Wednesday, January 16, 2019

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Dozens of Village Administrators Tender Resignation in Rakhine: Lawmaker

Posted: 16 Jan 2019 06:16 AM PST

YANGON — About 30 village administrators across Rakhine State’s Rathedaung Township submitted resignation letters to their local General Administration Department on Tuesday for fear of being wrongly accused of association with the Arakan Army (AA), according to a Union lawmaker with the Arakan National Party.

Daw Khin Saw Wai said the administrators played a key role in delivering public services in rural areas and that their departure en masse could destabilize the local government but that they increasingly felt under pressure from both the Myanmar military and the AA.

"They have to maintain good relations with everyone, otherwise it will be quite risky for them. But now they are afraid of being sued by senior authorities," she said.

The lawmaker said the township General Administration Department has asked senior officials how to handle the resignation letters. The Rathedaung department office could not be reached for comment.

The government recently announced that it would be transferring the General Administration Department from the military-controlled Ministry of Home Affairs to the Ministry of the Office of the Union Government, which is under civilian control.

Daw Khin Saw Wai said two of her constituents, Yae Gaung Chaung Village Administrator U Maung Tun Hlaing and another man, were accused by the military of having ties to the AA in December.

"Many administrators assume that kind of action could happen to them in the near future," she said.

Yae Gaung Chaung resident U Tun Hlaing said the two men were detained on Dec. 18 and that the administrator of neighboring Tha Yet Pyin Village in Buthidaung Township was recently charged under the Unlawful Associations Act.

A high-ranking military official recently sued the administrator of Say Taung Village for accusing the military of forcing 11 locals to act as human shields in the area for its soldiers. The administrator has been summoned by the court three times but yet to appear.

In a statement on Tuesday, the Myanmar military said it had detained 15 people in Tha Yet Pyin on suspicion of having ties to the AA and released all but two — the village administrator and another man — who confessed to informing the AA of the military’s movements. It said two residents of Yathedaung Township’s Kyein Thar Village were also detained for allegedly using their phones to take photos of its soldiers in the area and send them to the AA.

The post Dozens of Village Administrators Tender Resignation in Rakhine: Lawmaker appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Chinese Firm Proposes $1.5-bn Elevated Railway for Yangon

Posted: 16 Jan 2019 05:58 AM PST

YANGON—China is looking to make further inroads into Myanmar's economy by funding a US$1.5-billion elevated railway project in the country's commercial capital, Yangon.

China Railway Eryuan Engineering Group Co., Ltd (CREEC) made a presentation about its planned project to develop an elevated railway to lawmakers in a media room in the regional parliament on Monday.

Under the proposed project, CREEC will build the 37.9km-long elevated railroad with 24 stations in two to three years. The company said it will fund the project, which is estimated to cost $1.5 billion, but asked for a 50-year contract to operate the service, according to MPs who were at the presentation meeting.

Regional lawmaker U Than Naing Oo from Panbedan Township told The Irrawaddy that lawmakers raised the issue of the region's ongoing problems with land seizures and confiscations, and disagreed with the company's plan to develop an alternative route instead of connecting with the city's existing circular railway.

The Ministry of Transport and Communications is upgrading Yangon's circular railway line with the help of Japan International Cooperation Agency. The upgrade includes modernizing the line's stations, tracks and trains. Management expects to finish the project in 2023. Some 73,000 commuters ride the line daily.

Representatives of China Railway Eryuan Engineering Group Co. make a presentation about their proposed rail project to lawmakers at the Yangon Regional Parliament on Jan. 14, 2019. / Yangon Region Government / Facebook

U Than Naing Oo said CREEC expects the rail line to serve some 400,000 commuters daily. It proposed two lines: one from Kyee-myindaing to Mingalardon and another from North Okkala's Kyauk Yay Twinn to Yangon International Airport.

He said the 50-year term would need to be considered, as Parliament is reviewing long-term projects approved in the past.

Yangon Region Investment Monitoring Team chairwoman Naw Pan Thinzar Myo, who is also the region's Karen ethnic affairs minister, and Yangon Region Parliament deputy speaker U Lin Naing Myint were also present at the meeting.

According to lawmaker U Than Naing Oo, Naw Pan Thinzar Myo said the regional government basically agreed with the proposed project, as the government wouldn't need to fund it or obtain loans. However, for final approval, the minister said the plan would be submitted to the ruling National League for Democracy's economic committee and to the Union Government for review, the lawmaker added.

Prior to holding its first presentation about the project for lawmakers on Monday, the company met and discussed the issue with regional government officials in late 2018.

Regional lawmaker U Yan Aung from Mingalar Taung Nyunt Township said he heard that companies from other countries are also interested in developing the elevated railway and are preparing to present their plans to the regional chief minister.

"We welcome competition. Officials, including [we lawmakers], can decide which will be the best option for the public," he said.

In November last year Hong Kong-listed China Communications Construction Co. Ltd finalized its proposal for the development of US$1.5 billion (2.4 trillion kyats) worth of initial infrastructure for the controversial "New Yangon City" project to the west of the Yangon River.

The post Chinese Firm Proposes $1.5-bn Elevated Railway for Yangon appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Myanmar’s 2019 Economic Outlook

Posted: 16 Jan 2019 05:10 AM PST

YANGON—Despite Myanmar facing a significant economic downturn last year, government officials and business people alike have expressed positivity for the country's economy in 2019, especially in regards to foreign investment and the local business environment.

However, the country still has many challenges to face. The unsolved crisis in Rakhine State, weak strategies in the tourism sector and policies that do not favor local investors are just a few obstacles that must be tackled. Despite these, Myanmar expects to receive more investment from East Asia, for investment agreements to generate more job opportunities and to see progress in local small- and medium-sized enterprises.

As we set out on a new year, 2019, The Irrawaddy spoke to a range of experts including an official from the government investment body, the vice president of Myanmar Federation of Chambers of Commerce and Industry and business people from the industrial and tourism sectors about their expectations for this year.

U Aung Naing Oo

Director General

Directorate of Investment and Company Administration

U Aung Naing Oo, director general of the Directorate of Investment and Company Administration (DICA) at the launching ceremony of the Myanmar Companies Law in Yangon in 2018. / The Irrawaddy /

Although international organizations expect that the global investment outlook may not see significant improvements, I expect that Myanmar will receive more investment in 2019 compared to last year. We expect to receive more investment from Japan, China, South Korea, Hong Kong, Singapore and Thailand.

This year is also a time to focus on the implementation process of a major investment promotion plan called the Myanmar Investment Promotion Plan (MIPP). [The plan aims to attract more than $200 billion through responsible and quality business over the next 20 years.] Depending on each project, we will form an investment promotion committee that will be led by the chair of Myanmar Investment Commission.

At the end of the January, we will kick off the Invest Myanmar Summit 2019 in Naypyitaw jointly organized with the Union of Myanmar Federation of Chambers of Commerce and Industry (UMFCCI). We are seeking major investments from East Asia. The summit will provide international and local investors with the opportunities to discover potential investment opportunities in 10 regions and states across the country. Each state has a unique sector to invest in, so we decided to invite investors according to the location and its sectors.

Moreover, we have a plan to tour abroad with our investment promotion agenda with particular focus on Japan and other East Asia and ASEAN countries. We are preparing to hold an investment fair for Rakhine State in February and for Chin State in March.  

In terms of investment under the China-Myanmar Economic Corridor agreement, the investment for Mandalay, Muse and Kyaukphyu railway projects and major highways projects may begin and, including Kyaukphyu SEZ, we expect more local job opportunities under the agreement.

As we remove many restrictions on investors, foreign investors will get a chance to invest in the stock exchange market. The new Myanmar Companies Law took effect three months ago, so we expect to see more foreign investment in local companies which were off limits to foreign investors in the past. As a result of making business regulations more efficient and effective, small and medium enterprises will have more chances to look at new opportunities.

U Maung Maung Lay

Vice President

Union of Myanmar Federation of Chambers of Commerce and Industry (UMFCCI)

U Maung Maung Lay, vice president of the Union of Myanmar Federation of Chambers of Commerce and Industry (UMFCCI) in Yangon in January 2019. / Shwe Lay / The Irrawaddy /

The year 2019 will be totally different from 2018. Many economic reforms and policies made by the current government will come into effect. Business conditions should be better this year. The government has been in term for more than two-and-a-half years, so I hope they have been learning a lot about how to make the country's economy better and which are the best policies to help business to thrive. If they fail again this year, it will likely affect the next election results.

The country's image has been tarnished due to the Rakhine crisis. We can't deny that this case is one of the major factors behind the decline in foreign investment. However, the government changed their policy to "look east" (towards East Asia countries for investment). Moreover, the government has geared up its support for small and medium-sized enterprises. The relationship between the government and SMEs is become more active and making progress.

