Monday, September 11, 2017

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


‘They Worry About Their Lives’

Posted: 11 Sep 2017 07:12 AM PDT

Since Muslim militants attacked police stations in northern Rakhine State on Aug. 25, some 300,000 self-identifying Rohingya have fled the Bangladesh border while about 30,000 ethnic Arakanese have fled to state capital Sittwe.

Some Arakanese, however, stayed in their villages in Maungdaw and Buthidaung—the two townships hit hardest by the violence.

The 88 Generation Peace and Open Society group's relief team has been providing assistance to those affected people in the area since Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) launched its attacks.

One of the relief team's members, Daw Mee Mee, spoke to The Irrawaddy about her experiences and perspectives of the recent conflict.

Where in Maungdaw did you arrive?

We arrived at Sittwe on September 2 and the next morning continued to Maungdaw, the conflict zone. We requested the security come with us to provide assistance to those trapped villages, as they didn't have much support. We had to wait two nights to get the security, and then went to Kyein Chaung village with five police officers, but they switched with another team of five when we arrived. We slept in Kyein Chaung for the night but then the next morning we did not have any security with us so we returned to Maungdaw.

We heard there are improvised landmines along the road to Kyein Chaung. Did you see the clearing of those mines?

They [the security] cleared the improvised landmines early in the morning. We arrived there in the afternoon, after they did the clearance. On the way to Kyein Chaung, we were only faced with the terrible road and our trucks were bogged down in the mud, but we encountered no mines. On our return journey, we also had to wait for two hours for them to clear mines, so we did not see any. But we saw houses in flames from afar and heard gunfire over night in Kyein Chuang.

Local residents are extremely concerned about their security. What's your assessment of the government's security preparations? And in order to relieve residents' concerns, what should the government do?

We heard about their concerns in Kyein Chaung. When we arrived at the village, at night, shops in front of the police's special branch office were on fire. People were so afraid. We had for big trucks carrying food items, but on our way back, people hurriedly climbed on to those trucks. People also fled from Yan Aung Myint village, where the fighting happened. They wanted to get away from the villages as soon as possible and would not listen to us; we could not deter them. So we brought them with us to Maungdaw.

The public would not be in fear if they were sure they had protection. What we saw was defensive measures instead of prevention from the attacks, and then the clearance operations followed.

According to an officer, a corporal was injured by an improvised explosive device (IED). The security forces told me they could not follow the attackers after encountering the trapped mines. The attackers have complete awareness of the region. Security forces had to focus on taking the injured men to hospital in order to save their lives, so they could not follow the attackers. Local people staying in the village must be freed from fear. When I talked to them, they said they do not worry about their food—they worry about their lives.

Now is very different from the incidents back in 2012. The attacks were an intrusion on our sovereignty. It is very important for our country and for our people.

There are accusations the Tatmadaw planted the mines and set fires. Did local people talk of such incidents? Could they freely talk about it?

Many people say they [militants] burned their own houses and fled. But I did not witness it myself. What we saw were houses in flames.

People are questioning whether Muslim militants could burn their own homes and then flee. What is your view on it?

I could not tell who torched the houses, but what I can surely tell is, there are attacks using homemade bombs, IEDs and shooting. And there is counter shooting. In our country, only the Myanmar armed forces—Tatmadaw and police forces—have arms. Why did the villagers have such weapons, and why did they shot with guns and homemade guns and attacked with trapped mines? Their actions not only target government institutions but also civilians. Burning homes or not, the most important thing is these actions are trying to violate our country's sovereignty.

This interview has been edited for clarity and brevity.

The post 'They Worry About Their Lives' appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Myanmar Mystic ET Dies in Yangon

Posted: 11 Sep 2017 03:44 AM PDT

YANGON — Myanmar's well-known mystic Daw Swe Swe Win—known by her clients as ET—died of natural causes at her home in Yangon's Thingangyun Township early in the morning on Sunday. She was 57.

ET was consulted as a fortune teller or soothsayer by some of Myanmar's—and Asia's—most influential figures, including a number of ruling Myanmar generals and former Thai Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra.

Her family members began to notice her ability to make predictions when she was just nine years old.

A severe fever at the age of 14 left her deaf, mute, and unable to walk unassisted. She rose to fame as a fortune teller and was nicknamed ET by her clients for her resemblance to the main character in Steven Spielberg's movie "ET the Extra Terrestrial" (1982).

She turned 57 on July 5.

Even though she only received a formal education up to the fifth grade, her clients reported that she was able to write fluently in English.

She issued predictions in writing or through her younger sister Daw Thi Thi Win who read her lips.

She set up the ET Foundation to fund eye surgery for impoverished patients, including cataract procedures.

In May, she requested King of Thailand Maha Vajiralongkorn Bodindradebayavarangkun to grant an amnesty to two migrant workers from Myanmar sentenced to death in Thailand for the double murder of two British backpackers in Koh Tao in 2014.

The two men were arrested in October 2014, one month after the crime took place. On Dec. 24, 2015, it was announced they would receive the death sentence.

In a letter to the Thai King, ET said that Win Zaw Htun and Zaw Lin had been "falsely arrested and convicted" in the murder case, which has been ongoing for nearly three years.

During her career, she refused to predict political results or the results of illegal lottery—locally known as "chel." The policy was written on a sign in her house.

She will be buried on Tuesday at Yayway Cemetery in Yangon, according to family members.

The post Myanmar Mystic ET Dies in Yangon appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Karen Govt Mulls Lawsuit Against Organizers of Nationalist Rally

Posted: 11 Sep 2017 01:25 AM PDT

MAWLAMYINE, Mon State — The Karen State government may sue organizers of a nationalist rally on Rakhine State's unraveling conflict held at Taunggalay Ground in Karen State capital Hpa-an, according to the state's Mon ethnic affairs minister U Min Tin Win.

The organizers' application for the event was rejected by the Hpa-an administrator "for certain reasons," minister U Min Tin Win told The Irrawaddy on Monday. The administrator wrote to the state government, advising it to file a lawsuit against the organizers for persisting with the event.

The Karen State Association for Protection of Race and Religion claimed about 40,000 people attended its talks on Sunday. The chapter—known by its Myanmar acronym Ma Ba Tha—has defied a countrywide ban by the State Buddhist Sangha authority from operating under its current name.

Chapter spokesperson Ashin Gambisara said speakers at the event condemned the violence in Rakhine State. They called for an end to perceived oppression of Buddhism and Buddhists and unity among the citizens of Myanmar, he said.

Organizers requested permission for the event, said Ashin Gambisara, adding that authorities "did not reject it but did not like it."

"They cited things like security concerns and H1N1 flu virus, and said they thought it should not be organized. But they didn't say they would not allow it. If they hadn't allowed it, we would not have done it," Ashin Gambisara told The Irrawaddy.

Among the event's four speakers was ultranationalist monk U Wirathu, who the state Buddhist authority banned from delivering sermons for one year, starting from March 10, due to his religious hate speech.

He criticized the National League for Democracy (NLD) government at the event, accusing it of being "pro-Muslim" despite international criticism of its treatment of self-identifying Rohingya Muslims in Rakhine, nearly 300,000 of whom have fled to Bangladesh since Aug. 25 militant attacks on police outposts.

"Its name is National League for Democracy. This is a combination of two things—nationalism and democracy. If it puts all its efforts into nationalism and democracy, Myanmar would be top of Asia. But seeing is believing. Its name includes 'national,' but in its offices, all the staff are foreigners," he told the crowd.

Maung Thway Chun, chief editor of the nationalist group's recently suspended weekly journals, columnist for those publications, U Kyaw Swe, and writer Anyataya Kapiya also spoke at the event.

U Min Tin Win said the event was aimed at attacking a government facing growing crises across the country.

"They said their talks were about the immigration issue in Rakhine State, but they were not. They targeted the government and I think they are sparking one fire after another. It is not what a dutiful Myanmar citizen should do," he said.

After the event on Sunday, Karen State Ma Ba Tha released a statement calling on the government to officially deny self-identifying Rohingya recognition as an ethnicity in Myanmar, and to take prompt actions against Muslim militants in Rakhine.

It also called on the government to recognize the name Ma Ba Tha, allow it to continue publishing weekly journals Aung Zay Yatu and Atumashi, and release detained nationalists.

The state Buddhist authority—known as Ma Ha Na—on May 23 banned the nationalist organization from operating under its current name and also ordered that all signs bearing the name be taken down across the country by July.

Ma Ba Tha then changed its name to Buddha Dhamma Charity Foundation (Central), but the Karen State chapter has defied the ban and continues to operate under the current name.

The Irrawaddy was not able to reach Hpa-an Township administrator U Myo Min Tun for comment on Monday.

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post Karen Govt Mulls Lawsuit Against Organizers of Nationalist Rally appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Thoughts on Rakhine State 

Posted: 11 Sep 2017 01:08 AM PDT

Today it is extremely hard, almost impossible, to obtain credible information on the situation in Rakhine State. There are no impartial witnesses in the field. Reliable journalists have difficulty knowing the truth, as they are escorted by Myanmar security forces to selected locations, their interlocuters unable to speak freely. Disinformation reigns.

For the time being, I have not yet found a single article or TV report that has satisfied me. The context lends itself to extreme, emotional, passionate, irrational attitudes, that make it impossible to understand the reality on the ground.

