Thursday, December 25, 2014

The Irrawaddy Magazine

The Irrawaddy Magazine


Wanbao, Govt Failed To Address Mine Project Concerns: NLD

Posted: 25 Dec 2014 01:59 AM PST

Wanbao, Govt Failed To Address Mine Project Concerns: NLD

NLD MP Khin San Hlaing talks to locals in Letpadaung on Thursday (Photo: JPaing / The Irrawaddy)

CHIANG MAI, Thailand — After two days of protest at the site of the Letpadaung copper mine project in Sagaing Division, the National League for Democracy (NLD) issued a statement on Wednesday criticizing Burmese authorities and the Chinese company behind the mine for failing to address the social and environmental impacts of the project.

On Monday, Khin Win, a 56-year-old woman, was shot dead by police during a protest against the copper mine project—a joint venture between Myanmar Wanbao Mining Copper Limited and the Burma Army-owned Union of Myanmar Economic Holdings.

On Tuesday, several more villagers were injured in confrontations with police near the project site, including at least three who were shot with rubber bullets.

A parliamentary commission headed by opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi reviewed the controversial project in early 2013 and recommended that it continue, provided the company adequately address the mine's social and environmental impact.

In March 2013, President Thein Sein formed a committee to implement the findings of the parliamentary commission's report. The NLD said in its statement on Wednesday that authorities had failed to heed the commission's recommendations.

Khin San Hlaing, an NLD MP and a member of the Suu Kyi-led commission, told The Irrawaddy on Thursday that Thar Aye, Chief Minister of Sagaing Division, had rejected the NLD's claim.

"We met with the minister yesterday. We told him that the unrest on Dec. 22 broke out as the company and authorities did not follow the advice in our report," Khin San Hlaing said. "But, the Minister didn’t admit it. He said that they are following the [recommendations of the] report and will try to complete the project."

The project has drawn vehement opposition from local communities that have objected to the mine's environmental impact, land confiscation and the removal of religious structures in the area.

Tensions flared between villagers and Wanbao contractors on Monday and Tuesday after the latter began clearing land with bulldozers and fencing off more than a dozen acres of farmland in Hse Tae village as part of the planned expansion of the mine.

On Wednesday, a commission was formed to investigate the clashes between protestors and police, with Thar Aye as vice-chairman. "He [Thar Aye] said he would then handle the issue based on the findings of the commission," Khin San Hlaing said.

However, the NLD MP questioned the impartiality of the commission, as all its members were reportedly government officials.

Thar Aye said that the company would continue fencing off land in the project area, according to Khin San Hlaing.

The President's Office said in a statement on Wednesday that 11 police and 11 protestors were injured during protests at the mine site on Monday and Tuesday. The statement claimed that villagers were armed with slingshots, knives and sticks and said that security forces had fired warning shots.

Regarding the death of Khin Win, the President's Office said it was taking action according to the law.

In the last two years, there have been numerous confrontations between villagers and security forces as the mine's operators attempted to extend the project's operating area.

In Nov. 2012, dozens of protestors, many of them Buddhist monks, suffered serious injuries after police fired incendiary rounds, believed to be white phosphorous, into a protest camp near the mine.

The post Wanbao, Govt Failed To Address Mine Project Concerns: NLD appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

China Tightens Church Control Ahead of Christmas

Posted: 24 Dec 2014 09:44 PM PST

China Tightens Church Control Ahead of Christmas

A church seen under construction in a suburban area of Wenzhou, Zhejiang province, China, in Feb. 2011. (Photo: Reuters)

BEIJING — Two days before Christmas, members of a rural Christian congregation in the eastern city of Wenzhou welded some pieces of metal into a cross and hoisted it onto the top of their worship hall to replace one that was forcibly removed in October.

Within an hour, township officials and uniformed men barged onto the church ground and tore down the cross.

"They keep a very close watch on us, and there is nothing we can do," said a church official, who spoke to The Associated Press on Tuesday on condition of anonymity because of fear of government retaliation. "The situation is not good, as any attempt to re-erect the cross will be stopped."

That means that the worshippers in Wenzhou, like many Christians in the eastern Chinese province of Zhejiang, will worship this Christmas under a cross-less roof. Provincial authorities have toppled crosses from more than 400 churches, and even razed some worship halls in a province-wide crackdown on building code violations.

