Friday, June 13, 2014

Democratic Voice of Burma

Democratic Voice of Burma


Burma Business Weekly

Posted: 13 Jun 2014 03:58 AM PDT

 

Ups and Downs

The Burmese currency remained stable this week, with the buying rate finishing on Friday at 966 kyat – up 1 kyat compared to the week before – and the selling rate dropping slightly to 970 kyat. Meanwhile, the price of gold increased to 657,100 kyat per tical, compared to last week's rate of 649,800 kyat. Fuel prices remained the same, with petrol selling at 820 kyat per litre, diesel at 950 kyat per litre, and octane at 920 kyat per litre. The price of rice also did not fluctuate, with the high-quality Pawhsanmwe rice continueing to sell at 1,300 to 1,600 kyat per basket and low-quality Manawthukha rice going for 900 kyat per basket.

 

JICA dismisses accusations of negligence

Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) rejected allegations that it betrayed its own guidelines on "environmental and social considerations" in the Thilawa Special Economic Zone, in which it has a 10 percent equity stake. These allegations are from residents of the Myaing Thar Yar resettlement village, home to 68 families displaced by construction of the project's 400-hectare first phase. Masahiko Tanaka, JICA's chief representative in Burma, claimed that issues of compensation and compliance with "international standards" are ultimately the government's responsibility.

Read more here.

 

Price of LPG doubles due to Thai coup

The price of liquid petroleum gas (LPG) – the substance used mainly for cooking – has more than doubled in Burma during the last month due to a shortage in Thailand amid a military coup. The owner of a gas shop in Rangoon said that the LPG price, which stood at about 2,600 kyat (US$2.68) per tank last month, has now risen to about 6,500 kyat this week. Many gas shops have also temporarily closed due to a lack of LPG supplies.

 

Commercial Tax Law grants new exemptions

The newly adopted Commercial Tax Law offers exemptions on 18 types of goods and 26 commercial services, customs officials announced on Wednesday. Exempted goods include: fertiliser; farm equipment; household pharmaceuticals; stationary; condoms; textbooks; and equipment for defence and security organisations. Exempted services include funeral assistance and real estate services.

 

Japan pledges $40m to build Rangoon bridge

The Japanese government has pledged assistance worth over US$40 million towards the construction of a new bridge in Rangoon's Thaketa Township to improve transportation to and from the Thilawa Special Economic Zone and to reduce traffic congestion in the city. The Thilawa industrial site, some 25km south of the city centre, is a joint Burmese-Japanese development, and has attracted several multinational firms such as Mitsubishi and Sumitomo, and the US's Ball Corporation.

 

Thiha Groups signs steel deal with Thailand's Millcon

Thiha Group has signed a joint venture with Thailand's Millcon Steel Plc to tap the growing demand for steel and other construction materials in Burma, according to a Bangkok Post report. Millcon's president said his firm was "entering a new market to establish a foothold" and that it will have an advantage in being among the first foreign steel and construction firms in Burma. Despite both countries having similar populations, Burma reportedly uses 1.33 million tonnes of steel per year compared with 17.7 million tonnes consumed in Thailand.

 

Hilton to open 5 more hotels in Burma

Hilton Worldwide Holdings plans to open five more hotels in Burma over the next three years, Reuters reported on Wednesday. The company's first development in Rangoon was originally slated to open this year, but will be delayed until late 2015 or early 2016, the report said. Despite the delays, Hilton has signed new agreements with Eden Group Company Limited to rebrand two existing properties as Hilton hotels and develop three more.

 

One percent of Burma's population insured

About 700,000 people out of Burma's population of 60 million have life insurance, according to a report from Myanmar Business Today. Aye Min Thein, managing director of state-run insurer Myanma Insurance Enterprise, said this low insurance penetration – roughly 1 percent – is due to a lack of interest. "The public has very little interest and there is a knowledge gap, so the numbers are very low," he said. Sailors and migrant workers are the highest subscribers to life insurance, while people in the country seldom get insured.

 

US retailer Gap enters Burma’s market

Clothing giant Gap Inc. has become the first American retailer to enter the Burmese market, the US embassy announced last Saturday at a signing ceremony attended by Ambassador Derek Mitchell and Chris Milligan, the mission director of USAID, which is partnering the project. Gap intends to operate two clothing factories in Rangoon, an embassy statement said.

Read more here.

 

 

Bangladesh, Burma reach agreement on border crisis

Posted: 13 Jun 2014 02:50 AM PDT

After two weeks of rising tensions on the Bangladesh-Burma border, the two sides reached an agreement in Naypyidaw on Wednesday over the ongoing border crisis.

In a nine-point statement, the two countries agreed to share information regarding border issues and establish a direct channel of communication between senior officials from both sides.

They also vowed to work together to crack down on the illegal narcotics trade across their common frontier.

"With regard to preventing and controlling the illegal drug trade, the border guard units of both countries, and relevant organisations tasked with ensuring the rule of law, are to take necessary steps such as exchanging information," said Burma’s Police Maj-Gen Zaw Win.

The two sides will investigate the incidents surrounding the death of Bangladeshi Corp Nayek Mizanur Rashman, who was shot and killed on 28 May by Burmese border guard forces.

Burma's Ministry of Foreign Affairs claims that two men in unmarked camouflage uniform encroached onto Burmese territory, and were assumed to be members of the Rohingya Solidarity Organisation (RSO) insurgency group.

But Bangladesh maintains that the exchange of gunfire took place on Bangladeshi soil.

Tensions have been high between the two sides since the clash and a previous attempt to negotiate at a flag meeting in Arakan State's Maungdaw ended without resolution.

Burma claims that the RSO are active in the area and said it would share information with Bangladesh to help stop its armed operations.

"Regarding the activity of RSO insurgents based out of Bangladesh territory who are disrupting tranquillity along the border, Bangladesh officials have agreed for Burma to provide them with information regarding the group," said Zaw Win.

The two sides agreed to set up a border liaison office to curb cross-border crime, and to educate people living in the border area about the demarcation.

In a show of friendship, the two sides will also conduct goodwill visits.

‘We are ashamed of ourselves,’ says monk who helped raid Mahasantisukha

Posted: 13 Jun 2014 02:30 AM PDT

A Buddhist monk who assisted the Sangha Maha Nayaka Committee during its raid on the Mahasantisukha Monastery in Rangoon late on Tuesday, has come forward to say he was tricked into participating by the committee and was ashamed to have been involved.

Some 60 disciplinary monks from monasteries across Rangoon were summoned by the Sangha Maha Nayaka Committee, popularly known as the "Mahana" – the highest office of Buddhist monks in the country – to take part in the raid at the monastery, which is the subject of an ongoing land ownership dispute between the Sangha committee and a revered abbot, Penang Sayadaw.

Video and photographic footage of the senior monks wielding walkie-talkies and coordinating the raid with government officials were circulated in the media. During the late-night operation, which also involved riot police, five monks and 32 laypersons were arrested. The forceful action against monks drew much condemnation from Internet users across Burma.

Film actress Hla Hla Moe, a long-time supporter of Penang Sayadaw, voiced outrage at the raid on the monastery's monks and staff. "I cannot comprehend why the Religious Affairs Ministry and the Sangha Maha Nayaka have resorted to force instead of helping and protecting the monastic community," she said on Wednesday. "Watching them rounding up Buddhist monks as if they were fugitive thugs, it was all too much for my eyes!"

On Friday, a disciplinary monk from another Rangoon monastery told DVB on condition of anonymity that he and other monks had been lied to by the senior monk of the Rangoon Division's Mahana who told them the monastery was being occupied by "elements from across the border" who may be armed.

"The Mahana summoned monks from 12 townships in Rangoon to the divisional committee office around 8pm – there were about 300 monks in total including Mahana monks brought in on six express buses," he said. "We were read instructions from the national head monk which implied that Penang Sayadaw was inside the monastery.

"We really were not really sure what was going on, but went along to the scene. The officials said the 'occupiers' might be armed with sharp weapons, but when we arrived at Mahasantisukha Monastery all we found was a handful of peaceful monks."

