Saturday, July 26, 2014

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Opponents Seek to Halt Dam Construction on Salween River

Posted: 25 Jul 2014 08:35 PM PDT

Salween River

A viewpoint at Thailand's Ban Mae Sam Laep on the bank of Salween River, which demarcates the Thai-Burma border. (Photo: Saw Yan Naing / The Irrawaddy)

A viewpoint at Thailand's Ban Mae Sam Laep on the bank of Salween River, which demarcates the Thai-Burma border. (Photo: Saw Yan Naing / The Irrawaddy)

BANGKOK — Activists, researchers and environmentalists from Burma and Thailand met on Friday to find a way to stop hydropower dams planned on Burma's section of the Salween River, one of Asia's last free-flowing rivers.

Originating from the Tibetan Plateau, the Salween is Southeast Asia's second longest river. It flows roughly 2,400 kms through China, Thailand and Burma to the Andaman Sea, crisscrossing many of Burma's ethnic minority areas, where it provides food and jobs.

Campaigners say six dams in Burma, being developed jointly by Chinese, Thai and Burmese investors, threaten the future of local people and the rich biodiversity of the Salween basin. China is also planning 13 dams on the upper Salween.

The Burma dams, with a combined power generation capacity of around 15,000 megawatts, are also located in former or current conflict zones. This has raised concerns of renewed or increased fighting between the army and ethnic rebels over natural resources, undermining ongoing efforts to achieve nationwide peace.

Burma's powerful military is also involved in the dam projects. Growing militarization, illegal logging, land grabs and forced labor already affect communities in the dam areas—and those who voice opposition are threatened, say Shan and Karen campaign groups.

In addition, most of the electricity produced would be exported to China and Thailand, leaving little for energy-starved Burma, while ethnic minorities who are already marginalized would be left with a degraded river and environment.

"There is no local participation, no transparency and no benefit to the local people. The dams just lead to more fighting and human rights abuses, and villagers have to relocate," said Sai Khur Hseng, general secretary of Ethnic Community Development Forum (Burma), an alliance of ethnic organizations across the country.

"How do you measure the value of what all the people are relying on? You cannot measure the value of culture, religion [or] biodiversity," added Khur Hseng, who is also coordinator of the Shan Sapawa Environmental Organization.

Partly due to its remote location, the Salween River is less well known and populated than the Mekong, its big brother. Still, 6 million people, mostly ethnic and religious minorities, live in the Salween watershed and depend on the river for jobs and nutritious food, according to WWF.

These minorities are already neglected in China, Burma and Thailand, said Pianporn Deetes, campaign coordinator for environmental group International Rivers (IR) in Thailand.

"There is no spotlight on the area and it's easy for investors to exploit it. The voices of the marginalized ethnic [people] who will bear the cost of the dams are not heard," she said.

A petition with over 33,000 signatures calling for a halt to the dams was released on March 14, the International Day of Action for Rivers and against Dams. Campaigners also raised awareness during the Asean People's Forum in March, an event bringing together civil society from the 10 countries that make up the Asean regional bloc.

"Two months after that, the building of Kun Long dam was discussed in [Burma's] Parliament, and it sounded like they are going to go ahead," said Saw Thar Phoe of Karen Rivers Watch (KRW). "Whether they don't hear us or they are not listening, we do not know."

In September 2011, Burma's President Thein Sein suspended the Chinese-led Myitsone dam, Burma's largest hydropower project, after weeks of public outrage. Myitsone is located at the source of the Irrawaddy River, considered a lifeline for the country.

"For the ethnic groups in the east of Myanmar, the Salween plays the same role as the Irrawaddy," said IR's Deetes.

Carl Middleton, a former campaigner with IR who now lectures at Bangkok's Chulalongkorn University, said it was "highly likely" people living along the Salween would be worse off after the projects—both materially and culturally.

"While promises are often made from dam developers to support affected communities, the track record in the region for livelihood replacement programs is not good," said Middleton, who is organizing a research conference on the Salween in November.

Given that the Salween dam deals were signed with the Burmese junta, who ruled the impoverished Southeast Asian country with an iron fist for almost half a century, Burma's new quasi-civilian government should reconsider them, campaigners say.

There is no river basin authority and no agreement between the countries on how to develop and sustain the river, however, and activists are now mulling a legal challenge.

In June, a Thai court accepted a lawsuit against the government-owned Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT) and four other state bodies for agreeing to buy electricity from a controversial hydropower dam being built in neighboring Laos. Activists say the Xayaburi project threatens the livelihood of tens of millions who depend on the river's resources.

"Even if we cannot stop the dam, even if they find other buyers or funders, it's unprecedented that transboundary impacts are now officially recognized. We're working with the same group of lawyers to prepare similar stuff for the Salween dams," said IR's Deetes.

