Monday, June 18, 2018

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Court to Decide on July 2 Whether to Charge Reuters Reporters

Posted: 18 Jun 2018 09:10 AM PDT

YANGON – After six months of preliminary hearings, a Yangon court will decide next month whether two Reuters journalists arrested while covering the Rakhine conflict will be charged with violating the Official Secrets Act.

Yangon's Northern District Court has heard from the plaintiff and 22 witnesses in the case against Ko Wa Lone and Ko Kyaw Soe Oo.

On July 2, lawyers for both sides will make their arguments to the court regarding whether it should accept or reject charges against the journalists, judge U Ye Lwin said on Monday.

The last plaintiff witness, Police Major Tin Win Maung of the Criminal Investigation Department (CID), testified Monday in the case's 27th hearing since January 2018.

Monday's cross-examination of the witness focused on the CID officer's actions during the questioning of the journalists at the time of their arrests in December.

Maj. Tin Win Maung said he was not present when the reporters were questioned at the Aung Thabyay military camp in late December, which is in contrast to the journalists' accounts, defense lawyer U Than Zaw Aung said.

Ko Wa Lone said his interrogators at the Aung Thabyay interrogation center included officials from the Bureau of Special Investigation, the military, the police special branch and the CID.

Defense lawyers pointed to numerous inconsistencies between the testimony provided by nearly two dozen witnesses and the accounts offered by the accused.

Defense lawyer U Khin Maung Zaw told The Irrawaddy he did not know whether the court would accept the charge, adding, "However, according to the information from our clients and the legal reviews, some of the testimony is hard to accept."

The advocate said, "We will try to state specifically which testimony should not be accepted when we make our arguments before the court."

In total, 22 out of an initial 25 witnesses testified; three were removed from the list of witnesses, including Police Sergeant Khin Maung Lin, who was fired by the police and whose whereabouts have been unknown since May.

U Than Zaw Aung said the court removed the sergeant from the witness list as he is still at large. He was initially believed to be hiding somewhere in Myeik, in southern Myanmar's Tannithary Region, but this turned out not to be the case.

The two Reuters reporters were arrested on Dec. 12 and accused of breaching the colonial-era Official Secrets Act, which carries a maximum penalty of 14 years in prison.

At the time of their arrest, the reporters were working on an investigation into the killing of 10 Rohingya Muslim men and boys in Indin village in Maungdaw, Rakhine State. In April, the Myanmar military said seven soldiers had been sentenced to "10 years in prison with hard labor in a remote area" for participating in the massacre.

The killings took place during the military's crackdown following militant attacks on security outposts. The United Nations says the military crackdown sent nearly 700,000 people fleeing to Bangladesh.

During the six months of preliminary hearings, Police Captain Moe Yan Naing was fired for testifying that the two reporters had been framed. The officer was sentenced to one year in prison for violating the Police Disciplinary Act.

Ko Wa Lone on Monday told reporters covering the trial that, "We are very sorry to hear of Daw Aung San Suu Kyi's comments about us." He was referring to an interview with Japanese news outlet NHK World last week in which the State Counselor said the two Reuters reporters "were not arrested for covering the Rakhine Issues," but "because they broke the Official Secret Act."

Ko Wa Lone added, "We were not able to do our work due to being detained for six months. We totally believe justice will soon be served in our case."

The other detained journalist, Ko Kyaw Soe Oo, expressed doubt as to whether the State Counselor had been given correct information.

The post Court to Decide on July 2 Whether to Charge Reuters Reporters appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Quality Beefsteak, at Street-Food Prices

Posted: 18 Jun 2018 08:07 AM PDT

YANGON — Here's some good news for Yangon's foodies: Now you can get a tasty beefsteak at very reasonable prices — and you can experience this fine dining menu in a laid-back, streetside environment.

Steak on the Street opened as a weekend street-food stall near Yangon International School in February. Eight weeks later, it has become a "bomb" among meat lovers, known for its beefsteak and pork neck.

"Actually, we all have [other] professional jobs; the idea grew out of our private gatherings and family house parties, because one of our friends is really good at cooking beefsteak. He would always bring beef to the gatherings," said Ko Bo Gyi, one of the founders of Steak on the Street.

The open-air eatery Steak on the Street is located on Waizayanar Road, Yangon. (Photo: Aung Kyaw Htet/ The Irrawaddy)

One day, this group of friends — five in all — discussed ways of setting up their own business that wouldn't get in the way of their existing full-time jobs. That was when the weekend beefsteak stall popped up.

"We choose to open on the weekends because we all have full-time jobs during the week. And, as a fun business, initially we didn't take this very seriously at all," he said.

"After eight weeks, however, things got more serious." That's because the stand quickly developed a reputation on social media. In the beginning, the partners split up all the duties and did all the work themselves. Later, they decided they needed to hire staff.

"Eight weeks means 16 days for our shop, and [as it became more popular] we had to adjust our timetables, such as for marinating our meat, and we needed to buy more meat," Ko Bo Gyi said.

The shop's popular beefsteak dish. (Photo: Aung Kyaw Htet/ The Irrawaddy)

Then, the owners decided to expand their hours, and move to a larger location beside South Okkala's City Mart. The new location, which opened in May, is open from 3pm to 10pm.

The business concept is a good quality steak served in a simple location at street-food prices. They have tried to maintain this concept after upgrading their stall to a proper shop, Ko Bo Gyi said.

"As you see, the shop is not too big and does not have air-conditioning; it's open-air. We decorated the shop with a lot of street signs, graffiti and so on," he said.

Even though the shop is not really a stall set up on the sidewalk, it is close to the street and simply decorated. The feeling is relaxed and the seating consists of wooden low tables and chairs. The shop can serve about 50 people in total, and fills many take-away orders.

The shop is busy with its own customers and many take-away orders. (Photo: Aung Kyaw Htet/ The Irrawaddy)

The shop's famous beef tenderloin steak is excellent; the beef is local but very tender. The sauce spread on the meat wasn't great, but not bad. Best of all, it only cost 6,000 kyats.

Another famous dish, pork collar, costs 4,500 kyats. This one is fine, if not as special as the steak. It's still worth it for its cheap price and good taste.

We also tried their chicken sausage (4,000 kyats), which mixes spicy and normal flavors in one dish. I thought this was so-so; maybe I'm just not a chicken lover. All the grilled items are served up with mashed potato and carrots.

The shop also has other choices on the menu, such as grilled prawn and papaya salad.

The entrance and grill at Steak on the Street(Photo: Aung Kyaw Htet/ The Irrawaddy)

I went there with a friend and the total bill was only 14,500 kyats, and we left with a full stomach.

The staff are part-time workers and most of them are students, but they were helpful and polite. The shop also pays attention to hygiene, with all of the grill operators and prep staff using masks, hats and gloves. The food was served in single-use plastic boxes.

It's easy to find the shop; it's beside South Okkala's City Mart as I mentioned before. They also accept phone orders and you can check this on their Facebook page, "STEAK on the Street".

The post Quality Beefsteak, at Street-Food Prices appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Flooding Causes Swathe of Devastation Across the Country

Posted: 18 Jun 2018 07:35 AM PDT

Mon—Flooding triggered by heavy rainfall has caused widespread damage in Chin, Magway, Rakhine, and in particular Mon State, where hundreds of local people were displaced by rising waters, according to local sources.

Incessant downpours have been recorded in different parts of Myanmar for a week. Some fishermen were reported to have disappeared in Rakhine, while landslides occurred in Chin State, where several bridges were also damaged. Over 800 people in Pwint Phyu town in Magway Division were forced to flee their homes because of the flooding.

Most of the people affected by the flooding lived near rivers or in coastal regions.

Heavy rainfall the whole night on Saturday and into Sunday triggered flooding in five townships in Mon state — Moulmein, Mudon, Thanbyuzayat, Ye, and Paung – causing people to seek refuge at religious halls and Buddhist monasteries. The first four townships suffered extensive flood damage, according to U Aung Naing Oo, the vice house speaker of the Mon State Parliament.

Local volunteer rescue teams and civil servants had worked together to rescue people in Moulmein, he said.

In Mon State, a bridge collapsed, trees were blown over, and landslides hit some areas. Local public transportation was halted yesterday including travel by car and train, although cars were able to travel again today after the rain stopped and the water subsided.

Two local women were reportedly killed in related events, according to a local source. A snake bit one woman in Moulmein during the flood, while another fell into a strong river current and drowned as she tried to cross the waterway.

A total of more than 2,000 people have been displaced in Moulmein, Ye, and Thanbyuzayat townships, according to the Than Lwin Times.

The Global New Light of Myanmar reported that U Win Myat Aye, the union minister for social welfare, relief and resettlement, visited Mon State yesterday.

U Win Myat Aye and U Aye Zan, the chief minister of Mon State, met some local IDPs in Mottama, in Moulmein, to donate money while also distributing food to people staying in temporary camps at religious halls.

An estimated 1,000 people have been displaced in Moulmein, the Than Lwin Times reported yesterday, while another 800 in Ye were forced to seek refuge from the floodwaters.

An Irrawaddy reporter visited flood-hit areas in Panga village, Thanbyuzayat, where 500 people had fled their homes, although some had returned today, according to relief workers.

As of press time, 350 people were staying in a monastery compound in Panga village where some community leaders were taking care of them.

One of the main economic activities in Panga is the production of salt, which is then distributed to other parts of Myanmar. According to local people, an estimated 50 million kyat of salt stocks were damaged by the flooding.

Nai Shein, an owner of a salt company, said that he lost only about 5 million kyat of salt. "I was lucky as I moved out a lot of my salt bags," he said.

Most of the flood victims were employees of the salt companies.

The rain stopped today, and people may able to go back home soon, depending on the weather, according to relief team members. The relief workers appealed for donations and cooked food for the flood victims.

"We do not have enough money. But, some people donated 400,000 kyat to us this morning," said Nai Chit Sein, the head of a relief team.

The salt company employees are mostly migrant workers who had travelled to Mon State for work. As such, they did not have their own homes to go to, and they did not want to go back to their homes in Pegu and Yangon as they expect the rain will stop soon.

U Aye Zan, the chief minister of Mon State, was due to visit a shelter at 2 pm, according to Nai Chit Sein.

