Wednesday, March 9, 2016

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


No More Smiles: Transition Sours Ahead of Presidential Vote

Posted: 09 Mar 2016 05:31 AM PST

Burma's commander-in-chief, Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing, left, and National League for Democracy (NLD) leader Aung San Suu Kyi talk before their meeting in Naypyidaw on Dec. 2, 2015. (Photo: Reuters)

Burma's commander-in-chief, Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing, left, and National League for Democracy (NLD) leader Aung San Suu Kyi talk before their meeting in Naypyidaw on Dec. 2, 2015. (Photo: Reuters)

NAYPYIDAW — A deepening rift has opened between Burma's powerful military and Aung San Suu Kyi, sources say, threatening the democracy leader's prospects for forming a successful government even as Parliament prepares to nominate presidential candidates on Thursday.

With the date fast approaching for Suu Kyi's National League for Democracy (NLD) to take power, efforts to portray the party and its former foes as working cordially together toward a smooth transfer of power have faltered, according to politicians and officials familiar with the situation.

"She believed that she would be able to work with the military, but after the last meeting with the commander-in-chief, she realized that she cannot negotiate with them," said a senior NLD Upper House lawmaker briefed on the talks.

"It's quite clear that she has moved on from waiting for the military to collaborate."

Talks between the NLD and the military began soon after Suu Kyi's party won a landslide victory in a historic election on Nov. 8, heralding the country's first democratically elected government since the military took power in 1962.

But Suu Kyi has become frustrated with the intransigence of the military on issues ranging from a constitutional amendment that would allow her to become president to the location of the handover ceremony before the start of the new government on April 1, say sources in her camp.

Gen. Tin San Naing, the spokesman for military MPs, declined to comment on the details of negotiations.

The military has stressed its belief that it has a vital role to play in politics until the transition to democracy is secure, and had worried that changing the Constitution quickly could set a dangerous precedent.

Burma's junta handed power to a semi-civilian government made up of ex-generals in 2011, after nearly 50 years of military rule, but the Constitution it drafted left the military with considerable power.

As well as a clause that effectively bans Suu Kyi from becoming president because her children are British citizens, the Constitution also gives the military three powerful ministries and 25 percent of the seats in parliament that amounts to a veto over any constitutional change.

The charter, which leaves the security apparatus and much of the state bureaucracy under military control, will force the NLD government to work with the armed forces.

Parking Spots, Office Equipment

Underscoring the antipathy between the two sides, an official who met Suu Kyi recently said the bickering had extended beyond the Constitution and power-sharing to small details such as car parking slots at the handover ceremony and equipment removed from offices by outgoing government staff.

The tensions boiled over in Parliament two weeks ago in a rare show of dissent by military MPs, who stood up to protest against accusations by NLD parliamentarians that the outgoing administration had mishandled public projects.

"We were scared when the military MPs suddenly stood up against our MP's proposal … my heart just dropped when I turned around to check the noise. The situation was really tense," said Tint Soe, a Lower House NLD lawmaker.

The stand-off in Parliament came about a week after the third meeting between Suu Kyi and Min Aung Hlaing, the powerful army chief.

"The army came to the negotiating table with a long shopping list of demands that proved unfeasible," said Win Oo, a former member of the army-backed Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP), who closely monitors the transition.

"The two sides are now in the state of cold war. It's a political killing field."

The NLD had hoped the military could be persuaded to endorse a constitutional amendment allowing Suu Kyi to become president.

But as it became clear late last month that was not going to happen, the Nobel Peace Prize laureate decided to cut short the negotiations and bring forward by a week the process for selecting a proxy president—who will run the country at her behest.

The NLD has yet to say who that will be. Most of the speculation has centered on candidates who have a low profile and will be loyal to the party leader.

On Thursday, the Upper House and Lower House of Parliament, and the military bloc in the legislature, will each nominate a candidate. The joint chamber will vote on which of the three becomes president—and the NLD boasts a big enough majority to carry the vote no matter which way the military votes.

It has been unclear how quickly after Thursday's nominations the joint session vote will be held. A director from the Parliament told Reuters on Wednesday that the vote would not take place until Monday.

The losing candidates will become vice presidents. For some in the NLD, contemplating the end of a long wait to form a government, the wrangling over the transition is a grim portent.

"It will be really difficult for her in the future because of the military—it is very clear they don't want to cooperate," Tint Soe, the NLD lawmaker said. "It's such a miserable situation."

The post No More Smiles: Transition Sours Ahead of Presidential Vote appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

As Eyes Turn to Naypyidaw, a Question of Which Three

Posted: 09 Mar 2016 05:22 AM PST

 Policemen secure the gates of Burma's parliamentary compound in Naypyidaw on Nov. 11, 2014. (Photo: Reuters)

Policemen secure the gates of Burma's parliamentary compound in Naypyidaw on Nov. 11, 2014. (Photo: Reuters)

RANGOON — On Thursday, Parliament's Lower and Upper houses, along with military representatives in the legislature, will nominate three vice presidents who will then be put to a vote at the Union Parliament to determine who will serve as the country's next president.

The National League for Democracy (NLD) has the necessary majorities required to select two of these three vice presidents, and again has the votes to ensure that its choice takes up residence in the Presidential Palace thereafter.

On the eve of the big day, The Irrawaddy provides a look at prospective picks who have been publicly tipped as possible candidates, along with their short biographies.

2H9A9989 copy-2

Dr. Myo Aung

The 65-year-old Lower House lawmaker from Rangoon's Dagon Myothit (Seikkan) constituency is among those members of the NLD who have been tipped as possible presidential nominees.

Trained as a medical doctor, Myo Aung served as an army physician from 1985 to 1988 in Burma's Ministry of Defense. But he was ordered to quit from the position due to his involvement in political activities. He became a member of the NLD in 1996 and was thrown in prison several times under military rule.

He was elected to a Lower House seat in Burma's 2012 by-election and serves on the NLD's central executive committee, as well as on the NLD team formed to work with the government on matters pertaining to the power handover due in about three weeks' time.

Sai Nyunt Lwin, February 2016.

Sai Nyunt Lwin, February 2016.

Sai Nyunt Lwin

Sai Nyunt Lwin, the general secretary of the Shan Nationalities League for Democracy (SNLD), is a Shan ethnic now tipped as a potential choice for a vice president post.

The SNLD shunned Burma's 2010 general election along with the NLD, and among ethnic parties was the second-biggest winner in last year's vote, trailing only the Arakan National Party.

The 65-year-old is a former political prisoner who was released in January 2012, after being held for seven years. He had been sentenced to 85 years' imprisonment in February 2005 for holding a private meeting with senior Shan leaders and was charged with high treason, along with 11 others.

He would appear to be the SNLD's most likely candidate for a vice presidential slot if the NLD should offer one to the Shan party. The daughter of Khun Htun Oo, the SNLD chairman whose ties to Suu Kyi go back decades, holds Australian citizenship, rendering the party leader ineligible under the Constitution.

General Thura Tin Oo .

General Thura Tin Oo .

Tin Oo

NLD patron Tin Oo is a former general and ex-commander-in-chief of the Burmese military.

Following the NLD's victory in the election last year, the 89-year-old made it to the top of speculation rosters, given his military background and long-time senior role within the party. For his part, however, Tin Oo has said he can't take the position, citing his advanced age.

He was put under house arrest in 2004 by the former military government and released in 2010.

2H9A4208 copy

Htin Kyaw

A senior executive with a Suu Kyi-led foundation, Htin Kyaw has also been thought to be among potential candidates for one of the two VP posts since the NLD's election victory.

The 70-year-old Mon-Burmese is believed to be one of Suu Kyi's right-hand men; within the NLD, he has built a reputation as a man of honesty.

The Oxford graduate is the son-in-law of U Lwin, one of the NLD's cofounders. His wife Su Su Lwin is a newly minted Lower House NLD lawmaker who was recently appointed as chairperson for that chamber's International Relations Committee.

dr Tin Myo win

Tin Myo Win

Suu Kyi's personal physician, and former political prisoner. Tin Myo Win is working as a surgeon at the Muslim Free Hospital in Rangoon since his release in 1992. He is one of the few people permitted to regularly visit Suu Kyi during er house arrest. The 65-year old is the chairman of NLD's National Health Network.

_MG_0937

Myint Swe

Myint Swe, a former lieutenant-general and Rangoon Division's current chief minister, is rumored very recently to be the military's likely vice president pick, and is known as a member of the brass close to the former dictator Snr-Gen Than Shwe.

He graduated from the Defense Services Academy (DSA) 15th intake, four intakes senior to current military chief Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing. He is believed to have been behind the crackdown in 2007 on peaceful protestors in Rangoon, a movement that was led by Buddhist monks and came to be known as the Saffron Revolution. In 2014, he faced criticism over opaque tendering for a planned expansion of Rangoon.

 

STV_2913Thura Thet Swe

The former Burma Navy commander-in-chief resigned from his post in 2015 to contest the general election under the Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) banner at the  constituency of Coco Islands, which is largely populated by naval personnel, civil servants and there families. He won that seat.

The 56-year-old was criticized for having gained unfair electoral advantage by making trips to the island by military boat and aircraft while opponents were prevented from traveling to the constituency during much of the election's campaign period.

Gen. Khin Aung Myint

Until Myint Swe was recently tipped for the military's vice presidential post, Commander-in-chief (Air Force) and special operations coordinator (Army, Navy and Air Force) Gen. Khin Aung Myint was a popular pick among prognosticators.

The DSA 20th Intake graduate was thought to be on top of the list because the current military-backed vice president, Nyan Tun, is retired Navy, making an Air Force successor likely. He is junior to Min Aung Hlaing, a fact also put forward by some who believe he will get the nod.