Many Christians say their faith has been singled out because authorities, wary of its rapid growth, are seeking to curb its spread in a campaign that has targeted China's most thriving Christian communities.

Estimates for the number of Christians in China range from the conservative official figure of 23 million to as many as 100 million by independent scholars, raising the possibility that Christians may rival in size the 85 million members of the ruling Communist Party.

In August, Beijing rounded up Christian pastors and religious scholars in a national seminar with the edict that the Christian faith must be free of foreign influence but "adapt to China," a euphemism for obeying the Communist Party's rule.

This week, authorities in Wenzhou—known as China's Jerusalem because it has half of the province's 4,000 churches—have banned all Christmas celebrations or related activities in the city's kindergartens and grade schools.

"We had guidance on foreign holidays such as Christmas in the past, but this year marks the first time we issued a clearer notice," an education official was quoted as saying in a local, government-run newspaper on Wednesday.

Churches in Wenzhou and elsewhere in Zhejiang were first told last year to turn off any spotlights shining on their crosses at night. A few months later, the congregations were ordered to remove the crosses or face forced demolitions.

Resistance by local Christians has led to violent protests, bloody clashes and arrests of pastors and churchgoers. At least two people—one pastor and one churchgoer—remain in police custody for their acts to defend the cross, said Zhang Kai, a Christian rights lawyer.

When one rural village re-erected a cross in the summer, authorities put it under a 24-hour watch, which has now gone on for nearly five months.

"This year's Christmas has been exceptional, as a group of uniformed men have been helping us move tables, direct traffic, and guard holiday decorations as well as the front door, the back door, the warehouse and the sanctuary," church pastor Tao Chongyin wrote on a social media site.

The post China Tightens Church Control Ahead of Christmas appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

Out of Tragedy, Fortune For Sri Lankan Tsunami Village

Posted: 24 Dec 2014 09:09 PM PST

Out of Tragedy, Fortune For Sri Lankan Tsunami Village

Flowers are seen on the beach in Seenigama, about 110 km south of Sri Lanka's capital Colombo, on Dec 20. (Photo: Reuters)

SEENIGAMA, Sri Lanka — As towering waves came crashing into the southern coast of Sri Lanka on Dec. 26, 2004, Kushil Gunasekera gathered up his children and they ran for their lives to a nearby temple, the highest point they could find.

Returning later to his village in Seenigama district, he found a heart-breaking scene of death and devastation: one in four had been killed by the Boxing Day tsunami that swept across the Indian Ocean.

A decade on, Seenigama has risen from the ashes and is now a model of prosperity, thanks in large part to the efforts of Gunasekera who led a relief drive from the ruins of his ancestral home and later gave up his lucrative sugar business to devote himself to a charity he had founded in 1999.

Seenigama is an outlier, however, along the ravaged coastline. Tourists have returned to the palm-fringed beaches but livelihoods still hang by a thread in many villages that got scant assistance from the state.

In nearby Pereliya village—where more than 1,500 people perished, most of them passengers on a train that was hurled off its tracks as the waves rolled in—many feel abandoned and angry.

"Nothing has changed in our lives," said G. Premalal, a fisherman at Pereliya beach where the government has erected a granite monument to the tsunami dead. "We have low quality houses. A lot of money was donated for us, but it was not distributed equally. Some got richer and richer because of the tsunami money, while others simply became poorer."

More than 250,000 people died in the tsunami, which was triggered by a 9.0-magnitude earthquake off the coast of Indonesia's Sumatra island.

Indonesia bore the brunt, but Sri Lanka was the next worst-affected country with a death toll of about 40,000.

Seenigama, about 110 km (70 miles) south of the island nation's capital, Colombo, was hit particularly hard by the tsunami because reefs that might have shielded it had been destroyed by years of coral mining.

Years before the disaster, Gunasekera had started his Foundation of Goodness non-governmental organization to generate alternative livelihoods for the coral miners. But the tsunami, which wrecked thousands of houses and schools, presented him with a much bigger challenge.

"Waves of Compassion"

Seven photographs are propped up on a table in the front hall of D. Karunawathi's house, a reminder of the family members she lost in the tsunami, including her mother, sister, daughter-in-law and grand-daughter. None of their bodies were found.