Nai Lawi Chan, another member of the relief team from Panga village said, "We will help them the best we can. We cannot discriminate against them as they are Burmese. We need to help them as they are experiencing hardships," he said.

Some state workers were attempting to restore rail services yesterday after parts of the rail network were damaged by the flooding.

U Zaw Lin, a railway employee, said trains have not been able to run for two days.

There were also another two places where he and other state workers needed to repair the tracks, he said, adding that the trains may able to resume services after that.

The post Flooding Causes Swathe of Devastation Across the Country appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Court Revises Charges in U Ko Ni Assassination Case

Posted: 18 Jun 2018 05:40 AM PDT

YANGON — The Yangon Regional High Court on Monday revised the charges against several of the accused in last year's assassination of U Ko Ni, a constitutional lawyer and legal adviser to the ruling National League for Democracy.

"This is not a result of outside speculation. I make this ruling based on [my own] judgment," Yangon high court judge U Aung Naing said before announcing his decision.

The judge dropped charges relating to the importing/exporting and possession of firearms against accused conspirator Aung Win Zaw. He had been charged under Sections 19 (d) and 19 (f) of the 1878 Arms Act.

He will now face charges of conspiracy to commit murder under Section 302.(1) (b) of the Penal Code along with Kyi Lin, who fatally shot U Ko Ni, and taxi driver U Ne Win.

Additionally, the charge against fellow suspect Zeya Phyo was changed from conspiracy to commit murder to aiding and abetting an offender (from Section 302. (1) (b)/34 to 302. (1) (b)/109).

"Zeya Phyo will have to defend the charge of assisting in the murder, and not for conspiring to commit murder. The penalties for these two charges are much the same," said prosecuting lawyer U Khin Maung Htay.

Daw Pa Pa Win, a lawyer acting for Ko Zeya Phyo, said she would appeal to the Union Supreme Court to drop the charge against her client.

Gunman Kyi Lin is still faced with a charge of murder and a firearms charge.

Another accused conspirator, Aung Win Tun, is charged under the Penal Code's Article 212 with harboring an offender. The court granted him bail in March after he deposited 50 million kyats (about US$37,300) as a surety for his release from custody.

The post Court Revises Charges in U Ko Ni Assassination Case appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Red Cross to Pay For $300K Facelift of Insein Prison Visitors Area

Posted: 18 Jun 2018 05:33 AM PDT

YANGON — The visitors area at Yangon’s notorious Insein Prison will get a nearly $300,000 facelift aimed at reducing recidivism courtesy of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), the charity announced Monday.

"The upgraded facilities will allow detainees and their family members to maintain better relationships and reduce the strain of separation," the ICRC said in a statement.

The ICRC said the upgrades would include improved lighting, ventilation and privacy, new bathrooms, a coffee shop and a playground for children.

"The funding and design are fully supported by the ICRC," said U Myo Oo, a deputy director of the Insein Central Prison Department.

The partners expect the work to be finished early next year, at an estimated cost of 400 million kyats ($295,000).

The prison, the largest in the country, currently houses some 12,000 inmates.

"The space will be twice as big as it is now, so families will have privacy. We will install glass walls between the prisoners and visitors. They can communicate through a phone line," U Myo Oo said.

The current facilities offer little privacy and separate inmates from visitors with mesh wiring.

The deputy director said he could not yet describe the upgrades in detail but insisted that the new facilities would comply with international standards. He said the prison would also inform inmates’ families of rule changes during the construction period and post them outside.

An Insein Prison inmate receives visitors at the current visitors area. (above). A rendering of the planned upgrades to the visitors area (below). / ICRC / Facebook

According to renderings of the upgrades provided by the ICRC, the new facilities will provide seating for both inmates and visitors, separate them with a combination of glass and metal bars, and include a separate waiting area for visitors.

Insein Prison data indicates that it receives about 600 visitors a day on weekdays and 2,000 on weekends, and that inmates average two visitors per visit.

The prison, which dates back to the 19th century, acquired a reputation for torturing political prisoners during the decades of military dictatorship that finally started to fade in 2011. Last year, the Home Affairs Ministry reported that the corrections department had relaxed its rules on family visits and started improving its education programs.

Also last year, however, the National Human Rights Commission reported that overcrowding was a problem at Insein Prison and recommended new dormitories.

"We still don't have a plan for upgrades inside the prison cells," U Myo Oo said.

In 2011 the ICRC helped install a water purification system in the prison to improve inmates’ health and CCTV cameras to improve security.

After a five-year gap, the ICRC resumed visits to the prison in 2013. It helps inmates stay in touch with their families, organizes prison visits, and makes recommendations to authorities on ways to improve inmates’ welfare.

The post Red Cross to Pay For $300K Facelift of Insein Prison Visitors Area appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Experts Raise Alarm Over Flood-Prone Location of ‘New Yangon City’ Project

Posted: 18 Jun 2018 05:20 AM PDT

YANGON — Urban planners have questioned the suitability of the proposed site of a massive project the Yangon government has vowed to develop on the western bank of the Yangon River, warning that the low-lying area is prone to flooding as it has a maximum elevation of just 5 meters above sea level.

The government in March launched the New Yangon Development Company (NYDC) with capital of US$7.5 million from development funds allotted by the Union government to regional and state administrations. The company was set up to oversee the resurrection of the controversial new city project, which was marred by murky dealings under the previous government. The project was and hastily approved less than a week before U Thein Sein's administration stepped down on March 30, 2016.

"This development will be known as the New Yangon City and upon its ultimate completion will cover an area twice the size of Singapore," according to a recent company press release.

The NYDC, whose chairman and CEO is property mogul Serge Pun of Yoma Strategic Holdings, plans to develop 20,000 acres of land as the first phase of the project. This will include five village townships, two bridges, power plants, water and wastewater treatment plants and a 10-square-kilometer industrial estate generating 2 million jobs. The company says the cost of initial infrastructure work in the first phase is expected to exceed US$1.5 billion.

But experts with more than 20 years of experience in town planning with the Ministry of Construction told The Irrawaddy that the area slated for the first phase of New Yangon City had never been town planners' preferred location.  They said even the previous military government ignored the area when they embarked on a series of city expansion projects on the outskirts of Yangon in the early 1990s.

The main reason? The low-lying topography of the area.

Back in the late 1980s and early '90s, the Ministry of Construction's Department of Human Settlement and Housing Development identified new areas of potential expansion for the Yangon City and Regional Development Planning Project, which was backed by the United Nations Development Program. The plan proposed new developments in the city's east and west in Dagon Myothit, Hlaing Thaya and Shwe Pyi Tha. These areas were developed by the military regime but not fully urbanized.

The site of New Yangon City, mostly farmland, was never even on the list.

"We hadn't put the area [across the Yangon River] under consideration as it is very low," said U Than Moe, one of the strategic planners for the project, explaining that the area's elevation is about 20 feet lower than neighboring Hlaing Thaya, which is around 30 feet above mean sea level.

As a town planner working for the Department of Human Settlement and Housing Development at the time, U Aung Myint studied aerial photos of the area west of the Yangon River and did a site survey in the area that is now the proposed location of phase one of New Yangon City.

"We had to exclude it [from the proposed expansion plan] as it has an elevation of around 5 meters at the highest point. The other expansion areas are at around 30-40 feet. Even there, some areas lower than that height sometimes flood," the retired urban planner explained.

More than two decades later, their findings are still relevant. The Strategic Urban Development Plan of Greater Yangon report prepared by the Japan International Cooperation Agency in 2016 recommends serious consideration be given to flooding when it comes to developing low-lying areas.

Quoting a 2016 flood-management study by the Asian Development Bank, the report warns that areas along the west bank of the Yangon River (including the slated site for New Yangon City) are vulnerable to cyclonic surges of 2 to 5 meters — a height similar to the tidal wave caused by Cyclone Nargis in 2008.

"So, land development costs should be taken into consideration for any development in the area," according to the report.

'Extremely Costly'

Both U Than Moe and U Aung Myint said that as town planners they are not against the idea of expanding the city.

They said, however, that the proposed location of the new city would best be reserved for future use, as it will require a huge amount of investment just to develop the land, given the low-lying nature of the area.

U Aung Myint prepared a conceptual plan for a new city in the same area for a private company under the previous administration a few years ago. The senior town planner said the lowest point in the area is just over 7 feet above sea level, meaning that a huge amount of earth would inevitably be required to fill the site for any development there, something he said would be "extremely costly."

"You would need landfills as high as 30 feet if you want to build a new city there," he said.

He included this recommendation in the plan for the project, prompting one minister in the then Yangon government to ask "Are you serious?" as the proposed landfill was as high as a three-story building.

"Where would you get the soil needed to fill 20,000 acres? Even if it were available, there would be transportation costs. Then you would have to wait for several years to allow the landfill to fully subside [and become hard enough to build on]," U Aung Myint said.

Map of the key elements of the NYDC project. (Photo: NYDC)

Another urban planner, Dr. Kyaw Latt, agreed that the new city area had potential for use in the future, but said now was not the right time, given the costly bridges that would be needed to connect the site to Yangon. Yangon Chief Minister U Phyo Min Thein and NYDC have announced that two bridges will be built as part of the project. A key project map posted on NYDC's website shows one of the proposed bridges spanning the Yangon River from Kyimyindaing Township. The map does not show the second bridge.

The retired planner from the Department of Human Settlement and Housing Development explained that the bridge would need to be high enough for international cargo ships making port calls at terminals and wharfs \on the eastern bank of the river, right across from project area, to pass under.

"If you build that high, the bridge's approaching lanes on the Yangon side would probably be landed in Sanchaung Township. All hell would break loose, as it is already a very congested area," he said, referring to the fact that the township is among the most overpopulated areas in Yangon with a density of more than 1,000 people per hectare. That is far higher even than Dhaka, one of the most densely populated cities in the world with an average of 555 people per hectare.

"The only possible solution, according to transportation planning experts, is an underpass tunnel. But that would cost around US$1.5 billion. You shouldn't spend that much when the country's economy is not in good shape," he added.

Smart City

Chief Minister U Pyo Min Thein does not seem persuaded by the experts' warnings and concerns, however.

