Thursday, July 21, 2016

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Burma Army Reveals Concerns Over Ethnic Summit

Posted: 21 Jul 2016 08:16 AM PDT

Lt-Gen Mya Tun Oo of the Burma Army speaks at a press conference in Rangoon on July 20, 2016. (Photo: Tun Tun / The Irrawaddy)

Lt-Gen Mya Tun Oo of the Burma Army speaks at a press conference in Rangoon on July 20, 2016. (Photo: Tun Tun / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON – The Tatmadaw expressed concern over the upcoming Mai Ja Yang peace summit in Kachin State during a press conference on Wednesday in Rangoon, saying that the meeting could negatively impact the Union Peace Conference, which is slated to convene in late August.

Army spokesman and chief of military security affairs Lt-Gen Mya Tun Oo reiterated the Tatmadaw's—the Burmese term for the national army—intention to cooperate with the civilian-led National League for Democracy (NLD) government, but said the best results for the peace process would stem from open and honest discussion at the Union conference.

Reaching a common perspective amongst the different groups is already a challenge, he said.

"In a meeting, many agreements are reached. Then restraints are imposed…and making efforts to move things forward will get harder," Mya Tun Oo said, reportedly emphasizing the concerns of army chief Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing. "Thus, if possible, [the Burma Army] does not want the Mai Ja Yang meeting to happen. We don't want any more territorial claims or forming of alliances," adding that, the military would

The ethnic armed groups have said that the Mai Ja Yang summit will be held next week, from July 26-29, and will serve as a plenary discussion for the upcoming Union Peace Conference, as well as a forum to identify common perspectives on federal and state constitutions, security and defense and the country's political dialogue framework.

Padoh Kwe Htoo Win, secretary of the Karen National Union (KNU) and a vice chairman of the ethnic armed organizations' (EAOs) Summit Plenary Convening Committee for Mai Ja Yang, told The Irrawaddy that the summit itself "is not an action that would damage the upcoming peace conference, but, rather, it will be a supportive action for peace building."

He added that he hopes there will not be any objections from the Burma Army, as the military has pledged to collaborate with the NLD government concerning the country's peace process. Padoh Kwe Htoo Win pointed out that both the State Counselor—Aung San Suu Kyi—and army chief Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing were informed of the summit when they met in June with the leaders of eight signatory groups to 2015's nationwide ceasefire agreement (NCA).

The first EAO summit in Laiza, Kachin State, in 2013 moved the country toward the drafting of the NCA by the ethnic Nationwide Ceasefire Coordinating Team and the government, Padoh Kwe Htoo Win pointed out; the previous government had allowed for this gathering to take place. The second eight-day EAO summit was held in the KNU-controlled Law Khee Lar region of Karen State in June 2015.

The KNU was among the eight signatories of NCA last October. NCA non-signatory groups are continuing talks with the government regarding all-inclusive participation in the peace process. The senior leaders of one bloc of non-signatory armed groups—the United Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC)—met with Aung San Suu Kyi on Sunday in Rangoon to discuss further collaboration toward building a federal union, as well as participation in the political dialogue framework review and the peace conference.

One demand from non-signatories to the NCA is for a unilateral ceasefire to be jointly announced by the government, the Burma Army and ethnic armed groups before resuming peace talks in Naypyidaw in August. To this end, the government and UNFC delegations met again for talks in Chiang Mai, Thailand on Wednesday.

"Making unilateral ceasefires is easy, but the implementation is difficult if we do not have trust in each other and can not manage to agree on the NCA pact," said Padoh Kwe Htoo Win.

The post Burma Army Reveals Concerns Over Ethnic Summit appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Aung San Suu Kyi Accepts Obama’s Invitation to Visit the US

Posted: 21 Jul 2016 07:49 AM PDT

Aung San Suu Kyi speaks to journalists after meeting with US President Barack Obama, right, at Suu Kyi's lakeside residence in Rangoon during the President's first trip to Burma in November 2012. (Photo: The Irrawaddy)

Aung San Suu Kyi speaks to journalists after meeting with US President Barack Obama, right, at Suu Kyi's lakeside residence in Rangoon during the President's first trip to Burma in November 2012. (Photo: The Irrawaddy)

Burma government leader Aung San Suu Kyi has accepted an invitation from President Barack Obama to visit the United States, the government said on Thursday, in what would be her first trip to America since she won an election in November.

Suu Kyi planned to travel at a "mutually convenient time," a Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokeswoman said. Another government source said the trip was likely to coincide with the UN General Assembly session in New York in September.

Suu Kyi's party, the National League for Democracy, swept to power in a historic election in November after decades of campaigning against military rule.

It took over the running of the country after a transition from semi-civilian rule in April.

"She accepted President Obama's invitation to visit the US before his presidency ends," said Aye Aye Soe, a spokeswoman at the foreign ministry, which is run by Suu Kyi.

Visiting US Deputy National Security Advisor for Strategic Communications Ben Rhodes delivered Obama's invitation during a meeting with Suu Kyi in the capital, Naypyidaw, on Wednesday.

Suu Kyi, 71, is barred from becoming president by the constitution drafted under the previous regime, because her two sons do not have Burmese citizenship.

She is instead foreign minister and has also assumed the newly created post of state counselor. She is in overall charge of running the government.