"Yes, we lost lives," says 60-year-old Karunawathi from her robust two-storey house. "But we got a permanent home."

But Gunasekera's project went far beyond bricks and mortar.

Leaning on his own charisma and connections, including some of Sri Lanka's best-known cricketers, Gunasekera brought together villagers, volunteers and donors, ploughing financial assistance into long-term projects to build a comprehensive and sustainable model of community development.

The project now provides free services for more than 25,000 people, ranging from healthcare to vocational training and a sports academy for the young that has already produced two national-level cricketers.

On the day of the disaster, Pulina Tharanga had set out for a school cricket match with a pair of shoes that his mother had bought for 2,000 rupees ($15), money she had earned selling rice noodles over several months. When he returned she was dead.

"She had asked me not to play cricket because she couldn't afford it," said Tharanga, who played for Sri Lanka's junior national team in the 2012 World Cup in Brisbane, Australia.

The Foundation of Goodness village project, which costs about $1 a year, depends heavily on foreign donors. The academy's cricket ground was financed by England's Surrey Cricket Club and a swimming pool was funded by Canadian rock singer Bryan Adams.

"We harness waves of compassion to overcome waves of destruction and rebuild better," Gunasekera told Reuters. "When a tragedy like that happens, you can't reverse it. You need to look ahead and stay positive."

The post Out of Tragedy, Fortune For Sri Lankan Tsunami Village appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

US Think Tank Proposes Shake-Up Of Taiwan Defense

Posted: 24 Dec 2014 09:03 PM PST

US Think Tank Proposes Shake-Up Of Taiwan Defense

Chaff is set off from a Knox-class frigate during the Han Kuang military exercise held about 10 nautical miles east of the port of Hualien, eastern Taiwan, on Sept 17. (Photo: Reuters)

WASHINGTON — Fears of war between Taiwan and China have eased in recent years, but the growing gap in their military capabilities has prompted a US think tank to lay out a radical new approach in how Taiwan could defend itself if China invaded, relying less on conventional forces and more on guerrilla-style tactics and cyberwarfare.

The nongovernment Center for Strategic and Budgetary Assessments is wading into delicate territory. Relations between democratic Taiwan and communist-governed China have improved as they have forged economic agreements—a development welcomed by the United States.

Washington, however, remains obligated by US law to provide Taiwan the means to defend itself. US lawmakers have accused the Obama administration of refusing to sell Taiwan new fighter jets and submarines for fear of angering Beijing, which claims sovereignty over the self-governing island.

Congress last week approved the possible sale of four US frigates to Taiwan, drawing Chinese criticism, but Taiwan shows growing willingness to develop its own hardware. On Tuesday, it launched a stealthy, missile-launching corvette, the first ship of its kind produced by Taiwan.

But China's rapid military modernization has exposed a widening gulf between its forces and those on Taiwan, which spent $10.8 billion on its defense in 2013. According to a US Defense Department estimate, China's military spending that year was $145 billion.

"With the resource gap approaching fourteen-to-one, even if Taiwan were to massively increase its defense budget, it would not reverse the cumulative advantages the PRC has accrued over the past two decades," said the center's report, released this week. PRC stands for the communist-governed People's Republic of China.

A US congressional advisory panel reported last month that China has about 2,100 combat aircraft and 280 naval ships available for a Taiwan conflict, and more than 1,100 short-range ballistic missiles that could incapacitate Taiwan's air force in the early hours of a conflict. Taiwan has about 410 combat aircraft and 90 naval combat ships.

The center advocates an "asymmetric approach," with Taiwan using lighter forces to counter rather than match China's strengths. While Taiwan increasingly emphasizes such tactics, its military modernization plan still calls for big, conventional acquisitions, the report says.

For a fraction of the cost of building eight large diesel submarines that Taiwan is also planning, it could produce a fleet of 42 "midget submarines" similar in size to craft that North Korea and Iran have, the report says. These submarines could provide warning and targeting data for anti-ship cruise missiles deployed on mobile launchers resembling trucks hauling shipping containers.

