Wednesday, November 11, 2015

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Jailed Students on Hunger Strike Facing Health Woes

Posted: 11 Nov 2015 04:20 AM PST

Students in handcuffs raise their arms in solidarity prior to a hearing at the Tharrawaddy courthouse on March 25. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

Students in handcuffs raise their arms in solidarity prior to a hearing at the Tharrawaddy courthouse on March 25. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

MANDALAY — A hunger strike by a group of students and supporters in protest of the continued incarceration of political prisoners in Burma is beginning to take its toll on the participants' health, with one student admitted to Rangoon General Hospital on Wednesday.

Phyo Dana, who had been staging his hunger strike for about nine days, was admitted to the hospital suffering gastrointestinal problems, such as blood in his stool, that required urgent medical care, according to family members of the detained.

Than Htike, who has asthma, and Mar Naw and Kyaw Zwa Lin, who were suffering from hematemesis or vomiting of blood, have decided to end their hunger strike due to health concerns.

"They are in such a severe condition that they decided to stop the strike and because their families are worried too. Another one, Swe Lin Tun, is also very weak and unable to maintain the strike. However, he still refuses to take medicine or food," said a friend of the students who went to the Tharrawaddy courthouse to meet the detainees on Wednesday, when they appeared on court.

Aung Hmein San, who initiated the hunger strike on Oct. 23, is maintaining his protest, along with eight others who joined him in early November. He began his strike one week after a deadline he had set for President Thein Sein to release prisoners of conscience nationwide, an ultimatum that went unheeded by the government.

"He has lost some weight but is still in good shape and has had no serious health problems yet," said Lei Lei Nwae, the wife of Aung Hmein San. "I think it is his spirit that keeps him strong."

After a brief court appearance on Wednesday, the students were sent back to the Tharrawaddy Prison hospital. Their next hearing has been set for Nov. 17.

"I wonder why the government is so silent and is neglecting the students," Lei Lei Nwae added. "If they really want to be considered a democratic country, holding an election alone is not enough, without releasing the students and [other] political prisoners."

Soe Hlaing and Si Thu Myat, two students from Myin Chan Prison in Mandalay, also joined the hunger strike in early November, in a show of solidarity with their fellow students in Tharrawaddy Prison. Their current health conditions are unknown because their families have not been allowed to meet with them since their hunger strike began.

"We are still waiting to meet with them, but the prison authorities are not allowing us. We are now so worried for them," said Yay Aye, a close family member of Soe Hlaing, on Wednesday. "If they don't allow us to meet today, we have to wait till tomorrow when they will have to appear in court."

All of the students involved in the hunger strike were jailed for their involvement in a protest movement earlier this year against a controversial new National Education Law that was broken up violently by police in Letpadan Township, which neighbors Tharrawaddy.

The post Jailed Students on Hunger Strike Facing Health Woes appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

National News

National News


Myanmar military congratulates NLD for election win

Posted: 11 Nov 2015 11:00 AM PST

The Tatmadaw has congratulated the National League for Democracy for its landslide victory in the November 8 general election.

UEC chair hits out at ‘lawless’ criticism

Posted: 11 Nov 2015 10:40 AM PST

Criticism of the Union Election Commission should stay within the law to avoid creating anarchy, commission chair U Tin Aye said yesterday.

Ex-minister’s agent denies seeking recount

Posted: 11 Nov 2015 10:02 AM PST

Pipped at the post in Pobbathiri township, Nay Pyi Taw, despite an influx of military votes, the agent of former defence minister U Wi Lwin yesterday denied demanding a recount. The seat was taken by U Ye Mon, also known as Maung Tin Thit, with a bare margin of 176 votes.

Kyaunggon township count questioned

Posted: 11 Nov 2015 08:54 AM PST

A hotly contested vote in the delta may be subject to a recount after a party representative and the township election officials came up with wildly divergent ballot tallies, leading to different winners.

President congratulates NLD, promises peaceful power transfer

Posted: 11 Nov 2015 04:59 AM PST

President U Thein Sein has congratulated the National League for Democracy on its landslide victory in the November 8 vote and promised a peaceful transfer of power, the party said.