EGAT's international arm is involved in at least two out of the six planned Salween dams in Burrma.

The post Opponents Seek to Halt Dam Construction on Salween River appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

The Irrawaddy Business Roundup (July 26, 2014)

Posted: 25 Jul 2014 07:30 PM PDT

Ooredoo SIM Cards to Go on Sale in Less Than a Month

Qatari company Ooredoo is planning to end Burma's long wait for affordable mobile phone services next month, according to Mizzima.

"We will be selling our SIM cards in the third week of August, but for now we cannot confirm what the calling rates will be," Mizzima quoted the company's public relations manager Thiri Kyar Nyo as saying.

In a statement Thursday, the company said it had begun trialing its network with local distributors, six of whom have been named as the company's partners in different regions of the country.

More than a year ago, Ooredoo and Norway's Telenor were named as the winners of a highly competitive tender to be the first private operators in Burma's telecommunications sector.

Burma's only existing mobile phone operator, the state-owned Myanmar Post and Telecommunications (MPT), has recently teamed up with Japanese companies KDDI and Sumitomo, who have announced plans to invest US$2 billion to modernize MPT's services and compete with the newcomers.

MPT has historically restricted the distribution of SIM cards so not to overload its limited network, driving a black market on which people paid hundreds of dollars each for SIM cards.

But as the foreign operators get closer to selling their SIM cards, which are expected to cost 1,500 kyat, or about $1.50, MPT has increased the supply through lotteries and prices have fallen.

According to Eleven Media, MPT is currently preparing to finally put SIM cards on general sale.

"We are planning to change the sale plan of CDMA 800 MHz and GSM SIM cards. When we have finished making arrangements, we will announce the time to start it," said MPT General Manager Khin Maung Tun, according to Eleven.

Bangkok Airways Plans Chiang Mai Links to Burma: Report

Thai airline Bangkok Airways is planning to launch flights connecting the northern Thai tourism hotspot of Chiang Mai with Burma's two biggest cities, according to the Bangkok Post newspaper.

A report on Thursday cited "insiders" saying the privately owned airline wanted to tap into the market created by the growing number of people flying into Burma.

"[Bangkok Airways] will offer four flights per week on the new Chiang Mai-Yangon route and three a week on the Chiang Mai-Mandalay service," the newspaper said.

At present, only Tay Za's Air Bagan flies between Rangoon and Chiang Mai, operating two flights per week.

However, Burmese airline Air Kanbawza has also declared plans to fly between Rangoon and Chiang Mai, as well as Mae Sot, a town on the eastern side of the Burmese-Thai border. Local carrier Asian Wings has also launched flights between Chiang Mai and Mandalay.

"Bangkok Airways is already the largest provider of flights from Thailand to Myanmar, operating three routes from Bangkok to Yangon, Mandalay and Nay Pyi Taw with a combined 40 flights a week," the Bangkok Post said.

Regional Approval Slows Onshore Oil and Gas Contracts

The companies named in October as winners of 13 onshore oil and gas exploration blocks are still waiting to sign agreements with the government so they can start work.

According to The Myanmar Times, the deals have already been agreed by the Myanmar Investment Commission and the Cabinet, but still need to be approved by regional authorities.

The newspaper said the original deadline for the signing of the contacts was in June.

"The contracts for the onshore blocks are going to be signed at the end of month," it quoted Win Maw, deputy director general of the Energy Ministry's Energy Planning Department saying. "If not, it cannot be later than early August."

Malaysia's Petronas, ONGC Videsh Limited of India, Eni of Italy and Canada's Pacific Hunt Energy Corp were among the companies named as winners of 10 production sharing contracts and three Improved Petroleum Recovery agreements in the onshore tender.

In March, Burma also named the winners of 20 offshore blocks, including deepwater areas that will be explored by companies including Anglo-Dutch firm Royal Dutch Shell, France's Total, Norway's Statoil and ConocoPhillips from the United States. The contracts for those blocks have also yet to be signed.

Forbes Reports Problems for Burmese Tycoon Tay Za

Burma's most notorious "crony" is under increased scrutiny from the US government over his apparent involvement in North Korean arms deals, according to Forbes magazine.

Tay Za and his companies appear on the US Treasury Department's Specially Designated Persons list because the US government believes he acted as an arms dealer for Burma's former military regime.

A story about the businessman, which was published online this week and appears in the Aug. 18 issue of Forbes Asia, includes an interview with Tay Za and details of financial documents shown to the magazine.

Singapore's United Overseas Bank (UOB) wrote to Tay Za in April to inform him it was closing nine of his bank accounts, it said.

"The letters gave no explanation, and UOB did not respond to a request for comment, but Tay Za says the bank became nervous after American officials raised questions about transfers he made to companies in China with alleged links to North Korea," Forbes reported.

