Thursday, June 23, 2016

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Thousands of Burmese Migrants Unable to Meet With Suu Kyi

Posted: 23 Jun 2016 08:25 AM PDT

Migrants greet Aung San Suu Kyi amid a high Thai security presence. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

Migrants greet Aung San Suu Kyi amid a high Thai security presence. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

SAMUT SAKHON, Thailand — Despite around ten thousand Burmese migrant workers in Thailand waiting hours—under both the hot sun and, later, rain—for the opportunity to meet with Aung San Suu Kyi, less than five hundred were ultimately permitted to do so.

This caused widespread frustration at the Talay Thai Seafood Market in Mahachai, and led to the deployment of almost 1,000 security personnel by Thai authorities to quell any agitation, although the crowd remained peaceful.

Many of the migrants had reportedly traveled from all over Thailand to Mahachai, a port town in Samut Sakhon province about 45 kilometers southwest of the Thai capital of Bangkok. Those who were allowed to meet with Burma's de-facto leader had been bused in under the approval of Thai authorities and wore stickers demonstrating their permission to enter the factory.

Zin Mar, a garment worker in Bangkok's Bang Khae district, expressed her disappointment over not being able to meet Suu Kyi: "I came here at six in the morning, but only saw her from far away."

On Suu Kyi's arrival at the Mahachai market on Thursday afternoon, the Burmese migrant workers followed and waited outside, waving flags and singing the Burmese national anthem, as they were told that she would be addressing the crowd.

But heavy rain—a common afternoon occurrence during Thailand's monsoon season—prompted Suu Kyi to abandon course.

During her later meeting with the several hundred selected factory workers, Suu Kyi said, "My visit to Thailand mainly aims to deepen mutual understanding and friendship between the two countries."

"I want to listen to the voices of our citizens," Suu Kyi said. "I request you to speak frankly about what you expect us to do for you. But make sure you make reasonable demands. If you make unrealistic demands, we can only reply that it is impossible."

Suu Kyi said that they were trying to secure proper identity documents for migrant workers, including passports and formal Certificates of Identity, and the Thai government did not object to such plans.

"We are trying to make sure our citizens obtain their fundamental rights granted by the laws of this country," Suu Kyi said.

However, according to the few journalists who had access to the meeting, there was not a great deal of productive discussion—in part because, at the factory in question, workers were earning the official minimum wage and had an acceptable working environment.

Deeper concerns among the Burmese migrant community, and the activities of labor rights groups, were reportedly not discussed.

On the grounds of security, Thai authorities had effectively blocked access to Suu Kyi for labor rights groups and NGOs. Labor rights groups had prepared documents to hand to Suu Kyi, but did not succeed in doing so; they also said they felt as though the Thai government did not want to hear about the labor rights violations experienced by migrant workers from Burma.

Ma Oo of the Burma Association Thailand said she was pushed away when she tried to give a letter to Suu Kyi on her way out.

Ma Thida, who works at a chicken processing factory in Mahachai, shared her frustration on Thursday morning that she had been restricted from engaging with Suu Kyi along with thousands of other Burmese migrants.

Hailing from Taungdwingyi Township in central Burma's Magwe Division, she said, "We do not get full labor rights," and explained that many migrant workers must take on extra jobs on weekends as wage laborers.

Thailand-based migrant rights campaigner Andy Hall wrote on Twitter that he had briefly spoken with Suu Kyi in Mahachai: "Andy, tell all my people I am disappointed I cannot give a speech to them outside today, but I know their problems well!" she reportedly said to him.

The post Thousands of Burmese Migrants Unable to Meet With Suu Kyi appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Kachin Armed Group Releases Detained Farmers

Posted: 23 Jun 2016 07:01 AM PDT

View from a mountain in Kutkai Township, Shan State.  (Photo: Kyaw Kha/The Irrawaddy)

View from a mountain in Kutkai Township, Shan State.  (Photo: Kyaw Kha/The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — Nearly 50 ethnic Palaung were released in Kutkai Township, Shan State after they were detained by members of the Kachin Independence Army (KIA) due to a land dispute, according to local sources.

Yan Maung Ba, one of the 48 detainees, told The Irrawaddy that members of the KIA had arrested the farmers due to a disagreement over land between the local ethnic Palaung—also known as Ta'ang—and Kachin communities.

"We were released at 10:30 a.m. on Wednesday," said Yan Maung Ba. "We are corn farmers. They came to take us away at midnight [on Tuesday night]."

Yan Maung Ba said that for five years, he and his fellow Palaung have been growing corn on an area of around 1,000 acres of land—the rights to which have been disputed by the two main the Kachin and Palaung communities that reside in the area. After some local Kachin reportedly complained to the KIA, 48 Palaung farmers were arrested.

"They did not have any good reason. They simply took us away," said Yan Maung Ba.

The 48 victims included 19 men and 29 women. Some of the farmers told The Irrawaddy that members of the KIA had released them after they were made to pay a fee.

"Each of us had to give 15,000 kyats (US$12.70) to the [KIA] and they told us to farm there only after the land disputes are settled. But we have no other place to grow our crops," said Aung Puu, one of the detained farmers.

Yan Maung Ba added, "We have been told that [the KIA] will shoot us if we go back to the land again."

The farmers said that around 30 armed KIA soldiers from Battalion No. 9 of Brigade No. 4 had carried out the detention.

Kutkai Township, located in northern Shan State, is home to ethnic Shan, Palaung and Kachin communities.

The post Kachin Armed Group Releases Detained Farmers appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Despite Military’s Demands, Karen Armed Group Stands Its Ground

Posted: 23 Jun 2016 06:25 AM PDT

Soldiers from the Karen National Liberation Army stand guard at a conference in Law Khee Lar, Karen State. (Photo: Saw Yan Naing / The Irrawaddy)

Soldiers from the Karen National Liberation Army stand guard at a conference in Law Khee Lar, Karen State. (Photo: Saw Yan Naing / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — At an emergency meeting held on Thursday, the Karen National Liberation Army (KNLA) decided not to withdraw from a military checkpoint in the Htee Khee area of southern Burma's Tenasserim Division, according to local sources.

On Monday, a tactical commander from Military Operations Command 19 ordered the KNLA at the checkpoint to withdraw within three days of his visit to the area. But when the deadline came on Thursday, KNLA Brigade No. 4 said they would defend the outpost even if government troops attempted to take it by force.

A source close to the Karen National Union (KNU), the political wing of the KNLA, told The Irrawaddy on Thursday, "We decided not to withdraw from our checkpoint. We have a liaison office in Dawei [the capital of Tenasserim], and they should go there to talk about a withdrawal and make an official request."

"There is even a Joint Monitoring Committee (JMC) office in Dawei. They should have gone there and talked about it," he added, referring to the group assigned to monitor the implementation of Burma's nationwide ceasefire agreement between the government and ethnic armed groups.

The KNU signed the accord in 2015, and has been an active participant in the peace process. This is the first dispute that has threatened last year's truce.