Government accepts offer for talks

Posted: 11 Nov 2015 04:35 AM PST

The government has agreed to a request from Daw Aung San Suu Kyi to meet for "national reconciliation" talks, a spokesperson said.

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi invites military, president to ‘national reconciliation’ talks

Posted: 11 Nov 2015 02:49 AM PST

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi has written to President U Thein Sein, Pyidaungsu Hluttaw Speaker Thura U Shwe Mann and Tatmadaw Commander-in-Chief Senior General Min Aung Hlaing requesting a meeting in the interests of "national reconciliation".

NLD looking to repeat 1990 landslide

Posted: 11 Nov 2015 01:14 AM PST

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi's National League for Democracy seems on track for a repeat of its 1990 landslide election victory, with results from about 30 percent of all seats officially declared last night.

Fighting resumes in Shan State in wake of election

Posted: 11 Nov 2015 01:12 AM PST

Government forces have resumed their offensives in central Shan State, launching aerial attacks on a base of the Shan State Progress Party following the November 8 elections, according to an armed ethnic group in the area.

Preliminary election results, Wednesday, November 11

Posted: 11 Nov 2015 01:12 AM PST

A map of preliminary national election results, as of 8:00AM, Wednesday, November 11, 2015. For the latest news and results updates, check our live blog

Shan Herald Agency for News

Shan Herald Agency for News


Burma Army fires on known IDP site, displacing 2,000

Posted: 11 Nov 2015 02:51 AM PST

For five hours yesterday, the Burma Army fired long-range mortar shells at a high school in Kesi Township serving as a safe house for internally displaced civilians (IDPs), a local source confirmed. 

Internally displaced refugees arrive in Laikha, central Shan State. (Photo: Facebook)
The school in the village of Wan Saw had been housing 1,500 IDPs since fighting in central Shan State escalated in October. They said the attack was ongoing, from 11 a.m. until 4 p.m., and was launched by two groups within Burma Army's Military Operation Command—known as Za-Ka-Ka—Nos. 2 and 17.

"They said the soldiers shot 60 mm shells at them about 60 times," said Sai Rin, a 54-year-old who works in a Mong Hsu monastery now host to newly displaced IDPs from Wan Saw.

People hid in nearby bunkers until the firing stopped, and then fled the area, along with the 500 original Wan Saw residents, he said. With 2,000 civilians gone, the area is now nearly empty. 

A man internally displaced by fighting in central Shan State arrives in Laika. (Photo: Facebook)
The New Light of Myanmar, the government mouthpiece, reported today in its English language newspaper that, on November 9, the Shan State Progress Party/Shan State Army-North (SSPP/SSA-N), who are based in the region, attacked them from "residential quarters" near their compound; the Burma Army has responded by "combing the area for enemy combatants."

Sai Hla, spokesperson for the SSPP/SSA-N, told SHAN yesterday that they are fighting now to defend themselves.

"We have no reason to fight Za-Ka-Ka No. 2. They are 20 miles from Wan Hai," he said.
"We want to solve the problem with peace talks," he added.

Wan Saw's recently displaced IDPs followed one of two routes to safety—to SSPP/SSA-N headquarters in Wan Hai, five miles west, en route to Kesi, or to the neighboring township of Mong Hsu, twelve miles east.

Those who arrived in Wan Hai had to flee for a third time when the Burma Army launched an attack on that area as well, as SHAN reported yesterday. 

Infographic showing the location of central Shan State's IDP crisis (S.H.A.N)
Around 400 people have now sought refuge in the village of Wan Wa, about three miles south of the SSPP/SSA-N base. Some continued on to Kesi Town, or to another central Shan State township, Laikha. For those who took the route to Mong Hsu, hundreds of Wan Saw's IDPs have taken shelter in monasteries, both in the town and on the way.

Yesterday's attack occurred two days after Burma held general elections for the first time in 25 years; voting did not take place in Kesi and Mong Hsu townships, because polling was cancelled due to ongoing conflict. 