The US embassy in the city of Rangoon did not comment.

Suu Kyi, who spent years under house arrest during military rule, visited the United States as the leader of the opposition in September 2012.

The UN General Assembly session in New York is scheduled from Sept. 13 to Sept. 26. Obama will leave office in January after a November election.

(Reporting by Aung Hla Tun; Editing by Robert Birsel)

The post Aung San Suu Kyi Accepts Obama's Invitation to Visit the US appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Govt Publishes Data on Populations of Religious Groups

Posted: 21 Jul 2016 06:29 AM PDT

Residents of Rangoon's Thaketa Township participate in Burma's first nationwide census in more than three decades. (Photo: Hein Htet / The Irrawaddy)

Residents of Rangoon's Thaketa Township participate in Burma's first nationwide census in more than three decades. (Photo: Hein Htet / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — For the first time in more than three decades, Burma released data on the populations of the country's different religious groups, based on the results of the 2014 census.

The information was publicly launched by the Ministry of Labor, Immigration and Population, on Thursday in the capital Naypyidaw.

The ministry said that the size of the non-enumerated populations—groups that were not counted in the census—in Karen and Kachin states were not large enough to change the proportion of religious groups at the Union or state levels. However, the non-enumerated population in western Burma—an estimated 1.09 million people who identify as Rohingya—is significant enough to have an impact on the proportion of religious groups at both the state and Union level.

According to the figures, Buddhists constitute 87.9 percent of the country, Christians make up 6.2 percent, Muslims comprise 4.3 percent, animists are counted at 0.8 percent and Hindus are listed at 0.5 percent. People who identify with other religions constitute 0.2 percent and 0.1 percent identified as following no religion. These percentages represent the composition of Burma's total population of 51.4 million, including a non-enumerated population of approximately 1.2 million.

In comparison to the 1983 and 1973 censuses carried out by ex-dictator Ne Win's military regime, the 2014 figures revealed a slight decrease in the percentage of Buddhist population and a small increase in the percentage of Christian and Muslim populations.

The 1983 census reported that the Buddhist population was 89.4 percent, the Christian population was 4.9 percent, and the Muslim population was 3.9 percent—a figure believed by some to be a low estimation.

"Some people would like to make a bigger problem and raise rumors, if [this information] is concealed. So we released the data and we don't have any concerns with it," Thein Swe, Minister for Labor, Immigration and Population told The Irrawaddy.

Due to ongoing debates, publication of the census figures for religious and ethnic data was delayed after other results were made public in May of 2015 under the previous, Thein Sein-led government.

Concerns over social unrest reportedly contributed to the postponement, but the ministry's permanent secretary denied this, telling The Irrawaddy earlier in July that the delay was due to a need for further analysis of and consultations regarding the data, adding that there was no significant change from the 1983 census.

The figures published on Thursday also revealed that Burma's Muslim population had increased by only 0.4 percent; in recent years ultranationalists have stoked tension in the country by alleging that the Muslim community is growing at a much faster rate than other religious groups.

The demographic information also revealed the population of each religious group at the state and division level.

According to the enumerated data, Shan State has the largest number of Christians in Burma—nearly 570,000, out of its 5.8 million residents. Kachin State was a close second, with 555,000 Christians. But the states with the highest proportions of Christians are Chin State—more than 85 percent—and Karenni State, with nearly 46 percent.

Mon State has the largest Muslim population in proportion to its enumerated population, at 5.8 percent of its 205,000 residents. Rangoon Division has the highest number of Muslims, according to enumerated data: 345,600, or 4.7 percent of the total divisional population of 7.4 million.

If the estimated non-enumerated population were to be included—many of whom are Muslims—Arakan State would have the largest Muslim minority, but only around 28,000 were officially enumerated for the census.

In the case of the enumerated population of Burma, Buddhists make up 89.8 percent of the population, Christians 6.3 percent and Muslims 2.3 percent.

According to the ministry, census data on Burma's diverse composition of ethnic groups will still not be released for another "four or five months" due a stated need for further statistical analysis and consultations with leaders from ethnic minority groups.

This information, and its categorization, also has the capacity to inflame tensions, given the longstanding demands of Burma's various ethnic minority groups for greater autonomy and participation in political decision-making.

Additional reporting by Htet Naing Zaw from Naypyidaw.

The post Govt Publishes Data on Populations of Religious Groups appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Optimism Expressed at Economic Forum, Despite Govt Policy Blackout

Posted: 21 Jul 2016 06:15 AM PDT

A USAID presentation at the economic forum at Rangoon on Thursday. (Photo: USAID)

A USAID presentation at the economic forum at Rangoon on Thursday. (Photo: USAID)

RANGOON — Economists and businessmen gathered at a forum in Rangoon expressed disappointment at sluggish growth under the new government since April—in light of high expectations—but remain convinced of Burma's economic potential.

However, the lack of clarity from the National League for Democracy government on matters of economic policy prevented a more detailed discussion of Burma's current economic trajectory, with many participants making somewhat abstract calls for "inclusive" and "broad-based" growth.

The economic forum, jointly staged by the US Agency for International Development (USAID) and the Renaissance Institute in Burma's commercial capital on Thursday, drew several hundred Burmese and foreign economists and businessmen interested in Burma's ongoing economic transformation from a state of isolation and impoverishment.