The government needs to favor local investors while the country opens up to foreign investors including in the trade, retail and wholesale sectors. Local investors are concerned that they won't be able to compete with foreign investors in those sectors. It also poses threat that local companies may be shut down. They need to protect local investors first.   

We recently discussed investments from the United States, the UK, China, Japan, Australia, New Zealand, Thailand and Malaysia. We have been focusing on investment prospects for the coming three months. Among the foreign countries, more Japanese investors will look to invest in Myanmar.

Many foreign investors are interested in attending the Invest Myanmar Summit 2019 on Jan. 28 and 29 in Naypyitaw. We have one hundred projects on offer for both local and foreign investors. They will have chances to learn what types of projects and sectors are open to them and they can also make direct contact with officials and business people from each state and region. Considering the overall effort of the government and its investment body so far, the country's economy will be better in this year.

Daw Yin Myo Su

Managing Director of the Inle Princess Group

Founder of Inle Heritage Foundation

Daw Yin Myo Su, managing director of the Inle Princess Group in Yangon in 2017. / The Irrawaddy /

Last year, businesses experienced what could be said was the worst year in 20 years. This fiscal year [2018-2019] has so far dropped 20 percent below the 2017-2018 fiscal year. [The tourism sector calculates a fiscal year as starting from April 1 and therefore, the tourism 2018-2019 fiscal year will end on March 31.] We experienced a significant drop in 2007-2008, but it was because of political issues and a natural disaster. But this time, the drop is due to international pressure from outside. I still need to wait and see what happens between January and April 2019. If we are lucky it could increase by 5 or 10 percent.

Meanwhile, we have been reducing costs as much as we can to prepare for the worst conditions. Despite the visa exemptions for some Asian countries, I don't see a significant rise in tourist numbers from those countries. I still see a number of tourists from the west. We have more hotels than the number of tourist that we received. Even if the number [of tourists] increases a little, we don't really feel the result.

As we already know, living costs are quite expensive in Myanmar. It is a major reason that we can't compete with Thailand or Vietnam. As inflation rates are high, not only daily food expenses but also transportation costs are high too. If we calculate overall costs (of a tourism business), the amount is huge. As a result, it becomes double tax on customers. If we reduce the cost, we can't give a good service to the customers. It is like a cycle—if our service is not good, people will choose other destinations like Thailand or Vietnam over Myanmar. The government needs to help us to reduce the cost of living.

Moreover, the government can't effectively reach out to the international tourism community. We need more effective marketing strategies for the tourism sector. They are also weak at communication skills both outside and inside the country; they don't really know how to respond—how to explain the conditions like in the Rakhine crisis in order to save the country's image. If we respond in an aggressive way, we won't get a good result. They should have good public relation strategies both with international and local people. The government also needs to explain policy changes using short and simple terms for the public. Furthermore, this government is more focused on long-term policies. I support long-term plans but in Myanmar the majority of people cannot wait to get benefits. They need changes that can give them advantages within the short term. While implementing long-term plans, the government also needs to do some short-term reforms in order to make the people happy.  

U Myat Thin Aung

Chairman

Hlaing Tharyar Industrial Zone

U Myat Thin Aung, chairman of Hlaing Tharyar Industrial Zone at his office in Yangon on Jan. 16 2019. / Htet Wai / The Irrawaddy /

The National League for Democracy government took heed of the peace process but abandoned the country's economy. However, as they began to notice the country's economy declining, they tried to pay more attention to economic reforms just before the end of 2018. They ordered the easing of policies in many sectors in order to become investor-friendly.

I think we will see rewards from those efforts this year. The cabinet members, especially the vice president, met with local business people frequently to find ways to revive the business environment. The government also encourages local investors to make more investments in the country.

There are two major risks to economic growth this year—the Rakhine crisis and the possible withdrawal of EU trade preferences. The Rakhine crisis could intensify at any time and that would cause a loss of trust from investors. The revoking of EU trade preferences would impact the lives of the ordinary people and we also could lose one of the country's largest foreign incomes. But the garment sector is waiting to hear the EU's decision. If they decide to revoke the trade privileges, we will look for a new market.

Myanmar had a chance to capitalize on the trade tensions between the US and China but there wasn't much confidence in Myanmar so they did not come to us. When the trade tensions arose, Chinese companies mostly looked towards Vietnam. We still have many things to prepare in order to be able to accept massive investment, especially in the production sector.

Under this government, no one has special privileges. They provide a level playing field in terms of doing business in the country. However, since the ASEAN Economic Community came into effect, our production sector is struggling to compete with other ASEAN countries. [The first pillars of ASEAN Economic Community involves the free flow of goods, services, investment, labour and capital among the ASEAN countries.] One major problem is that the government cannot provide a sufficient power supply to the industrial zones.

Our country can only produce raw materials. We're not able to produce finished products or goods. We sell raw materials to the other countries, then we buy finished products from them. It is a failure of the industrial sector. We must change that condition.

The post Myanmar's 2019 Economic Outlook appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Regional Parliament Deputy Speaker Expelled for Embezzlement

Posted: 16 Jan 2019 05:04 AM PST

PATHEIN—The National League for Democracy (NLD) has expelled from its party the deputy speaker of the Irrawaddy regional parliament for alleged misappropriation of funds.

Following the filing of a complaint by a Pathein resident against deputy speaker U San Min Aung, who allegedly embezzled government funds for the purchase of five vehicles for the regional parliament, the NLD party launched an internal investigation into the case in December, leading to his dismissal following a meeting of the party's central executive committee on Jan. 13.

"We have done this because the special investigation body reported that he is responsible for the purchase of cars for the parliament. We will take further action as necessary according to the report. We have also given serious warnings to three lawmakers who were also involved in the purchase of the cars," NLD spokesperson U Myo Nyunt told The Irrawaddy.

The Irrawaddy was not able to contact either U San Min Aung or parliamentary speaker U Aung Kyaw Khaing for comments.

According to U Myo Nyunt, the Irrawaddy regional parliament obtained $104,000 from the budget of the Union Parliament for the 2017-18 fiscal year to buy five used vehicles. The regional parliament formed a committee and invited tender to buy a minibus, a light truck, two Toyota HiAces and a Toyota Hilux Double Cab.

Out of three companies that submitted tender for the purchase, only one company qualified. However, the qualified company failed to deliver the vehicles. The regional parliament then asked for permission to buy the cars directly, and also proposed buying one more Toyota HiAce instead of the minibus and to buy a Toyota Hilux Extra Cab instead of the Double Cab.

The regional parliamentary speaker formed an eight-member team to arrange the purchase of the vehicles. The team was led by U San Min Aung and included officials from the Road Transport Administration Department and a number of lawmakers.

The team bought three HiAce vehicles and a light truck from one company, and a Toyota Hilux Extra Cab from another company. Stamps and income taxes worth over $2,170 were given to Pathein Township Internal Revenues Department at the instruction of the Union Parliament. U San Min Aung told Akonthi news agency that he also had receipts for repairs of those cars.

"Lawmakers as well as other people are surprised that we got those cars for such [low] prices. They only know our buying prices and market prices. Only the team knows how much they paid in tax. They questioned why there is a difference of around 4 million kyats ($2,630), so I think people filed the complaint because they didn't know about the tax paid for those cars or the cost of car repairs," he said in the interview with Akonthi.

On the current market, a used HiAce car is usually sold for around $23,000, a light truck around $9,850 and a new Toyota Hilux Extra Cab, around $16,400.

U San Min Aung, 38, worked as a lawyer before his success in the 2015 election in Bogale Township, Irrawaddy Region after which he was appointed deputy parliamentary speaker.

Before U San Min Aung, the NLD also expelled Bogale Township's NLD member U Aung Myint in 2017 and vice-chairman of the NLD's Pathein Township chapter, U Hsan Shwe who was imprisoned under Article 66 (d) of the Myanmar Telecommunications Law.

On Wednesday, U Myo Nyunt told The Irrawaddy that the NLD's central executive committee would refer U San Min Aung on to the Anti-Corruption Committee.

The post Regional Parliament Deputy Speaker Expelled for Embezzlement appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Ta’ang Armed Group Wants Talks With China on Rail Project

Posted: 16 Jan 2019 04:31 AM PST

Mon State — The Ta’ang National Liberation Army (TNLA) says it wants China to negotiate with it on a proposed railway that would run through territory the ethnic armed group claims to control in northern Shan State, and not only with the Union government.

"We wanted China to negotiate with us on this project. We want some recognition from the Chinese side through negotiations on building this project in areas we control," said TNLA Brigadier General Tar Phone Kyaw.