By SIMMA FRANCIS / Shan Herald Agency for News (S.H.A.N)

Reporting by SAI YIPHONG / Shan Herald Agency for News (S.H.A.N)











Resolving constitutional crisis top priority for incoming NLD regime

Posted: 11 Nov 2015 02:11 AM PST

According to the Union Election Commission (UEC) elections' outcome announcement, starting on the 9 November, coming out intermittently, which should take for about a week or so, the likelihood of the National League for Democracy (NLD) winning with a landslide is an accepted, foregone conclusion.

On 10 November late evening, 285 candidates winner-list for the three parliaments – State/Region, Pyithu Hluttaw (Lower House) and Amyotha Hluttaw (Upper House) –  was announced, where NLD won 249  and other parties 36 seats.

Reportedly, according to UEC, the media centres will announce election results at 9 am, 12 noon, 3 pm, 6 pm, 9 pm and 11 pm everyday, provided new information is sent from region and state election sub-commissions to the UEC.

Understandably frustrated by the slow announcement of the UEC, the NLD has made public its own tally on election figures, where it said that it has passed the mark of absolute majority.

According to AP report on 10 November, the NLD has accused the government's UEC  of intentionally delaying results, saying it wants to "maybe play a trick."

The NLD's surprising accusation added a worrying twist to what had been an amicable election, with the ruling party appearing to be taking its expected loss gracefully after the Sunday vote.

"The Union Election Commission has been delaying intentionally because maybe they want to play a trick or something," NLD spokesman Win Htein told reporters at Suu Kyi's house after a party meeting. "It doesn't make sense that they are releasing the results piece by piece. It shouldn't be like that," he said.

The NLD's election campaign team said that the party has won at least 380 seats across both houses of Parliament, which would represent a majority of total Union Parliament seats. The military allotted seats in both houses are 166.

As the election could not be held in seven townships, there are now only 433 seats in the Lower House which, when combined with 224 Upper House seats, totals 657 seats in the bicameral parliament. Therefore, to form government, the key number is 329 seats.

Thus with the absolute majority in the pocket, during the early 2016, the NLD will be able to select two presidential candidates, against one proposed by the unelected, military representatives, who occupy 25% of the parliamentary seats.

It is quite clear that the NLD will be able to have one of its presidential candidates occupying the country's top position, with far-reaching responsibilities of:

• Appointing Union Ministers including the Chief Ministers of the States and Divisions;
• Granting pardons and granting amnesty based on the recommendations of the 11 person National Defence and Security Council (NDSC);
• Appointing diplomats;
• Establishing relations with foreign countries;
• Entering into international treaties subject to the consent of the National Parliament;
• Calling special sessions of parliament;
• Issuing laws between sessions of parliament;
• Taking military action in coordination with the NDSC; and
• Declaring war with the approval of the National Parliament.

The political sequence normally should likely move along further as planned, if no untoward circumstance befall the country, during the transitional period from Thein Sein to Aung San Suu Kyi's era.

SNLD and ANP

While the NLD is sweeping all the seats in all three parliaments country-wide, the two ethnic parties, the Shan Nationalities League for Democracy (SNLD) and Arakan National Party (ANP) are said to be doing well in their home states of Shan and Arakan.

The NLD seems to win in Chin, Karenni (Kayah) and Mon States, while Karen and Kachin States are undecided, as of this writing.

The Mizzima, on 10 November, reported that SNLD spokesman Sai Leik said that within Shan State that his party is leading with the most vote and have won 25 seats in State Parliament, 12 Pyithu Hlluttaw (Lower House) and 3 seats in Amyotha Hluttaw (Upper House) and still waiting for more results from Kachin State and Mandalay Division (Region) to come in.

In an interview with VOA, on the same day, Sai Leik said: "From the start of the elections, we consider Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) to be our main competitor. If you look at the winners now, in Shan State after the SNLD, the NLD is leading. But if you look at the acquired votes, SNLD is the top-runner. White Tiger (SNDP) captures only one seat, so far."