He said that the five resident monks from Mahasantisukha were then taken to the National Mahana office in Kaba-aye Township and ordered to disrobe. He added that the secretary of the township's Mahana pleaded with the senior monks to reconsider this order but his words were ignored.

"We are ashamed of ourselves," said the disciplinary monk, "but we handled the situation delicately so that no one was harmed."

FDA advises using only reputable beauty products

Posted: 13 Jun 2014 01:05 AM PDT

Burma's Food and Drug Administration (FDA) advised consumers to use only reputable foreign-made cosmetics because not all beauty products in an unregulated market have been tested.

A wide array of beauty products — some made in Burma and most imported from China and Thailand — are available to Burmese consumers. But FDA director-general Khin Chit told DVB that her agency is unable to test all the available products due to a lack of staff.

She added that the FDA has no power to control the sale of untested cosmetic products that are brought into the market with official import licenses.

Dr. Thazin Yi Hlaing, deputy director of the FDA's Cosmetics and Drugs department, said that the administration recently started testing skin-whitening beauty products. She advised consumers to check labels on anything they buy and to choose only the products that meet international standards.

"Before buying a product, consumers must check if they meet the labelling requirements and if there are ingredients in it that they are allergic to," said Dr Thazin Yi Hlaing, adding that cosmetic products do not require registration in order to be sold.

"A company will let us know when they start selling a certain cosmetic product in the market and we will inform them if we find something unsuitable in their products so that they can take it back off the shelves," she said.

In March this year, the FDA announced the names of nine Thai cosmetics brands that were found to be containing chemicals unsafe to use.

Mandalay farmers begin ‘plough protest’ on 3,000 acres

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 11:24 PM PDT

Some 800 farmers in Mandalay Division began ploughing more than 3,000 acres of farmland last week as a protest for its return since it was allegedly confiscated by the then ruling military government about 40 years ago.

Villagers in Sintgu Township's Nyaungwan village said that more than 3,000 acres of their land was confiscated in the 1970s by the Burmese army under the control of former dictator Gen. Ne Win. After President Thein Sein's government came into power in 2011, the villagers reignited their campaign by sending letters to the authorities to try to negotiate the return of the farmland. They say their letters have been repeatedly ignored.

On 6 June, the villagers began a "plough protest" – they started ploughing and cultivating the fallow farmland as a sign to the authorities that they are the original and rightful owners.

Speaking to DVB on Wednesday, Nyaungwan resident Sein Htay said, "We began ploughing the land with 80 pairs of cattle.  We've been at it for six days now.

"We also erected 'No Trespassing' signs in the area to indicate that we own this land."

He said that the villagers were demanding the returned of all 3,062.43 acres of confiscated farmland.

In neighbouring Sagaing Divison's Kantbalu, a similar situation is playing out as villagers in that area launched a "plough protest" campaign too, calling for the return of their land.

This type of demonstration is happening with increasing frequency throughout Burma since President Thein Sein's government came into power, highlighting the prevalent practice of land grabs during the decades of military rule.

 

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Authorities Charge Monks in Dispute With Govt-Backed Clergy

Posted: 13 Jun 2014 05:51 AM PDT

Myanmar Buddhism,

Monks look on Tuesday night as the State Sangha organized a raid to remove U Pyinnya Wuntha's followers from Maha Thanti Thukha Buddhist monastery in Rangoon. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — Authorities in Rangoon's Tamwe Township charged five Buddhist monks with religious offenses on Friday after they became embroiled in a dispute with the government-backed Buddhist clergy over the ownership of a large Rangoon monastery.

The monks were reportedly disrobed and sent to Insein Prison to await their trial, which could result in a prison sentence.

"It's true, we brought them to the court, but I don't' want to say any more [about this case]," Ye Myo Hein, a police officer involved in the case, said when asked whether the monks had been charged with religious offenses.

Burma's Penal Code Article 295 to 298 carries provisions that set punishments for acts that insult religious feelings and beliefs, or disturb places of religious worship and assembly. The charges carry fines and prison terms of between one and two years.

U Pamaukkha, a monk who went to the trial at Tamwe Township Court, said, "They were charged with offending religion by the court.

"Five monks, including U Ottara, were forced to change their robes and they were sent to Insein Prison."

The five were part of a group of seven monks and 32 laymen who were evicted from Rangoon's Maha Thanti Thukha Buddhist monastery on Tuesday by the government-backed Buddhist clergy, the Sangha Maha Nayaka, and subsequently apprehended. The laymen and two monks were later released.

They are followers of Penang Sayadaw U Pyinnya Wuntha, an 86-year-old abbot who has been involved in a dispute with the State Sangha over the ownership of the monastery since the early 2000s. The Ministry of Religious Affairs has backed the State Sangha in the case and supported the Tuesday raid.

Burma's former military regime built the large monastery in the late 1990s at a cost of about US$8 million and put U Pyinnya Wuntha in charge, presenting him with legal ownership documents.

But in 2002, after U Pyinnya Wuntha went on a visit abroad, the government claimed it found evidence of corruption at the monastery and it granted control over the building to the State Sangha.

Most of U Pyinnya Wuntha's followers were forced to leave but a small group was allowed to stay; these last followers were evicted and apprehended by the State Sangha on Tuesday night.

U Pyinnya Wuntha condemned the raid in a phone call from Japan Thursday and claimed he had full ownership over the monastery.

Win Htein, who is a lawyer and a lawmaker in Rangoon Division's legislature, said it was uncommon for authorities to charge monks under criminal law, as the clergy has its own rules and a special office to resolve disputes between monks.

He said police had failed to give prior warning of the raid, adding that it remains unclear on what grounds the five monks were being charged for offending religion. "There is a special office and a rules handbook for monks when there is a dispute. By bringing monks to a civilian court, police ignore these laws," said Win Htein.

The open dispute between Buddhist monks and the unusual actions by authorities have fascinated Burma's predominantly Buddhist public, which deeply revers the clergymen.

U Wirathu, the nationalist monk who is the public figurehead of the 969 movement that has been spreading anti-Islamic messages throughout Burma, has sought to publicly weigh in on the case.

He said he supported the evicted the monks. "They stayed at their own monastery. They were innocent. By putting innocent monks in prison, [the government] will get punishment from all monks in the country," Wirathu said.

The post Authorities Charge Monks in Dispute With Govt-Backed Clergy appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

Burma Teachers Group Balks at Performance-Based Transfer Scheme

Posted: 13 Jun 2014 05:47 AM PDT

university transfer orders

The road leading to the Convocation Hall at Rangoon University is seen in 2013. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — The Myanmar Teachers' Federation has said it "strongly condemns" the Education Ministry's new approach to handling transfer orders for Burma's university educators, which will see their postings determined by peer-based performance evaluations.

The Education Ministry recently issued details of a new procedure to rate the performance of teachers beginning this academic year, with the announcement communicated to rectors at Burma's universities. Educators' performance ratings will be based on an evaluation of 10 different factors and will be carried out by departmental colleagues.

The evaluations will be used to determine university educators' promotions and transfer orders. Across Burma, university educators are rotated every one to three years, based on a combination of need and the requests of the educators. Because the nation's more remote campuses are generally less desirable, the system sought to incentivize far-flung postings by tying promotions and pay raises to service in isolated areas.

Previously, transfer orders and promotions were determined largely by tenure, with longer-serving classroom educators given priority in the event that multiple requests were made for a given teaching position. Now, competing requests will be resolved via the peer-based performance evaluations.

Zaw Myo Hlaing, deputy chairman of the Myanmar Teachers' Federation, said that among other complaints, the MTF considered the evaluations to be a poor gauge of the effectiveness of education professionals.

"The evaluation form includes 10 points. The questions look like questions you would ask of an ordinary civil servant but do not have relevance to university teachers," he told The Irrawaddy.

"The [sample] questions are like, 'Whether [the teacher] is willingly performing their duties,' 'Whether [the teacher] has good communication with their colleagues," said Zaw Myo Hlaing, who is also an assistant lecturer at Dagon University in Rangoon.

The MTF said additionally, the new system could sow ill will among teaching colleagues.

"Some factors can incite enmity among teachers and divide them. The evaluations are also not related to the nature of teachers' work," the statement said.