China and Myanmar signed a memorandum of understanding in October to study the feasibility of a high-speed railway linking Mandalay to the Chinese border at Muse as part of Beijing’s Belt and Road Initiative.

The line would run 431 km and pass through conflict zones in Shan State, including territory claimed by the TNLA. A group is not happy that China has only discussed the project with the Union government.

"Our Ta'ang people are the original owners of this land. To launch such a huge project in our area, China needs to talk with us," Brig. Gen. Tar Phone Kyaw said.

He said China was taking advantage of a four-month ceasefire the Myanmar military declared in northern and eastern Myanmar in late December to start on the study and that the TNLA has been asked to provide the workers with protection.

"We have been told by China only to take care of security for their engineers and workers building the project. For our side, we think China pays us very little attention,” he added.

The TNLA says it has raised its concerns over the project with China’s special envoy for Asia affairs, Sun Guoxiang, but the envoy showed little interest.

Parts of the proposed route see sporadic fighting between the Myanmar military and local ethnic armed groups, and Brig. Gen. Tar Phone Kyaw suggested that China hold off on the project until the disputes are settled. He said the TNLA was also concerned that local authorities may not compensate people adequately for land appropriated to build the line.

"There is not transparency. Both the central and regional government administrations are very corrupt. We are worried that our people will not get the full benefits they deserve from the project,” he said.

The TNLA is worried of a repeat of the time China built a gas pipeline through northern Shan State several ears ago, when all that most locals got it return for their land were a few schools.

"Very few people got compensation." Brig. Gen. Tar Phone Kyaw said.

The general accused local officials of pocketing most of the money China gave the government to compensate locals.

"For example, China may have given 10 million kyats for one acre of land. But the local authority gave 50,000 to 100,000 kyats only," he said.

China has brokered several meetings between the Myanmar military and government and armed groups based along its border with country. It has repeatedly urged the armed groups to refrain from fighting along the border, where it has several BRI projects in the works.

The post Ta’ang Armed Group Wants Talks With China on Rail Project appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Latest Peace Talks with EAOs ‘Quite Successful’: Gov’t Spokesman

Posted: 16 Jan 2019 12:52 AM PST

CHIANG MAI, Thailand—The government peace delegation led by Peace Commission secretary U Khin Zaw Oo held separate, informal talks with four ethnic armed organizations (EAOs) in Chiang Mai, Thailand early this week. Negotiators met with representatives of the Karen National Union (KNU), the Restoration Council of Shan State (RCSS), the Karenni National Progressive Party (KNPP) and the Kachin Independence Army (KIA).

After the series of informal talks, The Irrawaddy reporter Nyein Nyein spoke to government spokesman U Zaw Htay about future peace negotiations, internally displaced persons (IDPs) who have fled the current conflict in Rakhine State between the Myanmar military (or Tatmadaw) and the Arakan Army (AA), as well as the government's view of the AA.

What can you tell us about the results of this series of informal talks with the different ethnic armed groups, held over two days? 

Our talks here in Chiang Mai in November were an attempt at damage control for the peace process, following the release of statements [by the KNU and RCSS]. We are worried about getting caught in a cycle of conflict. And our priority is to limit the damage in these situations. We conduct informal negotiations with the groups in order to bring them back to the normal path [of the peace process].

This time is a continuation of that effort. With the KNU, we had three informal talks, first in November and then in Yangon with [the group's military and security adviser] Colonel Htoo Htoo Lay. This week's talks were much more constructive. The KNU will hold discussions with its members and then they will meet other EAOs, and then they will meet with us. So we expect we will be back on the formal path soon and [the process] will be normalized.

The RCSS will meet separately with National Reconciliation and Peace Center leaders and with military leaders in Naypyitaw soon, to settle issues raised in their statement [suspending their participation in both the Union and state levels of the Joint Ceasefire Monitoring Committee]. From there, they will discuss the issues thoroughly; after that we will be in the normalization stage.

As with the KNPP, we have held informal talks five times. We, both sides, are trying to move forward [toward signing the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement (NCA)] and to reach that milestone. But we cannot specify a time frame, as we need to keep negotiating.

We will also meet with another non-signatory of the NCA [the KIA], on how they will participate in the NCA. Thus we are not able to say anything about that yet. [Note: This interview was conducted before the Peace Commission delegation's meeting with the KIA, which was not open to the media.]

Our aim in coming to Chiang Mai for informal talks is purely to get back to normalization [of the peace process]. Also [it is an effort to keep negotiating] with non-signatories to the NCA, in order to get them to sign. It has been quite a successful trip.

What does the government expect from the KNPP, a non-signatory to the NCA, if it is to participate in the upcoming session of the Union Peace Conference, assuming one is held this year? 

Both sides are trying. Not only the government, but also the KNPP is trying to achieve that [getting the KNPP  on the formal NCA path]. Currently, that is it; we can say no more.

In November, you met informally with KIA representatives. After that, the government's peace delegation went to northern Myanmar to hold talks with three EAOs—the Ta'ang National Liberation Army, the AA and the Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army—but we did not hear of any meeting with the KIA. What is the government doing to meet KIA leaders at the decision-making level? 

After this trip, the PC [Peace Commission] secretary, [retired] General Khin Zaw Oo, will travel to the northern region to hold more talks. We will not stop negotiating with signatories and non-signatories of the NCA, and we are continuously moving forward.

The AA is currently engaged in clashes with the Tatmadaw in western Myanmar. What impact does that have on its participation in the peace process? Will you hold bilateral talks with the AA? Last month's announcement from these groups included a willingness to hold such talks. 

No, it is for the Peace Commission to decide whether talks continue with these three groups. Only when the commissioners go there again [this month] and listen to their responses will we know for sure how this will proceed.

Currently, what we can say for sure is that we do not exclude the AA from the peace process. We have opened the door to the AA to join us at the peace table, where we can all negotiate.

For years, people have been affected by the civil war in the states where ethnic armed groups are based. These groups are now trying to cease fighting and end the cycle of conflict. On the other hand, in Rakhine State—which has also faced violence from ARSA [the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army]—the conflict is escalating. So it is the reverse situation. It is moving in the opposite direction from the current peace process, and there will be negative impacts from this. We have urged the AA to get back on track, as the group is also holding talks with the Peace Commission.

Specifically, negotiation is the best approach to any problem. We have to find the way through peaceful negotiation. We won't get the answer through armed conflict, because we have had that for more than 70 years.

This armed struggle [in Rakhine State] will yield no answers and benefit no one. First, the people suffer, and secondly the state suffers. And thirdly, there are many consequences for the Union [the country as a whole] and it doesn't benefit anyone. Thus, we urge [them] to choose the path of negotiation to end these conflicts.

Conflict causes suffering; no one wins. It is a [no-win situation]. Currently we are seeing and hearing that many local people are being forced to flee their homes. Our government is deeply sorry about this.

To help those displaced, our government is prioritizing their resettlement, the opening of IDP camps. Social Welfare and Resettlement Minister Dr. Win Myat Aye is working on it. We are trying to help the displaced people get access to humanitarian assistance, including shelter and food. Then, when their basic needs have been met, we will try to help children get access to formal education. [Primary and middle school students' year-end exams are only a couple of months away.]

Meanwhile, we are in talks with the Ministry of Health and Sports to be able to provide healthcare to them. Some of this assistance is under way. Medical staff are being sent to provide care; these are more like mobile clinics providing mobile healthcare.

I would like to emphasize that we are arranging assistance for those civilians affected by the armed conflict.

During your last press briefing, in the wake of the latest flare-up in the conflict in Rakhine, you told Rakhine State people not to support the AA. This was interpreted as a kind of threat against the public. Has this perception affected your ability to resolve the conflict in the state? 

We urged this because not all of the people [in Rakhine] believe that "We are all AA" or are supporters of the organization. We have some information on the AA's supporters, but we cannot say exactly who they are.

What is important is that peace be achieved in Rakhine State as quickly as possible; everyone in the state must contribute to its stability. Another important thing is to move forward with development. We have a lot of projects in Rakhine and we need stability in the area for the projects to be implemented. These projects will help to develop the region and the public will benefit. Therefore, we are focusing on stability.

Only when the area is stable will we be able to implement our support for IDPs to get access to humanitarian aid and healthcare, and for children to get access to formal education. Meanwhile, the communities must collaborate with us to keep the conflict from escalating.

We understand that everyone wants Rakhine State to be peaceful. For that to be achieved, every stakeholder—the governments and the local residents—must work together.

Therefore, we are asking [the EAOs] to join the negotiations to settle the problems. For that to happen, we need to meet at the political [negotiation] table. And the negotiations with the Peace Commission need to be effective and need to see improvement so that we can sort things out through political means. We have had this armed approach for many eras, and there has been no answer. Thus, it is a difficult problem to solve and we need to move on and settle things through political means.