In the article, Tay Za admits that he made $300 million of financial transfers on behalf of the Burmese government, but claimed he had no choice in the matter. "Whatever the government requests, I have to handle," he was as quoted saying.

Reports also emerged this week that suggest TayZa is offloading his majority stake in Asian Green Development Bank, the bank he founded in 2011. The grandsons of Burma's late dictator Gen. Ne Win said they will buy at least 60 percent of the bank, although Tay Za himself and officials at the bank have not confirmed the news.

In the Forbes article, Tay Za complained that his businesses are suffering as a result of American sanctions.

"For example, he says, he may be forced to shut down his Air Bagan airline, which has lost about $90 million over the past couple years, in part because he is not allowed to buy American-made spare parts at market prices," he said.

The post The Irrawaddy Business Roundup (July 26, 2014) appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

Democratic Voice of Burma

Democratic Voice of Burma


‘Are we revolutionaries?’ debate ethnic leaders

Posted: 26 Jul 2014 04:39 AM PDT

Meeting in Laiza for pivotal talks aimed towards signing a nationwide ceasefire agreement, ethnic leaders of the Nationwide Ceasefire Coordination Team (NCCT) debated on Friday whether to include the words "revolution" and "revolutionaries" in a draft document when referring to themselves.

Representing 16 ethnic armed groups, some 100 delegates have descended on Laiza, a Sino-Burmese border town in Kachin State, headquarters of the Kachin Independence Organisation, for the latest round of negotiations in a peace process initiated by the Burmese government.

Veteran Mon representative Nai Hongsar told DVB that the first day of talks focused mainly on the adoption of Section One–Basic Principles for any draft agreement.

"There was one important point. Shall we use the word ‘revolution’ in the title of the agreement?" said Nai Hongsar. "Other matters of terminology were raised – shall we refer to ourselves as 'ethnic armed groups' or 'armed ethnic groups'? And are we aiming for a 'ceasefire' or a 'cease of offensive activities'?"

He said the question of terminology had been referred to the leading committee of the NCCT which was appointed a day earlier with the Karen National Union's Mutu Say Poe as chairman.

Dr. Salai Lian Sakhong, an advisor to the NCCT, said that on Friday the representatives had concluded Section One of the second draft of a nationwide ceasefire proposal.

"Today's discussions finalised Section One – the Basic principles," he said. "We have also included three or four alternative versions."

The second draft of the nationwide ceasefire proposal was composed in Rangoon in May by a joint body of nine ethnic leaders and nine representatives from Naypyidaw: three each from the government, parliament and military.

A second day of negotiations in Laiza continues on Saturday, 26 July.

MPs debate pros and cons of proportional representation

Posted: 26 Jul 2014 03:23 AM PDT

Ten MPs took to the floor of the lower house of Burma's parliament on Friday as debate commenced on whether to employ a system of proportional representation (PR) in future general elections.

A motion to replace the first-past-the-post system with PR was already debated and approved by the upper house by a vote of 177 to 85 (with three abstaining) last month.

On the first day of the debate in the lower house, five MPs spoke in support of the motion to adopt PR, while five spoke against the change.

According to National League for Democracy (NLD) MP Min Thu, some 50 parliamentarians will be afforded the opportunity to address the house over the coming week with parties in support of the motion and those against given equal time to address parliament.

"Today, U Win Myint and Daw Khin Thandar from the NLD spoke against changing our electoral system to PR," said the Uttara Thiri constituency MP. "They were joined by U Khun Laing from the Chin National Party and one representative each from the Phalon-Sawaw Democratic Party and the Chin Progressive Party in speaking out against the motion."

He said that, on the pro-PR side, two MPS from the Union Solidarity and Development Party, Thein Htun Oo and Thar Win, addressed the lower house, followed by Nyan Swe Win from the National Unity Party, Daw Dwebu from the Unity and Democratic Party of Kachin State, and one unnamed MP from Chibwe Township.

Min Thu said that although Kachin MP Daw Dwebu spoke in favour of a PR system, she said it is not yet appropriate to employ this method in ethnic areas.

"In Kachin State, some constituencies had no elections [in 2010] for security reasons," she is reported to have said. "So although a PR system is preferable, our situation is not yet ripe for this change."

Aung Zin, an MP with the National Democratic Front, the party which originally proposed the PR motion, echoed her sentiments. He said that his party supported the adoption of PR, but that ethnic states should be excluded.

Speaking to DVB on Friday, Ko Ko Gyi of the 88 Generation civil society group, opined that that Burma was still too young in its transition to democracy to consider an immediate switch to PR.