The federation also criticized the evaluation system as biased, with classroom-based university educators being put under the microscope while senior administrative personnel like rectors and directors general escaped scrutiny.

The new system "fails to conduct evaluations on positions that need rating," the MTF statement said. "The practice of evaluating only lower positions for ordinary education staff shows that the Education Ministry lacks goodwill and is not sincere toward teachers and the whole education sector, thus the Myanmar Teachers' Federation strongly condemns the Education Ministry's administrative change."

The MTF also called on the ministry to issue transfer orders as soon as possible for affected teachers, some of whom have already begun teaching for the year but could receive transfer orders at any point.

Transfer orders are normally received in November of the preceding academic year but have not yet been issued this year, with the ministry blaming the death of former Education Minister Mya Aye for the delay. Mya Aye died in December 2013 and his successor, Khin San Yi, was not appointed until February.

The post Burma Teachers Group Balks at Performance-Based Transfer Scheme appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

Photo of the Week (13, 06, 2014)

Posted: 13 Jun 2014 05:44 AM PDT

Burma’s Upper House Votes to Change Electoral System

Posted: 13 Jun 2014 05:27 AM PDT

 

A session of the Upper House of Parliament in Naypyidaw. (Photo: The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — Burma's Upper House of Parliament has voted to adopt a proportional representation (PR) system for the nomination of Upper House lawmakers in 2015.

One hundred and seventeen lawmakers, a majority in the Upper House, voted on Wednesday to switch from the first-past-the-post (FPTP) system, which benefits dominant parties, to a PR system, which tends to benefit smaller parties. Eighty-five lawmakers, mostly from the military, the National League for Democracy (NLD) and ethnic minority parties, voted against the change.

After approving the decision, the Union Election Commission will work with Upper House lawmakers to draft regulations and bylaws for the new electoral system. The Lower House will not be affected by the Upper House's vote, but will likely discuss next week the possibility of also adopting the new electoral system in 2015.

Under the current FPTP system, the winning lawmaker in each constituency wins a seat in Parliament. Under a PR system, the number of seats won by a party is proportionate to the number of votes received.

Military lawmakers oppose a PR system, as does the NLD, the country's biggest opposition party, which would likely see major gains during the 2015 election under a FPTP system. The ruling Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP), expecting losses to the NLD, supports the PR system, as does the National Democratic Force (NDF), a small party.

The Upper House has formed a 42-member commission to consider which PR system will be most appropriate for its purposes in 2015. The commission is said to include both supporters and opponents of PR.

"We will cover a wide range of views in our consideration," said NDF lawmaker and commission member Khin Wine Kyi, who first made the proposal to adopt a PR system in the Upper House. She said the commission did not have a time frame for completing its task.

Ethnic political parties, which, under the current electoral system, would likely win seats in their constituencies of ethnic minority states, oppose the change to PR.

"We prefer the old FPTP system because our voters, also in the ethnic regions, are familiar with it, and that would mitigate the chances of any confusion," ethnic Mon lawmaker Banyar Aung Moe told The Irrawaddy, adding that many ethnic minority voters are not able to read Burmese, the language in which ballots are written.

In the Lower House, NDF lawmaker Aung Zin, who represents Rangoon's Pazuntaung Township, said he has been pushing for a PR system since last year because he believes it is best suited for a multi-party democracy.

"I think it will come up for discussion next week [in the Lower House]," he told The Irrawaddy.

"The public is not bad at voting," he added, in response to concerns among ethnic lawmakers that a PR system would confuse voters. He said the Burmese people had experience heading to the polls in the 1990 election, the results of which were annulled by the former regime, as well as the 2010 election and the 2012 by-election, which saw opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi elected to the legislature.

He also stressed the important role of the Union Election Commission in counting votes in 2015.

Ba Shein, an ethnic Arakanese lawmaker in the Lower House, expressed concerns about any change to the electoral system.

"As an ethnic parliamentarian, I would like to ask whether it is in accordance with the 2008 Constitution," he said, when asked about PR.

"We oppose the use of a PR system in these early years of our country's transition. It is unclear whether this system would really reflect minority rights."

The post Burma's Upper House Votes to Change Electoral System appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

Knee-Deep in Rangoon’s Rainy Season

Posted: 13 Jun 2014 04:32 AM PDT

flooding

Young men push a car through the floods at Thamine Junction, one of the busiest thoroughfares in Rangoon, on Thursday. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy

RANGOON — On Thursday morning, people in Rangoon awoke to cloudy skies. With rainy season officially here, they knew it would be a wet day, at best. More likely, it would be a day of flooding.

The city of more than 6 million people is prone to flooding whenever heavy rains fall, thanks to a poorly maintained drainage system. Even downtown, people are regularly forced to wade through flooded streets after only a few minutes of rain because the drains are blocked with trash.

Earlier this year, the government boasted that it had spent more than 12 billion kyats (US$12 million) to improve the drainage system. Scenes from recent rainy days suggest that the investment has not been effective.

Thursday's downpour lasted only a few hours, but it was enough to disrupt life in the Southeast Asian city, as most of the roads and railways connected to downtown were inundated with water. With traffic at a standstill, workers were late to the office and schools were temporarily closed in some areas.

After a few hours of rain, I found myself taking pictures at Thamine Junction, one of the busiest thoroughfares in Rangoon. Around me, public buses and cars were stopped dead in the deluge, while people were wading through knee-deep water. In houses, residents struggled to bucket out the invading rains.

Flooding at the junction did not subside until afternoon. Local people said the floods coincided with a rising tide at nearby Hlaing River, somewhat preventing the water levels from dropping.

Standing at a bus stop near the junction, a resident openly blamed the Yangon City Development Committee (YCDC) for failing to maintain the drainage system.

"The flooding is worse because the drainage system choked with trash. Water always overflows onto the road, even after a few minutes of rain. That shows they don't do their job well," he said.

The post Knee-Deep in Rangoon's Rainy Season appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

Suu Kyi’s Presidential Bid Not Dead Yet: NLD

Posted: 13 Jun 2014 03:54 AM PDT

constitution

Burma's opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi smiles before delivering the annual Godkin Lecture at the John F. Kennedy Jr. Forum at Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts, on Sept. 27, 2012. (Photo: Reuters)

MANDALAY — There is still hope for opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi to become president, her National League for Democracy (NLD) party says, after a parliamentary committee said it would not endorse amendments to a constitutional article that currently blocks her from the post.

The Constitutional Amendment Implementation Committee, tasked with making recommendations to Parliament before lawmakers vote on amendments, says it believes there should be no change to Article 59(F), which bars Suu Kyi from Burma's top post.

But lawmakers are not bound to follow the committee's recommendations, meaning that Suu Kyi's presidential bid is not dead yet.

"According to law, Parliament has to make a decision about this amendment, with votes from the parliamentarians," party spokesman Nyan Win told The Irrawaddy.

"Since the decision [not to endorse an amendment] was made only by the committee, it is too early for us to comment. We need to wait and see the decision of the Parliament and the parliamentarians."

On June 6, only five members of the 31-member Constitutional Amendment Implementation Committee voted to endorse changes to Article 59(f), according to a committee member from the ruling Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP).

The committee comprises seven unelected military lawmakers, 15 USDP lawmakers, two NLD lawmakers and eight lawmakers from other political parties.

Article 59(F) is controversial because it states that a president cannot have a spouse or children who are foreign nationals. Suu Kyi's two sons from her marriage to the late scholar Michael Aris are British nationals.

The post Suu Kyi's Presidential Bid Not Dead Yet: NLD appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

Investment in Rice Milling Key to Boosting Export, Report Says

Posted: 13 Jun 2014 03:42 AM PDT

Myanmar rice, Myanmar agriculture

A farmer plants rice seedlings in a paddy field on the outskirts of Rangoon. (Photo: Reuters)

RANGOON — A new World Bank report said Burma can greatly increase its agricultural exports if it can improve the quality of rice through investments in rice mills, while it should also reduce transport costs and formulate policies to support rice export and agricultural production.

Burma's reformist government aims to improve agricultural productivity and rice exports, and it has set a goal of exporting 4 million metric tons of rice by 2020. The report, titled "Capitalizing on Rice Export Opportunities", said that since reforms began in 2011 rice exports have significantly increased, but in the past two years export volumes levelled off at about 1.3 million tons annually.