STV_9608

Hla Htay Win

A general turned Lower House lawmaker, Hla Htay Win was former chief of staff of the Burma Army, Navy and Air Force. Despite his electoral victory in the military stronghold of Naypyidaw's Zayarthiri Township in the 2015 election, he was accused of making massive donations to his constituency in an attempt to curry voters' favor in the weeks leading up to the campaign period.

The 60-year-old  former general served as the regional commander of the Rangoon Division Military Command.

The post As Eyes Turn to Naypyidaw, a Question of Which Three appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Korean Investment in Burma Likely to Increase

Posted: 09 Mar 2016 04:46 AM PST

 An employee leaves Shinhan Bank in Seoul, South Korea in March, 2013. The bank is has been granted a license open commercial services in Rangoon, as Korean investment in Burma is expected to increase. (Photo: Lee Jae-Won / Reuters)

An employee leaves Shinhan Bank in Seoul, South Korea in March, 2013. The bank is has been granted a license open commercial services in Rangoon, as Korean investment in Burma is expected to increase. (Photo: Lee Jae-Won / Reuters)

RANGOON — After a delegation from the well-known South Korean Daewoo Group of Companies met with Burma's outgoing president on Tuesday, there is speculation that the country plans to increase investment in Burma.

During the meeting between Thein Sein and Daewoo CEO Young-Sang Kim, the topics of discussion included investment in Burma's hotels, energy, mining and steel sectors, as well as efforts to build modern rice mills. Ministers Wunna Maung Lwin, Soe Thane and Zeyar Aung also were present, according to the state media outlet Myanmar News Agency.

The Korean delegation also met with Minister of Industry Maung Myint regarding further investment opportunities in Burma. Following the meetings, some industry observers have suggested a link between South Korea's intensified interest in Burma and the increase in Japanese and Chinese economic presence in the country.

Since Thein Sein's quasi-civilian government took office in 2011, Asian countries in particular have begun investing in Burma, which has been described as a "frontier market."

Dr. Maung Maung Lay, vice chairman of the Union of Myanmar Federation of Chambers of Commerce and Industry told The Irrawaddy that Korean businesses are eyeing automobile, oil and gas sectors, as well as other smaller industries.

"Korean culture has already been exported to this country, so their brands do not need to be promoted as much," he said, adding that investors are interested in entering the beauty industry and developing Burma's cosmetic surgery market.

Korean garment factories are already operating in the country, so continued engagement with the manufacturing sector will be priority, Dr. Maung Maung Lay said.

The Central Bank of Myanmar approved a license for Korea's Shinhan Bank in the second round of foreign banks licenses issues this week, paving the way for more Korean businesses to establish a presence in Burma.

Since the first round of licensing in 2014, commercial banks from foreign investors' respective countries are now following them to Burma, including those from China, Singapore, Thailand, Malaysia, Japan, India, and Australia.

Dr. Soe Tun, chairman of the Automobile Dealers Association, said that it seems Japanese and South Korean businesses are now competing in Burma's markets.

"Many Japanese business are coming here now, so Korean businesses will follow, no doubt," he said. "We welcome more FDI [Foreign Direct Investment]."

According to the figures of the Directorate of Investment and Companies Administration, Korean investment in Burma reached US$300 million during the 2014-2015 fiscal year, ranking it the country's fifth highest investor after China, Singapore, Hong Kong and the UK respectively.

Burma expects about US$6 billion in foreign investment for the current fiscal year ending on March 31 and has received more than US$5 billion to date.

The post Korean Investment in Burma Likely to Increase appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Could Military VP Pick Sully New Govt Before It Takes Power?

Posted: 09 Mar 2016 04:31 AM PST

Myint Swe, the Rangoon Division chief minister, is pictured in 2013. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

Myint Swe, the Rangoon Division chief minister, is pictured in 2013. (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — In this confusing time of democratic transition and shifting political alliances, it is perhaps no surprise that a military general with a checkered past has surfaced as leading contender for a vice presidential slot due to be chosen this week.

An unsettling rumor swirling among politicians, top Burma Army sources and businessmen in Rangoon puts Lt-Gen Myint Swe, the current chief minister of Rangoon Division, in pole position for the vice presidential post that military lawmakers are constitutionally empowered to determine on Thursday.

Hardly the cleanest résumé among a slate of retired or serving generals who have been tipped as possible picks, Myint Swe's baggage includes corruption ties and links to a violent 2007 crackdown in the commercial capital on peaceful protestors led by Buddhist monks.

If true, some political observers predict the pick could lead to cracks and deep resentment within the military establishment itself, a faction of which is earnest in its desire to improve the powerful institution's image both at home and abroad.

It would also prove a headache for an incoming administration that has made "clean government" a hallmark pledge, including a zero-tolerance approach to graft and nepotism. Myint Swe's unusual wealth, allegedly corrupt tendencies and affiliation with the 2007 crackdown on street protests in Rangoon would no doubt be difficult for the National League for Democracy (NLD) government to defend. Though the party has no say in the military-selected VP slot, whoever is chosen will be a bona fide member of its cabinet.

His inclusion on the US Treasury Department's list of "specially designated nationals" means that, at least for now, a prospective Vice President Myint Swe would be barred from travel to the United States, a strong backer of NLD chairwoman Aung San Suu Kyi and democratic reforms of recent years.

Myint Swe is known for his nepotistic inclinations when granting business concessions. The best known example is the Rangoon City Expansion project, which came in for scrutiny in 2014 after the US$8 billion tender was granted in secrecy to a company run by two low-profile Chinese businessmen, Xiao Feng and Xiao Sen, who are close to Myint Swe.

After a public outcry, the Rangoon chief minister suspended the project and later reopened a tender that was awarded this year to three local companies. One of them, Yangon South West Development Public Company, is run by the same Chinese businessmen.

The expansion project itself is in part a response to Rangoon's rapid—and critics argue, unruly—development in recent years. Myint Swe is viewed by some as chiefly responsible for the city's disorderly transformation.

Every development project in Burma's biggest city technically requires approval from the Yangon City Development Committee (YCDC). But as high-rises have proliferated amid an influx of foreign investment, controversy has courted some developments that opponents have decried as ill-planned or otherwise threatening the city's unique character. In multiple examples of this, permission for proposed towers has been described as "coming from upstairs," meaning likely from senior government leaders at the divisional or Union level rather than following official channels for approval.

Myint Swe also recently took heat for giving his apparent imprimatur to a US$70 million international hospital project being built on land owned by the Ministry of Health near Rangoon General Hospital. He attended the groundbreaking ceremony in January.

The 65-year-old graduated from the 15th intake of the Defense Services Academy (DSA) in 1971 and rose steadily through the ranks to become the commanding officer of Light Infantry Division No. 11, overseeing security in the former capital. The ethnic Mon was brought to the War Office where he worked directly under Snr-Gen Than Shwe and his deputy Gen. Maung Aye. His relations with the former dictator Than Shwe's family are said to be close to this day.

Known to be a loyal and hardline soldier, Myint Swe was responsible for the careful execution of two high-profile operations in Burma's largest city: the arrest of Gen. Ne Win's family members in 2002 after an alleged coup conspiracy was uncovered, and the arrest of then-intelligence chief and Prime Minister Khin Nyunt in 2004. He then became head of the newly formed Military Affairs Security department after the armed forces hierarchy dismantled the powerful intelligence units.

During the Buddhist monk-led "Saffron Uprising" in 2007, Myint Swe was in charge of security affairs in Rangoon. He is believed to have been responsible for several raids on monasteries during this time, despite—or perhaps because of—his ultimately unsuccessful campaign to pacify the Buddhist clergy with donations of cash, rice, cooking oil and medicine.

In September 2013, he denied responsibility for the violent crackdown and said he was willing to be investigated and would even submit to the death penalty if found guilty of involvement.

"If you think I'm responsible, I am ready [to face justice]," Myint Swe told businesspeople people at a meeting in Rangoon, a local journal reported. "To be frank, I am ready to be hanged [if there is a guilty verdict]."

In 2015, he was one of the key persons involved in state-sponsored vigilantes' crackdown on supporters of students protesting for education reform. Myint Swe came out in defense of the methods used, saying the demonstrators were handled and detained according to existing laws, rubbing salt in the wound for a public that was outraged by the heavy-handed and thuggish tactics.

A former lieutenant-general who was tipped to be selected vice president in 2012, Myint Swe was passed over to fill that unexpected vacancy, as one of his sons was an Australian national. His son, it would appear, has since been reinstated as a Burmese citizen, removing that obstacle to his father's nomination.

As militarily appointed lawmakers continue to adjust to their role in Parliament as opposition to the NLD-dominated legislature, it's the Burma Army's choice for vice president that could shake up its relations with the now ruling party, and perhaps even within the uniformed ranks.

The post Could Military VP Pick Sully New Govt Before It Takes Power? appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

City Officials Guarantee No Water Shortage in Rangoon This Summer

Posted: 09 Mar 2016 02:50 AM PST

 A child at a water tank supplied by YCDC in Dala Township. (Photo: Thaw Hein Htet / The Irrawaddy)

A child at a water tank supplied by YCDC in Dala Township. (Photo: Thaw Hein Htet / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — Rangoon residents need not worry about a water shortage in the commercial capital this summer, said the Yangon City Development Committee (YCDC).

"Although it is expected to be hot this year, we will store more water in our reservoirs than in previous years," said Myo Thein, deputy head of the Water and Sanitation Division of YCDC.

El Niño is expected to cause low rainfall and high temperatures, but YCDC will adjust how they supply water to certain townships.