Reconciliation gesture

On the eve of the landslide victory, Soe Win Oo, the deputy chairman of the NLD's Rangoon election campaign team said: "We will cooperate with the military and ethnic parties. If the NLD wins the presidential position, we can form a government."

Guarded, but a bit stern and contrary to her deputy chairman, Aung San Suu Kyi, when she was asked by BBC Radio on 10 November, if her party, once in power, would prosecute former military leaders for human rights abuses, answered: "I have said that we are not going in for vengeance, and we're not going in for a series of Nurembergs or anything like that. But people must change their ways, it doesn't mean that we'll simply let people get away what they have been doing for the last 50 years."

Even then, news are making the rounds that unofficial talks are already underway between senior NLD officials and military and ruling party figures about the complicated political negotiations in coming months before the next parliament is seated next year.

Whatever the case, "peace and national reconciliation" have always been the dominant catchword for this deeply divided society, which as all the successive military-dominated government predecessors, including the quasi-civilian regime of Thein Sein, have tried in vain, without success, to come to grips. And this would be the core issues that the NLD would have to attend to.

Political pundits have time and again suggested that some sort of round table talks among the regime, military, political parties and ethnic nationalities should be the way to go. But half-hearted and pre-conceived ideas to uphold political power monopolization and group survival mentality have derailed any such meetings and proved to be just an ad hoc undertakings, without real substance, commitment or political will to strive for genuine peace and national reconciliation.

But this time around, the people of Burma has given her the mandate to fulfil the aspirations of genuine peace, human rights, self-determination and above all a genuine federalism that have been denied all these years. Of course, it is a tall order. But people are confident that she will be able to deliver and pave the way leading to the realization of those dreams.

It is important at this juncture to shed light on the father of  Aung San Suu Kyi, General Aung San's seven guiding principles, in the aftermath of Panglong Agreement and on the eve of Union of Burma constitutional drafting in 1947.

The seven guiding principles, interpreting the Panglong Agreement, to adhere to in formulating the Union of Burma Constitution are:

  1. It must be the constitution of the Union of Burma vested with freedom and sovereignty;
  2. All individual states must be vested with self-administrative power;
  3. The Union of Burma, all states and government organizations must accept (the notion) that political power derives from the people;
  4. All citizens are equal socially, economically, politically and so long as the public order is not violated, freedom of thinking, speech, belief, religion, livelihood and organization must be guaranteed in the constitution;
  5. The constitution must adequately guarantee the rights of the minorities;
  6. Guard and protect the country's perpetuation and sovereignty; and
  7. Strive for human development, prosperity and world peace together with the international community. (Source: General Aung San's seven principle guideline – 1947)

Constitutional crisis

Since 1962, after the military coup led by General Ne Win, Burma has been burdened with the constitutional crisis up to these days.

The 1974 Burma Socialist Programme Party (BSPP) and the military-drafted 2008 constitutions are also unitary in nature and don't cater to the federal form of government, in a real sense, while the 1948 Union of Burma Constitution, although federal in form is also unitary in practice. To make it short, in order to make the constitution more federal, the ethnic nationalities, spear-headed by the then Shan Government, in 1962, made a "Federal Proposal", citing Panglong Agreement and promises, which was signed by General Aung San representing Burma Proper (Ministerial Burma) in 1947.

Thus, when the ethnic nationalities said genuine federalism, they meant to say the amendment of the 1948 Union of Burma Constitution, together with the integration of 1962 "Federal Proposal". In other words, the ethnic nationalities' aspired federalism is rooted in 1948 Constitution, 1947 Panglong Agreement and 1962 Federal Proposal, perhaps with some innovation to be in tune with the modern time.

Many uninformed foreign experts and international NGOs tend to downplay the federalism knowledge and awareness of the ethnic nationalities by saying that they have no idea of what it is really all about. While it could be partly true that the new generation of activists and politicians might have not thoroughly read or studied the issue, due to the military's prohibition to even talk about it for decades, the old-hand, ethnic politicians definitely know what it is and what kind of federalism they are striving for.

In a nutshell, the Federal Proposal called for a separate Bamar state to be in line with equality with the other ethnic states, plus equitable power and resources sharing.

