Thursday, September 5, 2013

Shan Herald Agency for News

Shan Herald Agency for News


Weekly Diary, No.641 (24-31 August 2013)

Posted: 05 Sep 2013 04:38 AM PDT

  • US: BETTER RELATIONS REST ON NPT-PYONGYANG RELATIONS!
  • CHARTER SCRUTINY UP TO END OF YEAR!
  • VJ COMES TO LAIZA!
  • SHAN-KAREN TEAM MEETS VICE PRESIDENT!
  • DISABLED VETERANS GET $31 PER YEAR!
Cartoon
Tips for non-confrontationists: It'll be useful to remember!
wd-cartoon-036

Think Piece
Three persons cross a fast flowing stream:
  • One goes with the stream
  • The other goes against the stream
  • The last one follows the middle path
Only the last one reaches the other shore. (Anonymous)

Myanmar's honeymoon with the world is being built on the bodies of Muslim victims throughout the country.

Abdallah Yahya A. al-Mouallioni, Saudi Arabia's permanent representative to the UN, July press conference, reported by Bangkok Post, 2 September 2013

The World
25 August 2013

66 men and 4 women from former communist rebels graduate from Nepal's military academy and become officers in the national army they once fought against. (AP)

International Relations
28 August 2013
Burma announces foreigners holding its visas can freely choose to travel to the country via any of its 6 entry points: Tachilek, Myawaddy, Kawsawng as well as Rangoon, Mandalay and Naypyitaw. (Bangkok Post)

28 August 2013
Burmese embassy in Washington told Matt Rains and Alia Mehboob from Lux Capio Photography Agency earlier this month they were banned from returning to Burma after they visited conflict-stricken areas of Arakan State in April. (DVB)

28-29 August 2013
Dialogue between US Defense Institute of International Legal Studies (DILS) led by Captain Robert Sanders meet Ministry of Defense officials led by Maj Gen Ye Aung. They discuss human rights awareness and values and activities of a modern military, says Ambassador Derek Mitchell. (Myanmar Times)

29 August 2013

Statement by US Defense Department says Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel met his Burmese counterpart Lt-Gen Wai Lwin on the sidelines of the Asean defense meeting in Brunei. Hagel had discussed "the importance of Myanmar severing military ties to North Korea," defense spokesman George Little says. (UPI)

30 August 2013
William Brownfield, Assistant Secretary of State for International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs, will be visiting Rangoon on 4 September, says State Department. (UPI)

Thai-Burma Relations
24 August 2013

Sutin Wannabovorn, former reporter for Reuters and AP, known for asking hard questions and challenging authority, has launched a book titled Nakkhao Sai Jon (Reporter on the bandits' beat), sharing 40 years of his experience as a newshound. "Bandits" he has met included Khmer Rouge, Wa, Pulo, God's Army and Khun Sa. (Bangkok Post)

Politics/ Inside Burma
23 August 2013
Union Election Commission sends out warning to political parties any party found to be accepting assistance in cash or kind from foreign countries will be banned under 407 (c) of the constitution. 2 Lower House MPs say assistance for social work should not be counted. (Mizzima)

23 August 2013
Election Commission's bill debated in Lower House: Lawmakers can be removed if 1% of their constituents send complaints to EC. Shwe Mann and USDP lawmakers oppose the bill, but army representatives demand it should be approved. Debate suspended. If not approved, the president and union level high officials can be dismissed by parliament. If approved, lawmakers could be dismissed by the EC, made up of President's men, says Hsipaw MP Ye Htun. (Irrawaddy)

27 August 2013
Union Parliament has approved plan to agree to $ 261.5 million loan from World Bank to support development projects. It is a 40 year loan at a fixed 0.75% interest rate. (DVB)

27 August 2013
Statement released by parliament says a 4-month review of the constitution has been approved:
  • The 109 member committee will be divided into small groups to review the charter by sections
  • It will also consider historical background, current realities, "political maturity of the people", national reconciliation process, rule of law and stability
  • Findings will be submitted by 31 December
  • No punitive action will be taken against committee members criticizing the charter
(Irrawaddy)