YCDC plans to pipe water to townships across the Rangoon River, including Dala, Kyimyindaing and Seikgyikanaungto, which had been provided with lake water in previous years. They now pipe water to Dala, and will increase the piped water supply as needed to other townships, said Myo Thein.

However, Dala locals have complained that they still rely on lake water because they do not receive piped water on a regular basis. The township lays just south of Rangoon but is prone to annual summer water shortages.

YCDC supplies about 205 million gallons of water daily from four reservoirs: Hlawga, Ngamokeyeik, Phu Gyi and Joe Phyu.

YCDC said it will supply water in its municipal area mainly from Hlawga, Joe Phyu and Ngamoeyeik reservoirs this summer. The water volume in those reservoirs was almost 86 billion gallons on March 9—an increase from almost 84 billion gallons on the same day last year.

YCDC will ensure a sufficient water supply in Dagon, Seikkan, Thakayta and Dawbon townships. It is also working with the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA) to supply water to Japan-backed Thilawa Special Economic Zone (SEZ) in Thanlyin Township.

"YCDC is establishing a water purification plant, built with loans from Japan," said Myo Thein. "The plant is now about 90 percent complete. We expect to supply water at full capacity to those townships in 2018-19," said Myo Thein.

He also explained that because of the increased volume of water in the reservoirs, YCDC does not plan to reduce water usage during the Water Festival, Burma's New Year celebration. More than 145 million gallons of water were used during the festival last year.

The post City Officials Guarantee No Water Shortage in Rangoon This Summer appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Cancellation of Parliamentary Session Postpones Questions to Government

Posted: 09 Mar 2016 02:28 AM PST

Lower House lawmakers at the parliamentary complex in Naypyidaw on Friday. (Photo: Myo Min Soe / The Irrawaddy)

Lower House lawmakers at the parliamentary complex in Naypyidaw on Friday. (Photo: Myo Min Soe / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — The cancellation of Wednesday's Lower House parliamentary session has delayed the scheduled discussion of two proposals examining the outgoing government's performance.

During Tuesday's session, Lower House speaker Win Myint announced that proceedings would continue on Wednesday, but the MPs were informed that evening that the following day's session was in fact called off.

Khin San Hlaing, a Lower House lawmaker from the National League for Democracy (NLD), told The Irrawaddy that the notification did not mention the cause of the cancellation. However, according to the established agenda, Ba Shein of the Arakan National Party (ANP) and Sai Thiha Kyaw of the Shan Nationalities League for Democracy (SNLD) had planned to question the Thein Sein administration on issues of transportation and development.

Ba Shein was going to inquire whether the government had a plan to re-work ferry routes through the Inland Water Transport Department in Sittwe, the Arakan State capital. Sai Thiha Kyaw's proposal concerned the status of a reservoir project in Shan State's Mongyai Township, the construction of which locals have reportedly been waiting on for three years, in the hopes that it will serve as a water source for consumption and agriculture.

"The government officials wouldn't attend the Parliament to respond to the questions even if [the MPs] ask them," said Khin San Hlaing. "So it is good to take a break from the parliamentary session instead of asking questions which won't get answers."

Khin San Hlaing submitted an urgent proposal to the Lower House of Parliament on Feb 25 calling on the outgoing government to scrutinize permissions to sell or lease state-owned facilities and projects to private companies. She also criticized the forced removal of squatters on land affected by such transactions.

Government officials did not appear before Parliament though they were invited to respond to the allegations.

Burma's information minister, Ye Htut, defended the officials' absence from Parliament, saying that the government would answer directly to citizens.

"Whether the incumbent Union government should be accountable to the second Parliament is an issue to be reviewed according to the Constitution," he said.

Legislative sessions for both the Lower and Upper houses will resume on Thursday, when the presidential nominees are scheduled to be declared.

"I think it may be because they need to prepare for tomorrow's [vice presidential nominations]," Sai Thiha Kyaw said of the cancellation.

He said that he expects that he will have to send his questions directly to the government, who will be obligated to reply even if they do not appear in Parliament.

The post Cancellation of Parliamentary Session Postpones Questions to Government appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Burmese Entrepreneurs Encourage Future Women Leaders

Posted: 09 Mar 2016 01:12 AM PST

Panelists discuss gender parity at the

Panelists discuss gender parity at the "Women in the Lead" event held at the Chatrium Hotel on International Women's Day. (Photo: Tin Htet Paing / The Irrawaddy)

Burma's female entrepreneurs encouraged women to push cultural boundaries and pursue leadership roles, sharing their personal struggles as motivation on International Women's Day on Tuesday.

Rangoon's British Embassy and the Chatrium Hotel organized a "Women in the Lead" event to commemorate the occasion. Four hundred women from all sectors of society gathered at the Chatrium to discuss the roles that women can play in the country's future.

Panelists at the event included four entrepreneurial women with different backgrounds—Yin Myo Su, founder of Inle Heritage House; Thiri Thant Mon, managing director of the investment firm Sandanila; Htar Htar, founder of Akhaya women's group; and Thet Mon Aye, co-founder of online bus ticketing service StarTicket.

The women were forthcoming with their personal experiences.

Thiri Thant Mon talked about balancing her professional life and motherhood. She said women should find a balance that works for them, not the one that society expects.

"The words 'ambitious' and 'woman' together somehow have a negative connotation," she said. "While, 'ambitious man' has a positive connotation."

Htar Htar talked about how traditional gender roles hinder women from seeking leadership roles.

If women do not make household, it is not because they are unable to do so, but more likely because they are not used to having that power, she explained.

Yin Myo Su told the audience to take risks and face challenges rather than waiting for safe opportunities to present themselves.

"Am I ready?" she asked. "I will never be ready for anything. But you do it because it's about surviving."

Tina Singhsacha, a keynote speaker and chief representative of Standard Chartered Bank in Burma, raised the importance of having more women leaders as role models so that the next generation can see potential options.

She encouraged young girls to be fearless, ambitious and to believe that they can become respected leaders in society.

"Next to every successful man, there is a strong woman. We don't always have to be behind," she said, referring to the famous quote, "Behind every successful man, there is a woman."

Another keynote speaker, Dr. Su Su Tha Tun, head of the peace support unit of Burma's UN office, talked about understanding the current context within the country in order to successfully achieve gender parity.

"Slogans are not enough," she said. "We need to understand the context in which we live."

Dr. Su Su Tha Tun quoted studies that indicate that many Burmese still hold the view that gender discrimination is not a problem in the country and that women in Burma do not need to demand their rights because they have already been realized.

Such assumption is frustrating, she said, because it does not recognize existing challenges.

"The problem is that [gender discrimination] isn't seen as a problem."

The panelists urged women to continue working and striving for gender parity, despite the societal hurdles.

"Push the boundaries," said Htar Htar. "If you push the boundaries enough, they're going to break."

The post Burmese Entrepreneurs Encourage Future Women Leaders appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

ANP Split On Addressing Party Divide

Posted: 09 Mar 2016 01:02 AM PST

The Arakan National Party's Union Parliament MPs-elect pose for a photo outside the legislative compound in Naypyidaw in January. (Photo: Arakan National Party / Facebook)

The Arakan National Party's Union Parliament MPs-elect pose for a photo outside the legislative compound in Naypyidaw in January. (Photo: Arakan National Party / Facebook)

RANGOON — Myo Kyaw, a central executive committee member of the Arakan National Party (ANP), has invited Arakanese civil society organizations to mediate current internal divisions of the ethnic party in Rangoon, a call which has been rejected by other members of the ANP leadership.

Myo Kyaw and five other central executive committee (CEC) members—once integral players within the former Arakan League for Democracy (ALD)—held a press conference on Sunday in Rangoon to object to the current practices and direction of the ANP. The following morning, ANP's top leaders said that the CEC members had intentionally undermined the party's rules and regulations.

The ANP won a majority of state parliament seats in November's general election—44 out of the 77 contested—and is now boycotting any cross-party collaboration unless given permission to form its own state government.

Established in 2014 after merging the ALD and the Rakhine Nationalities Development Party (RNDP), it was hoped that the ANP's formation would consolidate votes in the 2015 election.

The ANP's vice chairperson Phoe Minn, a former RNDP leader, told The Irrawaddy on Tuesday that the ANP had already formed a team to investigate the CEC members and had summoned them to the Arakan State capital of Sittwe for questioning.

Myo Kyaw said he objects to the probe, pointing out that the leadership continues to clash along old party lines.

"The investigation process is led by the RNDP, so we deny it. We are going to invite some independent Arakanese organizations to facilitate [a discussion about] the dispute," he explained.

Hla Maung Thein, chairman of the prominent Arakanese charity Rakhine Thahaya, said that his organization had not received an official invitation letter from the CEC members regarding a future mediation. His concern is that the recent friction is a result of misunderstanding within the ANP and that resolution of the controversy must not be rushed.

Pe Than, an ANP MP who is also on the investigation team, said that party principles must be adhered to, and it would be inappropriate to involve outside organizations in addressing internal party matters.

"I can't say what could happen. There is no official announcement [about what happens to] disobedient members," he said.

Pe Than assumes that if the former ALD members "confess their wrongdoing" and halt any further opposition to the investigative team, they will not be penalized harshly. According to the party procedure, the strongest potential outcome is dismissal.

The Irrawaddy asked Myo Kyaw what might happen if the ANP leadership overrides the suggestion to involve civil society in resolving the internal conflict and instead expels the CEC members.

"The ANP will be divided and it will collapse if they fire us," he said. "This is not only about the perspective of six people, but also the huge number of supporters behind us."

