Friday, April 27, 2018

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


KNPP, Gov’t Agree to Further Peace Negotiations

Posted: 27 Apr 2018 07:14 AM PDT

CHIANG MAI, Thailand – Formal peace talks between the government and the Karenni National Progressive Party (KNPP) have made progress, with the two sides agreeing to create a mechanism for further negotiations as well as discussing military affairs, negotiators said on Friday.

"We established a mechanism that would actually guarantee peace and sustain peace in [Kayah] State" before signing the NCA, said Shwe Myo Thant, the general secretary of the KNPP.

The government and KNPP met for formal talks for two days on April 26-27 in Loikaw, the capital of Kayah (Karenni) state, and agreed on the implementation of bilateral terms through regular discussions at the state level.

U Kyaw Tint Swe, minister of the Office of the State Counselor and vice chairman of the National Reconciliation and Peace Center (NRPC), led the government delegation accompanied by Peace Commission chairman Dr. Tin Myo Win, along with commission members and advisers. The talks were also joined by Lieutenant-General Than Tun Oo, the commander of the Defense Ministry's No. 2 Bureau of Special Operations; Kayah State chief minister L Paung Sho; and Kayah State Security and Border Affairs Minister Colonel Myint Wai.

The KNPP's Peace Negotiation Committee was led by General Bee Htoo, who was accompanied by eight committee members. Absent was Khu Oo Reh, the KNPP's vice chairman and its key peace negotiator, due to the ill health of his father.

According to a joint statement issued on Friday after the formal talks, the two sides "agreed to further talks so that the KNPP can sign the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement [NCA] as soon as possible."

Both sides agreed to the creation of a local monitoring team, reestablishing liaison offices at both the state and Union levels, and regular negotiations at the state level on troop movements of both armed forces, according to the statement.

In his opening speech on Thursday, Gen Bee Htoo said that while the two sides have not yet been able to reach an understanding on signing the NCA, "It is important to keep peace in Karenni State."

The KNPP signed its first bilateral ceasefire in March 1995, but it broke down after three months. It entered bilateral ceasefire agreements in 2012 and 2013, and has since entered negotiations for the nationwide ceasefire, but has yet to sign the pact. It was also a member of the now defunct United Nationalities Federal Council, but two of its UNFC partners – the New Mon State Party (NMSP) and Lahu Democratic Union (LDU) – signed the NCA in February.

The KNPP was believed to be reluctant to sign the NCA as three of its soldiers and one civilian were allegedly murdered by Tatmadaw troops at the regional operation command based in Loikaw in December.

The Tatmadaw is conducting an inquiry into the incident and the KNPP would continue to push for justice for the three slain KNPP soldiers, Shwe Myo Thant said.

He told The Irrawaddy that the negotiators "focused on constructive discussions and would continue to build momentum in trust-building. There was also progress in discussions of military affairs."

"The formal talks were able to build further trust between the KNPP and the government," echoed U Hla Maung Shwe, an adviser to the Peace Commission, referring to the talks on Thursday and Friday.

Although the KNPP has not yet committed to signing the NCA, U Hla Maung Shwe told The Irrawaddy on Friday that "We were able to explain the current process to the KNPP leaders. They accepted when we explained what the government can currently do best to implement the terms of the bilateral agreements. Also we will fully implement those things that the government can do."

The government plans to convene the third session of the 21st-Century Panglong Peace Conference in late May, according to Dr. Tin Myo Win. In his closing remarks on Friday, he said he hoped the KNPP leaders would consider participating in the conference and signing the NCA pact by then.

The post KNPP, Gov't Agree to Further Peace Negotiations appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

German Investor in Ngapali Resort Eyes Legal Action against Ex-Partner

Posted: 27 Apr 2018 06:15 AM PDT

YANGON – A German businessman has filed an initial complaint in Yangon against the owner of Amara Ocean Resort (AOR), located in southern Rakhine State's Ngapali Beach.

U Thet Naing, a lawyer for Philipp Quack, the plaintiff in the case, confirmed that they met with Police Captain Mya Tun Kyaw, head of Yangon's Myo Ma Mingalardon police station, on Wednesday and filed a complaint letter against resort owner Daw Kalayar Moe.

The lawyer declined to provide further information, as a decision is pending on whether to accept the case, and which articles of the criminal code would be invoked.

When The Irrawaddy visited Myo Ma Mingalardon police station to clarify whether the case had been accepted, however, a police lieutenant said no foreigners had opened any cases at the station recently. Capt. Mya Tun Kyaw declined to be interviewed.

Daw Kalayar Moe told The Irrawaddy on Friday evening that she had also made inquiries at the police station and was told that police have no idea about the case.

Quack is acting as plaintiff on behalf of Dr. Jens Ehrahrdt, chief executive officer of DJE Kapital group based in Germany, according to sources close to Ehrahrdt. The company provides in-house financing and asset management to businesses. Quack confirmed meeting with the police captain but declined to offer details.

Daw Kalayar Moe declined to comment when contacted by The Irrawaddy on Friday.

In 2009, Daw Kalayar Moe, her then husband Gerald Schreiber, and another German investor, Eva Felten, jointly inked an agreement to develop a project on a profit-sharing basis on a 17-acre plot of land on Ngapali Beach, as well as a 6-acre freshwater dam located in Gaw village, a few miles from Thandwe Airport. The contract is recognized under the German Civil Code.

Under the terms of the agreement, Daw Kalayar Moe and Schreiber each held a 25-percent stake in the project, while Felten held 50 percent. With Myanmar under military rule at the time, foreign investment was generally considered to highly risky. Furthermore, majority property ownership by foreigners is legally prohibited in Myanmar. Therefore, the parties agreed to register the company under the name of a Burmese citizen, and Daw Kalayar Moe acted as the owner.

In June 2011, Felten sold her 50-percent stake to Ehrahrdt for US$2.8 million. "Contracts show that in the same year, Ehrahrdt lent the project an additional US$1.4 million to fund the completion of the resort's construction."

Daw Kalayar Moe and Schreiber's marriage ended acrimoniously and they obtained a divorce from a court in Munich, Germany in 2012. The division of their assets became the subject of a protracted legal dispute, partly because all their properties in Myanmar were registered under Daw Kalayar Moe's name.

Daw Kalayar Moe refused to return Schreiber and Ehrahrdt's shares of the Ngapali investment, or to sell her 25 percent stake. In 2013, Ehrahrdt sued Daw Kalayar Moe in a court in Munich and the judge ruled in his favor. Daw Kalayar Moe was fined 15,000 euros and sentenced to three months in prison as she failed to present detailed information about the AOR project. She later appealed the decision to a higher court, according to Schreiber. The outcome of the appeal is pending.

In an interview with The Irrawaddy at her residence in Yangon on April 9, Daw Kalayar Moe acknowledged the Munich court's decision, but said the decision was unfair and accused the court of being biased in favor of a German citizen. She declined to provide or show any documents relating to the AOR investment that she had signed.

Although the Munich court ruled against Daw Kalayar Moe, the decision has no effect in Myanmar. The plaintiff in the Myanmar case, DJE group, has filed an initial complaint against her but has yet to formally open a criminal case against her in Myanmar yet.

"In 2012, after Amara Ocean had just opened [in Ngapali Beach], we found out that Kalayar was cheating us. She was cheating foreign investors, plus her own husband," Schreiber said.

The post German Investor in Ngapali Resort Eyes Legal Action against Ex-Partner appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Police Officers Promoted, Transferred Amid Reuters Arrest Scandal

Posted: 27 Apr 2018 05:50 AM PDT

NAYPYITAW — More than 50 police officers were promoted or transferred in a mass reshuffle this week in the wake of explosive court testimony accusing a brigadier general in the force of setting up two Reuters reporters for arrest in December.

Police sources said Home Affairs Minister Kyaw Swe presided over the promotion of five officers to brigadier general and at least 12 to colonel at a ceremony in Naypyitaw on Thursday. They said another 38 officers have been transferred without promotions.

"I have to move to Shan State as a police brigadier general. The officers promoted to brigadier generals are police Colonel Win Bo, police Colonel Zaw Tun Aung, police Colonel Soe Naing Oo and police Colonel Thet Wai," Kachin State police chief Zaw Khin Aung, who was promoted to brigadier general himself, told The Irrawaddy.

"Since we were promoted, the junior officers will also be promoted to take over our positions," he added.