(This interview has been edited for clarity.)

The post Latest Peace Talks with EAOs 'Quite Successful': Gov't Spokesman appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Thai Top Court Orders Compensation for Myanmar Workers in Landmark Case

Posted: 15 Jan 2019 08:42 PM PST

BANGKOK—Thailand’s highest court on Tuesday ordered compensation be paid to 14 migrant workers from Myanmar whose accusations against a chicken farm of abuses sparked a landmark legal case for migrant laborers.

The workers in 2016 officially complained to Thailand’s National Human Rights Commission about forced overtime, being paid less than the minimum wage, confiscation of passports, and limited freedom of movement.

But employer Thammakaset farm, which had supplied meat to Thai food conglomerate Betagro, denied the charges and launched a defamation lawsuit, saying the workers voluntarily worked nights and chose to sleep next to the chicken warehouse.

Betagro, which sells to companies around the globe, later said it had cut ties with the farm.

After a three-year legal battle, the Supreme Court upheld a lower court verdict from 2016 which found in favor of the workers and ruled they must be paid 1.7 million baht ($53,000) in compensation.

“There is no significant legal argument from the company’s side,” the court said in its order, dismissing the appeal.

A lawyer for the workers said they welcomed the verdict in a country that has been at the center of a slew of slavery and human trafficking cases, including in its seafood sector.

“Hopefully, they will receive the compensation quickly and put this behind them,” said Koreeyor Manuchae at NSP Legal Office.

Last July, a Bangkok court dismissed charges against the workers in the criminal defamation case which accused them of damaging the reputation of Thammakaset farm.

Labor rights activist Sutharee Wannasiri said Tuesday’s verdict vindicated the workers.

“It’s a very rare victory for labor rights and migrant workers in Thailand, and it will help bolster the rights of migrant workers in the country,” she told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.

“The compensation is not a large amount, but it is symbolic, and shows there is a mechanism for securing remedies and accountability when businesses have violated rights.”

Campaigners have urged better protection for migrant laborers and activists from civil and criminal lawsuits for exposing abusive working conditions.

In the face of mounting global scrutiny of supply chains, Thailand has strengthened laws to crack down on labor exploitation, but activists said it was still widespread.

The post Thai Top Court Orders Compensation for Myanmar Workers in Landmark Case appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Singapore Urged to Fix Rules on Hiring Domestic Workers to Stop Forced Labor

Posted: 15 Jan 2019 08:32 PM PST

KUALA LUMPUR—Singapore must overhaul its rules and systems for the hiring of foreign domestic workers to put a stop to forced labor in the wealthy city-state, campaigners said on Tuesday.

Singapore is a top destination for impoverished women from countries including Indonesia, Myanmar and the Philippines, who take up work cooking and caring for local families.

But the estimated 250,000 migrant domestic workers are “highly susceptible” to forced labor due to a lack of legal protections and the isolated nature of their work, according to a report released by two charities on Tuesday.

“It’s pretty worrying,” said Sheena Kanwar, executive director at the Singapore-based Humanitarian Organization for Migration Economics (HOME), which campaigns for migrant workers and co-authored the report.

“Policies should make sure our workers are not vulnerable to forced labor but right now, they allow for that. The issue is so invisible because it happens in households,” she told the Thomson Reuters Foundation by phone.

Based on an 18-month study of more than 800 foreign helpers, the report said workers faced a wide range of issues including hefty fees charged by agents who help the women to find jobs but push them into crippling debt.

A S$5,000 ($3,700) security bond required by the government for every migrant worker also heightens employers’ fears and often leads to “draconian” measures to control their movement.

This includes confiscating workers’ passports and denying them rest days, the report added.

Singapore’s Ministry of Manpower said foreign helpers are protected under “comprehensive” legislation in the country and the report “does not accurately reflect” their work conditions.

“This cannot be further away from the truth,” a ministry spokeswoman said in an email to the Thomson Reuters Foundation, citing its 2015 survey of 1,000 migrant domestic workers which showed 97 percent were satisfied working in Singapore.

HOME and the report co-author, Hong Kong-based anti-slavery group Liberty Shared, urged Singapore to abolish the security bond conditions and move towards a system where employers pay for all the recruitment fees.

They also called on the government to include domestic workers under the country’s Employment Act to better regulate their working hours and overtime, and give them access to benefits such as sick leave.

“If the basic premise of protections is not clearly formulated then it makes access to justice very difficult,” said Archana Kotecha, a regional director at Liberty Shared.

Reports of domestic workers being burned, beaten and raped in Asia have sparked outrage in a region that has the largest share of the world’s domestic workers at more than 21 million.

A Singapore couple were jailed in 2017 for starving their Filipino domestic helper, who weighed just 29.4 kilograms (65 pounds).

The International Labour Organization considers people who are trapped in involuntary work—including through the use of intimidation, debt or the retention of identity papers—as forced labor.

The post Singapore Urged to Fix Rules on Hiring Domestic Workers to Stop Forced Labor appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Tuesday, January 15, 2019

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Calls Grow for Probe of Civil Service Board Following Fake Universities Scandal

Posted: 15 Jan 2019 07:53 AM PST

YANGON—Calls are mounting for an investigation into Myanmar's Union Civil Service Board (UCSB) in the wake of disclosures that it provided training and a master's degree program for high-ranking government officials via two unaccredited foreign universities.

The scandal broke last month after a Myanmar scholar doing a degree at Oxford University in England revealed on Facebook that Hawaii-based Akamai University and an affiliated institution, Malaysia's EDS Business School, were working with the UCSB, a government agency responsible for recruiting and training civil servants.

Neither university is recognized by the government of its home country.

The scholar, Ko Nay Yan Oo, posted videos of Akamai University showing two small rooms in a two-story building he described as being no bigger than "a grocery store". On a door of one of the rooms, a sheet of A4-sized paper could be seen bearing the name of the purported university. The posts were widely shared and many netizens questioned the motivation for the UCSB's decision to partner with the institutions.

Initially, the UCSB defended its relationships with the "universities". It posted on its website on Dec. 30 that both were accredited by the U.K.-based Accreditation Service for International Colleges (ASIC)—an organization that has faced allegations of accrediting "degree mills".

Following heavy criticism from the public on social media, the UCSB said on Jan. 9 that after a review, it had ended its partnerships with the two institutions on Jan. 4, and vowed to collaborate with worthier universities in the future. But no further details, nor any explanation of how the relationships were formed, have yet emerged.

The move failed to satisfy the public and has led to demands for accountability and transparency from the board. Meanwhile, EDS Business School's official Facebook page, which once actively touted its partnership with the UCSB, has disappeared. The school's website is "under maintenance."

Ko Nay Yan Oo told The Irrawaddy that simply ending the cooperation was not enough.

"They must explain to people why they worked with those institutions. How much [public] money has been spent on those two universities? Public funds spent on those two universities have been wasted," he said.

Under their partnerships with the board, Akamai University and EDS Business School conducted several courses starting in 2017, according to data from UCSB.

They offered courses like "Strategic and Corporate Planning for a Public Sector Organization", "Competencies for Transformational Leadership for Civil Service", "Developing a Good to Great Culture for Civil Service" and "Effective Supervision and Team Leadership Methods for Civil Service" to directors of government departments, lecturers from the county's central institutes of civil service, and officials from the Civil Service Affairs Department and the Civil Service Selection and Training Department.

From May 8-13, 2017, leadership training was also given to officials from Union-level institutions and permanent secretaries from Union ministries. In 2018, a "Master of Leadership in Civil Service" program was launched.

Daw Cho Mar Myint, UCSB spokesperson and assistant secretary, told The Irrawaddy on Jan. 10: "The decision to stop collaborating with them was made by the chairman," referring to Dr. Win Thein—who himself received an honorary doctorate from Akamai University in 2014.

She added that the two-year master's program, which was attended by around two dozen directors and deputy director-generals, would also be scrapped.

Dr Win Thein, chairman of the Union Civil Service Board (UCSB), delivers a speech at the opening of the Civil Services Academy in Pyin Oo Lwin. / Global New Light of Myanmar

Asked if the decision to end the collaboration was prompted by the ongoing public criticism of the bogus university, the UCSB spokeswoman declined to comment.

Who is Dr Win Thein?

Before assuming the leadership of the UCSB, ex-military man Dr. Win Thein served as the principal of the Myanmar Mercantile Marine College. His Army background began with the Defense Services Academy (DSA)'s Intake 11, the same class as ex-general U Shwe Mann, considered the third most powerful man in Myanmar's former military regime.

U Win Thein also served as a member of the Union Parliament's Legal Affairs and Special Cases Assessment Commission in 2012.