Khine Pyay Soe, leader of the ANP's disciplinary committee, said that the secretariat and the party chairman, Dr. Aye Maung, have the right to determine a penalty for the six CEC members.

The Irrawaddy contacted Dr. Aye Maung by phone but he declined to comment on the situation.

The post ANP Split On Addressing Party Divide appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

China Says Still Trying to Resolve Stalled Myitsone Dam Scheme

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 09:27 PM PST

A woman stands at the banks of the river confluence known as Myitsone in northern Burma's Kachin State. (Photo: Andrew D. Kaspar / The Irrawaddy)

A woman stands at the banks of the river confluence known as Myitsone in northern Burma's Kachin State. (Photo: Andrew D. Kaspar / The Irrawaddy)

BEIJING — China is pursuing efforts to resolve the problem of a stalled dam project in Burma, its foreign minister said on Tuesday, adding that Beijing had confidence in the incoming government of democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi's party.

In 2011, Burma's President Thein Sein angered Beijing by suspending the $3.6-billion, Chinese-invested Myitsone dam project, some 90 percent of whose power would have gone to China.

Other Chinese projects in Burma have proved controversial too, including the Letpadaung copper mine, against which residents have repeatedly protested, and twin Chinese oil and gas pipelines across the country.

China wants to help Burma to have better and quicker development, Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi told his yearly news conference on the sidelines of the annual meeting of parliament.

"The Myitsone dam is a commercial cooperation project, and had all its approvals completed. Difficulties in cooperation are 'growing pains.' Both countries will continue to proactively, appropriately handle it," Wang said.

"We have confidence in the future of Sino-Myanmar mutually beneficial cooperation."

He did not elaborate on how or when the dam issue might be resolved.

Suu Kyi's National League for Democracy (NLD) took some 80 percent of elected seats in November, enough to push through its president, but Suu Kyi is blocked from holding the country's highest office because her two sons are not Burmese citizens, nor was her late husband.

The NLD has no number two after Suu Kyi, who has said she will control the government from "above the president," and rumors have swirled over who might fill the top post.

While Beijing had strong ties with Burma's military junta, it has also moved to cement relations with Suu Kyi, who met Chinese President Xi Jinping in Beijing last year.

Wang said China's strong links with Burma would not change because of its domestic situation.

"Aung San Suu Kyi and the NLD she leads have always had friendly exchanges with China, and mutual understanding and trust continue to increase. We also have full faith in Myanmar's future."

The post China Says Still Trying to Resolve Stalled Myitsone Dam Scheme appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Iranian Couple in Cambodia Resettlement Deal Return Home

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 09:03 PM PST

Boys walk in front of a house that is used to temporarily house asylum seekers sent from a South Pacific detention center, in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, on Aug. 31, 2015. (Photo: Reuters)

Boys walk in front of a house that is used to temporarily house asylum seekers sent from a South Pacific detention center, in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, on Aug. 31, 2015. (Photo: Reuters)

PHNOM PENH — An Iranian couple who resettled in Cambodia under an expensive program funded by Australia to keep asylum-seekers from its soil returned to their homeland, Cambodian and Australian officials said Tuesday.

Gen. Tan Sovichea, head of the refugee office in Cambodia's Interior Ministry, said the couple, who arrived from a refugee camp on the South Pacific island nation of Nauru last June, departed for Iran on Feb. 12.

He said five people had resettled in Cambodia from Nauru under a four-year, 55 million Australian dollar ($41 million) program financed by Australia, which also pays for the South Pacific camp housing more than 600 refugees. Human rights activists claim conditions there are unhealthy.

"The Iranian couple told us that they decided to go back to Iran after they felt homesick," Tan Sovichea said. "We respected their rights to leave and we welcome their decision."

Last October, one of two ethnic Rohingya men resettled under the deal went home to Burma, leaving only an Iranian and another Rohingya in Cambodia. Tan Sovichea said they appeared to be happy with their new lives.

A statement released by a spokeswoman for Australian Immigration Minister Peter Dutton confirmed the Iranians' return home but declined to discuss related details.

It said the Australian government remained committed to supporting Cambodia's government in resettling refugees. "The Government holds firm on our policy that you if arrive by boat [to Australia] then you can either return to your country of origin or be resettled in a third country."

Australia refuses to accept any refugees who attempt to reach its shores by boat. It pays Nauru and Papua New Guinea, which has a detention center on Manus Island, to hold them instead. The deal with Cambodia, finalized in September 2014, was criticized out of concern that Cambodia was too impoverished to handle the new residents and that its poor human rights record would put them at risk.

Critics also suggested that after the volunteers were sent to Phnom Penh, the program was poorly implemented, although the International Organization for Migration and other groups in Cambodia were providing housing, jobs, transport and education in addition to initial orientation.

The post Iranian Couple in Cambodia Resettlement Deal Return Home appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Amid Repression, Art Scene in Thailand’s Capital Blooms

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 08:50 PM PST

Thai graffiti artist Asin Acid poses near his graffiti in Bangkok on March 7, 2016. (Photo: Reuters)

Thai graffiti artist Asin Acid poses near his graffiti in Bangkok on March 7, 2016. (Photo: Reuters)

BANGKOK — On a wall in a northern suburb of Bangkok "Asin Acid" puts the finishing touches to a spray-painted picture of a colorful giant chicken holding a broken loudspeaker.

"The loudspeaker represents the media. The media is trying to say something but is being interrupted," said Asin, who uses a pseudonym for his street art to protect his identity and said he is inspired by Cranio, a graffiti artist from Brazil.

"The rainbow colors represent freedom," he said.

Thailand's military seized power nearly two years ago and has censored media, hauled in hundreds of critics for sessions of "attitude adjustment" and snuffed out protests.

Junta leader Prayuth Chan-ocha has threatened to shut down news outlets critical of his government and regularly scolds journalists who he considers straying from the official line.

But state repression has unleashed a wave of artistic expression, say artists and art lovers, and the Thai capital's art scene is blooming in response to life under junta rule.

"It's because they can't talk about it that they're creating," said Gili Back, a cafe and gallery owner, referring to Bangkok's artists.

"You'll see a lot more graffiti and street art where people are having their say on walls."

Bangkok's art scene has traditionally been overlooked in favor of places like Hong Kong but in recent years venues have mushroomed with Thai and expatriate artists turning shop houses and disused spaces into galleries.

On a recent Friday night, a crowd packed into a room at the WTF Bar and Gallery to see "This is Not a Political Act" by Jirawut Ueasungkomsate, an exhibition on cases of enforced disappearance that have taken place under successive governments.

In the pitch-black room, audience members shine flashlights on black and white photographs of people, including prominent rights activists, whose whereabouts are not known.

Though not a direct commentary on the junta, it speaks about the impunity enjoyed by state officials, said Jirawut, adding that he was initially scared about holding the exhibition.

The junta, formally known as the National Council for Peace and Order, has shut down some political lectures and talks.

"It is because I am afraid that I have to do it," said Jirawut.

At "The Respectables," an exhibition by British artist Richard Mead, paintings—of fashion models, the media and political protests—depict different forms of power.

"The theme of power and 'The Respectables' really goes with the context of Thailand right now. Especially with the type of government we are under," said Teerapa Pirohakul, an art lover and history lecturer at Bangkok's Chulalongkorn University.

Across town, as his exhibition fills with the after-work crowd, Jirawut reflects on the city's art scene.

"No matter whether we are under a military or a civilian government, we need this space," he said.

"Society cannot exist if everyone thinks the same."

The post Amid Repression, Art Scene in Thailand's Capital Blooms appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

National News

National News


Yangon water supplies to outlast hot season, says YCDC

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 11:45 PM PST

Yangon has nothing to fear from El Niño, city officials say, despite warnings that the weather phenomenon will bring drought to many parts of the country. Thanks to advance planning, the reservoirs that supply the city's drinking water are 15 centimetres (6 inches) higher than they were this time last year, they say.

Bangladesh says no talks with military after Arakan Army attack

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 02:30 PM PST

The Bangladeshi embassy in Yangon has denied a statement by the Tatmadaw that the two sides are holding talks over how to coordinate actions against the Arakan Army, after the group claimed to have inflicted heavy casualties on Myanmar's military last week.

Ex-generals emerge as favourites for VP position

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 02:30 PM PST

Two former generals have been widely tipped as frontrunners for the military's vice presidency pick.

Kachin groups appeal to next government on resources

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 02:30 PM PST

Mismanagement of resources is deepening conflicts in northern Myanmar. That is the conclusion of an appeal by more than 60 civil society groups, political parties and religious organisations to the incoming National League for Democracy government to ensure power sharing and accountability in implementing mega-projects in Kachin State.

‘Plenty of bullets’ reported in Shan State fighting

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 02:30 PM PST

Government forces are stepping up offensives in northern Shan State with air strikes and artillery, according to an ethnic Palaung armed group which is fighting on two fronts and accuses the military of trying to disrupt the transition to the new National League for Democracy government.

Donors rush to prepare Magwe for big dry

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 02:30 PM PST

Amid dire predictions of drought, local officials and NGOs in Magwe Region are saying preparations have been made to ensure sufficient water supplies for most areas through the coming dry season.

Timetable set for Mandalay-Muse road

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 02:30 PM PST

A schedule has been introduced for trucks and highway buses on the traffic-plagued Mandalay-Muse trade route in a bid to ease the road's infamous backlogs and lethal accidents.

Ministry invites applications for private high school licences

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 02:30 PM PST

Those wishing to open a private school can now apply, say education officials. The education ministry says application forms will be available from the district education offices later this month.