It said much of the rice produced in Burma is of low quality and unfit for export to high-value markets such as the European Union, where Burmese products are exempt from import tariffs under the Generalized Scheme of Preferences, which grants least developed countries preferential market access.

"The current rice export strategy favors the production of low quality rice, which is largely sold to Africa and China. Consequently, farmers have earned minimal profits and agribusinesses have skipped necessary investments," a World Bank press release said. "The situation is worsening as the global demand for low quality broken rice is shrinking."

Burma's agriculture sector is the country's largest employer and 70 percent of all Burmese live in rural areas, but under the previous military regime the sector saw little improvement in agricultural productivity, while rice exports fell sharply compared to the 1960s.

Paddy yields in Burma are among the lowest in Southeast Asia at 2.5 metric tons per hectare and most rice mills used outdated machinery that produces rice with a high percentage of broken grains, making it unsuitable for foreign export markets, according to the World Bank.

"The milling sector operates with obsolete processing units that causes about 15-20 percent losses in quality and quantity during the milling," it said, adding that the government should take measures to attract foreign investment to the rice milling sector so that it can upgrade its machinery and produce better quality rice for export.

The report said the government should also take steps to make commercial loans more easily available to rice millers, who need capital to buy up paddy stocks for milling.

"A more efficient milling sector would give strong incentives to kick-start farm productivity growth as illustrated by the recent experience in Cambodia, but investments in public goods will be the key to maintain that growth over the long run," the report.

Other short term measures include establishing a predictable trade policy and lowering port charges and reducing export procedure costs. "Yangon Port, the main export gate, is small, outdated and with limited capacity during monsoons. The export procedure costs are some of the highest in the region," the report added.

To improve long-term rice production the World Bank said Burma's government should take steps such as improving water management, engaging farmers into decision-making, providing land tenure security and making investments in rural roads that connect farms to markets.

Soe Tun, general secretary of the Myanmar Rice Exporters Association, shared the conclusion of the World Bank report and he told The Irrawaddy in a recent interview that total rice exports in 2013-2014 had in fact dipped to 1.2 million tons, down from 1.47 million tons the year before.

According to the association, about 60 percent of exported rice goes to China and another large share is sent to South Africa, while small quantities of high-quality rice were shipped to the EU and Japan, with the latter receiving about 5,000 tons of Burmese rice last year.

Upgrading the country's rice mills, Soe Tun said, would be a key step towards boosting exports. "Our rice milling industry is quite old; more than 90 percent of total rice mills in Burma are of low quality… That's why we can export very little high-quality rice to Japan last year," he said.

Agriculture and rice milling have so far failed to attract foreign direct investment (FDI) required for improving rice production and processing.

"There is very little FDI in this agriculture sector. The investment rate in this sector is not increasing," Soe Tun said. "We need support from the government, and should work together with others in the private sector, government and other INGOs and local NGOs to improve the sector."

"We need to upgrade our cultivation system as well as the milling system. [And] we're facing a lack of infrastructure to export rice, for example, logistics fees are quite high, 25 percent of total [production costs are spent on logistics," said Soe Tun.

"Now, the transport costs of from Yangon to Muse [a Burma-China border crossing] is more than the transport cost from Yangon to Africa."

The post Investment in Rice Milling Key to Boosting Export, Report Says appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

India Rebuffs ‘Simplistic’ UN Criticism Over Sex Crimes

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 11:07 PM PDT

India rape, sexual violence

Demonstrators from All India Democratic Women’s Association (AIDWA) hold placards and shout slogans during a protest against the recent killings of two teenage girls, in New Delhi May 31, 2014. (Photo: Reuters)

GENEVA — India has rebuffed accusations by a U.N. investigator that sex crimes are rife in the world’s biggest democracy, calling her analysis "simplistic" and full of "sweeping generalizations".

India’s large northern state of Uttar Pradesh has seen a wave of violence and sex crimes, including the rape and murder of two girls aged 12 and 14, which stirred national outrage.

The United Nations special rapporteur on violence against women, Rashida Manjoo, said violence against women was systematic and continued "from womb to tomb" in a report submitted to the U.N. Human Rights Council in Geneva.

"According to numerous interlocutors, the physical, sexual and psychological abuse of women in the private sphere is widely tolerated by the State and the community," Manjoo wrote.

In its response, posted on the Council’s website on Thursday, India called that allegation "baseless". It said she had made "unsubstantiated yet sweeping generalizations".

"We do not agree with the labelling of ‘violence against women in India as systematic’," India said. "Such a sweeping remark smacks of a highly prejudiced state of mind."

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on Wednesday that respecting and protecting women should be a priority for the 1.25 billion people in India. "The government will have to act," Modi said, breaking his silence on the crime wave.

Manjoo, a South African law professor, said India should try to raise awareness of practices such as acid attacks against women who refuse a marriage proposal, so-called honor crimes where family members murder a woman because they believe she has dishonored them for example by opposing an arranged marriage, as well as executions of women branded as "witches".

Her report ranged from decrying degrading tests used on rape victims to urging India to define marital rape as a criminal offence and to repeal a law that criminalized consensual same-sex behavior.

On honor killings, the government said it gave "due consideration" to an Indian Law Commission report that had suggested a legal framework to tackle the practice.

It said "witch-hunts" were not a national phenomenon and complaints were always investigated. It said Manjoo should have informed the government if she knew of specific cases where there had been a complaint but no investigation.

India’s response to Manjoo’s report listed 16 allegations that it said were not backed up by facts.

The examples it gave included her claim that sexual violence was widespread across the country, that members of the security forces had committed mass rapes, that trafficking of women and girls to and from India was widespread, and that police and officials discriminated against people from certain castes.

The post India Rebuffs 'Simplistic' UN Criticism Over Sex Crimes appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

Ferry Family Boss Eludes South Korea’s Biggest and Most Bizarre Manhunt

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 10:56 PM PDT

South Korea manhunt

A South Korea navy officer gives a briefing about a rescue operation to the family members of missing passengers onboard the sunken passenger ship Sewol in the port city of Jindo on April 25, 2014. (Photo: Reuters / Kim Kyung-Hoon)

SEOUL — South Korea's biggest and most bizarre manhunt, linked to a ferry disaster in which hundreds drowned, has come full circle at the compound of a sect known for its organic ice cream as police on Thursday used earth movers to search for tunnels.

Police have raided the grounds of the Evangelical Baptist Church in Anseong, a two-hour drive south of Seoul, twice as they try to flush out church co-founder Yoo Byung-un, 73, South Korea's most wanted man since the Sewol ferry sank in April killing more than 300 people, mostly children from the same school.

But, so far, Yoo, a businessman and photographer who was once jailed for fraud, has eluded capture in a case that has become an embarrassment for authorities already under pressure for their handling of the disaster.

Yoo is wanted on charges of embezzlement, negligence and tax evasion stemming from a web of business holdings centered on I-One-I, an investment vehicle owned by his sons that ran the shipping company, Chonghaejin Marine.

Chonghaejin owned the Sewol, which sank off the southwest coast on April 16 on a routine journey from Incheon on the mainland to the southern holiday island of Jeju.

Of the 476 passengers and crew on board, 339 were children and teachers from the same school. Only 172 people were rescued and the remainder are all presumed to have drowned.

The hunt for Yoo, who once held a photographic exhibition at the Louvre in Paris, has sent authorities chasing leads from the sect compound to remote towns in southwestern Jeolla province—and back again to the compound.

The latest raid began on Wednesday and involved 6,000 police and investigators. Besides Yoo and one son, prosecutors said they were looking for two middle-aged female sect members known as "mamas" accused of helping him escape. Dogs roamed the compound sniffing for scent from Yoo's belongings.

Last month, police arrested a man on suspicion that he delivered organic food grown and marketed by the church to Yoo, as well as one of his drivers. Some church members handed out ice cream to police and journalists on Wednesday. Others threatened to fight police.

One said church members would protect Yoo.

"I don't know where he is, but he won't turn up until everything is clear about why the ferry sank," a man who said he had been a sect member for 30 years, told Reuters outside the compound.