The people's loud and clear amendment demand of the 2008 constitution and an attempt by the parliamentarians during the present Thein Sein's regime, within the parliament, are stark reminders that the constitutional crisis is very much alive and present, which have started since 1962.

Task for the incoming regime

While the priority of the incoming NLD regime is to either amend the military-drafted constitution or completely rewrite it, so that the aspirations of all the ethnic nationalities, Bamar included, could be realized, the immediate task is to end the institutionalized war in ethnic homelands and foster reconciliation. And the best place to start is to declare a unilateral ceasefire by the government and call for a genuine peace dialogue.

In "Brainy Quote: Aung San Suu Kyi Quotes",  she rightly pointed out: " Once serious political dialogue has begun, the international community can assume that we have achieved genuine progress along the road to real democratisation."

Her position regarding the definition to peace reads: " My attitude to peace is rather based on the Burmese definition of peace - it really means removing all the negative factors that destroy peace in this world. So peace does not mean just putting an end to violence or to war, but to all other factors that threaten peace, such as discrimination, such as inequality, poverty."

Her take on the military writes: "I don't want to see the military falling. I want to see the military rising to dignified heights of professionalism and true patriotism. 

Despite being armed with all such wisdom, immediate political woes keep knocking at the door, disguised as isolated armed conflict against, with the pretext of protecting sovereignty and national unity from the part of the military, when in fact, political solution is the only way out.

Meanwhile, as people across the country are rejoicing and having a sweet revenge for decades of military heavy-handedness and repression by voting and letting the NLD to win with a landslide – a foregone conclusion that needs only to be confirmed by the UEC -, a rude awakening has disturbed the public euphoria caused by the ariel bombings and ground attacks on the Shan State Progress Party/Shan State Army (SSPP/SSA) positions, around its headquarters, by the Burma Army, just two days after the election.

No doubt, the Lady will need all the help she could muster to overcome all the woes surrounding the country and the people are confident that she could do it, and it is this that counts.

The contributor is ex-General Secretary of the dormant Shan Democratic Union (SDU)- Editor



Tuesday, November 10, 2015

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Fresh Clashes in Shan State the Day after Election

Posted: 09 Nov 2015 09:09 PM PST

A cache of Burma Army weapons purportedly seized recently by the Shan State Army-North. (Photo: Tai Tan Yang / SSPP/SSA)

A cache of Burma Army weapons purportedly seized recently by the Shan State Army-North. (Photo: Tai Tan Yang / SSPP/SSA)

RANGOON — The day after Burma's historic election, clashes have once again broken out in Kyethi Township, where the Shan State Army-North (SSA-N) say the Burma Armed Forces have used aerial forces and artillery in an attack on its Wan Hai village headquarters.

"They have been attacking us since yesterday evening at 6pm," said SSA-N spokesman Sai Hla on Tuesday morning.

He claimed that two Air Force planes had strafed the area in the morning, destroying a Buddhist monastery, which The Irrawaddy has so far been unable to independently confirm.

"We are still collecting information about how many villagers were wounded. We do not know about causalities yet," he said, adding that all villagers from Wan Hai had already fled the area.

Fresh clashes between the military and SSA-N broke out on Oct. 6. Around 6,000 villagers have fled from the conflict and Shan civil society groups have repeatedly petitioned the government to put an end to the assault.

Sai Hla told The Irrawaddy fighting has stopped in the days leading up to the election before resuming on Monday evening.

The post Fresh Clashes in Shan State the Day after Election appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

National News

National News


NLD doctor knocks off Sagaing chief minister

Posted: 10 Nov 2015 07:09 AM PST

Budalin township, Sagaing Region, has gone heavily for the National League for Democracy, according to the party's candidate there. Dr Kyaw Zaw Lin said he had won by a landslide, taking 68 percent of the vote, and beating five other candidates, including the current chief minister of the region, U Thar Aye, who was running for the Union Solidarity and Development Party.

Drama in NPT as ex-defence minister’s request for recount rejected

Posted: 10 Nov 2015 04:33 AM PST

Township election commission officials in Pobbathiri have rejected a last-ditch attempt from former defence minister U Wai Lwin to stave off defeat.