Yangon Chief Minister U Phyo Min Thein (third from left) and the NYDC board of directors attend the company's launch in March. (Photo: The Irrawaddy)

During the NYDC launch ceremony, he told the audience that the less developed western bank of the Yangon River had to be transformed.

"We will make it happen. We want to see Yangon's old town become a green business hub with heritage buildings, while the new one across the river will be a smart city with development," he said.

The chief minister said the cost of investment in the project would not be borne solely by the government, but would be supported by public-private partnerships, adding that he "hoped to attract investment."

Regarding the topography of the project site, CEO Serge Pun said the company had kick-started a flood-risk assessment (FRA) for the New Yangon City project with Royal HaskoningDHV, a Dutch company that advises on the entire flood-risk management cycle, from concept to feasibility to impact assessment.

"Since late April, Royal HaskoningDHV has started site visits and data collection, and the company will submit a final report in October 2018," he writes in a weekly blog entry on the NYDC website.

The FRA's results and recommendations will be incorporated into the town planning, building design, and policy guidance of NYDC's New Yangon City project, he said.

The post Experts Raise Alarm Over Flood-Prone Location of 'New Yangon City' Project appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Bangladesh Rights Body Readies Sexual Violence Cases Against Myanmar for ICC

Posted: 18 Jun 2018 05:00 AM PDT

DHAKA — Bangladesh’s National Human Rights Commission has urged the country’s Foreign Affairs and Law ministries to assist the International Criminal Court (ICC) in prosecuting Myanmar over its alleged crimes against the Rohingya in Rakhine State last year and identified 53 alleged victims of sexual violence.

In separate letters to each ministry on June 10, commission Chairman Kazi Reazul Hoque said the rights body firmly believed that — apart from ongoing bilateral initiatives between Bangladesh and Myanmar to reach a permanent solution to the Rohingya crisis — it was “very important to approach the ICC."

The letters said the commission had conducted investigations separate from the government’s initiatives to resolve the crisis.

"A group of researchers trained by international experts secretly documented the testimonies of 53 women who experienced sexual violence in Myanmar," the letters said, adding that the commission was willing to share its evidence if and when a case against Myanmar at the ICC begins.

The letters followed the ICC’s request that Bangladesh opine on whether Myanmar could be prosecuted at the court over its alleged crimes last year in Rakhine State, where a military crackdown has driven some 700,000 mostly Rohingya to Bangladesh with reports of arson, rape and murder in what the UN has called a textbook example of ethnic cleansing.

Though Bangladesh recognizes the ICC, which is based in The Hague, Myanmar does not.

Dhaka-based daily the New Age reported that Bangladesh submitted its comments to the ICC on June 11 to help the court decide whether it has jurisdiction to investigate Myanmar for forced deportation across an international border. It reported that Bangladesh tacitly stressed the need to hold the perpetrators accountable.

The court was scheduled to hold a closed-door hearing on the matter on June 13, diplomats told the New Age, as ICC Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda was seeking an expedited decision both on its jurisdiction and for permission to launch a preliminary examination.

Bangladesh and Myanmar signed a repatriation deal in late November for the voluntary return of “forcibly displaced Myanmar nationals” sheltering in Bangladesh since October 2016, when hundreds of thousands of Rohingya fled Rakhine State during another outbreak of violence at the time.

At a public seminar in Dhaka on June 4, former ICC Prosecutor Kate Vigneswaran stressed the need to maintain international standards while collecting and recording evidence of crimes against humanity against Rohingya and to identify the individuals involved in Rakhine State, according to the New Age.

In a June 4 activity report, Doctors Without Borders said it treated 377 survivors of sexual and gender-based violence between Aug. 27 and April 30 involving victims ranging from 9 to 50 years of age. But it said the actual number of victims of such attacks was likely higher.

"Sexual violence is often underreported due to the shame and stigma associated with sexual assault, limited knowledge about medical and psychological support available, and the fact that access to health care in Myanmar was restricted heavily," the report said.

The aid group said it was also stepping up its mother-and-child and reproductive health care services in the refugee camps in Bangladesh, where many births take place at home in unsafe and unhygienic conditions. But it said many women and girls were seeking medical care for pregnancies resulting from rape, which could lead to unsafe abortions and death without support.

Doctors Without Borders said some women carrying babies from rape feared returning to their communities and were being sent to shelters run by other organizations, though space was very limited.

"We do know that there are a number of women/girls of child-bearing age within the settlements of Cox's Bazar District. We expect deliveries to continue but it is not possible for [us] to predict or speculate about the number of expected deliveries at any one time" the report said.

Refugees Protest for Safe Repatriation

On Saturday, on the Muslim holiday of Eid ul-Fitr, several hundred Rohingya residing of the Cox's Bazar camps held peaceful protests to reiterate their conditions for returning to Myanmar and to insist they be included in the negotiations.

The Arakan Rohingya Society for Peace and Human Rights said it organized protests in 24 locations across the camps.

The protesters held up banners and posters in English that read "Include Rohingya in Agreements About Rohingya," "Dignified Repatriation Must Include Full Citizenship Rights as Rohingya Ethnic Group" and "UNHCR Please Talk to Us About the MoU."

The UN refugee agency signed a memorandum of understanding with Myanmar earlier this month offering its assistance with the repatriation. It said the deal creates a "framework of cooperation" to achieve the "voluntary, safe, dignified and sustainable" repatriation of Rohingya refugees, but few details have been made public.

Video footage of the protests shared with The Irrawaddy by participants shows them wearing white plastic bags while marching through the camps and chanting “Yes Dignity, Dignity, Dignity,” 'Yes Security, Security, Security” and “Yes Rohingya Citizenship.”

"We wear white bags because white means that we want peace, security and safety," said Mohamed Eleyas, one of the organizers.

Many refugees say they fear returning to Myanmar — which refuses to recognize the Rohingya as an ethnic group or grant citizenship to those who identify as such — without international monitors on the ground.

Rights activist Nur Khan Liton said it was important to include Rohingya representatives in bilateral and multilateral deals on their repatriation because they were the victims.

"If it is not done, it will create many complexities in the future," he told The Irrawaddy.

A government official, speaking on condition of anonymity because he was not authorized to speak with the press, said security and intelligence agencies suspect others were involved behind the scenes in organizing the protests to coincide with the religious holiday and were searching for them.

A rights activist, also speaking on condition of anonymity, said he received phone calls from some of those agencies asking after the organizers.

The post Bangladesh Rights Body Readies Sexual Violence Cases Against Myanmar for ICC appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Uncertainty Surrounds 8888 Party Name

Posted: 18 Jun 2018 02:56 AM PDT

YANGON — U Ko Ko Gyi, chairman of the organizing committee for the formation of the Four Eights People's Party, said that he hoped the Union Election Commission (UEC) would give him a fair answer regarding the party's name following surrounding controversy.

After the UEC announced on May 5 the proposed registration of the Four Eights People's Party, more than 200 people filed objections regarding the party's name.

The commission then ordered the party organizers to change the name, logo and party flag.

"I asked if the commission would reconsider its order if tens of thousands of people support the party name, since it said it rejected the name because of the objection of some 200 people," U Ko Ko Gyi told the press on Friday about his meeting with UEC officials the previous day.

"But they said that they would not reconsider because it was a decision made by a plenary meeting of the commission," he added.

Early last year, U Ko Ko Gyi and his colleagues—who were among the leading members of the student-led, pro-democracy 8888 Uprising in August 1988—started laying the groundwork for setting up the Four Eights Party.

When the party founders tried to register the organization with the election commission in December, they drew criticism from those who see the designation 8888 as a symbol of the struggle for democracy, and as such, as the property of the entire country. These critics say 8888 should not be available for use by a particular party.

The organizers were accused of trying to appropriate the imagery and symbols of the historic movement.

Then, party organizers changed the name to the Four Eights People's Party, and the UEC gave the green light for the party's registration under the proposed name in April. But again, the name drew criticism.

U Ko Ko Gyi doubts that the UEC has verified that those who raised objections hold citizenship ID cards and live where they stated in their objection letters.

The politician earlier said the party's original name was decided upon only after yearlong consultations with multiple stakeholders. He has defended that most of the party's founding members were actively involved in the nationwide democracy movement, and therefore, the party deserves its name.

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post Uncertainty Surrounds 8888 Party Name appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Parliament Approves Govt Security Measures to Prevent Terrorism

Posted: 18 Jun 2018 01:14 AM PDT

NAYPYITAW — Parliament approved a proposal without holding a vote for the government to take necessary security measures to prevent terrorist attacks in Myanmar, especially northern Rakhine State.

Military representatives to the Lower House of the Union Parliament expressed concern that Rakhine State's Maungdaw would become a disputed territory like Kosovo.

Military representative Col Tun Ohn Thein blamed the illegal immigration of Muslims as the root cause for Kosovo's succession from Serbia as he discussed the proposal of former Lieutenant-General U Thaung Aye of the Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) at the Lower House on Friday.

In the case of Kosovo, Muslim Albanians illegally immigrated into Yugoslavia, which resulted in conflict between local Christian Serbs and Muslim Albanians, said Col Tun Ohn Thein.

In the Kosovo War, some Islamic countries backed the Albanians against the Serbs in response to perceived religious repression, he said, adding that on the ground, many Serbs had to flee Kosovo.

"Similarly, whenever there is conflict in northern Rakhine State, Arakanese and ethnic people have to flee. The difference is that [Rakhine] is not a racial conflict; it was prompted by an attack by extremist Bengali terrorists," he said, referring to an attack by the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army on border guard posts in August of last year and using 'Bengali' as a derogatory term used largely against Rohingya Muslims implying that they are interlopers from Bangladesh.

NATO intervened in Kosovo on the pretext of human rights without the permission of the UN, said Col Tun Ohn Thein, expressing his concern that foreign agencies might attempt a similar intervention in Rakhine.

The national security of Myanmar was broken by the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army attack in northern Rakhine State, said military representative Lt-Col Ye Min Oo, adding that some countries and agencies are supporting the 'Bengalis' due to misinformation.

"The sovereignty of the state is being threatened by pressures from various sides," said Lt-Col Ye Min Oo.

The current government is not afraid of international pressures and has never been hesitant to respond as necessary to the international community, said Daw Pyone Cathy Naing, a lawmaker of the ruling National League for Democracy.