"Our people have sacrificed their lives to control this checkpoint. So why should we withdraw from it?" another source from the KNLA said. "We will defend our checkpoint."

"[The Burma Army commander's] actions violated our ceasefire agreement. He does not have the right to come to our checkpoint. He should have gone to our liaison office if there was something to talk about," said the source.

This tussle comes a week after the Burma Army's encroachment into territory controlled by an ethnic Mon armed group.

In mid-June, the Mon National Liberation Army (MNLA) was ordered to withdraw from an outpost in Kyaikmayaw Township, Mon State. When the MNLA refused, the Burma Army raided the checkpoint by force and seized two weapons.

The post Despite Military's Demands, Karen Armed Group Stands Its Ground appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Timeline: Suu Kyi’s Foreign Visits

Posted: 23 Jun 2016 05:43 AM PDT

State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi smiles as she visits the 1148ft. observation deck at the Tokyo Skytree, the world's tallest broadcasting, in Tokyo April 18, 2013. (Photo: Franck Robichon / Reuters)

State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi smiles as she visits the 1148ft. observation deck at the Tokyo Skytree, the world’s tallest broadcasting, in Tokyo April 18, 2013. (Photo: Franck Robichon / Reuters)

As Burma's State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi arrives in Thailand for an official three-day trip on Thursday, The Irrawaddy looks back on her various international visits since her release from house arrest in 2010.

2016

May 7: On her first official trip abroad as Burma's State Counselor, Suu Kyi travels to Laos.

2015

June 10: At the invitation of the Communist Party of China, Suu Kyi makes her first visit to Beijing and meets President Xi Jinping and Premier Li Keqiang.

2014

April: She meets with Chancellor Angela Merkel and President Joachim Gauck in Berlin during a three-day visit to Germany, and then visits France and holds talks with President François Hollande.

2013

Jan 25: Suu Kyi attends the Rotary Global Peace Forum in Hawaii and receives the Hawaii Peace Award. She also meets the governor of Hawaii and the local Burmese community in Honolulu.

Jan 29: Suu Kyi visits the South Korean capital of Seoul where she holds talks with President Lee Myung-bak and the first woman president-elect of the country Park Geun-hye. She delivers a speech at the Global Development Summit in Pyeongchang. She then visits Gwangju where she collects the Gwangju Prize for Human Rights awarded to her in 2004.

April 13: Suu Kyi calls on Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe in Tokyo during her first visit to Japan in 27 years. She last visited Japan in 1986, when she worked as a researcher at Kyoto University. She also meets Japanese senior leaders, Burmese democracy activists and students from Tokyo University.

April 29: Suu Kyi addresses the 7th Ministerial Conference of the Community of Democracies in Mongolia's Ulaanbaatar.

September 11: She visits Poland and meets Speaker of the Sejm, Ewa Kopacz, and Speaker of the Senate, Bogdan Borusewicz, during her second visit to Europe.

September 13: Suu Kyi visits Hungary and meets Hungarian President Janos Ader and Deputy Foreign Minister Zsolt Nemeth in Budapest.

September 14: She makes her first visit to the Czech Republic as the keynote speaker of the Forum 2000 Conference and meets the Czech president and foreign minister in Prague.

September 20: She delivers the keynote speech at the Singapore Summit 2013. She calls on President Tony Tan Keng Yam and Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong.

October 19: Suu Kyi visits Belgium, beginning her third tour of Europe.

October 21: She visits Luxembourg where she meets foreign ministers of 28 European countries.

October 22: Suu Kyi accepts the 1990 Sakharov Prize for Freedom of Thought in Strasbourg, France, originally awarded to her in 1991.

October 25: She delivers a speech at the Royal Military Academy Sandhurst during her UK visit.

October 27: She receives honorary citizenship in Rome during her visit to Italy.

November 27: During her first visit to Australia, the honorary degree of Doctor of Laws is conferred upon Suu Kyi by Chancellor Belinda Hutchinson AM at a ceremony held in the Concert Hall of the Opera House. The chancellor and vice-chancellor of the University of Technology Sydney also confer an honorary doctorate upon her at the joint ceremony. The award was originally bestowed on her in 1997 and given to her late husband in her absence.

December 10: She attends the World Innovation Summit for Health in Doha, Qatar.

2012

May 30: Suu Kyi visits Thailand on her first foreign trip in 24 years to attend the World Economic Forum (WEF) on East Asia in Bangkok. She also visits a Karen refugee camp along the Thai-Burma border in Tak Province.

June 14: She delivers an address at the 101st International Labor Conference of the ILO in Geneva, Switzerland starting her first two-week tour of Europe in which she visits Norway, the UK, Switzerland, France and Ireland.

June 16: Suu Kyi collects her Nobel Peace Prize in Oslo, Norway 21 years after winning the award in 1991.

June 18: She accepts Amnesty International's Ambassador of Conscience Award—the organization's most prestigious honor—in Dublin, Ireland.

June 20: Suu Kyi gives a historic speech to both of Britain's houses of parliament, receives an honorary doctorate in civil law from Oxford University and meets UK Prime Minister David Cameron.

June 27: She visits France and meets French President François Hollande in Paris.

September 15: Suu Kyi visits the US, accepts the Congressional Gold Medal in Washington D.C. and meets President Barack Obama, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon.

November 14: Suu Kyi meets Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh during her visit to India, where she went to high school and college.

Compiled by Wei Yan Aung and Thet Ko Ko. 

The post Timeline: Suu Kyi's Foreign Visits appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

The Lady and a Junta, Thai-Style

Posted: 23 Jun 2016 03:24 AM PDT

 Burma's State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi (2nd L) arrives at Suvarnabhumi airport in Bangkok, Thailand, June, 23, 2016. (Photo: Narong Sangnak / Pool / Reuters)

Burma's State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi (2nd L) arrives at Suvarnabhumi airport in Bangkok, Thailand, June, 23, 2016. (Photo: Narong Sangnak / Pool / Reuters)

The visit this week by Nobel Peace Prize laureate and democracy icon Daw Aung San Suu Kyi will certainly brighten the spirits of the sombre Thai people and could also lift the profile of the Thai junta and Myanmar's top leader.

Yet we shouldn't romanticize too much about "The Lady" and her capacity as the political realities in Myanmar and Thailand remain daunting. Besides, she is no longer a secular saint but a fully fledged politician.

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi's three-day visit will include a stop in Mahachai, the seafood hub where she made a rousing speech to thousands of Myanmar laborers four years ago on one of her first trips abroad after years of house arrest.

At least 3 million Myanmar migrants work in Thailand, both legally and illegally. Daw Aung San Suu Kyi would like to see many of them return home and contribute to her country's economy – to the dismay of Thai employers who rely heavily on the workforce from next door.

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi is expected to thank Thailand for embracing the migrants and to remind the government to take care of their welfare, wages and human rights. She needs to let them know she cares, since they played a significant role in persuading relatives back home to "vote for change" and install the National League for Democracy (NLD) government last November.