Having said this, in brief, an attack by the ARSA (Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army) on some 30 security force outposts has recently triggered a new cycle of violence. The attack occurred just after a Kofi Annan-led advisory commission delivered its final recommendations to improve the situation in Rakhine State.

The reaction of government security forces was immediate. Disproportionate or not, their clearance operations led some 300,000 members of the local Muslim community to flee their homes and seek refuge in Bangladesh.

Ethnic Rakhine, Hindus and other groups fled to the south, fearing ARSA. The situation isn't black and white. There have been reprehensible acts on both sides. But widespread accusations of Muslim villagers burning their own villages before fleeing them are hardly plausibly. Those displaced to Bangladesh are not warmly welcomed and they do not seem to be willing to remain there long-term.

But in this context, it is advisable at this time not to qualify the situation as genocide or ethnic cleansing against the Muslim community – which the government does not recognize as an ethnic nationality but as a group of interlopers from Bangladesh. It is important to try to diffuse the tension and anger in the region, and use language that will not rile either side.

The international community should accept the fact that this Muslim community [that identifies as Rohingya] is not recognized as an ethnic nationality of Myanmar. Having said that, those who have lived in the country for generations should have the right to quickly become permanent residents and then citizens. If there are doubts regarding residency or the desire to integrate into Myanmar society, there should be a probation period established.

In the prevailing context, it is absolutely necessary for all of the victims, residents, the Myanmar government and the international community that the conflict zone is accessible to an international and credible organization whose mandate matches the needs of the current situation.

Today, only the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) with support from the Myanmar Red Cross Society (MRCS) is in a position to fulfill this task. It is extremely urgent that the government and other concerned parties give the green light to the Geneva Institution for relief and protective actions for all civilians who are victims of the conflict in Rakhine State.

Aung Ko Ko is a pseudonym – he is a seasoned Myanmar observer with extensive knowledge of ethnic issues and conflict in the country, who has lived in Myanmar and the surrounding region for 24 years.

The post Thoughts on Rakhine State  appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

One Arrested as Police Disperse Nationalist Mob in Magwe Division

Posted: 10 Sep 2017 11:09 PM PDT

MANDALAY – One man was arrested in Magwe Region's Taungdwingyi after a nationalist mob – some armed with swords – attacked a mosque and property owned by Muslims before being dispersed by riot police with rubber bullets on Sunday evening.

"The situation in Taungdwingyi is now under control and security forces are deployed," said a statement released by the government's Information Committee on Sunday, adding that some 21 army and 30 police from Magwe Division base were deployed to maintain order.

Hnin Ko Ko Lin, 30, was arrested for his part in stoning the house of butcher Ko Jinner in Ohn Taw Quarter No. 1 in the town at 8 p.m. on Sunday, the statement said, adding that police were searching for more culprits and that they would be dealt with "according to the law."

According to locals the nationalist mob was at times 400 strong and some carried swords and bamboo rods.

"The mob start stoning the house of a Muslim man and other shops along the Taungdwingyi-Magwe road while cursing and singing nationalist songs," a local Muslim resident told The Irrawaddy on the condition of anonymity.

They later began attacking a mosque in Shwe Kyar Inn quarter before being dispersed by police, he said.

"We do not know why the mob gathered like that. My family is hiding somewhere safe, as we are afraid to stay in our home," he added.

Local police told The Irrawaddy they are still investigating how the mob gathered. According to the Information Committee Hnin Ko Ko Lin said he was acting because of the "disappointing situation in Rakhine State."

Violence is sweeping Rakhine State after deadly attacks by the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) on 30 police outposts on Aug. 25.

Subsequent attacks, violence, and government security operations have killed hundreds, displaced thousands of ethnic Arakanese and Hindu according to the government and sent nearly 300,000 self-identifying Rohingya Muslims fleeing across the border to Bangladesh, according to the UN.

ARSA announced a month-long unilateral ceasefire, starting on Sunday, to enable aid groups to help ease the humanitarian crisis gripping Rakhine.

On Saturday, the government also requested the public not send "online and SMS attack warnings," after rumors spread of further ARSA attacks, and announced that it would take legal action against those instigating public panic.

Sunday's statement said security forces had been deployed in other cities to maintain order.

On Sunday, opposition party the Union Solidarity and Development Party held a meeting in Yangon titled "Discussion on the Rakhine Issue that is Threatening National Security,"

In Karen State, nationalists led by firebrand Buddhist monk U Wirathu gathered to condemn ARSA's attacks that they called the "oppression of race and religion."

The post One Arrested as Police Disperse Nationalist Mob in Magwe Division appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Letting Go of the Tiger’s Tail

Posted: 10 Sep 2017 08:28 PM PDT

The Irrawaddy revisits this story from September 2007 to commemorate the 10th anniversary of the Saffron Revolution, a series of nationwide monk-led protests against the former military regime that ended in a violent government crackdown.

Have you ever caught hold of a tiger's tail? If not, Myanmar generals can report what it's like—they've probably had some experiences to share with you.

Myanmar's Gen Ne Win, who staged a military coup in 1962, once caught hold of a tiger's tail and never let it go.

The general, who introduced the "Burmese way to Socialism" and self-imposed isolation to the country, soon realized the failure of his nationalization policy.

In 1965, three years after the coup, he famously told journalists and officials: “It was like having caught hold of a tiger’s tail." Then he added: “But there was nothing else to do but hang on to it.”

Today, the tiger is reawakening as the monks march out of their monasteries and members of the everyday public join them in the streets in what is looking like a repetition of the 1988 uprising.

But, the demonstrations this time are different to those of 1988. They started simply enough when members of the 88 Student Generation group staged a march in Yangon on August 19. Predictably, the generals cracked down again, arresting and imprisoning more than 400 activists.

But, the 88 Student Generation leaders’ demonstration touched a public nerve. They had stood up for everyday citizens, outraged over the sudden, steep hikes in fuel and commodity prices. The generals made a serious political blunder, and when 13 of the group's leaders were manhandled, imprisoned and some were reportedly tortured more fuel was added to the fire.

Enter the monks, who for years had remained silent in their monasteries. When they took to the streets, and were also subsequently manhandled and brutally beaten in Pakokku on September 5, the brutality of the authorities infuriated the Sangha who demanded an apology from the regime only to be met by silence.

What has happened since is a casebook study on street-politics, which some observers say indicates a controlling strategy behind the present demonstrations. Over the past week, the monks have sent clear symbols to the outside world and to the people of Myanmar.

First, they marched to religious pagodas not to public buildings, thereby claiming the highest moral ground and making it harder for the military to intervene.

Second, they marched to the Chinese Embassy where they paused to chant the “Metta Sutta,” the Buddha’s words on loving kindness, thereby sending a signal to those who support the junta.

Third, they marched to the home of opposition leader Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, who appeared before them, symbolically uniting with the monks.

And now the monks have asked the students and public “to join hands.”

A new tiger had been unleashed, one that will be harder for the junta to control.

Now the tiger's tail is being held by junta leader Snr-Gen Than Shwe and his cronies. If they fail through fear to let go of it they'll probably see history repeating itself.

The wave of protests led by thousands of monks has shaken a once confident regime that hijacked Myanmar's political legitimacy and took control of the country at gunpoint. Myanmar is clearly a political time bomb that can explode anytime.

The regime has lost all public confidence in its own plan to bring stability to the country through the mechanism of the National Convention tasked with drafting guidelines for a new constitution.

The determined monks' peaceful marches have stolen the regime's show and injected new energy into the fragile opposition movement.

What about the international community, however?

We continue to see selfish, opportunist and ill-informed neighbors who are quick to exploit Myanmar's resources but reluctant to support moves towards political change and democracy.

The UN and the West continue to adopt a policy of "closely watching" events in Myanmar. UN special envoys continue to fly in and out of Myanmar with no tangible results. By mixing small doses of good news with a bounty of bad they are only doing the Myanmar people a disfavor by equating one with the other.

The monks, activists and their supporters are the true heroes in the current stage of Myanmar history.

They are also realists, understanding full well that there is no easy shortcut or quick fix to cure Myanmar's ills. Yet they also know best how to confront the regime and solve the country's problems.

They know Myanmar cannot afford to lose many more years. Their message to the generals is: let go of the tiger's tail.

The post Letting Go of the Tiger’s Tail appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Changing The Lives of Displaced Children

Posted: 10 Sep 2017 06:28 PM PDT

At a camp for internally displaced persons (IDP) in Kachin State's Kutkai Township in 2016, humanitarian aid worker Lamai Mai Mai noticed 3-year-old Gun Mai was being teased by other children for covering his mouth all the time.

She found out that Gun Mai was born with a cleft palate.

Mai Mai felt heartbroken by what she saw and, by sharing a photo of the boy on her social media pages, she managed to find funding for his medical treatment in less than a week.

After seeing her post, other residents and aid workers of IDP camps contacted Mai Mai requesting help for children suffering from cleft palates and lips—birth defects that occur when a baby's mouth does not form properly during pregnancy and commonly called orofacial clefts.

This was how 39-year-old Mai Mai came to work treating IDP children with these problems. In the last year, she has helped 11 children access treatment.

"They have all had their cleft lip operations, and are just waiting for their cleft palate operations," she said.

Mai Mai is also a founder of the National Ethnic Youth Conference, which gathered 800 youth delegates from 27 ethnic tribes in Myanmar in August 2016, aiming to foster understanding and trust and build a peaceful, federal union in Myanmar.