It is important to cooperate strategically with the international community and diplomatically control intervention from powerful countries, she said.

"The current government will be the first government [of Myanmar] to address the root causes of the issues in Rakhine. That's why it has been taking steps to ensure rule of law and transparency," said Daw Pyone Cathy Naing.

The closed-door policy and the policy of denying the existence of problems, which successive governments followed, no longer work now, said the lawmaker.

Most lawmakers from the USDP, Arakan National Party, and Tatmadaw discussed the issues in Rakhine from the perspective of national security.

The deputy minister for home affairs said that he would listen to the decision of Parliament. Parliamentary Speaker U T Khun Myat asked the opinion of the proposer and he urged its approval. The proposal was approved without a vote.

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post Parliament Approves Govt Security Measures to Prevent Terrorism appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Thousands Protest in Vietnam Against Foreign Investment Plans

Posted: 17 Jun 2018 10:15 PM PDT

Thousands of people in central Vietnam demonstrated peacefully on Sunday against government plans to lease new economic zones to foreign investors, witnesses told Reuters, a few days after protesters in a nearby province clashed with police.

Protesters fear the leases may be snapped up by investors from powerful neighbor China, with which Vietnam has a rocky history, and were also upset about a recently-passed cybersecurity law that they worry would limit free speech.

Public protests in Vietnam are usually quickly quelled by the police. The ruling Communist Party, despite sweeping economic reform and increasing openness to social change, retains tight media censorship and tolerates little criticism.

Security on Sunday was tight in many cities and provinces in Vietnam, with a large presence of police in public areas.

But in central Ha Tinh province, thousands of people attending a Sunday mass protested peacefully against the laws, three witnesses told Reuters, confirming livestream footages on Facebook.

Protesters held signs that said “No leasing land to Chinese communists for even one day” or “Cybersecurity law kills freedom.” The protest in Ha Tinh province lasted for two hours on Sunday morning without a clash with the police, witnesses said.

Earlier this week the Vietnamese government vowed to punish “extremists” it said had instigated rare clashes with police where protesters hurled bricks and Molotov cocktails at police and damaged some government buildings in Binh Thuan province.

Vietnam’s National Assembly chairwoman on Friday said the lawmakers condemned “the acts of abusing democracy, distorting the truth, provoking, causing social disorder and greatly affecting the people’s life.”

General Secretary Nguyen Phu Trong, in a talk with Hanoi citizens on Sunday, called for the people to be calm and trust the Communist party and the government, state-run radio news website Voice of Vietnam reported.

“[We] do this for the nation, for the people and no other purpose, and no one is that foolish to hand over land to foreigners for them to come and mess things up,” Trong was quoted as saying.

The post Thousands Protest in Vietnam Against Foreign Investment Plans appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Assets Registered to Thai Crown Property Bureau to Be Held Under King’s Name

Posted: 17 Jun 2018 09:13 PM PDT

BANGKOK — Assets previously registered to Thailand’s Crown Property Bureau will now be held “in the name of His Majesty," the bureau said on its official website on Saturday, the latest shake-up in royal affairs under King Maha Vajiralongkorn.

The Crown Property Bureau said its assets will now be “subject to the same duties and taxation as would assets belonging to any other citizen." Previously, assets registered in the name of the Crown Property Bureau were exempt from tax.

“The removal of exempted status was accomplished in line with His Majesty’s wishes,” the statement said.

The exact size of the Crown Property Bureau is not made public, but Forbes magazine valued the bureau’s holdings in real estate and other investments at more than $30 billion in 2012.

King Vajiralongkorn, 65, who became monarch after the death of his father, King Bhumibol Adulyadej, in 2016, has overseen a number of changes to the way royal affairs are managed since taking the throne.

A royal property law was amended in July last year to formally give the king full control of the Crown Property Bureau, which manages the multi-billion dollar holdings of the monarchy and controls huge swathes of land in Bangkok.

A senior official at the Crown Property Bureau declined to comment when contacted by Reuters by phone about the changes.

Palace representatives did not respond to several Reuters attempts to reach the palace for comment.

Saturday’s announcement is an extension of the July 2017 legal change and gives even greater authority to King Vajiralongkorn, who has shown himself increasingly assertive since the death of his father.

In March, stock exchange data showed the king acquired a nearly $150 million stake in the country’s biggest industrial conglomerate, Siam Cement Group Pcl. In October, shares worth over $500 million in Siam Commercial Bank (SCB) were transferred to the king.

The king is listed as SCB’s seventh-largest shareholder.

Also in March, King Vajiralongkorn appointed Air Chief Marshal Satitpong Sukvimol as director-general of the Crown Property Bureau, replacing Chirayu Israngkun Na Ayuthaya who had held the post since 1987.

The post Assets Registered to Thai Crown Property Bureau to Be Held Under King’s Name appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Saturday, June 16, 2018

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Parliament Divided Over Latest Rakhine Investigation Commission

Posted: 16 Jun 2018 02:09 AM PDT

Ye Ni: Welcome to Dateline Irrawaddy! Last Friday, Parliament was suddenly adjourned and what could be considered a meeting of the National Defense and Security Council (NDSC) was held at the presidential residence. This was followed by a vote in the Lower House on Monday regarding the inclusion of an international member in the proposed independent investigation commission looking into issues related to Rakhine State. Ethnic and political affairs analyst U Maung Maung Soe and columnist U Thiha Thwe join me for the discussion. I'm Irrawaddy Burmese editor Ye Ni.

Last Friday, the Lower House session was suddenly adjourned and top leaders in the country met at the presidential residence in what could be dubbed an NDSC meeting. Then, on Monday, lawmakers debated in the Lower House over the inclusion of an international member in the government's independent investigation commission to investigate issues regarding northern Rakhine State. Tatmadaw representatives and lawmakers of the Union Solidarity and Development Party and the Arakan National Party strongly objected. The opposition parties questioned the government about why it favored international personalities over local eminent persons. They also asked if the country was ruled by the government or the international community. They even called the decision to include an international member a risk to the sovereignty of the country. This has led to concerns over the future of civil-military relations. What is your assessment of this, U Maung Maung Soe?

U Maung Maung Soe: Many commissions have been formed since the outbreak of the Rakhine issue—an investigation commission led by Vice President U Myint Swe, the Kofi Annan-led Commission, the Rakhine advisory panel led by former Thai foreign minister Surakiart Sathirathi, the UEHRD [Union Enterprise for Humanitarian Assistance, Resettlement and Development in Rakhine State], the commission to implement the recommendations of Kofi Annan Commission, and this latest one. The international community accepted the advisory commission led by Kofi Annan, who has influence on the international stage. So, the National League for Democracy (NLD) government apparently wants to take the same approach and include an international member who is respected by the international community. But we need to acknowledge that we have weak points regarding fact-finding in Rakhine.

Investigation teams were sent to Rakhine around the end of August. The Tatmadaw (Myanmar Army) sent an investigation team led by its Inspector-General Lt-Gen Aye Win. But there were no results from this. After the Inn Din massacre was exposed, the Tatmadaw had to send investigation team again and take action. With widespread allegations of abuses, the international community believes that investigation commissions of Myanmar are not credible. Also, the international community believes that there is still no press freedom regarding Rakhine. Reporters have been restricted from traveling freely to the area. And the trial for two Reuters reporters is still ongoing. The key to solving this problem is how we can give an acceptable answer to the international community. The question is not about inclusion or exclusion of an international member. I want the government to think about giving acceptable information to the international community. But on the other hand, no foreigner can know as much as a Myanmar citizen about Myanmar. No matter how much he is competent, he won't know about Myanmar. I personally prefer Myanmar scholars [be included in the investigation commission].

YN: I agree with your point that the commission should be credible with or without an international member on it, from the point of view of both local and international critics. Ko Thiha Thwe, what do you want to say about the formation of the commission?

Thiha Thwe: As U Maung Maung Soe has said, the government has had to implement the recommendations of the Kofi Annan Commission. I already knew that the government would face this problem if it implemented those recommendations. Since the formation of the Kofi Annan Commission, opposition parties and the Tatmadaw have spoken against the involvement of foreigners in addressing the Rakhine issue. So, I already predicted that there would be confrontation if an international member were included in the independent commission.

When I read Kofi Annan Commission's recommendations, I didn't think it would be so difficult [to implement those recommendations]. But after the Inn Din killings were exposed, a number of foreigners I talked to were suspicious that more people were killed and buried there. There are such allegations. Recently, groundwork was carried out in Maungdaw to build repatriation centers. There was excavation of land and the international community, which watched the process by satellite, alleged that the earth was moved to destroy the bodies. Their suspicion has grown significantly. If we fail to solve this, the pressures from the international community will keep growing.

The international community is apparently preparing to put political and economic pressures on our country. Our country will get into big trouble if it keeps failing to address those suspicions. As U Maung Maung Soe has said, the question is how to allay those suspicions, and not about the inclusion or exclusion of an international member. We should find a solution to dispel those suspicions together, rather than arguing about inclusion or exclusion of an international member. Suppose we are against the idea of including an international member in the commission, the question is how to make the commission acceptable to the international community. Or [the government] may choose to allow the international media to visit Rakhine State rather than forming investigation commissions. The opposition said that the country would be fraught with problems if we failed to follow the recommendations of a commission that included an international member; and that we wouldn't be able to dismiss what it says.

But I have a different view. We should not always have a negative view of international investigations. An Amnesty International delegation came to Sittwe and investigated, and as a result, the violence against Hindu residents was revealed and tensions have significantly declined. This was an immediate benefit of allowing an international investigation. There are both advantages and disadvantages of allowing this. In the case of Amnesty International's visit to Sittwe, I've seen two significant benefits so far. Because of Amnesty International, the international community accepted that the killing of Hindus was a reality. Previously, they didn't believe what we said. But now, since the international community believes the report of an international intermediary agency, pressures on us were largely reduced. We also found that the United Nations Security Council pays heed to the Kofi Annan Commission.