Thai democracy lovers and the Myanmar exile community are also curious about what Daw Aung San Suu Kyi will say about human rights in general. Having spoken out for years in support of students, politicians, ethnic groups and others persecuted by the Myanmar military, will she have a good word for those opposing the military strongmen running Thailand? Expect a few vague words of consolation to Thai people about working toward full democracy.

Also on her agenda are better border regulations to tackle illicit drugs and human trafficking, and cooperation to develop economic zones in border areas.

Thailand has prepared an amendment to a 2003 labor agreement that specified only employment to include rule of law and other protection aspects. The changes should make recruitment faster and more transparent for employers and more convenient and affordable for Myanmar migrant workers.

More effort is also expected to breathe life into the Dawei megaproject. Myanmar wants Japan to invest more in infrastructure there, but Japan wants to see its Thilawa port near Yangon up and running first – even though Dawei will substantially benefit Japanese investment in Thailand and the region.

Progress on Dawei could be linked to a solution to the long-running refugee problem. However, this can only materialize if the Myanmar government and armed ethnic groups as well as the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) are part of the solution.

It would be a noble gesture for the leaders of the two countries to propose a pilot project for the voluntary return of refugees to Dawei, where they could contribute to, and benefit from, economic development.

The roads to Dawei are the stronghold of the Karen National Union (KNU). If a political solution is found, some returnees – from camps in Ratchaburi and Kanchanburi – could be assisted to return to Myitta in Tanintharyi region, 70 kilometres (43 miles) from the Thai border.

But the KNU says any return "must be accorded with safety and dignity", which includes the clearing of landmines among other conditions. It is a complicated problem as the refugees have been away from their homes for two or three decades and a lot has changed. Activists say as many as 3000 villages have been destroyed or abandoned due to the actions of armed groups and the Myanmar military.

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi has so far been vague about ethnic issues. She has announced a new round of peace talks but the ethnic groups feel she has given too many concessions to the military, whose goodwill she needs to maintain.

So as a pragmatic politician Daw Aung San Suu Kyi will also avoid discussing issues unpopular among domestic constituents, such as the fate of the long-persecuted Rohingya, with Thailand. The Thai side probably was not going to mention it anyway.

Also expect silence on Thanlwin River dam projects, in which both Thai and Chinese players are involved, and which ethnic groups oppose. Continuing such projects at a time of peace-building would be an "opportunistic and exploitative act", they have said.

In short, the political realities on both sides suggest that in the end, the meeting with "The Lady" could be just one more photo opportunity for Thailand's premier to add to his collection.

The post The Lady and a Junta, Thai-Style appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Migrant Rights Advocate: ‘If the Thai Government Uses Violence, We Won’t Tolerate it”

Posted: 23 Jun 2016 02:35 AM PDT

Migrant workers protest outside Talay Thai Seafood Market in Mahachai, Thailand. (Photo: J Paing / The Irrawaddy)

Migrant workers protest outside Talay Thai Seafood Market in Mahachai, Thailand. (Photo: J Paing / The Irrawaddy)

The Irrawaddy reporter Nyein Nyein talks to Htoo Chit, migrant rights advocate and director of the Foundation for Education Development (FED), outside Talay Thai Seafood Market in Mahachai, Thailand—where Aung San Suu Kyi will meet with migrant workers from Burma on Thursday afternoon—about the Thai government's selection process for the meeting and why banned workers protested the decision.

Thousands of Burmese migrant workers gathered Thursday morning to meet with Suu Kyi later that day, but the Thai government and factories selected only 500 workers for the meeting while the rest were banned.

What do you think of the current situation?

We expected Suu Kyi to meet with migrants and listen their problems. But now the Thai government won't allow migrants in who have been waiting since very early this morning. They are saying that they will only allow selected workers from the factories; so, banned workers are blocking the selected workers.

Since they will only allow 500 workers to the meeting, everyone is not supposed to go inside. But we worry that those selected workers will just sit inside and not disclose the real situation. She and the Thai government can only find a solution for the migrant workers if they hear the real situation. If they meet only with workers who are instructed by the factories, it won't solve migrants' issues.

As your organization is also not allowed inside, how you will try to have your voice heard by Suu Kyi?

We have prepared various ways. We [migrants' advocacy groups] did a joint report with suggestions on migrant policies. We want her to clearly understand the details of the murder cases in Ranong and Koh Tao and that also as a government, that they need a policy to systematically protect migrants.

So we came here today to give that [suggestion]. It is still unclear whether we can go inside or not.

The banned workers are protesting and blocking the selected workers. What would you advise?

I have concerns about this. They arrived very early. If they don't allow them in and only selected factory workers enter, it is unfair. They might try other ways to get the chance to talk with Suu Kyi. I worry that the Thai government will use violence to disperse them because they are a military regime. I would like to advise them to wait and see, orderly and together. But if they [the Thai government] use violence, we won't tolerate it.

The post Migrant Rights Advocate: 'If the Thai Government Uses Violence, We Won't Tolerate it" appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

EU Says Burma Needs “Space” to Deal with Rights Abuses

Posted: 23 Jun 2016 12:39 AM PDT

A man protests against the United States for its use of the term Rohingya to describe Burma's stateless Muslim community outside the U.S. embassy in Rangoon, April 28, 2016. (Photo: Reuters)

A man protests against the United States for its use of the term Rohingya to describe Burma’s stateless Muslim community outside the U.S. embassy in Rangoon, April 28, 2016. (Photo: Reuters)

RANGOON — The European Union said on Wednesday that Burma needed "space" to deal with human rights abuses in its restive northwest, adding it would respect the call by country leader Aung San Suu Kyi to avoid the term "Rohingya" to describe persecuted Muslims there.

The statement exposes a rift in the West’s approach to the sensitive issue, standing in contrast with the United States, which said it would continue to use the term, citing respect for the right of communities to choose what they should be called.

Members of the group of 1.1 million, who identify as Rohingya, are seen by many Burmese Buddhists as illegal immigrants from Bangladesh. The term is divisive.

Tensions around the Muslim minority are rising. This week, Suu Kyi told the United Nations Human Rights investigator visiting the country that the government would not use the term because it was inflammatory.

Some 120,000 Rohingya remain displaced in squalid camps since fighting erupted in Arakan State between Buddhists and Muslims in 2012. Thousands have fled persecution and poverty. The U.N. said on Monday that the abuses, which include executions and torture, together may amount to crimes against humanity.

"We understand that the term 'Rohingya' is emotionally charged in [Burma] and we have heard the call of the government to avoid creating tension by using polarizing terminology," Roland Kobia, the EU ambassador to Burma, told reporters.

"So we ought to give political space to initiatives to gradually find a solution to this protracted issue," he said.

Suu Kyi's administration last week tabled a new term for the Rohingya—"Muslim community in [Arakan] State"—but the description has quickly run into opposition.

The Arakan National Party (ANP), formed by hardline Arakanese Buddhists who enjoy a considerable following in the state, said the government was biased and rejected the new term.

"We consider that using the new term […] is tantamount to meaning that they are natives of [Arakan State] by ignoring the original place of these Bengali people," the party said in a statement.