27 August 2013
Lower House MP Pe Than, a member of Land Seizure Inquiry Commission, says Army's decision to return 18,364 acres out of 297,000 acres seized is too slow, too less. At least another 19,000 acres should be returned. (Mizzima)

28 August 2013
Deputy defense minister Gen Kyaw Nyunt, in reply to MPs' query, says veterans who sustained permanent disabilities receive only 30,000 kyat ($31) per annum. (Mizzima)

28 August 2013
Farmers rights bill approved by Upper House and Lower House. (Eleven)

30 August 2013
Burmese military erects No Child Soldiers billboard in downtown Rangoon. (Irrawaddy)

31 August 2013
President Thein Sein and Aung San Suu Kyi meet at presidential ranch in Naypyitaw. No details reported. (DVB)

Ethnic Affairs
25 August 2013

Mahn Nyein Maung, Karen leader, launches his book Against the storm, Across the sea, detailing his escape from Coco Islands in 1971 in a small boat. It was first published outside Burma in 2000. (Irrawaddy)

27 August 2013
UN special envoy Vijay Nambiar meets Shan community leaders in Myitkyina who say the KIO has worked only for the Kachin ethnic group and not for the Shan. (RFA)

28 August 2013

Vijay Nambiar visits Laiza and spends 5 hours holding talks with KIO officials and inspecting IDP camps. (RFA)

26-29 August 2013
Karen commanders hold conferences in Hlaing Bwe. Decides to uphold ceasefire with the government although the latter has refused to withdraw from 90 out of 300 outposts in KNU territory. (Mizzima)

29 August 2013
The UNFC and the government will meet in Chiangmai on 7 or 8 September to discuss: political framework and nationwide peace accord, according to Dr Khin Maung of UNFC, and Hla Maung Shwe of Myanmar Peace Center. (Irrawaddy)

31 August 2013

Shan-Karen delegation meets Union Peacemaking Work Committee (UPWC) led by Vice President Sai Mawk Kham. (SHAN)

Shans/ Shan State
23 August 2013
Meeting in Taunggyi announces trust-building conference in September. Karen, Karenni, Chin and Shan will be participants, according to spokesman Sai Leik. (DVB)

Economy/ Business
28 August 2013
Land prices in Muse, earlier 25 million kyat ($25,600) per acre, has climbed up to 100 million kyat ($ 105,000), following plans for 288 acre Central Economic Zone project was approved early this year. (Irrawaddy)

Human Rights
24 August 2013

42 houses and 15 shops burned down in Kantbalu, Sagaing region, following rumors that a Muslim man tried to sexually assault a young woman. (Irrawaddy)

26 August 2013
Teachers associations issue statement criticizing the sacking of a teacher in Naypyitaw for attending political rally and meetings. (Irrawaddy)

28 August 2013
Retired police officers' criticism of today's police force:
  • Capacity building trainings to enable them to handle conflict situations
  • Insufficient finances
  • Cases when policemen have to buy their own uniforms
(DVB)

29 August 2013

Monywa court sentences Naw Ohn Hla to 2 years in prison with hard labor for Letpadaung protest earlier this month. (Irrawaddy)
2 September 2013
Human Rights Watch (HRW) says draft law relating to the forming of organizations, made public on 27 July, fails to meet international norms and should be revised:
  • NGOs must obtain official registration
  • Hand over authority to military
  • Subject to decisions without appeal
(KIC)

Environment
2 September 2013
Sai Htun Yin, Minister for Electric Power, Shan State Government, says it is negotiating with Chinese Hanergy to begin Kunlong Hydro power project this year. The 1,400 megawatt project will be completed in 7 years under $ 1.4 billion investment. The government will receive 10% of the shares and 15% of electricity. (Mizzima)

Drugs
1 September 2013
Lt-Col Sai Harn, head of RCSS's Anti Narcotics Committee (ANC), says implementation of October 2012 agreement for a joint project in Mong Nai and Mongpan has yet to take off:
  • State government says they know nothing about the agreement and refuses entry to Mong Pan
  • Government's militia groups are involved in trafficking
  • Further inaction will cause further suffering for the people
(Myanmar Times)