Discussions ranged largely between the agricultural, financial, trade and investment sectors.

David Roland-Holst, adjunct professor of agriculture and resource economics at the University of California, Berkeley, spoke of the "seemingly unlimited possibilities" for Burma but said "choices will have to be made."

He stressed the three "most potent catalysts" for inclusive growth in Burma as: greater labor productivity, equitable domestic capital allocation, and infrastructure development.

"Inclusive growth" was described as growth that extended income opportunities to the poor, ethnic and religious minority groups, women and isolated rural populations.

For agricultural development—understood to be a centerpiece of the NLD's economic vision for Burma, which has yet to be spelled out in any detail—David Roland-Holst emphasized diversification of crops and produce, secure property rights for smallholder farmers, greater market access, and the streamlining of rules and regulations for farmers that are currently difficult for most to interpret.

Steven Radelet, a professor of global human development at Georgetown University and a former USAID chief economist, noted that "almost all" developing countries that have gone on to achieve "sustained and inclusive growth" started with "a strong focus on agriculture."

A focus on agriculture is particularly pertinent in Burma where the majority of the population still practices farming as their primary livelihood, despite rapid urbanization in recent years and the growth of cities such as Rangoon and Mandalay.

Burmese economist Khin Maung Nyo, who largely concurred with the views of his international peers, said, "I accept that economic reform under the new government has been slow," because the government has been "focused more on national reconciliation" and other "political" matters, but the government needs to "accelerate economic growth."

Participants at the forum stressed their eagerness to learn about the government's economic policies, which remain generally obscured after more than 100 days in office. Industry sources have predicted an unveiling for certain sectors at the end of this month.

Win Aung, chairman of the Union of Myanmar Federation of Chambers and Commerce and Industry, criticized the delay but said he remained "very optimistic." He also emphasized the need for Burma's economy to hit the "right track"—one that is "inclusive and sustainable"—above the shorter-term imperative of faster growth.

The post Optimism Expressed at Economic Forum, Despite Govt Policy Blackout appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Arakan National Party Criticized by Arakanese Civil Society in Rangoon

Posted: 21 Jul 2016 03:59 AM PDT

Arakan National Party chairman Aye Maung addresses Arakanese civil society groups in Rangoon on Wednesday. (Photo: Arakan Youth Organization)

Arakan National Party chairman Aye Maung addresses Arakanese civil society groups in Rangoon on Wednesday. (Photo: Arakan Youth Organization)

RANGOON — Rangoon-based Arakanese civil society groups have chastised the Arakan National Party (ANP) for ignoring them after the support they gave the party during the November general election, and for failing to preserve "unity" in the Arakanese nationalist movement.

The criticism was made at a meeting on Wednesday at the Danyawaddy monastery in Rangoon's Bahan Township between senior ANP leaders and more than 40 Rangoon-based ethnic Arakanese civil society organizations—the first such meeting to have taken place.

The meeting had a three-fold agenda: preparations for a public conference on the 1982 Citizenship Law to be held by the ANP on Sunday, broad-based collaboration with civil society in addressing the affairs of Arakan State, and the challenges being faced by the ethnic Arakanese community in Rangoon.

ANP chairman Aye Maung told those assembled that the conference on the 1982 Citizenship Law would aim to educate the public on the "strengths and weaknesses" of the law, as well as lay out how the National League for Democracy (NLD) led government is finding "loopholes" in the law to provide "Bengalis" with preliminary citizenship documentation—a reference to the citizenship verification exercise now being undertaken in Arakan State. Arakanese legal experts will take part in the conference, he said.

The 1982 law in its current form places significant barriers to citizenship for communities not listed among 135 officially recognized ethnic groups in Burma.

This includes the Muslim minority in Arakan State who identify as Rohingya, most of whom remain stateless, and whom the ANP and ethnic Arakanese civil society—along with much of the Burmese public and significant sections of the government—considers illegal migrants from Bangladesh, and insists on calling "Bengali."

At the Wednesday meeting, Arakanese youth activist Sitt Nyein addressed party chairman Aye Maung and the ANP directly, stating that, despite overwhelming support from the ethnic Arakanese community in Rangoon during the election, ANP candidates had not since interacted with Rangoon-based Arakanese civil society.

Sitt Nyein also pointed to "infighting" within the party since the election, which had caused broader "disunity" within the Arakanese community across the country.

"We need a father to rely on," Sitt Nyein said, stating the need for a strong Arakanese ethnic party. He asked rhetorically whether they could "depend" on the party.

"Show me, what ANP has done for us?" he said, to loud applause across the meeting hall.

He recalled how ANP candidates had convinced "all Rangoon-based Arakanese civil society" to support their election campaigns, while handing out free "canned beers." Since the election, however, they had "disappeared."

He reminded the ANP leader that Arakanese youth are always "on standby" to champion the causes espoused by the ANP, for instance staging protests in opposition to the international community and to Aung San Suu Kyi when they go "against Arakanese national interests," particularly regarding the stateless Rohingya.

Despite activists being detained for such protests and other personal "sacrifices," he said, "Our efforts are in vain."

Other civil society representatives at the meeting cited several problems faced by the ethnic Arakanese community in Rangoon, which they said had not been addressed by the party or by the Arakanese ethnic minister in the Rangoon Division government (a post elected only by ethnic Arakanese people registered as living in Rangoon Division).