"The public must understand the pros and cons of the electoral systems," he said. "There should be a wide range of discussions, and commissions formed at different levels. We need a period of time to discuss the PR issue. We are still at a stage where the status of representation in parliament is questionable. For an important change like this, we must debate long and hard. We should not rush into this."

 

MSF ‘cautiously optimistic’ about Arakan return

Posted: 26 Jul 2014 01:33 AM PDT

Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) Holland, which was forced to suspend most of its relief activities in Arakan in late February, said on Friday that it welcomed a call from the Arakan State government for it to resume its operations but remained "cautious".

On Thursday, the Rakhine State Government invited MSF, along with the 24 non-governmental organisations (NGOs) currently operating in the state, "to participate in development, humanitarian, education, and healthcare programs in accordance with the wishes of the Rakhine [Arakanese] people."

Before it was forced to halt operations, MSF provided frontline healthcare for tens of thousands in areas of the state hardest-hit by communal conflict, principally Rohingya Muslims. The organisation has defended itself against criticism of its aid delivery amid allegations of bias towards the Rohingya at the expense of the state's Arakanese Buddhist majority. MSF maintains that its policies are guided by principles of humanitarian neutrality,

"MSF is cautiously optimistic about this development," Marcel Langenbach, MSF-Holland's Director of operations, said in a statement.  "Given that for many people in Rakhine, access to medical services remains a major challenge, we hope that MSF can restart treating patients as soon as possible."

No timeline has been announced for the resumption of MSF's activities in Arakan. Figures provided by the organisation claim that in 2013, its doctors performed more than 400,000 consultations across the state.

"We remain eager to resume activities throughout Rakhine State and have a team of national and international staff ready to provide medical care immediately," said Langenbach.

In late March, more than 170 staff members from international NGOs and UN agencies were evacuated from the state capital, Sittwe, following attacks by Arakanese nationalists targeting their offices and residences. Demands that aid delivery be "balanced" between the Rohingya and the Arakanese majority have raised concerns that future negotiations will be subject to political pressures, which may affect the ability of agencies to provide for the neediest.

The invitation to resume operations in Arakan came shortly after a significant political shake-up in the restive region when Maung Maung Ohn, the former deputy minister of border affairs, replaced Hla Maung Tin, an ethnic Arakanese politician, as the state's chief minister in late June.

Maung Maung Ohn served as the head of the union-level Emergency Coordination Centre for Arakan State, which is responsible for coordinating humanitarian activities between the government, NGOs and UN agencies.

The move met stiff opposition from Arakanese nationalists, who viewed Maung Maung Ohn's appointment as an unwelcome push by Naypyidaw to assert its agenda while ignoring Arakanese grievances.

Rangoon residents left in filth as waste collection system fails

Posted: 26 Jul 2014 01:12 AM PDT

Residents of Thaketa Township in eastern Rangoon have been left without a garbage removal service and they say their health is rapidly deteriorating as a result.

Not only is their own rubbish not being collected, but people have been coming from across Rangoon to dump in the area for the past two years.

Now, as rainy season sets in, the festering trash is blocking drains and creating stagnant pools of filthy water. Mosquitoes are breeding fast, leading to outbreaks of dengue fever in the community. Water-borne diseases such as amoebic dysentery are also rife.

Local resident San San Maw says it is the children who are suffering the most.

"Last week, my daughter was hospitalised for two days when she caught dengue," she said. "Other children, like her, are falling seriously ill too.

"We're demanding that the garbage is removed immediately."

However the Yangon City Development Committee (YCDC), which is responsible for the city's waste management, admits that it is only capable of collecting 50 to 60 percent of the city's refuse.

While blaming changing consumer habits—such as the move towards single-use items such as plastic food containers—and a lack of citizen awareness as to sanitation and the environment, the committee concedes to having no comprehensive plan for waste management. YCDC puts that to a shortage of funds for undertakings such as the purchasing of new landfill sites, equipment, staffing and the installation of communal bins.

That failure essentially became the main driving force in the committee's push to privatise Rangoon's garbage collection.

In late May, seven joint-venture companies submitted tenders for garbage collection contracts in the city. The contract winner will be announced in December, and will begin operations in 2015.

However, the residents of Thaketa say they can wait no longer.

Resident Toe Toe says she is desperately concerned for the health and future of the community.

"We are the ones to suffer," she says.  "There are a lot of people here who already have heart conditions and diabetes, and their health is getting worse.

"Children can't even go to school because of the flooding. The school has closed. The whole neighbourhood is under water."

Many youngsters suffer constantly from diarrhoea, she said, and three were recently hospitalised.

The residents of Thaketa are living in these conditions despite Rangoon property prices soaring, as investors flock to a city gaining increasing significance on the regional stage.

Rangoon is known for its enchanting architecture and leafy streets; however many of its residents see it from a very different perspective.