Wa unlikely to join ethnic alliance

Posted: 05 Sep 2013 04:42 AM PDT


Although the United Wa State Party/United Wa State Army (UWSP/UWSA) had attended the July conference led by the United Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC), it should not be supposed that it is ready to become a member of the alliance, according to an informed source close to the group.

talone
Ta Lone (Photo: UWSA)
"That goes for the National Democratic Alliance Army (NDAA) of Sao Sai Leun too," he added. "Only the Myanmar National Democratic Alliance Army (MNDAA) of Peng Jiasheng has agreed to join it."

A delegation from the grouping is currently visiting Panghsang, where the Wa headquarters is located. He refused to identify the names of the delegates.

Li Julie aka U Aung Myint (Photo: UWSA)
All three groups had sent delegates to attend the UNFC led Ethnic Conference for Peace and Reconciliation, 29-31 July, in Chiangmai. Xiao Hsarm Khun, the Wa delegate, then told SHAN he was there to learn and build rapport with other "fraternal organizations."

Both the UWSA and NDAA have maintained their fragile truce with Naypyitaw for 24 years. As for the ceasefire with MNDAA, better known as Kokang, it broke down when Kokang was invaded and occupied in 2009.

Zhao Guo-an (Photo: UWSA)
Hkun Okker, UNFC's Joint Secretary #2, however, says the alliance was only trying to win over the 3 groups to join the UNFC led political negotiation team to parley with the government.

Speaking on yesterday's meeting with Thura Shwe Mann, Speaker of the Union Assembly (Pyidaungzu Hluttaw) in Kengtung, the source commented it was a visit to cultivate relations with the UWSA and NDAA.
"He has already declared himself a candidate for the next presidency," he said. "The meeting therefore was useful also for the Wa and Mongla (NDAA headquarters)."

The Wa delegation was led by Ta Lone, Deputy Commander-in-Chief; Zhao Guo-an, Chief of External Affairs; and Li Julie aka U Aung Myint. The NDAA representatives were Sai Leun aka Lin Mingxian, Chairman; Hsan Per, Vice Chairman; and Khun Hsang Lu, Vice Chairman.

Graduate Seminar "Understanding the Changing Dynamics of China-Myanmar Relations"

Posted: 05 Sep 2013 04:35 AM PDT

 
understanding-cn-mmr

Statement by the Burma Rivers Network

Posted: 05 Sep 2013 04:35 AM PDT

September 3, 2013

Burma Rivers Network welcomes India's cancellation of Tamanthi Dam, urges China and Thailand to take similar environmental responsibility

The Burma Rivers Network (BRN) warmly welcomes the Indian government's recent cancellation of the controversial Tamanthi hydropower dam on the Chindwin River, which was planned for export of electricity to India. BRN urges China and Thailand to take similar responsibility for our shared environment and halt their accelerated plans to dam Burma's major rivers to fulfill their domestic power needs.

India signed an agreement with Burma's military regime in 2004 to develop the Tamanthi dam. In 2007 over 2,400 people were forcibly relocated from the dam site, and surveying continued until 2011. However, there has been strong local resistance to the 1,200 MW dam, which would have flooded an area the size of Delhi, displacing over 45,000 people, irreversibly impacting an area of rich biodiversity, and affecting livelihoods of millions relying on fisheries and riverside agriculture downstream. "Opposition from local groups over its environmental impact" was mentioned as a key factor in the Indian government's decision to cancel the Tamanthi dam in June 2013.

Regrettably, this responsible lead taken by India is not being followed by other neighbouring countries carrying out cross-border hydropower development in Burma. In March of this year, Burma's Deputy Minister of Electrical Power announced that six dams on the Salween were proceeding, despite ongoing conflict along the river, and complete lack of transparency around the dam plans. Most of the power from these dams, which will produce over 15,000 MW, will be exported to China and Thailand, while the millions living along the length of the river in Burma will bear the environmental and social costs.