She is also a founding member of the Kachin Youth Organization and helped organize the National Ethnic Youth Alliance meeting in July 2016. Mai Mai teaches Myanmar youth about federalism, democracy, citizenship.

On March 16, 2017, Mai Mai was recognized as a "Woman of Change" by the US Embassy to Myanmar.

A fellow organizer of the National Ethnic Youth Conference and president of the Naga Youth Council Athong Makury said Mai Mai is "ready to face challenges, she is compassionate and committed to her people."

Lamai Mai Mai (right) visits a disabled child in Lashio, Shan State in March 2017. (Photo: Supplied)

As a formerly displaced person who spent almost four years in Mai Jay Yang camp on the border of China in Kachin State she said, "I know how difficult IDP life is, I know the on-the-ground situation and the particular needs of IDPs."

"Life in the IDP camp is a struggle, filled with fear and insecurity," Mai Mai said as she reflected on the event.

Mai Mai has worked to help young Kachin people fight drug addiction and find jobs since 2002.

In late 2010, Mai Mai was working with jobless youth in Kachin Independence Army (KIA)-controlled areas. As she returned from a trip to China, she was accused of being a human trafficker by Myanmar authorities and evaded arrest by hiding in an IDP camp.

Mai Mai worked with civil society organizations to help some of the 100,000 vulnerable people displaced in northern Shan State and Kachin State in 2011 when a 17-year ceasefire between the Myanmar Army and the KIA broke down.

International and local aid groups provide the basic needs of IDPs including rice, oil, and shelter, she said, but often fail to provide adequate medical provision.

She found lots of disabled children suffering in camps in need of specialists support.

Incidences of cleft lips and palates occur in every 800 to 1,000 births, meaning an estimated 6,000 children are affected each year, according to a lecture by surgeon Dr. Thi Ha Myint Wei in January 2016.

Experts believe orofacial clefts may be caused by insufficient nutrient, drug and alcohol usage, cigarette smoking, or taking certain medication during pregnancy.

A doctor from Lashio in northern Shan State visiting an IDP camp said malnutrition and insufficient maternal health education were to blame.

Only a handful of practices in large towns and cities can perform the necessary surgical procedure to correct them, he said, adding that it's not just the costs of surgery that leaves families out of pocket, but also traveling and daily expenses during hospital stays.

Mai Mai is currently collecting data on orofacial clefts and other disabilities affecting children in IDP camps to be passed to the Social Welfare Ministry and the local authorities, Mai Mai told The Irrawaddy.

"As far as I know, there was no a specific organization or groups supporting these issues in IDP camps and nearby villages until now," Mai Mai said.

"I've decided to help as much as I can."

She told The Irrawaddy that she can't afford to do it alone. She is busy asking camp leaders, local communities, and authorities to help tackle the problem.

"This issue is important," Mai Mai stated, "children are our future."

The post Changing The Lives of Displaced Children appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Shan Herald Agency for News

Shan Herald Agency for News


‘Prosecute Suu Kyi for crime against humanity’

Posted: 10 Sep 2017 09:26 AM PDT

A lawyer today served legal notice to the prosecution of International Crimes Tribunal to prosecute Aung San Suu Kyi for "genocide and crime against humanity" in Myanmar.

Supreme Court lawyer Mohammad Delwar Hossain also sought investigation into alleged genocide and crime against humanity against Suu Kyi and six other Myanmar officials.


Six other officials of Myanmar are – Senior General Min AungHIaing, commander in chief of armed forces, Lt Gen KyawSwe, union minister for home affairs, NaiThetLwin, union minister of ethnic affairs, Lt Gen Ye Aung, union minister of border affairs, General Zaw Win, chief of national police, and Monk Ashin Wirathu, Leader of '969 Movement' currently representing Ma Ba Tha (Committee for the protection of Nationality and Religion), according to the legal notice.  

Delwar Hossain sent the legal notice through Advocate Yousuf Ali yesterday saying that he will seek relief in appropriate court, if the chief prosecutor of ICT does not take steps to investigate into the seven Myanmar leaders for the offence of "Genocide and Crime against humanity perpetrated against the ethnic minority group of Rhingya in the vicinity of Magndow Township of the Republic of Union of Myanmar" within seven days.

He said in the legal notice that CNN and Al Jazeera reported that the Rohingyas were being raped tortured or saw their homes burned down and family members executed.

The ongoing attacks of the Myanmar government, military, police and security forces on and persecutions of the Rohingya population in Myanmar constitute genocide as defined by the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (the Genocide Convention) which is ratified by both Bangladesh and Myanmar, he said in the legal notice, adding that the Convention declares that genocide is a crime under the international law.

The legal notice said, "The State Bangladesh had an 'erga omnes obligation' under genocide convention to bring end to the crime against humanity. Therefore to discharge that obligation the state has promulgated the International Crimnes (Tribunals) Act 1973 (the ICT) making provision of the setting up of the tribunals for the prosecution and trial of the perpetrators of the international crimes including the crime against humanity".

Link Story : goo.gl/1gFiKA

Commentary on “Myanmar violence may have killed more than 1,000: UN rapporteur”

Posted: 10 Sep 2017 09:11 AM PDT

It is certainly going to be a permanent dark spot in the history of mankind, like Rwanda, Srebrenica, Cambodia and many others, whether we like it or not.

It is particularly sad that this has happened in a predominant Buddhist country where metta, which means loving-kindness, friendliness, goodwill, benevolence, fellowship, amity, concord, inoffensiveness and non-violence, and compassion should be the practice and order of the day.


As we are now being bogged down by multitude of problems, some self-made and some inherited, the leadership and all stakeholders should look forward and use every means available to pull the country out of all these seemingly unsolvable woes.

Maybe the teaching of His Holiness Dalai Lama would guide us – sinners and victims alike - to reconcile, tread the right path and give us strength to overcome the nightmare we are facing today.

He said: "There are only two days in the year that nothing can be done. One is called yesterday and the other is called tomorrow, so today is the right day to love, believe, do, and mostly, live."


Link to the story: Myanmar violence may have killed more than 1,000: UN rapporteur

Sunday, September 10, 2017

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


ARSA Declares Temporary Ceasefire Amid Humanitarian Crisis

Posted: 10 Sep 2017 06:22 AM PDT

BANGKOK/COX'S BAZAR, Bangladesh—The Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army declared a month-long unilateral ceasefire, starting on Sunday, to enable aid groups to help ease a humanitarian crisis in northwest Myanmar.

Nearly 300,000 self-identified Rohingya have fled to Bangladesh and 30,000 non-Muslim civilians have been displaced inside Myanmar after the military launched a counter-offensive following attacks by the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) insurgents on 30 police posts and an army base on Aug. 25.

"ARSA strongly encourages all concerned humanitarian actors resume their humanitarian assistance to all victims of the humanitarian crisis, irrespective of ethnic or religious background during the ceasefire period," ARSA said in a statement.

The impact of the move is unclear. The group does not appear to have been able to put up significant resistance against the military force unleashed in Myanmar's northwestern Rakhine state. In the last two weeks, thousands of homes have been burned down, dozens of villages uprooted and thousands of people are still on the move towards the border with Bangladesh.

The wave of hungry and traumatized refugees pouring into Bangladesh has strained aid agencies and local communities already helping hundreds of thousands displaced by previous waves of violence in Myanmar.

In its statement, ARSA called on the military to also lay down arms and allow humanitarian aid to all affected people.

Myanmar says its security forces are carrying out clearance operations to defend against ARSA, which the government has declared a terrorist organization.

Help for Bangladesh

On Friday, the United Nations in Bangladesh found tens of thousands of refugees who had not been counted before, raising the count to 270,000 from some 164,000 the day before. On Saturday, that jumped by another 20,000 to 290,000.

On Saturday, thousands of self-identified Rohingya were milling on the road near the camp of Kutapalong, carrying bamboo and tarpaulin to build shacks. Children and women flocked to every stopping vehicle, begging.

Aid workers say a serious humanitarian crisis is also unfolding on the Myanmar side of the border.

Red Cross organizations are scaling up their operations in Rakhine after the United Nations had to suspend activities there following government suggestions that its agency had supported the insurgents. The United Nations evacuated non-critical staff from the area.

Thousands of displaced people in Rakhine have been stranded or left without food for weeks. Many are still trying to cross mountains, dense bush and rice fields to reach Bangladesh.

"The UN and INGOs have not been very welcome in Rakhine and…they are not able to operate and ensure the safety and security of their staff and volunteers," said Joy Singhal of the International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC).

The government had invited the Red Cross to assist them, he said.

Aid workers worry many displaced persons had been left without food since mid-July, when the World Food Programme (WFP), which had been providing food and cash assistance, was unable to operate.

The government said it would set up camps for internally displaced people in Rakhine but the move could draw opposition from UN humanitarian experts.

The post ARSA Declares Temporary Ceasefire Amid Humanitarian Crisis appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Myanmar Muslim Organizations Condemn ARSA, Pledge Collaboration

Posted: 10 Sep 2017 12:01 AM PDT

YANGON — The All Myanmar Islamic Religious Organization on Saturday strongly condemned the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) for its terrorist acts in northern Rakhine State, and pledged collaboration with the government, interfaith groups and the public to prevent such acts.