The previous military-linked government referred to the group as "Bengalis," implying they were illegal immigrants from Bangladesh, though many have lived in Burma for generations.

Wai Wai Nu, a Rohingya activist from Women Peace Network Arakan, said the government should protect, listen and consult with ethnic minorities. She wanted to ask it: "Why are you denying us our identity […] and not taking a feasible, constructive and inclusive step to move forward?"

"The government should address the targeted persecution and discrimination against minorities and ensure protection of their rights by respecting their ethnicity, identity and name," she said.

Yanghee Lee, the U.N. Special Rapporteur on Human Rights in Burma, is touring the country on her first visit since Suu Kyi took power.

Wirathu, the leader of radical nationalist Buddhist monks, threatened to beat her with a "wooden flip flop" if she "wasn’t smart enough." He warned Lee against acting as a "political broker," being "one-sided on the part of the trouble-makers" and "selling the country to others."

Last year, he called her a "whore" after Lee criticized laws seen as discriminating against non-Buddhists and women.

Suu Kyi, who starts her visit to Thailand on Thursday, has formed a committee to "bring peace and development" to the state in May, but its plans are not clear.

The post EU Says Burma Needs "Space" to Deal with Rights Abuses appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Rangoon MPs Clash Over Budget

Posted: 23 Jun 2016 12:12 AM PDT

Current Rangoon Chief Minister Phyo Min Thein campaigns in his home constituency Hlegu Township in 2012. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

Current Rangoon Chief Minister Phyo Min Thein campaigns in his home constituency Hlegu Township in 2012. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — Lawmakers have complained that the Rangoon divisional government has unfairly allotted a budget windfall due to the cancellation of flyover projects, highlighting the fact that the divisional chief minister's constituency received more money than any other township.

The budget for the construction of two flyovers at the junction of Kabar Aye Pagoda Road and Parami Street in North Okkalapa Township was approved under the previous government, but the plan was scrapped in April as the newly-elected members of parliament suggested spending the 32.2 billion kyats (US$26.1 million) on rural development projects since new flyovers have not been a solution to Rangoon's traffic problems.

"Lawmakers have disagreed with the regional government's budget because some of their plans have not been approved. Many rural areas are receiving less money and Hlegu [Township] is getting more money than the other townships," said Kyaw Zay Ya, a Rangoon Divisional lawmaker who is on the Finance, Planning and Economic Affairs Committee.

Hlegu Township, the home constituency of Rangoon's Chief Minister Phyo Min Thein, has been allocated around 4 billion kyats, the most of any constituency. Kawhmu and Kungyangon townships are set to receive more than 3 billion kyats, while all other townships have been budgeted around 2 billion kyats.

"Three townships will get more than 3 billion kyats while all the others get only around 2 billion kyats," said San Kyaw, a Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) member of the divisional parliament. "Now that the lawmakers have lodged complaints, they are negotiating with the government."

"It is unfair that the chief minister's constituency is getting the most money. All lawmakers want to do good for their constituencies because that is why we were elected," the USDP lawmaker said.

National League for Democracy (NLD) lawmaker Aung San Oo of Hmawbi Township said his township will get 2.5 billion kyats for development projects.

"We suggested using money from the flyover budget for rural development projects. But because the budget gives more money to urban townships than rural ones, we asked for it to be reviewed," he said.

"They said in Hlegu Township road construction would require more than 1 billion kyats, so the township was allotted more money. We all accepted that because the project is really needed. But the unequal budget allocation was inappropriate in some other respects," Aung San Oo said.

Planning and Finance Minister Myint Thaung told The Irrawaddy the budget is now being reviewed because some proposals which should have been prioritized were not included in the initial plan.

"It is true that Hlegu Township was allocated 1.3 billion kyats more than any other township, but it is for the maintenance of a road which is now in really bad shape," he said, adding the initial budget will not be changed under this current review, but they would tap into the government's reserves to pay for projects that are deemed necessary.

"Each township made a proposal based on their own needs, which are dependent on size, population and other factors. So it is hard to compare them. We allocated the budget to address each township's unique concerns," the minister said.

The budget will be used for road construction and maintenance, increasing access to running water, building bridges and improving the sewer system in the urban areas.

The post Rangoon MPs Clash Over Budget appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Malaysia Rescues 29 Trafficked Filipino Women From Bars

Posted: 23 Jun 2016 12:03 AM PDT

South East Asian leaders attend a Signing Ceremony Against Trafficking in Persons at the 27th Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) summit in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, November 21, 2015. (Photo: Reuters)

South East Asian leaders attend a Signing Ceremony Against Trafficking in Persons at the 27th Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) summit in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia, November 21, 2015. (Photo: Reuters)

JAKARTA, Indonesia — Malaysian authorities have rescued 29 Filipino women who had been trafficked into the country to work, and arrested their agents, Filipino officials said on Wednesday, in the country’s latest move to tackle the crime.

Malaysia has an estimated 2 million illegal migrant laborers, some of whom work in conditions of forced labor in sectors ranging from electronics to palm oil to domestic service, according to the U.S. State Department.

The Philippine embassy in Kuala Lumpur said it had contacted Malaysian police after it received tip-offs about some trafficked Filipino women, prompting a rescue operation.

On June 9, Malaysian police raided two bars in the coastal town of Bintulu in the eastern state of Sarawak on the island of Borneo, where they found the women, according to an embassy statement.

It said traffickers brought the women to Sarawak as tourists and promised them jobs by converting their tourist visas into employment visas in exchange for money.

"Under Malaysian immigration law, social visit passes [tourist visas] cannot be converted to work visas," the embassy said, urging Filipinos to be vigilant.

The 29 women will be transferred to a women’s shelter while an investigation is underway.

Three individuals who allegedly acted as agents for the women were arrested during the raid, the embassy statement said.

It was not clear whether the trio have been charged in any court. The embassy could not be reached for immediate comment.

The embassy urged Filipinos not to deal with unlicensed individuals or placement agencies as they could end up being victims of trafficking.

Last month, 15 officials were fired after Malaysia discovered an immigration racket involving the sabotage of its security system at the country’s main airport, heightening fears about human trafficking.

Malaysia last year was upgraded by the U.S. State Department in its annual Trafficking in Persons Report to the Tier 2 Watch List from Tier 3, the lowest ranking for countries with the worst trafficking records.

The upgrade followed international scrutiny and outcry over Malaysian efforts to combat human trafficking after the discovery earlier in the year of scores of graves in people-smuggling camps near its northern border with Thailand.

The post Malaysia Rescues 29 Trafficked Filipino Women From Bars appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

National News

National News


Anger as migrant workers in Thailand denied audience with Daw Aung San Suu Kyi

Posted: 23 Jun 2016 07:01 AM PDT

Thousands of Myanmar migrant workers in Thailand hoping for an audience with visiting State Counsellor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi were left disappointed on Thursday after Thai authorities denied them entry to a hall where she was due to speak.