The stated problems included women facing difficulties finding work in factories in the Hlaing Tharyar and Shwe Pyitha industrial zones, and being vulnerable to physical assault by "thugs;" and families facing eviction from houses when they fail to make monthly rental payments. In such cases, ethnic minister Zaw Aye Maung has offered no support, they said.

Paing Myint, who represents a small youth group, mentioned the case of 300 people working at a Shwe Pyitha garment factory, who could not afford to buy houses and so spent 4 million kyats (US$3,380) in 2013 on a stretch of land near the factory where they constructed dwellings.

This year, the new Rangoon Division government announced that they were "trespassing" on government land—as "squatters," they would be relocated under an audacious plan devised by the NLD government to address Rangoon's burgeoning squatter problem. Those affected appealed to the ethnic minister but received no response.

The ethnic minister Zaw Aye Maung had been invited by the civil society groups to attend the Wednesday meeting, but he was not present. ANP chairman Aye Maung said that he was there on the ethnic minister's behalf.

The ANP party chairman acknowledged that his party faces "many challenges" but presented this as a reason why Arakanese civil society should "accelerate their collaboration" with the party.

The references to "unity" made by the civil society representatives at the meeting point to a factional tussle within the ANP that has played out over the course of 2016.

Since the November general election—where the ANP won a large plurality of seats in the Arakan State parliament and in seats representing the state in the national parliament—there has been considerable friction within the ANP regarding cooperation with the ruling NLD, which has excluded the ANP from the Arakan State government and the new high-level committee charged with overseeing Arakan State.

The friction runs between the former leaders of the Arakan League for Democracy (ALD), which has historically been close to the NLD, and of the Rakhine Nationalities Development Party (RNDP), which pushes a harder line in defending the sectarian interests of the state's Buddhist majority, since the parties merged to form the ANP in early 2014.

The faction from the RNDP is now dominant within the ANP. After failing to be granted the position of Chief Minister of Arakan State, the ANP publicly vowed to work "in opposition" to the ruling NLD—a stance the former ALD members did not consent to.

The post Arakan National Party Criticized by Arakanese Civil Society in Rangoon appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

National News

National News


Daw Aung San Suu Kyi to visit US before end of Obama term

Posted: 21 Jul 2016 06:30 AM PDT

State Counsellor Daw Aung San Suu Kyi has accepted an invite from Barack Obama to visit the United States, the government said today, the first time the pair will meet since last November's landmark elections.

Long-delayed religion census reveals only modest Muslim increase

Posted: 21 Jul 2016 02:46 AM PDT

The long-awaited figures on religious affiliation from Myanmar's 2014 census were released earlier today, after a delay attributed to the contentious nature of the withheld data, particularly in regard to the numbers of Myanmar's Muslim population.

Tatmadaw admits to killing of 5 civilians in Shan State village

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

In a surprising admission yesterday, the Tatmadaw acknowledged its involvement in the murder of five Shan State residents and vowed to punish the soldiers conducting the interrogations that resulted in the killings.

Commander-in-chief retirement age set at 65

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

As the current commander-in-chief continues to serve a term beyond the typical civil servant retirement age, the Tatmadaw announced yesterday that it has officially defined the goalpost. The head of the defence services must retire at age 65.

US official announces $21 million in trade, economic support

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

The United States yesterday pledged US$21 million for improving trade and economic governance in Myanmar.

Nearly 70 Myanmar workers repatriated from ‘hell’ of detention in Malaysia

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

Nearly 70 Myanmar workers who had languished in immigration detention centres in Malaysia were welcomed home yesterday, the third group to be repatriated in honour of the state counsellor's 71st birthday.

Ma Ba Tha a ‘divisive’ minority, other monks say

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

Several revered Buddhist monks from across Myanmar have spoken out against the nationalist Ma Ba Tha movement, describing it as a minority group and its actions as divisive and politicised.

Chindwin River exceeds danger level

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

The Department of Meteorology and Hydrology announced yesterday that water levels along the Chindwin River exceeded their danger marks at three locations in Sagaing Region. Waters pushed past the mark by 2 feet (0.6 metres) at Paungbyin township, and 1.5 feet at both Homalin and Mawlaik.

Mandalay FDA lauds clampdown on food additives

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

The Food and Drug Administration is attributing a decrease in potentially toxic food additives to bi-weekly tests for chemical dyes in Mandalay markets.

Nay Pyi Taw police force copes with crimes

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

Police have vowed stronger action against crime in Pyinmana township, the modestly delinquent younger brother of sedate Nay Pyi Taw. Under the command of Nay Pyi Taw Regional Police Force, the Pyinmana township police force is now stepping up to its responsibilities for security.

Shan Herald Agency for News

Shan Herald Agency for News


Burma’s MI admits soldiers killed Lashio villagers

Posted: 21 Jul 2016 02:28 AM PDT

Lt-Gen Mya Tun Oo, the serving chief of Burma's military intelligence, confirmed yesterday that government soldiers were indeed responsible for the murder of five men from Mong Yaw in Lashio Township, northern Shan State.


Seven Mong Yaw villagers were killed late last month. According to eyewitnesses, five were arrested by a unit of Burmese government forces on June 25, and later found buried in shallow graves near an army camp. The other two were shot dead that same day when they failed to stop their motorbike at an army checkpoint in the town.