"I respect him as a mentor. He is our fellow believer and we will protect him."

Authorities have offered a half-million-dollar reward for Yoo, the maximum allowed for an individual in a criminal case, and quietly enlisted the military, a sensitive subject in a country where memories remain vivid of troops mobilized to suppress democracy movements from the 1960s to the 1980s.

Police said they believe Yoo and one son are still in the country. Another son is based in the United States and his whereabouts could not be established by Reuters.

"We haven't received information that they have stowed away or left for somewhere. We believe we can capture Yoo and his son," Lee Sang-won, commissioner of the Incheon Metropolitan Police Agency, said.

Yoo's daughter, Yoo Som-Na, has been held in France since May 28 after Interpol called for her arrest "for fraud and embezzlement." She was denied bail on Wednesday.

There have been no charges against Yoo directly related to the ferry disaster, although prosecutors are trying to establish a link between the financial charges and the sinking.

Fifteen members of the ferry's crew are on trial on charges ranging from homicide to negligence after they were caught on video abandoning ship as the children stayed put in their cabins.

Enlisting the military's help in the hunt shows just how desperate the government is to catch Yoo and satisfy an outraged public's demand for accountability.

"Basically in the south and west, the units based there have been looking out for people illegally entering, especially at night," Defense Ministry spokesman Kim Min-seok told a news briefing. "Related to that, there's a chance Yoo Byung-un may try to secretly flee, so guard duties are focused a little more on people being smuggled out."

Fatigue has become a factor as the manhunt drags on, with about a dozen investigators photographed sprawled out napping in a gym inside the Anseong compound during Wednesday's raid.

President Park Geun-hye this week said "it made no sense" that such a massive search operation had come up empty, and some sect members suggested the raid was staged to placate a bloodthirsty public.

Yu Chang-seon, an independent political commentator, said the search was excessive, expressing a minority view in a country still in mourning.

"Considering the charges against Yoo, this is basically a financial case," he said. "We should be holding him responsible to some degree, but the scale of the whole thing is unprecedented."

The post Ferry Family Boss Eludes South Korea's Biggest and Most Bizarre Manhunt appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

Neymar Leads Brazil to 3-1 Win Over Croatia

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 10:19 PM PDT

Brazil

Brazil's Neymar celebrates his goal against Croatia during their 2014 World Cup opening match at the Corinthians arena in Sao Paulo on Thursday. (Photo: Reuters)

SAO PAULO — Neymar gave Brazil a winning start to its home World Cup, scoring twice to lead the host nation to an unconvincing 3-1 victory over Croatia in the opening game on Thursday.

In his 50th match with Brazil, the 22-year-old forward scored a goal in each half to help the hosts survive an early scare and escape disaster in front of a packed Itaquerao Stadium after Croatia had taken an early lead.

Marcelo found his own net while trying to clear a low cross by Ivica Olic in the 11th minute, but Neymar then showed why the nation's high hopes are all pinned on him.

He equalized in the 29th minute, clearing a defender in midfield before making a run toward the edge of the area and firing a perfectly placed low shot that went in off the post.

The game turned on a controversial penalty awarded by Japanese referee Yuichi Nishimura in the 71st minute when striker Fred went down inside the area under minimal contact from defender Dejan Lovren.

Neymar scored from the spot for his 33rd goal with Brazil. The Barcelona star got a standing ovation when he was substituted near the end of the match.

"It's important to start these tournaments with the right foot, with a victory," Neymar said. "I'm happy that I got to score, but the entire team deserves credit. We maintained our calm and showed we could battle back."

The Croatians were furious.

"If that was a penalty, we should be playing basketball. Those kinds of fouls are penalized there," Croatia coach Niko Kovac said.

"That is shameful, this is not a World Cup referee. He had one kind of criteria for them and another for us. The rules were not the same," Kovac said.

As Croatia searched desperately for an equalizer, Oscar added to the lead in the first minute of injury time with a toe poke from just outside the penalty area.

Croatia had a few good chances toward the end and had a goal disallowed in the 83rd after the referee ruled Olic had fouled Brazil goalkeeper Julio Cesar.

The host nation hasn't lost the last nine times it played in the opening match. South Africa was held by Mexico to a 1-1 draw four years ago.

A draw would have been a huge disappointment for Brazil, which had won its opening match the last eight times. The five-time champion entered the home tournament having won 15 of its last 16 games, including five in last year's Confederations Cup, the warm-up tournament it won. The team hadn't been held to a draw in the opener since a 1-1 result against Sweden in the 1978 World Cup in Argentina.

"The team didn't give up," Brazil defender David Luiz said "We knew it would be hard but we played well and got that first goal and then the victory."

The result kept Croatia without a win in its last five World Cup matches. Its last triumph was a 2-1 win over Italy in 2002. The Croats didn't play in South Africa four years ago.

The tournament finally got underway as planned after months of talk about the preparation problems that plagued Brazil since it was picked as host seven years ago.

The troubled Itaquerao, which wasn't fully finished for the opener, held up without major setbacks to fans or the match itself, although part of the lights atop the pitch went out a few times for brief periods in the first half.

Despite the support from most of the more than 62,100 fans in attendance, Brazil got off to a slow start and allowed Croatia to threaten early. It opened the scoring with one of its first chances as Marcelo failed to clear Olic's cross. The ball was slightly redirected by striker Nikica Jelavic before the Brazilian defender touched it backward into the goal.

"I stayed calm because if I let myself get down I would have hurt the team," Marcelo said. "It's not the first time that this has happened, so you have to stay relaxed to help the team."

The penalty kick was awarded when Fred appeared to be tugged inside the area by Lovren. The Croats insisted Fred wasn't touched and at least five Croatian players swarmed around Nishimura of Japan to protest.

Neymar converted his shot from the spot even though Croatia goalkeeper Stipe Pletikosa touched the ball and nearly made the save.

Neymar had received a yellow card in the 27th for elbowing Real Madrid playmaker Luka Modric.

The other Group A match will be played between Mexico and Cameroon in Natal on Friday.

The post Neymar Leads Brazil to 3-1 Win Over Croatia appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

Junta Engineers World Cup Coup for Thailand

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 10:15 PM PDT

World Cup

Singers Jennifer Lopez and Pitbull perform during the opening ceremony of the 2014 World Cup at the Corinthians arena in Sao Paulo on Thursday. (Photo: Reuters)

BANGKOK — The military junta that overthrew Thailand's elected government struck a blow for freedom Thursday—the freedom to watch soccer.

As part of its goal to "return happiness to the Thai people," the junta engineered a World Cup coup that will enable the country's many soccer fans to watch all of the tournament's 64 matches for free.

The move is the latest to highlight the irony of the junta's pursuit of happiness, as it tries to win support by embracing populist policies after kicking out an administration less than a month ago that it criticized for doing the same thing.

"We hope that every Thai will receive happiness from viewing the 2014 World Cup games. Please watch and enjoy, all of you," said Lt. Gen. Chatudom Titthasiri, president of the army's Channel 5 television station.

The generals stepped in Wednesday by asking regulatory officials to find a way to deliver the World Cup to the masses. The intervention came after the telecom regulator lost its second court case seeking to have RS International Broadcasting air the matches on free TV channels.

RS, the company holding the exclusive broadcast rights, had planned to allow just 22 games to be broadcast for free. Viewing the remainder of the matches would have required fans to buy a 1,590 baht ($50) decoder box, a sum too pricey for many fans, especially in low-income rural areas.

On Thursday, the National Broadcasting and Telecommunications Commission held a news conference to announce it had struck a 427 million baht ($13 million) compensation deal with RS so the entire World Cup can be shown on free channels.

The tournament, which starts in the middle of the night Thailand time, will be broadcast on two military-run channels, in addition to a digital channel owned by RS.

The fee falls far short of the 766 million baht ($23 million) that RS had proposed to make up for the losses of its decoder boxes and licensing fees, the regulator said.

The company had initially threatened to black out the World Cup if it was forced to broadcast it for free. But its chief operating officer, Pornpan Techarungchaikul, tweeted a reaction to the deal that stayed on script with the theme of happiness, saying the company was "willing to cooperate" so all Thais could watch the event for free.