MCDC defends cost of mayor’s stage

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 02:30 PM PST

Mandalay City Development Committee has come under fire after it announced a 50 percent spending increase on the mayor's Thingyan pandal.

Court to rule on ANP rep’s case

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 02:30 PM PST

Mrauk-U District Court will next week decide an appeal against a six-month prison term handed down to a newly elected Arakan National Party politician. The verdict will also have an effect on the dynamics of the state hluttaw, with the potential to knock the ANP one peg further from its near majority.

Shan Herald Agency for News

Shan Herald Agency for News


To Hopeland and Back ( Day Two )

Posted: 09 Mar 2016 03:35 AM PST


Day Two, Thursday, 3 March 2016

When dealing with people, remember you are not dealing with creatures of logic, but with creatures of emotion.
Dale Carnegie

MiCasa (My Home) hotel is where we are meeting today. It is the 5th bi-annual meeting since the Committee for Shan State Unity (CSSU) was formed over two years ago. A belated one, you may say, because previously scheduled for August 2015, the nationwide campaigns for the November elections had intervened.

It is also the first time  it is being held inside the country, as pointed out by Sao Yawdserk, the outgoing annual chair of the alliance, during his opening address.

Among the high profile participants, apart from him, are Hkun Tun Oo, Gen Hso Ten, Sao Gaifa, Sai Nyunt Lwin aka Sai Nood, Sai Leik aka Sai La and Peun Kham Payakwong,  the CSSU's outgoing secretary. Also obvious by his absence is Sai Ai Pao, leader of the Shan Nationalities Democratic Party (SNDP), although he is reported to be in Rangoon.

The reason for his non- attendance is spelled  out by an explanatory note from the party which is read out by Peun Kham:

The Central Committee's tenure ended on 31 January and the party has fixed 20 March for its new election. In the meanwhile, there are no CC members to represent the party, it says.

Then comes the report by the Secretary General. The crowning success of the CSSU, according to him, is marked by the agreement on the 12 guiding principles for Shan Stateconstitution and the 23 basic principles for the future federal union.  ( See attachment)

It has also begun coordination with non- Shan groups, notably, PaO, Intha and Danu, with the aim to invite them for membership during the upcoming bi-annual conferences.

The cardinal aim of CSSU is to put forward a common proposal to the Union Peace Conference.

Below are the excerpted comments on the report by the other participants:

·        The report has little or no analysis of current world and internal situation. This needs to be improved in future conferences.
·        The world used to have a Yugoslaviabefore. Today it is gone.  Shan Stateis in danger of undergoing the same fate.

Next on the item is the relinquishment of the chair to the conference that has to elect a new successor.

According to Peun Kham, the SNDP is next in line. Moreover, it had already agreed last year to take over from the RCSS. However, due to its non-attendance and the CSSU can't go forward without a chair, the meeting, after a debate, passes a resolution to hand over the chair to the next, next in line, the SSJAC. Hkun Tun Oo himself rises up to accept the office, saying, " I'm already chairing the SNLD, SSJAC, UNA (United  Nationalities Alliance) and the 1990 winning parties coalition. What's more, our party is likely to lose some of our hardworking leading members to the new government to be formed. But I had never sidestepped duty when it was given. And I'm not going to do that now."

The burly Hkun Tun Oo receives a huge applause from the meeting.

Before the meeting adjourns for the day, there is an unexpected visit, in the form of problem. An official directive says the conference cannot continue without  permission.

I accompany Sai Nood, Sai La and Sai Kyaw Nyunt (SNLD member and secretary to the Union Peace Dialogue Joint Committee) to the Western District GAD (General Administrative    Department).

The GAD, as most readers informed about the country, permeates the whole administrative system up from the President's Office down to the village level.  

Takes us half an hour to get there and another hour to meet the officer, who's assigned the job of explaining why it can't grant permission. At least he is polite and patient, even if he is practically saying no to his visitors:

·        The application (which was written two hours ago) is not in order. No letters of recommendation from the ward and the township police concerned.
·        In any case, the district GAD's job is to submit the application upstairs.   It is only the regional chief minister's office that is empowered to give a decision.

The organizing committee's initial reaction is to go ahead with the conference at the hotel (tomorrow, it will be at Summit Parkview). "And if there is a showdown," one of the organizers says, "everyone will know democracy in this country is but the emperor's new clothes."

However, sometime toward the evening, the hotel management informs the committee that it has been warned by the authorities not to allow the conference to be held within its premises.

Everything thus seems to be in limbo when I get back to the hotel.

By SAI KHUENSAI / Director of Pyidaungsu Institute and Founder of Shan Herald Agency for News (S.H.A.N)
All views expressed are the author's own



Tuesday, March 8, 2016

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Endangered Irrawaddy Dolphin Population On the Rise

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 05:27 AM PST

A fisherman waits for a tail-swishing signal from a dolphin to begin a cooperative fishing session. (Photo: Teza Hlaing / The Irrawaddy)

A fisherman waits for a tail-swishing signal from a dolphin to begin a cooperative fishing session. (Photo: Teza Hlaing / The Irrawaddy)

MANDALAY – Burma's endangered Irrawaddy dolphin population increased this year, according to a survey by the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS).

The survey was conducted in February in the Irrawaddy River between Mandalay and Kachin State's Bhamo. It found 65 dolphins, including three babies. The previous 2015 survey found 58 dolphins in the protection area, and three that had died in 2014.

"The total we found in February is quite satisfactory," said Kyaw Hla Thein, a project coordinator with WCS. "We hope the number continues to increase, especially since we found three babies, swimming beside their mothers."

A 230-mile stretch of the Irrawaddy River from Mingun to Kyauk Myaung in Sagaing Division was designated as a wildlife protection zone in 2005. The area has strict measures in place to protect the dolphins, but rules go largely unenforced.

Catching or killing dolphins is prohibited, as is trading their meat. A ban on electro-fishing and regulations on the types of nets permitted are also intended to protect the species, which is listed as critically endangered in Burma.

According to WCS, the number of Irrawaddy dolphins found in the protection zone was fewer than 20 between 2007-2009. The number of dolphins increased dramatically after 2010, to 86.

However, in 2014, the number declined to 63, which shocked researchers. The deaths were attributed to electro-fishing, which is illegal in the country. Despite threats of jail time, the practice continues.

"We are still struggling to stop the electro fishing," said Kyaw Hla Thein. "Many still use this illegal method, threatening the lives of the dolphins and depleting fish stocks."

Despite the efforts of the WCS and the government's Fishery Department to stop the practice, attempts have been unsuccessful. But drawing the attention of foreign tourists and researchers has indirectly helped.

"On the bright side, the tourists' interest in the dolphins has somehow persuaded local fisherman to protect [the dolphins]," he said. "This, along with our education programs, has resulted in the increase in population."

The post Endangered Irrawaddy Dolphin Population On the Rise appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

10 Things to Do in Rangoon This Week

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 04:40 AM PST

EVENT

Invitational flyers for a host of events in the commercial capital this week.

The Irrawaddy picks 10 interesting events, ranging from dance and punk to arts shows, happening in Rangoon this week.

 

Various Events

BigB

Music – Punk

Big Bag, the punk rock music band, will stage a show.

Where: People's Park on Pyay Rd.  When: Fri March 11. Time: Starts at 6pm

ora

Music – Classical

Orchestra for Myanmar and a choir made up of children from local international schools will stage a show bringing musicians together from a range of organizations including the AOC Orchestra, Gitameit Music Center, the University of Arts and Culture, MIT, Ame Gita and MRTV.

Where: Strand Hotel, When: Fri 11 March. Time: Starts at 7pm

Technology

All things to do with mobile technology will be on show at the Mobile, Communication with Satellite Expo 2016.

Where: Tatmadaw Hall, U Wizara Road. Tel: 094-3096-666; 094-2000-1617

When: Sun 13 March ,Time: 9am – 5pm

photo-1

Yangon Photo Festival

The eighth edition of this festival under the patronage of Aung San Suu Kyi has the title: "Eyewitness: Myanmar by Myanmar Photographers." The festival of various exhibitions will be held at five galleries—River Gallery, Pansuriya Gallery, Myanmar Deitta, Goethe Villa, Rough Cut, and Institut Francais de Birmanie (French Institute), until March 31. For full information, visit yangonphotos.com/exhibitions. On Saturday, March 12, a selection of the best photos will be shown at the French Institut. Prizes, will be awarded by a jury of international photo personalities.

Where:  Various locations (above), When:    Sat 12 to Thurs 31 March

Zumba

Classes in the Brazilian dance are held every Tuesday and Thursday night.

Where:  Piano Bar at 2 Parami Road, Mayangone Township.

When: Tuesdays, Thursdays. Time: 6.30 to 7.30pm

 Art shows

San Minn 14th One Man Show Installation Series copy

Installations

Artist San Minn will display around 30 of his installation works dating back more than 10 years in his 14th one-man show.

Where: Think Art Gallery, 23, Nawaday Street, Dagon Township. Tel:  094-2016-2858

When: Tues 8 to Sat 12 March.  Time: 9am – 5pm    

Motion & Emotion copy

Motion and Emotion

Thabye Myint Thein and Soe Naing feature in a show of around 70 oil paintings titled Motion & Emotion. Prices from around $100 to $500. The event's brochure states: "When matter moves, motion starts. When mind moves, emotion starts. This event is a narration about how matter and mind move together."

Where: Lokanat Galleries, No. 62, Pansodan Street. Tel: 092-5004-1424

When: Wed 9 to Sun 13 March. Time: 9am – 5pm

6 YEAR COLLECTION OF AN LOVER copy

Collector's Choice

A collection titled "Six Years Collection of An Art Lover" will feature the works of 11 artists, including Khin Maung Than, Aung Maung and Myint Swe.