Traditional medicine practitioners sour over unlicensed technology prohibition

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 02:30 PM PDT

Practitioners of Myanmar traditional medicine are being reduced to the status of mere masseurs, they are complaining. They were attacking a statement released by the health department forbidding them to use technology that is unlicensed or has no connection with Myanmar traditional healing technices.

Residents fear landslides as Hpakant floods

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 02:30 PM PDT

After two days of consecutive downpours, Uru Creek in jade-rich Hpakant township has flooded, inundating nearby villages and sparking fears of landslides.

Govt warns against use of child labour

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 02:30 PM PDT

Business owners have been reminded to avoid hiring children under the age of 14, or face fines ranging from K5 million to K10 million, up to six months in prison, or both.

Nationalist party opposes official term for Muslim community in Rakhine

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 02:30 PM PDT

Nationalist politicians are slamming the government for pushing an official change of terminology to refer to a Muslim minority in Rakhine State.

Mutation key in malaria drug resistance along Myanmar-Thailand border: study

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 02:30 PM PDT

Frontline anti-malaria drugs are failing and the rapid decline in their effectiveness is directly linked to increasing parasite mutations, a study released this week has found.

Five countries discuss single-visa scheme

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 02:30 PM PDT

In what could one day become Southeast Asia's version of the European Union's Schengen visa-free zone, Myanmar and four other countries are discussing the introduction of a single visa that would permit travel to all of them.

Dengue infections down but govt ‘remains alert’

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 02:30 PM PDT

After a record dengue fever outbreak nationally and regionally last year, health officials say the number of cases so far this year have dipped.

Farmers hampered by difficulty accessing loans

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 02:30 PM PDT

Red tape is hampering farmers' attempts to secure the loans they need to start the next planting season, they say. And though the agriculture ministry has borrowed a total of K1700 billion to disburse in loans, many farmers say the amount provided is not enough.

India, Myanmar jointly inspecting bridges along trilateral trade route

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 02:30 PM PDT

India and Myanmar will jointly examine scores of bridges along the road connecting the two countries and Thailand, according to the Ministry of Construction.

Shan Herald Agency for News

Shan Herald Agency for News


Twilight Over National Reconciliation

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 09:35 PM PDT

The 1962 coup d'ėtat staged by General Ne Win ended an era of saophalong and mahadevi (ruling princes and princesses) in the Shan states, ushering in decades of repressive military rule in Burma. Like many Shan royalty, Sao Kya Seng, the saophalong of the northern Shan State of Hsipaw, was detained by the authorities. He had been in Taunggyi and was arrested at a nearby military checkpoint. He was never seen again. His last note was a signed letter smuggled to his mahadevi, Sao Thusandi, containing details of his detention and mistreatment in the ba htoo tatmadaw (Burmese military camp).

Their story is immortalized by Sao Thusandi, also known as Inge Sargent, in her book, Twilight Over Burma, which was published in 1994. Originally from Austria, she had met and married the prince while both were students in the United States. She was initially held under house arrest before fleeing Burma with her two daughters, Sao Mayari and Sao Kennari, in 1964.

All three now live in the USA and say they have written every year to the Burmese government demanding an explanation to Sao Kya Seng's disappearance. The family say they have never received the courtesy of a reply. Sao Thusandi once confronted Ne Win himself while he was in Austria receiving psychiatric treatment, personally demanding a response. The dictator's reaction was reportedly to scurry away from the angry young Austrian woman to the safety of locked doors and armed bodyguards.

Now adapted into a film of the same title, the English-language version was scheduled for a debut screening in Rangoon on Tuesday, June 14th – that was until it was reviewed by the national censorship agency, the Film Classification Board, which includes military representatives and is controlled by the Ministry of Home Affairs. Deemed a "threat to national reconciliation," it was abruptly banned, a particularly sad irony given that the venue was to be the Human Rights Human Dignity International Film Festival, which counts Aung San Suu Kyi as its patron.

"[It] could damage the ethnic unity of the state," explained a member of the board, Phone Maw, to the Irrawaddy.

It's an official response that, while not completely unexpected, reflects a deep structural problem in Burma, speaking volumes about the limits of Burma's military-guided transition. It is a reaction that is as deeply condescending as it is fatally flawed. At its heart, the unspoken message to many ethnic communities will once again be that accommodating the tatmadaw's hypersensitive disinclination to even begin to acknowledge its excesses takes precedence over ethnic histories and lived experiences, dismissing and trivializing human rights issues which are ongoing.

Sao Kya Seng, Saophalong of Hsipaw State, and Mahadhevi Thusandi
While Twilight Over Burma is the first international movie banned under the National League for Democracy (NLD)-led administration, the vocabulary justifying this action, "ethnic unity" and "reconciliation," and the sentiment behind this reasoning, are nothing new for ethnic communities in Burma, long accustomed to a decades-long pattern of Burman/Buddhist-centric cultural and political homogenization by successive centralized administrations. Until recently, the term "reconciliation" was not even a part of the official (tatmadaw) lexicon, the generals preferring "national reconsolidation". The implication was subjugation, by force or otherwise, a mindset that continues today.

At its most innocuous, this sentiment manifests in the often patronizing ethnic representations adorning tourist trinkets or at events and venues, particularly those catering to foreigners. At the East Asia Summit in November 2014 held in Naypyidaw, dozens of female ushers in colorful ethnic outfits welcomed world leaders. None were ethnic nationalities. A "Padaung" woman exclaimed to an Associated Press correspondent, "Oh, that's fake! Did you think I was really Kayan Padaung?"

At its worst, "reconsolidation" entails the deliberate targeting of ethnic communities in Burma by the tatmadaw with human rights abuses against civilians, a campaign of terror against those perceived to be a threat to their notion of a nation-state; in the tatmadaw's previous lexicon, "internal and external destructive elements" which must be "crushed."

Since 1996, more than 3,700 villages have been destroyed, relocated or abandoned in eastern Burma, forcing some 400,000 people to live as internally displaced persons, or IDPs. Many others were forced to flee to Thailand, living as refugees or migrants, often without any legal protection. A 2014 Harvard Law School analysis concluded that such pogroms against ethnic Karen communities in 2005-06, which entailed indiscriminate attacks on civilians, destruction of homes and food stores, laying landmines in populated areas, forced labor (including conscripted work as army porters), and arbitrary arrest and executions by members of the tatmadaw, may meet international criteria for war crimes and crimes against humanity.

The official response from governments has been a deafening silence. Maj-Gen Ko Ko, the military commander who executed this policy in Karen State, was promoted to lieutenant-general and appointed President Thein Sein's powerful Minister for Home Affairs until earlier this year.

The NLD administration plans a grand "21st Century Panglong Conference" to address Burma's ethnic conflicts, implying that Aung San Suu Kyi intends to build upon the uncompleted work of her father, independence hero General Aung San, who convened the first Panglong Conference in 1947, when, in return for joining the Union of Burma-to-be, ethnic leaders were promised the right to autonomy and self-determination. It was a promise never realized, seen in many ethnic communities as an act of betrayal by the Burman-dominated government and military.