Brig. Gen. Zaw Khin Aung was transferred from Naypyitaw to Kachin State in October 2017. His move coincided with the arrest of ACE hotel owner Phyo Ko Ko Tint San at the Naypyitaw International Airport for weapons possession, prompting speculation that the transfer was related.

Col. Htet Lwin will be transferred from Naypyitaw to Kachin State to replace Brig. Gen. Zaw Khin Aung. Col. Myo Swe will be transferred from Yangon to Naypyitaw to replace Col. Htet Lwin.

Brig. Gen. Win Bo will be transferred from Chin State to the No. 3 Security Police Command, while Brig. Gen. Zaw Tun Aung will move from the highway police force to the No.1 Security Police Command. Brig Gen. Soe Naing Oo will remain at the Criminal Investigation Department, and Brig. Gen. Thet Wai will stay with the aviation police force.

"I'm being promoted to police colonel and have to remain with the anti-human trafficking police force. Lieutenant Colonel Htoo Aung from the aviation police force and two others from the maritime police force are also being promoted to police colonel," Col. Thet Naung told The Irrawaddy.

The promotions and transfers come less than a week after police Captain Moe Yan Naing told a court in Yangon that two detained Reuters journalists who helped expose the massacre of Rohingya villagers last year by soldiers and civilians in Rakhine State were set up on orders from his superior, Brigadier General Tin Ko Ko.

But the officers recently promoted and transferred have no known connections to the case, and Brig. Gen. Tin Ko Ko was not among them.

"There have been promotions and reshuffles like this inside the police force before and it’s not special. But it is important to put the right person in the right place," said a retired police officer who now lives in Yangon.

"When transforming the police force to make it a trustworthy organization, there must be enough and effective police personnel at the ground level who always have to interact with the people," he added.

The post Police Officers Promoted, Transferred Amid Reuters Arrest Scandal appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

KNLA and Tatmadaw Clash Near Site of Planned Hatgyi Dam

Posted: 27 Apr 2018 05:15 AM PDT

A clash broke out yesterday between the Myanmar Army and the Karen National Liberation Army in territory held by the KNLA near the site of the planned Hatgyi Dam project in the Mae Tha Wor area, according to Karen sources.

The KNLA reported that two Myanmar Army soldiers were wounded when a landmine was detonated, but this could not be confirmed at press time. The KNLA said it suffered no casualties.

Padoh Mann Mann, a KNLA leader, told The Irrawaddy today that the fighting erupted at noon when the Myanmar Army entered an area held by KNLA Brigade 7.

"We heard that they have begun operations to secure the area as part of their preparations to build Hatgyi Dam," Padoh Mann Mann said.

He said that the Myanmar Army, or Tatmadaw, had deployed many troops from their Brigade 4 as well as men from Brigades 2, 5, 6 and 7. Fighting had also broken recently between the Myanmar Army and KNLA Brigade 5 in Papun District.

"We cannot trust the situation because they have deployed a lot troops. We are worried more fighting could break out soon," Padoh Mann Mann said.

The Myanmar Army says it wants to rebuild an old road in an area held by KNLA Brigade 5, however the KNLA is opposed to the project as it believes that the road is being restored to serve military purposes.

Some 2,000 Karen IDPs from at least five villages have fled from the fighting in Papun District since it broke out last month. They continue to hide in the jungle as they do not feel it is safe to return to their homes.

The KNU, which is the political wing of the KNLA, has actively participated in the national peace process with the government and the Myanmar Army since it signed a ceasefire in 2012. The group also signed the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement (NCA) in 2015, and has joined the Panglong Conference.

There has been relative peace and some local development in Karen State since the KNLA signed the NCA. The Karen have waged a decades-long civil war with the Myanmar Army and thousands of Karen refugees still remain on the at Thai-Myanmar border in camps unable to return home.

Despite the ceasefire, fighting has broken out sporadically between KNLA units and the Tatmadaw and many ethnic Karen are not happy with the current peace deal with the central government.

Under the NCA, the Myanmar Army needs to seek permission before entering KNLA-controlled areas or to undertake local development projects. According to the KNLA's Facebook page, the Tatmadaw did not inform the KNLA when they entered the area where the fighting broke out yesterday.

The post KNLA and Tatmadaw Clash Near Site of Planned Hatgyi Dam appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Push to Refer Tatmadaw to ICC Could Harm Stability: USDP

Posted: 27 Apr 2018 04:33 AM PDT

NAYPYITAW – Attempts to refer Myanmar's military leaders to the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague pose a serious threat to the country's stability and transition to democracy, the Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) said on Thursday.

"Attempts to refer the military to the ICC will only create a situation that could affect [national] stability. Removing the military entirely from the country's politics would make things worse for the country," USDP spokesman Dr. Nanda Hla Myint told The Irrawaddy.

In the wake of armed clashes in Kachin State's Tanai Township that have trapped many villagers inside the conflict zone and forced thousands to flee, some Kachin groups have urged the UN to refer the Myanmar military (or Tatmadaw) to the ICC.

According to U Thein Tun Oo, the director of the Thayninga Institute for Strategic Studies, the proposal is an effort to clamp down on the military, which he said is country's only strong institution. If the effort succeeded, the country's defense and security could be seriously affected, he said.

"Frankly, this is inference. Their ambition is to weaken the only remaining organization which has real strength. If the situation continues like this, the political situation will be harmed, especially while military officials and government authorities are trying to build unity," U Thein Tun Oo said.

Government officials have said in the past that attempts to take action against the military were not useful in advancing the country's transition to democracy.

"Given the country's history and political situation, we cannot deny the military its role. Any democratically elected government that wants to build a sustainable democracy in a country must join hands with its military," said Dr. Nanda Hla Myint, the USDP spokesman.

National League for Democracy central committee member Monywa Aung Shin said he did not support the several attempts that have been made to refer the military to the ICC by activists both in and outside of the country. He said such efforts accused the military of responsibility for abuses without evidence, and warned activists not to raise the issue of the ICC lightly.

"We have to investigate first to find the root causes [of abuses]. [State Counselor] Daw Aung San Suu Kyi has already said that. We have to investigate. When there is armed conflict, there are many effects but we should not blame one side. If there is concrete evidence everyone will accept it," Monywa Aung Shin said.

Senior-General Min Aung Hlaing, commander-in-chief of the military, said on April 18 that the military handled the incident in Inn Din village, in Rakhine State's Maungdaw Township, in accordance with the Geneva Conventions.

Seven military officials and soldiers involved in the killing of civilians in Inn Din village were sentenced to 10 years' imprisonment with hard labor, according to a military statement issued on April 11.

The post Push to Refer Tatmadaw to ICC Could Harm Stability: USDP appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Pair Behind 2016 Yangon Bombings Get Lengthy Jail Terms

Posted: 27 Apr 2018 04:19 AM PDT

YANGON — The Yangon West District Court on Wednesday sentenced two men to lengthy prison terms for the 2016 bombings of the Yangon Region Parliament compound and a city shopping center.

Authorities found an exploded bomb between the pipes leading to the toilet of the Immigration and Population Department inside the Parliament compound on Nov. 25, 2016. Another bomb was found unexploded 10 feet away on the same day.

The court sentenced Khin Maung Shwe, also known as Ko Shwe or Yacob, and Soe Win, also known as Mohammad Ali, to 10 years in jail with hard labor under Section 3 of the Explosives Act for planting the improvised bombs, which were made from M-150 energy drink cans filled with explosive.

Khin Maung Shwe was also sentenced to an additional 10 years in jail with hard labor for two bomb explosions eight days earlier at Yangon’s Ocean Shopping Center, one in the car park and another in a men’s toilet.

Two other suspects, Soe Min Zaw, also known as Tharnge, and Yasin, also known as Kyaw Gyi, were acquitted.

The November 2016 incidents were among a series of explosions to hit the country’s commercial capital that month. Other locations included the Capital Hypermarket in Dawbon Township and near the South Dagon Township Immigration and Population Department.

The post Pair Behind 2016 Yangon Bombings Get Lengthy Jail Terms appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Family of Boy Allegedly Beaten by Monk Files Charges with Police

Posted: 27 Apr 2018 04:16 AM PDT

The family of a boy who was hospitalized after being allegedly beaten by a Buddhist monk in Madaya Township has filed charges over the incident, police said.

The attack, which was caught on video, has caused outrage among many members of the general public after the footage was posted on Facebook.