Where: Gallery 65,  65  Yaw Min Gyi Street, Dagon Township. Tel: 01 246317

When: Sat 12 to Wed 16 March. Time: 10am – 5 pm

The Value art exhibition copy

Feet First

A debut solo show from 23-year-old Nyan Ye Naing is titled "The Value" and will feature 34 watercolor paintings of footwear. Prices from around $35 to $200.  "People have to use footwear every day, but usually they fail to notice the value of a pair of slippers which brings them where they want to go and bears their weight the whole time," says the artist.

Where:  Cloud 31 Gallery, No. 49/51. 1st Floor, 31st St (lower Block), Pabedan Township. Tel: 097-8510-4231

When: Fri 11 to Tues 15 March. Time:  9am – 5pm

The Myanmar Eminent artists exhibition copy

Eminent

A show featuring mainly acrylics and oils by 12 eminent Burmese artists.

Where: Embassy of the Republic of Korea, 97, University Avenue Road. Tel: 095-0058-49

When:  Wed 11 to Sun 15 March. Time:  Office hours

The post 10 Things to Do in Rangoon This Week appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Burma Army Chief’s Fixation on Ethnic Disarmament Hinders Peace Process

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 04:21 AM PST

Min Aung Hlaing

Burma Army Commander-in-chief Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing looks at pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi during talks at the Presidential palace at Naypyidaw on April 10, 2015. (Photo: Soe Zeya Tun / Reuters)

As armed conflict intensifies amidst both an ongoing peace process and a democratic transition, the time has come for the Burma Army to change its mindset if it truly wishes to build peace with the country's many ethnic groups.

Fighting broke out in one Kachin State location in June 2011, between the Burma Army and the Kachin Independence Organization. Five years later, at the end of outgoing President Thein Sein's term, armed conflict with government forces has spread to ethnic Palaung (Ta'ang), Shan, Arakan, Karen and Kokang areas.

Governmental power will soon be transferred to Aung San Suu Kyi's National League for Democracy (NLD), the winner of November's general elections. Many ethnic armed groups wish to seek peace under her leadership, but they dare not offer full trust to the Burmese government as long as there are military men who continue to attack them on their land. The Burma Army will remain an important political player, but one that has repeatedly shown itself to be an obstacle to peace and democracy in the country.

lawei

Lawi Weng is a Senior Reporter for The Irrawaddy English edition.

Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing, commander-in-chief of the Burma Army, has spoken of professionalizing the military in line with Burma's political reforms, which were initiated in 2011. He has reminded the military to treat civilians more humanely, to end the recruitment of child soldiers and the reliance on forced labor.

But one thing that has not appeared to have changed is Min Aung Hlaing's insistence that ethnic armed groups operate under his command. This has hurt Burma's peace process and contributed to intensified fighting in northern Shan State, where government offensives encourage ethnic armed groups to build up troop numbers, vowing not to disarm under the current conditions. Large numbers of internally displaced civilians in Kachin and Shan states is a reminder that reforms have not impacted these areas.

There is no guarantee that Min Aung Hlaing's views on disarmament will evolve with a new NLD-led government. The Burma Army's hope is that the ethnic armed groups will one day act as militias which defend government interests in their respective regions. For those who refuse to participate, the Burma Army will likely deploy more troops to their areas, surrounding and isolating the groups in order to pressure them to give up their struggle.

Most ethnic armed leaders do not speak of disarmament as an option; they believe they may need to fight again. They feel that their armies exist to protect their people and their regions, and to provide them with a power platform in the country. If they cease to be armed, the groups worry that the government may no longer listen to them.

These groups are aware of Min Aung Hlaing's intentions, and they continue to reinforce troops to defend against the Burma Army, even amidst the ongoing peace process. While ethnic armed groups feel that they need to pursue peace, if left with no other choice, they will continue to use force to fight for their goals.

Lawi Weng is a senior reporter for The Irrawaddy.

The post Burma Army Chief's Fixation on Ethnic Disarmament Hinders Peace Process appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

NLD Announces Second ‘Official’ Party Voice

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 03:54 AM PST

Zaw Myint Maung, a sitting lawmaker in the Mandalay regional legislature, is pictured in Naypyidaw in February. (Photo: Myo Min Soe / The Irrawaddy)

Zaw Myint Maung, a sitting lawmaker in the Mandalay regional legislature, is pictured in Naypyidaw in February. (Photo: Myo Min Soe / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — The National League for Democracy (NLD) designated an additional spokesperson on Tuesday, doubling the exclusive club of those allowed to speak officially on party matters, after chairwoman Aung San Suu Kyi was earlier this year declared the party's lone voice of authority.

A statement released by the party's central committee said Zaw Myint Maung of the Mandalay divisional legislature had been assigned as "an additional spokesperson for the party's policies and the transitional process."

In January, the NLD announced Suu Kyi as "sole spokesperson" on party matters after senior NLD member Nyan Win was quoted by Agence France‑Presse (AFP) revealing details on prospective candidates for legislative speakerships in the Union Parliament.

An apparent breach of NLD plans for the official rollout of its speakerships roster, the party quickly sought to cast doubt on Nyan Win's remarks, which ultimately proved to be true. The confusion highlighted what has been an opaque NLD march to the halls of power in Naypyidaw.

The party has defended the aversion to divulging details in recent months by saying its leadership had to "handle things delicately at present," amid an uncertain transition period ahead of a handover of power at the end of March.

A medical doctor by training, Zaw Myint Maung has been tipped as a prospective candidate for chief minister of Mandalay Division. He is an NLD central committee member and was recently appointed to a five-member NLD "secretary group." He is a former political prisoner who served 19 years behind bars and won a seat representing the NLD in Burma's abortive 1990 election, the results of which were ignored by the ruling military junta of the time.

The NLD is expected to reveal its pick for the presidency this week, with that individual due to take the reins of government on April 1. Suu Kyi is barred from assuming Burma's highest civilian office, owing to a contentious constitutional provision on presidential eligibility that disqualifies those with spouses or children of foreign nationality.

The NLD leader's two sons are British, as was her late husband.

The post NLD Announces Second 'Official' Party Voice appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Can Burma’s Human Rights Commission Fight Sexual Violence in Conflict Areas?

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 02:09 AM PST

Ethnic Kachin refugees in a camp for internally displaced people near the capital of Myitkyina in Kachin State in July 2015. (Photo: Soe Zeya Tun / Reuters)

Ethnic Kachin refugees in a camp for internally displaced people near the capital of Myitkyina in Kachin State in July 2015. (Photo: Soe Zeya Tun / Reuters)

RANGOON — The Myanmar National Human Rights Commission (MNHRC) has said they are ready to address cases of sexual violence perpetrated by the Burma Army, but rights groups remain skeptical of the commission's ability to achieve justice.

"If there are women being abused in the conflict areas, we want them to make complaints to the MNHRC, but they haven't done it so far," Dr. Than Nwe of MNHRC'S Policy and Law section, told The Irrawaddy. "If some cases are related to the military, we would ask the military for an explanation."

Lway Cherry, secretary of the ethnic Ta'ang Women's Union and policy board member of the Women's League of Burma (WLB), explained that trust in the commission depended on the results that the government-founded investigative body was able to achieve.

"So far we have not heard about the sexual abuses cases shared with the MNHRC being fairly solved," she said, adding that rights groups have long been sending evidence of military-perpetrated sexual violence both to government and non-government bodies, in search of justice for the victims.

While MNHRC members insist that they help as much as they can regarding crimes against women in conflict areas, in more than three years of operation, few cases related to the military's reported campaigns of systematic sexual violence against ethnic women have been pursued by the commission.

On Wednesday, which is also International Women's Day, the WLB highlighted in a public statement the need for "better justice" regarding cases of sexual violence against women in Burma's conflict zones.

"The rapists or perpetrators are still being given impunity," the statement said.

In November 2015, the WLB, the Kachin Women's Association of Thailand (KWAT) and the Shan Human Rights Foundation (SHRF) reported that sexual violence perpetrated by the Burma Army remains ongoing in ethnic areas. SHRF cited eight cases of rape in as many months in Shan State, all allegedly by government troops. SHRF added that such crimes are rarely prosecuted.

Many of the gender-based cases that the MNHRC handles are related to the issue of sexual harassment in the workplace, on which Dr. Than Nwe feels the commission has dealt with effectively.

"We try to solve [these cases] by meeting the relevant ministries. We are now working with UN Women on the issue," said Dr. Than Nwe.  "We were able to intervene by informing the respective ministries. They are required to respond to us within a month. They can not ignore and hide as they must respond us."

Burma Partnership, who has monitored and investigated the commission's work, laments that the MNHRC has "been unable to uphold its mandate of human rights protection and promotion." They attribute this to a lack of "independence, effectiveness and transparency," due to government ties.

The post Can Burma's Human Rights Commission Fight Sexual Violence in Conflict Areas? appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Inspiring Women of Burma  

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 12:25 AM PST

Ethnic Lisu women wait for the arrival of pro-democracy leader Aung San Suu Kyi in Hsihseng Township in Shan State on September 5, 2015. (Photo: Soe Zeya Tun / Reuters)

Ethnic Lisu women wait for the arrival of pro-democracy
leader Aung San Suu Kyi in Hsihseng Township in Shan State on September 5,
2015. (Photo: Soe Zeya Tun / Reuters)

Today is International Woman's Day, when people around the world mark the achievements and challenges of half of humanity.

There is no denying that in this country that one woman above all others dominates the national consciousness.