If Aung San Suu Kyi is serious about moving forward in the spirit of her father, rebuilding the ethnic trust and rapport that her father enjoyed, equality and an honest reckoning of past mistakes – which continue to be repeated today – must be a cornerstone of her policies. Although over half a century have elapsed since Sao Kya Seng's disappearance and likely murder, stories such as Twilight Over Burma continue to resonate deeply for many ethnic communities, particularly those who still face the abusive excesses of an unrepentant tatmadaw.

Just ask the families of Lahpai Gam and Brang Yung, Kachin villagers tortured into confessions and arbitrarily detained by the Burmese Army. Or ask the husband of Sumlut Roi Ja, also a Kachin civilian, last seen alive in the custody of the tatmadaw. Or take the case of Ja Seng Ing, a 14-year-old girl shot dead by the Burmese army. When her father had the temerity to petition the president and National Human Rights Commission, he was taken to court by the army for defamation – and found guilty. Or take a look at the tragic events surrounding Maran Lu Ra and Tangbau Hkwan Nan Tsin, two young volunteer teachers in northern Shan State who were brutally raped and murdered in January 2015; evidence strongly implicated a local unit of the tatmadaw, which continues to stymie any independent investigations. Or consider what happened to Sai Aik Naung, Sai Aik Mart and Sai Aik Dink, three Shan villagers last seen alive when they were arrested last month by tatmadaw soldiers in Kyaukme Township, near Hsipaw. Their burnt remains were recovered shortly afterwards.

On a population level, these individual tragedies are amplified a thousand-fold. The perpetrators never have to face justice, thanks to Burma's military-drafted 2008 constitution.

The Burmese Army's ongoing impunity for abuses, especially against ethnic civilians, causes the most damage to the image of the tatmadaw and prospects for national reconciliation, not stories such as Twilight Over Burma.

Silence is not reconciliation, it is a time-honored failure which creates instead a collective, myopic, state-directed amnesia dooming Burma to pernicious cycles of hatred and violence. To paraphrase a popular Shan proverb: "The floor continues to be mopped again and again, with no thought whatsoever to repairing the leaking roof."

Indeed, ongoing official reluctance to broach such sensitive ethnic issues will have dire consequences for reconciliation and a durable peace, further eroding ethnic trust in the NLD leadership. A good start towards breaking this cycle would be to begin honest open discussions about the mistakes of the past and present, particularly at events which promote human rights and human dignity. This would acknowledge and respect the lived experiences of so many ethnic peoples, allowing healing and reconciliation to finally commence. That this has yet to truly occur is only further underscored in the recent decision to cancel the Rangoon screening of Twilight Over Burma.

"Sao [Kya Seng] was always the good Buddhist," recalled Ms. Sargent. "I was more into the mystical, the fortune tellers and astrology, than he was … I try to be a good Buddhist now. I have been able to let go of the past, but one thing that I can never forgive is Ne Win and the cowards [emphasis is hers] who, to this day, are still too scared to admit to what they have done … The generals believe that just building pagodas and donating to temples will help clean away their crimes, but it won't. [Until they admit and atone] I cannot forgive them."
Without closure, she is far from alone.

Wednesday, June 22, 2016

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Suu Kyi’s Trip to Refugee Camp in Thailand Scrapped

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 05:48 AM PDT

Suu Kyi addresses those gathered to meet her at the Mae La refugee camp near the Thailand-Burma border in 2012. (Photo: Reuters)  

Suu Kyi addresses those gathered to meet her at the Mae La refugee camp near the Thailand-Burma border in 2012. (Photo: Reuters)

BANGKOK, Thailand — Local Thai authorities have reportedly cancelled the State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi's official visit to the Tham Hin refugee camp in Ratchaburi province on Saturday, according to sources close to the camp administration.

Suu Kyi will be arriving in Thailand's capital Bangkok on Thursday for her three-day visit, and had planned to travel on Saturday to Tham Hin camp in Ratchaburi, where more than 6,000 Burmese refugees are residing.

The source, who chose to remain anonymous due to the sensitivity of issues concerning the refugee camp, told The Irrawaddy that local Thai authorities had informed the camp committee on Wednesday that the trip had been cancelled, with no reason given.

"Communities in the camp would like to welcome our leader Daw Aung San Suu Kyi," the source said. "We would like her to see the situation of the camp in order to help us. We would like to raise some questions regarding refugees and hear what she has to say too."

Heavy restrictions on access are in place for non-residents in the Tham Hin camp, the second-smallest of the nine refugee camps along the Thailand-Burma border.

Sally Thompson, director of the Thailand Border Consortium, said she had also been informed by her field staff about the cancellation of the trip, but had not received an official confirmation.

"If it was cancelled, everybody [the refugees and the NGOs] will be disappointed," Thompson told The Irrawaddy. "It would have been a good opportunity for her [Aung San Suu Kyi] to have a dialogue with the refugees [who] can explain…why they are still here in the camp."

Some of the issues related to refugee repatriation are supposed to be discussed during the State Counselor's meeting with the Thai Prime Minister Gen Prayuth Chan-ocha on Friday, she said.

Landmines, land allocation issues and military presence have all been cited as obstacles preventing the refugees from returning to Burma.

"The government of Myanmar is not ready, and at the moment the Thai government is waiting for the Myanmar government to say they are ready," the Thailand Border Consortium's Sally Thompson said.

Thai government spokesperson Maj-Gen Werachon Sukondhapatipak was quoted by Thailand-based English-language newspaper The Nation on Wednesday as saying that Thailand has always been eager to return refugees to Burma but has been unable to overcome legal and logistical hurdles to doing so.

Burma's Ambassador to Thailand U Win Maung did not respond to multiple requests for comment.

The post Suu Kyi's Trip to Refugee Camp in Thailand Scrapped appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Four More National Committees Formed

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 05:41 AM PDT

President Htin Kyaw enters Parliament on March 30, 2016. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

President Htin Kyaw enters Parliament on March 30, 2016. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — Burma's President Htin Kyaw has formed four national-level committees for transportation, water resources, land use policy and foreigner supervision, chaired by two vice-presidents and two union ministers, according to a statement released by the President's Office today.

The four committees: the Implementation Committee for National Transport Master Plan; National Committee for Water Resources; Central Committee for Vacant Land Management; and Central Committee for Foreigner Supervision, were signed into formation by the president on Monday.

The controversial military-backed vice-president Myint Swe will chair the 19-member Foreigner Supervision Committee, which will be responsible for adopting policies and drafting appropriate laws for foreigners living in and visiting the country. The chief of police and the director-general of the immigration department will both act as secretaries.

The 21-member Water Resources Committee will be chaired by ethnic Chin vice-president Henry Van Thio and will include several union ministers, the mayors of Naypyidaw, Rangoon and Mandalay, and a hydrology expert. It will be responsible for drafting a strategy for, and implementing, an integrated water resources management system, and developing a national policy for water resources.