At the same time, Chinese authorities and investors are pressing to restart the Myitsone dam, suspended since September 2011. This is in spite of huge popular opposition to the giant 6,000 MW dam, which will block off the Irrawaddy at its source, and place the flow of Burma's main artery in the hands of Chinese engineers.

China and Thailand are adhering neither to international standards nor their own domestic regulations when building dams in Burma. They are taking advantage of Burma's lack of safeguards protecting the environment and local livelihoods in order to access "cheap" power for their own domestic use.

BRN therefore urges China and Thailand to take India's example in heeding the concerns of impacted communities. They should immediately cancel their untransparent and damaging dam projects on Burma's major rivers, and develop more regionally responsible and sustainable plans to fulfil their domestic energy needs.

Contacts:

Ngai Ngai – (+) 91-9436872556 ,(+)95-9400505203
Ah Nan – (+)66-848854154 ,www.burmariversnetwork.org

Naypyitaw: Nationwide ceasefire in October

Posted: 05 Sep 2013 04:31 AM PDT

U Aung Min, Vice Chairman of the Union level Peacemaking Work Committee (UPWC), said on Saturday, 31 August, he was confident the long advertised Nationwide Ceasefire Accord could be signed toward the end of October, according to a report by the Restoration Council of Shan State/Shan State Army (RCSS/SSA).

He was speaking at a meeting between the joint government-parliament team led by Vice President Sai Mawk Kham, who doubles as Chairman of the UPWC, and the joint Karen Shan delegation led by Karen National Union (KNU) President Gen Mutu Sayphoe in Naypyitaw.

"There are 14 armed groups that have concluded state level ceasefire with the government," he said. "The only two groups that have yet to agree to a ceasefire remain Kachin (Independence Organization) and Palaung (State Liberation Front). Sounding out the 14 ceasefire groups, 10 are found to be agreeable to the Nationwide Ceasefire Accord idea."

Although U Aung Min did not elaborate, the 4 ceasefire groups that are still withholding their consent appear to be Karenni National Progressive Party (KNPP), New Mon State Party (NMSP), PaO National Liberation Organization (PNLO) and Shan State Progress Party (SSPP), all being members of the United Nationalities Federal Council (UNFC), the alliance led by KIO, according to another report. Only two of its members, KNU and Chin National Front (CNF), enjoy somewhat better relations with Naypyitaw.

Lt-Col Sai Ngeun taking the floor at the UPWC-Karen/Shan meeting 31 August 2013.(Photo: RCSS/SSA)

He also announced that the government has drafted its own framework for political dialogue. Meanwhile, the armed groups had already presented their proposed framework to the government on 13 May. "That doesn't mean we are going to stick to our own agenda," he explained. "Both sides should negotiate until an agreement is reached."

While the armed groups, which include the UNFC, had proposed 19 dialogue topics, the government has only 9, according to him. "We want to hold the political dialogue in 2014," he said. "If there are too many topics, it will take too much time. And the next government may have to take over from us."

Saw Htoo Htoo Lay, adviser to the KNU, delivered a power point presentation of the armed groups' draft framework, dubbed Comprehensive Union Peace and Ceasefire Agreement.

Lt-Col Sai Ngeun, RCSS representative, urged the government not to leave out any armed organizations at the planned nationwide ceasefire signing ceremony, which is expected to be witnessed by world dignitaries including UN chief Ban Ki-Moon. "We also need to discuss thoroughly beforehand on the points that should be included in the Accord," he added. "For instance, the guarantee that the political dialogue will immediately take place after the signing, and a waiver on Section 17-1 (Unlawful Associations Act) for dialogue participants."

The common framework for political dialogue has been scheduled to be completed by February 2014, according to Sai Ngeun, quoting a government technical team.