Aung San Suu Kyi enjoys unrivalled stature at home and huge respect abroad. This month she holds the hopes of the nation's recent voters in her hands as she prepares—from whatever official position—to shepherd her party and the country into unchartered political territory.

It is sometimes forgotten that Burma has always had great female figures who have risen to the challenges of the day to help shape the nation's social and political life.

In the early 20th century when the country was under colonial rule, women were active in the nationalist movement that culminated in independence in 1948.

More recently, women from all backgrounds and ethnicities have played important roles in the country's struggles towards democracy and social justice.

Many more have overcome significant barriers to become leaders in the worlds of business, the arts, education and entertainment, among others.

This week the Irrawaddy will revisit some of the women who have featured in our coverage of Burma over the last two decades, and who continue to play a vital part in the transition to a more democratic future.

Today, we briefly reprise the careers of three significant women whose past and current activities highlight just a few of the arenas in which female figures are making positive contributions to the nation's social and political life.

Zin Mar Aung: Zin Mar Aung, Lower House lawmaker with the NLD. (Photo: The Irrawaddy)

Zin Mar Aung: Zin Mar Aung, Lower House lawmaker with the NLD. (Photo: The Irrawaddy)

Zin Mar Aung

Before she became an elected lawmaker with the National League for Democracy in last year's election, Zin Mar Aung was well known for having spent 11 years behind bars as a human rights activist.

The 40-year-old who is now sitting in the Lower House of Parliament representing Rangoon's Yankin Township, also serves as a member of the same house's Public Affairs Administration Committee.

In one of her first debates within the parliament she urged the government to review its drug eradication program, pointing out that in some parts of the country, ''there is no electricity, but drugs are easily available.''

She is known for her outspoken criticism of a controversial law restricting interfaith marriages, a stance for which extreme nationalists sent her hate mail and death threats.

"The proposal was unacceptable because it was based on extreme nationalism and religious extremism. It interfered with individual freedoms and particularly with the personal choices of women," she said.

Zin Mar Aung is a co-founder of the Yangon School of Political Science. She has also founded an organization titled Rainfall to encourage greater women's participation as the country moves toward democracy.

Thanks to her long time devotion to human rights, Zin Mar Aung was selected as an International Woman of Courage in 2012 and as a Young Global Leader at the World Economic Forum in 2014.

Ma Thandar: Ma Thandar, co-founder of the Women and Peace Network and Lower House lawmaker. (Photo: The Irrawaddy)

Ma Thandar: Ma Thandar, co-founder of the Women and Peace Network and Lower House lawmaker. (Photo: The Irrawaddy)

Ma Thandar

Long before she made headlines for seeking justice in relation the death in military custody of her husband Par Gyi in 2014, Ma Thandar was a leading political activist.

She was known especially for fighting on justice, women rights and land grabbing issues, along with her fellow activists who co-founded the Women and Peace Network.

Ma Thandar's victory in last year's general election has taken her to the Lower House as a lawmaker, and last month she also became a member of the Citizens' Fundamental Rights Committee.

She is hopeful about the possibilities her new positions may open up.

"I believe I will get more opportunities now, including to collaborate with the Home Affairs and Justice ministries, and the judiciary, to push for citizen's rights," she told The Irrawaddy.

Though two soldiers initially implicated in her husband's death were acquitted by a military tribunal, Ma Thandar's call for answers on the case prompted the army to make an unprecedented statement admitting the journalist had been shot in custody.

During her appeal for her husband's justice, she said: "If justice can be done for my husband, the truth may also be revealed for others who were killed unnoticed like him, and we can prevent this from being repeated."

Ja Nan: Ja Nan Lahtaw, director of the Myitkyina-based Nyein Foundation and technical advisor to Burma's peace process. (Photo: Nyein Nyein / The Irrawaddy)

Ja Nan: Ja Nan Lahtaw, director of the Myitkyina-based Nyein Foundation and technical advisor to Burma's peace process. (Photo: Nyein Nyein / The Irrawaddy)

Ja Nan Lahtaw

Ja Nan Lahtaw is one of only a handful of women privy to the inner workings of the peace process.

The director of the Nyein Foundation, a long-time local development organization that also operates as a peace facilitation group, she is among a small cadre of professionals working as technical advisors to the process.

The Nyein Foundation is also known as ''Shalom'' and is based in the Kachin State capital of Myitkyina.

For her activities Ja Nan has been the recipient of a number of international honors including a prestigious N-Peace Award, which she received last year.

Born in Myitkyina in 1965, Ja Nan was schooled abroad before she returned home and followed in the footsteps of her predecessors. The Nyein Foundation was established by her father, a reverend and former director general of the Kachin Baptist Convention (KBC), who along with his brother was a key broker of the 1994 ceasefire between the Burmese government and the Kachin Independence Organization (KIO).

Ja Nan has said that peace brokering is "something of a family tradition."

The post Inspiring Women of Burma   appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Kachin Groups Urge Halt to Resource Extraction in Northern Burma

Posted: 08 Mar 2016 12:16 AM PST

Trucks are seen at a mine dumping site at a Hpakant jade mine in Kachin State on Nov. 25, 2015. (Photo: Soe Zeya Tun / Reuters)

Trucks are seen at a mine dumping site at a Hpakant jade mine in Kachin State on Nov. 25, 2015. (Photo: Soe Zeya Tun / Reuters)

More than 60 civil society organizations, political parties and religious groups representing the Kachin and ethnic subgroups released a statement on Monday calling for a halt to resource extraction in northern Burma's Kachin State until political stability in the region can be achieved.

The groups put forward the demand after holding a forum to discuss natural resource governance in Kachin State, in the regional capital Myitkyina.

The statement, made by 61 signatory groups, called on respective stakeholders to "stop all project operations and natural resource extraction in ethnic areas without [first] resolving conflict politically," adding that strife in the region was fueled by natural resource-based interests.

Kachin State is rich in natural resources such as gold, jade and other precious stones, as well as a significant but shrinking endowment of teakwood forests. The state has also been fertile grounds for conflict in recent years, particularly since a 17-year ceasefire between the Kachin Independence Army (KIA) and Burmese government collapsed in 2011.

Monday's statement asserted that the Kachin people were the rightful owners of the state's natural resource endowment, urging business stakeholders to "disclose all information transparently and educate the people—on grievance mechanisms in natural resource extraction, taxation, licensing processes, revenue-sharing—with consideration for the 'right to know' of the people."

The coalition also called on the government to "ensure free, prior and informed consent with local communities before issuing operational permissions for any projects."

The statement proposed empowering the Kachin State government with "ultimate management authority" on natural resource extraction, taxation and revenue-sharing.

The post Kachin Groups Urge Halt to Resource Extraction in Northern Burma appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

From Myanmar Sweatshops to Billionaires in Switzerland

Posted: 07 Mar 2016 11:27 PM PST

 Workers from Myue & Soe Garment Factory stand in front of the Mayangone Township Labor Office in Rangoon during a protest for salary increases on September 7, 2012. (Photo: Soe Zeya Tun / Reuters)

Workers from Myue & Soe Garment Factory stand in front of the Mayangone Township Labor Office in Rangoon during a protest for salary increases on September 7, 2012. (Photo: Soe Zeya Tun / Reuters)

The young garment factory workers share a tiny room in a wooden shack, spotlessly clean, with pictures of Myanmar pop stars beside a photo of their parents back in the village. But there is no escaping the smell of the open drain outside. The three sisters and their cousin all work in factories making clothes for export to the UK, United States and other countries for household brands such as GAP, Primark, H&M and Tesco. They belong to a labor rights group working with Oxfam to fight for better conditions for workers, and we are there to hear about their experiences on the factory floor. Myanmar's garment sector is expanding fast, now employing around 300,000 people–90 percent female and mostly under age 25.

Daily average wages of US$2.80 are not enough to survive on. Oxfam's recent survey found that almost half of garment workers are trapped in debt and have to borrow money to meet basic needs like food, medicine and transport. They work up to 11 hours a day, six days a week, rarely receiving sick pay despite this being a legal requirement. Many reported working into the night to meet impossible production targets, on one occasion sewing until 6.30am before restarting at 7.30am every day for a week. Safety was a big concern, with one in three reporting a workplace injury and many afraid of factory fires because of blocked exits.

In the week we visited Myanmar, Oxfam's report 'An Economy for the 1%' caused a stir at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, revealing that 62 billionaires now own the same wealth as the poorest half of the world. The report shows that the global economic system is skewed in favor of the top one percent, who have seen half of the total increase in global wealth in the past 15 years, while the bottom 50 percent have had to make do with just one percent.

Interestingly four of the world's 62 richest billionaires made their fortunes in high-street fashion. Amancio Ortega of Spain, worth $64 billion, heads garment giant Inditex, owner of Zara. Swede Stefan Persson, worth $24 billion, is chairman of H&M and a 28 percent stakeholder. Tadashi Yanai of Japan owns Uniqlo and is worth $20 billion. The fourth is Phil Knight, who until June 2015 had spent 51 years as chairman of Nike, and is worth $21 billion.

H&M buys from factories in Myanmar and Uniqlo is considering doing so. Inditex pioneered the model of shorter supply chains and reduced lead times, now the norm in fast fashion. But this business practice puts huge pressure on suppliers and their workers, leading to forced overtime and pressure to squeeze wages as low as possible.

H&M does at least publish which factories produce its clothes in Myanmar. Many big brands refuse to even do this. As one of my colleagues put it, 'Can you think of one good reason why a high street brand would want to hide where its clothes are made?' Both H&M and Inditex have taken steps to address poverty wages, for instance by signing an agreement with global union IndustriALL to promote sector bargaining. However, between 2001 and 2011 wages for garment workers in most of the top 15 apparel-exporting countries fell in real terms.