SNLD pre-empts official results and calls victory in Muse

Posted: 10 Nov 2015 03:46 AM PST

The Shan Nationalities and Democracy Party is claiming victory in Muse township, though the official results have yet to be announced.

NLD wins two of three seats in tight Kalewa race

Posted: 10 Nov 2015 02:16 AM PST

Unofficial but apparently complete results have just come in from Kalewa township in western Sagaing Region have given the National League for Democracy two more seats, with the Union Solidarity and Development Party claiming one regional parliament seat.

NLD on track for landslide as more results come in

Posted: 10 Nov 2015 01:55 AM PST

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi's National League for Democracy is on track for a repeat of its 1990 landslide election victory with results from more than 20 percent of all seats officially declared.

Anger as advance votes push USDP to lead in Lashio

Posted: 10 Nov 2015 12:40 AM PST

Lashio candidates for the National League for Democracy and two Shan parties joined forces yesterday in calling for the annulment of advance votes that appeared set to give victory to the Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) for all seats in the township.

NLD takes Thandwe but Rakhine party claims north

Posted: 10 Nov 2015 12:38 AM PST

The National League for Democracy appeared to have swept Thandwe township yesterday, taking all four available seats – in some cases by a convincing margin.

In Kayah, USDP shows grace in defeat

Posted: 10 Nov 2015 12:37 AM PST

Union Solidarity and Development Party officials in Kayah State have praised the conduct and outcome of the November 8 vote, saying they had no complaints despite winning only seven of 34 seats.

UEC frustrates with lack of results

Posted: 10 Nov 2015 12:32 AM PST

Tensions run high over process of confirming results as NLD begins revealing its own tally of the count, pre-empting official announcements.

PACE praises competitiveness of election

Posted: 10 Nov 2015 12:23 AM PST

The November 8 vote was a tranquil affair and the most competitive electoral event in Myanmar since 1990, with 33 million eligible voters choosing from among more than 600 candidates representing 91 political parties, according to a report released by the People's Alliance for Credible Elections.

Shan Herald Agency for News

Shan Herald Agency for News


To Hopeland and Back: Joint Ceasefire Monitoring Committee Meets

Posted: 10 Nov 2015 03:50 AM PST

From 29-31 October, the Joint Ceasefire Monitoring Committee (JMC) members from both sides met at the Myanmar Peace Center (MPC) on Shweli Lane off 4 Wisara Road, Rangoon.

My job is to render assistance and advice when the EAO's representatives—particularly those from the Restoration Council of Shan State/Shan State Army-South (RCSS/SSA-S)—need it.

As my time is running out, this is obviously the only thing I can do.

JMC meeting (Photo: Nyo Ohn Myint) 

Wednesday, 28 October 2015


The wise knows fire is dangerous and avoids it.
The fool meanwhile thinks
With his fool's luck, he may find a way to harness it.

Anonymous

Today, I'm leaving for Rangoon.

The day begins with breaking news all over the Internet of the US-China naval confrontation in the Spratly Islands, where a US destroyer has sailed within the 12-nautical mile boundary around an artificial island built by China.

The incident coincides with an invitation from the Panghsang-based (Pangkham) United Wa State Party/Army (UWSP/UWSA) to ten non-NCA (Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement) signatories for a "summit" on 1-3 November. The two main topics will be the November 8 elections and the peace process in its aftermath.

Prior to the invitation, on September 4, Panghsang issued a statement which, in essence, declared it would not be a signatory, as it had already promised China's Yunnan government that it would sign only if Naypyitaw agreed to "inclusiveness," meaning not leaving out any group, especially the Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army (MNDAA), better known as the Kokang armed group.

Before the JMC meeting, the EAOs hold a pre-meeting from 19:00-21:30 at the Green Hill Hotel, where they also are staying for the duration.

Maj. Gen. Isaac Po of the Karen National Union (KNU) is chosen to deliver an opening remark tomorrow. Leading discussants will be Padoh Ta Do Moo (KNU) and Dr Sui Khar (CNF).