A confusion yet to be resolved was over the role of the parliament. "To our understanding, the national dialogue should be convened outside the parliament in order to make it inclusive," he told to meeting. "But the President's speech on 14 August has confounded us. According to him, the 3 stage peace roadmap is: state/regional level, Union government level and negotiation with the team formed by the Parliament. Which makes us wonder whether the government that started the process is going to turn over the job to the Parliament and just wash its hands off us. What we would like to see instead is the resumption of the peace process by the government until a Union Accord is reached. As for the Parliament, we would need its support to ratify the Accord."

To which Sai Mawk Kham replied it was merely a misunderstanding. No elaboration however was provided.

During has "State of the Union" address on 1 March 2012, President Thein Sein had said there were three steps to realize eternal peace:

  • Dialogue at state level
  • Dialogue at union level until agreement is reached
  • Agreement signed at the Parliament

The meeting lasted 10:00-12:30. It was also graced by Vice Senior General Soe Win, the Army Commander-in-Chief and U Thein Zaw, two other UPWC vice chairman. Ms Dwe Bu, Kachin MP, People's Assembly, mentioned that this was the first and U Thein Zaw, two other UPWC vice chairmen. time lawmakers were allowed to participate in a meeting with armed groups and demanded that they be invited to participate in such events in future.

Naypyitaw has signed ceasefire with 14 movements:


DateName of movementNote
16 September 2011United Wa State ArmyNon
27 September 2011National Democratic Alliance ArmyNon
33 November 2011Democratic Karen Buddhist ArmyNon
42 December 2011Restoration Council of Shan StateNon
56 January 2012Chin National FrontUNFC
612 January 2012Karen National UnionUNFC
728 January 2012Shan State Progress PartyUNFC
87 February 2012Karen Peace CouncilNon
925 February 2012New Mon State PartyUNFC
107 March 2012Karenni National Progressive PartyUNFC
115 April 2012Arakan Liberation PartyNon
129 April 2012National Socialist Council of NagalandNon
1325 October 2012PaO National Liberation OrganizationUNFC
145 August 2013All Burma Democratic FrontNon

U Tin E and Burma’s easy way out curse

Posted: 05 Sep 2013 04:35 AM PDT


tiger-as-editorAccording to the late U Tin E, regarded as one of the fathers of today's Union, the country might have been cursed with a second nature of looking for a quick cure, known as Say Mee Doe in Burmese, whenever a problem arises.

He traced it to the well known Tagaung legend of Kan Yaza Gyi and Kan Yaza Nge, the princely brothers who were told by their dying father that one who was able to construct a pagoda overnight would be designated his heir-apparent. Kan Yaza Gyi, the elder brother, apparently a simple person, tried to accomplish the task in the customary way. His younger brother, on the contrary, was a sophisticated man and what he did was, instead of ordering his workers to make bricks, he instructed them to weave mats which he assembled into a cone shape. This was in turn painted white and before the dawn broke the pagoda was ready for his father's inspection and subsequent approval.

U Tun E says this slipshod method, while useful for short term goals, are not worthwhile in the long run. The reason is obvious: it only goes for the symptoms but not the root cause.

Just listen to today's leaders explaining the reason for the non-Burmans' uprisings against the majority Burmans. According to them, it is because these hills peoples are poor. Make them richer and there'll be no more insurrections.

Meantime, other leaders are saying the country needs a strong, modern army to prevent its 135 national races from splitting away to establish 135 independent nations. Simply forgetting that the British conquerors were able to do the job with only a handful of infantry battalions:

  • 9 in Burma Proper
  • 6 in the non-Burman territories*
Which clearly demonstrates that having a big army and holding diverse peoples together under the same flag are totally different subjects. Holding them together requires something for more than having an army to buffaloe them and keep them buffaloed.

Anyone can run a country with guns and killings. But to run it without guns and killings, that takes a man, if SHAN is to paraphrase one of the world's favorite authors.

So our question to anyone who's leading the country, either behind the curtain or in front of it, and anyone, who aspires to do so, whether man or woman, is: Are you man enough?

*One noteworthy fact is that, in comparison, the British had less number of units in the Frontier Areas than the Burma Army does today:

Burma Proper        :    Frontier Areas
British days      3   :    2
Today               1   :    4

Why so would be an interesting question for researchers to answer.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.