency Xinhua.

The half year saw significant investments also from Vietnam, with $140 million, and Singapore with $136 million.

The largest investments were in energy developments, including power generation, oil and gas exploration, said the ministry.

The Burmese government recently authorized the opening up of more commercial trade border points with Thailand.

Both Thailand and China are listed as the biggest overall investors in Burma in recent years.

The ministry says China has invested a total of $14 billion and Thailand $10 billion. However, it gives no time frame for these investments, or what they were for.

One-Way Land Border Crossings Planned to Boost Foreign Tourism

Foreign tourists traveling in the Mekong region will soon be allowed to cross into Burma from land borders in Thailand and then leave by air from Mandalay or Rangoon, according to the regional tourism industry magazine TTR Weekly.

At present, foreigners can cross into Burma from Thailand at several northern border points but must leave their passports to ensure they return back to the same border post, usually the same day.

TTR Weekly quoted Burma's Ministry of Information as saying that this restriction was undermining tourism income and would end by the end of this year.

"We expect the tourism industry will show good signs of improvement once the new measure is introduced," Aung Win Thein, head of the Immigration Administration and National Registration of Myawaddy District, was quoted as saying by TTR Weekly.

However, foreigners will still need a visa in advance before crossing into Burma through land borders.

Japanese Business Group in Rangoon to Find Local Investment Partners

Burma is to get technical help from Japanese companies on constructing high-rise buildings in Rangoon, said the Myanmar Construction Entrepreneurs Association (MCEA).

Representatives from Japan's Construction Entrepreneurs Association met officials of the MCEA to discuss cooperation, reported Eleven Media.

The linkup between the two associations came in the same week that a delegation of 50 Japanese companies led by the Tokyo government-funded Japan External Trade Organization (Jetro) held meetings in Rangoon with the Union of Myanmar Federation of Chambers of Commerce and Industry.

The Jetro-sponsored visit was to help Japanese firms find business investment partners in energy, construction, real estate, consumer goods, clothing, warehousing, machinery and information technology, according to an Eleven Media report.

Bangladesh Sea Gas Hunt Draws Blank as Burma Readies to Explore

A survey of two deep-water blocks in Bangladesh's part of the Bay of Bengal adjacent to Burma has failed to find any signs of natural gas.

The two dimensional survey of blocks 10 and 11 by the US major oil company ConocoPhillips has so far been unsuccessful, reported EnergyBangla, the Dhaka-based oil and gas news website.

The two blocks cover about 2,500 square kilometers of sea, said EnergyBangla.

In July, the state-owned oil company PetroBangla said the country had failed to attract any firm bids for several new offshore blocks in shallow seas of the Bay of Bengal.

Burma's Ministry of Energy, working with the Myanmar Oil and Gas Enterprise, is in the middle of assessing international offers to explore for gas and oil in 30 blocks in shallow and deep waters of the Bay of Bengal and the Andaman Sea.

Note to Cameraman: Frame the Shot Shoulders and Above.

Posted: 09 Aug 2013 08:45 PM PDT

Two Ways of Remembering

Posted: 09 Aug 2013 10:00 AM PDT

Who could have imagined 25 years ago, at the height of the popular uprising to topple Burma's hated military regime, that many who participated in that historic event would one day be free to publicly commemorate it as we did on Thursday?

Surrounded by former political prisoners, activists and many friends and colleagues at the Myanmar Convention Centre, I saw many smiles, but also felt rather strange—a feeling that many who were there shared.

"It was surreal," said Min Zin, a former student leader activist who is now working on his PhD at the University of California, Berkeley.  Together, we spoke of establishing an archive of records about the thousands who died a quarter of a century ago, many of whom are still only privately mourned by their families but not publicly recognized for their role in the struggle to restore democracy in Burma.

Foreign journalists were also there, including some who covered the massive 1988 demonstrations. One of them was former BBC correspondent Christopher Gunness, who was vilified by the state-run press and even accused of triggering the uprising. He told me he was stunned to see the packed auditorium and the freedom that we now enjoyed.