To combat Chinese fighter planes, the report proposes "guerrilla" air defense, using hundreds of surface-to-air missiles—a tactic it says proved effective for North Vietnam against the United States during the Vietnam War. And if Chinese forces make it on land, guerrilla tactics to harass the occupying forces would slow their advance toward Taipei. It says cyberwar against Chinese battle networks would also be one of Taiwan's viable deterrents and "cost-imposing strategies."

The report's authors say asymmetric approaches toward defense would reduce Taiwanese dependence on US armaments, and should also appeal to other neighbors concerned over China's military buildup.

Nations like Vietnam, the Philippines and Indonesia "have territorial disputes with China and face many of the same challenges responding to the rapid Chinese military modernization looming over Taiwan," the report says.

The post US Think Tank Proposes Shake-Up Of Taiwan Defense appeared first on The Irrawaddy Magazine.

Democratic Voice of Burma

Democratic Voice of Burma


Shan State citizens rally for peace and ethnic rights

Posted: 25 Dec 2014 02:17 AM PST

Hundreds of people in the Pa-O and Danu self-administrated zones in Shan State held demonstrations on Wednesday calling for peace in Burma.

Around 400 Danu people marched through the town of Pindaya in western Shan State, carrying placards with demands for peace and for the recognition of all ethnic groups, said Chit Sein, chairman of the Danu Literature and Culture Association.

"The demands included calls for the government to take charge of the peace process; the country's development; ethnic affairs in Shan State; to include ethnic representatives in amending the Constitution; and objections to the proposed sexpartite dialogue," he said.

The march was also joined by the Pa-O Women's Organisation and several other civil society groups.

Chit Sein added that the demonstration was organised by the Danu people, without influence from the government or any political party.

He maintains that although Danu Pindaya and Ywarngan are within the Danu Self-Administrated Zone, its locals not do not enjoy full autonomy due to the administrative system being dominated by Burmese government officers.

On the same day, around 2,000 Pa-O people from Hsihseng and Hopong towns of the Pa-O Self-Administrated Zone marched in the Shan State capital Taunggyi with a similar list of demands.

"We have five demands: the government must accomplish implementation of the internal peace process; undertake swift development and reforms; include the demands and rights of ethnic nationalities in the law; to facilitate ethnic nationalities to extensively take part in the effort to amend the Constitution; and to immediately implement these points," said Khun Maung Baw, deputy-public relations coordinator of the Pa-O National Organisation, which organised the event.

The post Shan State citizens rally for peace and ethnic rights appeared first on DVB Multimedia Group.

Burma govt pledges support to Koh Tao murder suspects

Posted: 25 Dec 2014 01:34 AM PST

Burma's government and upper house of parliament have pledged to provide financial and moral support to Burmese migrants Zaw Lin and Win Zaw Htun, who are due in court on Friday to face charges of murdering two British tourists on the Thai island of Koh Tao.

Htoo Chit, one of the members of a delegation organised by the Burmese embassy in Bangkok, said, "On 19 December, we met with representatives of the upper house and they pledged to provide all necessary assistance, including financial support. Afterwards, we met with representatives of the President's Office in Naypyidaw, led by deputy-minister U Aung Thein, and they offered to help us find witnesses by writing to local governments where they might live."

He said most of the potential witnesses reside in southern Burma's Tenasserim Division.

The trial begins on Koh Samui in southern Thailand on 26 December. Families of the suspects are expected to attend.

Zaw Lin and Win Zaw Htun stand accused of seven charges, including the murders of Hannah Witheridge and David Miller, and the rape of Witheridge.

The Burmese pair have pleaded not guilty.

The post Burma govt pledges support to Koh Tao murder suspects appeared first on DVB Multimedia Group.

Former NLD official sued for ‘insulting religion’

Posted: 25 Dec 2014 12:28 AM PST

A former National League for Democracy (NLD) official appeared in court in Sagaing division on 24 December, after being sued for criticising the fundamentalist Buddhist monk-led group Ma-Ba-Tha .

Former NLD information officer and writer, Htin Lin Oo, is being sued by the local immigration chief Tun Khine under instructions from the regional Sangha Mahanayaka [head monk] Committee after he criticised the Ma-Ba-Tha in a public speech in Chaung-U Township on 23 October.

He was subsequently sacked by the NLD when his speech went viral on social media, drawing ire from Buddhist fundamentalists. He is being sued under articles 295(a) and 298 of the Penal Code for religious defamation and hurting religious feelings.