Police Lieutenant Naing Lin, an officer from Madaya, a small town in Pyin Oo Lwin District, Mandalay Region, told The Irrawaddy that the father of the victim had visited police to report how his son, who is in the eighth grade, was severely beaten by a monk at a township monastery.

"He charged that the monk beat his son in violation of Article 325," which refers to voluntarily causing grievous harm, the police officer said.

Lieutenant Nain Lin said that when the boy, who was identified as Wai Phyo Naing, recovers and is released from hospital, the police will interview him to find out what happened. The police have already sent letters to the Ministry of Religious Affairs and township authorities and asked them to let the police take action against the monk, Ashin Soe.

"Based on legal procedures, if we find the monk has violated the law, we will take action against him," Lieutenant Naing Lin said.

U Zaw Min Lwin, a Lower House lawmaker from Madaya Township, also confirmed that the father had sought to bring charges against the monk under Article 325.

He said he visited the hospital yesterday to see the victim, who was recovering from his injuries.

The incident occurred after Wai Phyo Naing entered the monastery grounds to collect mangos with a friend. Teasing his friend he said his words were like those "from an angel that came from the mouth of a dog," using an old Burmese saying for bad people who say good things.

His friend complained to Ashin Soe, who was staying at a temple inside the monastery grounds. Ashin Soe and several monks then grabbed Wai Phyo Naing.

Video footage that was widely shared on Facebook shows Wai Phyo Naing holding a small bag of mangos as he is hit by the monk.

"Words from an angel coming out of the mouth of a dog. He said that at our monastery. You all heard it, right?" Ashin Soe says to the monks in the footage before he launches into his assault of Wai Phyo Naing.

He then asks the other monks to join him in beating the boy. One monk tries to stop Ashin Soe from hitting the boy, but Ashin Soe punches Wai Phyo Naing in the face. He then drags the youth around by his hair, further torturing him.

"This is a monastic area. Why, why, would you come here and say these things," Ashin Soe says, before kicking the boy in the head and in his back.

Ashin Soe also hits the victim around the head with a stick several times. Despite the victim apologizing, Ashin Soe continues to strike him.

Many people who saw the video expressed outrage. The footage was posted on April 21 on the same day that Wai Phyo Naing was attacked.

Some Facebook users demanded that the authorities take action against Ashin Soe, who they called a bad monk. Some said the monk's violent actions had tarnished the image of Buddhism. Others asked what type of monk would beat a boy. According to the principles of Buddhism, monks should show compassion, and they are forbidden from killing, beating or torturing other humans or animals. But, noted several of the Facebook users, some monks who had behaved badly in their lay lives, continued to do so in the monkhood.

In Myanmar, any male can enter the monkhood and stay at a monastery near their village or township. Buddhism is reflected in much of the culture of Myanmar, and remains the dominant religion in the country.

Some families send their sons who are addicted to drugs or alcohol to join the monkhood in the hope that they will shed their bad habits.

The post Family of Boy Allegedly Beaten by Monk Files Charges with Police appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

28 Seek Hospital Treatment After Yangon Landfill Fire

Posted: 27 Apr 2018 04:01 AM PDT

YANGON — A total of 28 people have been treated for smoke inhalation at the Hlaing Tharyar General Hospital after inhaling noxious smoke and fumes from the Htein Pin dumpsite fire that has been burning since Saturday.

The Ministry of Health and Sports stated that from Tuesday to Thursday, 19 people had been admitted to the hospital, while 19 had been treated as outpatients. One patient with lung problems was referred to Yangon General Hospital.

The ministry stated that out of 19 inpatients, 14 had been diagnosed with high levels of carbon monoxide.

The foul-smelling smoke from the blaze reached several townships across the city, but particularly affected nearby residents, raising public health concerns.

Over the past few days, more than 90 people who live near the site have been treated at temporary clinics for symptoms such as eye irritation and coughing, while many firemen battling the fire have also been treated for respiratory problems and minor injuries.

Hlaing Tharyar General Hospital superintendent Dr. San Lwin Oo said that on Friday, 12 people were still hospitalized related to the fire – including three children – while the others had been released.

"We have been treating patients for smoke exposure. Most of the patients are elderly people who have received treatment for other problems before," he said.

The Yangon regional government imported 1,800 gallons of bio-foam, a fire suppression agent, from Thailand to use to cut down on the smoke. It stated on Thursday evening that more 5,000 gallons of the foam will be imported for the blaze, as it received donation money from KBZ's Brighter Future Myanmar Foundation for this purpose.

The post 28 Seek Hospital Treatment After Yangon Landfill Fire appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Selling the Country to China? Debate Spills Into Malaysia’s Election

Posted: 27 Apr 2018 12:43 AM PDT

KUANTAN, Malaysia — When Malaysia’s political parties unfurled their election flags and banners this month, Prime Minister Najib Razak’s critics sniggered on social media that the manufacturer named on banners of his ruling coalition was Chinese.

Mahathir Mohamad, who heads an alliance hoping to oust Najib, has seized on popular disquiet about Chinese investment pouring into Malaysia and turned it into an election issue.

Najib, he says, is selling Malaysia out to China.

This could matter for Beijing’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and for Malaysia’s economy because Mahathir, who was the country’s prime minister for more than two decades, has vowed to reconsider Chinese contracts if the opposition wins on May 9.

“Coming in here, buying land, developing luxurious towns, is not beneficial for us,” the 92-year-old former leader said of China’s investments in a recent interview with Reuters. “Quite definitely, we will review.”

Najib has repeatedly shrugged off Mahathir’s barbs on China, saying that allowing foreign direct investment does not amount to selling the country’s sovereignty.

A senior leader in the ruling coalition, commenting on the banners made in China, said: “The opposition are doing the same thing … because simply it is cheap and efficient.”

A Nomura report this month on the Belt and Road Initiative showed that Malaysia is one of the largest beneficiaries of Chinese investment commitments in Asia, securing $34.2 billion of BRI-related infrastructure projects.

There have been concerns in some BRI host countries, such as Sri Lanka and Pakistan, about rising debt levels, over-reliance on China and the environmental impact of mega-projects. Critics also say some projects give China access to strategic locations and trade corridors that could hurt the sovereignty of nations.

Objections to Chinese investments in Malaysia, however, have focused on the presence of thousands of Chinese workers, heavy dependence on Chinese materials, and limited opportunities for local companies.

For instance, the $100 billion township project by Chinese developer Country Garden in the Iskandar Malaysia special economic zone of Johor state, has ruffled feathers in a bastion of support for Najib’s United Malays National Organization (UMNO).

Johor locals complain that large numbers of Chinese people have been allowed to own properties in the project, which is called Forest City. Last year, Chinese nationals accounted for about 70 percent of apartment buyers there.

Other grievances over Forest City have included environmental damage, a property market glut, and the impact of land reclamation on the local fishing industry.

“Chinese Tsunami”

Najib’s Barisan Nasional (BN) alliance, dominated by UMNO, is widely expected to defeat Mahathir’s Pakatan Harapan coalition in the election, but will most likely be relying on the country’s majority Malays to do so.

Malaysia’s own economically powerful ethnic Chinese voted heavily for the opposition at the last election in 2013, handing the UMNO-led coalition its first-ever loss of the popular vote. Najib called it a “Chinese tsunami.”

This time, Najib needs to win comfortably to avoid a leadership challenge. To do that, he will need to reassure voters angry over the cost of living and corruption as well as fend off opposition attacks over Chinese investments.

“Please do not support and believe in what they are saying,” Najib said at a community event in Kuala Lumpur this week. “If you do, this would only hurt our economy.”

Ties between Malaysia and China have flourished under Najib, who visited Beijing in both 2016 and 2017.

The prime minister is under a cloud over a long-running scandal at state fund 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) but Chinese state-linked firms have purchased power assets and real estate linked to 1MDB, helping resolve some of its debt issues.

Najib has consistently denied any wrongdoing over billions of dollars that went missing from 1MDB but at least six countries, including the United States, are investigating transactions related to the fund.

In Kuantan, a laid-back coastal town with tropical beaches, China’s shadow is looming large.

Chinese firms are leading the construction of a 3,000-acre industrial park, which is rising out of sight behind what locals call a “Great Wall,” and they have taken a 40-percent stake in the operator of a deep water, multi-cargo port nearby.

Meanwhile, China Communications Construction Co. Ltd. is building a 55 billion ringgit ($14 billion) rail line that will link Malaysia’s east coast on the South China Sea to Kuala Lumpur and the strategic shipping routes of the Strait of Malacca in the west.