There are benefits of forming a commission that includes an international member. Can't we make use of such a commission shrewdly? What are we afraid of? [The opposition] said that they are afraid of our sovereignty being compromised. I have written in my articles that we will face sanctions by the international community if we resist investigation into this problem. If we were faced with sanctions like in the past, we would have to rely more on China. If this happens, how can we avoid the problem of our sovereignty being compromised? It is inevitable. So, rather than arguing about including an international member, the opposition, the government and the Tatmadaw should work together to find a solution that is acceptable to the international community.

YN: As I've said, the parliamentary session was adjourned and a meeting was held at the presidential residence [on Friday]. The proposal [to include an international member in the commission] was approved through voting [on Monday]. U Maung Maung Soe, what do you think of the government's handling of this?

MMS: The fact that there was a meeting of NDSC members shows that there is serious disagreement between the Tatmadaw and the government. The decision was made through voting on Monday. Personally, I feel like national reconciliation gets further and further away whenever a decision is made through a vote in Parliament over issues on which the Tatmadaw and the government have different views. As the National League for Democracy makes up the majority in Parliament, it can make the final decision regarding most issues.

But regarding provisions about constitutional amendments including Article 436, and about peace and ethnic issues, nothing can be changed without the approval of the Tatmadaw. Top leaders should take the approach of serious negotiation. They live in Naypyitaw and they can meet easily. They should find a solution acceptable to both sides. Only then, can national reconciliation be realized. Only then, will we be able to initiate further reforms. Otherwise, reforms won't be carried out and national reconciliation will remain distant.

YN: What else would you like to point out, Ko Thiha Thwe?

TT: The parliamentary session was adjourned to hold the meeting of top NDSC leaders. We can conclude that important decisions regarding the Rakhine issue were made at the meeting. So far, there is no report of the results of the meeting. There was a heated debate and political confrontation when Parliament resumed on Monday, as one side opposed strongly and another side passed the proposal with its voting majority. We don't want to see political confrontation. We feel that it is not yet over. If the NLD uses the power of its voting majority, others will also follow its example. For example, in Rakhine State Parliament, the Arakan National Party has the majority. There may be fighting in the Rakhine State Parliament [to oppose the investigation commission]. There may also be opposition on the ground. There was constant opposition to the Kofi Annan Commission. We can't put out fire with fire, but with water. We need to approach this with water to extinguish the fire.

YN: Thank you for your contributions!

The post Parliament Divided Over Latest Rakhine Investigation Commission appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

This Week In Parliament

Posted: 15 Jun 2018 09:28 PM PDT

Monday (June 11)

Over objections from the Union Solidarity and Development Party and the Arakan National Party, the Lower House voted in favor of including an international member on the government-appointed independent commission to investigate allegations of human rights abuses in Rakhine State.

"Who is ruling the country?" military representative Colonel Myint Cho asked, voicing disapproval of the government's decision to include a foreign expert.

Tuesday (June 12)

Lawmakers discussed the National Education Policy Commission's report on its work from October 2017 to April 2018. They acknowledged the importance of vocational education in Myanmar and the need for cooperation with local and international private schools.

Wednesday (June 13)

In the Lower House, lawmaker Daw Khin Saw Wai of Rathedaung Township asked when the Ministry of Labor, Immigration and Population would be able to release population data on the Kaman people, as the 2014 national census failed to provide an estimate for the group, who live primarily in Rakhine State.

Union Minister for Labor, Immigration and Population U Thein Swe replied that his ministry is still trying to count the Kaman population in cooperation with concerned departments. He blamed the delay on the Rohingya community, which he said had disrupted the administrative mechanism in Rakhine State so that the government was not able to conduct a census there.

Thursday (June 14)

The Lower House voted to put on record the report of the Joint Coordination Committee of the Union Parliament for the year 2016-17.

Military representatives have criticized the committee, saying its creation and operations have lacked transparency. Committee vice chairman U Aung Kyi Nyunt said the panel was formed in response to administrative requirements of the Parliament, and not for legislative purposes.

Military representative Major Zin Lin remarked that if the committee was formed solely to perform administrative functions, there should be no need for a vote to approve its work.

Friday (June 15)

The Lower House approved a proposal by Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) lawmaker U Thaung Aye urging the Union government to take action in cooperation with international agencies under the Counter-Terrorism Law against the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA), which launched attacks in 2016 and 2017 in northern Rakhine State.

The post This Week In Parliament appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Analysis: Where Some See Respect, Ethnic Groups See Burmanization and Loss of Rights

Posted: 15 Jun 2018 05:51 PM PDT

YANGON – During peace discussions with the public in Mon State on Thursday, State Counselor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi said using Burmese style honorific titles allowed the speaker to show respect to the person they were talking to and it was thus a good thing.

The country's de facto leader made her comment in response to a point raised by one of the participants in the dialogue, Mi Ngwe Lay, a Mon woman and philanthropic worker, who highlighted the issue of ethnic people who were forced to use a Burmese prefix with their names. Specifically, she cited the case of a former Mon candidate who had been required to add the prefix “Daw” to her name during the 2015 election.

As Daw Aung San Suu Kyi's comment hinted, the controversy centers on feelings of respect and the fear of being Burmanized.

The need to show respect and value each ethnic group's traditions is a refrain that is commonly voiced by the leaders of both the ethnic minority groups and the majority Burmans, with all sides stressing that it is key to the peace process. Through such respect, one can build trust and then work to achieve genuine peace. This line has been heard frequently since the democratic transition began in Myanmar in 2010.

In her role as state counselor, Daw Aung San Suu Kyi repeatedly reminds the public to respect one another, to listen to others and to share their experiences, to support the peace effort. As the de facto state leader as well as long-time moral icon, Daw Aung San Suu Kyi's words are a source of inspiration for many.

It is widely understood among Burmans that Burmese honorable titles as such Daw and Ma for women and U, Ko, and Maung for men are a way of showing respect to other people. The country's citizens have been taught this way for decades. But sadly most people don't sufficiently understand the sensitivities surrounding this issue and the underlying political implications. People tend to forget that such thinking is reinforcing the perception that the country is being Burmanized, particularly among the ethnic minorities.

Myanmar has 135 so-called ethnic groups as recorded by the government, however, it is unclear how many groups there actually are and how many are in danger of extinction. The 2014 census on the Myanmar Population and Housing does not provide an ethnic breakdown, due to "disputes about the names of the ethnic persons, the structures and the race."  On June 13, Minister of Immigration and Population U Thein Swe reiterated that the figures about the racial make-up of the country, the only data left to be disclosed, is still not ready to be published. U Thein Swe made the comment in a response to a question from the Rathaetuang lawmaker Daw Khin Saw Wai during a parliamentary session on Wednesday.

As a leader of a multiethnic nation with many diverse cultures, the state counselor "needs to address the meanings, the values and the feelings of ethnic groups behind these prefixes and honorifics, not just the words U and Daw (Bamar), Mi and Naing (Mon), Naw and Saw (Karen), especially in this special period of our country's history when we are building understanding and trust among ethnic groups," said Saw Bo Bo, the secretary of the Karen Literature and Culture Association in Yangon.

In addition to the prefixes, another problem is the changing of ethnic names into Burmese. The names of many minority ethnic people are either incorrectly spelt or forcibly changed to a Burmese version to make it easier for the staff recording the population and housing information data.

Saw Bo Bo noted that some ethnic Karen do not have Nan, Naw or Saw, Sa, Mahn as prefixes to their names. "They did not have a chance to use these Karen honorifics when they first made their NRICs (National Registration Identity Cards) and now it's extremely difficult to correct them since they would need to publish the change in a newspaper and go through other bureaucratic processes."

"We have people listed with Burmese nationality on their NRICs even though both sets of parents were Karens. The same has happened with their religion, as their faith is stated as Buddhist even though the person is Christian," Saw Bo Bo said.

It happens not only with the Karen, but to many ethnic minority people be they Chin, Kachin, Shan, Kayah, etc. Even this reporter had a similar experience. Regardless that my birth certificate and NRIC state that I am Karen-Bamar, on my officially renewed household registration paper, my identity was changed to Bamar only. Those careless immigration officials did not pay attention to my identity and obviously didn't think it is important, as we all are citizens of Myanmar.

"Use of the Bamar prefix hurts the public perception of the ethnic minority people," said Nai Soe Aung, chairman of the Mon Literature and Culture Association in Yangon.

Losing Identity: Losing Political Rights

Besides misspelling names or adding Burmese prefixes, changing a person's ethnic category can lead to an identity crisis or worse, the loss of political rights.

In the case of the Mon, not only those in Mon state, but also in Yangon region, many are registered as Bamar on their National Registration Cards.

Nai Soe Aung added, "Many were identified as Bamar even though they are Mon. The Mon population in Yangon is estimated at 150,000, but only around 40,000 are registered as Mon and this has led to the loss of Mon ethnic representation in the political arena."

According to the Constitution, minority ethnic populations with more than 50,000 are entitled to have their own ethnic representatives in the respective regional parliaments. Therefore, Karen and Rakhine ethnic affairs ministers are able to be elected in Yangon, while the Mon are denied this opportunity.

People, mostly Burmans, tend to think it is not important because Myanmar does not teach cultural diversity through mother-tongue language instruction in the education system. In terms of culture, they see the wearing of ethnic costumes as enough, and tend to omit the importance of the teaching of ethnic languages to schoolchildren.

"Daw Aung San Suu Kyi should have visited the Mon National Schools (run by the New Mon State Party in its controlled areas), where ethnic language, literature and history are primarily taught," said Nai Soe Aung.

The Mons' mother-tongue-based multilingual education curriculum is a success that is being followed by a few other groups. However, there is no government support for this MTB-MLE, he added.

To better understand Myanmar's diverse culture, Myanmar needs to support the teaching of ethnic children in their mother tongue, as they learn best in their own languages rather than in Burmese. As Myanmar is in a transition to democracy, it should follow the example of other democratic nations, especially neighboring India, where at least three languages — the official languages and the mother-tongue — are taught as compulsory subjects in school.

The more Myanmar leaders pay attention to mother-tongue education and value the feelings of the different ethnic groups, the closer we will be to building genuine peace in the country.

The post Analysis: Where Some See Respect, Ethnic Groups See Burmanization and Loss of Rights appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Friday, June 15, 2018

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Flooding Kills at Least Five in Magway, Displaces Thousands in Rakhine

Posted: 15 Jun 2018 07:44 AM PDT

MANDALAY – As the beginning of the monsoon season brings heavy rain and winds across Myanmar, many parts of the country have experienced floods and landslides in recent weeks, leaving villagers displaced and homes destroyed. Five people have died in Magway Division and more than 12,000 displaced in Rakhine State.