"The court martial found that they [soldiers] violated the rules, and failed to follow certain procedures that led to the death of the victims during interrogation," Lt-Gen Mya Tun Oo admitted at a public news conference in Rangoon.

He said a court martial was in progress, and that the verdict would be made open to the public.

Reached for comment, Sai Wan Leng Kham, an Upper House MP from the Shan Nationalities League for Democracy (SNLD), said he was relieved that the military had finally admitted its role in the crime, and had promised to bring the culprits to justice.

"The military has never admitted to their crimes in the past," he said. "The reason they did is because the people of Mong Yaw have fought fearlessly for justice."

The MP expressed sympathy for the families of the victims, noting that they had lost the breadwinners of their individual households.

"Will the military pay them compensation?" Sai Wan Leng Kham questioned. "We'll have to wait and see."

According to Lt-Gen Mya Tun Oo, the military will now assume the role of caring for and supporting the victims' families. However, he gave no further details.

On July 18, Shan Herald reportedthat the Tai Youth Organization, Kachin Youth Organization, Ta'ang Women's Organization, and Ta'ang Students and Youth Union led over 1,000 protestors in a rally in Lashio, demanding justice for the murder victims.

In a statement on July 20, Amnesty International urged the National League for Democracy-led government to take action against those who were involved in the incident.

"While it's positive that the authorities are investigating this case, the reality is that all too often victims and their families are denied access to justice, truth and reparations, and have faced reprisals when reporting cases of military abuse. This has to stop and Myanmar's [Burma's] new government must make it clear that no one is above the law," said Rafendi Djamin, Amnesty's director for Southeast Asia and the Pacific.

"This case is an important reminder of the need to reform the military and judicial systems in Myanmar," he added. "Although it is important that steps are taken to ensure those responsible for serious human rights violations are held to account, military tribunals are not the solution. The authorities in Myanmar must take immediate action to ensure that human rights violators can be effectively tried before independent, civilian courts – anything less would only serve to perpetuate the cycle of impunity."

BY: Shan Herald Agency for News (SHAN)


Rule of law within the context of military-drafted constitution

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 06:42 PM PDT

Aung San Suu Kyi on a lot of occasions said that the rule of law within the context of military-drafted, 2008 constitution should be adhered in striving to achieve a federal form of government.

She said this when meeting with the 8 Ethnic Armed Organizations (EAOs) that have signed the Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement (NCA), on 28 June, and again when she met the non-signatory EAOs of United Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC), on 17 July.

On 28 June meeting with the 8 signatory EAOs, Suu Kyi said: "Some could ask, why we go along with this (constitutional) law even we don't like it. It is because the future of a country, vested with equality, cannot be stable without the rule of law. Laws will be amended and made through the given legal channel and want our ethnic brothers and sisters to think the same."

Let us ponder on this argument if it makes sense, particularly from the point of the peace process and national reconciliation.

According to Khu Oo Reh, spokesperson of the UNFC, "The rule of law is not only concern with the armed organizations, but tranquillity, termination of armed conflicts, protests, blood-letting are all included. In a country there are a host of problems and (having) the rule of law is only real if such (mentioned) issues are absent (resolved). And the peace we want is the one that happens under such conditions".

But we cannot just jump on to the rule of law issue without clarifying or agreeing on the ownership of the country's  sovereignty. The ruling Bamar-dominated, National League for Democracy (NLD) government, including the military, considers itself to be the sole ownership of the sovereignty, while the ethnic nationalities staunchly believed that it is a shared-ownership, which has been robbed by the majority Bamar that let them to the political and armed resistance, in the first place.

The non-Bamar ethnic nationalities said that the independence from the British in 1948 is a co-independence, which in turn, gave them the entitlement as the co-owner of the country, leading to the notion of "shared-sovereignty".

If the regime in power considers itself  to be the sole ownership, issues like taxation and usage and extraction of the natural resources by any other party would mean breaching the given laws and thus must be punished.

But on the other hand, if the outgoing point is from those of the shared-sovereignty position, the EAOs have every right, within their inherited territories from their ancestors, to make use of the taxation of the population under their control, as revolutionary tax to defend their turfs, which the government is keen to dub as protection money or "Set Kye" in Burmese. The same goes for   making use of the natural resources such as mineral extraction and logging for examples.

Thus we could see that even during the transition period of peace negotiations this kind of problems popped up frequently, as the military launched attacks and conduct offensives in the name of upholding sovereignty and protecting the population.

Seen from this perspective, this seemingly unrelated question of sovereignty becomes a core crucial issue that is connected to the drawing of a federal constitution.

This, in turn, pushes us further to consider if what Suu Kyi has been advocating to achieve constitutional amendment through adherence of the rule of law that is anchored in the military-drafted constitution could be tangible, which is neither federal nor equitable form of governance that the ethnic nationalities have been striving for.

It is important not to forget that the EAOs' armed resistance is due to the fact that they were unable to push for the realization of their political aspirations through legal channel and that was why they have to resort to such actions.

And if it is the government's wish to resolve the ethnic conflict through peaceful settlement with give-and-take negotiations, implementation of this rule of law literally with rigid principles would only contribute to more failure than success.