Left Out

But local entrepreneurs feel left out of the bonanza.

“To me, the China investments here look fishy and don’t seem to benefit the locals as we hoped for,” said Syed Heider, a Kuantan-based building materials supplier who recently switched allegiance from Najib’s BN to the opposition. “Of 10 people that I know, eight people have already swung to Pakatan.”

At a recent groundbreaking ceremony in Kelantan state, the northern end of the rail line, Najib said Malaysia would have been “stupid” not to work with China because it offered a loan for 85 percent of the project value with a grace period of seven years.

Stressing the development potential for one of the country’s less developed states, he said the link would create 80,000 jobs and the project operator would be obliged to give at least 70 percent of these to local workers.

Noting that less than 20 percent of the east coast line’s workers are Chinese, Minister of International Trade and Industry Mustapa Mohamed told Reuters that China and Malaysia are trying to avoid a repeat of Forest City’s tensions.

“In hindsight, the Forest City experience taught them some lessons, and us as well … policymakers have learned quite a bit from this and now the Chinese understand the importance of respecting local practices,” he said.

The post Selling the Country to China? Debate Spills Into Malaysia’s Election appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

EU Extends Myanmar Arms Embargo, Prepares Individual Sanctions

Posted: 26 Apr 2018 10:32 PM PDT

BRUSSELS — The European Union on Thursday extended its arms embargo against Myanmar, following human rights violations in the country, and was preparing sanctions against individual army officials.

The embargo includes arms, other equipment that could be used for repression, the provision of military training and products used to monitor communications, the Council of the European Union said.

The Council added it had agreed on a framework for personal sanctions against officials of the Myanmar Armed Forces and the border guard police, should human rights violations in the country continue.

These personal sanctions could include travel bans and asset freezes, the Council said.

The EU accuses Myanmar of “serious and systemic” human rights violations in a military operation in the country’s northwest last year that sent nearly 700,000 Rohingya Muslims fleeing to neighboring Bangladesh.

The move follows similar measures by the United States and Canada.

Two Reuters journalists were jailed while reporting the army crackdown on the Rohingya and remain in prison in Yangon, where they face up to 14 years in jail for violating Myanmar’s Official Secrets Act.

Senior UN officials, Western nations and press freedom advocates have called for the reporters’ release.

The post EU Extends Myanmar Arms Embargo, Prepares Individual Sanctions appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Smiles and Long Handshakes Mark Start of Summit Between Leaders of Rival Koreas

Posted: 26 Apr 2018 09:59 PM PDT

SEOUL — The golden doors on the stately North Korean building swung open and leader Kim Jong Un, in a black Mao suit and surrounded by a gaggle of officials, began to descend the steps toward the border.

Not since the 1950-53 Korean War had a North Korean leader set foot on South Korean soil.

With a smile, Kim stretched out his hand toward a waiting, and smiling, South Korean President Moon Jae-in, who stood between the squat, light blue buildings that straddle the border at Panmunjom.

The village is one of the few places where there are no high barbed wire fences or minefields between the two countries, separated by a conflict that ended with a truce, not a treaty, meaning they are still technically at war.

Grasping hands across the border, the two men greeted one another.

“I was excited to meet at this historic place and it is really moving that you came all the way to the demarcation line to greet me in person,” Kim said.

“It was your big decision to make it here,” said Moon, dressed in a dark suit and light blue tie, who invited Kim to step over the line in the pavement, which he did.

That’s something Kim’s grandfather, the North Korean regime’s founding leader Kim Il Sung, or father Kim Jong Il, never achieved.

The two previous summits between leaders of the Koreas, in 2000 and 2007, were in Pyongyang, the North’s capital.

Shaking hands again, Moon, 65, and Kim, 34, turned to face photographers on the North and then the South before Kim grabbed Moon’s hand and, in an unplanned move, invited him to step across the border into the North, where they stood face-to-face to talk a bit more.

The scene unfolded in simple, even run-down surroundings, where a concrete slab marks the border and paint is cracking on the low wooden huts.

The apparent warmth between the men was in stark contrast to the tension between the two countries last year amid North Korean weapons testing.

Since January, however, ties have thawed, including having their Olympics sports teams march together under a common flag at February’s winter games in South Korea.

After being led along a red carpet by South Korean honor guard in traditional blue, yellow and red outfits, the two men entered the Peace House on the South side, where they were expected to discuss denuclearization and cultural exchanges.

Minutes before Kim entered Peace House, a North Korean security team conducted a sweep for explosives and listening devices, as well as sprayed apparent disinfectant in the air, on the chairs, and on a guest book Kim was to sign.

Kim’s written message in the guest book sounded hopeful.

“A new history starts now,” he wrote. “An age of peace, from the starting point of history.”

The post Smiles and Long Handshakes Mark Start of Summit Between Leaders of Rival Koreas appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Ethnic Groups Have Lost Faith in the NLD

Posted: 26 Apr 2018 09:07 PM PDT

The country is becoming more divided between the Burman and the other ethnic groups under the ruling National League for Democracy (NLD) government led by Daw Aung San Suu Kyi. There are several reasons why.

Since the NLD government came to power, the Myanmar Army has launched a string of military campaigns in Kachin State and northern Shan State despite the ongoing peace process at the national level.

It prompts the question, why is the Myanmar Army launching more offensives now than during the reign of the former military-installed government of U Thein Sein?

U Thein Sein was from the Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP). The Myanmar Army and USDP acted as one and yet the Myanmar Army rarely attacked the Kachin Independence Army (KIA), the Ta'ang National Liberation Army (TNLA) or the Arakan Army (AA), although it did launch several offensives against the Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army (MNDAA) during Thein Sein's five years as president.

According to a leaked paper from the six monthly meeting of the Tatmadaw, the Ministry of Defense has instructed the army's ground forces to focus their attacks on the KIA and TNLA to destroy their military capability.

The Myanmar Army has followed up on this order by launching a wide-ranging offensive in Kachin this year. The KIA and the Kachin people feel that the campaign is intended to eliminate the Christian ethnic Kachin who have a strong armed wing and a close-knit community in northern Myanmar.

At the same time, the Myanmar Army has launched a parallel campaign against the TNLA. Only this week, an army convoy of 60 trucks arrived in Lashio with plans to move further north to Namkham and Muse where the KIA and TNLA have bases.

The Myanmar Army has applied a different approach to dealing with the TNLA, using the Restoration Council of Shan State (RCSS), a signatory to the NCA, as a proxy to attack the TNLA. According to TNLA leaders, the Myanmar Army has helped deploy troops from the RCSS, whose stronghold is in southern Shan, in the north of the state to attack TNLA positions.

The TNLA has used guerilla tactics when it attacked the Myanmar Army but a more defensive strategy when engaging with the RCSS. The TNLA this year has suffered heavy casualties and the loss of military material in attacks against the RCSS to maintain its control of some areas. In March, for example, the TNLA engaged in firefights with the RCSS around Kyaukme, causing hundreds of IDPs to flee the area.

This strategy has allowed the Myanmar Army to sit back, arms folded and watch the fighting between the TNLA and RCSS. On occasion it has brought in its long-distance artillery to shell the TNLA to support the RCSS, forcing the TNLA to open two fronts.

The civil war in Myanmar has raged for decades but one thing that is different now is the reaction of the general public. In the past, protests were held to demand the government and Myanmar Army stop its offensives against the ethnic groups. But this time there has been almost no show of public support for the Kachin, even when the Tatmadaw's attacks have resulted in the deaths of civilians from air strikes or from artillery bombardments.

Why don't members of the public criticize the Myanmar Army? Many people are apparently worried that their criticism will damage the relationship between the NLD government – which still has the support of the majority of the people in the country — and the Myanmar Army. Some supporters of the NLD have argued that the civilian government is not mature yet, and it was not the right time to criticize it.

This is why some Kachin civil society organizations have appealed to the International Criminal Court to take action against the Myanmar Army for killing civilians and causing thousands of local Kachin to flee while also blocking UN agencies from delivering aid to Kachin IDPs.

The Myanmar Army has used all its resources in the military offensive in Kachin including air strikes, ground force assaults and 120 mm long-distance artillery. Some KIA leaders and Kachin community leaders feel that Myanmar Army is acting as if it is locked in battle with a foreign enemy. But the ethnic Kachin are citizens of Myanmar and the KIA is fighting for equal rights for the ethnic Kachin.

When the other ethnic groups look at the situation in Kachin state, they increasingly view the NLD and Myanmar Army as one and the same. Both are Burmese. The NLD government keeps silent when the Myanmar Army attacks the Kachin.