In Rakhine, heavy rain since June 3 has left many homes in the area inundated, especially in Mrauk-U, Ann, Min Pya, Taung Gote, Kyauktaw, with more than 12,000 people displaced, according to the Department of Disaster Management's official announcement on Thursday.

In an official statement, the department said it was cooperating with local authorities and civil society groups in Rakhine State to distribute safety kits and food.

Although the water level is decreasing, many locals are still stranded in makeshift shelters in monasteries and schools located on high ground, local lawmakers said.

"The water level has been falling since yesterday, but locals remain wary amid forecasts of heavy rain and rising water levels in the Laymyo River two days from now," said U Hla Thein Aung, a local lawmaker from the Arakan National Party, or ANP, who lives in Minpyar Township, the worst-affected area in Rakhine State.

Since June 3, heavy rain has swollen the Laymyo River to dangerous levels, causing its banks to erode and heavy flooding in Rakhine State's river basin area. High tides have worsened the flooding.

In Minpyar, floodwaters have reached as high as 10 feet in some villages.

According to local residents, at least 10 households from Shwetamar village in Minpyar have been forced to relocate due to erosion of the banks of the Laymyo River.

"Although the locals have received enough food and medicine, clean water is urgently needed, as the township's wells and ponds are contaminated by floodwater. We also need access to remote villages, as transportation has been cut off due to landslides," he added.

U Hla Thein Aung said landslides had occurred on mountains near Ann and Taung Gote, cutting off transportation of food to remote villages, whose residents' safety is at risk.

In Magwe Division, local residents were concerned about rising water levels in the Mone and Man rivers amid heavy rain in recent days, especially in the area around Pwintphyu Township, which experienced severe flooding in 2015.

According to the local authorities, at least 100 residents were relocated due to flooding on Monday. They are currently housed at 10 camps in Pwintphyu Township, awaiting further weather forecasts.

"A few lowland areas in the Saytotetayar and Pwintphyu regions have been deluged, though the water level has dropped significantly since yesterday. However, locals are very concerned, as they are still traumatized due to severe flooding in 2015," said U Myint Soe, a local official from the Magwe divisional office of the Ministry of Social Welfare, Relief and Resettlement.

According to the ministry, roads and small bridges in Minbu, Myothit, Salin and Pwintphyu Districts were washed away due to heavy rain and flooding on Monday. In these areas, five people died and 63 houses were destroyed. In Thayat District alone, about 70 villages were flooded, creating an urgent need for food and water.

Alerts and warnings of more rain in the area are expected to continue for a few days, but locals said the rain had subsided for the time being, and that water levels in the rivers were also decreasing.

"However, [false] rumors are spreading through social media that dams in the Pwintphyu area dangerously full, and the government has not issued any alerts to locals. Actually, none of that is true," explained U Tint San, a local parliamentarian from Pwintphyu, Magwe Division.

"We are constantly getting updated information from the Ministry of Agriculture and Irrigation, which tells us that the dams are safe and the water levels in those dams are not at dangerous levels. We will visit the dam tomorrow to reassure the locals," he added.

According to weather reports from the Department of Meteorology and Hydrology, showers are forecast across the country, with heavy rains expected in certain areas of Irrawaddy Division, Rakhine State, Chin State, Kayin State, Mon State, Yagon Division and Pegu Division in two days, due to strong monsoon winds in the Bay of Bengal.

The weather report also predicted that the water level in the Laymyo River in Rakhine State will drop below the dangerous level in two days.

The post Flooding Kills at Least Five in Magway, Displaces Thousands in Rakhine appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Election Commission Urged to Share Details of Pending Poll

Posted: 15 Jun 2018 06:10 AM PDT

YANGON — The People's Alliance for Credible Elections (PACE) has urged Myanmar’s top election authority to announce details about the Nov. 3 by-elections as soon as possible so that parties and civil society groups can prepare to monitor the polls.

The Union Election Commission (UEC) announced the date of the election last month, along with an early voting schedule for those casting ballots away from their constituencies. It said observers could start registering for accreditation earlier this month and met with 72 parties contesting the November vote on Thursday in Naypyitaw to coordinate.

At a press conference in Yangon on Friday, PACE said it planned to deploy 600 observers on election day and that 24 of its people would monitor the campaign period leading up to the poll.

PACE Executive Director Sai Ye Kyaw Swar Myint said his group would have observers in all 12 townships taking part in the by-elections but did not have enough information to plan for the race for Shan ethnic affair minister in Mandalay Region, for which voting will be regionwide.

While other cabinet ministers are appointed by the president, the 29 ethnic affairs ministers are elected.

"We don't have specific information yet on how many voting stations will be there for the voters to cast their ballots for the Shan ethnic affair minister,” Sai Ye Kyaw Swar Myint told The Irrawaddy.

“We heard three of the 26 townships in Mandalay have no ethnic Shan residents and some of them have very few, and that in those areas with few residents they will have to vote at the sub-electoral commission office. Only when we know about the voting stations and the statistics on Shan residents in the 23 townships can we include it in our monitoring list," he said.

The PACE director said independent election monitors recommended some changes to the UEC after the elections in 2015 and 2017 and wanted to know what came of them.

"We want to know what changes have been made and what still needs to be changed. These are also equally important for the upcoming by-election and the general election in 2020," he said.

Their recommendations included more transparency, changing the structure of the UEC, improving the voter lists and reviewing the composition of constituencies.

At Friday’s press conference, PACE also announced its plans to survey registered voters in the townships participating in the by-election on their views. It said the survey would start later his month and finish in early July.

The post Election Commission Urged to Share Details of Pending Poll appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Five Perish as House Collapses in Mogok Landslide

Posted: 15 Jun 2018 02:56 AM PDT

MANDALAY — Five family members were killed when their house was destroyed by a landslide in Mogok, Mandalay Region, early Thursday morning.

The incident happened in the ward of Aung Thit Lwin in Kathae village tract in Mogok, said Mogok Township lawmaker U Saw Thaung Tin in the Mandalay regional parliament.

"Three houses on the hillside in Aung Thit Lwin collapsed at around 4 a.m. on Thursday, as it had been raining heavily the whole week," he said.

Family members from two of the houses had been taking shelter at a temporary camp opened at a Chinese temple in the ward when the landslide happened.

"But five family members in the third house were killed," U Saw Thaung Tin said.

Given the risk of landslides in a number of places due to heavy rains, concerned authorities have been evacuating local people to safer areas.

"There have been a few other landslides reported at several hillside villages in the township. But there had been no casualties [except for the latest fatal case]," said U Saw Thaung Tin.

"As the earth got wet from the rain, houses built on the hillside collapsed. There has been only a small amount of damage apart from the fatal case," said U Sein Myint, a resident of Kathae.

The Department of Meteorology and Hydrology said on Thursday that scattered rains are likely to continue across Myanmar.

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post Five Perish as House Collapses in Mogok Landslide appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Former Ambassador to Myanmar to Lead National Democratic Institute

Posted: 15 Jun 2018 02:00 AM PDT

YANGON — A former US ambassador to Myanmar has become the new president of an international nonprofit working to support and strengthen democracy around the world through citizen participation, and openness and accountability in government.

The Washington-based National Democratic Institute (NDI) announced on Thursday that Derek Mitchell, who served in Myanmar from 2012-16, was approved by the institute's board of directors as president.

NDI Chairwoman Madeleine K. Albright said she was confident that the former ambassador would guide the organization with boundless energy and clear vision for many years to come.

"Throughout his varied and stellar career, Derek has been an innovator, a successful leader, and an eloquent advocate for improved governance and larger freedom. No one grasps better than he the intimate connection between the health of democracy abroad and the security of America at home," she said.

The chairwoman used to be a US Secretary of State and traveled to Myanmar in 1995. During her first visit, Albright delivered tough talk to Myanmar's generals, warning that the country would face continued isolation if the leaders of the military junta at the time did not take steps toward greater political freedom and democracy for Burmese people. She met in 1995 with military intelligence leader Lt-Gen Khin Nyunt and other government officials, as well as Daw Aung San Suu Kyi.

As the NDI chairman, Albright visited Myanmar again in 2013 and met again with the Nobel Peace Laureate as well as political parties, stating that the NDI was willing to assist the country in its ongoing transition to democracy.

Prior to Myanmar's 2015 parliamentary elections, which saw Daw Aung San Suu Kyi's National League for Democracy party win a landslide victory, the NDI supported the formation of the country's first citizen election observer group, the People's Alliance for Credible Elections, to mobilize over 5,000 citizen monitors throughout the country.

In 2012, Derek Mitchell became the first US Ambassador to Myanmar in two decades after Washington appointed a lower level diplomat to the Southeast Asian country after its military regime cracked down on the country's democracy movement.

Prior to his appointment in Myanmar, he was the special US representative and policy coordinator for Burma and was a key player in implementing the Obama administration's Burma policy.

The post Former Ambassador to Myanmar to Lead National Democratic Institute appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Why We Need to Recognize Migrant Domestic Workers’ Contribution to Our Economies

Posted: 15 Jun 2018 01:49 AM PDT

On Saturday we will celebrate two important days, the International Day of Family Remittances and the 7th anniversary of the adoption of the landmark Domestic Workers Convention (No. 189) of the International Labor Organization (ILO). In light of that, let us take a moment to appreciate the significant economic and social contribution migrant domestic workers make to the homes, communities and countries where they are employed, as well as to those they originate from.

The ILO estimates that more than 67 million people, mostly women, are employed in domestic work around the world. Southeast Asia and the Pacific employ some 9 million domestic workers. More than 2 million of them are migrant domestic workers, constituting nearly 20 percent of all migrant workers in the region.

Due to an aging population, lower fertility rates and women's increasing labor force participation, the care economies in many countries in the region including Brunei, Malaysia, Singapore and Thailand are heavily dependent on the work of migrant domestic workers. Projections indicate that the demand for domestic workers in the region will continue to grow in the near future, a demand that most likely will require migration.