Apart from the Military Code of Conduct (CoC) and Terms of Reference (TOR) for the JMCs, there are other topics, like confirmation of the JMC-Union level, the signed copies of the NCA yet to be received, and the parliamentary ratification of the NCA at the earliest date possible.


Kwe Htoo Win of the KNU (Photo: The Irrawaddy) 

 Ta Do Moo, like Kwe Htoo Win, is a great asset for the EAOs with his expertise in the subject and his experience gained during the two-year-long NCCT-UPWC (Nationwide Ceasefire Coordination Team-Union Peacemaking Working Committee) negotiations.



Dr Sui Khar also is an indispensable negotiator with his great sense of humor and resourcefulness. "If there are ten Chins like him," remarked one of the MPC officials, "there will be no need for us Burmans to run the country."

Thursday, 29 October 2015

One who is good at martial arts overcomes others' forces without battle.

From The Art of Warby Sun Tzu, Ch. 3

The JMC-Union Level's first meeting starts with opening speeches:
·         "The government will strictly honor the promise made in the NCA."
(U Khin Maung Soe, government's chair)
·         "Sun Tzu says 'To win without fighting is best'. To do it requires winning the hearts of the people on the other side. Only then genuine peace can be achieved."
(Maj. Gen. Isaac Po, EAOs' chairman)

The day's accomplishment is the agreement on the Military Code of Conduct (CoC) draft presented by the EAOs, thanks especially to Ta Do Moo and the government's Lt-Gen. Ye Aung, both veterans of the two-year-long NCA negotiations.

It should be noted here that on the government's side, the latter is the only old hand. Others are either newcomers or were passive participants during the NCA negotiation days. Whereas others are hesitant, he is forthright. He compares the CoC draft with Ch. 3 (Ceasefire related matters) and Ch. 4 (Maintaining and strengthening the ceasefire) of the NCA and on finding no disparities, he just says, "This point should go ahead." The rest just agree with him.

The day's session is followed by the daily press conference and interviews. I remember being asked why there are non-signatory groups, if the NCA is just fine as it is.

My answer: "This is the classic example of the half-full/half-empty glass of water metaphor. The signers think it's half-full and the non-signers think it's half-empty."
 
Dr. Sui Khar, of the CNF (Photo: Pyidaungsu Institute)

From 19:00-21:00, the EAOs hold a review session of the day.

Two of the topics that take up the bulk of the time are:
·         Whether or not to accept the government's proposal that the JMC-Union's formation be published in the government's official gazette. Some of the leaders think it's a good idea, making it more binding. The others are not sure. In the end, it is decided to refer the decision-making to the planned summit in November.
·         How to form the JMC-State/Region (JMC-S) level. With smaller states, the government's proposal that the EAOs' JMC-S deal directly with the corresponding regional command of the Burma Army isn't a problem. However with three EAOs, there are questions to be answered:

1.    The Arakan Liberation Party/Army (ALP/ALA) wants to know why there will be no JMC-S for the Arakan/Rakhine State.  The government says it hasn't been fighting enough to warrant a JMC. So what should they do to make it worth it?

2.    The KNU's armed wing—the KNLA (Karen National Liberation Army)—is spread out in areas under two regional commands: the Southeast and Coastal. Does it mean that the KNLA forces should regroup inside the area operated by one of the regional commands?

3.    The same goes for the RCSS, whose SSA-S operates in some 19 townships in Shan State in areas under four regional commands of the Burma Army. It is clear it will not agree to regroup in one single area.


Then comes the shock. I'm named as the opening remarks speaker for tomorrow. I ask them whether it's appropriate, as I'm not a member of any EAO. They say not being a member should be the best reason.

I accept it reluctantly. I later spend some time trying to think of what t say. That's how I fall asleep.


By SAI KHUENSAI  / Director of Pyidaungsu Institute and Founder of Shan Herald Agency for News (S.H.A.N)

The views expressed are the author's own.