The UCSB has requested several budget increases in recent years. Under the 2017 Budget Law (for April 1, 2017 to March 30, 2018), it sought 9.3 billion kyats. For the six-month interim budget from April 1 to Sept. 30, 2018, it asked for 4.6 billion kyats.

In the latest budget law for fiscal 2018-19, it asked for 39 billion kyats—an amount larger than the requests from some ministries, including those of the State Counselor's Office, Hotels and Tourism, Religious Affairs and Culture, Commerce, Industry and Ethnic Affairs.

Regarding financial issues, including how much the UCSB spent on the two institutions' training courses, Daw Cho Mar Myint told The Irrawaddy that, "I have no authority to discuss the issue."

Ko Myo Min, founder of PS Business School, said it was shocking that a government agency would work with unaccredited foreign universities to offer training to government officials.

"The problem of fake degrees and degree mills happens all over the world… But here, [the government] has neglected to address it. If they are at fault, they need to admit and provide an explanation to the public. Just saying 'We have cut ties' is so reckless," he said.

Conflicts of Interest

Accreditation aside, Ko Nay Yan Oo saw a possible conflict of interest in UCSB's partnerships with the two bogus universities.

UCSB chairman Dr. Win Thein and his nephew Dr. Win Min Thein have longstanding ties with Akamai University and EDS Business School.

Dr. Win Min Thein founded a business institute, Yangon City Training Center, in 2012. In 2017 it was renamed Nanyeng International College. He also works as a visiting professor at the UCSB's central institutes of civil service. His father, U Min Thein, is a member of the Naypyitaw Development Committee.

Ko Nay Yan Oo said he had discovered that Dr. Win Min Thein first held discussions with Akamai University and EDS Business School about offering business management training in Myanmar in late 2013.

Akamai University appointed Dr. Win Min Thein an assistant professor in its Asia Program. In October 2014, Akamai University bestowed U Win Thein, who was then a member of the Legal Affairs and Special Cases Assessment Commission, with a Doctor of Philosophy Honoris Causa in Educational Leadership in Yangon.

According to Ko Nay Yan Oo, Dr. Win Min Thein and EDS Business School held discussions on the training programs in late 2016 in Yangon. Following this, U Win Thein was appointed as UCSB chair. He later approved the two universities to offer training with the UCSB.

In 2017, EDS Business School awarded Dr. Win Min Thein the Presidential Award for Distinguished Achievement.

Contacted by The Irrawaddy for comment on this story on Sunday, Dr. Win Min Thein initially agreed to be interviewed on Tuesday afternoon. However, his assistant canceled the interview at the last minute, saying Dr. Win Min Thein "was on a tight schedule."

A graduation ceremony is held at the Central Institute of Civil Service (Upper Myanmar) on Feb. 23, 2018. / Global New Light of Myanmar

Calling for an investigation into the scandal, Ko Nay Yan Oo said, "With the country transitioning to a democratic system in which good governance, people-centered administration and transparency are required, what the Union Civil Service Board has done is unacceptable."

He said he would submit complaints to the President's Office, State Counselor's Office and Anti-Corruption Commission calling for an investigation of the UCSB.

Upper House Lawmaker U Myo Win, a National League for Democracy member from Mon State who has a record of calling for civil service reform in Parliament, agreed with Ko Nay Yan Oo.

"Personally, I believe there must be responsibility and accountability for the [UCSB's] cooperation with unaccredited universities," he said.

The President's Office and Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) are aware of the case. Responding to a reporter's question on the scandal at a press briefing in Naypyitaw last week, President's Office Spokesperson Zaw Htay said the UCSB had ended its partnerships with Akamai University and EDS Business School.

Contacted by The Irrawaddy last Friday, an ACC member said there was no immediate plan to launch an investigation into the case for the time being. "If there is a complaint over the case, we will have to review it first," commission spokesperson U Kyaw Soe told The Irrawaddy.

The post Calls Grow for Probe of Civil Service Board Following Fake Universities Scandal appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Home-Grown Tech Startup Taking on International Competitors

Posted: 15 Jan 2019 05:39 AM PST

YANGON—As recently as 2012, the internet in Myanmar was strictly censored, slow and very expensive. From 2013, the telecommunications market began to open up leading to a huge spike the number of internet users, most of whom access the internet via their smart phone and primarily use Facebook.

Since then, Yangon's tech scene has gone from strength to strength and diversified with successes in travel (GoP), accommodation (Ezstay) and employment (Chate Sat) startups exciting observers of the region's startup environment. Considering that less than a decade ago only about 1% of the population had access to the internet, this is significant.

Neh Thit, also known by its English name "New Day," is a local tech startup honing in on this proliferation of smartphone users and fast internet connectivity to provide easy-to-use technology that connects non-executive job seekers with employers. There are currently 50,000 job seekers and over 40 employers using the platform.

In its first year, the startup won an award for innovation from MIT and soon after, was given a vital six-digit grant under GSMA's Ecosystem Accelerator Innovation Fund.

Neh Thit technology can be accessed by smartphone, tablet or computer.

In early November 2018, the entrepreneurs behind Neh Thit pitched their startup alongside eight competitors at the Yangon chapter of Seedstars, an international startup competition, and came out winners, going on to attend the Seedstars Asia Summit held in Bangkok in late November. They have been invited to compete at the Seedstars Summit in Switzerland this April where the competition will be fierce with the global winner taking $500,000 for their company.

Based out of Phandeeyar co-working space in downtown Yangon, the first version of Neh Thit was rolled out in 2017 by a team put together by US-native Conor Smith who, after a number of years living in Yangon, decided to act on complaints he often heard from employers on the difficulties of finding and keeping quality staff. Now a team of 12 permanent staff, and a number of freelancers and advisors who pitch in along the way, run Neh Thit.

"We are trying to help the community and generate income for low-level or entry-level workers," said Ko So Phay Oo, Neh Thit's head of operations who returned from Singapore after seven years to join the Neh Thit team. The team work on creating a win-win situation for both employee and workers.

Head of Operations Ko So Phay Oo at the Phadeeyar co-working space in Yangon on December 5, 2018. / Marie Starr / The Irrawaddy

The Neh Thit team have developed chatbot technology which allows job seekers to start a conversation through Facebook's Messenger or Viber. The conversation is automated and details are acquired from the user, including what field of work they are hoping to find employment in. The chatbot technology automatically creates a resume for them and presents a list of job opportunities suited to their experience and skills. They then choose and apply for whichever jobs they are most interested in.

"We are collecting hundreds of data points, both demographic and behavioral, on our job seekers, which enables us to build full profiles that go beyond traditional CVs. We then apply a matching algorithm to best offer job opportunities to job seekers, and optimally pre-select and pre-interview our candidates to deliver a win-win for both employers and candidates," CEO Conor Smith told The Irrawaddy via email.

Ko So Phay Oo says a strength of Neh Thit is how easy it is to use; that "there is no training necessary in using the technology—everyone knows how to use Facebook Messenger."

"In terms of internet connection, Myanmar is one of the fastest in Southeast Asia. We found that there are a lot of users who are really familiar with Facebook. But we found that only 5% of users are willing to download an application so we decided not to create an app just yet," he said.

Despite the high number of smartphone users and fast internet, introducing a non-traditional method of job-seeking was one of the challenges for the startup.

"We are not only trying to build a product, we are also introducing a new culture of using a web portal and chat technology to find a job or employee which is quite difficult to implement in a short time," he said.

Employers register on the Neh Thit website, choose a pricing plan and list the details of the jobs vacancies they have in their company.

"Our backend system uses HR technology that will automatically match resumes using our systems and inform the employer," said Ko So Phay Oo.

"We have found that we can't just offer matches without additional assistances. To increase success rates of our job seekers throughout the process, we also offer recruiting guidance tools via chat-based online course curriculum. This includes application readiness, interview prep, onboarding prep, etc. So far, we have had over 1,200 candidates successfully complete these modules," said Smith.

The company's first year was all about research, market observation and feasibility studies. The beta version of Neh Thit was launched in August 2018 and—as with all good startups—the team is constantly improving, modifying and adjusting their product while sticking to the concept.

Neh Thit now employs 12 staff members who work at Phandeeyar co-working space in Yangon. / Marie Starr / The Irrawaddy

The company is proud of their office structure where everyone is on the same level—customer service, digital marketing, business development, management and finance and accounting—all work together and the equal respect and responsibility among team members fosters a positive team spirit and plenty of motivation.

Neh Thit targets the entry- and mid-level workforce which is the mass market in Myanmar and includes non-executive jobs such as customer services, hospitality and sales and marketing. So far, they operate only in Yangon but they have plans to move to other urban centers in the future.

The Seedstars summit in April is set to be an exciting opportunity to network with other startups and will provide a chance to meet potential investors as well as to attend seminars and conferences alongside their counterparts from international emerging and established markets.