But, who voted for the NLD?

I am an ethnic Mon person who told my family to vote for the NLD. Similarly, people from other ethnic groups who wanted to see the country amend the 2008 Constitution gave their votes to the NLD. We all believed the NLD was only party that would dare to challenge the Myanmar Army.

However, shortly after taking power, the NLD, which had told the country's ethnic groups it would run the country as democracy under a federal system with equal rights for all, tried to name a bridge in Moulmein after Gen Aung San. Many ethnic Mon, including members of my family, were outraged. Ethnic Mon today no longer view the NLD as a party that will help them attain equal rights. It is just a party that tries to rule and manipulate the ethnic minorities to service its own purposes.

The story in Kachin State is the same, only more extreme. When the country went to the polls, the KIA leaders reportedly told ethnic Kachin to vote for the NLD. The Kachin also had high expectations of the NLD, but no one from the party has spoken out to condemn the actions of the Myanmar Army, which launched yet another big military offensive against the KIA today.

The NLD has built statues of Gen Aung San in Myitkyina despite ethnic local Kachin opposition. It has erected statues of Gen Aung San in other ethnic areas as well including Mon State. Such actions have resulted in more disappointment in the NLD government.

The installation of statues of Gen Aung San is not a minor issue. Gen Aung San is a hero of the Burmese, but not for all ethnic people. Some Mon are worried that the statues are intended to be a signal that all the ethnic areas will one day belong to the Burmans.

The post Ethnic Groups Have Lost Faith in the NLD appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Thursday, April 26, 2018

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Bangladesh Prepares Rohingya Camps for Cyclone Season

Posted: 26 Apr 2018 06:53 AM PDT

DHAKA, Bangladesh – The Bangladesh government in cooperation with local and international humanitarian agencies is taking steps to prepare the community of Rohingya refugees camped on the outskirts of Cox's Bazar for the coming monsoon season.

Officials are also seeking to allay concerns among the refugees about a plan to move many of the Rohingya to an island in the Bay of Bengal, insisting that relocation to the site would be done on a voluntary basis.

Meanwhile, aid group Médecins Sans Frontières has warned that the refugees' current shelter provisions were insufficient for extreme weather conditions and said it was bracing for "mass-casualty scenarios."

Bangladesh disaster-management officials said they had already taken the necessary measures to cope with heavy rains and flash floods. Their main concern now is the damage that a cyclone would inflict upon the makeshift structures housing densely populated Rohingya camps in areas in Ukhiya and Tekhnaf sub-districts of Cox's Bazar.

UN agencies have also initiated a number of special safety measures ahead of the rainy season.

A government survey found that 133,000 Rohingya people are at critical risk – the highest level – in the event of floods, cyclones and landslides.

Bangladesh, the UN High Commissioner for Refugees and their partners are taking urgent steps to better protect nearly 80,000 people deemed at greatest risk of flooding in the area, and 23,000 threatened by landslides.

The UNHCR and other groups currently provide 80,000 families in the camp with bamboo poles and tarpaulins to construct flimsy shelters. However, the tarpaulins covering many shanties already require repairs, said Sirajul Mostafa, the chairman of a camp management committee at Kutupalang.

Habibul Kabir Chowdhury, head of the Bangladesh Disaster Management and Relief Ministry's Rohingya unit, said he was more worried about cyclones than landslides and flash floods. "Our major concern is cyclones, although we have identified a number of facilities including schools for use as shelters in an emergency," he said.

Kabir told The Irrawaddy that the government's cyclone-warning system could provide five days' notice ahead of a cyclone making landfall.

The Bangladesh Red Crescent Society has prepared an emergency contingency plan for the upcoming monsoon season. Some 300 volunteers have been trained in first aid, and search-and-rescue.

In June 2017, heavy monsoon rains triggered a series of landslides and floods in Rangamati, Chittagong and Bandarban, three hilly districts near Cox's Bazar, the town currently hosting hundreds of thousands of Rohingya refugees. The slides and floods killed over 150 people.

According to ReliefWeb, which monitors global crises and disasters, Cox's Bazar has been hit by cyclones every year for the past three years: Cyclone Mora in May 2017, Cyclone Roanu in May 2016, and Cyclone Komen in July 2015.

In Bangladesh, the pre-monsoon hot season, which brings some rain, usually lasts from March through May. The main monsoon season lasts from June through October, and often sees flooding.

Cyclones generally strike Bangladesh in March through July and September through December, with the greatest number of storms in May and October.

UNICEF, meanwhile, is providing GPS-enabled bracelets to around 250,000 Rohingya children so their families can trace them should they become separated during emergencies.

UNICEF Bangladesh spokesperson AM Sakil Faizullah told The Irrawaddy the agency aims to provide the bracelets to all children up to the age of 12.

"With the bracelet, anyone can be easily traced in any circumstances," Sakil said. He hoped they would start distribution by May.

UNICEF officials said that 5,000 Rohingya children had already been separated from parents and relatives during the violence that forced them to leave Rakhine State. Many of these children were now roaming Cox's Bazar in search of their loved ones.

From September to November 2017, the Bangladesh Social Services Department registered 36,373 Rohingya children who had been separated from at least one parent during the exodus. Some 7,771 had lost both parents.

Over 688,000 Rohingya have entered Bangladesh since Aug. 25, 2017, in what the UN describes as the world's fastest-developing refugee emergency.

The field officer for Médecins Sans Frontières' Bangladesh Mission, Mostafa Mohammad Sazzad Hossain, said, "The approaching monsoon rains and other natural hazards may lead to deaths in the camps, with hundreds of thousands of Rohingya and members of the host community at risk of disease outbreaks and aid disruptions. Current shelters and structures are unable to withstand extreme weather conditions such as heavy flooding or cyclones, and do not sufficiently meet the protection needs of the most vulnerable refugees. MSF is preparing for mass-casualty scenarios.

"MSF expects to see cases of injured people and likely fatalities resulting from heavy winds and landslides. Due to the poor infrastructure in the camp, access to our health posts and clinics will be even more difficult for patients, as well as healthcare staff. Access to safe drinking water is a priority and MSF is rehabilitating latrines and water distribution networks, as well as setting up bucket chlorination points."

'No forced relocations'

According to Agence France-Presse, authorities in Dhaka earlier said about 100,000 refugees from the persecuted Muslim minority would be shifted to an island in the Bay of Bengal where the Bangladesh Navy is building housing that can withstand cyclones.

A number of Rohingya community members told The Irrawaddy they are afraid of being shifted to the island, however.

"Yes, we know the fear of being shifted to Bhasanchar persists among the community… but, none will be taken there forcibly," said Habibul Kabir, the Rohingya unit chief.

Kabir said officials would visit Bhasanchar along with representatives of humanitarian agencies in the first half of May to get a clear picture of the proposed relocation process.

Rohingya community leader Sirajul Mostafa said he had not officially been told about the relocations to Bhasanchar, but he had heard rumors.

"We have taken shelter here from persecution in our land. And, we are here [waiting] to return to our land," he added.

The post Bangladesh Prepares Rohingya Camps for Cyclone Season appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Two Pyin Oo Lwin Officials Jailed for 10 Years in Corruption Cases

Posted: 26 Apr 2018 05:44 AM PDT

MANDALAY – Mandalay Divisional Court on Thursday jailed two Pyin Oo Lwin Township officials for 10 years for corruption.

The sentences, the harshest ever handed down by the Mandalay court for corruption, come on the heels of a promise by President U Win Myint to take strong action against corrupt officials.

Pyin Oo Lwin Township general administration officer U Tin Naing Soe and deputy administration officer U Kyaw Kyaw Naing were charged in October 2016 with two corruption counts each under Article 56 of the Anti-corruption Law for taking bribes from residents of Mageeinn village in return for registering their land.

The court found the two officials guilty of taking a total of more than 39 million kyats in two separate cases. They were each sentenced to 5 years' imprisonment in each case.

Article 56 states: "Other than the Political Post Holder, if any other Authorized  Person  is  convicted for committing  bribery; he/she shall  be  punished  with  imprisonment  for  a  term of not more than 10 years and with a fine."

In 2014, the two officials promised residents of Mageeinn that they would grant their registration requests, on the authority of the Home Affairs Ministry, in exchange for money.

The residents paid them more than 39 million kyats, but saw no action on their applications. After waiting for about two years, they reported the incident to Pyin Oo Lwin police and filed a lawsuit against the officials under the Anti-corruption Law.