Day after election, Burma Army soldiers allegedly rob two civilians in Shan State

Posted: 10 Nov 2015 12:57 AM PST

Burma Army soldiers allegedly robbed two civilians on a roadside in Kesi Township yesterday, according to a representative from the Shan Nationalities League for Democracy (SNLD).


Sai Hark Khur, a member of the SNLD leadership in Kesi Township, told SHAN that the two local men were robbed after returning from a market at around noon near Wiang Gao village tract in Kesi's Mong Nong sub-township.

"They were coming from Mong Hsu Township, where they were selling their cows and buffalos," said Sai Hark Khur. The soldiers allegedly stopped the men's car and instructed them at gunpoint to move away from their vehicle; Sai Lu, one of the victims, said that the soldiers were armed.

The soldiers then searched the vehicle; when Sai Lu and his friend—who wished to remain anonymous—returned to the car and were given permission to leave, they allegedly noticed that 3,000,000 kyats (over $2,300 USD) were missing.

Sai Lu reported the theft to community leaders, and together they went to the local military base to report the crime there. But the authorities refuted the allegations.

"Their commander said they didn't have those two soldiers in the base," said a community member, who also wished to remain anonymous.

The case was then reported to the SNLD office in Mong Nong. At the time of reporting, they were still searching for the alleged perpetrators.


One day earlier, Burma held its first general election in 25 years. SHAN also reported that on the same day, Burma Army soldiers shot two civilians in Kesi Township. The victims are now being treated at a local hospital in Taunggyi District. 

By SAI AW / Shan Herald Agency for News (S.H.A.N)

Shan State Army-North: “I can’t talk now—they are bombing us”

Posted: 10 Nov 2015 12:15 AM PST

An official in the Shan State Progress Party/Shan State Army-North (SSPP/SSA-N) reported a Burma Army attack from the air near their headquarters in Wan Hai, in central Shan State's Kesi Township, at 10 a.m. this morning.

The source said three helicopters from Military Operation Command No. 2—known locally as Za Ka Ka—dropped bombs on the outskirts of Wan Hai. At the time of reporting, it could not be confirmed if anyone was injured or killed in the attack, which is allegedly ongoing.

A Burma Army helicopter flies over Wan Hai, Kesi Township. (Photo: Zanhok Hengjai / Facebook)

When SHAN contacted SSPP/SSA-N representative Lt.-Col. Sai Kham Htee for further information, the sound of rapid gunfire interrupted the conversation over the phone.

"I can't talk now—they are bombing us," he said before the line cut.

The incident was allegedly a continuation of shelling and shooting in neighboring Mong Hsu Township and Kesi's Mong Nong sub-township, which began last night.

"Yesterday the Burma Army soldiers came into the village and shot guns into the houses. They have continued it today. Now we are saying in a bunker," said Sai Awn, one of the locals who is now in hiding. It is standard practice for Shan villagers in conflict zones to build underground bunkers to which they can flee when fighting erupts.

Today's attack occurred two days after Burma's November 8 national election.

"This kind of action makes the people not want to pay attention to the election results," said Sai Lek, a spokesperson for the Shan Nationalities League for Democracy (SNLD). "It will create a problem for unity amongst the ethnic groups and also for building a nation."

No parties were able to contest the election in Kesi and Mong Hsu, where the Union Election Commission (UEC) cancelled voting, claiming that the ongoing conflict created unfavorable conditions for polling to take place.

Fighting in central Shan State has been ongoing since October 6. Near the end of last month, civilians evacuated Wan Hai due to shelling by government forces, adding to the 6,000 civilians now displaced in the region. Most are staying in monasteries and temporary shelters with little aid. Last week, SHAN also reported that schools have been closed in the conflict areas.

"Students cannot go to school. On the street it is very quiet. Everyone stays in their houses," said Mong Hsu resident Nang Kham.

This is the second incident of military violence in central Shan State reported in as many days; yesterday, while leaving their farmland, two civilians—including one child—were shot by Burma Army soldiers in Mong Nong, Kesi Township.

By SIMMA FRANCIS / (Shan Herald Agency for News / S.H.A.N)

Reporting by SAI YIPHONG / (Shan Herald Agency for News / S.H.A.N)