But this is not to say that lawlessness must be glorified and tolerated, but only to work out a transitional period solution, to be as tolerable as possible for all parties concerned, while casting an eye on the constitutional amendment that all could live with.

In sum, rule of law must prevail but exceptional cases like the sustainment of the EAOs and their  dependants for the transitional period have to be worked out, before political settlement is reached. Otherwise, the government will have to act against the EAOs each time they make a move to survive as fighting forces and the progress made at the negotiation table will go down the drain and have to restart it all over again.



Wednesday, July 20, 2016

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Rangoon Property Developers to Petition Suu Kyi, Htin Kyaw

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 06:24 AM PDT

One of many construction sites that have sprung up in Rangoon in recent years, seen on October 31, 2013. (Photo: Reuters)

One of many construction sites that have sprung up in Rangoon in recent years, seen on October 31, 2013. (Photo: Reuters)

RANGOON — Rangoon property developers, whose high-rise projects have been suspended pending modifications in line with newly enforced urban planning standards, will submit their grievances in a letter to President Htin Kyaw and State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi.

The aggrieved property developers have already submitted a letter to Rangoon Mayor Maung Maung Soe, who is chairman of the Yangon City Development Council (YCDC), Rangoon's municipal authority.

A 13-member committee appointed by the Rangoon Division government to review "high-rise" building projects (defined as structures with nine or more stories) ordered that 12 buildings currently undergoing construction be reduced in height, adhere to original designs for car parking, and improve their safety standards.

The committee—which includes architects, engineers, heritage experts and a divisional government minister—started inspecting the buildings in June, which range in height between 12 and 29 stories.

"We have submitted a letter to the mayor stating how much money each construction project stands to lose [due to the decision]," said Myo Myint, managing director of the MKT construction company.

The letter, which bore the signatures of affected property developers, claims an average loss of US$20 million per project. The letter claims that the construction projects had already "received final approval from the YCDC," according to Myo Myint.

The aggrieved developers are preparing to insert more data in their forthcoming letter to President Htin Kyaw and State Counselor Aung San Suu Kyi, as well as the signatures of more developers, according to Myo Myint.

"We're not opposing the [high rise review] committee, we just want them to know what is happening here," he said.

Since May, the YCDC has ordered the suspension of more than 200 high-rise buildings, many of which had received only initial—and not "final"—approvals from city authorities.

The post Rangoon Property Developers to Petition Suu Kyi, Htin Kyaw appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Burma Army Claims Responsibility for Five Civilian Deaths in Northern Shan State 

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 06:21 AM PDT

Residents of Mong Yaw village in northern Shan State's Lashio Township carry the body of one of the deceased back to the village for a funeral in late June 2016 (Photo: Khun Myo Satt / Facebook)

Residents of Mong Yaw village in northern Shan State's Lashio Township carry the body of one of the deceased back to the village for a funeral in late June 2016 (Photo: Khun Myo Satt / Facebook)

RANGOON — The Burma Army has said it will take action against troops accused of killing civilians in a rural area of northern Shan State's Lashio Township in late June.

Lt-Gen Mya Tun Oo spoke at a press conference on Wednesday in Rangoon, and said that his army would punish soldiers who had violated laws.

"We did an investigation, met the victims' families, and even offered support to them. We found from our investigation that our troops violated laws and killed people. Therefore, we will take action against our troops," the lieutenant general said, without elaborating on what this action would entail.

Local sources have said that a total of seven people were killed in Lashio Township's Mong Yaw village on June 25: two men were reportedly shot while riding motorbikes, and five more bodies were found buried by a corn field after the individuals were detained by members of Burma Army Light Infantry Battalion (LIB) 362.

However, Mya Tun Oo said the investigation revealed that Burma Army troops had killed five people—the individuals whose bodies were found in the field—but said he did not know who was responsible for murdering the two men traveling by motorbike.

He told reporters at the press conference that his troops went to Mong Yaw after the Burma Army's Northeast Regional Command Center, based in Lashio, allegedly received information indicating that 200 armed rebels were attempting to recruit locals in the area.

The Northeast Regional Command Center allowed LIB 362 to go to the area; Mya Tun Oo said there was fighting between ethnic armed groups and the Burma Army near Mong Yaw village in the location where the two men were shot on their motorbikes.

"They drove motorbikes through the middle of the fighting. Their motorbike fell down after they got shot, but we do not know which side shot them," he said, adding that the men had died by the time Burma Army troops reached them and buried them beside the road. He also said that two packs of amphetamines were found near the bodies.

"Our troops drew the conclusion that those two persons' deaths were related to illegal drugs," Mya Tun Oo said.

At the time of their death, locals told a different account of the events: the men had been traveling through a rural area and were ordered to stop by the Burma Army. They were then shot when they refused to do so.

Regarding the additional five victims—of whom four were ethnic Palaung (Ta'ang) and one was Shan—Mya Tun Oo said his troops detained five people working on a corn farm. He said the soldiers allegedly found a phone on one of the detainees that held a photo of him with the Ta'ang National Liberation Army (TNLA), an ethnic armed group with whom the Burma Army is engaged in active conflict.

Mya Tun Oo also said that the troops found documents stating that the farmers were members of the TNLA.

"Our troops drew the conclusion that they had links to the TNLA," he added, continuing that, "whether they were insurgents or not, our army needs to respect the law. We have to punish persons who violate the law."