At the same time, remittances sent home by migrant domestic workers also make a significant contribution to the well-being of their families and the development of their home countries.

Migrant Worker Remittances Contribute Considerably to Socio-Economic Development

A 2017 study by the ILO and the International Organization for Migration (IOM) surveying over 1,800 migrant workers from Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar and Vietnam upon their return from Thailand and Malaysia found that 93 percent of migrant workers regularly sent remittances home while working abroad. These remittances were used for a range of purposes, including immediate household needs, children's education, paying off debt, savings, and supporting family members.

Remittances remain hugely important to developing economies, and the Asia-Pacific region is the biggest receiver of remittances worldwide. According to the World Bank, officially recorded remittances to low- and middle-income countries worldwide reached $466 billion in 2017, an increase of 8.5 percent since 2016. Migrant workers from the Asia-Pacific region sent $256 billion home in 2017; this is more than 10 times the amount of development aid received in the region. A total of 320 million family members were supported by remittances across the region, and remittances contributed on average 60 percent to a receiving household's income. In Asia and the Pacific, the Philippines and Vietnam remained the top remittance destinations with inflows to the Philippines at $33 billion and to Vietnam at $14 billion in 2017.

The average cost to send remittances from Thailand to Cambodia, Myanmar, Laos and Vietnam ranges from 3 percent to 20 percent, depending on the service provider used, according to the United Nations Capital Development Fund (UNCDF). Given that, we still have some work to do to realize Sustainable Development Goal Target 10 (c), which aims to reduce the transaction costs to less than 3 percent and eliminate remittance corridors with costs higher than 5 percent by 2030.

Barriers to Sending Money Back Home Safely Hampers Development

Maximizing the development impact of migrant remittances requires that migrant workers have access to affordable and migrant-friendly remittance and banking services. This is, unfortunately, not yet the case in the ASEAN region.

The ILO and IOM survey found that informal remittance channels were the most popular among migrants from Laos and Myanmar. Vietnamese migrants preferred using banks or hand carry, while Cambodian migrant workers preferred money transfer organizations. In addition to a greater risk for the migrant worker to lose their earnings on its way home, reliance on informal remittance channels in the region has led to the existence of a significant shadow economy which needs to be brought to formality.

Barriers to migrant workers' use of formal remittance channels include inaccessibility, high costs, low awareness of available remittance service providers, and a lack of trust. Lack of identification documents poses another challenge, especially for irregular migrant workers. Migrant domestic workers are among the most disadvantaged in accessing banking and formal remittance channels as they typically work very long days, have few days off, and are often unable to leave their places of work.

Realizing the Development Potential of Remittances

To make sure that remittances can contribute to development and reach their destinations safely and affordably, the ILO is working on a number of initiatives on both the demand and the supply side of financial services. On the supply side this involves working with financial institutions so they can develop adequate financial services and products matching the need of the migrant worker. One of the initiatives linked to the demand side of financial services is the soon-to-be-launched SaverAsia. SaverAsia is a digital platform that helps migrant workers compare remittance costs to find the best rates and money saving options. The portal also helps migrant workers find financial services such as savings, payments, credit and insurance products suited to their needs. A first-user-group testing of SaverAsia will take place in Singapore next week with Indonesian and Filipino migrant domestic workers, and it will be formally launched in September 2018.

More Remains to Be Done

Saturday is an important opportunity not only to recognize the contribution that migrant domestic workers, most of who are women, make to their host countries, but also to celebrate their important role in supporting socio-economic development of their home countries.

However, in addition to building individual migrant workers' capacity to make wise choices about their finances, an enabling environment needs to be created to maximize the development potential of their remittances. This requires making safe, affordable and migrant-friendly remittance and banking services available to all women and men migrant workers.

Also of critical importance are partnerships at the national, bilateral and regional levels that make migration a win-win proposition for countries of origin, destination and migrants themselves. Decent work for domestic workers, the essence of the Domestic Workers Convention, can only be achieved through a commitment to improving laws, making employers and workers aware of their obligations and rights, and partnerships among governments, workers and civil society that empower women migrant workers and protect their rights.

Tomoko Nishimoto is assistant director-general and regional director of the ILO Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific.

The post Why We Need to Recognize Migrant Domestic Workers' Contribution to Our Economies appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Myanmar Army Chief Asks UN Envoy for ‘Constructive’ Relationship

Posted: 15 Jun 2018 01:26 AM PDT

Mon State — Army chief Senior General Min Aung Hlaing urged the United Nations to seek constructive relations with the country during a meeting with the UN’s recently appointed special envoy on Myanmar in Naypyitaw on Thursday.

In a post to his Facebook page, the army chief said he told Christine Schraner Burgener that the UN’s cooperation could help improve Myanmar's situation. He said the UN faced challenges with locals in Rakhine State — where its assistance to Rohingya Muslims has angered many Buddhist Rakhine — but was welcomed elsewhere.

Schraner Burgener is on her first visit to Myanmar since her appointment as special envoy in April and is also scheduled to meet with ethnic armed groups, civil society organizations, religious leaders and diplomats. She will be looking into the situation in Rakhine State, the peace process, democratization efforts and human rights.

The trip comes amid heavy international pressure on the army, or Tatmadaw, over its alleged abuses in Rakhine State — including widespread reports of arson, rape and murder — that have driven some 700,000 Rohingya to neighboring Bangladesh since August.

“When conflicts arise, it is necessary to distinguish between the act of individuals and that of the Tatmadaw. Myanmar is still weak in democracy experience, wisdom and other sectors such as education and health. In its effort to build up a standard army, the Tatmadaw is trying to work in cooperation with the international community,” the general’s post said in English.

But he said the sanctions and “bias” against Myanmar were not constructive, and that the spread of fake news about the situation in Rakhine State would only lead to more hatred, misunderstanding and resistance to cooperation.

The general said some representatives of the UN Security Council had come to Myanmar in April with a bad attitude and, employing a pair of Burmese expressions, told the envoy: "Let the amicable relations last long and let the hatred shorten," and "Try to make a big case small and a small case disappear."

"It is therefore necessary for the UN to bring effective, constructive relations," he said.

The army has defended its actions in Rakhine State as a legitimate counterinsurgency operation against the militant Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army, whose attacks on security posts in August triggered the crackdown.

In his meeting with Schraner Burgener, the general also said the army had a duty to protect the country and that it respected the rule of law.

“In the issue of Rakhine State, the Tatmadaw was just serving its duty of restoring regional peace and stability and protecting the lives and property of the ethnic people. It has never done any acts that may harm the other country, other organizations and the human society,” he said.

Separately, Matt Pottinger, the US National Security Council’s senior director for Asia, is also in Myanmar for a three-day visit. During a press conference in Yangon on Thursday, he said the US would impose further targeted sanctions on Myanmar Army officials who committed human rights abuses.

In December the US imposed sanctions on General Maung Maung Soe — who oversaw the army’s crackdown in Rakhine State last year — that effectively shut him out of the US financial system. The US House of Representatives endorsed measures to impose sanctions on more army officials last month.

The post Myanmar Army Chief Asks UN Envoy for ‘Constructive’ Relationship appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

‘I Am Not a Turncoat’: Thura Shwe Mann

Posted: 15 Jun 2018 12:52 AM PDT

NAYPYITAW — "I am not a turncoat," said Thura Shwe Mann, the former head of the Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) and the current chairman of the Legal Affairs and Special Cases Assessment Commission of Myanmar's Parliament predominated by the National League for Democracy (NLD).

The ex-general, who was considered the third most powerful man in the military regime led by retired Snr-Gen Than Shwe, defended his move to ally himself with Daw Aung San Suu Kyi before the 2015 general elections.

He was serving as the Speaker of the Lower House under U Thein Sein's quasi-civilian government when he tried to forge ties with Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, who was then a legislator in the Lower House.

U Shwe Mann said he cooperated with Daw Aung San Suu Kyi in the interest of the country and because he believed the USDP would win the 2015 election. But critics believe that he made the move for his political survival due to uncertainty regarding his future with the USDP.

"I told her [Daw Aung San Suu Kyi] to hold an appropriate office and support me if I won [the election]. I said it was up to her if she won. I am not a turncoat," said U Shwe Mann during the launching of a report on Thursday on the resignation of the constitutional tribunal under President U Thein Sein's government.

He said so apparently in response to U Soe Thane, one the confidants of the former president and ex-President's Office minister, who wrote that some top-level USDP party leaders with more than 40 years of military service surrendered to the opposition NLD because the latter was much more likely to win the 2015 poll.

"They were traitors, becoming turncoats although they were saying that cooperation was necessary for the sake of the country and countrymen," writes U Soe Thane in his book "Myanmar's Transition & U Thein Sein: An Insider's Account."

With an evident power struggle between the two sides since the start of democratization in 2010, U Shwe Mann claimed that ex-president U Thein Sein acted like an authoritarian in the elected government.

During the military regime, the State Peace and Development Council (SPDC) chairman Snr-Gen Than Shwe was the top leader of Myanmar and any order signed by him was considered a decree, which the cabinet had to follow, said U Shwe Mann.

There was friction between the government and Parliament because U Thein Sein issued orders as if he were the head of the SPDC although any law had to be passed by Parliament in a democracy, said U Shwe Mann.

"Because he acted as if he were the SPDC chairman, lawmakers didn't accept it. He asked us to legislate what he wanted and there was friction," he said.

U Shwe Mann said he is not clear on whether he has been dismissed by the USDP or if he is still considered a member.

He was purged from the USDP chairmanship in August 2015 due to tension between himself and then President U Thein Sein. Other senior party members were also purged along with him.

U Shwe Mann said he submitted his resignation from the party some six months ago. "Three other colleagues and I submitted our resignation. The USDP replied to those three that their resignation was accepted. But their reply to me was ambiguous and I want it to be clear," said U Shwe Mann.

U Shwe Mann graduated with Intake No. 11 of the Defense Services Academy in 1965. He was elected to the Lower House from Zayarthiri Township in a 2010 poll.

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post 'I Am Not a Turncoat': Thura Shwe Mann appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Journalist Prepares ‘Pop Art’ Birthday Tribute for Daw Aung San Suu Kyi

Posted: 15 Jun 2018 12:09 AM PDT

Many people will be wishing the best for Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, who is still widely regarded as the hope of Myanmar, on June 19, when she turns 73.