Northern Rakhine State is reeling from the Muslim militant group's attacks on 30 police outposts on Aug. 25 and subsequent violence against civilians. The Myanmar government declared the group a terrorist organization shortly after the attacks began and has since begun clearance operations in the area, causing ethnic Rakhine, self-identified Rohingya and other Rakhine sub-ethnicities to flee their homes. The UN said that as of Friday, some 270,000 Muslim refugees had fled to Bangladesh.

The announcement from the national Islamic organization made up of five local Muslim organizations — including Jamiat Ulama-al Islam (H.Q), The Islamic Religious Affairs Council, All Myanmar Muslim Youth (Religious Affairs) and Myanmar Muslim Nation Affairs Organization — came a few days after anonymous warnings against possible Muslim and Buddhist attacks on Monday circulated via Facebook messenger and SMS to both Buddhist and Muslim communities across the country. Both the Myanmar government and the military issued a public alert that the ARSA was preparing for terrorist acts in the country's major cities, including Yangon and Naypyitaw.

The statement released by the Islamic umbrella organization said they "have never accepted terrorism and are totally against it."

"We are very much concerned about the attacks given the government's alert. The government needs to strictly prevent the online instigations calling for racial and religious conflict at the moment," it read.

It also added that the organization felt sorry along with the bereaved families of innocent civilians killed by terrorists in Rakhine State as well as for displaced people.

U Nyunt Maung Shein, the chairman of The Islamic Religious Affairs Council, one of the signatories, told The Irrawaddy on Sunday that the statement was the result of a meeting between members from all of the organizations on Saturday.

He added that the statement had been delayed after the attacks as some members were on religious trips and they were waiting for their return.

In a separate statement released on the same day, the Islamic organization urged all Muslims in Myanmar to condemn terrorism and collaborate with others for stability.

"Please don't share, believe nor react emotionally to those online instigations. If you find out any suspicious activity in your neighborhood, please report it to the authorities," it said.

On Saturday, the government also requested the public not spread the "online and SMS attack warnings," and announced that it would take legal action against those instigating public panic.

The post Myanmar Muslim Organizations Condemn ARSA, Pledge Collaboration appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Saturday, September 9, 2017

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


The Reality in Rakhine and Myanmar’s Complex Political Conundrum

Posted: 09 Sep 2017 02:31 AM PDT

What we can say definitively about the motivation behind the recent attacks in Rakhine State is that they were a violent rejection of meaningful recommendations made by the Kofi Annan-led Rakhine State Advisory Commission and a total obstruction against implementation as promised by the Myanmar government.

The Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA), led by Attaullah Abu Ammar Jununi – who was born in Pakistan and raised in Saudi Arabia – launched its synchronized attacks against 30 police outposts in Maungdaw on Aug. 25, hours after former UN secretary-general Kofi Annan presented comprehensive long-term solutions to solving the issues in Rakhine and integrating the local Muslim community (who self-identify as Rohingya).

The Myanmar government led by Daw Aung San Suu Kyi welcomed the commission's final report recommendations and officially said that it would implement them "within the shortest timeframe possible."

Within a few hours of Daw Aung San Suu Kyi's meeting with Kofi Annan and his commission members on Aug. 24, the State Counselor's Office released a statement saying: "As an immediate step, the government will form a new Ministerial-led committee responsible for the implementation of the commission's recommendations."

The statement also said, "We hope to set out a full roadmap for implementation in the coming weeks."

That's not exactly what the ARSA – designated a "terrorist" group by the government after its attacks – had in mind when it launched simultaneous attacks.

Two weeks since the attacks, the government still cannot set out to implement the recommendations as it has been too busy trying to control the situation on the ground, which is in turmoil due to the ARSA's attacks, militant supporters' attacks on ethnic Rakhine and other groups as well, and military "clearance operations," – all of which have forced hundreds of thousands of Muslim refugees to the Bangladesh border and thousands of Rakhine refugees to other cities in the state.

But the ARSA's violent methods have been a victory for them, at least so far. Their attacks – which killed more than a dozen security or government officials – may be seen by some outsiders as a 'legitimate' retaliation to alleged military oppression and human rights abuses against Muslims in Rakhine State. Beyond that, they have led to heavy criticism of the Myanmar government and its de facto leader Daw Aung San Suu Kyi.

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi is under attack by rights groups, campaign groups and the international media for not publicly defending the rights of the Muslim refugees.

But their criticism comes from a lack of knowledge regarding the country's complex political situation.

Emphasis of the international community and its media on the exodus of refugees and destruction alone is not helping this complex and volatile situation. Instead, it will prove to be counterproductive.

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and her government are sandwiched politically by the powerful military, nationalist parties and an undemocratic Constitution.

There is no civilian oversight of the military, and it is guaranteed 25 percent of the seats in Parliament and three key ministerial positions – defense, border and home affairs.

Some observers have said that the country is driven by two "parallel governments."

Nobody can clearly guess how much room the government has to use its executive power in dealing with the military in handling the latest situation in Rakhine. Daw Aung San Suu Kyi has said that the government cannot tell the military not to launch offensives.

On Aug. 24, when Kofi Annan met Myanmar Army Chief Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing, the army chief said that the commission's report included some factual inaccuracies and questioned its impartiality.

In fact, some political groups rejected the commission from the start. In Parliament, three main groups – members of the Arakan National Party, the previous ruling Union Solidarity and Development Party formed by the ex-generals, and all military-appointed lawmakers sought to abolish the commission in early September 2016. But they didn't succeed.

Critics of Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, including western media, denounced her for not criticizing military leaderships over the institution's alleged human rights violations – showing that these groups don't clearly understand the political situation.

The most important thing the country needs is genuine collaboration from the military leadership to continue this transition to democracy. The military could still return to power if military leaders believed it was necessary for the country. Critics of the military share a common view that since the current administration assumed office, military associates and USDP party members have a wait-and-see policy as the government confronts a difficult situation that may prove to be opportune for the opposition.

A handful of people can understand the complexity of Myanmar. Derek Mitchell, who was US ambassador to Myanmar under former President Barack Obama's administration, told the Associated Press that the militant attacks have "in some ways empowered the military to assert themselves 'as saviors of the country,' which is how they like to see themselves." The former ambassador added, "That's not very helpful to the transition."

Unlike him, most critics have shortsighted views without seeing the bigger picture, which is that the government and the military need to have good relations for the long-term benefit of the country.

Violence begets violence and it cannot be accepted, in response to human rights abuses or terrorist attacks. Security forces must restrain themselves from using "excessive force" against militants and from hurting Muslim civilians during field operations. The government should be assertively talking to military leadership to follow the principles of democratic reform.

But Daw Aung San Suu Kyi cannot afford to publicly criticize the military, which still has both seen and unseen power as the most established institution, with the experiences of coups in 1962 and 1988 and 50 years in power.

Only smooth relations between the two sides can solve the many problems facing the country, including the current Rakhine conflict and more importantly, the peace process involving ethnic armed groups. Her speaking out against the military would only backfire.

If the international community truly wants to see Myanmar as a stable country that can prosper under democratic rule, it needs to help the government halt the violence in Rakhine immediately and implement Kofi Annan's recommendations as soon as possible.

The post The Reality in Rakhine and Myanmar's Complex Political Conundrum appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Rakhine Violence: On the Ground in Maungdaw

Posted: 08 Sep 2017 08:31 PM PDT

Kyaw Zwa Moe: Welcome to Dateline Irrawaddy! It has been 10 days since Muslim terrorists launched attacks in Rakhine State's Maungdaw District. According to government figures as well as information we've collected, about 500 people were killed in 10 days. Our reporter Ko Moe Myint recently went to Maungdaw to interview the people there and also witnessed attacks and damage. We'll discuss who he interviewed, what he saw and the situation on the ground. I'm Irrawaddy English editor Kyaw Zwa Moe.

Dateline Irrawaddy : ေမာင္ေတာမွာတုုိက္ခုုိက္မႈေတြပုုိမုုိဆုုိးရြားလာႏုုိင္လား..ဒီတပတ္ဒိတ္လုုိင္းအစီအစဥ္ကေတာ့ အၾကမ္းဖက္တုုိက္ခုုိက္ခံခဲ့ရတဲ့ ေဒသေတြမွာကုုိယ္တုုိင္သြားေရာက္ သတင္းရယူခဲ့တဲ့ ဧရာဝတီသတင္းဌာနရဲ႕ အဂၤလိပ္ပုုိင္း သတင္းေထာက္ ကုုိမုုိးျမင့္ျမင္ေတြ႔ခဲ့ရတဲ့ ေျမျပင္အေနအထားေတြနဲ႔အၾကမ္းဖက္တုုိက္ခုုိက္မႈေတြကေရာဆက္လက္ဆုုိး၀ါးလာႏုုိင္ေသးလားဆုုိတာကုုိ ဧရာဝတီ အဂၤလိပ္ပုုိင္း အယ္ဒီတာ ေက်ာ္စြာမုုိးနဲ႔ ဧရာဝတီအဂၤလိပ္ပုုိင္းရဲ႕ သတင္းေထာက္ ကုုိမုုိးျမင့္တုုိ႔ကေဆြးေႏြးထားၾကတာပါ။

Posted by The Irrawaddy – Burmese Edition on Friday, September 8, 2017

KZM: According to a government release, around 400 ARSA [Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army] members were killed. The worst thing is reports that more than 80 Hindus—[Moe Myint] also interviewed some Hindu community members—were allegedly killed. You went to Maungdaw where attacks were taking place and houses were burned down. Would you recount what you saw?