After the civilian deaths, rights groups and community leaders in northern Shan State accused the Burma Army of involvement in the murders and called on the government to take action against the military.

"We wanted the government to take action against those who violate human rights. We want this government to be a government who can protect the people's lives and property," said Sai Wann Lern Kham, an Upper House lawmaker representing Lashio and nearby townships through the Shan Nationalities League for Democracy (SNLD). "If not, our locals feel that they have no security anymore."

The post Burma Army Claims Responsibility for Five Civilian Deaths in Northern Shan State  appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Dozens Treated After Fainting at Martyrs’ Day Events

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 04:09 AM PDT

A woman is carried by first aid workers through a crowd gathered outside of the Martyrs' Mausoleum in Rangoon on Martyrs' Day, observed on Tuesday, July 19, 2016. (Photo: Hein Htet / The Irrawaddy)

A woman is carried by first aid workers through a crowd gathered outside of the Martyrs' Mausoleum in Rangoon on Martyrs' Day, observed on Tuesday, July 19, 2016. (Photo: Hein Htet / The Irrawaddy)

RANGOON — With record crowds present at Rangoon's various martyrs' monuments on Tuesday, volunteers administering emergency first aid at the sites said that dozens of people were treated after fainting and some were sent to hospital.

Over 169,000 visitors gathered at the Martyrs' Mausoleum, the Secretariat building and the Bogyoke Aung San Museum on Tuesday to salute Burmese independence leader Gen Aung San and his eight colleagues, all of whom were assassinated 69 years ago on July 19.

Tun Tun Win from the Rangoon-based social outreach group Free Funeral Services Society said that the organization's emergency rescue team—as well as four ambulances—were put on standby at the memorial sites during Tuesday's events.

As thousands of people stood in line for hours in the rain before crowding to get inside the historical sites, some visitors fainted and suffered minor injuries, he explained. The team administered first aid to 36 such individuals. Four people, including three elderly visitors, were sent to Yangon General Hospital where they required further treatment.

Yet overall, he felt that the events went smoothly.

"Though there were big crowds, there were no major injuries or violence, as people were well-disciplined and followed instructions," Tun Tun Win said, describing his organization's participation in the first aid efforts as a "very meaningful" experience.

"It was really great to view [the proceedings] yesterday. All of country's top leaders paid respect to fallen national heroes, including the army chief, which happened for the first time," he added, referring to Snr-Gen Min Aung Hlaing's attendance at the Martyrs' Mausoleum commemoration ceremony; he was the first head of the Burma Army present the event since after the student-led uprisings of 1988.

The post Dozens Treated After Fainting at Martyrs' Day Events appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Amnesty International Calls for Relocation of Toxic Factory

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 04:00 AM PDT

The Thunder Sulphuric Acid Factory, which abuts farmland used by residents of Kankone Village in Monywa Township of Sagaing Division. (Photo: Amnesty International)

The Thunder Sulphuric Acid Factory, which abuts farmland used by residents of Kankone Village in Monywa Township of Sagaing Division. (Photo: Amnesty International)

London-based human rights group Amnesty International has called on the Burmese government to "immediately" relocate a sulfuric acid factory situated close to a village, which continues to operate despite adverse impacts reported on public health and the environment.

In a statement released on Tuesday, Amnesty said that, during fieldwork conducted last month, residents of Kankone Village in Monywa Township of Sagaing Division told of respiratory, skin and eye ailments linked to the "strong-smelling factory emissions," as well as damage to crops.

Village residents said the air had become so toxic that youth had stopped attending the local school, located only 50 meters from the factory.

A 2013 examination by the government and an environmental organization identified high levels of sulphates in the soil.

"[Burma's] government must intervene immediately and stop the operations of the sulfuric acid factory. The factory must be relocated to an area where it can't endanger anybody's health," said Amnesty International Business and Human Rights researcher Mark Dummett.

The Thunder Sulphuric Acid Factory was built in 2007 under Union of Myanmar Economic Holdings Limited (UMEHL), a major military-owned conglomerate in Burma.

An investigation led by then-opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi in 2013 discovered that it had been constructed without the required permission from local authorities—a criminal offence.

UMEHL acquired official permission to run the factory shortly afterwards, in July 2013, and faced no sanctions for illegally operating over six years.

The factory supplies two major, and controversial, copper mines located nearby—Letpadaung, and Sabetaung and Kyisintaung (S&K)—run jointly by UMEHL and Wanbao Mining, a Chinese company. Letpadaung mine began producing copper in May 2016, amid sustained opposition from local farmers who claim their land was seized for the mine without adequate compensation.

Last month, municipal authorities chose not to renew the factory's annual operating license pending a health and environmental impact assessment.

However, local residents said that the factory resumed operations after little more than a month. A local official said a "central government body" was allowing it to run despite not receiving a renewed license.

The post Amnesty International Calls for Relocation of Toxic Factory appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

Security Tightens for Goteik Viaduct Visitors

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 01:09 AM PDT

 Visitors at the Goteik Viaduct, located in northern Shan State around 100 kilometers north of the city of Mandalay. (Photo: Kyaw Hsu Mon)

Visitors at the Goteik Viaduct, located in northern Shan State around 90 miles north-east of the city of Mandalay. (Photo: Kyaw Hsu Mon)

NAWNGHKIO TOWNSHIP, Shan State—After banning visitors from walking on Shan State's famous Goteik Viaduct as a safety measure, security has tightened while people continue to visit during the rainy season.