Aung Zaw is founder and editor of the Irrawaddy magazine. He can be reached at aungzaw@irrawaddy.org.

"It is extremely significant that government ministers and military people came to an event like this, because in all societies that are transitioning from dictatorship to democracy, the first step along the way is truth, is discovering the truth, is telling the truth and acknowledging the truth," he told me.

This was indeed a significant occasion. Not so long ago, such a gathering would have been unthinkable: The generals who ran the country would have seen red and thrown us all in prison, or, more likely, have prevented it happening in the first place.

But right up until the event was held, there were some who felt it might never come to pass. The chief minister of Rangoon Division objected to the use of the word a yay taw bon, meaning "uprising" or "revolution," to describe what took place in 1988, and asked for it to be changed. But in the end, the central government in Naypyidaw approved the use of the term, overriding the chief minister's objections.

Min Ko Naing, who is generally regarded as the leader of the student-led uprising, delivered a speech that gave no hint of vengeful feelings against those who used brutal force against the peaceful protests of 25 years ago. He did, however, speak from the heart about the suffering of those whose lives were torn apart by the crackdown and the ensuing oppression. And he warned that if the changes of the past few years proved not to be genuine, another nationwide uprising was not out of the question.

Min Ko Naing—whose speech in some ways read like a poem—drew hearty applause, even from the high-rollers in the crowd, including some of the country's most prominent tycoons. After all, he is still the "Conqueror of Kings." Politicians, ethnic leaders, activists, diplomats and journalists in the crowd were also appreciative.

One foreign reporter, Gwen Robinson, formerly of the Financial Times, said she was impressed by what she heard, especially the fact that Min Ko Naing did not call for retribution against those who imprisoned him and countless others for decades.

After this speech was delivered, Aung San Suu Kyi arrived from Naypyidaw to give one of her own. I wish she had been there to hear what Min Ko Naing had to say.

In her speech, Suu Kyi acknowledged that she was not involved in the 1988 uprising. It was only after the mass killings in August had begun that she appeared on the scene. Initially, she thought she might be able to help defuse the tensions between the students and the Ne Win-led regime by acting as a mediator. But that wasn't what the people wanted. They were looking for a national leader who could steer the country after the regime was overthrown. As the daughter of independence hero Gen Aung San, she immediately became the one on whom everyone fixed their hopes for a better future.

But from the very beginning, there was a love-hate relationship between her and the students, some of whom accused her of riding the wave of unrest to achieve national prominence. They even criticized her for "stealing" the fighting peacock symbol for the flag of her party, the National League for Democracy.

Despite such hard feelings, however, the former activists who gathered on Thursday wanted her to join them for the anniversary. It was difficult at first to get past her minders, but in the end she agreed to come. If she hadn't, it would probably have done permanent damage to her political career.

A veteran foreign journalist told me that Suu Kyi stole the show, and I could see the public expectation when she began to speak. But to me, her speech sounded more like a lecture, and was not nearly as heartfelt as Min Ko Naing's.

Even when she told the packed auditorium, "We have to be grateful to the people for their involvement in the uprising," I felt like she wanted to avoid saying too much about the events of 1988 and the abuses of the next two decades. Now an MP, she seemed more interested in talking about her party and the Constitution.

After listening to her speech, some prominent leaders of 1988 told me that Suu Kyi failed to recognize the importance of the 88 Generation. "Did she feel that we were a threat to her?" asked one leader who spent several years behind bars as a political prisoner. He said it had been difficult to get in touch with her, even to invite her to the event. "She still treats us like schoolboys and is condescending," he complained.

These former student activists were imprisoned because they supported Suu Kyi all along, and I still believe that she and the 88 Generation complemented each other.

"Where is the metta?" asked Jeanne Hallacy, a Western journalist who has covered Burma since 1988, using a Buddhist term that in this case could best be translated simply as "heart".

She added: "It went away when she came and gave her speech."