Despite her age, the popular leader still appears full of beans and apparently much more active than her ministers, as she spoke with locals during peace talks in Mon State on Thursday, just five days before her birthday.

Hlaing Bwa is one of the many admirers who want to celebrate her birthday. The journalist-cum-artist has drawn 73 sketches of the state counselor to mark her 73rd birthday.

The artist, a big fan of Andy Warhol, the American artist and leading figure in the pop art movement, has chosen Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, to introduce this modern visual art form to Myanmar.

"I feel like pop art is still strange for Myanmar people. Pop art is about drawing public figures. So, I thought Daw Aung San Suu Kyi would make the perfect figure and subject for this. And I also want to celebrate her birthday," said Hlaing Bwa.

The exhibition, titled "73 Sketches", features pop art versions of 73 portraits measuring 12×10 inches plus a 5×15-foot illustration depicting 73 figures of Daw Aung San Suu Kyi.

"Because of her influence, I had difficulties depicting her character. Only after failing with around 20 paintings, could I grasp it. Deep colors do not match her. They make her look aggressive. So, I mostly used sweet colors and focused on her beauty," Hlaing Bwa said.

He has also incorporated a famous poem by one of Myanmar's most celebrated poets, Zaw Gyi in the big painting. "Pann Pan Lyet Pe", which metaphorically translates as "I don't mind difficulties" is a favorite poem of Daw Aung San Suu Kyi.

"There are a lot of challenges for Daw Aung San Suu Kyi at present. But she has endured them and keeps going. This poem relates to her life and her efforts at state building. So, I have incorporated this poem in the painting," said Hlaing Bwa, who is the deputy editor-in-chief of Democracy Daily, a Burmese-language daily.

The exhibition will be held at the Ahla Thit Gallery on University Avenue Road near Daw Aung San Suu Kyi's residence from June 19 through June 21.

The post Journalist Prepares 'Pop Art' Birthday Tribute for Daw Aung San Suu Kyi appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

‘Where is Singapore?’: Trump-Kim Summit a PR Coup For Tiny City-State

Posted: 14 Jun 2018 10:14 PM PDT

SINGAPORE — As images of North Korean leader Kim Jong Un strolling by revelers at a rooftop bar the night before an unprecedented meeting with President Donald Trump circulated around social media sites, US citizens started asking “Where is Singapore?”

“Singapore,” the tiny Southeast Asian city-state that played host to nuclear talks earlier this week, was the most searched term on internet search engine Google in the United States on Monday with over 2 million hits.

Related searches during those 24 hours included “Where is Singapore,” “Singapore summit” and “time in Singapore.”

Blanket media coverage on Monday included Kim’s surprise tour of the iconic Marina Bay Sands hotel and its surrounding gardens, and the first hours of the meeting with Trump on the resort island of Sentosa.

Singapore said it spent S$20 million ($15 million) on the summit, a figure that drew the ire of some citizens. However, marketing experts say the coverage generated from the event could be worth more than 10 times that.

“It places Singapore on the map for international audiences,” said Oliver Chong, executive director of communications and marketing capability at the Singapore Tourism Board.

Tourism contributes around 4 percent to Singapore’s GDP per year. Visitor arrivals hit a record 17.4 million last year, boosted by China, its top market, and India.

But just months ago, lifestyle magazine Time Out ranked Singapore among the world’s least exciting cities.

Andrew Darling, CEO and founder of communications agency West Pier Ventures, said it would cost more than S$200 million to generate the kind of publicity Singapore has received so far by hosting the summit.

Media intelligence firm Meltwater said the coverage over the three days around the summit equated to $270 million of advertising, while the month leading up to it was worth $767 million.

“The Trump-Kim Summit has arguably been the single most important event that brought Singapore to the attention of the most people around the world,” said Jason Tan of media advertising agency Zenith Singapore.

“For many Asians, Singapore as the choice of destination reinforces our image as an efficient and safe country. For Americans who might not be as familiar with Asia, the summit definitely brought Singapore into the global spotlight.”

Still, even some who should know better struggled to accurately place Singapore — known as the Little Red Dot in reference to its depiction on a map.

The US State Department mistakenly made Singapore a part of neighboring Malaysia in a note issued in connection with the summit, drawing a slew of snide comments on social media.

The post ‘Where is Singapore?’: Trump-Kim Summit a PR Coup For Tiny City-State appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Malaysia to Seek Return of 1MDB Money From Banks, Political Parties

Posted: 14 Jun 2018 10:06 PM PDT

KUALA LUMPUR — Malaysia intends to recover all funds illicitly taken from 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB), and determine whether there are grounds for claims against companies, including Goldman Sachs, that profited from dealing with the beleaguered state fund.

Finance Minister Lim Guan Eng told Reuters in an interview on Thursday that a plan was “on the table” to ask all individuals and political parties to return money that came from 1MDB, which was allegedly used as a slush fund by former prime minister Najib Razak.

Having defeated his former protege in an election last month, Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad’s administration has launched an investigation into how the fund founded by Najib lost billions of dollars.

Najib has consistently denied any wrongdoing, and repeated earlier this week that he did not benefit or steal money from 1MDB.

Lim said the government would also scrutinize the $600 million paid in fees to Goldman Sachs for raising nearly $6.5 billion in three bond sales between 2012 and 2013 for 1MDB. Critics said the fees earned from those bond issues were far in excess of the normal 1-2 percent fees a bank could expect.

“We will be looking at the possibility of seeking claims from Goldman Sachs, where there are grounds to do so… definitely,” Lim told Reuters in an interview.

Reuters had reported last week that according to sources familiar with the issue Malaysia is considering asking the US Department of Justice (DoJ) to get Goldman Sachs to return fees earned from the bond issues.

Civil lawsuits filed in 2016 by the DOJ alleged that over $2.5 billion raised from those bonds were misappropriated by high-level 1MDB officials, their relatives and associates.

He also said Malaysia will look at the conduct of other banks involved in 1MDB transactions.

“We’ve got to see the nexus, whether they were at fault.”

Lim said the United Malay National Organization (UMNO), the party Najib had led until his election defeat, and from which Mahathir resigned in order to join the opposition, was not the only party to have received 1MDB money.

“To be fair, UMNO is not the only political party that received money,” Lim said. “Those who have taken money from 1MDB, should return it to the country.”

International Effort

Lim said the DOJ and enforcement agencies in several other countries were giving strong cooperation to Malaysia’s efforts to recoup 1MDB funds, and bring prosecutions.

A proposal to monetize assets acquired using 1MDB funds that U.S. authorities are looking to seize under its anti-kleptocracy program was an option under consideration, Lim said.

The DOJ is seeking to seize $1.7 billion in assets allegedly bought with funds stolen from 1MDB, including a Picasso painting, shares in a Hollywood production company, a yacht and nearly $200 million in jewelry.

Last month, Malaysian police said that cash worth 114 million ringgit ($28.6 million), jewelry and over 400 luxury handbags were seized from several apartments linked to Najib, as part of their probe into 1MDB.

Lim said his ministry is also investigating several “highly suspicious” deals made by Najib’s administration to determine if they were carried out to help pay for 1MDB dues.

He declined to identify the deals, but said Malaysia was investigating state-run palm oil agency Felda’s $500 million acquisition of a non-controlling stake in Indonesia’s PT Eagle High Plantations Tbh.

He did not say if the Felda deal, which was criticized for being expensive, was linked to 1MDB.

Last month, the finance ministry said about $500 million raised from a land sale by the government to the central bank, along with funds from sovereign wealth fund Khazanah Nasional, were used to pay 1MDB’s liabilities in 2017.

Lim said the government will have to pay an estimated 50 billion ringgit in debts and interest accumulated by 1MDB.

“We are forced to pay that much against our will,” Lim said, adding that the government has sufficient funds, but may consider restructuring debt to clear 1MDB’s dues if it can secure better yields.

The post Malaysia to Seek Return of 1MDB Money From Banks, Political Parties appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Sri Lanka Jails Extremist Buddhist Monk for Six Months Over Threats to Woman

Posted: 14 Jun 2018 09:30 PM PDT

COLOMBO — A Sri Lankan court on Thursday jailed for six months a Buddhist monk accused of inciting violence against Muslims after finding him guilty of intimidating the wife of a missing journalist, in a case seen as a test of the independence of the judiciary.

Galagoda Aththe Gnanasara, the secretary general of the hardline Bodu Bala Sena (BBS) or “Buddhist Power Force”, was found guilty of having threatened the woman, Sandhya Eknaligoda.

“I have done my duty towards the country,” Gnanasara told reporters as he boarded the bus taking him to prison. “Why should I regret?”

In 2016, Gnanasara interrupted a court hearing over the abduction of the journalist, Prageeth Eknaligoda, in which military intelligence officials were accused.

He shouted at the judge and lawyers because the military officials had not been allowed bail, and threatened Eknaligoda's wife.

On Thursday, Magistrate Udesh Ranathunga sentenced the monk to two terms of six months in jail, to be served concurrently, as well as a fine of 1,500 rupees, and a payment of 50,000 rupees ($313) as compensation to the journalist’s wife.

The judge rejected Gnanasara’s request to make a statement after he expressed disagreement with the sentence. He was taken to prison while fellow monks, who attended the hearing in his support, chanted Buddhist scriptures.

Gnanasara faces a separate contempt of court case over the same incident. It was not immediately clear if he would appeal against Thursday’s sentence.

Dilantha Vithanage, the chief executive of the monk’s BBS group, told Reuters it would appeal against the verdict.

The monk has faced accusations in cases regarding anti-Muslim violence, hate speech, and defaming the Koran, the Muslim holy book.

The BBS, led by Gnanasara, has been alleged by Muslims and some government ministers to have stirred up violence against Muslims and Christian, mainly in Buddhist-dominated parts of Sri Lanka, allegations the monk has denied.

In 2014, Gnanasara signed a pact with Myanmar’s Ashin Wirathu, who once called himself “the Burmese bin Laden” in what they called the first step in a broad alliance against conversions by Islamists in the region.

The post Sri Lanka Jails Extremist Buddhist Monk for Six Months Over Threats to Woman appeared first on The Irrawaddy.