Going forward, Ko So Phay Oo says the company's ultimate goal is to have full coverage of employers and employees in Myanmar.

"We have made strong progress so far and we are excited about the momentum we have created, but there is still a very long way to go. We are still at the start of our journey, and we are driven to reach our long-term goal of creating an efficient jobs marketplace for non-executive employment opportunities across Myanmar,” said Smith.

The post Home-Grown Tech Startup Taking on International Competitors appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Four Arakanese Facing Charges for Murder of Army Intelligence

Posted: 15 Jan 2019 05:04 AM PST

YANGON—Four Arakanese men are being officially sued under Article 302 of the Penal Code in connection with the killing of a member of a military affairs unit Corp. Win Htike in Rakhine State's capital of Sittwe last September.

Defense lawyer for the four suspects, U Tun Aung Kyaw, confirmed that the court accepted the lawsuit on Monday. He explained that the victim's wife will act as a plaintiff in the case.

Two of the accused, Ko Aung Zaw Lin and Ko Khine Thaw, are Arakanese activists who are members of the Arakan Youth Conference (AYC), while Ko May Yu Tun is a member of the Arakan National Party (ANP). The three were arrested in October 2018 in different locations in Rakhine State but later granted bail, with police saying they hadn't found enough solid evidence to construct a case against them.

In November, the police arrested the fourth suspect in Yangon on suspicion of gunning down the military-affiliated officer who was a fellow member of the ANP. After a series of interrogations by Sittwe police over the course of two weeks, the suspect was beaten and allegedly forced to confess to the police accusations. The suspect Ko Ye Zaw received medical treatment in Sittwe General Hospital in December following the interrogations.

According to U Tun Aung Kyaw, the investigation officer has submitted evidence to the court which contains clothing worn by the victim, an empty bullet round and a handbag as well as some group photos of the three Arakanese activists. The police handed a list of 30 plaintiff witness names to the court.

"Well, I am pretty sure that all three Arakanese have nothing to do with this murder case. We truly believe that they are innocent and that they are being unfairly treated," said U Tun Aung Kyaw.

The lawyer claimed that Ko May Yu Tun was not even in the capital when military intelligence official was shot down at close range. Ko May Yu Tun was helping the 2018 by-election candidate for the ANP alongside an Arakanese Union lawmaker Daw Khin Saw Wai on the day of the incident.

The other two suspects, Ko Aung Zaw Lin and Ko Khin Thaw were socializing with friends at Sittwe strand on the night in question. U Tun Aung Kyaw claimed that the fourth suspect Ko Ye Zaw was also not in Sittwe, as he had already returned from Sittwe to Yangon on Sept. 19. He said that they have already provided travel itinerary to the authorities as a proof.

"I can't imagine how they are going to examine some group photos of three Arakanese as evidence in the court," said U Tun Aung Kyaw.

An Arakanese activist and Sittwe resident Ko Min Bar Chay who attended the initial court hearing of the four detainees on Monday also said that the process of the authorities is very questionable at this point as they granted bail for three of the suspects and then re-arrested them without further explanation.

Another defense lawyer Daw Aye Nu Sein confirmed that the three Arakanese were re-arrested on Monday and the next court sitting will take place on Wednesday.

The post Four Arakanese Facing Charges for Murder of Army Intelligence appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Why Is China In a Hurry to Revive the Myitsone Dam Projects?

Posted: 15 Jan 2019 04:58 AM PST

A statement from the Chinese government on Sunday has renewed concerns among ethnic Kachin over the stalled Myitsone dam project. In the statement, the Chinese Embassy in Yangon claimed that Kachin political leaders and social organizations had a "positive attitude" toward the dam. It added that "local people of Kachin State do not oppose the Myitsone hydropower project; it is some individuals and social organizations from outside that oppose the project."

Three Kachin political parties and community leader Rev. Hkalam Samson immediately issued a statement of their own to insist that China’s claims were false and misleading.

It is obvious that the people of Myanmar, and the Kachin in particular, have been opposed to the Myitsone dam projects even before it forced thousands of Kachin villagers to relocate.

Myitsone is hardly China’s only planned dam in Myanmar. It also hopes to build dams in Lasa on the Mali River and in Khaunglanghpu, Phizaw, Lakin and Pashe on the Nmai River. A dam on the Nmai in Chiphwi is already finished.

Source: International Rivers

The people of Myanmar are strongly opposed to the seven dams on the Irrawaddy and its tributaries because of the irreparable environmental damage they may cause, the potential for water shortages and unpredictable surges, and the knock-on social and economic damage facing the millions who depend on the waterways.

The sudden flurry of activity over the Myitsone begs the question: Why is China so keen to revive the project?

The reasons are many.

First, China wants to push the project forward in order to help meet the power demands of its ambitious Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). As noted in the embassy's statement, China is planning to establish three “economic cooperation zones" on its borders with Kachin and Shan state as part of the BRI. Moreover, China is expanding road and rail links with the country as part of the China-Myanmar Economic Corridor (CMEC). It is also speeding up construction of an industrial park in Namjim, in northern Kachin. The Myitsone dam would go far in providing them all with a ready supply of electricity.

Second, with bilateral relations on the upswing, China wants to seize the moment. There is a saying: "Strike while the iron is hot." In a recent column, I wrote that State Counselor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi could make a bargaining chip of the steering committee she has just formed to coordinate BRI projects. China, on the other hand, is using its support for Myanmar in the face of mounding international pressure over the Rohingya crisis to try to revive the Myitsone project and push forward with others.

Beijing also promised to strengthen cooperation with the Myanmar military, or Tatmadaw, improve border management and control, and maintain border stability when Vice Senior General Soe Win paid an official visit to China in mid-November. China always protects Myanmar from scrutiny or punishment at the UN Security Council in accordance with its "paukphaw" brotherhood. It appears that China wants to seize this moment to restart the dams, while Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and the Tatmadaw need its help.

Third, China may be trying to draw attention to the Myitsone dam to distract from other investment opportunities it is pursuing. For example, Myanmar Yang Tse Copper, a subsidiary of Beijing-based Wanbao Mining, has reportedly sought permission to carry out ground inspections for a possible copper mine in a 100,000-acre area in Monywa, in Sagaing Region. China is also continuing to pursue the Kyaukphyu Special Economic Zone in Rakhine State despite warnings in Myanmar that it could pose a debt trap for the country. While implementing the CMEC, China may also have to confiscate land from locals and come in for complaints of paying insufficient compensation, as it did when it built the Shwe gas pipeline connecting Rakhine and China’s Yunnan Province.

Fourth, China wants to reduce its dependence on coal for its electricity supply. As the figures below show, China currently gets 64.7 percent of its electricity from coal and only 18.6 percent from hydropower.

Source: China Energy Portal

China is the world’s second largest coal importer after Japan. Its coal imports hit a record high in the summer of 2018. However, China is aware of the importance of reducing its dependence on coal, having faced protests by miners, average citizens and environmental activists both at home and abroad. For example, thousands of coal miners protested in China over unpaid wages in 2016 and thousands of locals have protested against coal mining in the Letpadaung region of Sagaing in recent years.

China will never give up on the Myitsone dam. It is currently building dams on the Namtu and Nam Teng rivers despite local opposition.

China may have yet more reasons for wanting to revive the Myitsone dam project than the ones listed here. Whatever they are, the people of Kachin State should not be made the scapegoats.

Joe Kumbun is the pseudonym of an analyst based in Kachin State.

The post Why Is China In a Hurry to Revive the Myitsone Dam Projects? appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Three Villagers Shot Dead in Fighting Between Gov’t, AA Troops in Rakhine

Posted: 15 Jan 2019 04:39 AM PST

 

YANGON—At least three villagers were reportedly killed in armed clashes between the Myanmar Army and the Arakan Army (AA) near Hpon Nyo Leik village in northern Rakhine's Buthidaung Township on Sunday, Muslim and Rakhine villagers said.

The village is home to nearly 8,000 Rohingya and several dozen Arakanese homes. The village with a mixed population of Rohingya and Arakanese was spared during the military's clearance operations in 2017, which drove more than 700,000 Muslims into neighboring Bangladesh.

Hpon Nyo Leik resident Nrul Islam told The Irrawaddy on Monday afternoon that Muslim villagers found three bodies on Monday morning near the site of Sunday's fighting. He said they were killed by gunfire. One of the victims was a 19-year-old Rohingya boy and the other two are believed to be Arakanese villagers from the Rakhine community.

Villagers wanted to perform funeral services for the victims, but Army (or Tatmadaw) troops claimed the three bodies on Monday afternoon. They later returned the Muslim boy's body. According to Nrul Islam, the two dead Arakanese were clad in plain clothes and had a black backpack each. Neither firearms nor ammunition were found among their belongings.