Moe Myint: As soon as we got into Buthidaung, we could feel the severity of the conflict in Maungdaw. We saw clouds of smoke billowing into the sky. As soon as we arrived at Buthidaung Jetty, we heard the bad news that four Arakanese people were killed near Zula village in Maungdaw's three-mile camp. There is a village called Myo Thugyi which is just a five-minute walk out of Maungdaw. It is a big Muslim village. There are around 1,200 houses there. All the houses were torched and none of them remained intact.

I went to Maungdaw after attacks in Oct. 9, 2016. At that time, the situation was different. Myo Thugyi village was lively with bazaars and students. But now, all of the houses have been reduced to ash. The whole village is gone. This was the first sign of the immensity of the conflict on the ground. I went to [relief] camps and interviewed Hindus. After the conflict broke out on Aug. 25, Muslim crowds threatened them [they said]. Hindus live together with Muslims in No. 4 and No. 5 wards [of Maungdaw]. All those wards have been torched. Witnesses said arson attacks were carried out by religious extremists. I also witnessed [their feelings].

KZM: You mean Hindu witnesses?

MM: Yes.

KZM: You have also reported about this. Were [Hindus] killed by Muslim militants?

MM: Muslims made threats. Some shot with a gun and one [Hindu] was killed. I also interviewed the mother of a victim.
She could identify from where the gun was fired. But things are different from what we usually see in movies—not every one of them is shooting with a gun. Some have improvised firearms, some have guns and some have swords. They are a large crowd and it is easier for them to threaten and attack small groups of people. Hindus are the minority there and they dare not talk back to them. What they can do is to avoid conflict. So, they flee. But the town is too small, only four or five wards. So, they flee to Arakanese wards. They escaped, but unluckily some were killed on the way.

KZM: According to witnesses, how many Hindus were killed?

MM: I met the survivors of a family whose members included children [and said] about four or five [members of the family] were killed. She was a Hindu woman called 'Kamala' who was receiving treatment at Buthidaung Township Hospital. Her 12-member family came back from southern Maungdaw on Aug. 26 and 27 after conflict broke out. And they took a rest at three-mile camp where police were providing security. They followed a police convoy to go to Ward No. 4 [in Maungdaw]. But by that time, that ward had already been reduced to ashes. The security convoy encountered hundreds of Muslim militants in Myo Thugyi village on their way to Maungdaw. It was followed by an exchange of fire, and the Hindu family fled in fright to the district court, which was under construction. The security convoy didn't care about the people who were travelling behind them. Perhaps they wanted to avoid conflict with large crowds or perhaps they hadn't noticed the people travelling behind them. They left. The [Hindu] family was too frightened and so they fled into a nearby building. Some of the people in the crowd had guns and they shot [at them]. Kamala was hit. She was shot in the chest and lost consciousness. The rest were killed with swords. Witnesses told us that [attackers] said words related to religion like 'Allah is taking you. So you must go.' [Attackers] left her because they thought she was dead. We can say her account is very credible.

KZM: Did you interview any Muslims living in Maungdaw or Sittwe? What did they say?

MM: I met about six Muslims. Most of them were educated and businesspeople. Anyway, it is fair to say they were educated. They said they condemned such violence. Violence disrupts regional stability and order. They are in hardship now. There were attacks on 30 locations in Maungdaw District, and that also impacts urban areas. Grassroots poor Muslim families who have to rely on rivers and creeks for their daily livelihoods and who know nothing about politics also suffered from the impact of that conflict. They could not go to the market. There is no food and they have to share food with each other. There are two separate things here: ARSA claimed that it fights for its political goal, but its actions have shifted to terrorism. Their acts cannot move the situation for everyday people in a positive direction. At least, they should have displayed tolerance. Kofi Annan's [Rakhine State Advisory] Commission formed by Daw Aung San Suu Kyi has also provided recommendations. But [ARSA] didn't wait for the implementation of those recommendations, and instead it launched attacks.

MM: We discussed this in last week's Dateline. Attacks were launched on Aug. 25, the same day Kofi Annan submitted his recommendations to the government, the president and Daw Aung San Suu Kyi. The government said it would implement those recommendations. Then, immediately, attacks followed. It is fair to say attacks were launched even before that. [ARSA's] response is that they didn't accept Kofi Annan's recommendations and their implementation by the government. They responded in a violent way.

MM: I think they are undermining the positive move made by Daw Aung San Suu Kyi's government to solve the problem. Viewing ARSA's recent official video clips on YouTube, its ultimate political goal is to build an Islamic State [for the Rohingya]. To put it bluntly, it is no longer about human rights. It is about self-interest, which is contrary to human rights. Reconciliation, I think, would be difficult in Maungdaw if they work to that end.

KZM: You mean it will be hard to reconcile between the two communities?

MM: Not just two sides, it is three parties now. One more party has been involved—the Hindu community. I've asked Hindus, and all of them unanimously said they dare not live together with [Muslims]. They will not go back to stay within Muslim quarters anymore and also refuse to accept government suggestions that they live together with Muslims. They asked the government for segregation.

KZM: What about other sub-ethnic groups such as the Mro [an Arakanese sub-group]? Did you interview them and what did they say?

MM: Mro people also dare not live [alongside Muslims]. They know nothing about politics. They don't know who the Rohingya are. To put it bluntly, they don't even know who the president of Myanmar is. Such people who lead a simple life on farms and who know nothing about urban life were killed, and fell victim to the conflict. They are frightened to death. They have lived and worked on hillside farms for generations and never experienced this before. Now, they have all moved.

KZM: Before you went to Maungdaw, the government declared ARSA a terrorist organization. Did you witness its activities on the ground in Maungdaw? To what extent is it involved in the Maungdaw [attacks]?

MM: What I found out is—I didn't witness it—from the car I was in, I saw the location of a mine explosion on the way. It is obvious that ARSA has influence over local Muslim people. When I interviewed Muslim sources about ARSA, they were reluctant to answer. We must understand this. I also understand this, so I don't disclose the identity of Muslim sources. Because if they criticize the government—they are businessmen and educated—it could impact their long-term relations [with the government]. But on the other hand, if they criticize ARSA and if we disclose their identity—there are previous examples of Muslim men beheaded after they gave interviews to the government. The situation is dangerous for them in the conflict zone.

KZM: Do you think this conflict will go on?

MM: It is very likely that it will continue. An Islamic State, which is the ultimate goal of ARSA according to their online video clips, will continue the conflict. This is quite sure. And regarding the geographical location of Maungdaw, it is surrounded by three large Muslim villages. There are at least 30,000 people. Of them, only Myo Thugyi is gone and two others remain intact. No houses were burned and there was no conflict there. So, it is fair to say there is still some hope for remedy. But if the goal of an Islamic State is real and people from those villages join them, the problem will get worse.

KZM: Thank you for your contribution!

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post Rakhine Violence: On the Ground in Maungdaw appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Reporter’s Notebook: Understanding Maungdaw’s Reality

Posted: 08 Sep 2017 07:50 PM PDT

SITTWE, Rakhine State – I was among the 22 journalists from local and international news publications who arrived Buthidaung Township in the afternoon on August 30. We were met by news that four young Arakanese had been killed by Muslim militants in Zula village in neighboring Maungdaw Township, and that clashes were ongoing with government security forces.

The police escorted us 24 kilometers down a road linking Buthidaung and Maungdaw, crossing through the green Mayu mountain range. We saw very few cars or bikes. After nearly one hour, we reached Tha Si village, three miles from the border checkpoint where several thousand internally displaced Arakanese people (IDPs) shelter.

A couple minutes' drive from Tha Si village, we reached Myo Thu Gyi village, a Muslim community of 8,600 residents located on the highway, only 1.6 kilometers from the entrance of Maungdaw town, where there is a police checkpoint.

The village has been reduced to a heap of ash. It was the worst scene I have witnessed in recent years. Myo Thu Gyi had been spared following clearance operations after last year's October 9 attacks, in which tens of thousands of Muslims fled across the Bangladeshi border to Teknaf District.

Remnants of Myo Thu Gyi village, a Muslim community burned down. (Photo: Moe Myint / The Irrawaddy)
Fields which once belonged to the residents of Myo Thu Gyi village, now left untended. (Photo: Moe Myint / The Irrawaddy)

Rising Death Toll

According to the latest information from the government, since the August 25 attacks by the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) on police outposts, its members killed 14 Arakanese Buddhists, seven Hindus and seven Muslims, as well as 15 members of government security forces, and three civil servants.

Security forces have killed 371 suspected militants and apprehended 38 suspects since late August. There has been criticism from the international community regarding the discrepancy between the death toll and the weapons seized by the authorities—a few assault rifles and homemade guns, as well as swords, darts and knives.

During the two-day trip to Maungdaw, displaced Arakanese and Hindu residents and government officials told reporters that at least 100 people were involved in attacks on them, mostly carried out with swords, machetes, slingshots and daggers—few of them had guns, they said.

Police look for a suspect in the torching of a house in Ka Nyin Tan quarter of Maungdaw on August 30. (Photo: Moe Myint / The Irrawaddy)

Some security forces who have been receiving medical treatment in Sittwe hospital said attackers opened fire on police and then marched forward, and the police decided to shoot into the crowd. Otherwise, they said, they would have been killed on the spot.