President U Win Myint has vowed to crack down on bribery and corruption. He reportedly instructed members of the Anti-Corruption Commission not to be influenced by powerful figures in undertaking their duties, and to report to him if they encounter cases of powerful people protecting those accused of corruption. (https://www.irrawaddy.com/news/president-orders-anti-corruption-panel-not-influenced-powerful-figures.html)

Mandalay Divisional Court is currently preparing to hand down sentences in a separate case in which Naypyitaw municipal council members were convicted of taking bribes from vendors. (https://www.irrawaddy.com/news/burma/court-case-begins-naypyitaw-municipal-officials.html)

In another case, the director-general of the Food and Drug Administration was recently charged under the Anti-corruption Law for allegedly demanding personal favors from a company that won a tender to build laboratories. (https://www.irrawaddy.com/news/burma/anti-corruption-commission-files-case-fda-chief.html)

The post Two Pyin Oo Lwin Officials Jailed for 10 Years in Corruption Cases appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

With Yangon Trash Fire Mostly Under Control, Authorities Tackle Smoke

Posted: 26 Apr 2018 05:09 AM PDT

YANGON — A fire that has been burning at Yangon’s largest dumpsite since Saturday has been brought mostly under control, the regional government announced Wednesday, but warned that smoke from the site continued to pose a health risk.

"About 80 percent of the fire is now under control, but what we can't control is smoke," Yangon Region Chief Minister U Phyo Min Thein said at a meeting about the fire, according to a statement the regional government released Wednesday afternoon.

The chief minister said bio-foam, a fire suppression detergent, would be used to cut down on the smoke. The statement added that the government would import 1,800 gallons of the foam from Thailand within 36 hours.

The fire at the 17-year-old Htein Pin landfill in Hlaing Thaya Township started on Saturday, sending smoke across nearby townships and raising public health concerns.

As of Wednesday, 13 patients were being treated at a local hospital after inhaling smoke from the blaze. U Phyo Min Thein said air quality had been tested at five locations near the dump and that the results would be made public.

The Yangon City Development Committee, Myanmar Fire Services Department and Yangon Military Command are collaborating to put out the fire using a combined 800 personnel, according to the regional government.

The post With Yangon Trash Fire Mostly Under Control, Authorities Tackle Smoke appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Civil Society Groups Urge Release of Reuters Reporters

Posted: 26 Apr 2018 04:30 AM PDT

MANDALAY — More than 160 civil society groups sent an open letter to President U Win Myint on Thursday, urging for the immediate release of two Reuters journalists and calling for an investigation committee to look into the case.

The letter stated that the two reporters were set up by police, but that they still do not have their freedom.

The statement continued to say that the arrest and trial didn't make sense and that it was unjust that the reporters and police officers were still detained.

"We are urging for the immediate release of the detainees," it read.

The open letter was signed by 163 civil society groups including the Burmese Women's Union (BWU), Generation Wave, Community Response Action Group (COMREG), Association of Human Rights Defenders and Promoters (HRDP) and National Network for Educational Reform (NNER).

The groups also urged for a national-level investigation committee to be formed.

"We urge the president to form a national-level investigation committee to investigate the whole case and to review the trial. If not, trust in the judicial system could be damaged," said Ko Thatoe, a spokesperson from COMREG.

The civil society groups also urged the president to provide social security to the families of the detained, as well as to ensure their rights.

"We believe the president will address this matter because he once said that he would try his best to make the judiciary more just, fair, and free from bias," he added.

The civil society groups said they are closely watching the trial and will act accordingly.

"The detainees were arrested four months ago. We want them to be released immediately, as the reporters were framed," said Ko Thatoe. "We are closely watching whether the judiciary is just and we will increase our action if necessary."

The two Reuters reporters, Ko Wa Lone and Ko Kyaw Soe Oo, were arrested on Dec. 12 last year. They were accused of possessing confidential government papers and have been charged under the colonial-era Official Secrets Act. They are facing a maximum sentence of 14 years in prison for the alleged crime. 

Police captain Moe Yan Naing, a prosecution witness, testified to the court on April 20 that police Brigadier-General Tin Ko Ko had ordered police officers to frame the reporters by handing the confidential documents and then arresting them.

The police captain was also detained following the arrest of the reporters. He is facing separate charges for passing the government documents that could result in imprisonment and dismissal from his position.

The post Civil Society Groups Urge Release of Reuters Reporters appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Despite Govt Efforts, Divide Persists Over Rohingya Freedom of Movement

Posted: 26 Apr 2018 02:12 AM PDT

YANGON — Members of the opposition Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) vowed to strongly object to granting freedom of movement to national verification card (NVC) holders from Rakhine State.

Last week, a delegation led by Social Welfare Minister Dr. Win Myat Aye visited Rohingya refugees camps in neighboring Bangladesh. Afterward, they held a press conference in Yangon where they stated that the Myanmar government would grant freedom of movement, access to healthcare and education, and the ability to cross international borders if returnees hold NVC cards.

The mission of the Myanmar delegation was to convince some 700,000 Rohginya Muslim refugees of this. The refugees have been displaced for months, after being driven out by army clearance operations following an attack on border guard posts in late August 2017. The Myanmar Army has been accused of extrajudicial killings, rape and arson and the UN has described the military's actions as a "textbook example of ethnic cleansing."

Dr. Win Myat Aye, Muslim and Hindu religious leaders explained to the refugees the potential advantages of the NVCs, despite people's mistrust. During the press briefing, the social welfare minister also stated that cardholders could fill out an associated immigration form at the Immigration Department and then receive citizenship within five months.

In response, USDP spokesman Dr. Nanda Hla Myint told reporters at party headquarters in Yangon that the party will not accept the government plan, and that it will strongly oppose it along with other party alliances and nationalist groups.

"Regarding this issue, our party will submit an urgent proposal to Parliament during the upcoming regular session," he said.

NVCs as a Control Mechanism

National verification cards were introduced by former President U Thein Sein's administration as a replacement for white cards, or temporary registration cards.

The government has said the Rohingya, an ethnicity not officially recognized in Myanmar, must undergo a verification process in line with the 1982 Citizenship Law and accept NVCs before they can become citizens. Being granted a NVC does not guarantee citizenship, but holders of the card are able to apply for citizenship through a formal process.

A sample of Form (4), locally known as the travel permit for the Rohingya community in Rakhine State.

USDP spokesman Dr. Nanda Hla Myint told The Irrawaddy that it is clearly stated on NVCs that cardholders are not recognized as citizens. He added that the immigration form that Dr. Win Myat Aye referred to – Form 4 – was designated for non-citizens.

Previous governments used the form to issue permits for travel, health and education, but even once approved, the permits did not allow for more than 45 days of travel outside of Rakhine State and regional authorities needed to be notified of travel 24 hours in advance of every arrival and departure within that timeframe.

"We use Form (4) as a control mechanism for non-citizens, similar to how we used to use the Guest Registration Law or State Surveillance Law. If everyone is allowed to travel freely around the country, we lose that control," Dr. Nanda Hla Myint said.

The USDP spokesman said he is seriously concerned about state security if NVC holders are permitted freedom of movement.

"How can we prevent extremists from entering our country if we no longer have this mechanism?" he asked. "That is why I am strongly opposing it."

Some Arakanese social activists have voiced that they believe the USDP is taking this stance to seek public support and political advantage.

The USDP spokesman responded by saying that this would not win the party the next election. "We are just emphasizing national interests and pointing out that the NLD is slipping from procedure," he said.

Arakanese Perspectives on the NVC

Many people assume that the Arakanese often hold the opposite stance of the Rohingya Muslims. But on this issue, the Arakanese community, Arakan National Party lawmakers and civil society groups have largely remained silent or criticized the USDP stance on freedom of movement for NVC holders.

The Irrawaddy conducted a mini-survey of 40 Arakanese via messenger regarding the issue. The participants were activists, politicians, civil servants and educated workers, primarily living in Rakhine and Yangon.

Of those who responded, 27 answered in support of freedom of movement for NVC holders, 2 voted against and 2 abstained.

ANP lawmaker U Pe Than replied, "This question is very difficult to answer yes or no… Let the Myanmar people weigh in first,"

Ethnic Arakanese U Win Aung said that the NVC was similar to white cards, which at one time allowed holders to vote – one of the highest rights of a citizen. That right was later revoked.