An Arakanese resident of the same village who asked not to be identified due to fears for his safety confirmed that some civilians had been killed, and that Muslim villagers had found some bodies in the morning.

He said that about 15 Arakanese residents of various villages were detained by Army officers on Sunday, the same day as the fighting between the AA and the Tatmadaw broke out. Thirteen of these villagers were released from Buthidaung-based Border Police Headquarters No. 13 on Tuesday morning. The detainees included seven Arakanese civilians from Pyin Chaung village; a villager from Tha Yet Pyin and an administrator—identified as U Maung Than Hlaing—from the same village; two villagers from Yae Kaung Chaung and one from Oo Yin Thar village. Cases against the villager and administrative official from Tha Yet Pyin are being opened under the Unlawful Association Law's Section 17 (a). Tha Yet Pyin is a neighboring village of Hpon Nyo Leik.

Video footage uploaded by Mayu Rashid on Facebook at 5:30 p.m. on Monday shows the dead body of a Rohingya man. A brief statement accompanying the post in Burmese says that one Rohingya man was shot dead by Army troops.

The video includes a narration in the Rohingya language. The Irrawaddy had the narration translated. It says that at least three Rohingya were believed to be missing following the clash. Both the translated narration and what can be gleaned from the footage suggest that the man killed was a resident of Hpon Nyo Leik village. According to the translator, the narrator adds that Rohingya villagers were asking Rohingya netizens to spread the video clip to show that Rohingya are being caught in the crossfire of two armed groups.

This video posted on Facebook on Monday evening shows the body of a dead Rohingya man from Hpon Nyo Leik village in northern Rakhine's Buthidaung Township, according to the Rohingya-language narration. According to The Irrawaddy's translation, the narrator also claims that at least another three Rohingya were believed to be missing following a clash between Tatmadaw and AA forces near the village.

Nrul Islam elaborated that as this month is paddy-harvesting season, many Rohingya villagers are working as casual labors in the region. But since armed fighting erupted between AA and government troops unexpectedly on Sunday, more than 30 villagers have gone missing. The Irrawaddy was not able to independently verify his claims.

Brigadier-General Zaw Min Tun of the Commander-in-Chief's Office confirmed Sunday's clash to The Irrawaddy on Monday morning, acknowledging that there were fatalities on both sides.

"We've got five AA deaths; at the same time, there are some on our side," he said. He refused to give the exact number.

When The Irrawaddy called him on Monday and Tuesday afternoon to confirm the civilian deaths and arrests, he didn't answer the phone.

The AA's vice chief of staff, Major-General Nyo Tun Aung, denied to The Irrawaddy that anyone from his armed group was killed in the clash, and claimed that five Muslim villagers were reportedly killed by government troops. The Irrawaddy contacted some Muslim and Rakhine villagers from Hpon Nyo Leik and they said at least three were killed.

Early on Monday morning, armed skirmishes occurred in Rathedaung Township's Kyein Pyin village, which is about 6 miles from downtown. A Rathedaung resident said that even in the town, some residents were digging reinforced trenches as shelters from incoming artillery shells, in case the armed conflict reached downtown.

"When I was washing my face in the morning, a number of shells exploded on the outskirts of town. At first I thought it might be thunder," he said.

The recent fighting between the AA and government troops has prompted local people to flee their villages. The conflict area has broadened into five townships, and on Monday the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) said the number of IDPs had risen to 5,000 on Monday.

The post Three Villagers Shot Dead in Fighting Between Gov't, AA Troops in Rakhine appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

KNPP Raises Tatmadaw Troop Movements in Karenni State with Peace Commission

Posted: 15 Jan 2019 02:48 AM PST

CHIANG MAI, Thailand—The Karenni National Progressive Party (KNPP) raised the issue of the Myanmar military's recent deployment of troops in areas under the party's control in Karenni State with the government's Peace Commission (PC) during informal talks in this northern Thai city on Monday.

The KNPP sees the deployments by the Myanmar military (or Tatmadaw) since late 2018 as being of concern not just to itself, but also to the security of the public.

The KNPP has held five rounds of informal talks with the government since last year. The talks are aimed at finding a path for the group to eventually sign the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement (NCA).

KNPP vice chairman Khu Oo Reh headed the party's delegation to the negotiations, which were led by PC secretary U Khin Zaw Oo.

KNPP spokesman Nei Neh Plo, who took part in the negotiations, said the KNPP discussed the situation on the ground, which has seen increased deployments of Tatmadaw troops in Karenni-controlled areas. Delegates also discussed ways of overcoming this obstacle to the KNPP's joining the path to the NCA.

Only when the disputes on the ground are solved and mutual trust improves will the two sides be able to move forward with negotiations, Nei Neh Plo said.

"Many incidents in late 2017 and in 2018 hindered the KNPP from moving forward to [enter] bilateral negotiations on the NCA. For instance, the case of the murders of four Karenni soldiers [in December 2017] and clashes with Tatmadaw troops, after they failed to inform us in advance of their movements in our areas. Thus, negotiations were set back and didn't advance," he said.

He added that recent decisions by NCA signatories had slowed the progress of the KNPP's efforts to join the NCA process. He cited the Karen National Union's temporary suspension of its participation in the formal peace process in October, and the Restoration Council of Shan State's decision to put off its participation in the mechanisms of the Joint Ceasefire Monitoring Committee.

"Thus for the KNPP, signing the NCA seems to getting more distant, even if we wanted to join," Nei Neh Plo said.

The KNPP entered bilateral talks with the government after peace negotiations with the United Nationalities Federal Council's Delegation for Political Negotiation ended in early 2018.

U Zaw Htay, the director general of the Myanmar State Counselor's Office, told reporters on Monday after the informal talks that negotiations are ongoing to settle the problems on the ground in Karenni State, and to get the KNPP on the NCA path. He said the talks were a positive development.

"We still have to negotiate the date [for further talks] and how we move the process forward step by step. Our discussions were constructive and it was a good meeting. We hope the KNPP will sign the NCA soon, and we are moving forward based on that expectation," he said.

The post KNPP Raises Tatmadaw Troop Movements in Karenni State with Peace Commission appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

120 Projects Worth $3B to Showcase at Invest Myanmar Summit 2019

Posted: 15 Jan 2019 01:03 AM PST

YANGON—More than 120 regional and private business projects worth a total of over $3 billion will be showcased at the upcoming Invest Myanmar Summit 2019 which aims to attract major investment from East Asia countries.

The summit is part of the government's effort to counteract a significant decline in foreign direct investment (FDI) seen in Myanmar over the last two fiscal years and it will be held on Jan. 28 and 29 at Myanmar Convention Centre 2 in Naypyitaw.

"With the projects on showcase, local and international investors at the summit will have a very clear picture of the prospects they can look forward to when investing in Myanmar, the industries they can invest in and types of projects open to them in each state and region," said U Zaw Min Win, president of the Union of Myanmar Federation of Chambers of Commerce and Industry (UMFCCI).

Invest Myanmar Summit 2019 is a collaboration between the Myanmar government, region and states governments and the business community and aims to create a platform for businesses to meet. The summit will provide international and local investors with the opportunity to discover the investment potential in the country and potential investors will be supplied with relevant information.

The countries targeted during the summit will be China, Hong Kong, Japan, Korea, Thailand, Singapore, India, Australia, the United States and the United Kingdom.

"I expect the summit will help our investment figures to increase this year. From initial discussions with international investors, Japan and Hong Kong investors are quite interested in investing more here," U Maung Maung Lay, vice president of UMFCCI, told The Irrawaddy.

According to the official summit website, ten states and regions will participate in the event—Karen, Chin, Mon, Rakhine, Shan, Yangon, Sagaing, Mandalay, Irrawaddy and Tanintharyi. Industries to be targeted will be the manufacturing, garment, electricity and energy, tourism, education, food processing and fisheries, heath care, infrastructure and property.

During the summit, a centralized database of key projects called Project Bank will be launched. The database is expected to enable effective implementation of the Myanmar Sustainable Development Programme (MSDP) was drawn up with an ambition to align the country's numerous policies and institutions in order to achieve inclusive and transformational economic growth.

According to the event press release, one of the projects with good prospects is the development of Myotha Industrial Park City (MIPC) in Mandalay Region which currently holds the highest value in the Project Data Bank which is expected to create up to 33,700 jobs and target infrastructure, labor intensive-industries like food and wood processing, capital-intensive industries like pharmaceutical and renewable energy production, consumer services and producer services like banking and finance.

The key speakers at the summit will include State Counselor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, newly-appointed Union Minister of Investment and Foreign Economic Relations U Thaung Tun, Deputy Minister of Planning and Finance U Set Aung and a member of the National Economic Coordination Committee (NECC) U Min Ye Paing Hein.