A police major told The Irrawaddy that if a Muslim targeted for recruitment by ARSA refused to be involved, they were often killed. He also alleged local religious leaders had played a role in recruitment—a claim which The Irrawaddy could not verify.

Maungdaw Township administrative official U Ye Htut revealed an intelligence report that the ARSA had already recruited at least 100 members throughout Maungdaw. He also told reporters that the rest of the people—namely, women and children—involved in the attacks against security forces or civilians would be recognized as "terrorists" and dealt with as such.

With a death toll of nearly 400 suspected militants is highly possible that many of them would not have used firearms and applied as human shield to fight against government troops in the battle.

Kai Gyee, a Buddhist Arakanese village in southern Maungdaw, was abandoned by residents after attacks by ARSA on August 25. (Photo: Moe Myint / The Irrawaddy)

Reuters has discovered that ARSA leader Ata Ullah delivered a voice message to his supporters ordering the launch of an offensive against government border outposts last month. It occurred hours after the release of the Kofi Annan-led Advisory Commission on Rakhine State's final report on August 24.

The message stated, "if 200 or 300 people come out, 50 will die. God willing, the remaining 150 can kill them with knives."

Complexity

According to an update from the Government Information Committee this week, 6,845 houses in 60 villages have been burned down. The government said the fires were set by the ARSA, while militants cite the army as being responsible. The Irrawaddy was told by many sources from the Hindu, Buddhist Arakanese and Muslim communities that arson has been carried out by both sides.

This Irrawaddy reporter asked to stay one more night in the conflict-area to collect further information, but the request was refused by the authorities.

Human Rights Watch (HRW) has released satellite images showing the destruction of 17 villages populated by self-identifying Rohingya. International rights groups have again accused the Myanmar Army of committing arson during military operations.

More than 26,700 Arakanese Buddhists and Hindus have been displaced and evacuated to 33 locations in Maungdaw, according to government figures.

Nearly 2,000 Hindu IDPs shelter in a downtown quarter in Maungdaw. (Photo: Moe Myint / The Irrawaddy)

The UN has stated that 146,000 Muslims have fled to Bangladesh and are living in makeshift shelters. Some of those fleeing are confronted with landmines along roads, and a lack of access to aid in temporary relief camps.

Burdens and Barriers

During a three-day trip to Rakhine, I documented several witnesses' accounts, including those from internally displaced persons who were Hindu, Arakanese and belonging to the Arakanese sub-ethnicities.

But the government's guided tour did not allow us to meet with Muslim IDPs and those who had lost their homes elsewhere in Maungdaw. We were only allowed to meet with Muslim village administrative officials and a few elderly community members.

Muslim sources from Maung Ni village leave after speaking with journalists on August 31. (Photo: Moe Myint / The Irrawaddy)

Most of the Muslim sources what we met during the trip were businessmen, who were careful to avoid criticizing either government troops or the ARSA. One such man condemned the militant attacks as having caused the collapse of commerce, education and life in the town.

Journalists have to understand the potential risks that sources take by speaking with us, especially those who live in a conflict-torn region.

There have been more than 60 homicides documented by the government since the first attacks on police outposts in Oct. 2016. Muslim sources have been found beheaded, after being suspected of speaking with the authorities or media.

These numbers suggest that Muslim sources are hesitating to speak out against or criticize either side in the conflict, as they likely find themselves standing on a tightrope.

A Muslim refugee woman and child are pictured after crossing the Bangladesh-Myanmar border in Teknaf, Bangladesh, on September 7, 2017. (Photo: Mohammad Ponir Hossain / Reuters)

Information and Misinformation

This reporter went to three temporary camps housing Hindu and Arakanese IDPs under the protection of government security forces. The security at these camps was questionable—no one appeared to be guarding them. Landmines and ambushes plagued the area. Several hundred people bought boat tickets to the state capital of Sittwe—others could not afford to leave.

During this time, unconfirmed news went viral on social media, including rumors that border outposts in Maungdaw had been deserted, and conflicting stories about which villages had been burned and by whom, and the numbers of people killed. This unfiltered information reached the IDPs through word of mouth, as many do not own mobile phones.

There have been multiple incidents of viral photos online being wrongly attributed to Rakhine State, or being misdated.

On Aug. 29, Turkish Deputy Prime Minister Mehmet Simsek tweeted four pictures, encouraging the international community to stop a genocide against the Rohingya in Rakhine State. The post was retweeted more than 1,600 times and "liked" by at least 1,200 readers. However, none of the photos posted by Simsek were from the fresh clashes in northern Rakhine; they should have been checked for accuracy before posting.

During a phone conversation between State Counselor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and Turkey's President Erdogan earlier this week, she pointed out that these photos contribute to "a huge iceberg of misinformation."

She went as far as stating that such actions "create a lot of problems between different communities" and "promot[e] the interest of the terrorists."

Few are familiar with the situation in Maungdaw. This period of conflict requires caution, as information and misinformation spreads around the world online and encourages fear to grow among the displaced people of Maungdaw, who have already been mentally and physically harmed.

The post Reporter's Notebook: Understanding Maungdaw's Reality appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Friday, September 8, 2017

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Analysis: Who Is Burning Homes in Rakhine State?

Posted: 08 Sep 2017 09:16 AM PDT

MAUNGDAW, Rakhine State — In the three weeks since Myanmar security posts were attacked by the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA), more than 2,600 homes have been torched in more than 60 villages.

Rights advocates have said that security forces and local extremist Buddhists could have committed these crimes as part of the Myanmar Army's clearance operations in northern Rakhine State, which followed coordinated attacks on police outposts by the ARSA on Aug. 25. In contrast, the Government Information Committee has said that Muslim militants burned these homes before leaving the villages, as the inhabitants seek refuge in Bangladesh.

Photos and stories have gone viral depicting Arakanese and Mro Buddhists, and Rakhine Hindus being killed or injured by Muslim militants, and describing their fear of them. Muslims speak of being afraid of security forces, militants, and Buddhist nationalists as well. Area residents are apprehensive about living near other communities of which they are now suspicious.

Amid this tension, the burning of homes has continued. On Thursday, Irrawaddy reporters and a group of journalists on a government-organized reporting trip witnessed that houses in at least two new villages, including a Muslim community called Gawdu Zara, had been torched.

Homes on fire in Gawdu Zara. (Photo: The Irrawaddy)

The presence of non-Muslim local residents armed with swords and sticks seen at the blaze of an abandoned village on Sept. 7 in Maungdaw Township triggered suspicion as to why were they were there.

When asked, they answered in Burmese that they "came to look at what happened in the village," and said no more.

The journalists witnessed a few of them taking household items from the smoldering homes. Some held knives and slingshots as they walked between the houses.

A villager who carried away some looted household items in a cart—a mat, buckets, and kitchen utensils—told The Irrawaddy team that they "took them from those abandoned Muslims' homes," but these reporters did not hear them admit whether they had started the fire.

A local non-Muslim hides his face from the camera after he was seen looting from the site of the torched Gawdu Zara village, a Muslim community. (Photo: The Irrawaddy)

Further down the village road, the group of journalists saw houses freshly set alight, a jug of gasoline left on the road and matches nearby, but, from the road, could see no people.

The police accompanying the journalists appeared at ease in this situation and did not interrogate or detain the looters.

It is possible that they might have been curious onlookers. They could have been carrying swords for their own safety in a time of chaotic violence. But the security forces should have questioned them about their presence at the scene and about the burning homes. If they were suspicious, the police should have proceeded according to protocol. But those things didn't happen.

These actions raise doubt about the authorities' framing of the situation in Rakhine State. After livestreamed reports and photos of the burning of Gawdu Zara went viral, the government said, hours later, that local administrative officials were investigating the incident.

If the government did not act according to the rule of law concerning those people looting from the abandoned homes, or the arson, the whole narrative could change, affecting Myanmar's image.

After just over two weeks of military clearance operations following ARSA attacks on police outposts, the UN has reported that 270,000 Muslims have fled across the border to Bangladesh; around 30,000 Arakanese Buddhists and Hindus remain internally displaced. Maungdaw Township remains under a dusk-to-dawn curfew, and many shops in the town itself have closed.

As of last week, some 15 members of government security forces have been killed, as well as 370 suspected militants, as of last week. The government announced on Friday that authorities have detained 50 more people who they suspect of being ARSA members. It is unknown how many civilians have been killed in total.

The post Analysis: Who Is Burning Homes in Rakhine State? appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Locals Object to Mandalay Hill Cable Car Installation

Posted: 08 Sep 2017 08:59 AM PDT

MANDALAY — A proposal to build a cable car at Mandalay Hill, a landmark in the cultural center of Mandalay, has been widely criticized by locals.

The initial proposal, recently submitted by the Korean company Sky Dream Co. Ltd., to the regional government, was explained to local environmentalists, lawmakers and Mandalay Hill trustee committee members on Wednesday.

"Mandalay Hill is a city landmark, so we must not allow any project that would affect its scenery or nature," said U Hla Moe, a local parliamentarian who was present at the meeting.

Lawmakers at the event stated that locals were worried that the cable car would alter their beloved landmark.

"The Mandalay Hill trustee committee and local environmentalists also expressed their concern that the cable car installation would obstruct the view from the hill," U Hla Moe explained.

The project will cost about US$20 million and is expected to create job opportunities and increase visitors to the area.