The Transport Committee will be chaired by transport and communications minister Thant Zin Maung, and joint chaired by the ministers of national planning and finance, and construction. The 22-member committee is responsible for analyzing the master plan and financial sources, specifying project priorities and time frames, allocating annual financial budgets for projects, seeking loans from foreign countries and collaborating with international organizations.

Lastly, the Vacant Land Management Committee will be chaired by the union minister of agriculture, livestock and irrigation, Aung Thu. The 18-member committee will handle land use proposals for agriculture, livestock and minerals in line with the country's existing laws. The land use policy in Burma is complex due to past instances of land grabbing and customary land use practices in ethnic areas. The committee includes the director-general of the President's Office and two military-controlled offices—the Home Affairs Ministry's General Administration Department and the office of the Quartermaster-General.

The previous administration, under former President Thein Sein, annulled 112 national committees on March 29, just before transferring power to President Htin Kyaw. The new government has formed multiple national committees during the last three months, including the Committee for the Prevention of the Recruitment of Minors in Military Service, the Preparatory Committee for the 21st Century Panglong Conference and the Committee for Arakan State Peace, Stability and Development.

The post Four More National Committees Formed appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

UN Rapporteur Avoids Contentious Terms with Arakan Chief Minister

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 05:36 AM PDT

United Nations human rights rapporteur Yanghee Lee meets the Arakan State Chief Minister Nyi Pu in a room in Sittwe airport on Wednesday. (Photo: Tayzar)

United Nations human rights rapporteur Yanghee Lee meets the Arakan State Chief Minister Nyi Pu in a room in Sittwe airport on Wednesday. (Photo: Tayzar)

RANGOON — The United Nations (UN) special rapporteur on human rights in Burma, Yanghee Lee, and Arakan State Chief Minister Nyi Pu struck a conciliatory tone on a meeting in the state capital Sittwe on Wednesday, in which the contentious terms "Rohingya" and "Bengali" were avoided.

Yanghee Lee expressed confidence in the leadership of Nyi Pu, a National League for Democracy (NLD) member who was appointed as Chief Minister by the NLD leadership in the face of opposition from the Arakan National Party (ANP), which represents the Arakanese Buddhist majority and holds the largest plurality of seats in the state parliament.

Despite a reported request from Yanghee Lee, the ANP issued a statement on Wednesday saying they would not meet with her because she was "coming to write a biased report" for the UN.

Yanghee Lee and the UN have been the subject of fierce criticism, and abuse, from nationalists in Burma for highlighting discrimination against the stateless Rohingya Muslim minority in Arakan State, whom the general public in Burma refers to as "Bengali," to imply they migrated illegally from Bangladesh.

This week, the UN's human rights office released a report stating that violations against the Rohingya—including denial of citizenship rights, forced labor and sexual violence—could amount to "crimes against humanity." The report has already drawn criticism from within the Burmese government.

Arakan State government spokesman Min Aung told The Irrawaddy on Wednesday that Yanghee Lee—who is in Arakan State for two days—was travelling to Kadi, a Muslim-majority village tract of 421 households in Ponnagyun Township.

Yanghee Lee will then proceed to the Pa Nyar Wa camp in Kyauktaw Township, which is sheltering members of non-Muslim ethnic minority groups—including the Mro and Daingnet—displaced by recent fighting between the Burma Army and the Arakan Army.

Min Aung said that Yanghee Lee arrived at 10 am on Wednesday at Sittwe airport, where she held a ten-minute meeting with Chief Minister Nyi Pu. According to Min Aung, Yanghee Lee did not use either of the controversial terms "Bengali" or "Rohingya."

The Arakan State government spokesman also said that Yanghee Lee's agenda did not include visits to any of the camps for displaced Muslims.

He said that Yanghee Lee was interested to visit Kadi village tract in Ponnagyun Township because it is one of the sites being targeted by the government's re-booted citizenship verification program aimed at stateless Muslims in Arakan State.

As previously reported by The Irrawaddy, Muslim residents of the village tract have met the process with distrust, with some refusing to cooperate.

The Irrawaddy contacted four separate individuals who attended the meeting between Yanghee Lee and Nyi Pu. They concurred with the account of spokesman Min Aung.

A government source shared an audio file of the meeting with The Irrawaddy, which featured no mention of the words "Rohingya" or "Bengali."

Chief Minister Nyi Pu said the state government is now "observing and analyzing" the situation in Arakan State and following instructions from State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi, who chairs the new Committee for Arakan State Peace, Stability and Development.

Nyi Pu said that, "under Suu Kyi's leadership, we will quickly implement changes and deliver development. I believe our people will fully obtain the benefits."

Nyi Pu mentioned that the world is watching Aung San Suu Kyi and her actions will be judged according to "international standards." Nobody should doubt her sincerity, he said. He added that there was no cause for misunderstanding between the UN and the Burmese government. He called on Yanghee Lee to collaborate with the government's plan.

Yanghee Lee said she had "come as a true friend" of Arakan State and was there to help.

Yanghee Lee expressed her gladness that Aung San Suu Kyi was leading the new committee on Arakan State, and was devoting attention to its pressing issues. She also expressed confidence in Chief Minister Nyi Pu, whom she trusted would help deliver positive change.

"Today I would like to take the opportunity again to thank you all for working hard on a very complex and very difficult situation," she said.

On Tuesday, Ms. Yanghee Lee told civil society groups in Rangoon that she had been prohibited by the government from visiting northern Shan State, where several thousand civilians have fled armed conflict in recent months, out of concern for her "safety."

The Irrawaddy phoned President Office's spokesman Zaw Htay on Wednesday to clarify this restriction imposed on Yanghee Lee but the calls went unanswered.

The post UN Rapporteur Avoids Contentious Terms with Arakan Chief Minister appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Low-Grade Gems in High Demand in Moe Goke

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 04:27 AM PDT

Gems trading inside Mogok's Hta Pwe gems market, June 2016. (Photo: Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy.) Gems trading inside Mogok's Hta Pwe gems market, June 2016. (Photo: Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy.) Gems trading inside Mogok's Hta Pwe gems market, June 2016. (Photo: Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy.) Gems trading inside Mogok's Hta Pwe gems market, June 2016. (Photo: Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy.) Gems trading inside Mogok's Hta Pwe gems market, June 2016. (Photo: Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy.) Gems trading inside Mogok's Hta Pwe gems market, June 2016. (Photo: Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy.) Gems trading inside Mogok's Hta Pwe gems market, June 2016. (Photo: Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy.) Gems trading inside Mogok's Hta Pwe gems market, June 2016. (Photo: Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy.) Gems trading inside Mogok's Hta Pwe gems market, June 2016. (Photo: Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy.) Gems trading inside Mogok's Hta Pwe gems market, June 2016. (Photo: Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy.) Gems trading inside Mogok's Hta Pwe gems market, June 2016. (Photo: Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy.) Gems trading inside Mogok's Hta Pwe gems market, June 2016. (Photo: Zaw Zaw / The Irrawaddy.)

RANGOON — The demand for large quantities of low-grade stones in Burma's ruby rich Moe Goke has remained strong even as prices increase and the country enters the rainy season, gems traders said.