Myanmar experienced a significant decline in FDI, from $9.5 billion in the 2015-2016 fiscal year to $6.6 billion in 2016-2017, after the 2017 Rohingya crisis in Rakhine State which tarnished the country's image and caused caution among western investors.

In October 2018, the Myanmar Investment commission (MIC) launched the Myanmar Investment Promotion Plan (MIPP), a major investment plan that aims to attract more than $200 billion in investment from responsible and quality businesses over the next 20 years.

According to U Aung Naing Oo, director general of the Directorate of Investment and Company Administration (DICA), the government's first priority in 2019 is to focus on the implementation of the MIPP.

Through the MIPP, the government aims for Myanmar to become a middle-income country by 2030 and will make economic reforms to ensure fair and transparent investment systems and institutional development for investment promotion. They intend to oversee infrastructure development, supportive business-associated systems, competitive industrial links and a higher quality of human resources.

The post 120 Projects Worth $3B to Showcase at Invest Myanmar Summit 2019 appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

China Court Sentences Canadian to Death as Diplomatic Row Deepens

Posted: 14 Jan 2019 08:52 PM PST

BEIJING/OTTAWA — A Chinese court on Monday sentenced a Canadian man to be executed for drug smuggling, prompting Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to accuse China of using the death penalty arbitrarily.

The ruling, and Trudeau’s reaction, could aggravate already sour relations between Beijing and Ottawa following the arrest of a Chinese executive in Canada and China’s subsequent detention of two Canadians.

The Dalian Intermediate People’s Court in China’s Liaoning Province re-tried Robert Lloyd Schellenberg, who had appealed his original 15-year prison sentence, and decided on execution, the court said in a statement.

Schellenberg was told in court he had the right to appeal to Liaoning High Court within 10 days upon receiving the ruling, the intermediate court said in a second statement.

“It is of extreme concern to us as a government, as it should be to all our international friends and allies, that China has chosen to begin to arbitrarily apply [the] death penalty … as in this case,” Trudeau told reporters in Ottawa.

Late on Monday, Canada’s Foreign Ministry updated its travel advisory for China to warn citizens about “the risk of arbitrary enforcement of local laws.”

It added: “We continue to advise all Canadians travelling to China to exercise a high degree of caution.”

Schellenberg’s aunt, Lauri Nelson-Jones, said the family’s worst fears had been confirmed.

“Our thoughts are with Robert at this time. It is rather unimaginable what he must be feeling and thinking,” she said in a statement to Reuters. “It is a horrific, unfortunate, heartbreaking situation.”

In a second statement sent hours later, she said “the Schellenberg family requests that all Canadians stand with us and pray for the safe return of our loved one.”

China-Canada ties turned icy in early December after Meng Wanzhou, chief financial officer of Chinese telecommunications giant Huawei Technologies Co Ltd, was arrested in Vancouver on a U.S. extradition warrant.

China warned of unspecified consequences unless Meng was released, and detained Michael Kovrig, a Canadian diplomat on unpaid leave from the embassy in Beijing, and Michael Spavor, a Canadian consultant, on suspicion of endangering state security.

Beijing has not drawn a direct link between the detentions and the arrest of Meng, wanted by U.S. authorities for allegedly misleading multinational banks about Iran-linked transactions. Western diplomats say the cases are a tit-for-tat reprisal.

Lu Shaye, China’s ambassador to Canada, suggested in a newspaper article last week the arrest of Kovrig and Spavor was “China’s self-defense,” but gave no details.

Earlier on Monday, Beijing dismissed Trudeau’s statement that Kovrig enjoyed some form of diplomatic immunity.

A foreign ministry spokeswoman said Trudeau should “earnestly study” the Vienna Convention governing diplomatic ties so as to “not become a laughing stock.”

Trudeau said Ottawa “will continue to engage strongly” with Beijing over Kovrig’s status and what he called China’s arbitrary use of justice.

222 kg of methamphetamine

Rights groups condemned the Schellenberg sentence while Guy St-Jacques, who was Canada’s ambassador in Beijing when Kovrig worked there, expressed concern at how quickly the courts had acted.

“The Canadian government will make representations in Beijing, but based on past experience I am not sure whether this will work,” he told the CBC. “We are in a very difficult place.”

William Nee of Amnesty International noted drug-related offences did not meet the threshold of the “most serious crimes” to which the death penalty must be restricted under international law.

Drug smuggling is routinely punished severely in China. Beijing has previously executed foreign nationals convicted of drug-related crimes. A Briton was executed in 2009.

The court said Schellenberg had conspired with others in an attempt to smuggle 222 kg of methamphetamine from China to Australia in 2014.

Chinese state television said in an earlier report that Schellenberg argued he was a tourist visiting China and was framed by criminals.

A lawyer for Schellenberg, Zhang Dongshuo, told Reuters his client would probably appeal against the death sentence.

Beijing considers the number of people executed in China to be a state secret. International human rights organizations estimate the annual figure at around 2,000.

The post China Court Sentences Canadian to Death as Diplomatic Row Deepens appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Malaysia Seizes Huge Crystal Meth Haul in Two Raids

Posted: 14 Jan 2019 08:17 PM PST

KUALA LUMPUR — Malaysian police seized nearly 600 kg of drugs they believe was mostly crystal methamphetamine in a crackdown on two trafficking syndicates over the weekend, they said on Monday.

The seizures came just months after Malaysia reported a record bust of nearly 1.2 tons of crystal meth, or shabu as it is locally known, that was disguised as tea in a shipment from Myanmar.

Malaysian police chief Mohamad Fuzi Harun said the bulk of the drugs seized on Saturday was found in a container truck in the northern state of Perak.

“We found 569.5 kg of what we believe is shabu in the container, valued at 28.47 million ringgit ($6.94 million),” Fuzi told reporters.

Police believe the container was bound for Port Klang, where the shipment was to be split between local distribution and export. Fuzi said they were investigating the source and destination country for export.

Three men aged between 39 and 49 were detained at three locations in Perak in connection with the seizure and have been remanded until Jan. 19 to aid investigations.

The post Malaysia Seizes Huge Crystal Meth Haul in Two Raids appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

UN Calls for ‘Rapid and Unimpeded’ Aid Access to Myanmar’s Rakhine

Posted: 14 Jan 2019 08:14 PM PST

YANGON—The United Nations called on the Myanmar government on Monday to allow "rapid and unimpeded" humanitarian access to Rakhine State, where fighting between government troops and autonomy-seeking rebels has displaced thousands of people.

The Rakhine State government issued a notice last week blocking non-governmental organizations and UN agencies from travelling to rural areas in five townships in the northern and central parts of the state affected by the conflict.

The International Committee of the Red Cross and UN World Food Programme were exempted from the ban, it said.

Myanmar’s president urged the military to “crush” the rebels of the Arakan Army during a rare meeting with the commander-in-chief last week. The president, U Win Myint, is a loyalist of the de facto government leader, Nobel laureate Aung San Suu Kyi.

Fighting has forced about 5,000 people to flee from their homes and take shelter in monasteries and communal areas across the region since early January, according to the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs.

“We are seriously concerned about new restrictions on humanitarian access which leave thousands of women, children and men in affected areas of Rakhine without access to adequate assistance and protection," said Pierre Peron, a spokesman for UN office.

"We hope the government responds positively to our call for rapid and unimpeded humanitarian access, and to ensure the protection of civilians in accordance with international humanitarian and human rights law," he said in an email.

The Rakhine State municipal affairs minister, whose name is also U Win Myint, told Reuters the restrictions on humanitarian access were put in place for "security reasons."

"We don't know how long it will last," he said, "Access will be granted again if there is no security concern."

Rakhine state has been roiled by successive rounds of violence in recent years.

In 2017, the region was the site of an extensive military crackdown, following attacks by Rohingya Muslim insurgents, that prompted about 730,000 Rohingya to flee westwards into neighboring Bangladesh.

The Arakan Army, the group behind the recent fighting, is demanding greater autonomy from the central government for Rakhine State, where the mostly Buddhist ethnic Rakhine people form the majority of the population.

Arakan Army fighters killed 13 policemen and wounded nine in attacks on four police posts in early January, state media reported.

An Arakan Army spokesman outside Myanmar told Reuters last week the group attacked the security forces in response to a broad military offensive in the north of Rakhine State that also targeted civilians.

Myanmar governments have battled various autonomy-seeking ethnic minority insurgent groups since shortly after independence from Britain in 1948, though some have struck ceasefire agreements.

The post UN Calls for ‘Rapid and Unimpeded’ Aid Access to Myanmar’s Rakhine appeared first on The Irrawaddy.