The suggested base of the installation is on the western side of the hill.

Some locals criticize that the project is motivated by profit at the risk of environmental impacts, as the hill already has a staircase and road for visitor convenience.

"I told representatives of the company that the installation would surely affect the area, so the company needs to consider the historical, cultural and religious effects," U Hla Moe added.

A company consultant said the proposal was still in its initial phase, and that two to three months would be needed to complete environmental impact assessment reports.

"We will do various tests such as soil tests, water tests and environmental impacts. The regional government will make a decision based on those reports," said U Mahn Tun, a consultant of Sky Dream Co. Ltd.

"If the project is allowed, there will be job opportunities in both construction and operation," he said, but that relies on government approval.

Mandalay Hill is about 800 feet above sea level and located northeast of Mandalay's city center. The hill is a major local travel destination and tourist attraction, where visitors can enjoy a view of Mandalay, especially at sunrise and sunset.

The post Locals Object to Mandalay Hill Cable Car Installation appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Police Open Case Against Former Buthidaung MP

Posted: 08 Sep 2017 08:41 AM PDT

YANGON — Police have opened a case against former Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) lawmaker U Shwe Maung (aka Abdul Razak) under the Counter-Terrorism Law for allegedly supporting the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA), which has been declared a terrorist organization by the government.

Police Cpt Thaung Kywe of Buthidaung Myoma Police Station told The Irrawaddy on Friday that he filed a case against U Shwe Maung under Article 50 of the Counter-Terrorism Law. He said U Shwe Maung posted a video on his Facebook page, in which he supported the acts of ARSA and defended them.

He said the case has now been transferred to the criminal investigations department in Rakhine State capital Sittwe and the investigation is ongoing.

U Shwe Maung, a self-identified Rohingya former lawmaker reportedly now living in Texas in the United States, was elected to the Lower House seat of Buthidaung in northern Rakhine State in 2010 representing the once-ruling USDP. After he resigned from the USDP in August 2015, his candidacy to run in the general election that year was turned down.

On Aug. 28, he posted a Facebook Live video on the account named MP Ro Shwe Maung in which he called for the Myanmar government and military commander-in-chief to stop all violence against self-identifying Rohingya in Rakhine State immediately, if they genuinely wanted peace and security in the region.

"We won't just stand and watch the persecution. If the government and the army don't protect them, we will communicate and seek international assistance," he said in the 20-minutes of footage, in which he also said that he could not accept accusations of violence against the Muslim community.

He said that any unwanted problems were the fault of the government and army chief and accused security forces of burning villages and arresting civilians in his former constituency (Buthidaung). U Shwe Maung alleged that troops had collaborated with members of the Arakan National Party (ANP), who he said had detained and even killed women and children.

The government declared the ARSA – which launched a series of attacks on 30 police outposts on Aug. 25, killing 13 security force members – a terrorist organization, and said its supporters would be charged under the Counter-Terrorism Law.

Subsequent violence has left 28 civilians dead, internally displaced around 30,000 Buddhist Arakanese, Arakanese sub-ethnicities, and Hindus, and sent some 270,000 Muslims fleeing to Bangladesh, according to the most recent UN figures available at the time of reporting.

The post Police Open Case Against Former Buthidaung MP appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Climbers to Settle Dispute over Tallest Mountain in Southeast Asia

Posted: 08 Sep 2017 06:01 AM PDT

YANGON — Three climbers from the Myanmar Hiking and Mountaineering Federation will attempt to summit Mt. Hkakabo Razi in Kachin State next August, in hopes of settling a dispute over whether it is Southeast Asia's tallest mountain.

The remote mountain, which is part of the eastern range of the Himalayas, has long been officially regarded as the tallest mountain in the country, measured at 19,296 feet (5,881 meters) above sea level, also making it the highest peak in Southeast Asia.

The question of whether Gamlang Razi, also in Kachin State, is taller was raised after a Myanmar-US team climbed it in 2013 and recorded a height of 19,258 feet (5,870 meters) above sea level. The team claimed that the mountain was actually the highest in the country, and that the earlier estimate overstated Hkakabo Razi's height, which their digital estimations found could be less than 5,800 meters (19,028 feet).

In the latest attempt to end the dispute, a team comprised of all men in their 30s: Ko Pyae Phyo Aung, Ko Aung Khaing Myint and Ko Zaw Zin Khaing, will begin their ascent in the first week of August 2018 to scientifically prove the height.

Ko Pyae Phyo Aung was one of first of two climbers from Myanmar who reached the summit of Mt. Everest in May of last year, and planted a Myanmar flag.

At the end of October, they will train at Ama Dablam Mountain in Nepal, which is higher than Hkakabo Razi at 6,812 meters above sea level.

The trip will be sponsored primarily by the Htoo Foundation, the philanthropic branch of Burmese tycoon Tay Za's sprawling business conglomerate. The foundation donated US$35,000 for the Nepalese training trip on Sept. 6.

Chairman of the Myanmar Hiking and Mountaineering Federation Dr. Nay Soe Maung told The Irrawaddy that the trio has about 10 years of experience in mountaineering and that they will be prepared for their ascent next summer.

In 2014, an eight-member team from the Universities Hiking and Mountaineering Association and the Invitation of Nature (ION) Foundation made the ascent, however, only two climbers reached the ice-capped peak, becoming the first Myanmar climbers to do so, but they went missing on the descent.

The post Climbers to Settle Dispute over Tallest Mountain in Southeast Asia appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Myanmar Govt to Fence Remaining 40-mile Border with Bangladesh

Posted: 08 Sep 2017 04:42 AM PDT

NAYPYITAW — The Myanmar government will fence some remaining 40 miles of the 170 mile-border with Bangladesh without delay, U Zaw Htay, spokesperson of the President's Office, told The Irrawaddy.

He announced the plan amid news reports that there was no budget for fencing in the Home Affairs Ministry's current fiscal year.

"We will fence it by all means; it won't wait until next year. We don't know where the funds will come from, but we'll do it anyway," he told The Irrawaddy after the State Counselor's Office press conference on Rakhine State on Wednesday.

A high-level meeting including the members of National Defense and Security Council (NDSC) was held in Naypyitaw on Wednesday afternoon to discuss the situation in Rakhine State and issues relating to rule of law in Myanmar.

President U Htin Kyaw, State Counselor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, both of the country's vice presidents, the Upper House Speaker, Military Chief Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing, the deputy military chief, and the ministers of home affairs, defense, and border affairs – all of whom are the members of NDSC – were present at the meeting.

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, Vice President U Myint Swe, Military Chief Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing and his deputy discussed the urgent repair and construction of fences along the Bangladeshi border, a speedy budget allowance for the process, and increasing security troops in areas where the existing border fence has been compromised.

Upper House lawmaker U Khin Maung Latt of the Arakan National Party (ANP) said he believed that Parliament would approve the fencing budget if asked.

"Fencing is a must. Problems arose because the fence was compromised. Compared to fences used internationally, ours are very low in quality. You can see that the fencing was broken and crossed," U Khin Maung Latt told The Irrawaddy.

Border Affairs Minister Maj-Gen Than Htut has also told The Irrawaddy that his ministry is working for the development of Rakhine State and border areas as a priority.

The post Myanmar Govt to Fence Remaining 40-mile Border with Bangladesh appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Govt Investigates Controversial Arson Photos

Posted: 08 Sep 2017 04:00 AM PDT

YANGON – The Myanmar government announced that it was investigating controversial photos posted online that claimed to show Muslim residents burning down their houses in conflict-torn Maungdaw, Rakhine State, on Thursday evening.

President's Office spokesperson U Zaw Htay released a statement that warned, "Everyone will be treated equally by the law, whoever is behind the case."

The photos went viral online on Thursday morning, with some local news outlets erroneously publishing the photos as news. Netizens questioned the authenticity of the photos, some pointing to inconsistencies in religious dress and others stating that the men in the photos were Hindu men that were currently sheltering in Maungdaw after their village had been burned at the end of August.

In the photos, people pour fuel on thatched houses and light them on fire. U Zaw Htay tweeted the controversial images and captioned them "Bengalis [Rohingya] setting fire to their own homes."

When strong public criticism resulted, the government spokesman deleted his post and stated that the government would investigate the images. He then called on the public not to behave unethically to try to prove that Muslim residents were torching their own homes, a claim that has been brought against them. Government officials have blamed the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army for torching thousands of homes, while fleeing civilians have accused Myanmar Army soldiers.

Human Rights Watch analyzed satellite imagery that showed widespread burning in at least 17 distinct areas in Rakhine State since ARSA attacks on police outposts occurred on Aug. 25. The rights group has called for access to independent monitors to assess the source of the fires and the allegations.

U Zaw Htay added, "Govt won't accept any fake," in his post.

The post Govt Investigates Controversial Arson Photos appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

RCSS/SSA to Meet State Counselor, Likely to Focus on Ceasefire Monitoring  

Posted: 08 Sep 2017 12:32 AM PDT

YANGON — Chairman of the Restoration Council of Shan State (RCSS) and commander-in-chief of its armed wing the Shan State Army-South (SSA-S) General Yawd Serk and State Counselor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi will meet soon, according to sources close to both sides.

General Yawd Serk is likely to meet Daw Aung San Suu Kyi in the second week of this month, and will also meet Myanmar Army Deputy Commander-in-Chief Vice Snr-Gen Soe Win at the same time, according to sources.