Moe Goke, also known as 'Ruby Land', is a lush valley known for its rubies, sapphires, moonstones and other gems located about 202 kilometers (126 miles) north of Mandalay city. The area is peppered with dozens of varieties of semi-precious stones, but miners have said the deposits are noticeably thinning.

While rubies and other semi-precious gemstones have become more difficult to find, low-grade gems are in demand for buyer's who eye a bigger market share, Moe Goke gems traders said.

"Last year, the price for low-grade stones was about 100,000 kyats (about US$85) per stone, but this year some have fetched up to 3-5 million kyats as demand continues to increase, said Yu Yu Hlaing, a trader in Hta Pwe, Moe Goke's gems market.

Hta Pwe, which translates to 'a plate for showing,'  opens every day at noon when both local and foreign traders rush in.

"More traders are coming to Hta Pwe from all over the country," she said.

Because the once-abundant quality stones are no longer so easily found, thousands of low-grade gem stones are passing hands alongside the slower market for rubies and other semi-precious stones.

Nge Nge, another gems trader, said some low-grade stones, especially one known by the local name 'hot pink,' are in particularly high demand.

These stones are not common in other areas of the country and are in high demand in Yangon, she added.

Locals have mined the area by hand since the British colonial era, setting up modest mining operations. Those small businesses began winding down around 1988, when the then-ruling military junta offered up large-scale mining concessions.

The post Low-Grade Gems in High Demand in Moe Goke appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

After Shooting of Kachin Teen, Protesters Dispute Burma Army Claims

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 04:00 AM PDT

A group of protesters march in Myitkyina Tuesday, carrying the dead body of Gum Seng Awng from the hospital to his home. (Photo: Kachin Waves / Facebook)

A group of protesters march in Myitkyina Tuesday, carrying the dead body of Gum Seng Awng from the hospital to his home. (Photo: Kachin Waves / Facebook)

RANGOON — After nearly one thousand local residents in Myitkyina, Kachin State took to the streets on Tuesday to protest the shooting of a teen by a Burma Army soldier, the Ministry of Defense has officially announced the cause of death as a "misfire."

On Monday night in the Kachin State capital, an unarmed 19-year-old ethnic Kachin university student, Gum Seng Awng, was shot to death by a Burma Army soldier.

The Ministry of Defense announced in The Global New Light of Myanmar, a state-run newspaper, on Wednesday, "The death of a Kachin man on Monday night was caused by a misfire from a soldier's gun."

"The two soldiers were providing security at the Bala Min Htin Bridge in Myitkyina and were escorting four [female] civilians who asked them to help as they were being threatened by a group of men," said the statement. "When the soldiers arrived back [at] the bridge, a group comprising eight men fought them and attempted to grab the arm of a soldier, who then apparently misfired his weapon killing a young male."

The two soldiers were injured and are receiving medical treatment at a local Army battalion base.

"Action will be taken according to the procedures," said the Ministry of Defense.

However, residents and relatives remain upset because the victim was an unarmed civilian. Local sources confirmed that there was an argument between the two soldiers and a group of young Kachin men that led to the Gum Seng Awng's death. But they dispute the events that led up to the shooting.

Zau Lat, Gum Seng Awng's uncle, told The Irrawaddy the cause of the death was unclear because his nephew's friends had different accounts.

"His friends said they were on their way home when they saw two girls and joked around with them. But then the two soldiers drove behind the girls and asked the young men why they were talking with the girls, so they had an argument," said Zau Lat.

"But, looking at his injures, it looks like he was shot from behind deliberately at close range," added Zau Lat, adding that his nephew's body had three bullet holes.

According to the account Zau Lat heard, Gum Seng Awng was with three of his friends, as opposed to the Army's claim of a group of eight men.

Relatives of the victim wanted local authorities to investigate the killing and bring to justice those responsible. However, they said they had low expectations and claimed the local authorities tried to prevent them from seeing and examining Gum Seng Awng's corpse at the hospital on the night of the incident.

In their march on Tuesday, the protesters held placards and posters that read, "Stop killing students, stop killing unarmed civilians, stop killing Kachins."

"They marched yesterday [Tuesday] to condemn the killing of civilians, and they want guarantees it won't happen again," Zau Lat said. "They are trying to put pressure [on the authorities]."

There was no protest today, and a funeral ceremony will be held Thursday at 1 pm, led by the Kachin Baptist Convention, a local Christian civil society organization.

The post After Shooting of Kachin Teen, Protesters Dispute Burma Army Claims appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Credit Bureau Alone Won’t Overcome Limited Credit Access

Posted: 22 Jun 2016 02:10 AM PDT

Cashiers behind piles of kyat banknotes in a private bank in Rangoon. (Photo: Reuters)

Cashiers behind piles of kyat banknotes in a private bank in Rangoon. (Photo: Reuters)

The creation of a credit bureau is usually a key enabler in improving the access of credit for individuals, business owners and small enterprises.

A credit bureau provides lenders with the credit history of borrowers and statistical information to assess their ability to repay loans. It also introduces a level playing field with all lenders accessing the same information, driving borrowing costs down through competition for prime customers. Eventually, it limits the number of nonperforming loans that remain outstanding because lenders can make better-informed decisions.

These are the benefits of a successful credit bureau, whether it is a public credit registry attached to the central bank or a privately-run entity with obligations to the regulator or the banking association.

However, the introduction of a credit bureau in Burma may not bring significant benefits in the short- and medium-term.

The implementation of a credit bureau will take time and face many of the operational issues commonly observed in emerging markets. These include difficulties in identifying customers, the absence of reported financial information, and the lack of comprehensive and accurate data from lenders. Many banks do not yet have a core banking system or a developed IT system, and have to resort to manual and paper-based reporting.

The existence of a large informal lending sector also presents an obstacle to building a reliable credit bureau, because informal sector credit will not be reported.

More fundamentally, current limitations in credit access are not just linked to an absence of information that would be overcome by a credit bureau, but more to existing regulation and insufficient credit and risk management skills in the banking sector.

The relaxation of eligible collateral rules and the widening of the credit spread (the difference between the minimum deposit rate and the maximum credit rate, which is currently set at 5% by the Central Bank) would allow consumers with a higher risk profile, who are nonetheless still creditworthy, to borrow.

The development of credit risk management processes and skills in the banking sector would be needed to encourage the banks to do away with their current practices of monetizing existing collateral rather than lending to creditworthy economic agents.

The establishment of a credit bureau is undoubtedly an important step but should be part of a broader, much-needed banking sector transformation plan. Sequencing the plan and defining priorities would be key to maximizing impact, given the capacity constraints of both the government regulator and the banking industry.

Mr. Chassat is a Partner with Roland Berger and Head of Financial Services Practice, Southeast Asia.  He has been advising the Central Bank of Myanmar on Foreign Bank Licensing and Interbank Market development.

The post Credit Bureau Alone Won't Overcome Limited Credit Access appeared first on The Irrawaddy.