Some commentators have accused Oxfam of being anti capitalist for throwing rocks at an economic system than has helped to reduce global poverty. It is of course true that real progress has been made. The young women we met now earn more than the extreme poverty line of $1.90 a day, so are no longer officially counted as poor. But is that really good enough?

Oxfam recognizes the power of capitalism to transform people's lives – but we believe the current warped 'market fundamentalist' model, as the Bank of England Governor calls it, is failing us all. Matthew Paris, a former Conservative MP writing about our Davos report in The Times newspaper, put it best when he said that listening to those trying to defend today's capitalist system reminded him of Communists trying to defend the USSR: 'How much longer, then, can we market liberals shrug off huge failures in the working examples we have of capitalism?…If the free market is to be defended in the new century, these inequities are no longer something from which the center-right can turn away.'

Throughout our history, the majority of those who fought to stop children having to go to work, or for a ten hour working day, or for a weekend, or paid holiday, sick pay and above all for wages which allow ordinary women and men to live a decent life were not anti-capitalists.  They just believed we could do better. Activists of the past were dismissed as naive or seditious or both, but what they fought for we now see as being a part of a civilized society.

Today we have to continue that fight. We need to make capitalism work for the majority rather than the top 1 percent. This can be done. For example, a critical mass of companies could commit to source from countries with good labor regulation, adapt their business practices so factories can afford to pay a living wage and ensure workers are free to negotiate with management.

We have the talent, technology and imagination to build a more human economy—one where we have not just minimum wages, but maximum ones too. Where we see an end to this extreme wealth that benefits no one but a tiny elite.

When I met those young women in Myanmar learning about their rights, and the successful struggles of other garment workers in Thailand and Cambodia, I was filled with hope for the future.  For a better, fairer, future they will fight for. I know I want to do all I can to help them.

Max Lawson is Oxfam's Head of Global Campaigns. This article originally ran on Oxfam's blog, From Poverty to Power.  

The post From Myanmar Sweatshops to Billionaires in Switzerland appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Philippine Rebel Warns Islamic State May Gain From Autonomy Delay

Posted: 07 Mar 2016 10:02 PM PST

Moro National Liberation Front rebels take up position at a guard post in Maguindanao province, in the southern Philippines, on March 12, 2015. (Photo: Reuters)

Moro National Liberation Front rebels take up position at a guard post in Maguindanao province, in the southern Philippines, on March 12, 2015. (Photo: Reuters)

KUALA LUMPUR — The head of a Philippine Muslim rebel group warned Monday that the Islamic State group could gain from frustrations in the country's south following the failure of the Philippine Congress to pass an autonomy bill as part of a peace agreement.

Murad Ebrahim, chairman of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front, said the militant IS group has attempted over the past year to recruit supporters in Mindanao but his group has worked to convince people that the peace pact signed with the government in 2014 was the best solution.

But he said the delay in enactment of the bill that aims to establish a more powerful and better-funded autonomous region for minority Muslims has led to frustrations that could be capitalized on by the IS and other small hardline rebel groups.

Malaysia is a facilitator in the peace talks, and Murad spoke while passing through Kuala Lumpur.

"There have been some efforts of penetration [by IS] but they have not succeeded in establishing a stronghold in Mindanao," he said during a news conference. "But now after the non-passage of the [bill], we are quite concerned that they can capitalize on this because the [frustration] of the people in the area is now very strong."

In Manila, Philippine presidential adviser on the peace talks Teresita Deles agreed that "frustrations of the people on the ground can lead to recruitment for radical, extremist thought and action."

However, Philippine security forces with the help of the Moro rebels have curbed the spread of extremism and maintained peace and order through joint government and rebel ceasefire committees, Deles said.

The 11,000-strong Moro Islamic Liberalization Front dropped its secessionist bid and settled for broader autonomy for minority Muslims in the south of the largely Roman Catholic nation in a Malaysian-brokered pact it signed with the Philippine government in 2014. The conflict has left 150,000 people dead and stunted development in the country's poorest region.

Under the deal, a bill was submitted to Congress to create the autonomous region to be called Bangsamoro. The bill's passage was stalled by anger over the killing last year of 44 police commandos in fighting that involved some fighters from the Moro group.

Lawmakers ended the last regular session of their term last month without passing the bill.

Murad said his group will not completely abandon its armed struggle but will not revert to violence as long as the peace process has a chance of moving forward. He said he is hopeful that the new Philippine president, to be elected later this year, will support and continue the efforts for peace.

The post Philippine Rebel Warns Islamic State May Gain From Autonomy Delay appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

MH370 Families’ Painful Choice: Demand Answers or Move On?

Posted: 07 Mar 2016 09:42 PM PST

 Family of passengers onboard of Malaysia Airlines flight MH370, which went missing in 2014, hold placards as they shout slogans in front of a holding area for journalists at Lama Temple in Beijing on March 8, 2016. (Photo: Reuters)

Family of passengers onboard of Malaysia Airlines flight MH370, which went missing in 2014, hold placards as they shout slogans in front of a holding area for journalists at Lama Temple in Beijing on March 8, 2016. (Photo: Reuters)

BEIJING — Nearly every day, the retired factory worker goes to the airline office, riding a series of buses across Beijing to hand-deliver a letter. And nearly every day, the letter says the same thing.

"Tell us the truth, and get our loved ones back to us."

Once she hands over the letter, Dai Shuqin gets back on the bus and goes home, back to a small apartment where boxes hold copies of hundreds of letters she has delivered over the past two years, all begging for news on her sister and four other relatives who vanished when Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 disappeared on March 8, 2014. There were 239 people on board.

Most of the passengers on the plane, which was en route from Kuala Lumpur to Beijing, were Chinese. So across China, dozens of families are still wrestling with how—or if—to accept that their relatives are dead. Investigators believe the Boeing 777 crashed in a remote stretch of the southern Indian Ocean, killing everyone on board after flying far off course and running out of fuel. But they have only theories to explain exactly what happened, or why. Only one confirmed piece of plane wreckage has been found, a battered, rowboat-sized wing part that washed up on an Indian Ocean island about eight months ago.

What can you do when you don't know what happened to people you loved?

Some of the grieving families have filed lawsuits, including 12 families who did so Monday. Some have accepted cash settlements with Malaysia Airlines in exchange for agreeing not to file suit. Many are still debating what to do.

And some, like Dai, find their only solace comes in believing that their relatives are still alive. Somewhere. Somehow. As a result, their lives are now consumed by demanding answers from an airline that has few answers at all.

"People say we are nuts," said Dai, a 62-year-old woman whose younger sister was on the flight, along with her sister's husband, son, daughter-in-law and grandson. "But for us, we have the feeling that our loved ones are still alive."

Officials "just tell us all the passengers are dead. We don't accept that. If they tell us the truth, or give us a convincing explanation, then we'll stop coming here every day."

She does not care if her quest looks impossible.

"I can't sleep and I can't get over this," Dai said.

Her apartment has few decorations beyond a large world map stuck to one wall. A folding metal table is covered with copies of letters sent to the airline.

"I have no other ways to handle this. … Going to Malaysia Airlines every day gives me a bit of relief, and I feel I am doing something for my sister."

Many relatives believe the real story of MH370 has been hidden from them. They disagree on what may have happened, debating theories and trading facts and rumors. But few believe they know the entire truth.

That suspicion is heightened in China, where widespread censorship and the official control of access to information has led to a general sense among Chinese that what they see in the media, or hear from the government, is not to be trusted. This widespread cynicism foments a quiet if deep-seated anger, and a willingness to accept conspiracy theories.

Kelly Wen, who runs a furniture store, is desperate to move on, to find a way to start her life again after her husband disappeared with the plane.

But she remains overwhelmed by the loss.

"My family is still in the shadow of the MH370 accident," said Wen, a 31-year-old Beijing resident with a 5-year-old son now left without a father. "I can't work like I did before because there are too many issues I need to handle in my family. But I do hope I can gradually walk out of the accident and go back to work."

With the second anniversary approaching, Wen increasingly believes she needs to make up her mind about what to do.

"I need to decide whether to accept compensation and reach agreement with Malaysian Airlines or file suit in court," she said.

She and some 80 other relatives of MH370 passengers went together to meet Malaysia Airlines staff in late February to get updates on the situation. From the start, it did not go well. Outside the airline office were nearly two dozen policemen in case there was trouble.

When they left, few of the relatives were satisfied.

They had come with detailed questions about the status of the search and the investigation. Wen wanted to see security video of passengers boarding the aircraft. The search is expected to end in June, plane or no plane, and they wanted more details on that decision.

But no security video was released, she said, and little new information emerged. Few of the relatives have faith in the official investigation, which was set up by Malaysia and includes experts from Malaysia, Australia, China, Britain, the United States and France.

"We hope we can have a third-party, independent investigation when they stop search-and-rescue in June," she said.

After the meeting, about 10 members of the group ate lunch together in a nearby restaurant.

"This kind of gathering is very important for us," said Wen. "We are already so helpless. If we don't gather among other relatives, we will feel even more lonely," she said.

Dai, however, doesn't think much about moving on. For the foreseeable future, her life is about delivering the letters that she and other relatives have signed.

A year ago, her only daughter had a baby, her only grandchild. Now, her daughter wants Dai to look after the little boy.

But Dai says that won't happen. Going to the airline office takes up too much of her time.

Sullivan reported from New Delhi.

The post MH370 Families' Painful Choice: Demand Answers or Move On? appeared first on The Irrawaddy.