"We will issue a press release on the meeting in a few days," RCSS/SSA spokesman Col Sai Ngin told The Irrawaddy.

The meeting is likely to focus on ceasefire monitoring since clashes have still occurred frequently between the two sides, despite the RCSS/SSA signing the nationwide ceasefire agreement (NCA) with the government in Oct. 2015.

The State Counselor's Office invited Gen Yawd Serk for talks at the end of August, according to an RCSS/SSA statement released on Aug. 24.

"We welcome the State Counselor's invitation because it is a move that strengthens mutual trust toward the goal of peace," read the statement.

The RCSS/SSA will form a working team to make preparations with the government side for the talks with Daw Aung San Suu Kyi, who is also the chairperson of the National Reconciliation and Peace Center.

"We believe the visit will contribute to building trust, the peace process and building a federal Union," read the statement.

However, Gen Yawd Serk told The Irrawaddy in July that 2017 might not be the "year of peace" that State Counselor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi and President U Htin Kyaw have envisioned.

President U Htin Kyaw said in his Burmese New Year speech in April that they have aimed for 2017 to be a peaceful year, which State Counselor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi also stressed in her speech during the second session of the 21st Century Panglong peace conference in May.

There were skirmishes between the two forces in March, April and July this year, and joint ceasefire monitoring committees at the national and state levels have not been able to address the problem.

Translated from Burmese by Thet Ko Ko.

The post RCSS/SSA to Meet State Counselor, Likely to Focus on Ceasefire Monitoring   appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Asia Must Lead Charge for Pollution-free Planet: UN Environment Head

Posted: 07 Sep 2017 10:08 PM PDT

BANGKOK — Asia-Pacific – home to more than half the world’s population and some of its fastest-growing economies – is a key battleground in the fight against pollution, one of the biggest threats to the planet and its people, the UN environment chief said.

An estimated 12 million people die prematurely each year because of unhealthy environments, 7 million of them due to air pollution alone, making pollution "the biggest killer of humanity," Erik Solheim told the first Asia-Pacific Ministerial Summit on the Environment in Bangkok this week.

Humans have caused pollution and humans can fix it, said Solheim, executive director of UN Environment, in an interview with the Thomson Reuters Foundation at the four-day summit.

"The struggle for a pollution-free planet will be won or lost in Asia – nowhere else," said the former Norwegian minister for environment and international development.

The sheer size of Asia-Pacific, as well as its continued economic growth, put it at the heart of the challenge, he added.

The region's development has been accompanied by worsening pollution of its air, water and soil. Its emissions of planet-warming carbon dioxide doubled between 1990 and 2012, and the use of resources such as minerals, metals and biomass has tripled, according to the United Nations.

World Health Organization figures also show Asia has 25 of the world’s 30 most polluted cities in terms of fine particles in the air that pose the greatest risks to human health. The pollution comes largely from the combustion of fossil fuels, mostly for transport and electricity generation.

Solheim said Asia is also a major contributor of plastic polluting the world's oceans – and solutions can be found in the region. He pointed to a huge beach clean-up campaign in Mumbai that inspired Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi to overhaul the country's waste management system.

"There's enormous environmental opportunity," Solheim said. "Asia has by and large strong governments, and they have the ability to fix problems."

Coal No Longer King?

Solheim said fighting pollution by moving towards renewable energy sources such as wind and solar would also benefit efforts to curb climate change, which scientists say is stoking more deadly heatwaves, floods and sea level rise around the world.

But environmentalists worry that Asia's demand for coal, the most polluting of the major fossil fuels, is likely to grow for years to come.

Figures from a forum organised by the King Abdullah Petroleum Studies and Research Center in Singapore earlier this year show that some 273 gigawatts of coal power are still being built, although much more has been put on hold.

In July, analysts told the Thomson Reuters Foundation that Japan, China and South Korea are bank-rolling coal-fired power plants in Indonesia despite their pledges to reduce planet-warming emissions under the Paris climate deal.

The landmark 2015 Paris Agreement seeks to limit the rise in average world temperatures to well below 2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial times. Experts say curbing or ending the use of coal is required if this goal is to be reached.

Globally, many countries – including China – are shutting down or suspending plans for coal-fired power plants as costs for wind and solar power plummet.

Solheim is optimistic, noting that the International Energy Agency significantly raised its five-year growth forecast for renewables led by China, India, the United States and Mexico.

"There are very, very few people in the world who believe that the future is coal," he said. "I think we will see the shift [to renewables] happening much faster than people tend to believe."

On US President Donald Trump's decision to pull his nation out of the Paris Agreement, Solheim sees a silver lining.

"The surprising judgement of history may be that Donald Trump did a lot of service to this fight against climate change by withdrawing, because he galvanized the reaction of everyone else," said Solheim.

"All the big, iconic companies of modern capitalism – Apple, Google, Microsoft, Amazon – they immediately said, 'We will move into the green economy.'"

The post Asia Must Lead Charge for Pollution-free Planet: UN Environment Head appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Muslims ‘Refuse to Accept’ ARSA

Posted: 07 Sep 2017 07:30 PM PDT

MAUNGDAW, Rakhine State — Muslims in northern Rakhine State's Maungdaw Township told The Irrawaddy they have rejected the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army's (ARSA) attempts to recruit villagers in recent weeks.

Self-identifying Rohingya villagers from the Shwe Zar village tract—an area home to 13,000 people, most of whom are Muslims, but among the residents are Hindus and Buddhists—told The Irrawaddy that they had responded firmly to pressure from the group.

Sarad Ah Mein, a medic from Shwe Zar's Kat Pa Kaung village, said ARSA members had approached the village tract committee weeks ago about recruitment.

"They came at night," he said. "We refused to accept the terrorists' mobilization. Our committee rejected them in their approach," he told The Irrawaddy on Wednesday, referring to the ARSA. The organization has been denounced as a terrorist group by the government after it attacked 30 police outposts on Aug. 25. Military clearance operations have since ensued in the region, and 146,000 Muslims have fled to Bangladesh, according to UN figures. The government has said that 27,000 Buddhist and Hindu villagers are internally displaced.

"We told them, 'please don't trouble the villages. If you do so, we all will suffer a lot. Please go back,'" Sarad Ah Mein said, recalling the meeting. "We all have been living with Rakhine [Buddhists] here and we haven't had any problems. We want to keep living in that way."

Mamud Jolly, another villager from Shwe Zar, reiterated the community's rejection of the ARSA's tactics. "We don't accept them. We don't support any terrorism act. That's what I want to say."

Sarad Ah Mein alleged that to speak negatively about the ARSA was dangerous, and that to do so would be a risk to their lives.

According to the government statistics, 63 Muslims have believed to have been killed by militants between October 2016—when the first attacks on police outposts were launched—and mid-August of this year.

Displacement and Insufficient Aid

 Since the Aug. 25 attacks, the Myanmar government has responded to the ARSA with intensified military action in the region, causing mass displacement across communities. Northern Rakhine State remains embroiled in conflict and those internally displaced or trapped in their villages are in need of humanitarian aid.

Maungdaw, once a bustling border town focused on trade, had grown quiet on Wednesday, when The Irrawaddy visited. Few shops opened, and many houses appeared locked. The area remains under a dusk-to-dawn curfew, but administrative staff who fled to the state capital of Sittwe last week have since returned.

The Shwe Zar area saw a clash between Muslims and Hindus on Aug. 26 in a village bazaar, after which Hindus and Buddhists reportedly fled. Apart from this, Shwe Zar initially seemed to have been spared some of the violence of the surrounding areas, which has included the torching of homes and mass displacement.

According to an update from the Government Information Committee on Wednesday, 6,845 houses in 60 villages had been burned down. The government said the fires were set by the ARSA and its supporters. Militants, in turn, cite the army as the perpetrators.

But the number is almost certainly higher at the time of reporting, as The Irrawaddy witnessed the burning of dozens of houses in Gawdu Zara Muslim village, near Maungdaw, on Thursday afternoon. There are also reports that houses were torched near Kyein Chaung village—home to both Buddhists and Muslims—on Wednesday night.

Munee, a Muslim woman and mother of four from the Shwe Zar tract, told The Irrawaddy that villagers were short of food since the bazaar had closed.

"We are told by the police just to stay in our village and not to worry," she said.

Her husband works in Malaysia, Munee explained, adding that he was unable to transfer her necessary funds because markets, shops and private banks were closed.

"I don’t know what to say. We just cry and cannot think of anything," she said. "We can’t go out either to Maungdaw or to other villages. We have no support from either from the government or NGOs."

Sarad Ah Mein explained that villagers have had to halt their work as fishermen and traders, as they are confined to their villages. The consequence, he said, "is that we are in need of food."

Yet government representatives maintain that they are providing aid to those in need.

Local and national civil society groups are offering support to some of the displaced, but many remain beyond the reach of these efforts, particularly in overcrowded temporary relief camps.

As is true elsewhere in Myanmar, women and children make up the majority of the displaced in Rakhine State. Hindus taking shelters at one of eight relief camps in Maungdaw told The Irrawaddy on Monday that they want to go home as soon as possible, but only with a guarantee for their security.

However, Maungdaw District administrator U Ye Htut said that the district remains an "operational area," or a conflict zone.

The post Muslims 'Refuse to Accept' ARSA appeared first on The Irrawaddy.