Located in Nawnghkio Township in northern Shan State—on a stretch of the Mandalay-Lashio railway between Pyin Oo Lwin and Kyaukme—the popular tourist site is the highest bridge in Burma and was once the largest railway trestle in the world.

 Visitors at the Goteik Viaduct, located in northern Shan State around 100 kilometers north of the city of Mandalay. (Photo: Kyaw Hsu Mon)

Visitors at the Goteik Viaduct, located in northern Shan State around 90 miles north-east of the city of Mandalay. (Photo: Kyaw Hsu Mon)

Construction began during the British colonial era in 1899 and the steel towers and 2,260 feet of track was completed in 1900 by Pennsylvania and Maryland Bridge Construction, an American company. Tourism has grown in the area in recent years.

"Even during rainy season, more than 500 people come on the weekends to see the bridge, so we've restricted crossing," said Yin Htwe, an official from Myanmar Railways.

He said the restriction was put in place in February, because many people walked on the viaduct in order to take "selfies" on it.

"The bridge is so high—more than 300 feet from bottom to top—and there were times when people have nearly fallen off. We are limiting them for their safety," Yin Htwe added.

 Visitors at the Goteik Viaduct, located in northern Shan State around 100 kilometers north of the city of Mandalay. (Photo: Kyaw Hsu Mon)

Visitors at the Goteik Viaduct, located in northern Shan State around 90 miles north-east of the city of Mandalay. (Photo: Kyaw Hsu Mon)

"Some people want to sneak past the 'restricted' signpost. That's why security personnel have to watch visitors all the time," he said.

Yin Htwe said that many foreign tourists now take the Mandalay-Lashio railway, which runs twice a day and takes 20 minutes to traverse the Goteik viaduct, the indisupted highlight of the route.

Aung Lin, a first-time visitor from Rangoon, said it amazed him to see a train slowly crossing the bridge

"We took a one hour drive on a bumpy road from Nawnghkio to Goteik. It's tiring but worth it to enjoy a new experience," he added.

Prior to February, the Burmese government had allowed people to walk on the bridge, but fearing for the safety of visistors they issued the ban.

The post Security Tightens for Goteik Viaduct Visitors appeared first on The Irrawaddy.

National News

National News


Hotels told to get licences before building

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 12:46 AM PDT

Would-be hoteliers who fail to apply for a licence before construction starts will not be permitted to operate, the government has announced. U Myo Win Nyunt, director of the hotel and tourism supervision division of the Ministry of Hotels and Tourism, told The Myanmar Times yesterday that the ministry's days of turning a blind eye were over.

Irrigation budget halved in agricultural policy change

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 12:31 AM PDT

A shift in policy, away from building dams and toward running irrigation channels to farmland, has led to a 50 percent cut in the request for irrigation funding next year, the agriculture ministry says. U Myo Tint Tun, assistant secretary in the ministry, told The Myanmar Times on July 18 that expenditure in 2017-18 would be less than half of this year's level.

Flood-wary Sidoktaya locals demand dam fixes

Posted: 20 Jul 2016 12:30 AM PDT

Hundreds of flood victims protested in Magwe Region's Sidoktaya township on July 17, demanding upgrades to local dams and compensation for crops lost to flooding.

Martyrs’ Day crowd packs Yangon’s Bogyoke Aung San Museum

Posted: 19 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

People flocked to the Bogyoke Aung San Museum in Yangon's Bahan township yesterday, as nationwide commemorations marked the day 69 years ago that Myanmar's independence hero and eight colleagues were gunned down by a political rival.

Daw Aung San Suu Kyi Park monument lacks funds

Posted: 19 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

Additional money is needed to erect a Bogyoke Aung San statue and a Panglong monument in Pindaya township's new Daw Aung San Suu Kyi Park, said National League for Democracy official U Myint Lwin.

Martyrs’ Day makes strides for national reconciliation

Posted: 19 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

Yesterday's commemoration of the 69th anniversary of Martyrs' Day was marked by a series of firsts: the first observed under the new government, the first attended by the commander-in-chief and the first held at the newly upgraded Martyrs' Mausoleum.

President U Htin Kyaw observes Waso and Martyrs’ Day

Posted: 19 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

On yesterday's double holiday – Martyrs' Day and the full moon day of Waso – President U Htin Kyaw donated Waso robes and honoured fallen martyrs in the Dhammayone, a religious community hall in the Nay Pyi Taw Council Office compound.

Embassy forms team in bid to better protect migrants in Malaysia

Posted: 19 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

The Myanmar embassy in Malaysia launched a migrant protection task force on July 17.

New representatives on Arbitration Council disputed

Posted: 19 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

Workers are demanding that a new election be held for representatives to the Nay Pyi Taw Arbitration Council, claiming that the recently appointed members were not democratically elected.

Luxury wood seized along border to China

Posted: 19 Jul 2016 02:30 PM PDT

Police are on the lookout for drivers of two trucks carrying 8 tonnes of illegally harvested padauk logs to China. The abandoned vehicles were seized on July 12 in Kyaingtong/Kengtung township, Shan State.