The junta that seized power May 22 has curbed freedom of expression, banned political assembly of more than five people, and has no plans to restore civilian rule any time soon. It has also summoned and temporarily detained hundreds of activists, politicians, academics and journalists who have been warned not to criticize the coup.

On Thursday, a military court extended the detention of prominent activist Sombat Boonngam-anong for an additional 12 days. Under martial law, Sombat could face up to 14 years in prison on possible charges of inciting unrest, violating cyber laws and defying the junta's orders. Sombat had spearheaded an online campaign calling for people to raise a three-finger salute borrowed from "The Hunger Games" to show opposition to the coup.

Last month's coup ousted the civilian government of ex-Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra, which had faced months of street protests that left dozens dead and the government paralyzed. The junta said it acted to restore order.

The military government now says that new elections will take at least a year, after political reforms occur. In the meantime, it has launched an official campaign to bring back happiness, something it says the divided nation desperately needs.

The campaign has involved weekly free concerts that offer free food and free haircuts. Authorities have announced that this week's concert will include free flu shots and entertainment including dog shows.

On Sunday, the junta is offering free admission nationwide to cinemas screening the latest installment of a popular Thai movie, "The Legend of King Naresuan 5," a nationalistic, historic epic.

While some soccer fans were bound to cheer the junta for its World Cup freebie, not all were pleased.

"This is not the way to create sustainable happiness," said Manchester United fan Paisarn Ruchisawatwong, who is rooting for the Brazil national team. "The World Cup comes and goes, but what happens next? Will the economy be good? Will Thais stop fighting? You can't just sweep our problems under the carpet by giving us free soccer matches."

For those who don't follow the sport, it seemed a high price to pay.

"I don't watch soccer, so I disagree with spending millions of baht to let everyone watch the World Cup for free," said Supanan Thaodai, a 27-year-old freelance art director in Bangkok. "The money should be spent on things that benefit everyone."

The post Junta Engineers World Cup Coup for Thailand appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

National News

National News


Govt, Sangha committee under fire for night raid

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 01:37 PM PDT

The State Sangha Maha Nayaka Committee and Ministry of Religious Affairs have come under fierce criticism for a nighttime raid on a monastery at the centre of a high-profile land dispute.

US critical of interfaith marriage law

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 01:37 PM PDT

The United States has voiced concerns to Myanmar on proposed restrictions on interfaith marriage amid growing worries about actions that target minority Muslims.

Suu Kyi advises activists report threats to police

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 01:36 PM PDT

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi has urged human rights activists who have received death threats for criticising controversial new religious laws to go to police.

Inle under threat

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 01:27 PM PDT

Inle Lake is drying up, and could disappear within the next century if stronger measures are not taken to preserve it, experts warn.

Many townships yet to report on constituency funding expenditure

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 12:43 PM PDT

Seventy-three townships are yet to report on how they spent more than US$100,000 each in government funds under a constituency funding program introduced by MPs, according to the Pyidaungsu Hluttaw Office.

Parliament forms commission to probe voting system

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 12:41 PM PDT

Amyotha Hluttaw speaker U Khin Aung Myint has formed a commission to investigate the possibility of switching to a proportional voting system, following three days of vigorous debate among MPs.

Voting system debate rises from the grave

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 12:40 PM PDT

It appeared dead and buried, but the debate over proportional representation has been revived – and could precipitate conflict between opposition parties.

Hundreds of households to get water hookup

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 12:22 PM PDT

Yangon City Development Committee says hundreds of households in the most water-deficient wards of Dala township will finally be connected to piped water in July.

Greater cooperation vowed after border clashes

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 05:33 AM PDT

Myanmar and Bangladeshi authorities have vowed to strengthen border security and combat "illegal armed groups and criminals" following clashes on their shared frontier that Dhaka said left one of its soldiers dead.

Thursday, June 12, 2014

Democratic Voice of Burma

Democratic Voice of Burma


Burma braces for late-night football fever

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 05:19 AM PDT

After four long years of anticipation, Burmese sports fans are set for a month-long football festival as the World Cup kicks off in Brazil late on Thursday night or– let's face it – early Friday morning.

A total of 64 matches will be held from 12 June to 13 July, but with Brazil lying nine and a half hours behind Burmese time, almost all games are scheduled to be televised live in the middle of the night.

Nonetheless, many fans say they will stay up and watch the games – while employers worry about bleary-eyed workers and an increase in sick days during the competition.

The World Cup this year will only be available on the SkyNet channel, a satellite TV operator, which has secured a contract with FIFA, the world football governing body, to be sole broadcaster in Burma for the tournament.

Those without access to SkyNet are left frustrated, and many will be banking on Thai TV broadcasts or streaming matches from the Internet.

Sithu Aung Myint, a well-known columnist, says SkyNet is violating their agreement with FIFA.

"I have been digging into this, and I'm discovering more and more dirt," he told DVB. "SkyNet did not tell the public how they acquired the broadcasting rights. Channels around the world who acquire rights from FIFA are obliged to broadcast 22 matches free. But because the SkyNet has no wish to do so, they did not even mention this to viewers – they just flagrantly sell cable boxes, and of course they are making a lot of profit."

DVB's Mandalay-based reporter Kyaw Zay said residents in the city will head to regular screening venues such as restaurants which show the English Premier League throughout the season.

"I am guessing that most fans in Mandalay will go to restaurants and venues with big screens," he said. "Most people like to watch the games, drink, gamble and cheer rather than stay at home."

Myo Hlaing Win, a former striker for the national team, said that Rangoon's teashops will always be the favourite gathering spots for football aficionados.

"You don't get the same feeling watching at home. I guess most people are planning to go to the teashops and restaurants that have SkyNet," he said. "There are venues with two or three big screens so that everyone can see."

Soccer fan Pho Thar from Naypyidaw echoed the impression that most night-owl soccer buffs will head for their regular restaurants and sports bars.

"Watching at home makes people sleepy – it's more exciting if a group of friends is watching together," he said.

But Thura Tin Oo, the patron and founder of the National League for Democracy, said he for one won't be watching many matches this year.

"I was planning to go to sleep early so I could get up early and catch the games, but the schedule is just too awkward," he told DVB. "I am 88 years of age, and I need to be careful. But as a football fan, I would really want to watch the games as the World Cup comes around only once every four years and it's the most intense football competition. I guess I might force myself to get up for some crucial matches."

Meanwhile in Thailand, where thousands of Burmese migrants work, getting out to bars and restaurants for the games might be a tricky proposition as the country is currently under martial law and a midnight curfew.

But, for a handful of more fortunate Burmese fans, there will be no need to set alarm clocks. At least 20 have bought full tour packages to fly to Brazil for the month and can watch the games live at the stadiums. Win Honey, operations manager at Gandawin Shwe Bagan tour company, said his firm arranged tickets, flights and accommodation for about 20 diehard fans. The cost? US$12,000 each.

Govt to provide housing to the homeless by end of 2015, minister says

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 03:44 AM PDT

The Burmese government is drafting plans to provide housing for the homeless in more than 50 towns and cities across the country by the end of 2015 in order to resolve the problem of squatters and homelessness, Deputy Minister of Construction Soe Tint said on Wednesday during a session in the parliament's lower house.

According to Pe Than, a member of parliament in the lower house, Soe Tint said that the new urban housing projects are being planned for 56 cities.

"The deputy minister said that the government is looking to resolve homeless issues by drawing up housing plans in 56 cities across the country, with an aim of implementing them before the end of 2015, " Pe Than said, adding that providing homes will not solve this urban problem, but that job opportunities would have to be created as well.

"For the time being, the government will deal with the situation by erecting low-cost housing projects in the cities."

Currently, the government is providing low-cost homes for poor families in Rangoon and Mandalay at around 20 million kyat per apartment, a little over US$20,000. However, this cost is still too high for many.

As demand for land has surged in recent years following Burma's economic reform, rent and home prices have soar in cities, making it more difficult for the under-privileged to find housing. Real estate agents in Rangoon estimated that rent values rose by 25 percent in 2013, while sales prices have more than doubled in certain neighbourhoods. As a result, those priced out of their homes have set up shantytowns around Rangoon.