"The plaintiff [Tun Khine] told the court that remarks made by Htin Lin Oo in his speech were deemed defamatory towards the religion," Htin Lin Oo's attorney, Thein Than Oo, said after the hearing.

Tun Khine, responding to the defence lawyers' questioning, insisted the lawsuit against Htin Lin Oo was not politically motivated and had nothing to do with his status as an NLD member.

Htin Lin Oo was denied a request for bail and has been detained in Monywa prison since he was indicted on 17 December. He had pledged to personally apologise to Buddhist monks for his remarks if he was granted bail.

Defence lawyer Thein Than Oo said there was no Ma-Ba-Tha mob in front of the courthouse on Wednesday, unlike the previous hearing on 17 December when the fundamentalists showed up and demanded harsh punishment on Htin Lin Oo. However, a group of Htin Lin Oo's supporters, including an influential monk from Mandalay, attended the hearing.

"After learning that the Ma-Ba-Tha came to pressure the court in the first hearing, many supporters of U Htin Lin Oo including the Myawaddy [monastery] Sayaadaw Ariawunsa from Mandalay showed up on Wednesday and the Ma-Ba-Tha monks were nowhere to be seen," Thein Than Oo said.

The post Former NLD official sued for ‘insulting religion’ appeared first on DVB Multimedia Group.

Latpadaung protestor was killed by gunshot, says coroner

Posted: 24 Dec 2014 09:04 PM PST

The coroner at Salingyi Township Hospital confirmed a woman killed at a protest in Latpadaung on Monday died from a gunshot wound to the head.

After performing autopsy on Khin Win's body in Wednesday, the hospital's coroner, Dr Tin Nwe, and head of hospital Nyunt Than told reporters at a press conference she died from a single gunshot wound.

"By the look of the injury, we conclude that it is a bullet wound – we checked elsewhere on the body and did not find any other injury," said Tin Nwe.

"This wound was not inflicted by a blunt object. We conclude that a bullet hit her in the forehead."

He said there was no anomaly found in the autopsy, and that he could not answer questions from reporters as to what type of firearm was used or the distance the bullet traveled as he is not a firearms expert.

A government report on Tuesday claimed security forces fired 15 shots from crowd-control guns amid confrontations with the villagers at the Latpadaung copper mining project site on Monday.

This confirms the suspicions of many already involved in the case. Earlier in the week a firearms specialist who saw photos of Khin Win's body and activists who were on the scene when she was killed told DVB they believed she died from a gunshot wound.

Nyan Linn, a member of the activist group 88 Generation Peace and Open Society, who was at the morgue in Monywa, said based on the look of the wound, it was not possible that Khin Win was shot with a rubber bullet.

"Khin Win was not shot with a rubber bullet. It has has the characteristics of a gunshot – a small entry wound and large exit wound."

He said three villagers were shot with live ammunition during the clash on Monday, and others sustained injuries from rubber bullets.

After the autopsy, Khin Win's body was carried back to her home in Mogyopyin village by fellow villagers. Her funeral is scheduled for Thursday afternoon.

The post Latpadaung protestor was killed by gunshot, says coroner appeared first on DVB Multimedia Group.

National News

National News


Madaya residents demand closure of alabaster mine

Posted: 24 Dec 2014 08:21 PM PST

Residents of Pat Lae Inn village tract in Mandalay Region's Madaya township have demanded a local alabaster mining operation be halted because they say it is destroying crops and is too close to a monastery.

Migrants haunted by memory of tsunami missing

Posted: 24 Dec 2014 08:19 PM PST

A decade after towering waves wrenched her newborn baby from her arms, Mi Htay remains haunted by memories of the children she lost in the tsunami whose bodies, like hundreds of other Myanmar migrants in Thailand, were never identified.

Labour Ministry plots daily cost survey to prepare minimum wage

Posted: 24 Dec 2014 08:17 PM PST

The Ministry of Labour is planning a survey of the daily cost of living for low-paid workers in 108 townships, it said in a statement last week.

Warnings that ward, village law could disrupt elections

Posted: 24 Dec 2014 08:14 PM PST

A local administration law passed in 2012 is being used to stifle political activities and could affect campaigning for next year's elections, activists say.