"If the previous government allowed these cardholders voting rights, why should we object to freedom of movement for NVC holders?" he asked.

Border police check point in southern Maungdaw Township. (Photo: Moe Myint/ The Irrawaddy)

The NVC Conundrum

In Naypyitaw on Thursday, the Labor, Immigration, and Population Minister U Thein Swe said that people were misinterpreting the freedom of movement that would be granted, and that there were more steps than were being stated.

"What the media recently reported about NVC holders being able to freely travel anywhere in the country is wrong," he said.

According to him, travel would still be limited and the NVC was only an initial step in recognizing residency. After filling out Form (4), applicants would have their documents checked and need approval from township, district, state and the central government before being granted citizenship in line with the 1982 Citizenship Law.

He did not elaborate on the immigration form and it is unclear how it will be used under the National League for Democracy (NLD) government. The form was created during the State Peace and Development Council (SPDC) era, under military dictator U Than Shwe, and mainly targeted Muslims in Rakhine. Most Muslims in Rakhine at that time needed a recommendation letter from the state government and the director of the immigration department to travel outside of Rakhine State.

It is also unclear if what Dr. Win Myat Aye stated will be put into practice as the new policy of the government. The NLD-dominated Parliament had proposed to get rid of Form (4) altogether, and unless it is removed, freedom of movement could remain difficult for NVC holders.

Statements from Union ministers, senior NLD and USDP members indicate that different sides and translating the situation differently.

Despite the social welfare minister repeatedly discussing the benefits of NVCs, Muslims in strife-torn towns Buthidaung, Maungdaw and Rathedaung are banned from traveling and currently need recommendation letters from village officials and local authorities to even visit neighboring Muslim villages. This indicates that even now, the NVC doesn't work on the ground and the meaning of the NVC remains a puzzle for the Rohingya.

A Rohingya man from Maungdaw said, "We are not allowed to visit a neighboring village without the recommendation of a village administrative officer even now. How can we trust the NVC?"

The post Despite Govt Efforts, Divide Persists Over Rohingya Freedom of Movement appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Youth Safety and Health at Work: Early Education Equals Early Protection

Posted: 26 Apr 2018 01:42 AM PDT

 In the Asia-Pacific region, more people than anywhere else start working from a young age. As youths, they often work in hazardous and exploitative jobs to earn income for their families. Some of this work constitutes child labor. This year, for World Day for Safety and Health at Work, the International Labor Organization (ILO) is focusing on improving the working conditions of young workers as well as bringing an end to child labor.

In Myanmar, there are more than 8 million workers aged between 15 and 24. These workers comprise 21 percent of the country's workforce. Often it is poverty that pushes young people to start working from an early age. They enter the workforce with virtually no knowledge about occupational hazards and risks, nor any awareness about their occupational safety and health (OSH) rights.

Many young workers in Myanmar and in the rest of the Asia-Pacific are in the informal economy and are engaged in agricultural, industrial and artisanal work. These workplaces tend to be out of the reach of OSH laws and are otherwise difficult to inspect. In addition, workers frequently lack an understanding of the importance of OSH.

Poor working conditions and a lack of OSH training often translate to higher rates of injury among workers who would otherwise have had a long working career ahead of them. They are also at risk of contracting occupational diseases with harmful long-term effects. For example, exposure to hazardous agents such as asbestos, pesticides and other chemicals can ultimately lead to serious diseases and potentially death.

Concerted Tripartite Efforts

Providing young workers with decent and safe employment opportunities is indispensable for future social and economic development. Governments, employers and workers need to build, implement and continuously strengthen a culture of prevention. Indeed, the Myanmar government is currently engaging in regular tripartite dialogues to set standards and a new comprehensive OSH law, currently before the Parliament, will hopefully be adopted shortly.

It is crucial that national policies are in line with international labor standards. In particular, there should be full compliance with the ILO Promotional Framework for Occupational Safety and Health Convention, 2006 (No. 187).

Encouragingly, there have been increased ratifications of the Convention in the region, and we hope Myanmar will follow suit.  Myanmar already ratified ILO Convention 182 on the worst forms of child labor in December 2013, and with the assistance of the ILO the government is in the process of finalizing its first National Action Plan on Child Labor and the list of hazardous jobs prohibited for workers under the age of 18.

Educating for a Safer Future of Work

While efforts to improve the current state of workplaces are critical, there must also be efforts to educate future generations in OSH. By one estimate, 65 percent of children in primary school today will work in jobs that currently do not exist. In order to ensure that these jobs do not jeopardize the health and safety of future generations, it is crucial that children are educated from a young age.

This system of early education should be provided consistently, thus promoting a culture of prevention.

When it comes to building a culture of prevention, clear and effective communication is essential. In Myanmar, the ILO's Youth4OSH Project is providing organizations and networks with tools and strategies to raise workplace OSH awareness among young workers and young employers.

The ILO SafeYouth@Work Project is working to mainstream OSH in technical vocational education and training curricula so that young workers in Myanmar learn how to work safely at the same time that they acquire marketable job skills.

Educating young people on the importance of OSH is necessary for a safe future of work. We must do all we can to ensure that young people are aware of, and protected by, OSH principles so that they too are given the chance to work in a safe and healthy workplace.

Tomoko Nishimoto is an assistant director-general of the International Labor Organization and regional director for Asia and the Pacific.

The post Youth Safety and Health at Work: Early Education Equals Early Protection appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Fighting Fire in a Wasteland

Posted: 26 Apr 2018 01:13 AM PDT

A giant fire raging at Yangon’s largest dumpsite, in Hlaing Thaya Township, has been defying firefighters since Saturday. Making matters worse, noxious smoke from the fire has spread to nearby areas and hit downtown, choking some residents. On Wednesday, Yangon Mayor U Maung Maung Soe said 80 percent of the fire was under control. State Counselor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi has offered the union government’s help. As of Wednesday afternoon, though, firefighters and soldiers were still hard at work battling the blaze.

The post Fighting Fire in a Wasteland appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

EXCLUSIVE: US Team in Refugee Camps Investigating Atrocities Against Rohingya

Posted: 25 Apr 2018 10:52 PM PDT

WASHINGTON/COX’S BAZAR, Bangladesh — The US government is conducting an intensive examination of alleged atrocities against Myanmar’s Rohingya Muslims, documenting accusations of murder, rape, beatings and other possible offenses in an investigation that could be used to prosecute Myanmar’s military for crimes against humanity, US officials told Reuters.

The undertaking, led by the State Department, has involved more than 1,000 interviews of Rohingya men and women in refugee camps in neighboring Bangladesh, where almost 700,000 Rohingya have fled after a military crackdown last year in Myanmar’s northwestern Rakhine State, two US officials said. The work is modeled on a US forensic investigation of mass atrocities in Sudan’s Darfur region in 2004, which led to a US declaration of genocide that culminated in economic sanctions against the Sudanese government.

The interviews were conducted in March and April by about 20 investigators with backgrounds in international law and criminal justice, including some who worked on tribunals for Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia, the US officials said.

The information will be analyzed in Washington and documented in a report to be sent to the State Department’s leadership in May or early June, the officials said. It’s unclear whether the Trump administration will publicly release the findings, or whether they will be used to justify new sanctions on the Myanmar government or a recommendation for international prosecution.

“The purpose of this investigation is to contribute to justice processes, including community awareness raising, international advocacy efforts, and community-based reconciliation efforts, as well as possible investigations, truth-seeking efforts, or other efforts for justice and accountability,” said a document used by the investigators in the sprawling refugee camps and reviewed by Reuters.

Three US officials in Washington and several people involved in the investigation on the ground in Bangladesh disclosed details of the fact-finding operation to Reuters.

A State Department official, asked to confirm the specifics of the investigation conducted in the refugee camps as reported by Reuters, said “the program details are accurate.” The official, speaking on condition of anonymity, said the US government was using all available information and a wide range of tools, but added: “We cannot get ahead of the deliberative, policymaking process.”

As of publication, the Myanmar government and military had not responded to questions from Reuters. Myanmar has said its operations in Rakhine were a legitimate response to attacks on security forces by Rohingya insurgents.

The interviewers in the camps asked the refugees basic demographic questions, the date the person left Myanmar, and to recount their experiences during the wave of violence unleashed against the Rohingya in Rakhine State by the Myanmar military and local Buddhist residents.