Hla Maung, an economist in Rangoon, said that many people move from rural areas to the city in order to find better jobs, and the government needs to plan for housing projects near these potential job opportunity sites.

"In their hopes to find better jobs, many from the rural population moved to the cities and set up homes on vacant spots," Hla Maung said. "If we really want to solve the squatter issue, we should also consider their livelihoods, and factors such as the distance from their homes to their workplaces."

Faith Conversion Law should be ‘scrapped’, say activists

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 02:32 AM PDT

Following the Burmese government's invitation for public opinion on a proposed Religious Conversion Law, 81 organisations from Burma and elsewhere have recommended that it be completely discarded.

In a joint statement published on Thursday, the alliance said the legislation violates the Universal Declaration of Human Rights by granting authorities "sweeping powers" over choice of faith, and called for the Burmese government to "immediately scrap" the law on the grounds that it encroaches on rights and "appears to legitimize the views of those promoting hate-speech and inciting violence against Muslims and other minorities".

The proposed Religious Conversion Law is part of a package of bills tasked to a drafting committee in March, known collectively as the Race and Religious Protection bills. The bills were originally proposed to Burma's President Thein Sein in July 2013 by a coalition of nationalist monks affiliated with the government-appointed Maha Nayaka, or National Head Monks Committee.

The package comprises four laws that would impose new regulations on religious conversion, marriage, monogamy and childbearing. The Religious Conversion Law is the only part of the package that has yet been made public; state media published the draft in full on 27 May, soliciting public review and recommendations in the lead up to a parliamentary vote.

"The only positive aspect of this entire process has been the publication of the draft law and request for comments," said Phil Robertson, deputy Asia director for Human Rights Watch (HRW), "but we should not get fixated on an issue of procedure when the content of the proposed law is so bad."

Upon viewing the draft, international observers immediately called foul. Sam Zarifi, Asia Regional Director of the International Commission of Jurists, told DVB that while it's not rare for a nation to create laws requiring citizens to provide the government with details about their religion, "the draft text itself, to the extent it limits religious proselytisation and conversion, runs afoul of international standards."

The seven-chapter conversion bill would establish township-level "registration" boards and grant them powers to examine and approve religious conversions. The draft also states that "every person has the freedom to convert". But opponents argue that the bill creates excessive obstacles to religious choice; those wishing to change their religion must submit an application providing personal details such as family members' names and faiths, and a reason for conversion. The registration board would then interview the applicant to determine the sincerity of their faith and assess whether the conversion is voluntary.

Those suspected of either coercing someone to convert or applying "with the intent of insulting or destroying a religion"could face up to a two-year prison term, which the rights groups argue "[raises] the prospect of arbitrary arrest and detention for those wishing to convert from Theravada Buddhism – the faith of the majority in Burma/Myanmar – to a minority religion, or no religion at all."

Thursday's statement, released by the Chin Human Rights Organisation (CHRO) and endorsed by 80 other rights groups, claims that the "broad wording of this provision may effectively outlaw proselytizing in the country."

 "The broad wording of this provision may effectively outlaw proselytizing in the country."

While the law has been criticised as a thinly-veiled attempt to prevent Islamicisation in the context of two years of deadly ethno-religious conflict, the Conversion Law has also raised alarm for Burma's other religious minorities, notably Christians, many of whom reside in parts of the country that are either still in direct conflict or slowly resolving conflict with the central government.

In Chin, Kachin and Karen states, all of which have large Christian populations, to impose new restrictions on freedom of faith could "seriously undermine the peace process," said Rachel Fleming, advocacy director for CHRO. "There is a risk that people will view it simply as a continuation of the long-standing ‘Burmanisation’ policy practised under the previous military regime."

In Chin State, said Fleming, the Conversion Law is particularly threatening because of a clause leaving the definition of "influence" widely open to interpretation. It could, in effect, subject Chin missionaries, who have historically withstood severe religious persecution by the Burmese military, to a year in prison for doing their jobs. Hence, Fleming argued, "this law could result in an increase in the number of prisoners of conscience in Burma’s jails."

Other bills in the package have received similar scorn; in early May, a group of 97 civil society groups urged the government to abandon the proposed Marriage Law — often referred to as the Interfaith Marriage Act — on the grounds that it violates women's freedom of choice. HRW went so far as to call it "unconstitutional". A group of about 15 civil society leaders also met with Aung San Suu Kyi, who chairs the Rule of Law Committee, on Wednesday to register similar complaints.

In a Wednesday press briefing, a US State Department spokesperson said that approving the Marriage Law would be "inconsistent with the government's efforts to promote tolerance and respect for human rights," adding that, "more broadly, we continue to have serious concerns about other pending legislation that could have a detrimental effect on religious freedom."

Mahasantisukha monks, supporters will be charged, say religious dept officials

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 02:01 AM PDT

Buddhist monks and staff from the Mahasantisukha Monastery will be charged in accordance with the law, said the Ministry of Religious Affairs at a press conference in its Rangoon office near Kaba-aye Pagoda on Wednesday.

Officials confirmed that 32 laypersons had been released from detention following the Tuesday night raid on the monastery, which is at the centre of a land dispute between local abbot, Penang Sayadwa, and the Sangha Maha Nayaka Committee, the highest office of Buddhist monks in Burma.

According to the deputy-director of the State Department of Religious Affairs, attempts by the abbot and his supporters to claim ownership of the land are a contravention of Buddhist principles.

"Privatisation of religious property is in violation of the Vinayas [Buddhist code of discipline]," he said. "The government has now respectfully donated and transferred the monastery to the State Sangha Maha Nayaka Committee."

The officials did not elaborate on what charges they expected to be brought against the abbot's followers.

The ministry official said a number of security forces were deployed during the raid because of a rumour that a large group of monks inside the monastery were armed with swords and sticks, ready to fend off the officials.

The head of the Rangoon Division's Religious Affairs Department said that the raid on the monastery had been conducted late at night to avoid any possible conflict.

"Penang Sayadaw U Pannavamsa has no right to privately own the property as the government has already handed it over to the State Sangha Maha Nayaka Committee," he said.

According to state media, Religious Affairs officials maintained that the government "supervised" the monastery construction – some 8.5 billion kyat (US$8.5 million) – which had been collected from government departments and donors, as well as a 2-billion kyat loan from the Yangon City Development Committee Bank.

Supporters of Penang Sayadaw, also known as U Pannavamsa, claim that the land was originally donated to the revered abbot in the 1990s, and that he has documents to prove it.

In an exclusive interview with DVB from Japan on Wednesday, Penang Sayadaw rejected the Sangha Committee's claims, and said he built the Buddhist monastery "from scratch".

"In 1995, the year I was awarded the title of Agga Maha Pandita, I was allocated an empty plot of land by the government on which I built this 10-storey monastery from scratch, with the assistance of some architects from Singapore," he said.

"The centre was opened on 17 December 1999, and a blessing ceremony was conducted the following day, attended by [then ruler] Snr-Gen Than Shwe, Vice-Snr-Gen Maung Aye and military intelligence chief Khin Nyunt."

The abbot went on to say that the dispute over the property arose when he went abroad for a number of years due to a financial scandal involving the monastery's committee chairman.

"I reached out to the Sangha Maha Nayaka upon my return, expressing my gratitude to them for looking after the monastery while I was away," he said. "However, now that I was back, I asked them to allow me to return to the Mahasantisukha Monastery. They refused, claiming the property had been transferred to them in a blessing ceremony."

Penang Sayadaw said the matter dragged on for years, until eventually he enlisted the support of President Thein Sein last year to help him recover the holy site.

Prominent activist group 88 Generation Peace and Open Society (88GPOS) on Wednesday released a statement denouncing the raid at Mahasantisukha Buddhist Monastery by religious affairs officials.

"The incident, in a country where Buddhism is prevalent, was an ugly state of affairs, and we assume there was dishonest intent behind the forceful eviction as it was carried out while the abbot of the monastery was away on a foreign mission," the statement read. "We hereby denounce in the strongest terms the forceful eviction at the monastery by the State Sangha Maha Nayaka Committee and the Ministry of Religious Affairs instead of resolving the situation with compassion and wisdom."