The investigators also asked refugees to describe the battalions and weaponry used by the Myanmar military in Rakhine State during operations against the Rohingya, said one person involved with the investigation in the camps, which are located in the Cox’s Bazar district in southern Bangladesh. The investigators have received names of individual perpetrators and the identities of specific battalions allegedly involved, this person said.

A second person involved in the project on the ground said 1,025 refugees have been interviewed and the assignment may include a second phase focused on military units.

Zohra Khatun, 35, a Rohingya refugee in the camps, said she told investigators that soldiers waged a campaign of violence and harassment in her village in Rakhine State starting last August. They made arrests and shot several people, driving her and others to flee, she said.

“One military officer grabbed me by the throat and tried to take me,” she told Reuters, clutching her shirt collar to demonstrate. The military, she said, burned homes in the village, including hers.

The investigation coincides with a debate inside the US government and on Capitol Hill over whether the Trump administration has done enough to hold Myanmar’s military to account for brutal violence against the largely stateless Rohingya.

The Rohingya are a small Muslim minority in majority-Buddhist Myanmar. Though they have been present in what’s now Myanmar for generations, many Burmese consider them to be interlopers. Violence against them has increased in recent years as the country has made a partial shift to democratic governance.

In November, following the lead of the United Nations and the European Union, then-Secretary of State Rex Tillerson declared that the Rohingya crisis constituted “ethnic cleansing,” a designation that raised the possibility of additional sanctions against Myanmar’s military commanders and increased pressure on its civilian leader, Nobel peace laureate Daw Aung San Suu Kyi. The Myanmar government has denied the accusations.

The United States responded in December by imposing targeted sanctions on one Myanmar general and threatening to penalize others. Washington has also scaled back already-limited military ties with Myanmar since the Rohingya crisis began. Human rights groups and Democratic lawmakers in Washington have urged the Republican White House to widen sanctions and designate the violence as “crimes against humanity,” a legal term that can set the stage for charges at the International Criminal Court in The Hague.

“No decisions have been made on that front, but it’s something being looked at very carefully,” a senior Trump administration official told Reuters.

A Reuters investigation published in February provided the first independent confirmation of what had taken place in the village of Inn Din, where 10 Rohingya Muslim men and boys were hacked to death by Rakhine Buddhist villagers or shot by security force members. The story was based on accounts not only from Rohingya refugees but also from soldiers, police officers and Buddhist locals who admitted to participating in the bloodshed.

Pictures obtained by Reuters showed the men and boys with their hands tied behind their backs and their bodies in a shallow grave. Two Reuters journalists were jailed while reporting the story and remain in prison in Yangon, where they face up to 14 years in jail on possible charges of violating Myanmar’s Official Secrets Act.

So far, there has been resistance by lawyers in the White House and State Department to adopt the terms “crimes against humanity” or “genocide” in describing deaths of Rohingya in Myanmar, the US officials said.

The State Department itself has been divided over how to characterize or interpret the violence against the Rohingya, the officials said.

The East Asian and Pacific Affairs Bureau, staffed largely by career diplomats and representing the view of the embassy in Myanmar, has held at times “to a success narrative” on Myanmar since the lifting of sanctions was announced in October 2016 and the strong public role played by the US government in the historic 2012 opening of the country after decades of military rule, one official said.

Diplomats in Yangon have also been reluctant to jeopardize Washington’s relationship with Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, a democratic icon who has faced criticism for failing to do more to rein in the violence against the Rohingya. Some senior US officials still believe Daw Aung San Suu Kyi remains the best hope for a more democratic Myanmar, one official said. “They are reluctant to upset that relationship.”

That contrasts with the State Department’s Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor, based in Washington, which has pushed for tougher sanctions, the officials said. Bridging that gap has been made more difficult because the State Department under President Donald Trump has yet to fill many important diplomatic positions, the officials said.

Officials described the process in the refugee camps of documenting the abuses as rigorous. Each interview was coded with key words according to the alleged crime, such as killing, rape, sexual violence and lynching. Different categories of alleged perpetrator also have codes – from civilians to insurgents, Myanmar military personnel and police.

“After the 1,000 interviews and statistical analysis, we can draw certain conclusions about the perpetrators of crime and patterns of crime,” one official said.

The official said one possible result from the documentation of abuses against the Rohingya could be a vote by the United Nations General Assembly to establish an international body to investigate the most serious crimes committed against the Rohingya, similar to what it’s done with Syria.

The State Department did not respond to questions about divisions within the administration over how to characterize the violence and criticism that the administration was too slow in acting to halt abuses.

Subiya Khatun, 29, who fled her Rakhine home in September and reported seeing three dead bodies in a canal on her way to the Bangladesh border, said she hoped for justice and a safe return to Myanmar.

“They said they have come from America. ‘This investigation will be used for your help,'” she said she was told by the people who interviewed her in the camps. “If Allah wishes, we will get justice and our demands will be fulfilled.”

The post EXCLUSIVE: US Team in Refugee Camps Investigating Atrocities Against Rohingya appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

EU Readies More Sanctions Against Myanmar

Posted: 25 Apr 2018 10:07 PM PDT

BRUSSELS — The European Union will extend its arms embargo on Myanmar for another year this week and may then move to target more Yangon generals with fresh sanctions, EU diplomats and officials said.

The EU accuses Myanmar of “serious and systemic” human rights violations in a military operation in the country’s northwest last year that sent nearly 700,000 Rohingya Muslims fleeing to neighboring Bangladesh.

The EU arms embargo is now in place until the end of April and the diplomats and officials said it would be extended for another year before that deadline expires.

It will also be expanded to cover already limited training for the Myanmar military, they said.

Last October, the EU decided to shun Myanmar generals over the operation in Rakhine State, which the United Nations denounces as ethnic cleansing. Yangon rejects these accusations.

The US government is now conducting an intensive examination of alleged atrocities against the Rohingya that could be used to prosecute Myanmar’s military for crimes against humanity, officials told Reuters.

EU sources said the bloc might slap visa bans and asset freezes on more Myanmar military figures in May or June, with Major General Maung Maung Soe being one name on the list.

Last December, the United States levied sanctions on the man who had been in charge of the crackdown on the Rohingya minority in Rakhine.

Canada followed suit in February when Reuters also reported on what had taken place in the village of Inn Din, where 10 Rohingya Muslim men and boys were hacked to death by Rakhine Buddhist villagers or shot by security force members.

The killings were part of the larger army crackdown on the Rohingya. Two Reuters journalists were jailed while reporting the story and remain in prison in Yangon, where they face up to 14 years in jail for violating Myanmar’s Official Secrets Act.

The EU is considering six other members of the military as well, the diplomats and officials said, though that has not yet been discussed by all 28 member states who must reach a unanimous decision to introduce sanctions.

The West’s relations with Myanmar soured over the crackdown on the Rohingya despite the Southeast Asian country making a partial shift to democratic governance in recent years.

The post EU Readies More Sanctions Against Myanmar appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

UN Chief Taps Swiss Ambassador to Germany as Myanmar Envoy: Sources

Posted: 25 Apr 2018 09:56 PM PDT

UNITED NATIONS — United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres has tapped Switzerland’s Ambassador to Germany, Christine Schraner Burgener, to be his special envoy on Myanmar, UN sources said on Wednesday.

Myanmar has faced international criticism over a military crackdown that has sent nearly 700,000 minority Rohingya Muslims fleeing to Bangladesh. The United Nations, United States, Britain and others have described the operation as ethnic cleansing, which Myanmar has denied.

In December the UN General Assembly adopted a resolution asking Guterres to appoint a UN special envoy on Myanmar, putting a special focus of the world body on trying to help resolve the crisis.

Myanmar UN Ambassador Hau Do Suan did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Wednesday on Guterres’ plan to appoint Schraner Burgener, who was previously Switzerland’s ambassador to Thailand.

UN spokesman Stephane Dujarric said on Wednesday that he expected an announcement of an appointment “in the coming days.”

UN Security Council envoys are due to travel to Bangladesh and Myanmar shortly to assess the situation.

Hau Do Suan told Reuters earlier this month that his country welcomed “any constructive engagement and counsel of any kind from the international community to advance human rights.”

However, he said Myanmar does not believe the appointment of a special envoy “will solve the multi-faceted and complex situation of Myanmar unless his or her mandate is carried out based on the principle of respect for the sovereignty and dignity of the country concerned, objectivity and impartiality.”

He noted that the position would need the full cooperation of the government and people of Myanmar to work.

The post UN Chief Taps Swiss Ambassador to Germany as Myanmar Envoy: Sources appeared first on The Irrawaddy.