88GPOS said it put the blame for the incident firmly on the shoulders of the Union government, the Rangoon divisional government and the Sangha Committee. The civic group warned that public protests could break out as a consequence of the eviction, and urged the government to find a peaceful solution to the situation.

Film actress Hla Hla Moe, a long-time supporter of Penang Sayadaw, voiced outrage at the raid on the monastery's monks and staff.

Speaking outside the Rangoon Ministry of Religious Affairs office on Wednesday, she said, "I cannot comprehend why the Religious Affairs Ministry and the Sangha Maha Nayaka have resorted to force instead of helping and protecting the monastic community.

"Watching them rounding up Buddhist monks as if they were fugitive thugs, it was all too much for my eyes!" she exclaimed.

Meanwhile on Thursday, concerns surfaced that one of the detained monks, Ven. U Uttara, was in fact a British passport holder, having lived in England while he was head of the Birmingham Buddhist Vihara.

Speaking to DVB on Thursday, a spokesperson for the British Embassy in Rangoon said, "We have received reports that a British subject has been arrested in Rangoon, and we are following up with the relevant authorities."

Thai police raid Burmese neighbourhood in Chiang Mai for illegal migrants

Posted: 12 Jun 2014 12:36 AM PDT

More than 100 Thai security police raided a Burmese migrant neighbourhood in Chiang Mai on Wednesday morning to detain undocumented migrant workers.

Located behind the Buddhist temple Wat Pa Pao in northern Chiang Mai, the predominantly Burmese neighbourhood has a dense population of migrant workers from Shan State. Police entered the neighbourhood at 6 am and went from door-to-door to look for undocumented migrant workers.

According to Sai Mong, an ethnic Shan man who owns a shop there, the security forces announced via loudspeakers before conducting the raid that residents should come out of their homes with their identification cards ready.

The search was completed at around 11 am, and the security forces detained a truck full of migrant workers. Sai Mong said the exact number of people detained was unclear.

Since the coup last week, Thai government TV channels announced that an "environmental cleansing" operation will be carried out in order to build a "pleasant" society. Supervised by Chiang Mai provincial deputy governor Chana Faengpiboon, this operation involves both the military and police forces, as well as 500 civilians.

Located in northern Thailand, Chiang Mai has been home for many years to thousands of Burmese migrants, the majority of whom are ethnic Shan, or Tai Yai, from Burma’s eastern Shan State across the border. Shans speak a language similar to the northern Thais; therefore they have been able to integrate relatively seamlessly into the society. While many have lived in Thailand for generations, more recent migrants are frequently found working for lower-than-minimum wages in the construction and agriculture sectors around the city.

Rights groups call for transparency in Kaladan Project

Posted: 11 Jun 2014 08:34 PM PDT

An alliance of civil society organisations on Wednesday urged the Burmese and Indian governments to be more transparent in the planning and construction of the controversial Kaladan Project, a combined highway and waterway project that will traverse Arakan and Chin states into India.

Proposed by the Indian government in 2008, the project will connect a deep-sea port in Sittwe to Mizoram State in northeast India via inland waterways and highways through two of Burma's poorest states, Arakan and Chin states. The objective is to create a more straightforward route for trade from the Kolkata seaport in eastern India.

The Kaladan Movement, a coalition of ethnic rights groups, believes that the US$214 million project – which is financed by India — will affect approximately one million people living along the Kaladan River, but very little information has been made public.

According to a statement released on Wednesday by the Kaladan Movement, the alliance submitted a "questionnaire" to Essar Projects Ltd, a Mumbai-based company overseeing the construction, and both governments, calling on them to provide details concerning the project's timeline and how it would affect ethnic communities in the area.

"Thus far, the Kaladan Project has been implemented without an adequate community consultation process, and with no efforts made to achieve the free, prior, informed consent of affected communities," the statement said, adding that it is important for the indigenous people living in the affected areas to be involved in the decision-making process.

Bawi Pi of the Chin Human Rights organization (CHRO) – a member of the Kaladan Movement – said in the statement that since the project broke ground four years ago, "no environmental impact assessments have ever been conducted for the project area in Burma, and no details regarding the route of the planned highway have been made public".

The statement also said that residents around the affected areas are most concerned about compensation for their land, as well as the environmental and social impacts of dredging in Arakan State – which has been known to exacerbate soil erosion and place villagers under threat if they are not prepared.

Sam Cartmell, project manager with CHRO, told DVB in an email that since the project is classified under "development assistance" from India, the implementation must follow international best practices.

He urged Essar and the two governments to publicly release detailed information, especially regarding the construction of the highway linking Paletwa in Chin State to the India-Burma border.

"[T]here are a number of concerns about the potential for land confiscation along the highway route," Cartmell said. "To date, local people have no information regarding the exact route of the highway, who will be building it or when construction will start."

Rohit Chawla, an Essar representative based in Rangoon, said the project was mildly delayed because of a series of riots in Sittwe between "the Rakhine [Arakan] people and the Bangladeshi people."

He also played down concerns of compensation, and referred these questions to the Burmese government.

"We are not concerned about the compensation given to the people affected by the project. It has been taken care of by the Myanmar [Burma] government personnel. This issue is taken up by them," Chawla told DVB. "We are only the contractor of the project."

He added the Essar Project has subcontracted construction out to "five to eight" local companies.

The deep-sea port in Sittwe is slated for completion by December 2014, said project director Anil Vishwakarma, while the construction of the highway from Paletwa to the India-Burma border should be completed by June 2015. He declined to provide further details.

 

Upper house votes for proportional representation

Posted: 11 Jun 2014 08:33 PM PDT

The upper house of Burma's Parliament has passed a proposal to recommend that the Union Election Commission (UEC) adopt a proportional representation (PR) voting system in future elections.

The proposal, which was the subject of debate in the upper house since Monday, was passed by standing vote – with 177 MPs in support, 85 against and three abstaining.

Khin Waing Kyi, upper house MP from the National Democratic Force party, who submitted the original proposal, said a commission will be formed to gauge different approaches in switch to a PR system from the currently employed first-past-the-post (FPTP) system.

"The upper house concluded – based on debate over the past three days –  to bring together members of the parliamentary Bill Commission with representatives of the Union Election Commission to study proportional representation and discuss approaches which could be adopted in this new system," said Khin Waing Kyi.

"The commission will then submit a report to parliament outlining its conclusions."

She noted that among the supporters of her proposal were military MPs.

The Nationalities Brotherhood Federation (NBF), an alliance of 15 ethnic parties, on Tuesday publicly voiced their objection to a PR system, asserting that the system will allow major parties – those with sufficient resources to run campaigns nationwide –to seize seats from smaller, local ethnic parties. It said it would organise public protests to prevent such an electoral system being employed.

Aye Maung, upper house MP and deputy-chairman of the Arakan National Party, said that an attempt to switch to this new system may face public opposition.

"We believe that now is an inappropriate time to submit this proposal – it's not fair to win by outnumbering smaller groups," he said.

Aung San Suu Kyi's National League for Democracy has also rejected the adoption of a PR system. However, the ruling Union Solidarity and Development Party, which has a majority in parliament, has thrown its support behind changing to PR.

The NDF originally submitted the PR proposal to the bicameral parliament last year via the UEC; however it was immediately rejected on the grounds that the approach was not in line with parliamentary procedures.

A similar proposal – to switch to the PR voting system – has also been submitted to the lower house and is scheduled to be discussed in parliament next week.

PR is designed to offer each party a proportional number of seats in parliament to the total number of votes its candidates receive. The alternative, an FPTP system, dictates that the winning candidate in each and every constituency wins that seat, and hence the parliament is ultimately made up of election winners, regardless of party affiliation.

The PR system was introduced in Europe in the mid-19th century to guarantee minority groups more representation than was possible under the FPTP or plurality system. Its supporters claim that it creates a more accurate reflection of public opinion; its opponents argue that by allowing more parties in a legislature, it may result in weaker, less stable governments.

The system is employed in many Western European countries, notably Germany, Spain, Netherlands, the Scandinavian nations and Russia. The USA, France and UK, however, use a FPTP system.